Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC010205542019
2026:GAU-AS:9056
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6307/2019
GOPAL CHANDRA DAS
S/O. LT. RAJEN CHANDRA DAS, R/O. HOUSE NO.16, CHANDRA
CHOUDHURY PATH, BYE LANE RUDRAPUR, BHETAPARA, GUWAHATI, P.O.
BELTOLA, DIST. KAMRUP (M), ASSAM, PIN-781028.
VERSUS
THE ASSAM GRAMIN VIKASH BANK AND ANR.
HAVING ITS HEAD OFFICE AT BHANGAGARH, G.S. ROAD, GUWAHATI,
DIST. KAMRUP (M), ASSAM, PIN-781005, REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN.
2:THE CHAIRMAN
ASSAM GRAMIN VIKASH BANK
SITUATED AT BHANGAGARH
G.S. ROAD
GUWAHATI
DIST. KAMRUP (M)
ASSAM
PIN-781005
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. A SARMA, MR E SHITIRI,MR A DAS
Advocate for the Respondent : MR SISHIR DUTTA, MR. S DUTTA,MS M BORCHETIYA
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 22-06-2026
Page No.# 2/11
Heard Mr. A. Sarma, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. S. Dutta,
learned Senior counsel, assisted by Ms. S. Musahary, learned counsel for the respondent
Bank.
2.
The present writ petition was heard at length on 27-05-2026 and was directed to
be listed today for delivery of the order.
3.
The petitioner, by instituting the present writ petition, primarily seeks a direction to
the respondent authorities to release his Gratuity, which has been withheld following his
discharge from service by way of imposition of a penalty of Compulsory Retirement vide
order dated 23-12-2015.
4.
As projected in the writ petition, a disciplinary proceeding was instituted against
the petitioner, culminating in the order dated 23-12-2015, whereby the penalty of
Compulsory Retirement was imposed. Upon his discharge from service, the petitioner
approached the respondent authorities for the release of his pension and other
pensionary benefits, including gratuity. Aggrieved by the non-release of these benefits,
the petitioner has approached this Court.
5.
Mr. A. Sarma, learned counsel for the petitioner, submitted at the outset that the
petitioner is not challenging the penalty of Compulsory Retirement in the present
proceeding, rather, the petitioner claims service benefits that he remains legally entitled to
receive despite the imposition of the said penalty. Mr. Sarma submitted that the petitioner
is entitled to receive gratuity alongside other retirement benefits, such as leave
encashment and the Group Savings Linked Insurance (GSLI) pension.
5.1.
Mr. Sarma submits that since the petitioner is already in receipt of his regular
Page No.# 3/11
pension, that specific prayer is not pressed. Mr. Sarma fairly conceded that no material
has been brought on record regarding the claims for leave encashment and GSLI.
Accordingly, he prayed that the petitioner be granted liberty to approach the respondent
authorities by filing a fresh application seeking the release of those two benefits.
Accordingly, he submits that the scope of the present writ petition be confined solely to
the petitioner's claim for the release of Gratuity.
5.2.
Mr. Sarma submitted that the provision governing the release of Gratuity is found
under Regulation 72 of the Assam Gramin Vikash Bank (Officers and Employees) Service
Regulations, 2010. He submitted that every officer or employee is eligible for gratuity
upon the termination of service in any manner, except by way of punishment, provided
they have completed 10 years of service. Mr. Sarma by referring to the proviso to SubRegulation (2) of Regulation 72 has submitted that the same stipulates that an
employee's gratuity cannot be forfeited upon dismissal for misconduct unless such
misconduct has caused a quantifiable financial loss to the Bank, and even then, forfeiture
is restricted only to the extent of that loss.
5.3
Mr. Sarma submitted that because gratuity is a beneficial financial provision for
retirees, it must be released to the petitioner, especially since no financial loss to the Bank
was ever quantified in the disciplinary proceedings concluded against the petitioner. He
argued that the beneficial rules applicable to an "employee" should similarly extend to the
petitioner, who holds the rank of an "officer."
