The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
20. In the result, the writ petition being WPA 23996 of 2025 is allowed.
21. Baruipur Police Station Case no. 1668 of 2025 dated 25th August, 2025 corresponding to G.R. Case no. 7168 of 2025 is quashed.
22. The petitioners be set at liberty at once and discharged from their bail bonds.
23. There shall however be no order as to costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APELLATE SIDE
The Hon‟ble JUSTICE SUVRA GHOSH
WPA 23996 of 2025
Goutam Chakraborty & Anr.
v/s.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the Petitioners:
Mr. Rajdeep Mazumder
Mr. Pritam Roy
Ms. Triparna Roy
For the State:
Mr. Santanu Kr. Mitra
Mr. Tapas Kr. Dey
Hearing concluded on:
08.01.2026
Judgment delivered on:
16.01.2026
SUVRA GHOSH, J. :1.
The petitioners have sought quashing of Baruipur Police Station Case no.
1668 of 2025 dated 25th August, 2025 corresponding to G.R. Case no.
7168 of 2025 primarily on the ground that the FIR does not make out the
offences alleged.
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that one Gour Biswas
lodged written complaint on 8th August, 2025 to the effect that the
accused persons therein assaulted one Rajib Biswas on 8th August, 2025
and 9th August, 2025 who succumbed to the injuries. A specific case was
registered and it was claimed that the victim belonged to a particular
political dispensation. It is alleged that the first petitioner held a press
conference and exhibited a distorted version of the responsibility of the
police in such political murder which resulted in severe resentment and
confusion in the minds of people and there was every possibility of serious
political clash in the area. A suo moto complaint was lodged by the police
on 25th August, 2025 against the petitioners under Sections 196(1)
(a)/61(2)/352/353(2)/351(2)/3(5) of the BNS. The petitioners are in fact
some of the whistle blowers who tried to raise their voice against the
heinous murder and have been implicated falsely. The petitioners seek
protection of their personal liberty and quashing of the FIR lodged against
them.
3.
Learned counsel has placed reliance on the authorities in Patricia
Mukhim v/s State of Meghalaya and Others reported in (2021) 15
Supreme Court Cases 35, Bilal Ahmed Kaloo v/s. State of Andhra
Pradesh reported in (1997) 7 Supreme Court Cases 431, State of Haryana
v/s. Bhajan Lal reported in AIR 1992 Supreme Court 604, E.P. Royappa
v/s. State of Tamil Nadu reported in AIR 1974 Supreme Court 555 and
Maneka Gandhi v/s Raj Narain reported in AIR 1975 Supreme Court
2299 in support of his contention.
4.
Vehemently opposing the prayer of the petitioners and placing reliance on
the authority in M/s. Neeharika Infrastructure Private Limited v/s. State
of Maharashtra reported in AIR 2021 Supreme Court 1918, learned
counsel for the State has submitted that due to motivated and wilful
intent of the petitioners, there was severe resentment and confusion in
the minds of the people and there was every possibility of severe political
clash for which a suo moto complaint was lodged by the police in order to
maintain peace and tranquillity in the locality. The allegations in the FIR
have been substantiated during investigation which is in progress.
Investigation should be allowed to continue since no exceptional case has
been made out for quashing the same.
5.
I have considered the rival contention of the parties and material on
record.
6.
It is trite law that though the power of the High Court for quashing FIR or
charge sheet is very wide, it should be exercised with great caution so as
not to stifle a legitimate prosecution. The High Court should normally
refrain from giving a prima facie decision in a case where the entire facts
are incomplete and hazy. The allegations of malafide are of no
consequence and cannot by themselves be the basis for quashing the
proceedings.
7.
