Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH
DATED THIS THE 7TH DAY OF JANUARY 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 100365 OF 2019
C/W CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.100149 OF 2020 &
100069 OF 2021
IN CRL.A NO. 100365/2019
BETWEEN:
SRI.RAMESH S/O. SURESHAPPA HAVANUR,
AGE: 23 YEARS, OCC. LABOUR,
R/O. KURUBAGERI, SOPPINAPETE,
TQ. RANEBENNUR, DIST. HAVERI-581115.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. N.S. BADIGER, ADVOCATE)
AND:
Digitally signed
by
VIJAYALAKSHMI VIJAYALAKSHMI
M KANKUPPI
M KANKUPPI
Date: 2026.01.29
10:39:43 +0530
STATE OF KARNATAKA THROUGH
RANEBENNUR TOWN POLICE STATION,
REPRESENTED BY STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
DHARWAD BENCH, DHARWAD
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI.JAIRAM SIDDI, HCGP)
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 374(2)OF
CR.P.C. PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT DATED 16/04/2019
AND ORDER OF SENTENCE DATED 20/04/2019 PASSED BY THE II
ADDITIONAL DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE, HAVERI (SITTING AT
RANEBENNUR) IN S.C.NO.06/2015 IN CRIME NO.157/2014 OF
RANEBENNUR TOWN POLICE STATION CONVICTING THE APPELLANT
AND 3 OTHERS AND SENTENCED HIM TO UNDERGO IMPRISONMENT
FOR LIFE AND TO PAY A FINE OF RS.10,000/- IN DEFAULT TO UNDER
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
GO RIGOROUS IMPRISONMENT FOR THREE YEARS FOR THE
OFFENCE PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTION 302 R/W. 34 IPC AND
FURTHER CONVICT AND SENTENCED UNDERGO IMPRISONMENT FOR
LIFE AND TO PAY A FINE OF RS.10,000/- IN DEFAULT TO UNDER GO
RIGOROUS IMPRISONMENT FOR THREE YEARS FOR THE OFFENCE
PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTION 120B R/W. 34 OF IPC AND FURTHER
CONVICTED AND SENTENCED UNDERGO RIGOROUS IMPRISONMENT
FOR A PERIOD OF 7 YEARS AND TO PAY A FINE OF RS.10,000/- IN
DEFAULT TO UNDERGO IMPRISONMENT FOR ONE YEAR FOR THE
OFFENCE PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTIONS 397 R/W. 34 OF IPC ALL
SUSTENTATIVE SENTENCE RUN CONCURRENTLY AND ACQUIT
ACCUSED NO.2 FOR OFFENCE 120B, 302, 397 OF IPC AND ETC.
IN CRL.A NO.100149/2020
BETWEEN:
SHEKHAPPA S/O. RAMAPPA SUNAGAR,
AGE: 26 YEARS, OCC. LABOUR,
R/O. MARATGALLI, HARIHAR,
DIST. DAVANAGERE-577601.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI.N.S. BADIGER, ADVOCATE)
AND:
STATE OF KARNATAKA THROUGH
RANEBENNUR TOWN POLICE STATION,
REPRESENTED BY STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
DHARWAD BENCH, DHARWAD.
...RESPONDENT
(BY SRI.JAIRAM SIDDI, HCGP)
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 374(2) OF
CR.P.C., PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT DATED 16.04.2019
AND ORDER OF SENTENCE DATED 20.04.2019 PASSED BY II ADDL.
DISTRICT & SESSION JUDGE AT HAVERI (SITTING AT
RANEBENNUR) IN S.C. NO.06/2015 IN CRIME NO.0157/2014 OF
RANEBENNUR TOWN POLICE STATION IN SO FOR AS CONCERN TO
PETITIONER / ACCUSED NO.3, FOR OFFENCE 120B, 302, 397 R/W.
34 OF IPC AND ETC.
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
IN CRL.A NO.100069/2021
BETWEEN:
GOVIND S/O. HEMANNA PUJER,
AGE: 27 YEARS,
OCC. PRISONER SERVING SENTENCE AT
DHARWAD CENTRAL PRISON,
R/O. MAKANUR, TQ. RANEBENNUR,
DIST. HAVERI-581123.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI.N.S. BADIGER, ADVOCATE)
AND:
STATE OF KARNATAKA THROUGH
RANEBENNUR TOWN POLICE STATION,
REPRESENTED BY STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
DHARWAD BENCH.
