Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:2402-DB
NAFR
Digitally signed
by ALOK
SHARMA
ALOK
Date:
SHARMA 2026.01.21
12:24:29
+0530
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 330 of 2017
1 - Guddu @ Shivdayal S/o Gajanand Suryawanshi, Aged About 45
Years R/o Jarhabata, Police Station Civil Line, Tahsil And District
Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh., Chhattisgarh
--- Appellant(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through S.H.O. Civil Line Bilaspur, District
Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh., Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent(s)
CRA No. 282 of 2023
1 - Narad Suryawanshi S/o Late Deendayal Suryawanshi, Aged About
38 Years R/o Near Jatiya Talab Jarhabhata, Tahsil And District Bilaspur,
Chhattisgarh.
---Appellant(s)
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through S.H.O. Civil Line Bilaspur, District
Bilaspur Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Raj Kumar Gupta, Advocate.
For Respondent/State
: Mr. Dharmesh Shrivastava, Dy. Advocate
General.
For Complainant/Objector : Mr. Ajay Chandra, Advocate.
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Order on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
15/01/2026
1.
Both these appeals arise out of the same crime number and the
same incident; therefore, they are being heard and decided
together.
2.
The Criminal Appeal no. 330/2017 filed by the appellant Guddu
alias Shiv Dayal against the impugned judgment of conviction
and sentence dated 28.01.2017, passed by learned First
Additional Sessions Judge, Bilaspur in Sessions Case No.
151/2005, whereby the appellant Guddu alias Shiv Dayal has
been convicted and sentenced in the following manner with a
direction to run all the jail sentence run concurrently:
Conviction
Sentence
Under Section 147 of IPC
01 year RI
Under Section 148 of IPC
02 year RI
Under Section 323/149 of 06 months RI
IPC
Under Section 452 of IPC
03 year RI and fine of Rs. 100/- in
default of 06 months RI
Under Section 302/149 of Life imprisonment and fine of Rs.
IPC
100/- in default of 06-06 months RI
3.
The Criminal appeal No. 282/2023 filed by the appellant Narad
Suryavanshi against the impugned judgment of conviction and
sentence dated 23.01.2023, passed by learned First Additional
Sessions Judge, Bilaspur in Sessions Case No. 151/2005,
whereby the appellant Narad Suryavanshi has been convicted
and sentenced in the following manner with a direction to run all
the jail sentence run concurrently:
Conviction
Under Section 147 of IPC
Sentence
01 year RI and fine of Rs. 500/-, in
default of payment of fine 06
month RI
Under Section 148 of IPC
02 year RI and fine of Rs. 500/-, in
default of payment of fine 06
month RI
Under Section 323/149 of 06 months RI and fine of Rs.
IPC (3 times)
500/-, in default of payment of fine
02 months
Under Section 452 of IPC
03 year RI and fine of Rs. 1000/-,
in default of payment of fine 06
months RI
Under Section 302/149 of Life imprisonment and fine of Rs.
IPC
1000/- in default of payment of fine
01 year RI
4.
On 26.11.2004 at about 20:00-20:30 hours, the deceased Ramu
alias Ramkumar was murdered, and four other persons were
injured by the accused persons with an axe, rod, iron pipe, etc.
The FIR Ex.P/8 was registered against the 11 accused persons,
including the present appellants, at the time of filing of the
charge-sheet 05 accused persons, namely Mohan, Ramkushal,
Daraslal, Narad Suryavanshi and Ganesh, were arrested, and a
charge-sheet was filed against them. At that time, the other coaccused persons, namely Sharad, Chota alias Ram Dayal,
Guddu alias Shiv Dayal, Sita Bai, Devki Bail and Sarita Bai were
absconding, and a charge-sheet was filed against them showing
them as absconding. During the trial, the accused Guddu alias
Shiv Dayal was arrested on 04.08.2005, and a trial against him
was also carried out. After the conclusion of the trial, the learned
trial Court has acquitted all the accused persons of the alleged
offences vide its judgment dated 10.08.2006.
5.
The judgment of acquittal dated 10.08.2006, passed by the
learned First Additional Sessions Judge, Bilaspur, in Sessions
Case No. 151/2005, was challenged by one of the injured,
namely Badri Prasad Garhewal PW-7/PW-3, before the High
Court by filing Criminal Revision No. 618/2006.
6.
During the pendency of the Criminal Revision No. 618/2006, the
other absconding accused persons, namely Sharad, Chota alias
Ram Dayal, Smt. Sita Bai, Smt. Devki Bai and Smt. Sarita Bai
were arrested on 13.06.2007 and 12.07.2007, and they were also
put to trial before the learned trial Court. After the conclusion of
the trial, on 18.06.2008, the learned trial Court passed its
judgment with respect to these 05 accused persons, and they
have been convicted and sentenced in the following manner:
Sharad and Chota alias Ram Dayal
Conviction
Sentence
Under Section 147 of IPC
01 year RI
Under Section 148 of IPC
02 year RI
Under Section 452 of IPC
03 year RI and fine of Rs. 200/- in
default of payment of fine 01
month additional imprisonment.
Under Section 302/149 of Life imprisonment and fine of Rs.
IPC
500/- in default of payment of fine
02 month additional imprisonment.
Smt. Sita Bai and Smt. Devki Bai
Conviction
Sentence
Under Section 147 of IPC
They have been sentenced for the
Under Section 148 of IPC
period already undergone by them
Under Section 452 of IPC
and fine of Rs. 200/- only for the
offence under Section 452 of IPC
in default of payment of fine
additional 01 month SI.
Sarita Bai
Conviction
7.
Sentence
Under Section 147 of IPC
SI for 1-1 year for all the offences
Under Section 148 of IPC
with fine of Rs. 200/- in default of
Under Section 323 of IPC
payment of fine additional SI for 01
Under Section 452 of IPC
month.
Against the judgment of conviction and sentence dated
18.06.2008, accused Smt. Sarita Bai preferred Criminal Appeal
No. 697/2008, and the two other accused persons Sharad and
Chota alias Ram Dayal, preferred Criminal Appeal No. 713/2008,
before this Court, challenging their conviction and sentence
awarded by the learned trial Court.
8.
The coordinate bench of this Court decided the Criminal Revision
No. 618/2006, filed by the injured Badri Prasad Garhewal, the
Criminal Appeals No. 697/2008, filed by the accused Smt. Sarita
Bai and Criminal Appeal No. 713/2008, filed by accused Sharad
and Chota alias Ram Dayal, on 18.01.2016. The Criminal Appeal
No. 697/2008 was partly allowed, while maintaining the conviction
of the appellant, Smt. Sarita Bai, for the offence under Section
148, 452 and 323 of IPC, her sentence is reduced for the period
already undergone by her.
9.
The criminal appeal No. 713/2008, filed by the accused persons
Sharad and Chota alias Ram Dayal, is dismissed, and their
conviction and sentence for the offence under Sections 147, 148,
452 and 302/149 of IPC are maintained. On the same day, by a
separate judgment, the Criminal Revision No. 618/2006, filed by
injured Bardi Prasad Garhewal, was allowed, and the matter was
remitted back to the learned trial Court to re-hear both the parties
and to pass the judgment afresh.
10.
