Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/16
GAHC040018212025
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
(ITANAGAR BENCH)
Case No. : WP(C)/514/2025
Gyati Taki
Son of Late Gyati Tatum, residence of Village Hari, PO and PS Ziro, Lower Subansiri
District, Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The Director of Audit and Pension and 3 Ors
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh, Naharlagun, PO and PS Naharlagun, Papum Pare
District, Arunachal Pradesh.
2:The Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Department of Administrative Reforms
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar.
3:The Principal Secretary (Finance)
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar.
4:The Superintending Engineer
Age: 0
Occupation :
AP Electrical Circle-V
Department of Power
Ziro
Lower Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh
Page No.# 2/16
Po and PS Ziro
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Hage Lampu, Dani Dolley,Joram Sanjay,Khyoda Moses
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP), Lissing Perme,SC(Power)
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
ORDER
24.03.2026
Heard Mr. H. Lampu, learned counsel for the petitioner; Ms. G. Ete,
learned Additional Senior Government Advocate for the State respondent Nos.
1, 2& 3; and Mr. L. Perme, learned standing counsel for the Power Department,
being respondent No. 4.
Prayers:2.
In this petition, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the
petitioner has prayed for:(i)
setting aside and quashing the File Noting No. AR/129/2018-ARDDEPTT, dated
19.08.2019, issued
by the Secretary to
the
Department of Administrative Reforms, Government of Arunachal
Pradesh, Itanagar;
(ii)
issuing direction to the respondent No.1, i.e. the Director of Audit
and Pension, Government of Arunachal Pradesh, Naharlagun, to
cancel/rescind/re-call the letter No.Pen/AP/42414/25-26/427, dated
05.09.2025and further direct to call his Pension Papers along with
the Service Book from the respondent No.4, i.e. the Superintending
Engineer, Arunachal PradeshElectrical Circle – V, Ziro, Government of
Page No.# 3/16
Arunachal Pradesh; and
(iii)
issuing direction to the respondent No.1, i.e. the Director of Audit
and Pension, Government of Arunachal Pradesh, Naharlagun,not to
act upon the File Noting No. AR/129/2018-ARD-DEPTT, dated
19.08.2019, issued by the Secretary to the Department of
Administrative Reforms, Government of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar
and to settlehis Pension Papers along with the Service Book in terms
of GovernmentOrder No. PWRS/E-953/2003/232, dated 30.05.2003
and Government of Arunachal Pradesh Finance Memo No.Estt-II200015/126/2022/215, dated11.03.2024.
Submissions:3.
Mr. Lampu, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner
herein retired from service as Executive Engineer(E), on 30.05.2025, on
attaining
the
age
of
SuperintendingEngineer,
superannuation
Arunachal
and
Pradesh
after
Electrical
his
retirement,
Circle
–
V,
the
Ziro,
Government of Arunachal Pradesh, vide its letter, dated 30.05.2025, submitted
his Pension Papers along with the Service Book before the Director of Audit and
Pension, Government of Arunachal Pradesh, Naharlagun, for settlement and
authorization of his pension. But, the Director of Audit and Pension, Government
of Arunachal Pradesh, Naharlagun,vide its letter dated 07.07.2025, returned the
Pension Papers along with the Service Book of the petitioner with an
observationthat there is some anomalous in Initial Pay Statement.
3.1. Mr. Lampu further submits that the main issue raised in the letter, dated
07.07.2025, issued bythe Director of Audit and Pension,was that since the
petitioner was promoted tothe post of Assistant Engineer from the post of Junior
Page No.# 4/16
Engineer, his case comes under the ACP/MACP, not under the Time Bound
Promotion Scheme,which is implemented vide Government Order No. PWRS/E953/2003/232, dated30.05.2003.
