Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU &KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
…
WP(C) No. 2201/2021
CM No. 7879/2021
Reserved on: 29.06.2026
Pronounced on: 03.07.2026
Uploaded on: 03.07.2026
Whether the operative part or full
Judgment is pronounced: Full
Gurdeep Singh (Age No. 46 years)
S/o S. Jaspal Singh, R/o Village Raika
Labana, Tehsil and District Samba.
…….Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. Nitin Bhasin, Advocate
Versus
1. Union Territory of Jammu and
Kashmir through Commissioner/
Secretary
to
Govt.
School
Education
Department,
Civil
Secretariat, Jammu/Srinagar.
2. Director,
Jammu.
School
Education,
3. Chief Education Officer, Samba.
4. Zonal Education Officer, Ramgarh
(District Samba)
……Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Suneel Malhotra, GA
CORAM: HON’BLE MR JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Respondent No. 3, vide Advertisement Notice dated 27.04.2011,
invited fresh applications to fill up two vacancies for the post of
WP(C) No. 2201/2021
Rehbar-e-Taleem (ReT) Teacher for the target year 2009-10 under the
Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (SSA) at the newly established Primary
School, Raika Jougian, Zone Ramgarh. Pursuant to the said notice, the
petitioner, possessing the educational qualifications of B.Sc. and
B.Ed., submitted his candidature for engagement as a ReT Teacher at
the aforementioned school. In addition to the petitioner, eleven other
candidates also applied for the said posts.
2.
Respondent No. 4 then prepared an inter se merit list of the twelve
eligible candidates, ranking the petitioner at Serial No. 2. On
28.05.2011, a tentative selection panel was prepared reflecting the
petitioner at Serial No. 2 and one Ms. Sukhvinder Kour (M.A., B.Ed.)
at Serial No. 1. All members of the Village Education Committee
signed this tentative panel, and objections were invited against the
said panel. Since no objections were filed against the panel, the panel
became final for the engagement of ReT Teachers at Primary School,
Raika Jougian.
3.
Since Raika Jougian did not qualify as an independent 'habitation'
under the parameters of Government Order No. 288-Edu of 2009
dated 08.04.2009, the merit panel was prepared on the basis of the
Revenue Village as the unit of selection. Upon realizing that no
resident of Raika Jougian was included in the said panel, the local
inhabitants approached the Sarpanch and Panches of Panchayat Halqa
Raika Labana. They requested that the operationalization of the newly
opened Primary School be deferred until their habitation was formally
accorded Revenue Village status. Yielding to this public demand, the
WP(C) No. 2201/2021
Sarpanch approached respondent No. 3, who accepted the Panchayat's
representation and formally endorsed it vide communication dated
01.06.2011. Consequently, the selection process initiated under the
Advertisement Notice dated 27.04.2011 was kept in abeyance.
4.
The petitioner and one Ms. Sukhvinder Kour, whose names appeared
in the select panel, challenged respondent No. 3’s endorsement by
filing
SWP
No.
1304/2011.
Later,
through
the
counter-
affidavit/objections filed by the respondents, the petitioner revealed
that the decision to open the Primary School at Raika Jougian had
been withdrawn. This withdrawal was prompted by requests from the
Village Panchayat and political pressure from the local MLA and the
then Minister for Industries and Commerce. A corrigendum reflecting
this withdrawal was published in the State Times newspaper on
18.06.2011. In light of these facts, the petitioner subsequently
amended the writ petition to challenge the validity of the 18.06.2011
corrigendum.
5.
A Coordinate Bench of this Court in terms of judgment dated
05.10.2018, allowed the writ petition and quashed the corrigendum
issued by the respondent No. 3 with the direction to respondents to
take the selection process initiated vide Advertisement Notice dated
27.04.2011 to its logical conclusion by recommending the panel to the
higher authorities. The Coordinate Bench further directed that if the
petitioner is ultimately found to be eligible and entitled to selection as
ReT Teacher on the basis of his merit, a formal order of his
engagement be issued and the respondents were further directed to
WP(C) No. 2201/2021
culminate the whole process and issue the letter of engagement in
favour of the selected candidate within a period of two months from
the date of receipt of copy of the judgment dated 05.10.2018.