The judgment of conviction and sentence was passed against the
accused persons. Sharad and Chota alias Ram Dayal have not
been challenged by them in any higher forum, and their
conviction and sentence attains its finality, and they have
undergone the entire sentence awarded to them by the learned
trial Court. learned counsel appearing for the appellants has also
not disputed the fact that these two accused persons have
undergone the entire sentence awarded to them.
11.
When the matter was remitted to the learned trial Court pursuant
to the order dated 18.01.2016 passed in Criminal Revision No.
618/2006, only one accused, Guddu alias Shiv Dayal, was
arrested on 28.02.2016, and he was put to trial before the learned
trial Court. After the conclusion of the trial, the judgment was
passed by the learned trial Court on 28.01.2017, and he was
convicted for the offence under Section 147, 148, 323/149, 452
and 302/149 of IPC and sentenced as mentioned in the earlier
part of this judgment. Against the said conviction and sentence,
he filed Criminal Appeal No. 330/2017.
12.
Subsequent to the judgment passed by the learned trial Court on
28.01.2017,
another
accused,
Ganesh,
was
arrested
on
04.09.2018, and he was also put to trial, and he too has been
convicted by the learned trial Court vide judgment dated
04.02.2019 for the offence under Sections 147, 148, 452,
302/149, 323/149 (on three counts). The accused Ganesh has
also preferred Criminal Appeal No. 290/2019, but during the
pendency of the Criminal appeal he died on 26.09.2020 and
therefore, his appeal is declared as abated by a separate order
passed by this Court today itself.
13.
The co-accused Narad Suryavanshi was also arrested on
13.12.2021, and he too was put to trial before the learned trial
Court. vide judgment dated 23.01.2023, the accused Narad
Suryavanshi has also been convicted for the offence under
Sections 147, 148, 452, 302/149 and 323/149 (on three counts)
and sentenced as mentioned in the earlier part of this judgment.
14.
Thus, at present, two criminal appeals bearing Criminal Appeal
No. 330/2017 (Guddu alias Shiv Dayal vs. State of Chhattisgarh)
and Criminal Appeal No. 282/2023 (Narad Suryavanshi vs. State
of Chhattisgarh) are pending for its consideration, which is being
decided together by this judgment.
15.
Brief facts of the case are that on 25.11.2004, at about 08:0008:30 pm, there was an altercation between the deceased Ramu
alias Ram Kumar and the accused Sharad. On 26.11.2004, at
about 08:00 pm, when the deceased have had his dinner along
with his family members, on the issue of altercation of
25.11.2004, the accused persons Narad, Ganesh, Sharad,
Mohan, Guddu, Ram Kushal, Sarita Bai, Devki Bai and Sita Bai
and other persons trespassed the house of the deceased armed
with axe, rod, hockey stick and iron rod and started assaulting the
deceased and his other family members. By the assault made by
the accused persons, the deceased Ramu alias Ram Kumar,
Naina Garhewal, Badri Prasad, Vinay and Dev Kumari received
injuries on their bodies. Ramu alias Ram Kumar received
grievous injuries, and he died on the same day at about 10:30
pm. The merg intimation Ex.P/9 was given by Dev Kumari. At the
same time, at about 08:30 pm, the injured Naina Garhewal
lodged FIR Ex.P/8 against 11 accused persons, on which the FIR
for the offence under Sections 307, 147, 148, 149 and 323 of IPC
was registered. The injured persons Naina Garhewal, Badri
Prasad, Vinay and Dev Kumari, were sent for their medical
examination to CIMS Hospital, Bilaspur, where Dr. B. K. Bais
medically examined them and gave MLC report Ex.P/4 to Ex.P/7
respectively. Notice for inquest Ex.P/10 was given to the
witnesses, and inquest of the dead body of the deceased Ex.P/11
was prepared in the presence of the witnesses.
16.
The dead body of the deceased was sent for its post-mortem to
CIMS Hospital, where Dr. P. Sahini conducted the post-mortem of
the dead body of the deceased and gave a post-mortem report,
Ex.P/19. During the post-mortem, the doctor noticed various
lacerated wounds, contusions and incised wounds all over the
body, including the fracture of skull bone and opined that the
cause of death is due to extensive craniocerebral injury,
haemorrhage and coma. The injuries are homicidal in nature,
caused by combination of a sharp, heavy cutting weapon and a
hard blunt weapon. The time since death is 12 to 24 hours.
Blood-stained and plain soil have been seized from the spot vide
seizure Ex.P/1, clothes of the deceased were seized vide seizure
memo Ex.P/2. From the accused Ram Kushal one iron rod and
his full shirt have been seized vide seizure memo Ex.P/3, from
the accused Daraslal, one axe and his full shirt have been seized
vide
seizure
memo
Ex.P/12,
from
the
accused
Narad
Suryavanshi, one scooter rod and his full shirt have been seized
vide seizure memo Ex.P/14. From Ganesh Suryavanshi, one Iron
pipe and his full shirt have been seized vide seizure memo
Ex.P/15. From the accused Mohan, one axe and a full shirt have
been seized vide seizure memo Ex.P/22. The seized weapon and
clothes were sent for their chemical examination to FSL, Raipur,
from where the report Ex.P/26 was received. According to the
FSL report, no blood was found on plain soil, the full shirt of the
accused Narad and full shirt of the accused Ganesh and the rest
of the articles were found to be stained with blood.
17.
Statements of the witnesses were recorded, and after completion
of the usual investigation charge-sheet was filed before the
learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bilaspur. The case
was committed to the learned Sessions Court, from where the
same has been transferred to the learned trial Court for its trial.
18.
The learned trial Court has framed charges on 20.05.2005
against the accused Mohan, Ganesh Sarve, Darash Lal, Narad
Gadhewal, Ramkushal, and on 11.08.2005 against Shivdayal for
the offence under Sections 147, 148, 452/149, 302/149, 323/149
(on three counts) and on 06.11.2007 against the accused
persons Sharad, Chhota @ Ramdayal, Sita Bai, Devki Bai and
Sarita Bai for the offence under Sections 147, 148, 452, 302/149,
323/149 (on three counts). The accused persons denied the
charge and claimed trial.
19.
In order to prove the charge against the accused persons, the
prosecution initially examined 18 witnesses. Statements of the
accused persons under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C. have also
been recorded, in which they denied the circumstances that
appear against them, pleaded innocence and have submitted
that, they have been falsely implicated in the offence.
20.
One defence witness Pardeshi Sarthi/DW-1 was examined by the
defence on 19.07.2006. When the matter was remitted back after
the judgment dated 18.01.2016, in Criminal Revision No.
618/2006 by this Court, Pardeshi Sarthi/DW-1 has been reexamined.
21.
After appreciation of oral as well as documentary evidence
produced by the parties, the learned trial Court passed the
judgment on 10.08.2006 with respect to 06 accused persons
namely; Mohan, Ramkushal, Darash Lal, Narad Suryawanshi,
Ganesh and Guddu @ Shivdayal, who have been arrested at that
time, and they have been acquitted by the learned trial Court.
When the other accused persons were arrested and put to trial,
the judgment was passed by the learned trial Court on
18.06.2008 with respect to the accused persons Sharad, Chhota
@ Ramdayal, Smt. Sita Bai, Smt. Devki Bai and Smt. Sarita Bai
and they have been convicted and sentenced as mentioned in
the earlier part of the judgment. Against the order of acquittal
dated 10.08.2006, the injured Badri Prasad filed Criminal
Revision No. 618/2006, which was allowed on 18.01.2016 and
the matter was remitted back to the learned trial Court for
rehearing of the parties and to pass a judgment afresh.
