Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRM-M-70366--2025 (O&M)
(124)
IN THE HIGH
H
COURT OF PUNJAB
JAB A
AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
ARH
CRM-M-70366-2025 (O&M)
Date of decision : 05.03.2026
... Petitioner
GURJIT SINGH
NGH @ KALU
Versus
STATE OF PUNJAB
PUNJ
...Respondent
CORAM: HON'BLE
HON
MRS. JUSTICE MANIS
ANISHA BATRA
Present:
Mr.
r. G.S. Randhawa, Advocate for the petitioner
Ms. Ruchika
R
Sabherwal, Sr. DAG,
G, Pu
Punjab
****
MANISHA BATR
BATRA, J. (ORAL)
1.
The instant one is the second petitio
petition preferred by the petitioner
ioner
under Section
on 48
483 of Bharatiya Nagarik Surak
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (for short
“BNSS”) forr gran
grant of regular bail in casee arisi
arising out of FIR No.015 dated
ated
08.03.2024 registered
regist
under Section 21(C)
(C) oof the Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropicc Subs
Substances Act (for short “NDPS””) at Police Station Behrampur,
pur,
District Gurdaspur
daspur. His prevous petition bearing
aring C
CRM-M-33207-2024 had been
dismissed by
y this Court
C
vide order dated 05.09.202
09.2024.
2.
The petitioner has been booked for the commission of
aforementioned
ned offences
of
and is facing trial on the allegations that he alongwith
with
the co-accused
sed ha
had procured 470 grams off hero
heroin from Pakistani smugglers
glers
through drone.
ne. T
The recovered contraband was fo
found lying in the fields off one
Gurpreet Singh.
ngh.
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.06 12:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-70366--2025 (O&M)
3.
It is argued
a
by learned counsel for th
the petitioner that ever sincee the
date of dismissal
issal o
of his previous petition a period of more than 01 year and
d 05
months has been passed.
p
He is otherwise in cust
custody for a period of more than
01 year and 10 m
months. Despite lapse of this m
much period, the trial hass not
progressed much as only 04 out of 18 prose
prosecution witnesses have been
examined so
o far. There is no direct evidence
nce to connect him with the subject
bject
crime and hee was nominated on the basis off the disclosure statement allegedly
edly
suffered by him in some other case which cannot
annot bbe considered to be admissible
sible
in evidence. The co-accused has already been eextended benefit of bail. On
parity, he too d
deserves to be extended the ssame benefit. His prolonged
nged
incarceration militates
milit
against his fundamental
tal righ
rights granted under Article 21 of
the Constitution
tion of India. Each day spent byy him in custody has furnished him
im a
new ground to seek
see bail afresh. It is thus, argued
rgued that the petition deserves to be
allowed.
4.
Per contra,
c
learned State counsel
sel ha
has argued that the petition is a
successive one
ne and is not maintainable. It iss also aargued that there are no drastic
astic
or substantive
ve changes
cha
in the circumstances
es from the dismissal of his earlier
arlier
petition. Commer
ommercial quantity of contraband
nd wa
was recovered in this case. The
rigors of Section
ction 3
37 of NDPS Act are attracted.
ted. T
The antecedents of the petition
tition
are also not clean. It is, therefore, urged thatt the petition is not maintainable and
is liable to bee dismissed.
dism
5.
This Court
C
has heard the rival submis
ubmissions made by learned counsel
unsel
for both the parties at considerable length.
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.06 12:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-70366--2025 (O&M)
6.
Recov
Recovery
of the contraband had not been effected from the
conscious possess
ossession of the petitioner. Rather
ther th
the same was lying dropped
ed in
the fields off one Gurpreet Singh. As per the al
allegations, the contraband had
been supplied
ed at the instance of the present
ent pe
petitioner. The petitioner is in
custody for a per
period of 01 year 10 months
ths an
and 16 days.
The chancess of
conclusion of trial
tria in the near future are bleak.
leak. It is well-settled law thatt the
Court, whilee cons
considering an application forr gran
grant of bail, has to keep certain
rtain
factors in mind
ind such
su as whether there is a prima
rima fa
facie case or reasonable ground
ound
to believe that
at the accused has committed the
he offe
offence, circumstances which
h are
peculiar to the accused,
acc
likelihood of the offence
fence being repeated, the nature and
gravity of thee accu
accusation, severity of the punishm
nishment in the event of conviction,
tion,
the danger of th
the accused absconding orr flee
fleeing if released on bail, and
reasonable appreh
pprehension of the witnesses being
eing th
threatened, etc. However, att the
same time, the per
period of incarceration is also
so a re
relevant factor to be considered
ered
while deciding
ing wh
whether bail should be granted
nted to an accused charged with
th an
offence. Thee Hon
Hon’ble Apex Court has observed
served in a catena of cases that
at an
accused cannot
not be kept in custody for an indefini
definite period of time, and the bail
application can be considered on its own merits
erits eeven if it is filed repeatedly.
ly. It
has also been
n held that every day spent in custod
custody can provide a new cause
se of
action for filing
ling a bail application under certain
rtain ci
circumstances. This principle
le is
a part of the broad
broader approach emphasizing that la
law prefers bail over jail, aiming
ming
to balance the
he rights
righ of the accused with the requi
requirements of the criminal justice
stice
system. It is well settled
s
proposition of law that gr
grant of bail on account of delay
elay
in trial and long
ong period
pe
of incarceration is to be co
considered in the light of Section
ction
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.06 12:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-70366--2025 (O&M)
37 of the NDPS
PS Act.