6.
Due to the respondents' failure to implement the judgment dated
05.10.2018 passed by the Coordinate Bench, the petitioner filed
contempt petition bearing CPSW No. 22/2019. This contempt petition
was taken up during the Covid-19 pandemic and disposed of on
02.06.2020. The learned Single Judge closed the proceedings after
recording that the respondents had considered and rejected the
petitioner's case vide order dated 07.02.2020, while granting the
petitioner liberty to challenge the rejection through fresh proceedings.
In the rejection order dated 07.02.2020, respondent No. 3 denied the
petitioner's engagement as a ReT Teacher by retrospectively applying
Government Order No. 919-Edu of 2018 dated 16.11.2018, under
which all pending selection panels lacking formal appointment orders
were deemed cancelled/withdrawn.
7.
Through the medium of the instant writ petition, the petitioner assails
not only Government Order No. 919-Edu of 2018 dated 16.11.2018
issued by respondent No. 1, whereby all advertisement notices and
selection panels for the engagement of ReT Teachers lacking formal
engagement orders were cancelled and withdrawn ab initio, but also
challenges the rejection order dated 07.02.2020 passed by respondent
No. 3. Additionally, the petitioner seeks a writ of Mandamus
commanding the respondents to finalize the selection process for the
two posts of ReT Teacher at Primary School, Raika Jougian, Zone
WP(C) No. 2201/2021
Ramgarh, in terms of the panel prepared by respondent No. 4 pursuant
to the Advertisement Notice dated 27.04.2011. The petitioner further
seeks a direction to engage him as a ReT Teacher at the said school
retrospectively from the date other candidates selected in the different
Zones of District Samba under the same advertisement notice, were
engaged, along with all consequential benefits.
8.
The petitioner challenges the impugned Government Order dated
16.11.2018 primarily on the ground that an administrative order
cannot operate retrospectively to divest a citizen of accrued or vested
rights. Furthermore, the petitioner submits that the executive cannot,
through an administrative fiat, strip this Hon’ble Court of its judicial
power or impair existing litigations, as doing so violates the mandate
of the Constitution. In the present case, the petitioner’s rights were
established after nearly seven years of litigation, concluding with the
Coordinate Bench's judgment dated 05.10.2018. Because the
petitioner’s case was merely awaiting the ministerial act of
implementing that judgment, the subsequent policy decision to close
the ReT Scheme cannot retrospectively defeat a binding judicial
mandate. To apply the Government Order in a manner that denies the
petitioner the fruits of his successful litigation in SWP No. 1304/2011
is ex-facie illegal and unconstitutional.
9.
The respondents, in their reply, have merely reiterated their previous
stance, contending that the petitioner is not entitled to any relief in
light of the subsequent closure of the ReT Scheme. In support of this
contention, the respondents have placed reliance upon an interim
WP(C) No. 2201/2021
order passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of
Jatinder Singh v. State of J&K and Ors.
10.
Mr. Nitin Bhasin, learned counsel for the petitioner, has drawn the
attention of this Court to the fact that the petitioner figured at Serial
No. 2 both in the initial merit list and the panel prepared by
respondent No. 4. He would submit that since no objections were
preferred against the said tentative panel, the panel attained finality.
He further urges that this position stood judicially affirmed by a
Coordinate Bench of this Court in the earlier round of litigation vide
judgment dated 05.10.2018, which went unchallenged by the
respondents and consequently holds the field. He has vehemently
argued that the impugned order dated 07.02.2020 was passed solely
on the ground of the formal closure of the ReT Scheme. However, in
view of the law settled by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union
Territory of Jammu and Kashmir & Others v. Saba Wani, 2026
INSC 439, the subsequent closure of the scheme cannot
retrospectively impair the rights of merit-holders placed in select
panels. Consequently, the petitioner is fully entitled to engagement,
and the respondents cannot deny him the same on account of an
administrative policy change.
11.
