Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010759192017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3397]
WEDNESDAY,THE FOURTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE VENUTHURUMALLI GOPALA
KRISHNA RAO
SECOND APPEAL NO: 1211/2018
Between:
Gudivada Jayaram / Jayaram Naidu and Others
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
Guggila Ramesh Babu and Others
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. P DURGA PRASAD
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. KALEEMULLA S
The Court made the following:
...RESPONDENT(S)
Reserved on 31.01.2026
Pronounced on 04.02.2026
Uploaded on 04.02.2026
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE V. GOPALA KRISHNA RAO
SECOND APPEAL No.1211 of 2018
JUDGMENT:
This second appeal is filed aggrieved against the Judgment and decree
dated 20-02-2015 in A.S.No.112 of 2012, on the file of the Special Judge for
Trial of cases under SCs & STs (POA) Act-Cum- Additional District Judge,
Vizianagaram, confirming the Judgment and decree dated 28.09.2012 in
O.S.No.461 of 2005, on the file of the Additional Junior Civil Judge at
Vizianagaram.
2.
The appellants herein are the plaintiffs and the respondents herein are
the defendants in O.S.No.461 of 2005, on the file of the Additional Junior Civil
Judge at Vizianagaram.
3.
The plaintiff initiated action in O.S.No.461 of 2005, on the file of the
Additional Junior Civil Judge at Vizianagaram, with a prayer for declaring the
plaintiffs 1 and 2 are the absolute owners of the plaint schedule property and
for consequential relief of permanent injunction, restraining the defendants
and their men from in any way interfering with the peaceful possession and
enjoyment of the plaintiffs over the plaint schedule property and for costs of
the suit.
4.
The learned Additional Junior Civil Judge at Vizianagaram, dismissed
the suit with costs. Felt aggrieved of the same, the unsuccessful plaintiffs in
the above said suit filed the aforesaid appeal before the first appellate Court.
VGKR, J.
SA_1211_2018
The learned Special Judge for Trial of cases under SCs & STs (POA) ActCum- Additional District Judge, Vizianagaram, dismissed the first appeal by
confirming the judgment and decree passed by the trial Court. Aggrieved
thereby, the unsuccessful plaintiffs/appellants approached this Court by way
of second appeal.
5.
For the sake of convenience, both parties in the second appeal will be
referred to as they are arrayed in the original suit.
6.
The case of the plaintiff, in brief, as set out in the plaint averments in
O.S.No.461 of 2005, is as follows:
The plaintiff No.1 is the son, and the plaintiff No.2 is the wife, of late
Gudivada
China
Thati
Naidu
of
Chodamma
Agraharam
Village
in
Possapatirega Revenue Mandal, Vizianagaram District. The plaintiffs pleaded
that the plaint schedule properties are the ancestral properties belonging to
late Gudivada China Thati Naidu and that he died in the year 1989, leaving
behind the plaintiffs and another son by name Gudivada Sanyasinaidu, i.e.,
the husband of the defendant No.2 and father of the defendant Nos.3 to 6.
The plaintiffs further pleaded that after the death of late Gudivada China Thati
Naidu, as the properties inherited from him were not partitioned, the plaintiffs
filed a suit against Gudivada Sanyasinaidu and his wife, Gudivada
Eswaramma, i.e., the defendant No.2, for partition and separate possession of
the plaintiffs’ share in the joint properties in O.S.No.45 of 1992, on the file of
the Subordinate Judge’s Court at Vizianagaram. During the pendency of the
VGKR, J.
SA_1211_2018
said suit, the plaintiffs and the defendants in the said suit, i.e., Gudivada
Sanyasinaidu and the defendant No.2, entered into a compromise, and the
same was referred to the Lok Adalat. Before the Lok Adalat, both the parties
filed a compromise petition vide I.A.No.27 of 1999, wherein the compromise
was recorded, and an award was passed on 29.01.1999 in terms of the
compromise.