...RESPONDENT
(BY SRI.JAIRAM SIDDI, HCGP)
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 374(2) OF
CR.P.C., PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT DATED
16/04/2019 AND ORDER OF SENTENCE DATED 20/04/2019 PASSED
BY II ADDL. DISTRICT AND SESSION JUDGE, AT HAVERI (SITTING
AT RANEBENNUR) IN S.C.NO.06/2015 IN CRIME NO.157/2014 OF
RANEBENNUR TOWN POLICE STATION CONVICTING THE APPELLANT
AND 3 OTHERS SENTENCED HIM TO UNDERGO IMPRISONMENT FOR
LIFE AND TO PAY A FINE OF RS.10,000/- IN DEFAULT TO UNDER GO
RIGOROUS IMPRISONMENT FOR THREE YEARS FOR THE OFFENCE
PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTION 302 R/W. 34 OF IPC AND FURTHER
CONVICT AND SENTENCED UNDERGO IMPRISONMENT FOR LIFE
AND TO PAY A FINE OF RS.10,000/- IN DEFAULT TO UNDERGO
RIGOROUS IMPRISONMENT FOR THREE YEARS FOR THE OFFENCE
PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTION 120B R/W. 34 OF IPC AND FURTHER
CONVICT AND SENTENCED UNDERGO IMPRISONMENT FOR A
PERIOD OF 7 YEARS AND TO PAY A FINE OF RS.10,000/- IN
DEFAULT TO UNDERGO RIGOROUS IMPRISONMENT FOR ONE YEAR
FOR THE OFFENCE PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTION 397 R/W. 34 OF
IPC ALL SUSTENTATIVE SENTENCE RUN CONCURRENTLY ACQUITS
IN SO FAR AS CONCERN TO ACCUSED NO.1 FOR OFFENCE 120B,
302, 397 OF IPC AND ETC.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
THESE CRIMINAL APPEALS COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING,
THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
1.
These appeals are preferred against the judgment
and order dated 16.04.2019 and 20.04.2019 passed by the
Court of II Additional District and Sessions Judge at Haveri
(Sitting at Ranebennur) in S.C. No.6/2015.
2.
Vide impugned judgment dated 16.04.2019, the
learned Sessions Judge has convicted accused Nos.1 to 4 for
the offence punishable under Section 302, 120B and 397
read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the IPC’, for short). Further, vide order dated
20.04.2019, passed the following sentence:
“13. …… accused Nos. 1 to 4 each convicted and
sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life for the
offence punishable U/Sec.302 R/W Sec. 34 of IPC.
Accused Nos. 1 to 4 each further convicted and
sentenced to pay fine of Rs.10,000/- each for the said
offence punishable U/Sec.302 R/W Sec. 34 of IPC. In
default of payment of fine, accused Nos. 1 to 4 shall
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
further undergo rigorous imprisonment for a further
period of 3 years each.
14. Accused Nos. 1 to 4 each further convicted
and sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life for the
offence punishable U/Sec. 120-B R/W Sec. 34 of IPC.
Accused Nos. 1 to 4 further convicted and sentenced to
pay fine of Rs.10,000/- each for the said offence
punishable U/Sec. 120B R/W Sec. 34 of IPC. In default
of payment of fine, accused Nos. 1 to 4 shall further
undergo rigorous imprisonment for a further period of 3
years each.
15. Accused Nos. 1 to 4 each further convicted
and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a
period of 7 years for the offence punishable U/Sec.397
R/W Sec.34 of IPC. Accused Nos. 1 to 4 further
convicted and sentenced to pay fine of Rs.10,000/- each
for the said offence punishable U/Sec.397 R/W Sec.34
of IPC. In default of payment of fine, accused Nos. 1 to
4 shall further undergo rigorous imprisonment for a
further period of 1 year each.”
3.
Criminal Appeal No.100069/2021 is preferred by
accused No.1, Criminal Appeal No.100365/2019 is preferred
by accused No.2 and Criminal Appeal No.100149/2020 is
preferred by accused No.3.
