The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. It is also ro be noted that, the dismissar of w.A.No.g cannot be construed as a final adjudication entitlement to approval of appointment. 11zot t; 9 scc 6ls .\ i t, li P E E G \ 46 of 2022 on the appellant,s The Division Bench merely declined to interfere with the direction issued by the learned single I Judge to consider the appellant's case and did not issue a positive mandamus granting approval. Conclusion i L4, For the foregoing reasons, we hold that the learned Single i Judge was justified in exercising Review jurisdiction on the ground of an error apparent on the face of the record. The appellant's suppression of a material fact disentitles him to any equitable relief. The appellant's appointment, having been made after the imposition of the ban on aided posts, was rightly hetd to be impermissible. The order passed in Review suffers from no legal infirmity. The Writ Appeal is d-evoid of merit and is liable to be dismissed.
15. Accordingly, the Writ Appeal is dismissed. No order as to costs. As a sequel, miscellaneolls petitions, pending if any, stand closed //TRUE COPYII To,
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3488 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, THE EIGHTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHTEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WRIT APPEAL NO: 876 OF 2025
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent Preferred Against the order
dated 2810212025 Passed in W.P.No 28768 of 2016 on the file of the High Court.
Between:
a
Gulam Jeelani, S/o. Late Sri Gulam Afzal, Aged about 34 years,
Occ. Attender, Govt. Aided lslamia High School, Sherpura, Warangal,
Warangal District
...APPELLANTMRIT P ETITION ER
AND
1. The Governrnent of Telangana, Rep by its Principal Secretary to G_overnment,
School Education Department, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad, T.S.
2. the Commissioner and Director of School Education, State of Telangana,
Hyderabad.
3. The Regional Joint Director, School Education, Warangal.
4. The District Educational Officer, Warangal Urban, Warangal District5. The Government Aided lslamic High School, Rep. by its Correspondent and
Secretary, Warangal, Warangal District.
...RESPONDENTS
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the operation of the order in Review l.A.No.1/2024 dated 28.O2.2025 in
W.P.No.287681 2019 in allowing the Review Petition and recalling the order
dated 15.11.2022 passed in the W.P.No.2876812019 by the Learned Single
Judge pending the above writ appeal.
Counsel for the Appellant: SRI RAMACHANDAR RAO VEMUGANTI
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.l to 4: SRI S. RAHUL REDDY, SPECIAL GP
ATTACHED TO THE OFFICE OF THE ADDITIONAL ADVOCATE GENERAL
Counsel for the Respondent No.5: -The Court made the following: JUDGMENT
IN THE HIGH COI'RT F1OR THE SIATE OF TEUINGAI{A
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF"JI'STICE SRI APARESIH KI'MAR SINGH
A}ID
I
I
I
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
I
I
I
V'RIT APPEAL No.876 of 2o25
I
j
DATI}: O8 -or-2026
I
I
I
i
t
BETWEEN:
I
I
I
i
.Appellant
Gulam Jeelani
AND
:
I
:
I
.
The Government of 'l'elangana,
rep. by its Principal Secretary to Government,
School Education Department and for-rr others
....Respondents
JUDGMENI
Heard sri Ramchandar Rao Vemuganti, Iearned counsel lbr
the appellant; and Sri S. Ra.hul Reddy, learned Special Government
Pleader attached to thc office ol the learned Additional Advocate
General appearing fbr respondent Nos.l to 4 and perused the
material on record.
2.
The present writ Appeai is directed against the order dated
28.02.2025 passed in Review I.A. No. L of 2024 in w.P.No.28768 ot
2olg, whereby the learned Single Judge recalled the earlier order
dated 15.1 1 .2022 and dismissed the writ petition, holding that the
appointment of the appellant on compassionate grounds was made
subsequent to the inrposition of the ban on appointments in aiCed
posts and was, therefore, impermissible in law.
..)..
3.