The plaintiffs further pleaded that they were put in possession of the
said property as per the terms of the compromise and that the plaintiffs have
been enjoying the properties that fell to their share with absolute rights.
Gudivada Sanyasinaidu, i.e., the husband of the defendant No.2 and the
father of the defendant Nos.3 to 6, enjoyed the remaining properties of the
said plaint schedule, and each of them is also paying land revenue for their
respective lands. The plaintiffs further pleaded that while so, the defendant
No.1 purchased some lands around the plaint schedule properties from the
neighboring landowners and also from late Gudivada Sanyasinaidu and his
son Srinivasa Rao, i.e., the defendant No.3. At that time, the defendant No.1
requested the plaintiffs to sell the plaint schedule property also, which would
be convenient for him for enjoying his other lands purchased from the
neighboring landowners, but the plaintiffs refused to sell the same, as they
had only a small extent of land for their livelihood. As such, he purchased the
other neighboring lands from their owners and got some sale deeds executed
through them.
VGKR, J.
SA_1211_2018
The plaintiffs further pleaded that they have been in possession and
enjoyment of the same, and even if they executed any such document in
favour of the defendant No.1 in respect of the plaint schedule property, it is not
valid or binding on the plaintiffs and is non est in the eye of law. The plaintiffs
pleaded that the plaintiff No.1 got issued a legal notice dated 04.02.2005 to
the defendant Nos.1 and 3, which they received, and the defendant No.1 got
issued a belated reply dated 12.05.2005 with false allegations. The plaintiffs
further pleaded that the defendant No.1 is claiming right over an extent of
Ac.1.30 cents in Sy.Nos.14/3, 14/7, 14/8, and 14/13 under the sale deed
dated 07.10.2003, whereas the plaintiffs are the owners of the plaint schedule
property to an extent of Ac.0.54 cents. Hence, the plaintiffs are constrained to
file the present suit.
7.
The defendant No.1 filed written statement before the trial Court. The
brief averments in the written statement are as follows:
The defendant No.1 pleaded that the suit is not maintainable either
under law or fact and that the above suit was filed in collusion with the other
defendants, who are close relatives inter se. The defendant No.1 further
pleaded that the plaintiffs have never been in possession and enjoyment of
the suit schedule land at any time, and this fact can easily be seen from the
records submitted by the plaintiffs. As they want to twist the matter to their
advantage, the plaintiffs are taking advantage of the demise of late Gudivada
Sanyasinaidu. The defendant No.1 further pleaded that the concerned
revenue records, including the Pattadar Passbooks, issued by the competent
VGKR, J.
SA_1211_2018
authority, which are public in nature, were submitted by the vendors of the
defendant No.1 at the time of the registration of the sale deed in favour of the
defendant No.1, in respect of the lands covered under it, including the suit
schedule lands. He further pleaded that from the date of obtaining the
registered sale deed from their owners, the defendant No.1 has been in
continuous and peaceful possession and enjoyment of the said lands, and that
the suit filed by the plaintiffs is not maintainable either under law or fact,
especially due to the suppression of all real and true facts. Further, the suit is
not maintainable for mere injunction without a declaration, and as such, he
prayed for dismissal of the suit with costs.
8.
On the basis of above pleadings, the learned Additional Junior Civil
Judge at Vizianagaram, framed the following issues for trial:
1) Whether the plaintiff is in lawful possession and enjoyment of the plaint
schedule property as on the date of filing of the suit? If so entitled for
permanent injunction as prayed for?
2) To what relief?
The trial Court had also framed the following Additional Issue:
1) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for declaration that they are the
absolute owners of the suit schedule properties?
9.
During the course of trial before the trial Court, on behalf of the
plaintiffs, P.Ws.1 to 3 was examined and Exs.A-1 to A-8 were marked. On
VGKR, J.
SA_1211_2018
behalf of the defendants, D.Ws.1 to 3 were examined and Exs.B-1 to B-9 were
marked.
10.