4.
Insofar
as
accused
No.4,
Criminal
Appeal
No.100218/2019 preferred by him was dismissed as abated
vide order dated 03.09.2025, since the said accused was
reported to be dead on 16.03.2021.
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
5.
We have heard learned counsel Sri. Namadev
Seetaram Badiger for the appellants, learned High Court
Government Pleader Sri. Jairam Siddi for the respondentState and perused the evidence and material on record.
6.
It is the case of prosecution that deceased
Neelamma, wife of Kotrappa Omkari, was residing along with
her son Basavaraj Omkari (PW.23) at 1st cross, Vageesh
Nagar, Ranebennur, Haveri District.
Shivayogi
Omkari
(PW.5)
was
Her another son
residing
in
Bangalore.
Deceased wanted to let out a house belonging to her
situated adjacent to the house where she was residing,
hence put up a let out board.
Accused Nos.1 to 4 with a
common intention of committing robbery and murder and
having
conspired
among
themselves,
approached
the
deceased on 17.6.2014 at about 12:30 pm when she was
alone, in the guise of taking the house on rent.
When the
deceased was about to show the house to them, they held
her mouth and nose tightly, strangulated her using a cloth
and committed her murder.
Thereafter, robbed the gold
ornaments worn by her and cash of Rs.30,000/-.
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
7.
Law was set into motion by one Kotresh Bangali
(PW.1) brother of the deceased, who came to know about
the incident from Basavaraj Omkari (PW.23). Based on his
complaint marked as Ex.P.1, FIR was registered against
unknown persons. Investigation was taken over by PW.22.
He visited the spot and conducted the spot mahazar and
inquest mahazar in the presence of panchas.
was conducted by PW.20.
Postmortem
In the course of investigation,
accused Nos.1 to 4 were arrested on 22.08.2014.
The
voluntary statement of accused No.1 was recorded as per
Ex.P-50. His voluntary statement led to the discovery of the
gold ornaments such as one gold chain, a finger ring and
another finger ring with elephant’s hair, marked as M.Os.9 to
11 from the house where he was residing, apart from cash,
motor bike, a screw driver and an iron rod from accused
Nos.1 to 4 under different panchanamas in the presence of
panchas.
On completion of investigation, PW.22 laid the
charge sheet.
8.
Charges were framed against A1 to A4 for the
offence punishable under Section 302, 120B, 397, 451 and
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
380 read with Section 34 of IPC. The accused pleaded not
guilty to the said charges.
9.
In order to bring home the guilt of the accused,
the prosecution, in all, examined PW.1 to PW.23, got marked
Ex.P-1 to P-52(a) and (b) and M.Os.1 to 21.
10.
denial.
The defence of the accused was one of total
They denied all the incriminating materials put to
them while they were examined under Section 313 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure. However, they did not choose
to lead any evidence on their behalf.
11.
The learned Sessions Judge on appreciating the
oral and documentary evidence on record proceeded to
convict the accused for the charged offences and passed the
sentence accordingly, as noted supra.
12.
It
is
vehemently
contended
by
the
learned
counsel for the appellants that the learned Sessions Judge
has convicted the accused without there being any legal
evidence on record and without properly appreciating the
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
cross-examination conducted by the defence. He contended
that the prosecution has utterly failed to establish that
Neelamma died a homicidal death.
He further contended
that there are no eyewitnesses to the incident in question
and
the
entire
case
of
the
prosecution
is
based
on
circumstantial evidence and the said circumstances relied on
by the prosecution are not sufficient to establish the guilt of
the accused beyond all reasonable doubt. He contended that
the alleged recoveries from the accused are not at all proved
and
the
prosecution
has
also
failed
to
establish
the
ingredients of Section 397 of IPC. He further contended that
the FIR was registered against unknown persons and there is
no sufficient evidence to connect these accused with the
crime and therefore, the learned Sessions Judge was not
justified in recording the conviction against them.
therefore, contended that the
He
impugned judgment has
resulted in miscarriage of justice and accordingly sought to
set aside the judgment and acquit the accused.
13.
Per contra, the learned High Court Government
Pleader has contended that the prosecution has adduced
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
acceptable and legal evidence to hold the accused guilty of
the charges leveled against them.