The factual matrix, in the present case, i.s that the appellantls
father, who was working as an Attender in the sth respondent_
School, an aided minority institution, died in harness on 05. 12.2003.
consequent thereto, the appellant's mother submitted a
representation dated 30.06.2004 seeking appointment on
compassionate grounds. The management of the 5r-1, respondentSchool appointed the appeflant as an Attender on 27.o1.2005
and
forwarded a proposal dated 05.02.2oo5 to the 4th respondent seeking
approval of the said appointment.
4.
Prior thereto, the Statc Government had imposed a ban on
creation and filring up of
aided posts uid.e Memo
No.1208o/cosE/A2/2oo4-4 dated 2o.ro.2oo4. The said ban was
subsequently clarified to be applicable even to appointments
on
il
i.
I
compassionate grounds uide Memo No.g544/ps-i/2o0s_3
dated
14.11.2005. The appellant earlier approached this court by
filing
I
I
I
I
w.P. No.22262 of 2o11, which was disposed of with a direction
i
consider his case. pursuant thereto, the 4th respondent rejected
I
proposal for approval uide proceedings dated 2g.ro.2org.
I
,l
i
5.
I
I
I
E
to
the
Aggrieved thereby, the appellant filed w.tr.No.2g76g of
20i9,
which was allowed by the learned Single Judge by order
dated
r
I
I
i
15.1i .2022, directing the respondents to consider the
case for approval without reference to the ban
appellant,s
order. The said order
was carried in appear in w.A. No.g46 of 2022
\
by the appellant;
\
..1..
A
however, the writ appeal was dismissed on 21.06.2023, affirming the
direction issued by the learned Single Judge. Thereafter, the
respondents filed Review I.A. No. I of 2024 before the learned single
I
I
I
i
Judge. By ord.er dated 28.02.2025, the learned Single Judge allowed
the review, recalled the order dated 15.11.2022 and dismissed the
writ petition.
Contentions of the aPPellant
The appellant, in this appeal, has raised several grounds,
6.
contending as under:
(0
(ii)
That the exercise of revierv jurisdiction was barred by the
principles of finality, inasmuch as the order of the learned
Single Judge had already been affirmed by the Division
Bench in W.A. No.846 of 2022.
That the ban imposed by the State Government vide Memo
dated 2o.lo.2oo4 did not extend to appointments on
compassionate grounds until the issuance of the
clarification dated 14.11.2005 and, since the appellant was
appointed on 27.O1.2O05, the said ban had no application
to his case.
(ii0 That the learned Single Judge, while exercising review
. jurisdiction, erred in distinguishing the Judgments in w.P.
No.15621 of 2007 and w.P. No.21938 0f 2012, which had
been relied upon while passing the earlier order'
(iv) That the review application was filed with a delay of 301
days without proper explanation or condonation and was,
therefore, erroneously entertained'
::4::
Contentions of the respondents
7'
The learned Special Government pleader,
order passed in review, contended as
(i)
while supporting
under:
That the orcrer sought to be reviewed
suffered from an error
apparent on the face of the record,
rearned singre Judge had relied
inasmuch as the
upon precedents applicable
to cases where appointments were made prior
imposition of the ban, whereas, in
appellant's appointment was made
force.
to the
the present case, the
after the ban came into
(ii) That the appelrant had suppressed th.
material
having sought and obtained leave from
fact of
the Division Bench
in w.A. No.g46 of 2022 to move a review
learned Single Judge, which fact was
review proceedings.
petition before the
not discrosed in the
(iii) That the ban imposed uide Memo dated
2o.1o.2oo4 was
"
prospective and appricable to all
appointments in aided
posts' including appointments on
compassionate grounds,
and that the subsequent Memo dated
L4.LL20os was
merely crarificatory in nature and,
therefore, operated
retrospectively.
(iv) That the delay in filing the review petition
condoned and that the review was rightry
in the interest ofjustice.
8.
we have taken note of the respective
was dury
a,owed on merits
contentions urged.