5.4.
By referring to the provisions of Regulation 44 of the Assam Gramin Vikash Bank
(Employees' Pension) Regulations, 2018, Mr. Sarma submitted that the Rules governing
Page No.# 4/11
the release of provisional pension draws no distinction between an employee and an
officer. He maintained that the term "employee" in Sub-Regulation (1) of Regulation 44 is
used generically to describe all personnel in the service of the Bank. Under SubRegulation (2) of Regulation 44, Gratuity is to be paid upon the conclusion of
proceedings, subject to adjustments for any recoveries. Therefore, he argued that the
term "employee" in the proviso to Regulation 72(2) of the 2010 Regulations must be read
in harmony with Regulation 44 of the 2018 Regulations to give it a wider and more
inclusive meaning.
5.5.
In support of his contentions, Mr. Sarma relied upon the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Shyam Lal Vs. State of U.P. & Ors. reported in (1954) 1 SCC 572.
He also cited a decision of a Coordinate Bench of this Court in Boloram Bordoloi Vs.
Lakhimi Gaolia Bank (Order dated 03-04-2009 in W.P.(C) No. 219/2006), which
was subsequently upheld by the Division Bench in W.A. No. 361/2008 and by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 4394/2010 . Relying on Shyam Lal
(Supra), Mr. Sarma argued that a penalty of Compulsory Retirement cannot be equated
to a penalty of dismissal or removal from service, and thus cannot act as an absolute bar
to the entitlement of gratuity and retirement benefits.
6.
Per contra, Mr. S. Dutta, learned Senior counsel appearing for the respondent
Bank, referred to the definitions under Regulation 2 of the Assam Gramin Vikash Bank
(Officers and Employees) Service Regulations, 2010, to demonstrate that the terms
"employee" and "officer" carry distinct legal meaning.
6.1.
Mr. Dutta submitted that while both Officers and Employees are generally eligible
Page No.# 5/11
for gratuity under Regulation 72(2), an officer whose services are terminated by way of a
penalty, is expressly excluded from such eligibility. He emphasized that the proviso to
Sub-Regulation (2) of Regulation 72 applies strictly to an "employee" and cannot be
stretched to cover an "officer."
6.2.
Mr. Dutta further pointed out that the petitioner has not claimed gratuity under the
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, but has based his claim on Regulation 72 of the 2010
Regulations; hence, the 2010 Regulations must strictly govern the field. It is further
submitted that as the penalty of compulsory retirement severed the employer-employee
relationship by way of punishment, the disqualification clause under Regulation 72(2)(e),
is squarely attracted in the case of the petitioner.
6.3.
In support of his submissions, Mr. Dutta relied upon the Division Bench decision of
this Court in United Bank of India Vs. Sujoy Kr. Roy (W.A. No. 59/2015, decided
on 26-05-2016), as well as the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s ruling in P. Rajan Sandhi Vs.
UoI & Ors. reported in (2010) 10 SCC 338.
6.4.
Mr. Dutta, with regard to the submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner
that the term ‘employee’ as finding mention in the provisions of Regulation 44 of the
Pension Regulation of 2018 must be given an inclusive meaning, submits that the term
‘employee’ cannot be given a meaning contrary to the 2010 Regulations. He noted that
while ‘officer’ is not explicitly defined within the 2018 Pension Regulations, Sub-Regulation
(2) of Regulation 2 of the 2018 Regulations explicitly mandates that any terms undefined,
therein, but defined in the 2010 Regulations shall carry the meanings assigned to them
under the 2010 Regulations. Mr. Dutta further submits that the provisions of Regulation
Page No.# 6/11
44 of the Pension Regulations of 2018, applies in case of an employee, who retires from
his services during the pendency of a departmental or judicial proceedings instituted
against him and/ or continued. He submits that the provisions of Sub-Regulation (2) of
Regulation 44 of the said regulations mandates the manner in which the Gratuity of an
employee, against whom a departmental enquiry or judicial proceeding is pending on the
date of his superannuation is to be regulated. He submits that the manner in which a
Gratuity to such employee is to be released, upon conclusion of the departmental
proceeding or judicial proceeding instituted against him, would be governed by the
provisions of Regulation 72 of the Regulation of 2010.