He contended that the
homicidal death of Neelamma has been proved by examining
the doctor who conducted the postmortem examination and
the postmortem report marked as Ex.P-46.
He contended
that the injuries found on the dead body also clearly
establishes that the
accused have used force and inflicted
those injuries while committing murder. He contended that
all the accused have conspired to commit robbery and
murder
of
Neelamma.
Further,
the
recovery
of
gold
ornaments belonging to the deceased, which were identified
by all the relatives, clearly establish the guilt of the accused
beyond all reasonable doubt. He would also contend that the
accused have robbed a cash of Rs.30,000/- from the house
of the deceased and some cash was recovered from them
and they have confessed that they have committed the
murder and robbed cash and gold which were recovered
from them.
Hence, there is substantial compliance of
Section 27 of the Evidence Act.
He contended that the
learned Sessions Judge having given acceptable reasons,
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
appreciating the evidence adduced by the prosecution, has
rightly convicted the accused for the charged offences and
there is no illegality or perversity in the said judgment. He
has, accordingly sought for dismissal of the appeals.
14.
It is the specific case of the prosecution that
accused Nos.1 to 4 with a common intention of committing
robbery and murder, conspired among themselves and went
to the house of the deceased on a motorcycle in the guise to
request the deceased to give the house on rent, as she had
put up ‘let out’ board outside her house and in that guise,
they went inside the house and held her nose and mouth
tightly and suffocated her by tying a cloth around her neck
and committed murder and then robbed the bangles, gold
chain and two finger rings and cash of Rs.30,000/-.
15.
From the material on record, it is evident that the
deceased was residing in the house along with her son
Basavaraj (PW.23). The incident took place on 17.06.2014.
As could be seen, PW.23 was not present in the house at the
time of incident. In his evidence, PW.23 has stated that on
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
16.06.2014, he had been to Anaji village to give some
medicine to his Aunt Vishalakshi (PW.9). He has stated that,
during that time, his mother was alone in the house.
On
17.06.2014 at about 6:30 pm, he returned to Ranebennur
from Anaji village, at that time, he noticed the door of the
house was open and there was no response from his mother
and therefore, went inside the house and saw all the things
scattered.
Thereafter, when he went inside the kitchen of
the house which the deceased wanted to give for rent, he
noticed his mother lying dead. Immediately, he informed his
uncle i.e., Kotresh Bangli (PW.1) who was residing at
Harapanahalli.
On receiving the information from PW.23-
Basavaraj, Kotresh Bangli (PW.1) immediately rushed to
Ranebennur, to the house of the deceased at about 9:00 pm.
Thereafter, he lodged a complaint as per Ex.P-1.
16.
PW.1 in his evidence has reiterated the complaint
averments, receiving the information from PW.23 over phone
and then visiting the house, noticing the dead body of his
sister and also the house hold articles being scattered.
He
has stated about lodging the complaint as per Ex.P-1,
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
mentioning the missing of gold chain, rings and bangles. PW23 has stated that when he enquired with the neighbours, he
came to know that a neighbour by name Kusuma, had
spoken to the deceased at about 10:00 am.
Hence, PW.1
lodged the complaint stating that in between 10:00 am and
6:30 pm some unknown persons have committed the
robbery and murder of his sister.
17.
There are no eyewitnesses to the incident.
The
prosecution relies on circumstantial evidence to prove the
charges.
In order to establish that the deceased died a
homicidal death, the prosecution has examined the Doctor,
who conducted the postmortem examination, as PW-20. He
issued postmortem report which is marked as Ex.P-46.
18.
PW.20 has deposed in his evidence that on
18.06.2014 in between 10:00 am to 11:00 am, he has
conducted autopsy over the dead body of Neelamma.
He
has noticed injuries over the nose, neck and left hand. He
has stated that all the injuries are antemortem in nature. He
has given his opinion regarding cause of death that the death
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
is due to asphyxia as a result of strangulation with a large
cloth and also suffocation caused by forcible closure of
mouth and nose by hands and cloth.
19.