3.2. Mr. Lampu also submits that the petitioner doesnot comes under Time
Bound Promotion Scheme, and therefore, his pay is not re-regulated under Time
Bound Scale and that the SuperintendingEngineer, Arunachal Pradesh Electrical
Circle – V, Ziro, Government of Arunachal Pradesh, vide its letter dated
30.05.2025,clarified the same and mentioned that petitioner was promoted
tothe post of Assistant Engineer on 22.08.1994, vide Government Order
No.PWRS/E-447/98/Vol-II/7850-61, dated21.07.2004 and he was not in the post
of
Junior
Engineer
implemented,w.e.f
while
the
Time
Bound
Promotion
01.06.2003,
vide
GovernmentOrder
Scheme
No.
was
PWRS/E-
953/2003/232, dated30.05.2003 and therefore, his pay was regulated under the
MACP.
3.3. Mr. Lampu further submits that the Director of Audit and Pension, in spite
of the fact that the petitionerwas promoted from the post of Junior Engineer to
the post of Assistant Engineer, prior to implementation of Time Bound
Promotion Scheme, returned his Pension Papers along with the Service Book,
vide letter dated 05.09.2025, with an observation that the issue was placed
before the Department of Administrative Reforms Department, Government of
Arunachal Pradesh for clarification, vide e-file No.DAP-15/1/2024-(DAP), dated
26.08.2025 and directed to re-submit the Pension Papers along with the Service
Book of the petitioner, once clarification is received from the Administrative
Reform Department, which will be intimated. He also submits that subsequently,
clarification from the Administrative Reform Department has been received and
in the said clarification it advised to adhere to the advice given on 19.08.2019,
Page No.# 5/16
vide File No. AR/129/2018-ARD-DEPTT.
3.4. Mr. Lampu also submits that the petitioner was promoted to the post of
Assistant Engineer, on 22.08.1994, vide order No.PWRS/E-447/98/Voll-II/785061, dated 21.07.2004 and he was no more in the post of Junior Engineer while
Time Bound Pay was implemented,w.e.f 01.03.2003and that the same is clear
from Government Order No. PWRS/E-953/2003/232, dated 30.05.2003 and
Government
of
Arunachal
Pradesh
Finance
Memo
No.Estt-II-
200015/126/2022/215, dated 11.03.2024, that the Time Bound Promotion
Scheme is applicable to serving as Junior Engineers only. As such, there is no
reason at all to seek a clarification from the Administrative Reforms Department,
Government of Arunachal Pradesh and thereby, delay has been caused in
settlement of Pension Papers and Service Book of the petitioner by the Director
of Audit and Pension.
3.5. Under such circumstances, Mr. Lampu has contended to allow this petition
by
setting
aside
the
File
Noting
No.
AR/129/2018-ARD-DEPTT,
dated
19.08.2019, issued by the Secretary to the Department of Administrative
Reforms, Government of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar.
4.
Per-contra, Ms. Ete, learned Additional Senior Government Advocate for the
State respondent Nos. 1, 2 & 3 submits that Time Bound Promotion Scheme
was implemented,w.e.f. 01.06.2003, vide Government Order No. PWRS/E953/2003/232, dated30.05.2003 and the petitioner was promoted from the post
of Junior Engineer to the post of Assistant Engineer and as such, his case is
covered by the Time Bound Promotion Scheme and therefore, there is no fault
on the part of the Director of Audit and Pension in seeking report from the
Administrative Reforms Department and as such, there is no merit in this
petition and accordingly, the same may be dismissed.
Page No.# 6/16
5.
On the other hand, Mr. Perme, learned standing counsel for the Power,
being respondent No. 4, has subscribes the submission of Ms. Ete, learned
Additional Senior Government Advocate for the State respondents.
Issue before the Court:6.
Having heard the submissions of learned counsel for both the parties, this
Court has carefully gone through the petition as well as the documents placed
on record.
7.
In view of the pleadings of the parties and the submissions advanced by
learned counsel for the parties, the issue to be answered by this court is
formulated as under:(i)
Whether the case of the petitioner falls under the
Time Bound Scheme implemented vide Government Order
No. PWRS/E-953/2003/232, dated 30.05.2003 or under
the ACP/MACP Scheme?
