Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 6TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 2925 OF 2025
BETWEEN:
Digitally signed
by AL BHAGYA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
1.
GOPALKRISHNA S. BAKALE
S/O. SUNDERLALBAKALE
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
RESIDING AT NO. 16/1
4TH FLOOR, 9TH CROSS ROAD
OPP WILSON GARDEN CLUB
WILSON GARDEN, BANGALORE - 560 027.
2.
VENKATESH S. BAKALE
S/O. SUNDERLALBAKALE
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
RESIDING AT NO.16/1
GROUND FLOOR, 9TH CROSS ROAD
OPP WILSON GARDEN CLUB
WILSON GARDEN, BANGALORE - 560 027.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. GUNASHEKAR .S, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
SRI GANAPATHI C. BAKALE
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS
R/AT NO. 16/1, NEW NO.36/2
9TH CROSS, WILSON GARDEN
BENGALURU -560 027.
ALSO R/AT NO.56, J K ROAD
VINAYAKANAGAR, SHANTHINAGAR
BENGALURU-560 030.
-2NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.
SRI. PRAMOD JAIN
S/O. MANAK CHAND JAIN
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS
R/AT NO.A 205, WILSON MANOR APARTMENT
13TH CROSS, WILSON GARDEN
BANGALORE - 560 030.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. GAJENDRA .S, ADVOCATE)
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SEC.96 OF CPC., AGAINST
THE ORDER DATED 8.12.2025 PASSED ON IA NO.1 IN EX
NO.2401/2024 ON THE FILE OF C/C LVI ADDITIONAL CITY
CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE, BENGALURU., ALLOWING THE IA
NO.1 BY THE DHR UNDER SEC.151 OF CPC.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
ORAL JUDGMENT
The captioned appeal is filed by the appellants Objectors assailing the impugned order dated 08.12.2025
passed in Ex.No.2401/2024 by the LVI Additional City Civil
and
Sessions
Judge,
Bengaluru
(CCH-57)
on
the
application tendered by the Objectors.
2. Though an objection was raised by the Office with
regard to the maintainability of the appeal and though the
specific statutory provision was not indicated in the
-3NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
objection
tendered
objections
filed
before
to
the
the
Executing
main
Court,
execution
the
petition
unmistakably satisfy the essential ingredients of Order XXI
Rule
of
the
Code
of
Civil
Procedure,
1908.
Consequently, the impugned order answers the description
of a decree within the meaning of the Code, and the
appeal is therefore maintainable before this Court.
3. Respondent No.1 – the Decree Holder instituted a
suit in O.S.No.3159/2021 against respondent No.2 – the
original Judgment Debtor seeking ejectment. The suit was
founded on the assertion that the lease in favour of
respondent No.2 had been terminated and that the Decree
Holder was entitled to recover possession of the suit
schedule property. During the trial, the present appellant
No.1 – Objector was examined on behalf of respondent
No.2–Tenant as D.W.2.
4. Upon appreciation of the evidence of the Decree
Holder, the Judgment Debtor and D.W.2, the Trial Court
-4NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
decreed the suit recording a categorical finding that
respondent No.2 was inducted as a tenant by respondent
No.1. Accordingly, respondent No.2 was directed to quit
and
deliver
vacant
possession
of
the
suit
schedule
property to respondent No.1 within a period of four
months.
5.
The said judgment and decree was carried in
appeal by respondent No.2–Tenant in RFA No.2637/2024.
This Court, by judgment and decree dated 21.08.2025,
dismissed the appeal and affirmed the decree of eviction.
6. During the pendency of the execution proceedings,
the present appellant No.1, who had earlier deposed as
D.W.2 in the suit, filed an application objecting to the
execution. It was asserted that though the suit schedule
property stands in the name of respondent No.1 – Decree
Holder, the sale consideration was paid by the appellants–
Objectors that the old structure was demolished and a new
building was constructed in the year 2014 by investing
-5NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
substantial amounts and that the property is, therefore, a
joint family ancestral property. It was further contended
that a partition suit in O.S.No.74/2021 is pending in
respect of the said property and therefore, respondent
No.1 is not entitled to take possession. The Objectors also
claimed that they had secured possession from respondent
No.2–Tenant in the year 2021 and being in actual physical
possession, the decree passed in O.S.No.3159/2021 is
inexecutable. On these grounds, dismissal of the execution
petition was sought. The Executing Court, however,
rejected the said application.
7.