A perusal of the postmortem report-Ex.P-46
clearly discloses that the deceased sustained abrasions over
forearm etc. Neck and face were cyanosed, congunctival
congestion in the eyes, a dark colour mark over front of neck
measuring
15cm
in
length
and
7cm
in
subcutaneous hemorrhage below the mark.
width
and
PW.20 has
stated that it may be caused by the cloth measuring 53x34
inches. Further, the postmortem report reveals that thyroid
bone and nasal bone were fractured.
20.
PW.20 has opined that the death has taken place
about 18-24 hours prior to postmortem examination which
corresponds to the time of incident.
There is nothing
elicited from his cross-examination, to deny the fact that the
deceased died a homicidal death.
Hence, the prosecution
has established that the death was homicidal in nature.
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
21.
Admittedly, there are no eyewitnesses to the
incident. The case rests on circumstantial evidence. As per
prosecution,
PW.17-PSI
while
on
patrolling
duty
on
21/22.08.2014 at about 1:10am along with other police
personnel, noticed two persons speeding on a motorcycle
from Harihar towards Ranebennur.
In spite of they asking
them to stop, they did not stop. Hence, the said motorcycle
was intercepted. Two persons on the motorcycle were
apprehended. They confessed to have involved in theft cases
in and around Ranebennur.
PW.17 informed the matter
through wireless to the CPI (PW.22). The said two persons
namely accused Nos.1 and 3 were produced before PW-22,
who after their arrest, recorded the voluntary statement of
accused No.1, who confessed committing the crime in
question. A screw driver and an iron rod marked as M.Os.12
and 13 kept in the motor cycle and the motorcycle marked
as M.O.19 were seized under a mahazar.
22.
After the arrest of accused Nos.1 and 3, on the
information furnished by them, accused Nos.2 and 4 were
also
arrested.
The
said
accused
confessed
to
have
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
committed
the
robbery
and
murder.
Based
on
the
information furnished by accused No.1, PW.22 along with
other
police
officials
and
panchas,
‘Manapuram Finance’ and seized
initially,
went
to
gold ornaments allegedly
pledged by the accused pertaining to some other case.
Further, at the instance of accused No.1, one gold chainM.O.9, two finger rings-M.Os.10 and 11 and bangles were
recovered from his house under a mahazar Ex.P-25 in the
presence of panchas CWs.8 and 9.
23.
The prosecution would rely on the confessional
statement of the accused to prove that the accused have
conspired to commit robbery and murder and proceeding
together to the house of the deceased on a motorcycle.
Based on their confessional statement, the Investigation
Officer has conducted panchanamas at the places, where the
conspiracy was held and the motorcycle was parked as per
Ex.P.23 and Ex.P.24. At this stage, it is relevant to mention
that the said confessional statement alone does not provide
conclusive proof, without
corroborating evidence to hold
that the prosecution has established the fact that all the
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
accused have conspired together to commit robbery and
murder and they went to the house of the deceased together
on a motorcycle. Apart from the said confessional statement,
there is no evidence adduced by the prosecution to show
that the accused were either present at the place, where the
mahazar was drawn, to conspire to commit robbery and
murder or to show that accused Nos.1 to 4 went to the
house of the deceased together on a motorcycle.
24.
appellants
It is the contention of the learned counsel for
that
the
alleged
seizure
of
motorcycle,
screwdriver, iron rod or even the gold ornaments is not
sufficient to hold that it was these accused who have
committed the robbery and murder. He contended that the
recovery is not in accordance with Section 27 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 and therefore, the accused cannot be
held guilty of the charged offences.
25.
It is pertinent to mention that in Ex.P.1-complaint
itself, P.W.1 has mentioned about the missing of bangle,
gold chain and gold rings belonging to the deceased. Though
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
the descriptions of those articles were not stated, that itself
is not fatal to the prosecution case. The prosecution has
examined P.W.1, P.W.5 to P.W.9 and P.W.23, the close
relatives of the deceased. Except P.W.8, all the other
witnesses have identified the gold chain-MO.9 and two finger
rings-MO.10 and MO.11 as belonging to the deceased. They
have categorically stated that the deceased was wearing
those ornaments when she was alive. Insofar as the bangle
is concerned, P.W.6, daughter-in-law of the deceased has
stated that the bangle which the deceased used to wear was
an artificial bangle. The witnesses have stated that after the
accused were arrested, the gold chain, a finger ring and
another finger ring with Elephant's hair were shown to them
and they have identified those ornaments as belonging to the
deceased.