Per contra, Mr. Suneel Malhotra, learned counsel for the respondents,
argues that the selection panel prepared by respondent No. 4 was
strictly tentative and subject to objections. At the same time, he has
very fairly conceded that no objections were ever preferred against the
petitioner's placement in the said panel.
WP(C) No. 2201/2021
12.
Heard and perused the record.
13.
The record reflects that the petitioner’s placement at Serial No. 2 in
both the merit list and the tentative panel is completely undisputed.
Given the admitted position that the respondents received no
objections against the panel prepared by Respondent No. 4, the panel
stood uncontested and consequently became final. In the earlier round
of litigation, namely SWP No. 1304/2011, the Coordinate Bench of
this Court issued the following directions:
“For the foregoing reasons, I find merit in the writ petition
and the same is, accordingly, allowed. The impugned
corrigendum issued by respondent No. 3 is quashed and a
direction is issued to the respondents to take the selection
process initiated vide Advertisement notification dated
27.04.2011 to its logical end. Refusal by the Village
Education Committee to sign the panel, which is,
otherwise, in accordance with SSA norms and Rehbar-eTaleem Scheme shall not come in the way of respondent
No. 4 to proceed further and recommend the same to
Higher Authorities. An action with is in consonance with
law cannot be left to the mercy of Village Education
Committee, which is motivated by the considerations not
countenanced by law. Needless to say that, if the petitioner
is ultimately found to be eligible and entitled to selection
as ReTon the basis of his merit, a formal order of
engagement in his favour be issued. Respondents would
culminate the whole process and issue formal letter of
engagement in favour of the selected candidates within a
period of two months from the date a certified copy of this
judgment is served upon the respondents.”
14.
In terms of the judgment (supra) the impugned corrigendum issued by
the respondent No. 3 therein was quashed and a direction was issued
to the respondents to take the selection process initiated vide
notification dated 27.04.2011 to its logical end. Refusal by the Village
Education Committee to sign the panel, which is otherwise in
accordance with the SSA norms and Rehbar-e-Taleem Scheme, shall
not come in the way of the respondent No. 4 to proceed further and
WP(C) No. 2201/2021
recommend the same to the higher authorities. It was simultaneously
observed that if the petitioner is ultimately found to be eligible and
entitled to selection as ReT on the basis of his merit, a formal order of
engagement in his favour be issued.
15.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Union Territory of Jammu
and Kashmir & Others v. Saba Wani (supra) has issued the
following directions:
“25. In this view of the matter, we deem it appropriate to
issue following directions:
(a) The Closure Order of ReT Scheme dated 16.11.2018 for
cancellation/withdrawal shall not retrospectively impair
the right of the candidates found placed in the select
panel. In view of the discussion made hereinabove, the
candidates placed in respective select panels shall be
issued engagement/appointment orders as per their
position in the select panel having regard to the available
vacancies.
(b) The State shall issue the formal engagement orders to the
candidates of select panel within a period of eight weeks
in terms of the direction (a) above.
(c) Candidates appointed as per directions (a) and (b) from
the select panel under the ReT Scheme are directed to
acquire minimum qualification prescribed under NCTE
Regulations and Notifications, including to qualify the
TET, within 3 years and 3 attempts from date of their
engagement/ appointment. In this regard, the State is
directed to organize the TET annually. After successfully
acquiring the minimum qualification and passing TET
within prescribed time limit, the services of such
appointees shall be, accordingly, regularized on
completion of two years of service thereafter.
(d) The direction (c) above shall be applicable to the other
similarly situated candidates who have already been
appointed from the select panels under the ReT Scheme
after 23.08.2010 i.e., the date of NCTE notification
prescribing minimum qualifications and prior to the
issuance of Closure Order, and do not possess minimum
qualification including TET as per the notification of
NCTE. However, those appointees shall acquire
prescribed qualification within the time as specified in
direction (c).
(e) It is obligatory upon this Court to direct that once the
candidates/appointees under the ReT Scheme have
acquired the prescribed qualifications and qualified the
TET as indicated above, the seniority of all such
candidates/ appointees shall be redrawn and determined
by the competent authority of the State, maintaining their
WP(C) No. 2201/2021
respective positions in the select panels uninfluenced by
the date of appointment, joining or regularization. The
inter se seniority shall also be determined accordingly.
