Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:1076
NAFR
INDRAJEET INDRAJEET SAHU
Date: 2026.02.11
SAHU
10:27:25 +0530
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRMP No. 4 of 2026
1 - Gurdeep Singh S/o Late Shri Keshar Singh, Aged About 68 Years
Occupation- Dairy Business, R/o- Railnagar, Charoda, P.S.H.- Old Bhilai 3,
Tehsil Bhilai, District, Durg, Chhattisgarh.
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through P.S.H. Old Bhilai District Durg,
Chhattisgarh.
2 - Shri Dilip Hinduja, S/o Shri Tikam Das Hinduja, Aged About 58 Years, R/o
New Shanti Nagar, Raipur, Chhattisgarh, P.S.H.- Civil Lines, Raipur, Tehsil
and District Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
... Respondent(s)
For Petitioner
:
For State
:
Shri Ashok Verma, Sr. Advocate along
with Shri Gajendra Sahu, Advocate.
Shri Ashish Shukla, Additional Advocate
General.
Hon’ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, J
Order on Board
07.01.2026
1.
The present Criminal Misc. Petition has been filed by the petitioner
under Section 528 of BNSS, 2023, against the impugned order dated
13.11.2025 passed by the 9th Additional Sessions Judge, Durg, in
Criminal Revision No.47/2025 whereby the said Criminal Revision filed
by the respondent No.2-Dilip Hinduja was allowed and the order dated
07.12.2024 passed by the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Bhilai-3,
District Durg, in Criminal Case No.663/2014 was set aside.
2.
The subject matter in brief is that, an FIR of Crime No.120/2013 was
registered at Police Station, Old Bhilai, District Durg, for the offence
under Sections 420,467,468,471, 34 IPC against the present petitioner
Gurdeep Singh, co-accused Mohd. Shakeel Khan and Keshari Begum.
After investigation, charge sheet was filed on 02.08.2014 against the
co-accused persons Shakeel Khan and Keshari Begum stating no
sufficient evidence was found against the present petitioner Gurdeep
Singh during investigation and since the co-accused Keshari Begum
was absconding, charge sheet was filed only against Shakeel Khan. It
was the allegation in the complaint made by the complainant Dilip
Hinduja that the present petitioner along with other co-accused
persons prepared forged Rin Pustika and power of attorney and got the
land of Khasra Nos. 462/2 & 463/2 situated at village Charoda, District
Durg, transferred in the name of co-accused in between 30.11.1994
and 24.02.2012. Initially charge sheet was filed against the co-accused
Shakeel Khan and subsequently when the co-accused Keshari Begum
was arrested, supplementary charge sheet was filed against her on
26.03.2016. Further, another supplementary charge sheet was filed
against the present petitioner on 12.08.2024 for the offence under
Sections 420,464,467,468,471, 34 IPC along with Section 120-B IPC.
On 17.09.2024 an application was filed by the present petitioner under
Section 91 CrPC for directing the police authorities to produce the
relevant documents of Revenue Case No.78/B-121/2017-18 and the
report of Naib Tehsildar dated 18.01.2018 and 12.07.2019. The trial
court directed the prosecution to produce the documents of letter dated
03.12.2017 written to Naib Tehsildar by Police Station Old Bhiali, report
of the Naib Tehsildar dated 27.12.2017, stay order dated 18.01.2018
and the amended order dated 12.07.2019. The prosecution took time
repeatedly to comply with the order dated 17.09.2024 and the certified
copies of the relevant documents in compliance of the order dated
17.09.2024 was produced by the prosecution on 20.11.2024.
Thereafter, the matter was being heard on the issue of framing charge
against the petitioner Gurdeep Singh and after recording submissions
of the parties, on 07.12.2024 the petitioner Gurdeep Singh was
discharged from the offence under Sections 420,467,468,471, 34 and
120-B of IPC.
3.