26.
As per prosecution, the voluntary statement of
accused No.1 was recorded as per Ex.P.50. The said accused
initially led the police and panchas to one Manapuram
Finance, from where certain gold ornaments were seized and
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
thereafter, he took them to his house at Makanuru, wherein,
at his instance, MO.9 to MO.11 were seized under Ex.P.25.
27.
The prosecution has examined C.W.8 as P.W.4,
one of the panch witnesses to Ex.P.22 under which MO.12,
MO.13 and MO.14 to MO.17 and MO.19 were seized and
Ex.P.23, Ex.P.24, Ex.P.25 under which MO.9 to MO.11 were
seized and Ex.P.26 to Ex.P.39 (photographs taken at the
time of drawing of the panchanamas).
28.
P.W.4 has deposed in his evidence that the
accused took them to Makanuru village, from where one gold
chain, gold earrings and finger rings were seized. As could be
seen from the evidence adduced by the prosecution, the gold
chain and the two finger rings pertain to the present case.
The prosecution has also got examined one Gajanana
Shejavadkar-P.W.15
to
establish
the
recovery
aspect.
Though he has not wholeheartedly supported the case of
prosecution and has been treated hostile, in the crossexamination conducted by the Public Prosecutor, he has
admitted that out of the articles seized, one gold chain, one
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
finger ring with Elephant's hair and another finger ring (MO.9
to MO.11) were produced by accused No.1 and he has signed
the mahazar-Ex.P.25. Thus, his evidence corroborates the
evidence
of
Investigation
P.W.4
as
well
as
the
evidence
Officer-P.W.22,
who
prepared
the
of
the
seizure
panchanama.
29.
At the cost of repetition, all the witnesses, namely
the relatives of the deceased including P.W.1-brother of the
deceased, P.W.5 and P.W.23-sons, P.W.6-daughter-in-law,
P.W.7-brother-in-law and P.W.9-sister of the deceased have
identified MO’s 9 to 11 as the gold ornaments belonging to
the deceased. Hence, we have no hesitation to hold that the
said MO’s 9 to 11 belongs to the deceased and they were
robbed from the house after committing the murder. The
said ornaments were seized at the nstance of accused No.1.
30.
It is the contention of the learned counsel for
appellants that the ingredients of Section 397 of IPC are not
made out. The said contention is not acceptable, as this is
not only a case of robbery but also a case of murder. The
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
postmortem report would clearly reveal the injuries inflicted
on the deceased. The hyoid bone was fractured and the
cause of death is due to asphyxia as a result of strangulation
using a cloth. At the time of conducting the spot mahazar,
P.W.22-Investigation Officer has seized a cloth and it was
sent to P.W.20, the doctor who conducted postmortem
examination. P.W.20 has opined that the cloth-MO.7, which
was found around the neck of the deceased could also be
used for strangulating the deceased and causing the death
by strangulation.
31.
The incident took place on 17.06.2014. The
prosecution has established that the deceased died a
homicidal death. The gold ornaments of the deceased were
found missing and it was mentioned in Ex.P.1-complaint.
Hence, this is a case of murder for gain. The accused were
arrested on 22.08.2014. According to prosecution, a cash of
₹.30,000/- was also robbed from the house of the deceased.
After the arrest of accused No.1 to 4, a sum of ₹.1,200/- was
recovered from accused No.1, ₹.840/- from accused No.2,
₹.350/- from accused No.3 and ₹.610/- from accused No.4.