The learned Additional Junior Civil Judge at Vizianagaram, after
conclusion of trial, on hearing the arguments of both sides and on
consideration of oral and documentary evidence on record, dismissed the suit
with costs. Felt aggrieved thereby, the unsuccessful plaintiffs filed the appeal
suit in A.S.No.112 of 2012, on the file of the Special Judge for Trial of cases
under SCs & STs (POA) Act-Cum- Additional District Judge, Vizianagaram,
wherein the following points came up for consideration:
1) Whether the findings and observations made by the lower Court are
contrary to Law, weight of evidence and probabilities of the case?
2) If so, to what relief, the parties are entitled to?
11.
The learned Special Judge for Trial of cases under SCs & STs (POA)
Act-Cum- Additional District Judge, Vizianagaram, i.e., the first appellate
Judge, after hearing the arguments, answered the points, as above, against
the plaintiffs and dismissed the appeal suit filed by the plaintiffs. Felt
aggrieved of the same, the plaintiffs in O.S.No.461 of 2005 filed the present
second appeal before this Court.
12.
Heard
Sri
K.M.R.
Bala
Prasad,
learned
counsel
representing
Sri P.Durga Prasad, learned counsel for the appellants and Sri M.Sohail
Shareef, learned counsel representing Sri Kaleemulla.S, learned counsel for
the respondents.
VGKR, J.
SA_1211_2018
13.
It has to be kept in mind that the right of appeal is neither a natural nor
an inherent right attached to the litigation. It is regulated in accordance with
law. A second appeal preferred under Section 100 of C.P.C., could be
admitted only when the appellants satisfies the Court that substantial question
of law between the parties arise in the case. A proper test for determining
whether a question of law raised in the case is substantial would be or
whether it directly and substantially affects the rights of the parties and if so,
whether it is either an open question in the sense that it is not finally settled by
the superior Courts or is not free from difficulty or cause for discussion of
alternative views. In a case of Boodireddy Chandraiah v. Arigela Laxmi1,
the Apex Court held that it is not within the domain of High Court to investigate
grounds on which the findings were arrived at by the last Court of fact namely,
the first appellate Court. In a case where from a given set of circumstances
two inferences of facts are possible, one drawn by the lower appellate Court
will not be interfered by the High Court in a second appeal. Adopting any other
approach is not permissible. Where, the facts required for a point of law have
not been pleaded, a litigant should not be allowed to raise that question as a
substantial question of law in second appeal. Mere appreciation of facts,
documentary evidence and contents of documents cannot be held to be
raising a substantial question of law.
14.
The plaintiffs having chosen to invoke the jurisdiction of this Court under
Section 100 of Civil Procedure Code, it is for them to meet the above
(2007) 8 SCC 155
VGKR, J.
SA_1211_2018
principles and satisfy the Court whether there exists any substantial question
of law.
15.
This second appeal is filed against the concurrent findings arrived by
both the Courts below, therefore, the grounds urged in the second appeal are
to be scrutinized to find out whether the appellants has shown any substantial
question of law. The contention of appellants is that the judgment and decree
of the trial Court as well as the first appellate Court are contrary to law and
that the second appeal may be allowed by setting aside the judgment and
decree passed by both the Courts below i.e. the trial Court and the first
appellate Court.
16.
The appellants are the plaintiffs in the suit in O.S. No.461 of 2005, on
the file of the Additional Junior Civil Judge, Vizianagaram. The appellants filed
the suit for seeking the relief of declaration of title and consequential relief of
permanent injunction in respect of the plaint schedule property. The learned
trial Judge, after considering the entire evidence on record, dismissed the suit
filed by the plaintiffs. Aggrieved by the said decree and judgment, the plaintiffs
in the aforesaid suit filed the first appeal before the First Appellate Court, and
the said first appeal was dismissed by the First Appellate Court by confirming
the decree and judgment passed by the trial Court. Aggrieved by the same,
the appellants/plaintiffs in the first appeal filed the second appeal before this
Court.
VGKR, J.
SA_1211_2018
17.
