Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.16
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 141 of 2022
Date of Decision :24.04.2024
1. Shri. Gurdeep Singh,
S/o Shri. Gurmaj Singh
R/o Punjabi Colony, Goralane,
Laitumkhrah, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
2. Smti. Sabitri Lama,
D/o Shri. Dhanu Lama,
R/o New Colony, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
3. Smti. Vimi Dorjee,
D/o (L) N.D.Dorjee,
R/o Nongmynsong, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
4. Shri. Suraj Ray,
S/o Shri. Arjun Ray,
R/o Nongrim Hills, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
5. Shri. Ajay Singh,
S/o Robinder Singh,
R/o Punjabi Colony, Goralane,
Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
6. Shri. Gurmeet Singh,
S/o Gurmat Singh,
R/o Punjabi Colony, Goralane,
Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
7. Shri. Preetimon Riahtam,
H/o (L) R. Nongkynrih,
R/o Demseiniong, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
8. Shri. Pronoy Kar,
S/o Pramod Kar,
R/o Pynthorbah, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
9. Smti. Mamta Mishra,
D/o T. N.Mishra,
R/o Pynthorbah, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
10.Smti. Trilian Jyrwa,
D/o S. Nonglyer,
R/o Demseiniong, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
11.Shri. Bikram Singh,
S/o Shri. J. Singh,
R/o Punjabi Colony, Goralane,
Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
12.Smti. Bina Sangma,
D/o Shri. Poresh Marak,
R/o Pynthorbah, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
13.Shri. Jiban Paul,
S/o Naren Kr. O Paul,
R/o Pynthorbah, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
14.Shri. Kalban Kaur,
S/o Mukhtar Singh,
R/o Punjabi Colony, Goralane,
Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
…Writ Petitioners
-Versus1. The Union of India represented by the
Secretary, Ministry of Power.
2. The North Eastern Electric Power
Corporation Ltd., Shillong.
3. The Chairman and Managing Director
of the North Eastern Electric Power
Corporation Ltd., Shillong.
…Respondents.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. R.Jha, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Dr. N.Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. A.Pradhan, Adv. for R 1.
Mr. V.K.Jindal, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. B.Jyrwa, Adv. for R 2 & 3.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The writ petitioners, numbering 14 in Nos. in this third round of
litigation have sought for regularization of their services as permanent
workers under the respondent No. 2.
2.
The brief facts are that the petitioners are stated to be part-time
Cleaners and Sweepers with the respondent Corporation, and have been
employed on various dates commencing from the year 1985, with the last
employment being in 2008, which are as follows:
Sl.No.
Name
Post
Initial date
of joining
6.
Shri. Gurdip Singh
Sweeper
01/02/1989
7.
Smti. Mamta Mishra
Cleaner
03/07/1995
8.
Shri. Suraj Rai
Cleaner
03/07/1995
11.
Smti. Bina Sangma
Cleaner
01/05/2008
16.
Smti. Vimi Dorjee
Cleaner
16/10/1990
17.
Smti. Preetimon Riahtum
Cleaner
24/05/1996
18.
Smti. Sabitri Lama
Cleaner
08/04/1985
24.
Shri. Jibon Paul
Cleaner
03/07/1995
25.
Shri. Pronoy Kar
Cleaner
06/02/1996
27.
Shri. Ajay Singh
Sweeper
03/07/1995
3.
28.
Smti. Trilin Jyrwa
Sweeper
01/04/2000
29.
Smti. Kalbon Kaur
Sweeper
01/01/1987
30.
Shri. Gurmit Singh
Sweeper
03/07/1995
32.
Shri. Bikram Singh
Sweeper
01/04/2002
The basis of their claim is that though the writ petitioners have been
working for a considerable period of time, they have not been considered
for regularization against sanctioned posts, as was done to 26 other
employees wherein, for the same or similar posts, the 26 employees were
given regular employment.
4.
Mr. R.Jha, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the
very fact that the petitioners have rendered services commencing from
1985 and so forth, will entitle them as per law to consideration for
regularization as given in the judgment of Uma Devi, inasmuch as, the
Corporation has been using their services continuously, and as the same is
required, there is no question of them being denied their due service
benefits. It is further submitted that the stand of the respondents that there
are no sanctioned posts of Sweepers, is belied by the very fact that on an
affidavit by the respondent Corporation filed on 01-03-2024, it has been
shown that the appointment of 5 persons from the list of 26 were Sweepers
in a regular scale of pay under the Corporation. He therefore, submits that
the writ petitioners have been discriminated in not being afforded regular
employment inspite of their services having been used by the respondent
Corporation till date.
5.