The said order of discharge of the petitioner Gurdeep Singh was
challenged by the complainant Dilip Hinduja before the 9 th Additional
Sessions Judge, Durg, in Criminal Revision No.47/2025. The said
Criminal Revision was allowed vide order dated 13.11.2025 and the
order passed by the trial court dated 07.12.2024, discharging the
petitioner/accused Gurdeep Singh, was set aside and the matter was
remitted back to the trial court for its fresh consideration and to
proceed in accordance with law against the accused Gurdeep Singh,
which is under challenge in the present Criminal Misc. Petition.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that there is no
sufficient material in the charge sheet to proceed with the trial against
the present petitioner Gurdeep Singh. At the time when first charge
sheet was filed against co-accused persons, it has been specifically
mentioned in the charge sheet that no sufficient evidence is found
against the present petitioner Gurdeep Singh and accordingly he was
not arrayed as an accused in the original charge sheet. After about 11
years of filing original charge sheet, supplementary charge sheet has
been filed against the petitioner on the same same facts which were
available in the year 2014 itself. Filing of supplementary charge sheet
against the petitioner is abuse of process of law as well as process of
the court. In supplementary charge sheet, the dead persons have been
made witnesses which itself shows that the supplementary charge
sheet has been filed against the petitioner with malafide intention. He
would further submit that the respondent No.2-Dilip Hinduja, is claiming
to be the legal representative of the deceased Kewal Ram on the basis
of an alleged will executed in his favour, but the said Will was not
executed with respect to subject land and Dilip Hinduja was having no
locus to file Criminal Revision against the order dated 07.12.2024
before the Sessions Court. The main witness Kewal Ram, who was
complainant in the case, died in the year, 2018 itself, yet he has been
shown as witness in the supplementary charge sheet.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would further submit that the
respondent No.2 had filed a Criminal Complaint Case against the
petitioner and two other co-accused persons before Judicial Magistrate
First Class, Bhilai-3 for the offence under Sections 406, 420, 464, 467,
468, 471 and 120-B IPC which was registered as Criminal Complaint
Case No.314/2015 in which the evidences are also started and it has
been fixed for 08.01.2026. Filing of charge sheet by the police in the
same matter amounts to double jeopardy and two separate
proceedings for the same offence cannot be continued in violation of
Article 20(2) of the Constitution of India. In Crime No.663/2014 which is
pending before the trial court against co-accused Shakeel Khan &
others and in the Criminal Complaint Case filed against the petitioner,
the allegations are the same. He would also submit that the Additional
Sessions Judge has failed to appreciate that one Civil Suit was also
filed by the respondent No.2 against the petitioner and other accused
persons in the Court of 6th Additional District Judge, Durg, vide Civil
Suit No.65-A/2014 to declare the sale deed null and void which is still
pending consideration. Therefore, in the garb of criminality, civil dispute
cannot be converted into a Criminal Case and as such the
supplementary charge sheet against the petitioner cannot be filed
when the civil dispute as well as criminal case against other accused
persons are still subjudice. It is also submitted that another Civil Suit
No.51-A/2012 has been filed by the petitioner against Kewal Ram for
specific performance of the Contract which is also pending before the
Civil Judge, Senior Division, Bhilai-3, District Durg. The petitioner was
cited as prosecution witness in first charge sheet filed against the coaccused Shakeel Khan as also in the first supplementary charge sheet
filed against co-accused Keshari Begum. Filing of supplementary
charge sheet after such a long time of 11 years would amount to abuse
of judicial process of law as well as court. After considering the entire
facts and circumstances of the case the trial court has rightly
discharged the petitioner, however the Additional Sessions Judge have
not considered the true aspect of the facts of the case as well as law
laid down by the Supreme Court holding the field, and set aside the
well reasoned order passed by the trial court and remitted the matter
back for fresh consideration against the petitioner in accordance with
law, therefore, the same is liable to be set aside and the order passed
by the trial court may be restored. In support of his contentions, he
would rely upon the following judgments:
•
Tuhin Kumar Biswas @ Bumba Vs. The State of West
Bengal, SLP(Cr.)No.3002 of 2024.
•
Sanjaysinh Ramrao Chavan Vs. Dattatray Gulabrao Phalke,
AIR 2015 SC (Cr.)500.