The plaintiffs are none other than the son and wife of late China Thati
Naidu. It is the specific case of the plaintiffs that the plaintiffs filed a suit in
O.S.No.45 of 1992, before the Subordinate Judge Court at Vizianagaram,
against Gudivada Sanyasi Naidu and his wife for partition of the properties,
and during the pendency of the said suit, both the parties in the said suit
entered into a compromise before the Lok Adalat, and an award was passed
by the Lok Adalat on 29.01.1999, in terms of the compromise decree by
Lok Adalat Bench, and the plaintiffs were put in possession of the property.
The appellants’/plaintiffs’ claim is based on Ex.A-1, certified copy of the
compromise petition and award copy dated 29.01.1999 in O.S. No.45 of 1992,
on the file of the Senior Civil Judge Court, Vizianagaram. As seen from
Ex.A-1, in the award itself, it was mentioned that compromise was recorded
and that the final decree was to be engrossed as and when non-judicial
stamps were deposited. It is undisputed by both sides that no final decree was
engrossed on non-judicial stamps. As per the terms of the Lok Adalat award,
<a final decree has to be engrossed as and when the non-judicial stamps were
deposited=. It is undisputed that non-judicial stamps were not deposited by the
plaintiffs in the said suit. The plaintiffs in the said suit are none other than the
plaintiffs in the present suit. Therefore, unless and until the Lok Adalat award
was engrossed on non-judicial stamps, as ordered by the terms of the
Lok Adalat award, it cannot be said that the plaintiffs will get right and title by
virtue of the said award passed by the Lok Adalat Bench. Except relying on
Ex.A-1, the plaintiffs herein have not filed any document to prove their right
VGKR, J.
SA_1211_2018
and title in the plaint schedule property. As stated supra, the plaintiffs herein
are seeking relief of declaration of title and consequential relief of permanent
injunction in respect of the plaint schedule property.
18.
As noticed supra, the plaintiff relied on Ex. A-1, namely, the Lok Adalat
award passed by the Lok Adalat Bench in O.S.No.45 of 1992, there was a
specific recital in the award itself that the compromise was recorded and
engross the final decree as and when non-judicial stamps were deposited. It is
undisputed by the plaintiff that the non-judicial stamps were not deposited,
and therefore, the final decree is not engrossed on non-judicial stamps. The
plaintiff No.1/P.W.1 admitted in his evidence, in cross-examination, that they
themselves got partitioned the property subsequent to the compromise award.
But, in order to prove the same, no evidence is produced by the plaintiffs, and
the same is not pleaded by the plaintiffs in the plaint itself. As per the own
case of the plaintiffs in the present suit, after the date of passing of the award,
on the same day, they were put in possession of the said property. Therefore,
the evidence of P.W.1 is not in consonance with the pleadings in the plaint.
19.
As per the own case of the plaintiffs, they were put in possession on
29.01.1999. But, in order to prove the same, the plaintiffs have not filed any
single document to prove their possession since 1999. The plaintiffs relied on
Ex. A-3, Land Revenue Receipt, dated 12.12.2004, said to have been issued
in favour of the plaintiff No.1, which is much prior to the institution of the suit.
The plaintiffs also relied on Ex. A-8, Tax Receipt, dated 27.01.2007, said to
VGKR, J.
SA_1211_2018
have been issued in favour of the plaintiff No.1, which relates to the pending
suit proceedings.
It is needless to mention that the suit is instituted by the plaintiffs before the
trial Court in the year 2005, for seeking relief of declaration of title and
consequential relief of permanent injunction in respect of the schedule
property. Moreover, the trial Court held in its judgment that <a Panchayat
Secretary is not supposed to issue tax receipt in respect of the agricultural
property. A Panchayat Secretary will collect the house tax, but not the tax on
agricultural land=. As noticed supra, the Panchayat Secretary issued Ex. A-3
and Ex. A-8; here, the schedule property is an agricultural land. The learned
trial Judge held in its judgment, by giving reasons, that Ex. A-3 and Ex. A-8
are not legally valid..