Thereafter, on different occasions some of the accused persons
have been arrested and judgment with respect to them have
been passed on 28.01.2017, 04.02.2019 and 23.01.2023, which
have been described in the earlier part of this judgment. Hence
these appeals.
22.
Mr. Raj Kumar Gupta, learned counsel for the respective
appellants would submit that, the prosecution has failed to prove
its case beyond reasonable doubt. There are material omissions
and contradictions in the evidence of prosecution witnesses and
they are inconsistent. Considering their inconsistency, earlier the
learned trial Court has acquitted the present appellants, and
when the matter was remitted back for rehearing of the case, they
have been convicted. He would further submit that, there is no
specific overt act against the present appellants, but omnibus
allegations have been leveled by the complainant party. No any
weapon of offence has been seized from the appellant Guddu @
Shivdayal and on the iron rod seized from accused Narad, no any
human blood was found. The seizure of weapon of offence and
clothes from other accused persons are also doubtful and only to
show the involvement of the accused persons in the offence. He
would also submit that there are material exaggeration in the
evidence of PW-5/1 with that of her 161 CRPC statement. There
is no allegation that the present appellants have caused any
injury to the deceased. The witnesses are close relative of the
deceased and there is no independent witness. The entire
investigation is suspicious right from very beginning and there are
serious lacuna in the investigation of the case. There is reason of
false implication of the accused persons in the offence, as there
exists previous dispute with respect to the property and both the
parties were residing in the same vicinity. The impugned
judgment of conviction and sentence against the present
appellants suffers from perversity and illegality and the same are
liable to be set aside and the appellants are entitled for their
acquittal.
23.
On the other hand, Mr. Dharmesh Shrivastava, Dy. Advocate
General, appearing for the State and Mr. Ajay Chandra, learned
counsel appearing for the objector in Criminal Appeal No.
330/2017 vehemently oppose the submissions made by learned
counsel for the appellants and submitted that, there are sufficient
evidence against the appellants that they along with other
accused persons have committed the offence. But for minor
omissions and contradictions, their evidence are fully supported
the prosecution’s case. PW-5/1 Naina Gadhewal, PW-7/3 Badri
Prasad and PW-6/2 Dev Kumari are the injured eyewitnesses,
who have duly supported the prosecution’s case and their
presence on the spot are quite natural, as they are the family
members of the deceased and they were having dinner along
with the deceased in their house. In a situation like in the present
case, one cannot specifically say about who has assaulted whom
by what weapon and on what part of their body, however in the
present case, there is sufficient evidence that the present
appellants have assaulted the deceased and injured witnesses
along with other accused persons. At the time of incident, they
trespassed the house of the deceased with common object to
commit the offence, armed with weapons and therefore, they can
also be held liable under the vicarious liability under the common
object to commit the offence. They formed unlawful assembly and
then committed the offence, and their active participation in the
offence have been proved by the witnesses. The number of
injuries found on the body of the deceased would also show that
the assault was made by number of accused persons including
the present appellants. The appellants could not be able to rebut
the evidence of the witnesses, therefore, the prosecution has
proved its case beyond reasonable doubt. He would also submit
that the two other co-accused persons namely; Sharad and
Chhota @ Ramdayal have been convicted by the learned trial
Court for commission of murder of the deceased Ramu @
Ramkumar and causing injuries to the injured witnesses. Their
conviction have been upheld by the coordinate Bench of this
Court and they undergone the entire sentence as has been
disclosed by the learned counsel appearing for the appellants.
Therefore, there is no merit in the present appeals and the same
are liable to be dismissed.
24.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record of the trial Court with utmost circumspection and
judgments passed by the learned trial Court on different
occasions as well as order dated 18.01.2016, passed by
coordinate Bench in Criminal Revision No. 618/2006 and the
judgment dated 18.01.2016 passed by coordinate Bench in
Criminal Appeal No. 697 of 2008 and Criminal Appeal No. 713 of
2008.
25.
The first and foremost question for consideration would be,
whether the death of the deceased Ramu @ Ramkumar is
homicidal or not.
26.
PW-16, Dr. Neeraj Shende treated the deceased at CIMS
Hospital, Bilaspur. He stated in his evidence that on 26.11.2004,
Ramkumar was admitted in the hospital and his condition was not
good. He was unconscious and brain matter coming out. He was
given initial treatment, however after sometime his relatives took
him to another hospital against the medical advise. His bedhead
ticket is exhibit P-18. The injured Ramkumar was received
grievous injuries on his head.
27.
The prosecution, in order to prove the homicidal death of the
deceased, examined Dr. Preetam Sahni/PW-17, who conducted
the postmortem of the dead body of the deceased. He stated in
his evidence that on 27.11.2004, the dead body of deceased
Ramu @ Ramkumar brought before him for postmortem and he
noticed en number of lacerated wound, contusions and incised
wounds all over the body of the deceased. He also found
Hematoma over whole of the skull, fracture of skull running along
coronal plank from left mastoid process over vertex to midline.
Commuted fracture of right parietal bone, right temporal and
frontal bone. Gross laceration of meningeal and brain underneath
with thick SD/H over whole of brain. He opined that all injuries are
antemortem in nature. Injury No. 3 and 4 on skull caused by
hard, sharp and heavy cutting weapon, commuted fracture on
skull caused by force impact transmitted through the bonny skull
or other hard blunt force. Injury No.10 caused by sharp cutting
object, injuries No. 7, 8, 9 and 11 caused by hard and blunt force
impact. He further opined that cause of death is extensive craniocerebral injury hemorrhage and coma. Injuries are homicidal in
nature caused by a combination of sharp, heavy cutting weapon
and hard blunt weapon and his postmortem report is exhibit P-19.
He further stated that he examined two axes and gave his query
report (exhibit P-20) opined that the injuries found on the body of
the deceased could have been caused by the said axes. In crossexamination, the defence could not be able to extract any
discrepancy, so that the evidence of the doctor could be
disbelieved. He being the independent witness proved the
postmortem report and the injuries found on the body of the
deceased, by which he died.
28.
From the evidence of the doctor as well as postmortem report
(exhibit P-19), the prosecution has proved that the death of the
deceased Ramu @ Ramkumar was homicidal.
29.
To prove the involvement of the present appellants in the offence
in
question,
the
prosecution
has
examined
the
injured
eyewitnesses PW-5/1 Naina Gadhewal, PW-6/2 Dev Kumari and
PW-7/3 Badri Prasad.
30.
On 11.08.2005, Naina Gadhewal, who is the sister of the
deceased, has been examined as PW-5. She stated in her
evidence that, on the day of Ekadashi festival, when her brother
burning crackers in his house, the accused persons came out
from their house, started abusing them. When her brother and
other family members asked them not to to abuse, because it is
the day of Ekadashi festival, they walked away to their house.
After four days i.e. on 26.11.2004, at about 8 PM, when he was
taking her dinner along with other family members, her sister-inlaw rushed to her house by saying that, the accused persons are
assaulting the deceased Ramkumar. The accused persons
entered into the house and took the deceased out of his house.