•
State of Haryana Vs. Bhajanlal & Others, 1992 CrLJ 527.
•
S.C. Garg Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Another, 2025 INSC
493 (Criminal Appeal No.438 of 2018)
•
Robert Lalchungnunga Vs. Chongthu @ RL Chongthu, 2025
INSC 1339 {SLP(Cr.)No.10130 of 2025}
•
Nitya Dharmananda @ K Lenin and Another Vs. Gopal
Sheelum Reddy and Another, 2018(2) SCC 93.
•
T.T. Anthony Vs. State of Kerala, AIR 2001 SC 2637
•
Shiv Charan & Others Vs. The State of Rajasthan & Another,
2012 CrLJ 211.
•
Vakil Prasad Singh Vs. State of Bihar, 2009 AIR SCW 1418
•
Pankaj Kumar Vs. State of Maharashtra & Others, 2008 CrLJ
3944.
6.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the State supported the
impugned order passed by the revisional court.
7.
I have heard the counsel for the parties and perused the material
annexed with the petition.
8.
It is not in dispute that on the complaint made by the complainant Dilip
Hinduja an FIR was registered on 24.02.2012 against three accused
persons namely Gurdeep Singh (Petitioner), Mohd. Shakeel Khan and
Keshari Begum. It is alleged in the complaint that his Uncle late Idan
Das and his cousin brother Kewal Ram was having 0.97 Hect. of land
at Charoda, out of which 3000 sq.feet of the land was fraudulently
alienated in the name of co-accused Keshari Begum by the present
petitioner Gurdeep Singh and Shakeel Khan by preparing a forged
power of attorney. His brother has given him a power of attorney on
08.11.2011. He also gave the details of transaction in the complaint. On
02.08.2014, at the time of filing of first charge sheet, the police has
considered that there is no sufficient evidence against the present
petitioner Gurdeep Singh for filing charge sheet, however, the charge
sheet was filed against Shakeel Khan who was arrested on 15.05.2014
showing Keshari Begum absconding. It has also been mentioned that
charge sheet was filed under Section 173(8) CrPC. In the first charge
sheet the present petitioner Gurdeep Singh S/o Keshar Singh was
shown to be a witness and his name appears in the witness list. On
18.03.2016 when supplementary charge sheet was filed against coaccused Keshari Begum, the present petitioner Gurdeep Singh S/o
Keshar Singh again shown to be a witness for prosecution side and his
name appears in the witness list.
9.
From FIR it transpires that there was allegation against the present
petitioner that the land of late Idan Das and Kewal Ram was illegally
transferred by the accused persons in the name of co-accused Keshari
Begum by preparing forged document. The Rin Pustika of the land was
given to the present petitioner Gurdeep Singh in the year 1994 for
correction of revenue records, but he did not return the original
documents of land to its owner. Subsequently the complainant came to
know that the land was transferred in the name of Keshari Begum.
From the statement of Sukhdev Singh Siddhu it also transpires that the
present petitioner was also interested to purchase the subject land and
initially the transaction was made between him and Laxman Singh. The
named FIR has been lodged by the complainant, but in absence of
sufficient evidence initially the charge sheet was not filed against the
present petitioner.
10.
It further transpires from the ordersheet dated 08.01.2018 of the trial
court which has been annexed at page No.262 of the petition that the
police
authority
made
an
application
for
permission
to
file
supplementary charge sheet against the present petitioner Gurdeep
Singh as the complainant Dilip Hinduja had made a complaint that he
has not been arrayed as an accused in the earlier charge sheet and on
application being made by the prosecution, the trial court has observed
in its order that the police is competent to file supplementary charge
sheet under Section 173(8) CrPC as and when he received additional
evidence or sufficient evidence against the accused. For that, there is
no need to obtain any permission from the Magistrate.
11.
