The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. The said award dated 23.11.2020 in case of “Waryam Singh vs. UOI and others” in MA No.171 of 2011 was assailed at the instance of respondents No.1 and 2 before the ld. Additional District Judge, Jalandhar having invoked Section 34 of the 1966 Act, however, the said petition was dismissed vide decision dated 2026.02.02 19:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
13. 02.2023 and thus, the adjudication dated 23.11.2020 passed by Commissioner, Jalandhar Division-cum-Arbitrator with respect to the market value @ Rs.1,45,000/- per marla has become final.
13. In view of the aforesaid, by applying the principle of parity and to maintain the equality and uniformity, the petitioner-landowner being identically placed is awarded the benefit of same market value @ Rs.1,45,000/- per marla along with all other statutory benefits permissible and awarded in terms of decision dated 23.11.2020 against acquisition of his land forming part of khasra No.31//18 (2 kanals 9 marlas) situated in Village Khanpur, Tehsil Mukerian, District Hoshiarpur. The present writ petition is thus allowed in the above terms.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
226 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
CWP-35373
35373-2025 (O&M)
Decided on:
on:-21.01.2026
Gurdip Singh
....Petitioner
vs.
Union of India and others
....Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARKESH MANUJA
Present:
Mr. Satbir Rathore, Advocate,
Ms. Jyotika Behl, Advocate and
Mr. Vinod Pundir, Advocate,
for the petitioner.
Mr. Harmanjot Singh Gill, Advocate,
for respondent No.2.
Mr. Athar Ahmed, DAG, Punjab.
*****
HARKESH MANUJA J. (Oral)
1.
By way of present writ petition, challenge has been laid to
an award dated 19.11.2025 (Annexure P
P-12) passed by learned
Arbitrator-cum--Commissioner,
Commissioner,
Jalandhar
Division,
respondent
the
of
No.4,
whereby,
claim
the
Jalandhar
Jalandhar-
petitioner
for
enhancement of market
market value against his acquired land has been
dismissed on the ground that khasra number mentioned in the
arbitration petition was incorrectly mentioned.
2.
Briefly stating, 2 kanals & 9 marlas of land forming part of
khasra No.31//18 situated in the revenue estate of Village Khanpur,
Tehsil Mukerian, District Hoshiarpur, owned by the petitioner came to
SANJAY GUPTA
2026.02.02 19:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
be acquired vide notifications dated 24.12.2004 and 11.07.2005
issued under Sections 3-A and 3-D respectively of the National
Highways Act, 1956 (for short, “1956 Act”). Award by respondent
No.3 was passed on 14.12.2007, whereby, the market value was
assessed @ Rs.6875/- per marla.
3.
Being
aggrieved,
the
petitioner-landowner
invoked
Section 3G (5) of the 1956 Act by filing an arbitration petition before
respondent No.4, which was disposed of vide decision dated
05.04.2010 (Annexure P-2), while reassessing the market value @
Rs.31,250/- per marla. Aggrieved thereof, respondent No.2 invoked
Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter
referred to as “1996 Act”), which was allowed by the learned
Additional
District Judge, Jalandhar vide
its
decision
dated
30.07.2011 (Annexure P-3) with the following observations:“4.The impugned award would show that the Arbitrator
overlooked Clauses (b), (c) and (d) of Section 3 (G) (7) of the
Act altogether and hardly any sustainable reason has been
spelt out for arriving at the figure of market value of the land at
the time of publication of notice of acquisition. The Arbitrator is
required to record evidence in whatever manner he likes the
evidence of the parties and then to appreciate and appraise
the same for passing the award in any way but with reasons.
In view of the above, the award dated 05.04.2010 is set aside
and the matter is remanded back to the Arbitrator to decide the
matter afresh after taking into consideration all the aspects as
stipulated by Section 3-G (7) (a) to (d) of the Act, as the both
parties are aggrieved from the award. The Arbitrator shall
expedite the matter as early as possible, as public and
national interest is involved i.e. construction of National
Highway. The parties are directed to appear before the
Arbitrator on 16.08.2011.
SANJAY GUPTA
2026.02.02 19:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
File be consigned to the record room.”
4.
The aforesaid decision dated 30.07.2011 was challenged
at the instance of petitioner-landowner having preferred FAO-27492017, titled as “Gurdeep Singh vs Union of India and others”,
which was disposed of vide decision dated 04.05.2023 (Annexure P4) without interfering with the decision dated 30.07.2011. Thereafter,
the learned Arbitrator vide its award dated 19.11.2025 (Annexure P12) dismissed the arbitration application preferred at the instance of
petitioner. Relevant para 11 thereof is extracted hereunder:“11.