(ii) Whether the File Noting, dated 19.08.2019 of ARD
Department where in it has been held that the Junior
Engineers who got promotion as Assistant Engineer
prior to grant of Time Bound Scale will be counted as
First Time Bound Scale and therefore, he/she will be
entitled to second time bound scale on completion of
24 years of service only, has any force, while the
same has not been expressed in the name of the
Governor as required by clause (1) of Article 166 and
also not been communicated?
8.
It appears that the basic facts here in this case are not in dispute. The
petitionerwas retired from service as Executive Engineer(E), on 30.05.2025, on
attaining the age of superannuation. Thereafter, he submitted his pension
Page No.# 7/16
papers and accordingly,the Superintending Engineer, Arunachal Pradesh
Electrical Circle – V, Ziro, Government of Arunachal Pradesh, vide its letter dated
30.05.2025, submitted the Pension Papers along with the Service Book of the
petitioner tothe Director of Audit and Pension, Government of Arunachal
Pradesh, Naharlagun, for settlement and authorization of the pension of the
petitioner. But, the Director of Audit and Pension, Government of Arunachal
Pradesh, Naharlagun, vide its letter dated 07.07.2025, returned the Pension
Papers along with the Service Book of the petitioner with an observation that
there is some anomalous in Initial Pay Statement.
8.1. It is also not in dispute that the petitioner was allowed to work as
officiating Assistant Engineer vide Order dated PWRS/E-51/95-96(A)/53595-602
dated 28/08/1997. Thereafter, on recommendation of DPC he was promoted to
the post of Assistant Engineer (Electrical) vide Order dated PWRS/E-447/98(A)
dated 12/03/2001. His promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer was due in
the year 1994. But as such benefit was denied to him, he approached this court
by filing a Writ Petition, being Writ Petition No. 204(AP)/2001, and the said
petition was allowed granting his prayer. Then on recommendation of
subsequent DPC, he was promoted to the post of Assistant Engineer (Electrical)
with effect from 22.08.1994, vide order dated PWRS/E-447/98/Vol. II, dated
20/07/2004.
8.2. Indisputably, the Time Bound Promotion Scheme, was implemented vide
Government Order No. PWRS/E-953/2003/232, dated 30.05.2003. The said
order read as under:Government of Arunachal Pradesh
Department of Power, Itanagar
Page No.# 8/16
Dated Itanagar the 30th May 2003
ORDER
The Governor of Arunachal Pradesh is please to enhance the entry
grade pay scale in respect of the Junior Engineers working under PWD,
power, PHE, RWD, IFCD, UD, RD, APEDA, and Sports Deptts. Under Govt.
of Arunachal Pradesh as indicated below with effect from 01/06/2003
1.Last Grade pay Scale-Existing Pay scale--Enhance pay scale
Rs. 1500-125-4000/-Rs. 4500-125-7000/-Rs. 5500-175-9000/2. It is further order the following pay scale will be conferred on
them after completion of 12 years and 24 years of services
respectively.
After 12 years-
Rs. 8000-275-10500/-
After 24 years-
Rs. 10000-175-16500/-
3.The above pay revision will also cover Junior Engineers serving
with special designation like extension Officers (RuralEngineering),
Assistant Urban Program Officer, ArchitecturalAssistant, Town Planner
Asstt. Etc. (those having diploma qualification and engaged in
Engineering jobs).
4. The fixation of pay in the enhance pay scale under this order with
effect from 1-6-2003 shall be regulated is as under:
(i) The pay shall be fixed at the same stage as which the pay
is drawn by the incumbent. If there is such a stage in the
existing scale, or at the next higher stage in the enhance
pay scale. If there no such stage.
(ii) If the pay is fixed at the same stage, the next date of
increment should be counted from the date on which it would
have acquired in the existing scale;
(iii)
If however the pay is fixed at the next higher stage,
the next date of incumbent should be granted after
completion of the normal incremental period of 12 months in
the enhance pay scale.