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
The said seizure of cash itself is not sufficient to hold that
they were robbed from the house of the deceased or that
accused No.2 to 4 were also part of conspiracy or they have
committed robbery and murder. The learned Sessions Judge
while holding all the accused guilty of the charges leveled,
has observed at para Nos.148 and 149 of the judgment as
under:
“148. Facts and circumstances of this case
shows that, it is humanly impossible for one of the
accused i.e., accused No.1 to commit the offence
of murder and robbing of gold and cash and
accordingly he conspired with other accused nos.2
to 4 and accordingly, brought accused Nos.2 to 4
in the motor cycle near the house of deceased,
parked the bike in a lonely place and all of them
together with a common intention entered the
house of deceased Neelamma to commit murder
and to rob the gold ornaments found on the
person of the deceased Neelamma. If at all if there
is no such criminal conspiracy hatched up interse
between accused nos.1 to 4 then there was no
occasion for accused nos.1 to 4 to trespass in to
the house of deceased Neelamma. So in
furtherance of the common object all the accused
Nos.1 to 4 trespassed in to the house of deceased
Neelamma with an intention to commit an offence
of murder and robbery and executed the intended
act by committing murder. The role of accused
nos.1 to 4 has been clearly mentioned in the
voluntary statement of accused No.1, which is
produced in this case as per Ex.P50. He also
disclosed about the sharing of the amount which is
the subject matter of robbery in the house of the
deceased Neelamma.
149. The personal search and panchanama
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
drawn as per Ex.P22 also discloses the fact that,
cash was also recovered from the possession of
accused Nos.1 to 4 in the police station while
conducting personal search of accused Nos.1 to 4.
When amount was recovered from accused Nos.1
to 4, they never raised any voice contending that,
it is the amount that they earned by doing any of
their independent work.”
32.
The reasons assigned by the learned Sessions
Judge to convict accused No.2 to 4 for the charges leveled
are not in accordance with law.
Reasons are based on
assumption and presumption. As we have already held,
except the confessional statement of the accused, there is no
legal evidence to show that even accused No.2 to 4 were
part of conspiracy or they have gone to the house of the
deceased together on a motorcycle, along with accused No.1.
Admittedly, the voluntary statements of accused No.2 to 4
are not marked in evidence. It is only the voluntary
statement of accused No.1, which is marked as Ex.P.50. The
gold ornaments were seized on the confession statement of
accused No.1 from his house situated at Makanuru. P.W.18,
owner of the said house has deposed that the house was
given on rent to accused No.1 and for about 15 days, the
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
said accused was staying in the said house. The recovery of
cash from accused No.2 to 4 is not sufficient to hold that
they are also involved in the crime in question. There is
absolutely no material against accused No.2 to 4 either in
the form of recovery or any other acceptable evidence to
hold that they are guilty of the charges leveled against them.
However, insofar as accused No.1, we find that there is
evidence to show that he has not only committed robbery
but also committed the murder of Neelamma.
33.
Accused No.1 has not offered any explanation,
while being questioned under Section 313 of Cr.P.C., for the
possession of gold ornaments. Hence, the only conclusion
which could be drawn is, he has committed the robbery and
murder of Neelamma. Murder and robbery have been proved
to be integral parts of the same transaction and therefore,
the presumption arising under illustration (a) to Section 114
of the Evidence Act is that not only the accused committed
the murder of the deceased but also committed robbery of
her ornaments which form the part of same transaction. At
this juncture, it is useful to refer to the relevant para of the
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
judgment reported in (1983) 2 SCC 330 in the case of
Earabhadrappa
Alias
Krishnappa
vs.
State
Karnataka, which reads as under:
“13. This is a case where murder and robbery are
proved to have been integral parts of one and the same
transaction and therefore the presumption arising under
Illustration (a) to Section 114 of the Evidence Act is that
not only the appellant committed the murder of the
deceased but also committed robbery of her gold
ornaments which form part of the same transaction. The
prosecution has led sufficient evidence to connect the
appellant with the commission of the crime. The sudden
disappearance of the appellant from the house of PW 3
on the morning of March 22, 1979 when it was
discovered that the deceased had been strangulated to
death and relieved of her gold ornaments, coupled with
the circumstance that he was absconding for a period of
over one year till he was apprehended by PW 26 at
village Hosahally on March 29, 1980, taken with the
circumstance that he made the statement Ex. P-35
immediately upon his arrest leading to the discovery of
the stolen articles, must necessarily raise the inference
that the appellant alone and no one else was guilty of
having committed the murder of the deceased and
robbery of her gold ornaments. The appellant had no
satisfactory explanation to offer for his possession of the
stolen property. On the contrary, he denied that the
stolen property was recovered from him. The false
denial by itself is an incriminating circumstance. The
nature of presumption under Illustration (a) to Section
114 must depend upon the nature of the evidence
adduced. No fixed time limit can be laid down to
determine whether possession is recent or otherwise
and each case must be judged on its own facts. The
question as to what amounts to recent possession
sufficient to justify the presumption of guilt varies
of
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
according as the stolen article is or is not calculated to
pass readily from hand to hand. If the stolen articles
were such as were not likely to pass readily from hand
to hand, the period of one year that elapsed cannot be
said to be too long particularly when the appellant had
been absconding during that period. There was no lapse
of time between the date of his arrest and the recovery
of the stolen property.”