The accused Mohan, Ramdayal, Sharad were having axe and
assaulted Ramkumar. Shiv Dayal, Darash, Ramkushal, Ganesh
and Narad were having iron pipe and rod and they assaulted the
deceased Ramu @ Ramkumar on all over his body. When she
along with other family members intervened, they too have been
assaulted by Sita Bai, Sarita and Devki. Sarita was having iron
plate, by which she assaulted her and Devki assaulted her by
danda. Sita assaulted her by hockey stick. The accused persons
threatened them that, if they disclosed the incident to police, all
the family members would be killed. Her father and other family
members took her brother Ramu @ Ramkumar to the hospital
and she and her brother Shiv Kumar had gone to Police Station
to lodge report, where FIR (exhibit P-8) is lodged by her. She too
was sent for her medical examination to the hospital. In crossexamination, she remained firm in the assault made by the
accused persons and lodging of the report by her. She
specifically stated that the accused persons Ramdayal, Sharad
and Mohan were assaulted the deceased by axe and other
accused persons were also assaulted the deceased by the
weapons, which they were having at that time. Her brother has
received multiple injuries all over his body and the persons of the
vicinity were witnessing the incident. She also stated that after
lodging of the report, she was sent for her medical examination.
Nothing substantive could be extracted from her evidence, which
makes her evidence doubtful.
31.
On 01.12.2007, Naina Gadhewal was again examined after the
arrest of other accused persons Sharad, Chhota @ Ramdayal,
Sita Bai, Devki Bai and Sarita Bai, as PW-1. She reiterated that,
on the date of incident her sister in law shouted for help, then she
and her parents rush to the house of sister-in-law and saw that
the accused persons including Mohan, Sharad, Ramkushal,
Ganesh, Narad, Devki, Sarita, Sita and others entered into her
house and abusing her brother Ramu by filthy language and they
dragged him outside of the house and Sharad, Ramdayal, Mohan
and others assaulted her brother by axe, Shivdayal assaulted by
rod, Ramkushal and Ganesh assaulted by pipe and Narad and
Darash assaulted by iron plate. Devki, Sarita and Sita assaulted
her by danda and iron plate. By the assault made by the accused
persons, her brother Ramu @ Ramkumar fell down and
Ramdayal threatened her, that if she lodged the report, he will
also kill her. Ramu received grievous injuries on all over the body.
He was taken to CIMS Hospital, where he died during treatment.
She lodged a report (exhibit P-8). In her cross-examination, she
again remained firm in saying that the accused persons assaulted
the deceased by axe, rod, pipe and her family members were
also assaulted by the accused persons, when they intervened in
the incident. The defence tried to brought omission and
contradiction in the evidence of this witness, but such omission or
contradiction are trivial in nature and does not affect the credibility
of this witness. She being the injured witness and sister of the
deceased, clearly deposed about the incident and the persons
involved in the assault made by them to the deceased and injured
witnesses.
32.
It is necessary here to reproduce the contents of the FIR (exhibit
P-8) lodged by this witness to show that there is no material
discrepancy in her evidence, which reads as under:“eS tjgkHkkBk tkfr;k rkykc ds ikl vius ek¡ cki ds lkFk jgrh gwa¡ rFkk
d{kk 6 oha rd i<+h gw¡ fd fnukad 22-11-2004 dks jkf= esa QVkdk QksM+us
ij esjs iMkslh 'kjn ds lkFk esjs HkkbZ jkew firk cnzhizlkn ds lkFk >xM+k
ekjihV gqvk Fkk fd vkt fnukad 22-11-2004 dks djhc 8 cts jkf= ge
yksx ifjokj lfgr [kkuk [kkus cSBs Fks] mlh fnu ds fookn dks ysdj ’kjn]
33.
ukjn] nj’k eksgu] x.ks’k] xqMMw] jkedq’ky] jken;ky] lfjrk] nsodh
lhrkckbZ cxSjg jkM] gkdh fLVd] pn~nj iV~Vh cxSjg ysdj gekjs ?kj vanj
?kql x;s jken;ky mQZ NksVk vius gkFk esa Vafx;k j[kk] tks ;g dgrs
eknjpksn rqe yksx ml fnu gekjs lkFk ekjihV fd;s Fks] vkt iwjs ifjokj
dks tku ls [kRe dj nsxsa] ekjihV djuk pkyw dj fn;s] jken;ky esjs cM+s
HkkbZ jkew dks Vkafx;k ls ekjk tks flj esa yxk fd ’kjn] nj’k ukjn cxSjg
ykBh fLVd oxSjg ls ekjihV djus yxs] fd lfjrk] nsodh ,oa lhrk ckbZ
eq>s idM+ dj [khap fy;k rFkk yksgs dh iV~Vh ls esjs flj ds ihNs fgLls esa
ekjs] tks esjs flj esa ihNs rjQ yxh] os yksx lHkh ,d jk; gksdj Vkafx;k]
ykBh fLVd oxSjg] ge yksxks dks tku ls ekj Mkyus dh fu;r ls ekjihV
fd;s] ftles esjs cMs+ HkkbZ jkew mQZ jkedqekj dks dkQh pkasVs vkbZ ekjihV
djus NksV w lq;Z ,oa esjs ifjokj mifLFkr rFkk vklikl ds vU; yksx ns[ks
lqus gSA esjs HkkbZ jkew ds flj gkFk iSj oxSjg es dkQh pksV vkbZ Fkh] ftlls
og csgks’k gks x;k gS] fd eSa vius HkkbZ f’ko us lkFk Fkkuk fjiksVZ djkus vkbZ
gSw] esjs c;ku vuqlkj lgh fy[kh xbZ gS] tks tkap fd;k tkosA”
The other injured witnesses is PW-6 Dev Kumari has been
examined on 11.08.2005. She is the wife of the deceased. She
stated in her evidence that on 22.11.2004 there was a quarrel
took place between them and the accused persons, when the
deceased was burning crackers in his house. On 26.11.2004, at
about 8 PM, her husband Ramu @ Ramkumar came back from
his work, at the same time, the accused persons suddenly
entered into her house and started assaulting her husband and
took him out of the house. She called her in-laws and other family
members and all of them tried to intervene. By the assault made
by the accused persons, she, her sister-in-law and in-laws have
also received injuries. Mohan, Ramdayal and Sharad assaulted
her husband by axe, Shivdayal and Darash assaulted by rod and
Ganesh, Narad and Ramkushal assaulted by pipe. The accused
Devki, Sita and Sarita were having danda and iron plate and they
assaulted by said weapons. After assaulting them, the accused
persons fled away. Her husband was being taken to police
station, from where he was taken to hospital and during
treatment, he died. She too has been injured and lodged merg
intimation (exhibit P-9). In cross-examination, she also remained
firm with respect to involvement of the accused persons in the
offence in question. Though the defence tried to extract some
discrepancy in her 161 CRPC statement, but from perusal of the
161 CRPC statement of this witness (exhibit D-3), it transpires
that she made allegation against the accused persons about the
incident. Although it is not in the same manner, but substantively
she alleged about the entire incident. She is also an injured
witness, wife of the deceased and her presence is natural.
34.