In dealing with the issue of quashing of an FIR, the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court, in the authority in M/s. Neeharika Infrastructure (supra) has laid
down the following parameters:“In view of the above and for the reasons stated
above, our final conclusions on the principal/core issue, whether the High
Court would be justified in passing an interim order of stay of
investigation and/or “no coercive steps to be adopted”, during the
pendency of the quashing petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. and/or
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India and in what circumstances
and whether the High Court would be justified in passing the order of not
to arrest the accused or “no coercive steps to be adopted” during the
investigation or till the final report/charge sheet is filed under Section 173
Cr.P.C., while dismissing/disposing of/not entertaining/not quashing the
criminal proceedings/complaint/FIR in exercise of powers under Section
482 Cr.P.C. and/or under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, our
final conclusions are as under:
i. Police has the statutory right and duty under the relevant
provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure contained in
Chapter XIV of the Code to investigate into a cognizable
offence;
ii. Courts would not thwart any investigation into the cognizable
offences;
iii. It is only in cases where no cognizable offence or offence of any
kind is disclosed in the first information report that the Court
will not permit an investigation to go on;
iv. The power of quashing should be exercised sparingly with
circumspection, as it has been observed, in the „rarest of rare
cases (not to be confused with the formation in the context of
death penalty).
v. While examining an FIR/complaint, quashing of which is
sought, the Court cannot embark upon an enquiry as to the
reliability or genuineness or otherwise of the allegations made
in the FIR/complaint;
vi. Criminal proceedings ought not be scuttled at the initial stage;
vii. Quashing of a complaint/FIR should be an exception rather
than an ordinary rule;
viii. Ordinarily,
the
Courts
are
barred
from
usurping
the
jurisdiction of the police, since the two organs of the State
operate in two specific spheres of activities and one ought not
to tread over the other sphere;
ix. The
functions
of
the
judiciary
and
the
police
are
complementary, not overlapping;
x. Save in exceptional cases where non-interference would result
in miscarriage of justice, the Court and the judicial process
should not interfere at the stage of investigation of offences;
xi. Extraordinary and inherent powers of the Court do not confer
an arbitrary jurisdiction on the Court to act according to its
whims or caprice;
xii. The first information report is not an encyclopaedia which
must disclose all facts and details relating to the offence
reported. Therefore, when the investigation by the police is in
progress, the Court should not go into the merits of the
allegations in the FIR. Police must be permitted to complete the
investigation. It would be premature to pronounce the
conclusion based on hazy facts that the complaint/FIR does
not deserve to be investigated or that it amounts to abuse of
process of law. After investigation, if the investigating officer
finds that there is no substance in the application made by the
complainant, the investigating officer may file an appropriate
report/summary before the learned Magistrate which may be
considered by the learned Magistrate in accordance with the
known procedure;
xiii. The power under Section 482 Cr.P.C. is very wide, but
conferment of wide power requires the Court to be more
cautious.
It casts an onerous and more diligent duty on the Court;
8.
However, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court has laid down certain guidelines for
exercising such power, in the authority in State of Haryana and Others
(supra). The first guideline is relevant and is reproduced hereunder:i. Where
the
allegations
made
in
the
First
Information Report or the complaint, even if
they are taken at their face value and accepted
in their entirety do not prima facie constitute
any offence or make out a case against the
accused.
9.
The authority in Imran Pratapgadhi v/s. State of Gujarat and Another
reported in 2025 Supreme Court Cases OnLine Supreme Court 678
echoes the said observation and reiterates that there is no absolute rule
that when the investigation is at a nascent stage, the High Court cannot
exercise its jurisdiction to quash an offence. When the High Court, in the
given case, finds that no offence was made out on the face of it, to prevent
abuse of the process of law, it can always interfere even though the
investigation is at the nascent stage. It all depends on the facts and
circumstances of each case as well as the nature of the offence.
10. In order to arrive at a conclusion as to whether investigation against the
petitioners should be allowed to continue, each of the allegations made
against them in the FIR need to dealt with.