20.
Learned counsel for the appellants placed reliance on a case law in
K.Srinivasappa and others (S) Vs. M.Mallamma and Others (S)2.
Learned counsel for the appellants has also placed another reliance on
a case law in P.T. Thomas Vs. Thomas Job3.
In the case at hand, the plaintiffs are seeking the relief of declaration of
title in respect of the plaint schedule property and consequential relief of
permanent injunction in respect of the plaint schedule property. In Ex. A-1
award itself, it was specifically recited that the final decree has to be
2022 SCC Online SC 636
AIR 2005 SUPREME COURT 3575
VGKR, J.
SA_1211_2018
engrossed as and when non-judicial stamps are deposited by the plaintiffs.
Admittedly, non-judicial stamps were not deposited from 1999 till the date of
filing of the suit. If an award like a final decree in a suit for partition is passed
by the Lok Adalat, the same also requires registration. There is a specific term
and condition in Ex. A-1 award itself that the final decree has to be engrossed
on non-judicial stamps. Therefore, unless and until the Lok Adalat award was
engrossed on non-judicial stamps as stipulated in the Lok Adalat award, the
plaintiffs will not get any right and title in respect of the plaint schedule
property.
21.
P.W.1 admits in his evidence in cross-examination itself that they
themselves got partitioned the properties subsequent to the compromise
award passed by the Lok Adalat. But, no evidence was produced by the
plaintiffs. It is not the case of the plaintiffs in the plaint that, subsequent to the
passing of the award by the Lok Adalat Bench, both the parties in the said suit
have partitioned their properties. If a suit for partition is settled before the Lok
Adalat, non-judicial stamps have to be necessarily deposited for engrossing at
the time of execution of such award through the court of law. Unless and until
the final decree of partition is engrossed on non-judicial stamps, it cannot be
enforced, and it can be enforced only when engrossed on proper stamp and
registration. In this case, admittedly, the final decree is not engrossed on nonjudicial stamps, and the terms and conditions as stipulated in Ex.A-1 award
that a final decree has to be engrossed on a non-judicial stamp itself is not
complied with by the plaintiffs.
VGKR, J.
SA_1211_2018
22.
As noticed supra, the plaintiffs in the present suit filed a suit for relief of
declaration of title and consequential relief of permanent injunction in respect
of the schedule property before the Civil Court.
23.
In a case of Union of India and others vs. Vasavi Cooperative
Housing Society Limited and others 4 , wherein the Apex Court held as
follows:
<In a suit for declaration of title, burden always lies on the plaintiff to make out and
establish a clear case for granting such a declaration and the weakness, if any, of the
case set up by the defendants would not be a ground to grant relief to the plaintiff. The
legal position, therefore, is clear that the plaintiff in a suit for declaration of title and
possession could succeed only on the strength of its own title and that could be done
only by adducing sufficient evidence to discharge the onus on it, irrespective of the
question whether the defendants have proved their case or not. We are of the view
that even if the title set up by the defendants is found against, in the absence of
establishment of plaintiff‟s own title, plaintiff must be non-suited.=
In a case of Moran Mar Basselios Catholicos vs. Thukalan Paulo
Avira & others5, wherein the Apex Court held as follows:
<It is perfectly clear that in a suit of this description if the plaintiffs are to succeed they
must do so on the strength of their own title.=
In a case of Sajana Granites, Madras and another vs. Manduva
Srinivasa Rao and others6, wherein the Composite High Court of Andhra
Pradesh at Hyderabad, held as follows:
<The Supreme Court in M.P. Athanastus case (supra), M.M. Catholices v. Polo Avira
case (supra) and this Court in C. Audilakshmamma case (supra) held that plaintiff in a
suit for declaration of title, and for recovery of possession, can succeed only on the
strength of his own title and that it is not obligatory on the defendants to plead and
(2014) 2 Supreme Court Cases 269
1958 SCC OnLine Supreme Court 136
2001 SCC OnLine AP 666
VGKR, J.