On 03.03.2008, Dev Kumari was again examined after the arrest
of other accused persons Sharad, Chhota @ Ramdayal, Sita Bai,
Devki Bai and Sarita Bai, as PW-2. She stated in her evidence
that, on the date of incident, on the issue of burning crackers,
quarrel raised by the accused persons and after sometime, when
they convinced the accused persons, they walked away. On the
date of incident, i.e. on 26.11.2004, at about 8 PM, when her
husband came back from his work, the accused persons,
Ramdayal, Shivdayal, Darash, Sharad, Narad, Mohan, Ganesh,
Ramkishan, Sita, Sarita and Devki entered into her house and
started assaulted her husband. They dragged him outside of the
house and at that time, she shouted for help. Her in-laws and
sister-in-law came out from their house and they tried to intervene
in the incident. Mohan, Ramdayal and Sharad assaulted her
husband by axe, Shivdayal, Darash assaulted by rod, Ganesh,
Narad and Ramkushal assaulted by pipe. Devki, Sita and Sarita
having pipe and iron plate, by which they assaulted her husband.
Her husband has received injuries all over his body. They too
have been assaulted by the accused persons and then her sisterin-law Naina Bai and in-laws have also received injuries. After
assaulting them, the accused persons went away towards lane.
They had gone to Police Station Civil Lines, from where the
injured persons were sent to the hospital and at CIMS Hospital,
he died during treatment. She also received injuries on her body
and medically examined by the doctor. She lodged the merg
intimation (exhibit P-9). In her detailed cross-examination, she too
remained firm in saying that, the accused persons entered into
their house and assaulted the deceased by axe, rod and pipe and
they too have been assaulted by them. She is the wife of the
deceased and reiterated the incident, which occurred on the date
of incident and the involvement of the accused persons, who
assaulted her husband. Her 161 CRPC statements (exhibit D-3)
is also bears with the names of the accused persons and the
manner, in which the incident occurred.
35.
The another witness PW-7 Badri Prasad is also the injured
eyewitness, who is the father of deceased and examined on
12.08.2005. He stated in his evidence that, on 26.11.2004, at
about 8 PM, he heard the noise of quarrel coming from the house
of his daughter-in-law Dev Kumari. When he along with his other
family members went to the house of his son Ramu, they saw
that all the accused persons inside the house of Ramu and they
abusing them. They dragged Ramu outside of his house. The
accused Sarita was holding iron plate, Sita holding hockey stick,
Devki Bai holding danda, Mohan, Ramdayal @ Chhota and
Sharad were having axes, the other accused persons were
having iron rod and pipe. The accused Sarita, Sita and Devki Bai
assaulted his daughter Nainvati and they exhorted the other
accused persons to assault them and then, they started
assaulting his son Ramu. By the assault made by the accused
persons, his son Ramu, Naina, Bedin Bai @ Devki Bai and he
himself received injuries. When they shouted for help, the
accused persons fled away. His son Ramu was being taken to
police station, from where he was sent to hospital, where he died
during treatment. Report has been lodged by Amravati and Dev
Kumari in the hospital. In his cross-examination, he also stand in
his allegation that the accused persons have assaulted the
deceased as well as the witnesses by weapons, which they were
having at the time of incident. But for minor omissions or
contradictions, the defence could not extract any material from
this witness also, so that the credibility of the evidence of this
witness could be doubted. He being the father of the deceased
and injured eyewitness, his evidence could not be disbelieved by
saying that he is the interested witness.
36.
On 03.03.2008, Badri Prasad was again examined after the arrest
of other accused persons Sharad, Chhota @ Ramdayal, Sita Bai,
Devki Bai and Sarita Bai, as PW-3. He is the father of the
deceased and injured witness. He stated in his evidence that on
26.11.2004, at about 8 PM, when he was in his house, his
daughter-in-law started shouting that Darash and Ramkushal
quarreling with her husband inside the house. When they rush to
her house, they saw that Mohan, Ramkushal, Sharad, Dashrath,
Narad, Shivdayal, Ramdayal @ Chhota and three ladies Sarita,
Sita and Devki by abusing his son Ramu and they dragged him
outside of his house. Sarita was having iron plate, Sita was
having hockey stick and Devki was having danda and dragged
Nainawati and assaulted her by their weapon. They exhorted the
other accused persons to assault and then they started
assaulting his son Ramu. Mohan, Ramdayal @ Chhota and
Sharad have assaulted him by axe, Narad, Shivdayal, Darash,
Ganesh, Ramkushal assaulted them by iron rod and pipe. His
son Ramu received multiple injuries all over his body and he went
in unconsciousness. They too have been assaulted by the
accused persons. They have taken the injured person to Civil
Line Police Station, from where they were sent to the hospital.
During treatment, his son Ramu has died. In his crossexamination also, the defence tried to extract the material to
disbelieve the evidence of this witness, but they could not
succeed to extract any substantive material, which makes his
evidence doubtful. He is the father of the deceased and his
presence on the spot cannot be doubted, particularly when he is
also injured in the incident.
37.
PW-1, Shyam Kumar Suryavanshi is the another eyewitness, who
is the brother of the deceased. He initially examined on
12.07.2005 at the time when the accused persons Mohan,
Ramkushal, Darash Lal, Narad Suryavanshi, Ganesh and Guddu
@ Shivdayal were arrested and put to trial. When the other
accused persons Sharad, Chhota @ Shyamdayal, Sita Bai, Devki
Bai and Sarita Bai were arrested, Shyam Kumar Suryavanshi
again examined as PW-4 on 04.03.2008. In both these
occasions, he deposed that on 26.11.2004, when he came back
from his work at about 8 PM, he saw that his sister-in-law Dev
Kumari shouting for help, and when he went there, he saw that
his brother was lying unconscious having multiple injuries on all
over his body and his sister-in-law informed him that, Sharad,
Ramdayal and Mohan assaulted him by axe and Shivdayal,
Darash, Narad, Ramkushal, Ganesh assaulted him by pipe, rod
and hockey. He also named three ladies/accused persons Sita,
Sarita and Devki. When he saw backside, the accused persons
Ramdayal, Shivdayal, Narad, Sharad, Mohan, Ramkushal,
Ganesh, Darash, Devki, Sita and Sarita were standing near the
pole. They were exhorting to kill them the other members by
hurling abuses. He took the injured persons to police station and
after lodging of the report, they took the deceased Ramkumar to
the Hospital, but on the way he died. Though, he did not state
about witnessing the actual assault made by the accused
persons, but came on the spot immediately after the incident and
saw the accused persons together armed with weapons, standing
near the pole and hurling abuses that, they will kill the other
members. From his 161 CRPC statement (exhibit D-1), his
evidence is duly corroborated that when he reached on the spot,
he saw his brother lying in injured condition and the accused
persons were standing together near electric pole having armed
with weapons and hurling threats. The defence in their detailed
cross-examination could not be able to bring any material to
disbelieve the evidence of this witness except for the minor
variations in his evidence. His evidence is duly supported to the
evidence of other injured witnesses.
38.
PW-5, Dinesh Kumar who is another brother of the deceased,
has been examined on 04.03.2008 after arrest of the accused
persons; Sharad, Chhota @ Ramdayal, Sita Bai, Devki Bai and
Sarita Bai. At the time, when the other accused persons were
arrested and their trial was concluded vide judgment dated
10.08.2006, this witness PW-5/Dinesh Kumar was not examined.