(f) It is further directed that if the candidates/appointees
including those already appointed and regularized who
do not acquire/possess the requisite qualifications in
terms of the NCTE notifications and fail to qualify the
TET within the period prescribed hereinabove, the State
is at liberty to dispense with their services as the mandate
of Article 21-A of the Constitution of India cannot be left
at altar even while rendering complete justice
invoking Article 142 of the Constitution of India. It is
further clarified that those candidates/appointees would
not have any claim with respect to seniority or
regularization as directed hereinabove.
(g) The directions issued hereinabove are in rem and shall
apply mutatis mutandis to the candidates already
appointed pursuant to 74 advertisements that are subject
matter of present proceedings, though they are not party
to the present appeals. In view thereof, this judgment
shall
be
widely
publicized,
and
all
the
candidates/appointees shall be duly informed of these
directions so that they can take recourse for acquiring the
minimum qualification as per NCTE Regulations and
Notifications, if they have not already acquired the same.
(h) The directions contained in clauses (a) to (g) hereinabove
shall apply to all the candidates who are litigating in any
Court and such cases have been filed prior to the date of
this judgment. It is further clarified that candidates who
have not already filed cases in any Court shall neither
acquire any fresh cause of action by virtue of these
directions nor be entitled to seek any further directions
from any Court in that regard.
(i) At the cost of repetition, it is clarified that this judgment
shall not be construed as reviving the ReT Scheme for
any purpose whatsoever, nor shall it be interpreted so as
to create or confer any right upon candidates who were
not part of a prepared select panel or who failed to
approach the Court timely. Moreover, these directions
are being issued in the peculiar facts and circumstances
of this case invoking the power under Article 142 of the
Constitution of India and it shall not be treated as
precedent in any manner whatsoever.
(j) In view of the observations made in para 24 above, we
believe that the State Government shall apply their mind
to the facts and circumstances of the case and the
situation prevalent in the State and to take an appropriate
decision with respect to the revision of the honorarium of
such teachers as they deem fit.”
16.
In terms of the judgment (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
explicitly held that the administrative closure of the ReT Scheme vide
Government Order dated 16.11.2018 cannot operate retrospectively to
WP(C) No. 2201/2021
impair or extinguish the rights of merit-holders placed in a validly
formulated selection panel. The Apex Court further mandated that
candidates featuring in such select panels must be issued formal
engagement and appointment orders in accordance with their
respective merit positions, having regard to the availability of
vacancies.
17.
Once the petitioner figured at Serial No. 2 in the selection panel
formulated by the respondents, and the said panel attained finality in
the absence of any objections, his right to be considered for
engagement as a ReT Teacher became absolute. This position stood
judicially protected under the judgment passed in the earlier round of
litigation. Consequently, the petitioner could not have been arbitrarily
deprived of his right by a retrospective policy change. The impugned
rejection order dated 07.02.2020 is, therefore, wholly unsustainable in
the eyes of law and is liable to be set aside more particularly in light
of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.
18.
Accordingly, the writ petition is disposed of in the following terms:
(i)
The impugned order No. 548-CEOS of 2020 dated 07.02.2020
is hereby quashed and set aside.
(ii)
The respondents are directed to consider the claim of the
petitioner for engagement as a Rehbar-e-Taleem Teacher in PS
Raika Jougian, Zone Ramgarh in terms of the judgment dated
05.10.2018 passed by the Coordinate Bench of this Court in
SWP No. 1304/2011, and in the light of the directions issued by
WP(C) No. 2201/2021
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in “Union Territory of Jammu
and Kashmir & Others v. Saba Wani (supra)”
(iii)
The respondents shall pass appropriate order strictly in
accordance with law within the period prescribed by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the aforesaid judgment.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
Jammu
03.07.2026
Karam Chand
Whether approved for reporting? Yes/No
KARAM CHAND
2026.07.03 13:12
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review