After hearing the detailed arguments of both the
parties and perusing the record, it has been noted that the
land in village Khanpur was acquired vide notification for
acquisition of land U/s 3(A) of National Highway Act issued on
24.12.2004. The applicant has in his claim petition dated
01.08.2008 and application dated 04.08.2023 that he is owner
of land falling in Khasra No. 33//18 (6-4), whereas, the counsel
for the respondents No.1 and 2 has stated that the land
measuring 2 Kanals 9 Marlas comprised in Khasra no.31//18
(2-9) situated at Village Khanpur Tehsil Mukerian, District
Hoshiarpur has been acquired vide Notification under Section
3A bearing S.O. No. 1422 (E) dated
24.12.2004. The
counsel further stated that the land measuring 2 Kanals 9
Marlas comprised in Khasra no 33//18 as alleged by the
applicant in the petition has never been acquired by the
respondents. The onus was upon applicant to prove that land
comprising khasra no.33//18 was acquired by the respondents.
The applicant has tendered evidence wherein he has placed
on record notification U/s 3(A) dated 24 12.2004 and copy of
award vide which land of the applicants was acquired. In the
notification dated 24.12.2004, the Khasra No.33//18 (6-4) does
not find mention. As such, the applicant has not approached
the court with clean hands and has suppressed true and
material facts. Accordingly, present application is dismissed
SANJAY GUPTA
2026.02.02 19:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
being devoid of merits.
File be consigned to the Record Room after usual
formalities.”
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and gone
through the paper book.
6.
A perusal of record shows that inadvertently on account
of typographical error, the petitioner in his arbitration application
preferred under Section 3G (5) of the 1956 Act mentioned the details
of the land as Khasra No.33//18 (6 kanals & 4 marlas), however, in
fact as per records, the land acquired by respondent No.2 formed
part of Khasra No.31//18 (2 kanals & 9 marlas) situated in the
revenue estate of Village Khanpur and this fact was even admitted by
respondent No.2 in paragraph No.1 of its written statement filed
before the learned Arbitrator. The same is extracted hereunder:“1.
That para No.1 of the application is wrong and
denied. The applicant has not mentioned the true facts. Land
comprised in Khasra No.31//18/2 (2-9) Nehri situated at Village
Khanpur, Tehsil Mukerian, District Hoshiarpur has been
acquired. The acquired land has been classified as Nehri and
assessed @ Rs.6875/- per marla. The applicant has been paid
Rs.3,36,875/- on account of compensation for the land. There
was no structure on the acquired land.”
Although, the aforesaid bonafide mistake about incorrect
mentioning of khasra number of land was pointed out by respondent
No.2 in his written statement, yet no effort was ever made by the
petitioner to rectify the same in his pleadings. However, in the humble
opinion of this Court, for such inadvertent human error, the claim of
the petitioner-landowner could not have been rejected by the learned
SANJAY GUPTA
2026.02.02 19:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Arbitrator for the reasons that from the material available on record, it
was never disputed either by the National Highway Authority of India
or even by CALA that the land owned by the petitioner-landowner,
forming part of Khasra No.31//18 (2 kanals 9 marla)
was in fact
acquired for public purpose.
6.1
Moreover, the petitioner-landowner having not accepted
the award passed by respondent No.3 filed arbitration application in
terms of Section 3G (5) of the 1956 Act and the said statutory
provision nowhere mandates or calls upon the landowner to provide
the details of the acquired land especially when respondent No.2NHAI being the beneficiaries and respondent No.3-CALA being the
authority, which is carrying out the entire process of acquisition
followed by passing of award and disbursement of compensation is
conscious and in the knowledge of all the material facts including the
details of the acquired land owned by the landowner-applicant.
7.
It must be borne in mind that when a government
authority compulsorily acquires land, the owner is not voluntarily
parting with the property but is being deprived of it by the State,
therefore it is imperative that the landowner is awarded just and
adequate
compensation.
An
already
aggrieved
landowner,
dissatisfied with the compensation assessed by the competent
authority, ought not to be subjected to further hardship by dismissal of
a claim for enhancement merely on account of typographical
mistakes or technical irregularities in the pleadings.
8.
Under Section 3G(5) of the National Highways Act, 1956,
the Arbitrator is entrusted with the responsibility of ensuring that the
SANJAY GUPTA
2026.02.02 19:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
compensation awarded is fair, just, and reasonable. This role
necessarily requires the arbitrator to look beyond mere technicalities
and to adjudicate the dispute on its merits. The primary aim of legal
proceedings, particularly in matters relating to compensation, is to
secure equitable justice. Rejection of claims on hyper-technical
grounds, when substantive rights are otherwise evident, would be
wholly inconsistent with the spirit of justice.
9.
It is worth reiterating that the very object of the process
of arbitration is to provide parties with a prompt, efficacious, and less
cumbersome forum for resolution of disputes, thereby avoiding the
delays and procedural rigours of ordinary litigation. Where an
Arbitrator dismisses a claim for enhancement of compensation solely
on the ground of a typographical error in the claim petition,
landowners are compelled to approach higher forums, defeating the
quintessential purpose of arbitration.
10.