He stated in his evidence that, on 26.11.2004, at about 8:15 PM,
his sister-in-law shouted for help and when he along with his
parents, brother and sisters had gone to the house of the
deceased, they saw that his brother was being dragged by the
accused persons outside of his house and the accused Darash,
Narad, Ramkushal assaulted his brother by pipe, crowbar and
lathi. Sharad, Mohan and Ramdayal assaulted him by axe. Sita,
Sarita and Devki were also present there having hockey stick and
lathi in their hands and they assaulted his sister Naina @
Nainwati. He and his parents intervened in the quarrel and his
brother lying on the ground after received injuries. His elder
brother took him to hospital, but he died. In cross-examination, he
stuck in saying that the accused persons have assaulted his
brother by axe rod and pipe. Though this witness has been crossexamined by the defence with respect to certain discrepancies
with that of his police statement (exhibit D-5), but from perusal of
his police statement, it transpires that he made allegation that the
accused persons have assaulted the deceased and injured
witnesses. Though, the details of the manner in which the
accused persons have assaulted the deceased is not in the same
manner, but the substance is that, the accused persons have
accused the deceased and injured witnesses, by which they
received injuries.
39.
From the accused Narad, one iron rod and shirt have been seized
vide exhibit P-14. From the accused Ramkushal, iron rod has
been seized vide seizure memo (exhibit P-3). From accused
Darash, an axe has been seized vide seizure memo (exhibit P12). From the accused Ganesh, iron pipe and T-shirt have been
seized vide seizure memo (exhibit P-15) and from accused
Mohan, axe has been seized vide seizure memo (exhibit P-22).
Though
the
seizure
witnesses
have
not
supported
the
prosecution’s case, but they have admitted their signature in the
seizure memo (exhibit P-14). In the FSL report (exhibit P-26),
blood has been found on the rod seized from the accused Narad.
40.
PW-18, D.P. Thakur is the investigating officer, who duly
supported the investigation, which he carried out with respect to
the alleged offence and he has proved the documents which he
prepared during the investigation.
41.
In the case, the witnesses are the family members of the
deceased, who are also injured in the incident. The defence has
raised a plea that, they being the interested witnesses, cannot be
relied upon, as they are the close relatives of the deceased. The
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of “Laltu Ghosh v. State of
West Bengal” 2019 (15) SCC 344, has held that:“12. As regards the contention that the eyewitnesses
are close relatives of the deceased, it is by now wellsettled that a related witness cannot be said to be an
"interested" witness merely by virtue of being a
relative of the victim. This Court has elucidated the
difference between "interested" and "related"
witnesses in a plethora of cases, stating that a
witness may be called interested only when he or she
derives some benefit from the result of a litigation,
which in the context of a criminal case would mean
that the witness has a direct or indirect interest in
seeing the accused punished due to prior enmity or
other reasons, and thus has a motive to falsely
implicate the accused (for instance, see State of
Rajasthan v. Kalki, Amit v. State of U.P.3 and
Gangabhavani v. Rayapati Venkat Reddy).
13. Recently, this difference was reiterated in
Ganapathi v. State of T.N.5, in the following terms, by
referring to the three-Judge Bench decision in State of
Rajasthan v. Kalki²: (Ganapathi case, SCC p. 555,
para 14)
"14. "Related" is not equivalent to "interested". A
witness may be called "interested" only when he
or she derives some benefit from the result of a
litigation; in the decree in a civil case, or in
seeing an accused person punished. A witness
who is a natural one and is the only possible
eyewitness in the circumstances of a case
cannot be said to be "interested".…"
14. In criminal cases, it is often the case that the
offence is witnessed by a close relative of the victim,
whose presence on the scene of the offence would be
natural. The evidence of such a witness cannot
automatically be discarded by labelling the witness as
interested. Indeed, one of the earliest statements a
with respect to interested witnesses in criminal cases
was made by this Court in Dalip Singh v. State of
Punjab, wherein this Court observed: (AIR p. 366.
para 26)
"26. A witness is normally to be considered
independent unless he or she springs from
sources which are likely to be tainted and that
usually b means unless the witness has cause,
such as enmity against the accused, to wish to
implicate him falsely. Ordinarily, a close relative
would be the last to screen the real culprit and
falsely implicate an innocent person.
15. In case of a related witness, the Court may not
treat his or her testimony as inherently tainted, and
needs to ensure only that the evidence is inherently
reliable, probable, cogent and consistent. We may
refer to the observations of this Court in Jayabalan v.
State (UT of Pondicherry): (SCC p. 213, para 23)
"23. We are of the considered view that in cases
where the court is called upon to deal with the
evidence of the interested witnesses, the
approach of the court while appreciating the
evidence of such witnesses must not be
pedantic. The court must be cautious in
appreciating and d accepting the evidence given
by the interested witnesses but the court must
not be suspicious of such evidence. The primary
endeavour of the court must be to look for
consistency. The evidence of a witness cannot
be ignored or thrown out solely because it
comes from the mouth of a person who is
closely related to the victim.
16. In the instant matter, as already discussed above,
we find the testimony of the eyewitnesses to be
consistent and reliable, and therefore reject the
contention of the appellants that the testimony of the
eyewitnesses must be disbelieved because they are
close relatives of the deceased and hence interested.”
42.
In the matter of “State of Uttar Pradesh v. Naresh and others”
2011 (4) SCC 324, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has considered
the normal discrepancies in the evidence of witnesses and the
minor contradictions or inconsistencies are bound to occur due to
normal errors of observations, error of memory due to lapse of
time and their mental disposition, such as shock and horror at the
time of occurrence. In para 27 to 30 of its judgment, it has been
held that:27. The evidence of an injured witness must be given
due weightage being a stamped witness, thus, his
presence cannot be doubted. His statement # is
generally considered to be very reliable and it is unlikely
that he has spared the actual assailant in order to falsely
implicate someone else. The testimony of an injured
witness has its own relevancy and efficacy as he has
sustained injuries at the time and place of occurrence
and this lends support to his testimony that he was
present during the occurrence. Thus, the testimony of an
injured witness is accorded a special status in law. The
witness would not flike or want to let his actual assailant
go unpunished merely to implicate a third person falsely
for the commission of the offence. Thus, the evidence of
the injured witness should be relied upon unless there
are grounds for the rejection of his evidence on the basis
of major contradictions and discrepancies therein. (Vide
Jarnail Singh v. State of Punjab, Balraje v. State of
Maharashtra and Abdul Sayeed v. State of M.P.3)
28. The High Court disbelieved both the witnesses,
Subedar (PW 1) and Balak Ram (PW 5) as being closely
related to the deceased and for not examining any
independent witnesses. In a case like this, it may be
difficult the prosecution to procure an independent
witness, wherein the accused had killed one person at
the spot and seriously injured the other. The independent
witness may not muster the courage to come forward
and depose against such accused.
29. A mere relationship cannot be a factor to affect
credibility of a witness. The evidence of a witness cannot
be discarded solely on the ground of his relationship with
the victim of the offence. The plea relating to relatives'
evidence remains without any substance in case the
evidence has credence and it can be relied upon. In such
a case the defence has to lay b foundation if plea of false
implication is made and the court has to analyse the
evidence of related witnesses carefully to find out
whether it is cogent and credible. (Vide Jarnail Singh,
Vishnu v. State of Rajasthan and Balraje)
30. In all criminal cases, normal discrepancies are bound
to occur in the depositions of witnesses due to normal
errors of observation, namely, errors of memory due to
lapse of time or due to mental disposition such as shock
and horror at the time of occurrence. Where the
omissions amount to a contradiction, creating a serious
doubt about the truthfulness of the witness and other
witnesses also make material improvement while
deposing in the court, such evidence cannot be safe to
rely
upon.