11. Section 196(1)(a)- (1) “Whoever(a) by words, either spoken or written, or by signs or by
visible
representations
or
through
electronic
communication or otherwise, promotes or attempts
to promote, on grounds of religion, race, place of
birth, residence, language, caste or community or
any
other
ground
whatsoever,
disharmony
or
feelings of enmity, hatred or ill-will between different
religious, racial, language or regional groups or
castes or communities; shall be punished with
imprisonment which may extend to three years, or
with fine, or with both”.
The FIR discloses that the first petitioner alleged that the police
administration and a political dispensation were responsible for the
murder and destruction of credible evidence. It does not speak about
promoting or attempting to promote disharmony or feelings of enmity,
hatred or ill-will between different religious, racial, language or regional
groups or castes or communities.
12. Section 61(2) deals with punishment for the offence of criminal
conspiracy. Criminal conspiracy is defined in Section 61(1) as hereunder:(1) “When two or more persons agree with the common
object to do, or cause to be done-
a) an illegal act; or
b)
an act which is not illegal by illegal means,
such an agreement is designated a criminal
conspiracy.”
Herein, the petitioners were allegedly addressing a press conference and
holding the police and a political party responsible for the murder. Such
act of the petitioners does not constitute criminal conspiracy.
13. Section 352 of the BNS deals with intentional insult with intent to
provoke breach of peace. Deliberation of the petitioners in the press
conference does not amount to intentional insult or provocation and there
was in fact no breach of peace or tranquillity following such deliberation.
14. Section 353(2) of the BNS reads as follows:“Whoever makes, publishes or circulates any statement or
report containing false information, rumour or alarming news, including
through electronic means, with intent to create or promote, or which is
likely to create or promote, on grounds of religion, race, place of birth,
residence, language, caste or community or any other ground whatsoever,
feelings of enmity, hatred or ill will between different religious, racial,
language or regional groups or castes or communities shall be punished
with imprisonment which may extend to three years, or with fine, or with
both.”
The statement made by the petitioners as stated in the FIR does not
appear to contain false information, rumour or alarming news.
15. Section 351 deals with criminal intimidation. The FIR does not speak of
any criminal intimidation at the behest of the petitioners.
16. Section 3(5) deals with criminal act done by several persons in
furtherance of their common intention.
17. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court, in the authority in Patricia Mukhim (supra)
has dealt with Section 153A and Section 505(1)(c) of the Indian Penal
Code corresponding to Sections 196(1)(a) and 353(2) of the BNS. The
Hon‟ble Court has observed that the matter complained of must be read
as a whole and strongly worded and isolated passages cannot be relied
upon for proving the charge, nor can a sentence here and a sentence
there be taken and connected by a meticulous process of inferential
reasoning. The Hon‟ble Court has referred to the authority in Bilal Ahmed
Kaloo (supra) wherein mens rea has been held to be a necessary
ingredient for the offence. The Hon‟ble Court has observed that it is
necessary that at least two groups/castes/communities should be
involved. Merely inciting the feelings of one community or group cannot
attract such offences.
18. In the case in hand, the petitioners have expressed their opinion with
regard to the incident of murder at the press conference which did not
result in any agitation or unrest among the public. There was only
apprehension of political clash in the complaint/FIR and no provocation
of breach of peace by the petitioners.
19. Upon consideration of the entire material on record, this Court is of the
view that the case falls within the first parameter laid down in the
authority in the State of Haryana and Others (supra). The allegations in
the FIR, taken at their face value, do not constitute any of the offences
alleged and allowing the proceedings to continue shall be an abuse of the
process of law.
20. In the result, the writ petition being WPA 23996 of 2025 is allowed.
21. Baruipur Police Station Case no. 1668 of 2025 dated 25th August, 2025
corresponding to G.R. Case no. 7168 of 2025 is quashed.
22. The petitioners be set at liberty at once and discharged from their bail
bonds.
23. There shall however be no order as to costs.
24. All parties shall act on the server copy of this judgment duly downloaded
from the official website of this Court.
25. Urgent certified website copies of this judgment, if applied for, be supplied
to the parties expeditiously on compliance with the usual formalities.
(Suvra Ghosh, J)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review