In
such
circumstances,
rather
than
rejecting
the
arbitration application preferred at the instance of petitioner merely on
the basis of trivial technicalities, the learned Arbitrator was required to
take note of the factual aspects available on record with respect to
the acquisition of 2 kanals 9 marlas of land falling in Khasra
No.31//18, situated in Village Khanpur, owned by the petitionerlandowner and was thus required to adjudicate the claim on merits.
Even as per the admission and the facts stated in the written
statement preferred before the learned Arbitrator, the learned
Arbitrator was thus required to adopt a more pragmatic approach
rather than going too technical thereby causing serious prejudice to
SANJAY GUPTA
2026.02.02 19:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
the rights of the petitioner-landowner who is entitled for just and fair
compensation against compulsory acquisition of his land in terms of
the object and purpose of the statute under discussion. In such
circumstances, respondent No.4 having acted in undue haste and
without any justifying reasons while rejecting the arbitration
application preferred at the instance of petitioner-landowner, the
impugned order dated 19.11.2025 (Annexure P-12) passed by
respondent No.4 is hereby quashed.
11.
Further, a perusal of record shows that the present
acquisition pertains to Village Khanpur, Tehsil Mukerian, District
Hoshiarpur, which was initiated vide notification dated 24.12.2004
issued under Section 3-A of the 1956 Act, followed by award dated
14.12.2011 passed by respondent No.2 and with respect to the
identically placed other landowners of same acquisition, the market
value for the same nature of land has been assessed @
Rs.1,45,000/- per marla in their favour vide award dated 23.11.2020
(Annexure P-6) passed by the learned Arbitrator. The operative part
thereof is extracted hereunder:“10.
Having considered the arguments filed by both the
sides, and considering the papers and evidence on file, as well
as the judgement of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of
India vs. Tarsem Singh & ors. In Civil Appeal no. 7064 of
2019, pronounced on 19.9.2019, including recent judgements
of the Hon'ble High Court of Punjab & Haryana, my Award is
as follows:
i.
The applicant is awarded Rs. 1,45,000/- (one lac
forty five thousand) per marla for the acquired land, as per his
share, which I consider to be fair and reasonable.
ii.
SANJAY GUPTA
2026.02.02 19:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
The applicant will be entitled to interest as per the
provisions of s. 28 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, 9% per
annum on the excess amount, for the 1 year from the date of
taking possession of the land to the date of payment, and 15%
per annum shall be payable from the date of expiry of said
period of one year on the amount of such excess or part
thereof which has not been paid before the date of such
expiry.
iii.
Easement amount of 10% is permitted.
iv.
The
applicant
is
also
awarded
additional
compensation @ 12% per annum on the market value
assessed, for a period commencing on or from the date of
publication of the notification under s. 4 upto the date of award
of the CALA or the date of taking possession of the land,
whichever is earlier, as per section 23(1)(A) of Land
Acquisition Act, 1894, in the view of recent judgment dated
19.9.2019 passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in case
titled as Union of India v/s Tarsem Singh & others.
v.
The applicant is also awarded Solatium amount 30%
on such assessed market-value, in consideration of the
compulsory nature of acquisition, as per provisions of section
23(2) of Land Acquisition Act.
11.
Competent
Authority-cum-Land
Acquisition
Collector, Mukerian, is directed to re-calculate the due amount
as per this Award, within 30 days from receipt of copy of this
award, taking into consideration the actual area acquired of
applicant, his share therein, and to convey to NHAI for
payment as decided above, and said enhanced amount be
paid to the applicant as per share after deducting the amount
already paid.”
12.
The said award dated 23.11.2020 in case of “Waryam
Singh vs. UOI and others” in MA No.171 of 2011 was assailed at
the instance of respondents No.1 and 2 before the ld. Additional
District Judge, Jalandhar having invoked Section 34 of the 1966 Act,
however, the said petition was dismissed vide decision dated
SANJAY GUPTA
2026.02.02 19:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
13.02.2023 and thus, the adjudication dated 23.11.2020 passed by
Commissioner, Jalandhar Division-cum-Arbitrator with respect to the
market value @ Rs.1,45,000/- per marla has become final.
13.
In view of the aforesaid, by applying the principle of parity
and to maintain the equality and uniformity, the petitioner-landowner
being identically placed is awarded the benefit of same market value
@ Rs.1,45,000/- per marla along with all other statutory benefits
permissible and awarded in terms of decision dated 23.11.2020
against acquisition of his land forming part of khasra No.31//18 (2
kanals 9 marlas) situated in Village Khanpur, Tehsil Mukerian, District
Hoshiarpur. The present writ petition is thus allowed in the above
terms.
14.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
21.01.2026
Sonika/sanjay
Whether speaking/reasoned:
Whether reportable:
SANJAY GUPTA
2026.02.02 19:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
(HARKESH MANUJA)
JUDGE
Yes/No
Yes/ No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review