A Reliance in this regard can be placed upon the observations
tions
made by Hon’ble
’ble Apex Court in Mohd. Muslim
slim @ Hussain v. State (NCT of
Delhi), 2023 SCC OnLine SC 352, wherein
in it w
was held that grant of bail
il on
account of undue
ue delay in trial cannot be said
id to bbe fettered under Section 37 of
the NDPS Act, given
g
the imperative of Section 436-A of Cr.P.C. which
ch is
applicable to offence
off
under the Act. It was also observed that jails are
overcrowded
d and their
t
living conditions are,, more often than not, appalling.. The
danger of unjusti
unjustified imprisonment is that
at inm
inmates are more likely to
o be
hardened rather
ther th
than reformed. Reliance cann also be placed upon Manmandal
dal
and Another v. State of West Bengal, Specia
pecial Leave Petition (Criminal)
al)
No.8656 of 2023
023 decided on 14.09.2023 and Rab
Rabi Prakash v. State of Odisha,
ha,
2023 LiveLaw
w (SC)
(S 533, wherein the Hon’ble
n’ble Supreme Court had extended
nded
benefit of bail
ail to the accused who had beenn inca
incarcerated for a long period
d by
observing that
hat pr
prolonged incarceration militate
ilitated against the most precious
cious
fundamentall right guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution and in such
ch a
situation, thee con
constitutional principles must
st ov
override the statutory embargo
argo
contained under
nder Section
Se
37 of the NDPS Act.
7.
Relia
Reliance
can also be placed upon Santosh Pawar Vs. State of
Chhattishgarh
h & Anr., Criminal Appeal No.48
o.4883/2025, which is a recently
ently
pronounced verdic
verdict of Hon’ble Supreme Court
ourt ob
observing that rigors of Section
ction
37 of NDPS Act will
w not be a bar for considering
ering the case of an accused forr bail
as it comes with a condition that the prosecuti
osecution would press for an early
completion of trial.
tria In the above-mentionedd case
case, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
ourt
held that appella
ppellant who was being prosecuted
ecuted for being in possession
n of
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.06 12:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-70366--2025 (O&M)
commercial quantity
quant of narcotic substance, was eentitled for bail in view off her
incarceration
n for a period of 19 months.
8.
Simil
Similarly
in another case i.e. inn the ccase of Satender Kumar Antil
ntil
v. Central Bureau
reau of Investigation, (2022) 100 SC
SCC 51 prolonged incarceration
ation
and inordinate
te delay
del engaged the attention off the H
Hon’ble Supreme Court, which
hich
considered the
he cor
correct approach towards bail,
l, with respect to several enactments,
ents,
including Section
ection 37 NDPS Act. The courtt expre
expressed the opinion that Section
ction
436A (which
h requires
requ
inter alia the accused to be enlarged on bail if the trial
ial is
not concluded
ed wit
within specified periods) of the Cr
Criminal Procedure Code, 1973
would apply.
9.
In the
th case of Ismail Khan @ Pa
Pathan vs. State of Rajasthan
an
Crminal Appeall No.4911 of 2025 with regard to recovery of commercial
rcial
quantity of narcotic
narcoti substance, the Hon’ble Supre
Supreme Court accorded the benefit
nefit
of bail to thee accused
accus in view of prolonged incarce
incarceration for a period of 02 years
and 08 months
ths of the
t accused.
10.
Simil
milar benefit has been extended
ended in another appeal i.e. SLP
LP
No.15699-2025
25 titled
tit
as Ebrahim @ Ibrahim SK vs. The State of West Bengal
gal
and in the case
ase of Pamesh Arora vs. UT Chandig
ndigarh Criminal Appeal No.4872
of 2025.
11.
On analyzing
an
the peculiar facts
ts an
and circumstances of the present
esent
case in the light of
o the aforementioned principle
nciples of law, it transpires thatt the
petitioner has
as suffered
suff
prolonged incarceration
tion fo
for a period 01 year, 10 months
nths
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.06 12:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-70366--2025 (O&M)
and 16 days.. The trial is not likely to be conclude
ncluded in near future as only 04
4 out
of 18 prosecution
ecution witnesses have been exam
examined so far.
The continued
nued
detention off the p
petitioner is not likely to serve any fruitful purpose. The co-accused has also been extended benefit off bail. Therefore, on parity too,, he
deserves to be ext
extended benefit of bail. There
ere is nnothing on record to show that
if released on
n bail, the petitioner will not participat
rticipate in the trial or will abscond.
12.
In view
vie of the above discussion,
n, this Court is of the opinion that
hat a
case is madee out ffor grant of bail to the petitioner
itioner at this stage. Accordingly,, the
petition is allowed
llowed and the petitioner is ordered
ered to be released on bail subject
ct to
her furnishing
ng personal
per
as well as surety bonds
nds to the satisfaction of the learned
rned
trial Court/Chief
hief Judicial
J
Magistrate/Duty Magistr
agistrate concerned.
13.
Howe
However,
it will be open for
or th
the prosecution to apply for
cancellation of bail
b
in case the petitionerr is ffound involved in any other
subsequent case.
14.
It is made
m
clear that any observation
vation made herein above is only for
the purpose of deciding
dec
the present petition and tthe same shall have no bearing
aring
on the meritss of th
the case.
15.
Since the main petition has been
een all
allowed, pending application,
n, if
any, is rendered
ered in
infructuous.
(MA
(MANISHA BATRA)
JUDGE
05.03.2026
Amit Sharma
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.06 12:26
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
Whether speaking/reasoned:- Yes
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review