Further, the supplementary charge sheet was filed against the
petitioner on 12.08.2024 and cognizance of offences were taken
against the petitioner on the same day. However, the petitioner has not
challenged filing of supplementary charge sheet or order taking
cognizance against him. On 17.09.2024 an application under Section
91 CrPC was filed by the petitioner for calling certain documents which
were not the part of charge sheet saying that earlier the charge sheet
was filed against co-accused persons in which there was no sufficient
evidence against the petitioner to file charge sheet and to proceed with
the trial against him. The trial court considering the application under
Section 91 CrPC filed by the petitioner, called the enquiry report from
the concerned revenue authority and vide its order dated 17.09.2024
directed the police authorities to produce enquiry report dated
27.12.2017, stay order dated 18.01.2018 and amended order dated
12.07.2019 for consideration on framing charge against the petitioner.
The copy of documents were filed by the prosecution as per the order
passed by the trial court and after considering those documents which
were filed by the prosecution in compliance of the order dated
17.09.2024, the trial court discharged the petitioner from the alleged
offences holding that Naib Tehsildar, Bhilai-3 have conducted a
detailed enquiry, but the said enquiry report was not the part of charge
sheet and as per the enquiry report there is evidence against the
present petitioner Gurdeep Singh that he was also involved in the
conspiracy with the co-accused persons Shakeel Khan and Keshari
Begum, but there is no sufficient evidence against him (petitioner) to
proceed with the trial.
12.
The revisional court has considered in its order that at the time of
framing of charge, the accused has no right to produce any documents
in his defence and further the trial court while framing charge cannot
consider the documents submitted by the accused. They should
consider only those documents which were produced along with
charge sheet.
13.
The revisional court has observed in its order dated 13.11.2025 that
FIR has been registered against the present petitioner also and
presently after adding the offence of Section 120-B IPC, the
supplementary charge sheet has been filed against him. It is alleged in
the case that the accused persons on the basis of forged and
fabricated documents got the land of Kewal Ram transferred in the
name of co-accused Keshari Begum. The Rin Pustika of subject land
was obtained from the record of Civil Suit which was filed by the
present petitioner in the Civil Suit and got it enquired from Naib
Tehsildar, Bhilai-3, to which he reported that there are certain
manipulation in the Rin Pustika which has been used for alienation of
the subject property. Considering the conduct of parties, the offence
under Section 120-B IPC has also been added. The revisional court
has also considered that the trial court, based upon the enquiry report
conducted by the Naib Tehsildar, Bhilai-3 has discharged the petitioner
which is against the law governing the field.
14.
The Supreme Court in case of Nitya Dharmananda @ K Lenin and
Another Vs. Gopal Sheelum Reddy and Another, 2018(2) SCC 93,
has held in paragraph 8 as under:
“8. Thus, it is clear that while ordinarily the Court has to proceed
on the basis of material produced with the charge sheet for
dealing with the issue of charge but if the court is satisfied that
there is material of sterling quality which has been withheld by
the investigator/prosecutor, the court is not debarred from
summoning or relying upon the same even if such document is
not a part of the charge sheet. It does not mean that the defence
has a right to invoke Section 91 Cr.P.C. de hors the satisfaction
of the court, at the stage of charge.”
15.
Further, in State of Orissa Vs. Debendra Nath Padhi, 2005(1)SCC
568 the Supreme Court has held in paragraph 25 as under:
“25. Any document or other thing envisaged under the aforesaid
provision can be ordered to be produced on finding that the same
is 'necessary or desirable for the purpose of investigation, inquiry,
trial or other proceedings under the Code'. The first and foremost
requirement of the section is about the document being
necessary or desirable. The necessity or desirability would have
to be seen with reference to the stage when a prayer is made for
the production. If any document is necessary or desirable for the
defence of the accused, the question of invoking Section 91 at
the initial stage of framing of a charge would not arise since
defence of the accused is not relevant at that stage. When the
section refers to investigation, inquiry, trial or other proceedings,
it is to be borne in mind that under the section a police officer
may move the Court for summoning and production of a
document as may be necessary at any of the stages mentioned
in the section. In so far as the accused is concerned, his
entitlement to seek order under Section 91 would ordinarily not
come till the stage of defence. When the section talks of the
document being necessary and desirable, it is implicit that
necessity and desirability is to be examined considering the
stage when such a prayer for summoning and production is
made and the party who makes it whether police or accused. If
under Section 227 what is necessary and relevant is only the
record produced in terms of Section 173 of the Code, the
accused cannot at that stage invoke Section 91 to seek
production of any document to show his innocence. Under
Section 91 summons for production of document can be issued
by Court and under a written order an officer in charge of police
station can also direct production thereof. Section 91 does not
confer any right on the accused to produce document in his
possession to prove his defence. Section 91 presupposes that
when the document is not produced process may be initiated to
compel production thereof.”