Objectors
Learned counsel appearing for the appellants–
reiterating
the
grounds
urged
vehemently
contended that the Executing Court has acted contrary to
the scheme envisaged under Order XXI Rule 97 CPC by
summarily rejecting the objections without conducting an
enquiry. It was urged that the procedure adopted is
fundamentally flawed, resulting in grave miscarriage of
justice, inasmuch as the Objectors were denied an
-6NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
opportunity to substantiate their independent right, title
and interest in the suit schedule property. In support of
the said contention, reliance was placed on the following
decisions:
(i) V.V. Nageswara Rao, Hyderabad v.
State of Andhra Pradesh, in Criminal Appeal
No.324/2017; and
(ii) Paramound Industries v. C.M. Malliga,
decided on 29.06.1990.
8.
Per-contra,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
respondent No.1 – Decree Holder drawing attention to the
evidence
of
appellant
No.1
examined
as
D.W.2
in
O.S. No.3159/2021 stoutly opposed the appeal. Referring
to paragraph No.12 of the judgment in the ejectment suit,
it was submitted that D.W.1 had categorically admitted the
absence of any documentary material to show that he was
inducted as a tenant by the present Objectors. Learned
counsel further relied upon the admissions elicited in the
cross-examination of appellant No.1 as D.W.2, wherein it
-7NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
was unequivocally admitted that the father of respondent
No.1 – namely, Chandrakanth Bakale had executed a
Release Deed in the year 1969 in respect of the joint
family properties and had separated from the family.
It was, therefore, contended that the suit schedule
property is the self-acquired property of respondent No.1
and that the mere pendency of a partition suit cannot be a
valid
ground
to
entertain
objections
in
execution
proceedings.
9.
In the light of the rival submissions urged and
upon perusal of the material on record, the following
points arise for consideration:
i)
Whether
the
Executing
Court
was
justified in summarily rejecting the Objectors’
application
without
affording
them
an
opportunity to lead evidence as contemplated
under Order XXI Rule 97 CPC?
-8NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
ii) Whether the impugned order passed by
the Executing Court suffers from perversity and
warrants interference at the hands of this
Court?
Findings on Point Nos.1 and 2;
10.
Before this Court adverts to the claim of the
appellants - Objectors, this Court deems it fit to extract
para No.12 of the judgment rendered by the Trial Court in
O.S.No.3159/2021. Para No.12 is extracted, which reads
as under;
"12.
On
perusing
the
certified
copy
of
the
registered sale deed dated 23.08.2010 it reveal that the
said sale deed has been executed in the name of plaintiff
with
respect
to
the
Sri.N.Lakshminarayana.
suit
It
schedule
is
recited
property
in
the
by
said
document that the plaintiff has paid the consideration
amount of Rs.24,00,000/ by way of cheques and pay
orders. This show that the entire amount is paid by the
plaintiff.
Ex.P.2
is
the
rectification
deed
dated
21.09.2010 executed in favour of plaintiff. Ex.P.3 is the
khata certificate and Ex.P.4 is the khata extract show
that the khata of the suit schedule property is standing in
the name of plaintiff. Ex.P.5 is the tax paid receipt and it
-9NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
show that the tax has been paid by the plaintiff. Though,
the defendant has contended that D.W.2 Gopal Krishna
Bakle is the owner of the suit schedule property, no
document is produced by him to prove the same. Even
D.W.2 has not produced any document to prove his
ownership over the suit schedule property. Though,
D.W.1 has got marked the certified copy of the plaint and
order sheet in O.S.No.24/2021 marked as Ex.D.12 and
13, the said documents will not in any way help the
defendant to prove his contention. The said documents
reveal that a suit for partition has been filed against the
plaintiff and others by D.W.2 and others and it is
pending. The decree is not yet passed in favour of
D.W.2.
Further,
D.W.1
has
stated
in
his
cross
examination at page 7 that he has not produced any
documents to show that D.W.2 Gopal Krishna Bakle is
the owner of the suit schedule property. He has also
admitted that he has not produced any document to
show that he was the tenant under Gopal Krishna Bakle.
At page 8 of his cross examination he has admitted that
in the rental agreement it is shown that the plaintiff is
the owner of the suit schedule property. He has further
stated that at the time of inducting him as a tenant,
D.W.2 Gopal Krishna Bakle was present and even at the
time of payment of security deposit he was present.