SA_1211_2018
prove the possible defects in the plaintiffs title and so if the plaintiff fails to establish his
title, even if the defendant fails to establish his own title, plaintiff must be non suited. In
this case since appellants are seeking declaration of their title to the suit property they
have to establish their title; and cannot expect relief on the basis of the weakness of
the case of respondents 1 and 2, or on the basis that the evidence adduced by
respondents 1 and 2 does not establish their title to the suit property.=
24.
Admittedly, in the case at hand, no single document is filed by the
plaintiffs to prove their possession in the suit schedule property since 1991 till
the date of filing of the suit. In the case at hand, except relying on Ex.A-1 Lok
Adalat award, the plaintiffs did not produce any documentary evidence to
prove their right and title in the plaint schedule property. As noticed supra, the
plaintiffs will not get any right and title through Ex.A-1 award, since it was not
engrossed on non-judicial stamps as per the terms and conditions stipulated
in the Lok Adalat award. Furthermore, the plaintiff No.1 admitted in his
evidence in cross-examination itself that subsequent to the passing of the
Lok Adalat award, there was a partition between both the parties; the same is
not yet pleaded by the plaintiffs in the plaint itself. As per the own case of the
plaintiffs, they were put in possession of the plaint schedule property by virtue
of the Lok Adalat award in the year 1999. As noticed supra, the plaintiffs failed
to prove that they are in possession and enjoyment of the plaint schedule
property since 1999. Furthermore, the plaintiffs also failed to prove that they
are having absolute right and title in the plaint schedule property. Therefore,
the plaintiffs approached the Civil Court with unclean hands. Furthermore, the
defendant No.1 relied on Ex.B-1, registered sale deed, Ex.B-6, Pattadar
Passbook, Ex.B-7, title deed passbook said to have been issued by the
VGKR, J.
SA_1211_2018
Revenue Officials, and Ex.B-8, No.3 Adangal issued by the Revenue
Department to prove his possession in the plaint schedule property. On
appreciation of the entire evidence on record, the learned trial Judge rightly
dismissed the suit filed by the plaintiffs, and the same is confirmed by the First
Appellate Judge.
25.
Having regard to the reasons assigned, this Court is satisfied that the
concurrent findings of fact recorded by both the Courts below on all the
issues/points against the plaintiffs and in favour of the defendants do not
brook interference and that both the Courts below are justified in dismissing
the suit against the plaintiff. The findings of fact recorded by both the Courts
below were based on proper appreciation of evidence and the material on
record and there was neither illegality nor irregularity in those findings and
therefore, the findings do not require to be upset. Further, the existence of
substantial questions of law is a sine qua non for the exercise of jurisdiction by
this Court as per Section 100 of Code of Civil Procedure. The questions
raised, strictly speaking, are not even pure questions of law, let alone
substantial questions of law.
26.
Viewed thus, this Court finds that none of the questions raised are
substantial questions and there is no subsistence in the questions raised and
that therefore, the second appeal is devoid of merits and is liable for dismissal
at the stage of admission. The law is well settled that a second appeal shall
not be admitted if no substantial questions of law arise for consideration and
when no substantial questions of law is involved. The view of this Court is
VGKR, J.
SA_1211_2018
reinforced by the ratio laid down by the Apex Court in the case of Gurdev
Kaur v. Kaki7. In the case on hand, as stated supra, this Court finds after
careful examination of the pleadings, evidence and contentions that no
substantial question of law is involved, this second appeal is liable for
dismissal at the stage of admission, in view of narrow compass of Section 100
of Civil Procedure Code.
27.
In the result, the second appeal is dismissed at the stage of admission,
confirming the judgment and decree of both the Courts below. Pending
applications, if any, shall stand closed. No costs.
__________________________
V. GOPALA KRISHNA RAO, J.
Date: 04.02.2026
SRT
AIR 2006 SC 1975
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review