(iv)
Page No.# 9/16
(M.K Parida) IAS
Commissioner & secretary (power),
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Dated Itanagar, the 30* May 2003
9.
The main contention of the Director of Audit and Pension, in its affidavit in
opposition is that since the petitioner was promoted from the post of Junior
Engineer to the post of Assistant Engineer, he is not covered under the
ACP/MACP, but by the Time Bound Promotion Scheme, implemented vide
Government Order No. PWRS/E-953/2003/232, dated 30.05.2003. The said
contention is based upon an Office Note of the Administrative Reform
Department, dated 19.08.2019. Said Note read as under:-
Ref pre-page notes.
The matter regarding grant of pay up-grading under Modified
Assured Career Progression Scheme to Junior Engineers has been
examined as per existing rules and guidelines.
In this connection, it to inform that the Junior Engineers
are entitled to 2 (Two) Times Bound Scales on completion of 12
years continuous regular in the pay scale of Assistant Engineer
as First Time Bound Scale and on completion of 24 years of
regular service in the pay scale of Executive Engineer as second
Time Bound Scale as per Government Order No. PWRS/E-953/2003/232
dated 30/5/2003. So, all the individuals who were initially
appointed to the post of Junior Engineer whether he/she secure
promotion to Assistant Engineer or not are entitled to Time Bound
Scale and not ACPS or MACPS. The Junior Engineer who got
promotion as Assistant Engineer prior to grant of Time Bound
Scale will be counted as First Time Bound Scale on completion of
24 years of service only.
The above Time Bound Scale was notified by the Department of
Page No.# 10/16
Power vide No. PWRS/E-953/2003/232 dated 30/5/2003. Unless the
department of power decides to switch over the MACP Scheme, no
individual can opt for switch over to MACPS. This will result in
double benefit and the Time Bound Scale and the Modified Assured
Career Progression Scheme (MACPS) cannot run concurrently under
condition No. 13.
Therefore, the Department is advised to settle the matter
accordingly.
This is issued with the approval of Secretary to the
Government of Arunachal Pradesh, Department of Administrative
Reforms.
Sd/
Mari Angu
Dated Mon, Aug-19 16:35:19 IST 2019
Commissioner (PWD)
9.1. However, it appears that while the Director, Audit and Pension Department
has sought for an opinion of the Administrative Reform Department, then it had
again on 13.10.2025, (Annexure-K of the affidavit in opposition of respondent
No. 1,) has directed to the Director Audit and Pension to follow the advice given
on 19.08.2019. Said opinion is read as under:The proposal of the department has been re-examined
in terms of records placed on the Departmental e-file.
The Department seems to have re-submitted this file
without observing the advice rendered to them on
19.08.2019.
Therefore, the Department of Administrative Reforms
re-iterates its earlier advice dated 19/08/2019.
This is issued with the approval of Secretary to the
Government
of
Arunachal
Pradesh,
Department
of
Administrative Reforms, Itanagar.
Page No.# 11/16
Dr Mari Angu
Date: 13-10-2025, 16:29:37
Joint Secretary
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
9.2. Admittedly,this File Note, dated 19.08.2019 of ARD Department, where in
it has been held that the Junior Engineers who got promotion as Assistant
Engineer prior to grant of Time Bound Scale will be counted as First Time Bound
Scale and therefore, he/she will be entitled to second time bound scale on
completion of 24 years of service only, has not been expressed in the name of
the Governor as required by clause (1) of Article 166 and also not been
communicated to any other department. In that view of the matter, what is to
be looked into is whether this File Note has any legal sanctity?
9.2. Hon’ble Supreme Court, while dealing with the issue of importance of a
File Noting in Mahadeo & Ors. versus Smt. Sovan Devi & Ors.
in
Civil Appeal No. 5876 of 2022, (arising out of S.L.P. (C) No.