However,
minor
d
contradictions,
inconsistencies, embellishments or improvements on
trivial matters which do not affect the core of the
prosecution case, should not be made a ground on
which the evidence can be rejected in its entirety. The
court has to form its opinion about the credibility of the
witness and record a finding as to whether his deposition
inspires confidence.”
43.
It is further held in para 32 of the judgment of “Naresh” (supra), it
has been held that:-
44.
“32. It is a settled legal proposition that an FIR is not an
encyclopaedia the entire case. It may not and need not
contain all the details. Naming of the accused therein
may be important but not naming of the accused in FIR
may not be a ground to doubt the contents thereof in
case the statement of the witness is found to be
trustworthy. The court has to determine after b examining
the entire factual scenario whether a person has
participated in the crime or has falsely been implicated.
The informant fully acquainted with the facts may lack
necessary skill or ability to reproduce details of the entire
incident without anything missing from this. Some people
may miss even the most important details in narration.
Therefore, in case the informant fails to name a
particular accused in the FIR, this ground alone cannot
tilt the balance of the case in favour of the accused.
(Vide Rotash v. State of Rajasthan and Ranjit Singh v.
State of M.P.10).”
Further, considering the all circumstances, it cannot be said that
the appellants had not participated to prosecute a common
object. Their presence along with the weapon of offence have
been duly proved by the witnesses and their active participation
have also been described by them. The witnesses being the
injured witnesses cannot be disbelieved. There is enough
evidence on record to establish that the appellants were present,
armed with weapons and their identification is not in issue.
45.
In the case of “Amerika Rai and Others v. State of Bihar” 2011
(4) SCC 677, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held in para 13 of
its judgment that:“13. The law of vicarious liability under Section 149 IPC
is crystal clear that even the presence in the unlawful
assembly, but with an active mind, to achieve the
46.
common object makes such a person vicariously liable
for the e acts of the unlawful assembly. In that light,
when the evidence is examined, it is obvious that
Amerika Rai (A-1) who was the elder in the family and
father of Darbesh Rai (A-2), Mithilesh Rai (A-4) and
Chulhan Rai (A-3), instead of acting in a responsible
manner and preventing any unpleasant incident,
exhorted the accused persons to bring the gun. The
guns are normally not brought for making a show. The
exhortation to bring the gun definitely! speaks about the
guilty mind of Amerika Rai (A-1), so also the use of guns
by Mithilesh Rai (A-4), Sanjay Rai (A-5) and Sipahi Rai
(A-6) is very clear that they also had guilty mind.
Mithilesh Rai (A-4) went to the extent of injuring
Dineshwar Rai (PW 7). Therefore, even their presence
and part played by them was obviously pointing towards
the common object of committing murder of Shankar Rai.
Unfortunately, Shankar Rai became the 9 victim of the
circumstances. The accused persons had nothing to do
with Shankar Rai. Their main ire was directed at Ram
Babu (PW 6). But, perhaps because Shankar Rai took
side of Ram Babu (PW 6), he became the victim of
circumstances and had to pay with his own life.
Therefore, at least insofar as these persons are
concerned, their presence and their active participation
would make them guilty under Section 149 IPC, though
the author of the injury to Shankar Rai was Chulhan Rai
(A-3) whose appeal has already been dismissed.”
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of Lakshman Singh
Vs. State of Bihar, reported in 2021 (9) SCC 199, has observed
in Para 12 to 17 of its judgment that:"12. Now so far as the conviction of the accused under
Section 147 IPC is concerned, the presence of all the
accused persons at the time of incident and their active
participation has been established and proved by the
prosecution by examining the aforesaid witnesses who are
the independent witnesses and injured witnesses also. The
accused persons belong to another village. They formed an
unlawful assembly in prosecution of common object, i.e., “to
snatch the voters list and to cast bogus voting”. It has been
established and proved that they used the force and, in the
incident, PW5, PW8, PW10 & PW12 sustained injuries. All
the accused persons-appellants were having lathis. Section
147 IPC is a punishable section for “rioting”.
13.The offence of “rioting” is defined in Section 146 IPC,
whichreads as under:
"146. Rioting – Whenever force or violence is used
by an unlawful assembly, or by any member thereof, in
prosecution of the common object of such assembly, every
member of such assembly is guilty of the offence of rioting.”
14. On a fair reading of the definition of “rioting” as per
Section 146 IPC, for the offence of “rioting”, there has to be,
(i) an unlawful assembly of 5 or more persons as
defined in Section 141 IPC, i.e., an assembly of 5 or more
persons and such assembly was unlawful;
(ii) the unlawful assembly must use force or violence.
Force is defined in Section 349 IPC; and
(iii) the force or violence used by an unlawful
assembly or by any member thereof must be in prosecution
of the common object of such assembly in which case every
member of such assembly is guilty of the offence of rioting.
15. “Force” is defined under Section 349 IPC. As per
Section 349 IPC, “force” means “A person is said to use
force to another if he causes motion, change of motion, or
cessation of motion to that other…….”
16. As observed hereinabove, all the accused persons were
the members of the unlawful assembly and the common
intention was “to snatch the voters slips and to cast bogus
voting”. They used force and violence also, as observed
hereinabove. It is the case on behalf of the accused that
there is no specific role attributed to them for the offence of
rioting under Section 147 IPC. However, as observed
hereinabove and as held by this Court in the case of Abdul
Sayeed (supra), where there are large number of
assailants, it can be difficult for witnesses to identify each
assailant and attribute specific role to him. In the present
case, the incident too concluded within few minutes and
therefore it is natural that exact version of incident revealing
every minute detail, i.e., meticulous exactitude of individual
acts cannot be given by eyewitnesses. Even otherwise, as
held by this Court in the case of Mahadev Sharma (supra),
every member of the unlawful assembly is guilty of the
offence of rioting even though he may not have himself
47.
used force or violence. In paragraph 7, it is observed and
held as under:
“7. Section 146 then defines the offence of rioting. This
offence is said to be committed when the unlawful assembly
or any member thereof in prosecution of the common object
of such assembly uses force or violence. It may be noticed
here that every member of the unlawful assembly is guilty of
the offence of rioting even though he may not have himself
used force or violence. There is thus vicarious responsibility
when force or violence is used in prosecution of the
common object of the unlawful assembly.”
17. Thus, once the unlawful assembly is established in
prosecution of the common object, i.e., in the present case,
“to snatch the voters list and to cast bogus voting”, each
member of the unlawful assembly is guilty of the offence of
rioting. The use of the force, even though it be the slightest
possible character by any one member of the assembly,
once established as unlawful constitutes rioting. It is not
necessary that force or violence must be by all but the
liability accrues to all the members of the unlawful
assembly. As rightly submitted by the learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the State, some may encourage by
words, others by signs while others may actually cause hurt
and yet all the members of the unlawful assembly would be
equally guilty of rioting. In the present case, all the accused
herein are found to be the members of the unlawful
assembly in prosecution of the common object, i.e., “to
snatch the voters list and to cast bogus voting” and PW5,
PW8, PW10 & PW12 sustained injuries caused by
members of the unlawful assembly, the appellants- accused
are rightly convicted under Section 147 IPC for the offence
of rioting.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court has also observed the scope of
Section 149 of I.P.C. in the matter of State of M.P. Vs. Kallu,
2020 (16) SCC 375 in Para 8 and 9, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
has held as under:"8. Since the instant case depends upon the extent and
application of the principle of vicarious liability under
Section 149 of the IPC, at the outset, we may consider the
leading case of Masalti vs. State of U.P. The submission of
the appellants therein was that mere presence in an
assembly would not make a person member of an unlawful
assembly unless it was shown that he had done something
or omitted to do something which would make him a
member of unlawful assembly. Reliance was placed by said
appellants on the earlier judgment of this Court in Baladin
vs. State of Uttar Pradesh. The issue was dealt with as
under:“17… … The observation of which Mr. Sawhney relies,
prima facie, does seem to support his contention; but, with
respect, we ought to add that the said observation cannot
be read as laying down a general proposition of law that
unless an overt act is proved against a person who is
alleged to be a member of an unlawful assembly, it cannot
be said that he is a member of such an unlawful assembly.