Mr. V.K.Jindal, learned Sr. counsel assisted by Ms. B.Jyrwa, learned
counsel for the respondent Nos. 2 & 3, has submitted that the terms of
appointment of the writ petitioners is on a different footing altogether and
they were employed strictly on a part-time basis. It is further submitted
that such employment is purely casual in nature and not against any regular
sanctioned posts. Further, it is submitted that the entry of the writ
petitioners into service as part-time workers was also not through due
selection process, which is necessary for regular employment. It is further
submitted that it is not a question of the writ petitioners holding any adhoc
posts on a temporary basis against any posts, to vest them with any right to
regular employment.
6.
He concludes, by submitting that the writ petitioners having no
vested rights are not entitled to any relief prayed for, and moreover, this
being the third round of litigation on the same relief, the writ petition is
barred by the principle of res judicata.
7.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and seen the materials on
record. Admittedly, the writ petitioners were employed by the respondent
Corporation since the dates mentioned hereinabove, and further the factum
that they continued in employment is also not disputed by the respondent
Corporation. The only fact that distinguishes them from other regular
employees is that the mode of recruitment was not through a regular
selection process, and further were employed only on a part-time basis. A
perusal of one such appointment order dated 11th April, 2022
of the
petitioners, reflects that the terms of engagement were purely on a parttime basis at a fixed rate and fixed working hours, i.e. only morning and
evening on working days.
8.
The writ petitioners on entering this engagement, therefore, were
well aware about the nature of the employment and also as to whether they
were to be eligible for regularization. In the backdrop of these facts, the
appointment of the writ petitioners as part-time workers stands on a
different plank altogether from the 26 regularly appointed persons referred
thereto, and as such, no parity can be claimed by the writ petitioners. It is
also settled law that there is an estoppel against challenging the nature of
appointment, once having duly accepted the same. The writ petitioners
therefore, in the considered view of this Court, on the terms of
employment and as the same not being against any sanctioned posts, nor
adhoc in nature, but purely part-time, are not entitled to the reliefs as
claimed.
9.
However, it is disconcerting to note that the respondent Corporation
has repeatedly maintained the stand that there are no sanctioned posts of
Sweepers in the Corporation. As the learned Sr. counsel for the respondent
Corporation has again made submissions that, at the time when the writ
petition was filed, and before the affidavit was filed, there were no
sanctioned posts, it would be expedient to reproduce paragraph 4 (iii) of
the affidavit filed by the respondent Corporation on 27-06-2022, which
reads as follows:
“4 (iii)
It is the settled law that any
regularization of services after casual
engagement tantamount to back door entry and
is against the principle of providing equal
opportunity enshrine in the Constitution of India.
Further, the case of the Petitioners even does not
fall within the exception of Uma Devi Case in as
much as the exception carved out by the
Constitution Bench of India, in Uma Devi case
(2006) 4 SCC 1 is only with respect to duly
qualified workman in duly sanctioned post who
had continued for 10 (ten) years or more. But in
the case of the Petitioners, the post in question
i.e. the post of regular full time Sweeper or
Cleaner does not even exist or sanctioned and
they were only engaged on temporary basis as
Part Time Sweeper or Cleaner on a consolidated
fixed wage of Rs. 4,000/- per month, hence
question of regularization of the services of the
Petitioners in this case does not arise.”
(emphasis supplied)
10.
The same stand is again noticed in the speaking order dated 20th
March, 2020, answering the representation dated 30th September, 2019,
which had been filed pursuant to the orders of this Court dated 22-072019, in WP(C). No. 263 of 2019. In the said speaking order, at para iv
thereto, the Deputy General Manager of the respondent Corporation has
stated as follows:
“iv. There is no such regular post of either
sweeper or cleaner and no such post is ever
sanctioned by the NEEPCO and you also do not
hold any such post on adhoc or temporary basis
and as such there is no question of regularization
of your services on the post which does not
exist.”
(emphasis supplied)
11.
Strangely, on the last affidavit dated 01-03-2024, filed by the
respondent Corporation, at Annexure-A to the said affidavit, 5 persons
have been shown to be appointed vide appointment order dated 05-111990, as sweepers in the regular posts. The stand of the respondent
Corporation which is contradictory and misleading, is therefore deprecated
by this Court.
It is therefore, not expected from a Public Sector
Undertaking which is regarded as a model employer to adopt such double
standards. Though this Court refrains at this stage from imposing any cost,
it is expected that in any such matters, there should be a level playing field,
and persons eligible be permitted to participate for selection to such posts,
especially considering the fact that their services are being used for the
benefit of the Corporation.
12.
Though the writ petitioners in view
of the nature of their
appointment are not entitled to be considered for regularization, inasmuch
as, the initial appointment is clearly as part-time workers, to balance the
equities and as it has been submitted that they are engaged for the entire
working day, it is directed that the respondent Corporation pay the said
employees Minimum Wages as prevalent under law, and further
considering the nature of the services rendered by the petitioners, calculate
the arrears, which will be payable from the date the writ petition was
instituted i.e. 19th April, 2022 till date.
13.
With the above directions, this writ petition is closed and disposed
of.
Judge
Meghalaya
24.04.2024
“Samantha PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review