20839 of 2021), held as under:“It
is
well
settled
that
inter-departmental
communications are in the process of consideration for
appropriate decision and cannot be relied up on as a
basis to claim any right. This Court examined the said
question in a judgment reported as Omkar Sinha v. Sahadat
Khan, reported in 2022 SCC OnLine SC 601. Reliance was
placed on Bachhittar Singh v. State of Punjab, reported
in AIR 1963 SC 395, to hold that merely writing something
on the file does not amount to an order. Before something
amounts to an order of the State Government, two things
are necessary. First, the order has to be expressed in
Page No.# 12/16
the name of the Governor as required by clause (1) of
Article 166 and second, it has to be communicated. As
already indicated, no formal order modifying the decision
of the Revenue Secretary was ever made. Until such an
order is drawn up, the State Government cannot, in our
opinion, be regarded as bound by what was stated in the
file.”
9.3. Again, in the case of Municipal Committee v. Jai Narayan & Co.
2022 SCC OnLine SC 376, while dealing the same issue, it has held that a
noting recorded in the file is merely a noting simpliciter and nothing more. It
merely represents expression of an opinion by the particular individual. It was
held as under:
“16.
This Court in a judgment reported as State of
Uttaranchal v. Sunil Kumar Vaish, (2011) 8 SCC 670 held
that a noting recorded in the file is merely a noting
simpliciter and nothing more. It merely represents
expression of opinion by the particular individual. By no
stretch of imagination, such noting can be treated as a
decision of the Government. It was held as under:“24. A noting recorded in the file is merely a noting
simpliciter and nothing more. It merely represents
expression of opinion by the particular individual.
By no stretch of imagination, such noting can be
treated as a decision of the Government. Even if the
competent authority records its opinion in the file
on the merits of the matter under consideration, the
same cannot be termed as a decision of the
Government unless it is sanctified and acted upon by
issuing an order in accordance with Articles 77(1)
and (2) or Articles 166(1) and (2). The noting in
the file or even a decision gets culminated into an
order affecting right of the parties only when it is
Page No.# 13/16
expressed in the name of the President or the
Governor, as the case may be, and authenticated in
the manner provided in Article 77(2) or Article
166(2). A noting or even a decision recorded in the
file can always be reviewed/reversed/overruled or
overturned and the court cannot take cognizance of
the earlier noting or decision for exercise of the
power of judicial review.(See State of Punjab v.
Sodhi Sukhdev Singh AIR 1961 SC 493, Bachhittar
Singh v. State of Punjab, AIR 1963 SC 395, State of
Bihar v. Kripalu Shankar (1987) 3 SCC 34, Rajasthan
Housing Board v. Shri Kishan (1993) 2 SCC 84, Sethi
Auto Service Station v. DDA (2009) 1 SCC 180 and
Shanti Sports Club v. Union of India (2009) 15 SCC
705).”
9.4. In view of the aforesaid proposition of law, this court afraid the said File
Note, dated 19.08.2019 of Administrative Reform Departmentdoes not carry any
legal sanctity. In view of the given factual and legal position the Issue No. II
has to be answered in negative, and accordingly, the same stands answered.
10. And admittedly, on the basis of the said File Note, dated 19.08.2019 and
its subsequent opinion,Dated 13.10.2025, the pension paper and service book
of the petitioner has not yet been settled.
10.1. Mr. Lampu, learned counsel for the petitioner, referring to the Annexure –
H, at page No. 95 of the petition, submits that the said order, dated 30.05.2003,
indicates that the same is applicable to the Junior Engineers, who are working
under PWD, RWD, IFCD, UD, RD, APEDA and Sports Departments under the
Government of Arunachal Pradesh and the same will also cover Junior
Engineers, who are serving with special designations like Extension Officer
(Rural Engineering), Assistant Urban Programme Officer, Architectural Assistant,
Page No.# 14/16
Town Planner Assistant etc.