In appreciating the effect of the relevant observation on
which Mr. Sawhney has built his argument, we must bear in
mind the facts which were found in that case. It appears
that in the case of Baladin2, the members of the family of
the appellants and other residents of the village had
assembled together; some of them shared the common
object of the unlawful assembly, while others were merely
passive witnesses. Dealing with such an assembly, this
Court observed that the presence of a person in an
assembly of that kind would not necessarily show that he
was a member of an un- lawful assembly. What has to be
proved against a person who is alleged to be a member of
an unlawful assembly is that he was one of the persons
constituting the assembly ,and he entertained along with the
other members of the assembly the common object as
defined by Section 141, I.P.C. Section 142 provides that
whoever, being aware of facts which render any assembly
an unlawful assembly, intentionally joins that assembly, or
continues in it, is said to be a member of an unlawful
assembly. In other words, an assembly of five or more
persons actuated by, and entertaining one or more of the
common objects specified by the five clauses of Section.
141, is an unlawful assembly. The crucial question to
determine in such a case is whether the assembly
consisted of five or more persons and whether the said
persons entertained one or more of the common objects as
specified by Section.141. While determining this question, it
becomes relevant to consider whether the assembly
consisted of some persons who were merely passive
witnesses and had joined the assembly as a matter of idle
curiosity without intending to entertain the common object of
the assembly. It is in that context that the observations
made by this Court in the case of Baladin assume
significance; otherwise, in law, it would not be correct to say
that before a person is held to be a member of an unlawful
assembly, it must be shown that he had committed some
illegal overt act or had been guilty of some illegal omission
in pursuance of the common object of the assembly. In fact,
Section.149 makes it clear that if an offence is committed
by any member of an unlawful assembly in prosecution of
the common object of that assembly, or such as the
members of that assembly knew to be likely to be
committed in prosecution of that object, every person who,
at the time of the committing of that offence. is a member of
the same assembly, is guilty of that offence; and that
emphatically brings out the principle that the punishment
prescribed by Section.149 is in a sense vicarious and does
not always proceed on the basis that the offence has been
actually committed by every member of the unlawful
assembly. Therefore, we are satisfied that the observations
made in the case of Baladin must be read in the context of
the special facts of that case and cannot be treated as
laying down an unqualified proposition of law such as Mr.
Sawhney suggests.”
9. After considering the cases on the point including
Masalti, the order of acquittal passed by the High Court was
set aside by this Court in State of Maharashtra vs. Ramlal
Devappa Rathod. Relevant paragraphs of the decision are:“22. We may at this stage consider the law of vicarious
liability as stipulated in Section 149 IPC. The key
expressions in Section 149 IPC are:
(a) if an offence is committed by any member of an unlawful
assembly;
(b) in prosecution of common object of that assembly;
(c) which the members of that assembly knew to be likely to
be committed in prosecution of that object;
(d) every person who is a member of the same assembly is
guilty of the offence.
This section makes both the categories of persons, those
who committed the offence as also those who were
members of the same assembly liable for the offences
under Section 149 IPC, if other requirements of the section
are satisfied. That is to say, if an offence is committed by
any person of an unlawful assembly, which the members of
that assembly knew to be likely to be committed, every
member of that assembly is guilty of the offence. The law is
clear that membership of unlawful assembly is sufficient to
hold such members vicariously liable.
23. It would be useful to refer to certain decisions of
this Court. In State of U.P. v. Kishanpal it was observed:
(SCC p. 93, para 47)
“47. … It is well settled that once a membership of an
unlawful assembly is established it is not incumbent on the
prosecution to establish whether any specific overt act has
been assigned to any accused. In other words, mere
membership of the unlawful assembly is sufficient and
every member of an unlawful assembly is vicariously liable
for the acts done by others either in the prosecution of the
common object of the unlawful assembly or such which the
members of the unlawful assembly knew were likely to be
committed."
Further, in Amerika Rai v. State of Bihar5 it was observed
as under: (SCC p. 682, para 13)
“13. The law of vicarious liability under Section 149 IPC is
crystal clear that even the presence in the unlawful
assembly, but with an active mind, to achieve the common
object makes such a person vicariously liable for the acts of
the unlawful assembly.”
24. The liability of those members of the unlawful assembly
who actually committed the offence would depend upon the
nature and acceptability of the evidence on record. The
difficulty may however arise, while considering the liability
and extent of culpability of those who may not have actually
committed the offence but were members of that assembly.
What binds them and makes them vicariously liable is the
common object in prosecution of which the offence was
committed by other members of the unlawful assembly.
Existence of common object can be ascertained from the
attending facts and circumstances. For example, if more
than five persons storm into the house of the victim where
only few of them are armed while the others are not and the
armed persons open an assault, even unarmed persons are
vicariously liable for the acts committed by those armed
persons. In such a situation it may not be difficult to
48.
ascertain the existence of common object as all the persons
had stormed into the house of the victim and it could be
assessed with certainty that all were guided by the common
object, making every one of them liable. Thus when the
persons forming the assembly are shown to be having
same interest in pursuance of which some of them come
armed, while others may not be so armed, such unarmed
persons if they share the same common object, are liable
for the acts committed by the armed persons.”
Further, the co-accused Sharad and Chhota @ Ramdayal have
been convicted by the learned trial Court vide its judgment dated
18.06.2008 and their Criminal Appeal No. 713/2008 has been
dismissed by coordinate bench of this Court vide judgment dated
18.01.2016. As per the submissions made by learned counsel for
the parties, they have already undergone the entire sentence,
and their judgment of conviction and sentence attains finality, and
thus, the incident, homicidal death of the deceased Ramu @
Ramkumar and involvement of the accused persons is
established by the prosecution. The injured eyewitnesses duly
supported the prosecution’s case and after adverting the entire
facts and circumstances of the case as well as the evidence
available on record, the learned trial Court convicted the
appellants for the alleged offences, in which we do not find any
perversity or illegality to interfere with the same.
49.
Accordingly, the appeal filed by the appellants Guddu @
Shivdayal (CRA No. 330/2017) and Narad Suryavanshi (CRA No.
282/2023) are hereby dismissed.
50.
The appellants are reported to be on bail. They shall be taken into
custody to serve their remaining sentence, as awarded by the
learned trial Court
51.
Let a copy of this judgment and the original records be
transmitted to the trial Court concerned forthwith for necessary
information and compliance.
Ved/Alok
Sd/-
Sd/-
(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review