Further, D.W.2 has admitted in his cross examination
that the father of the plaintiff by name Chandrakanth
Bakle has executed a release deed with respect to the
joint family properties in the year 1969. In his cross
examination at page 6, D.W.2 has admitted the khata
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
extract pertaining to the suit schedule property is
standing in the name of plaintiff. He has further admitted
that
the
plaintiff
had
borrowed
loan
from
Textile
Cooperative bank with respect to the suit schedule
property. He has also admitted that by borrowing loan,
the plaintiff has constructed the building in the suit
schedule property. At page 8 of his cross examination he
has very clearly admitted that he has not produced any
documents to show that he is the owner of the suit
schedule property. Further, D.W.2 has also admitted in
his cross examination that the plaintiff has filed the suit
in O.S.No.529/2021 against him for eviction. As such,
the documents marked as Ex.P.1 to 5 and also the
admission of D.W.1 and 2 that the property is standing in
the name of plaintiff clearly show that the plaintiff is the
owner of the suit schedule property. Unless and until the
suit in O.S.No.24/2021 is decreed in favour of D.W.2, it
cannot be said that he has right over the suit schedule
property and he is the owner of the suit schedule
property. The plaintiff has placed sufficient materials to
prove that he is the owner of the suit schedule property.
Though, the defendant has contended that D.W.2 Gopal
Krishna Bakle is the owner of the suit schedule property
and he had leased the same to him on monthly rent of
Rs.13,000/ p.m by receiving Rs.1,50,000/, there is no
evidence to believe the same."
(emphasis supplied by me)
11. On a bare reading of the deposition, it is evident
that he has further deposed that at the time of inducting
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
him as a tenant, D.W.2 – Gopal Krishna Bakle was present
and that D.W.2 was also present when the security deposit
was paid. This evidence clearly establishes that the
induction of the tenant was not a unilateral act, but was
done openly and with the knowledge and participation of
D.W.2.
12. Further, in the course of his cross-examination,
D.W.2 has categorically admitted that the father of the
plaintiff, namely Chandrakanth Bakle, had executed a
release deed in respect of the joint family properties as far
back as in the year 1969. This admission is of considerable
significance, as it demolishes any claim of subsisting joint
family
rights
over
the
suit
schedule
property
and
reinforces the plaintiff’s independent and exclusive title.
13.
More importantly, in the cross-examination of
D.W.2, he has unequivocally admitted that the khata
extract pertaining to the suit schedule property stands in
the name of the plaintiff. He has further admitted that the
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
plaintiff had availed a loan from the Textile Co-operative
Bank by offering the suit schedule property as security. He
has also admitted that out of the said loan, the plaintiff
has constructed the building on the suit schedule property.
These admissions not only affirm the plaintiff’s ownership
and dominion over the suit schedule property but also
demonstrate that the plaintiff has exercised all incidents of
ownership, including raising construction by investing his
own funds.
14.
In view of the aforesaid clear, categorical and
unambiguous admissions made by D.W.2, coupled with
the evidence regarding induction of the tenant in his
presence, the existence of the jural relationship of landlord
and tenant between respondent No.1 and respondent No.2
stands
admitted.
Consequently,
the
appellants/cross-
objectors are estopped from disputing the said jural
relationship and any contention to the contrary is wholly
untenable and liable to be rejected.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
15. On a closer scrutiny of the findings recorded by
the Trial Court, particularly at paragraph No.12 of the
judgment
in
O.S.No.3159/2021,
what
clearly
and
unequivocally emerges is that the ejectment suit instituted
by respondent No.1 – Decree Holder culminated in a
categorical finding that respondent No.2 was inducted as a
tenant exclusively by respondent No.1. The Trial Court,
upon
an
elaborate
appreciation
of
the
oral
and
documentary evidence, more particularly, the admissions
elicited in the cross-examination of appellant No.1, who
was examined as D.W.2 and on consideration of Exs.P.1 to
P.5, has recorded a clear conclusion that the suit schedule
property stands exclusively in the name of respondent
No.1 as absolute owner. The Trial Court has further
observed that unless appellant No.1 establishes his alleged
right, title or interest in the pending partition suit, the
claim set up by the Objectors cannot be examined or
accepted in collateral proceedings.
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
16. The Trial Court has further held that respondent
No.1 – Decree Holder successfully substantiated the jural
relationship of landlord and tenant by establishing that
respondent No.2 was inducted as a tenant on a monthly
rent of Rs.13,000/- after receipt of a security deposit of
Rs.1,50,000/-.