\
l^,
Analysis and reasons
9.
It is pertinent to note that the power of review under Section
114 read with Order XLVII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure is
limited and cannot be equated with appellate jurisdiction. In the
present case, the learned Single Judge found that the earlier order
proceeded on a misapplication of precedents relating to
appointments made prior to the ban, whereas the appellant's
appointment was admittedty made after the ban. Such
misapplication constituted an error apparent on the face of the
record, warranting exercise of review jurisdiction.
10. tt is also borne out from the record that the State had sought
leave of the Division Bench in W.A. No.846 of 2022 to file Review
petition before the learned Single Judge, which fact was not
disclosed by the appellant. Suppression of a material fact,
particularly one having a bearing on the maintainability of the
proceedings, disentitles a litigant to discretionary relief and justifies
the learned Single Judge's order in Review, warranting no
interference in the present appeal.
11. It is to be notecl that the ban on creation and liliing up of aided
posts was itnposed uide Memo dated 20.LO.2O04. The contention that
the ban dicl not extend to compassionate appointments until the
issuance of the clarification memo dated 14.11.2OO5 is misconceived.
The sttbsequent memo is clarificatory in nature and merely
,/
::6::
elucidates the scope ancr intent of
the earlier ban. As held by the
Honble supreme court in Goaernment
of And,hra prad.esh u. sri
seaqdas vidgamandir Higtt schoolr,
administrative instructions
are ordi,arily prospective unress expressly
implication made otherw'ise. In the present
not introduce a new restriction but
or by necessary
casc, the clarification did
only clarified what was implicit in
the original ban, namery, that it applied
to alr appointments in aided
posts, including those ol1 colnpassionate
grounds.
L2' The learned Single Judge, while exercising
rightly distinguished the judgments
Review jurisdiction,
reried upon by the appellant, as
the appointments in w.p. Nos.1562 r
of 2oor and 2193g of 2or2
were made prior to the ban dated
20.Lo.2004, whereas thc
appellant's appointment was admittedly
made on 27.o1.2005, after
the ban came into force. The finding that
similarly situated suffers from no
petition, though filed with a deray
the appelrant was not
infirmity. Further, the review
of 3o I days, rvas condoned by the
learned Single Judge upon being
offered' Such exercise of discretion
satisfied with the explanation
calls for no interference in the
absence of perversity or arbitrariness.
13. It is also ro be noted that, the dismissar of w.A.No.g
cannot be construed as a final adjudication
entitlement to approval of appointment.
11zot
t; 9 scc 6ls
.\
i
t,
li
P
E
E
G
\
46 of 2022
on the appellant,s
The Division Bench merely
declined to interfere with the direction issued by the learned single
I
Judge to consider the appellant's case and did not issue a positive
mandamus granting approval.
Conclusion
i
L4, For the foregoing reasons, we hold that the learned Single
i
Judge was justified in exercising Review jurisdiction on the ground of
an error apparent on the face of the record. The appellant's
suppression of a material fact disentitles him to any equitable relief.
The appellant's appointment, having been made after the imposition
of the ban on aided posts, was rightly hetd to be impermissible. The
order passed in Review suffers from no legal infirmity. The Writ
Appeal is d-evoid of merit and is liable to be dismissed.
15. Accordingly, the Writ Appeal is dismissed. No order as to
costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneolls petitions, pending if any, stand
closed
ISMAIL
DEPUW REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPYII
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. One CC to Sri Ramachandar Rao Vemuganti, Advocate [OPUC]
2. Two CCs to Additional Advocate General, High Court for the State of
Telangana, at Hyderabad [OUT]
I
I
3. Two CD Copies
T J/PMK
I
HIGH COURT
DATED:08/01 12026
JUDGMENT
WA.No.876 of 2025
T}iE S
t
DISMISSING THE WRIT APPEAL
WITHOUT COSTS
b
$
I ct.g
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review