10.2. It also appears that entry grade pay scale in respect of the Junior
Engineers, who are working under PWD, RWD, IFCD, UD, RD, APEDA and Sports
Department, is implemented w.e.f. 01.06.2003. Whereas, the petitioner was
promoted to the post of Assistant Engineer with effect from 22.08.1994, vide
order dated 20.07.2004. Further, there is no indication in the order dated
30.05.2003, that it will be applicable with retrospective effect.
10.3. Moreover, from a perusal of the Annexure No. 11, an Office
Memorandum, issued by the Principal Secretary, Finance Govt. of Arunachal
Pradesh, Itanagar indicates that the Pay scale of Junior Engineers, under the
Government of Arunachal Pradesh, under Time Bound Scale: -Rs-8000-27513500/- Level-10 (after completion of 12 years of regular service.) -RS-10000375-16500/- Level-11 (after completion of 24 years of regular service.)And date
of effect is 01.01.2006, and their pay will be fixed notionally with actual financial
benefits w.e.f. 01.01.2016 without arrears. This order will applicable 10 the
serving Junior Engineers only.
10.4.
The said Office Memorandum is read as under:OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Sub:- Clarification on pay scale of the Junior Engineers
of various Engineering departments of Govt. of Arunachal
Pradesh with respect to OM No. FIN/E-11/22/2008, Dated
Itanagar the 28th August,2009.
It is hereby clarified that the Pay scale of Junior
Engineers under the Government of Arunachal Pradesh,
under Time Bound Scale:-Rs-8000-275-13500/- Level-10
(after completion of 12 years of regular service.)-RS-
Page No.# 15/16
10000-375-16500/- Level-11 (after completion of 24 years
of regular service.)
And date of effect is 01.01.2006 and their pay will be
fixed notionally with actual financial benefits w.e.f.
01.01.2016 without arrears. This order will applicable 10
the serving Junior Engineers only.
The O.M No.Est-II-20015/126/2022-ESTT-II-FPID, E-No.85956
Dated Itanagar the 06th March 2023 stands cancelled.
This issues with the approval of the Competent Authority.
Sd/Principal Secretary, Finance
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
Dated Itanagar the 11' March'2024.
Memo No. Estt-lI-20015/126/2022/2/5
10.5. In that view of the matter, the case of petitioner comes under the
ACP/MACP Scheme and his case will never come under the purview of Time
Bound
Scheme
implemented
vide
Government
Order
No.
PWRS/E-
953/2003/232, dated 30.05.2003. Mr. Lampu, the learned counsel for the
petitioner has rightly pointed this in his argument and this court finds sufficient
force in his submission.
10.6. In view of the aforesaid discussion and finding theIssue No. I, as
formulated herein above, is answered in negative. And accordingly, the same
stands answered.
Conclusion:11. In view of the given factual and legal position, this court is of the
considered opinion that repeated returning of the Pension Papers along with the
Service Book of the petitioner by the Director of Audit and Pension is illegal and
Page No.# 16/16
arbitraryand on such count, the action of the respondent authority, warrants
interference of this court.
12. In the result, this court finds sufficient merit in this appeal and accordingly
the same stands allowed, granting following relief(s):(i)
The File Note No. AR/129/2018-ARD-DEPTT, dated
19.08.2019, issued by the Secretary to the Department
of Administrative Reforms, Government of Arunachal
Pradesh, Itanagar stands set aside and quashed as it
failed withstands the legal scrutiny.
(ii)
By a mandamus of this court, the Director of Audit and
Pension,Government of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar is
directed and to settle the Pension Papers along with
the Service Book of the petitioner in terms of
Government Order No. PWRS/E-953/2003/232, dated
30.05.2003 and Government of Arunachal Pradesh
Finance Memo No. Estt-II-200015/126/2022/215, dated
11.03.2024.
(iii) The aforementioned exercise has to be carried out
within a period of 3 (three) weeks from the date of
receipt of the certified copy of this order.
13. The petitioner shall obtain a certified copy of this order and place the same
before the respondent authorities, especially before the respondent No. 1, i.e.
the Director of Audit and Pension, Government of Arunachal Pradesh,
Naharlagun, within a period of one week from today.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review