34.
In the case on hand, the incident took place on
18.06.2014. Recovery of gold ornaments from Accused No.1
was on 22.08.2014. The time lag between the date of
commission of the offence and the date of recovery is not so
wide as to snap the link between recovery and commission of
offence. In this regard, it is relevant to refer to para No.15 of
the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
Ganesh Lal Vs. State of Rajasthan reported in (2002) 1
SCC 731, which is extracted hereunder:
“15. A review of several decisions of this Court, some of
which we have cited hereinabove, leads to the following
statement of law. Recovery of stolen property from the
possession of the accused enables a presumption as to
commission of offence other than theft or dacoity being
drawn against the accused so as to hold him a
perpetrator of such other offences on the following tests
being
satisfied:
(i)
the
offence
of
criminal
misappropriation, theft or dacoity relating to the articles
recovered from the possession of the accused and such
other offences can reasonably be held to have been
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
committed as an integral part of the same transaction;
(ii) the time-lag between the date of commission of the
offence and the date of recovery of articles from the
accused is not so wide as to snap the link between
recovery and commission of the offence; (iii) availability
of
some
piece
of
incriminating
evidence
or
circumstance, other than mere recovery of the articles,
connecting the accused with such other offence; (iv)
caution on the part of the court to see that suspicion,
howsoever strong, does not take the place of proof. In
such cases the explanation offered by the accused for
his possession of the stolen property assumes
significance. Ordinarily the purpose of Section 313 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure is to afford the accused
an opportunity of offering an explanation of
incriminating circumstances appearing in prosecution
evidence against him. It is not necessary for the
accused to speak and explain. However, when the case
rests on circumstantial evidence the failure of the
accused to offer any satisfactory explanation for his
possession of the stolen property though not an
incriminating circumstance by itself would yet enable an
inference being raised against him because the fact
being in the exclusive knowledge of the accused it was
for him to have offered an explanation which he failed
to do. (See Earabhadrappa v. State of Karnataka para
13, Gulab Chand v. State of M.P. para 4.)”
35.
The findings recorded by the learned Sessions
Judge insofar as convicting accused No.1 for the offence
punishable under Sections 397 and 302 of IPC are therefore,
justified. However, we find that the evidence adduced by the
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
prosecution to record conviction against Accused Nos.2 to 4
is not sufficient.
36.
Hence, we proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
1. Criminal
Appeal
No.100365/2019
and
Criminal
Appeal No.100149/2020 are allowed;
2. The judgment dated 16.04.2019 and order on
sentence dated 20.04.2019 passed against accused
No.2 and 3 for the offence punishable under Section
120B, 397 and 302 read with 34 of IPC are set
aside; (Appeal filed by accused No.4 has been
dismissed as abated);
3. Accused No.2 and 3 are acquitted of the charges
leveled
against
them;
Their
bail
bonds
stand
cancelled.
4. Criminal Appeal No.100069/2021 is partly allowed;
5. The judgment dated 16.04.2019 and order on
sentence dated 20.04.2019 convicting accused No.1
for the offence punishable under Section 120B of
IPC is set aside;
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC-D:132-DB
CRL.A No. 100365 of 2019
C/W CRL.A No. 100149 of 2020
CRL.A No. 100069 of 2021
HC-KAR
6. The
conviction
and
sentence
passed
against
accused No.1 under Section 397 and 302 of IPC is
confirmed;
7. Accused No.1 shall surrender before the Trial Court
to undergo the sentence passed against him for the
aforementioned offences;
8. A copy of the judgment shall be forwarded to the
Trial Court.
SD/(MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
JUDGE
SD/(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
Kmv upto para 22
SH,
CT:PA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review