16.
The powers of police to conduct further investigation, even after laying
final report, is recognized under Section 173(8) CrPC. Dealing with the
said issue, in Sri Bhagwan Samardha Sreepada Vallabha Venkata
Vishwanandha Maharaj Vs. State of A.P. & Others, 1999(5)SCC
740, the Supreme Court in paragraph 10 of its judgment held as under:
“10. Power of the police to conduct further investigation, after
laying final report, is recognised under Section 173(8) of the
Code of Criminal Procedure. Even after the court took
cognizance of any offence on the strength of the police report
first submitted, it is open to the police to conduct further
investigation. This has been so stated by this Court in Ram Lal
Narang v. State (Delhi Admn.) (AIR 1979 SC 1791). The only
rider provided by the aforesaid decision is that it would be
desirable that the police should inform the court and seek formal
permission to make further investigation.”
17.
Recently in the matter of Rajnish Kumar Bishwakarma Vs. State
(NCT of Delhi) and another reported in 2024 Live Law SC 537, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has reiterated the principals laid down in the
case of State of Orissa Vs. Devendra Nath Padhi (Supra) and held in
Para 6 that:“6. At the stage of framing charge, the trial court is required to
consider whether there are sufficient grounds to proceed against
the accused. Section 227 of the Code provides for the eventuality
when the accused shall be discharged. If not discharged, the
charge against the accused is required to be framed under
Section 228. These two sections read as under.
Section 227 CrPC
“227 Discharge--If, upon consideration of the record of the case
and the documents submitted therewith, and after hearing the
submissions of the accused and the prosecution in this behalf,
the Judge considers that there is not sufficient ground for
proceeding against the accused, he shall discharge the accused
and record his reasons for so doing.
Section 228 CrPC
“228. Framing of charge(1) If, after such consideration and hearing as aforesaid, the
Judge is of opinion that there is ground for presuming that the
accused has committed an offence which(a) is not exclusively trable by the Court of Session, he
may, frame a charge against the accused and, by order,
transfer the case for trial to the Chief Judicial Magistrate,
and thereupon the Chief Judicial Magistrate shall try the
offence in accordance with the procedure for the trial of
warrant cases instituted on a police report;
(b) is exclusively triable by the court, he shall frame in
writing a charge against the accused.
(2) Where the Judge frames any charge under clause (b) of subsection (1), the charge shall be read and explained to the
accused, and the accused shall be asked whether he pleads
guilty of the offence charged or claims to be tried."
18.
In the present case also after permission from the court, the police
authority have filed the supplementary charge sheet against the
present petitioner, in which, the trial court discharged the accused vide
order dated 07.12.2024, however, the revisional court set aside the
order of discharge of the present petitioner and remitted the matter
back to proceed with the trial in accordance with law by impleading the
present petitioner also as an accused in the case.
19.
In the matter of State (NCT of Delhi) vs. Shiv Charan Bansal and
Others, 2020 (2) SCC 290, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that at
the stage of framing of charge, the trial court is not required to conduct
a meticulous appreciation of evidence or a roving inquiry into the same
and has the power to sift and weigh the evidence for the limited
purpose of finding out whether or not a prima facie case is made out
against the accused to proceed with the trial.
20.
The judgments relied upon by the petitioner does not help him as the
facts and circumstances of those cases are distinguishable to the facts
and consideration of present case.
21.
Accordingly, this court does not find any scope for interference in the
present petition. The same deserves to be and is hereby dismissed.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
inder
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review