On
such
findings,
the
suit
in
O.S. No.3159/2021 was decreed directing respondent
No.2–Tenant to quit and deliver vacant possession of the
suit schedule property. The said judgment and decree has
attained finality, having been affirmed by this Court in RFA
No.2637/2024.
17. The present contention urged by the appellants–
Objectors that they were not parties to the ejectment suit
and therefore, they are not bound by the decree is wholly
misconceived. The record unmistakably discloses that
appellant No.1 entered the witness box as D.W.2 in
support of respondent No.2–Tenant thereby demonstrating
complete awareness of the eviction proceedings initiated
by
respondent
No.1.
These
vital
admissions
and
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
circumstances have been duly noticed and relied upon by
the Trial Court.
18. In the backdrop of these significant findings, the
crucial question that arises for consideration is whether
the Executing Court was justified in declining to relegate
the parties to a full-fledged enquiry merely on the filing of
objections by the Objectors under Order XXI Rule 97 CPC.
It is well settled by a catena of decisions that the mere
filing of an application under Rule 97 does not ipso facto
mandate the Executing Court to treat such objections as a
suit and embark upon a detailed trial. Only in cases where
the Objector sets up an independent and competing title,
supported
by
prima
facie
documentary
material
demonstrating exclusive possession or a superior right,
does the obligation arise on the Executing Court to
conduct an adjudication by permitting parties to lead
evidence.
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
19.
In the case on hand, a careful reading of the
objections filed by the appellants–Objectors reveals that
their claim is founded solely on the assertion that the suit
schedule property is joint family ancestral property and
that
a
partition
suit
in
O.S.No.74/2021
is
pending
adjudication. On this premise, it is contended that the
eviction
decree
unenforceable.
passed
This
in
contention
O.S.No.3159/2021
is
not
only
is
legally
untenable but also fundamentally misconceived. Even
assuming
that
the
Objectors
ultimately
succeed
in
establishing their claim in the partition suit, delivery of
possession to the Decree Holder pursuant to a valid and
final eviction decree would not prejudice the rights of the
Objectors, as such, possession would necessarily remain
subject to the outcome of the partition proceedings.
20.
The burden squarely lies on the Objectors to
establish that the suit schedule property is joint family
ancestral property notwithstanding the registered sale
deed standing in the name of respondent No.1 – Decree
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
Holder. The allegations that the sale consideration was
paid by the Objectors and that substantial investments
were made by them in reconstructing the building raise
disputed questions of fact, which can be adjudicated only
in the pending partition suit. Significantly, the Objectors
have
not
produced
any
prima
facie
material
competing
before
the
title
deeds
or
Executing
Court
to
demonstrate a superior or independent right warranting a
full-fledged enquiry.
21.
Similarly,
respondent
No.1-decree
holder
is
equally entitled to take benefit of admissions elicited in
cross-examination of
DW- 2 in the partition suit bearing
O.S.No.3159/2021. In such circumstances, the Executing
Court was fully justified in summarily rejecting the
objections without relegating the parties to a protracted
trial.
22. Further, the plea of the Objectors that they had
secured possession of the suit schedule property in the
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
year 2021 stands in direct conflict with the findings
recorded
in
finality
upon
O.S.No.3159/2021,
affirmation
by
which
have
this
Court
attained
in
RFA
No.2637/2024. In view of the binding findings and the
admissions made by appellant No.1 during trial, the said
contention cannot be countenanced. It is also relevant to
note that in the pending partition suit in O.S. No.74/2021,
respondent No.1 – Decree Holder is restrained from
alienating the property thereby ensuring preservation of
the subject matter. The rights of the Objectors are thus
adequately safeguarded and they are yet to substantiate
their claim that the property forms part of the joint family
estate.
23.
In the light of the foregoing discussion, this
Court finds that the impugned order does not suffer from
any illegality or perversity warranting interference. The
judgments relied upon by the learned counsel for the
appellants are clearly distinguishable on facts and have no
application to the present case. Accordingly, Point No.1 is
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC:398
RFA No. 2925 of 2025
HC-KAR
answered in the Affirmative and Point No.2 is answered in
the Negative.
Hence, this Court proceeds to pass the
following;
ORDER
(i) The appeal is devoid of merit and is
accordingly dismissed.
(ii) It is, however, clarified that this order
shall not preclude or prejudice the appellants–
Objectors
from
establishing
their
alleged
rights, title and interest in the suit schedule
property in the pending partition suit in
O.S.No.74/2021 in accordance with law.
Sd/(SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM)
JUDGE
NBM
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 20
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review