6.5.
Mr. Dutta further submitted that the reliance on Shyam Lal (Supra) and
Boloram Bordoloi (Supra) is misplaced, as the Compulsory Retirement in Shyam Lal
(Supra) was not imposed as a disciplinary penalty but as a retirement upon the
completion of 25 years of service based on administrative suitability.
7.
I have heard the learned counsel for the respective parties and meticulously
perused the materials available on record.
8.
The foundational facts are not disputed. Following the imposition of the penalty of
compulsory retirement, a clear cessation of the employer-employee relationship occurred
between the petitioner and the respondent Bank. An employee or officer of the Bank is
entitled to receive gratuity either under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, or under
Regulation 72 of the 2010 Regulations. Since the petitioner has confined his claim to the
framework of the 2010 Regulations, his entitlements must be strictly interpreted through
the lens of Regulation 72 of the said Regulations.
Page No.# 7/11
9.
For clarity, the relevant text of Regulation 72(1) and 72(2) of the 2010 Regulations
is reproduced below:
“72. Gratuity. - (1) An officer or employee shall be eligible for payment of
gratuity either as per the provisions of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (39 of
1972) or as per sub-regulation (2), whichever is higher.
(2) Every officer or employee shall be eligible for gratuity on, (a) retirement,
(b) death,
(c) disablement rendering him unfit for further service as certified by
a medical officer approved by the Bank, or
(d) resignation after completing 10 years of continuous service, or
(e) termination of service in any other way except by way of
punishment after completion of 10 years of service:
Provided that in respect of an employee there shall be no forfeiture of
gratuity for dismissal on account of misconduct except in cases where such
misconduct causes financial loss to the bank and in that case to that extent only.”
10.
A plain reading of Sub-Regulation (2) mandates the precise contingencies under
which an officer or employee qualifies for gratuity. Under clause (e), termination of
service qualifies an individual for gratuity only if it is brought about "in any other way
except by way of punishment". Because the petitioner’s service was terminated as a direct
consequence of a disciplinary penalty, namely, compulsory retirement, he is statutorily
excluded from claiming gratuity under Regulation 72(2)(e) of the 2010 Regulations. The
petitioner’s attempt to circumvent this restriction by reading the proviso to Regulation
72(2) alongside Regulation 44(2) of the 2018 Pension Regulations does not alter this legal
reality.
11.
The proviso to Sub-Regulation (2) of Regulation 72 explicitly restricts its application
to an "employee" of the Bank, intentionally omitting any reference to an "officer".
Page No.# 8/11
Consequently, this Court is of the considered view that the protection against total
forfeiture outlined in the proviso cannot be extended to benefit the petitioner, who was an
officer.
12.
This Court would now consider the submissions advanced by the learned counsel
for the petitioner basing on the provision of Regulation 44 of the 2018 Pension
Regulations. The provisions, thereof, being relevant is extracted, here-in-below:
"44. Provisional Pension. — (1) An employee who has retired on attaining the
age of superannuation or otherwise and against whom any departmental or judicial
proceedings are instituted or where departmental proceedings are continued, a
provisional pension, equal to the maximum pension which would have been
admissible to him, would be allowed subject to adjustment against final retirement
benefits sanctioned to him, upon conclusion of the proceedings but no recovery
shall be made where the pension finally sanctioned is less than the provisional
pension or the pension is reduced or withheld, either permanently or for a specified
period.
(2) In cases referred to in sub-regulation (1), the gratuity shall be paid to the
employee and only on conclusion of the proceedings and any recoveries to be
made from an employee shall be adjusted against the amount of gratuity payable."
13.
Sub-Regulation (1) of Regulation 44 applies strictly to an employee against whom a
departmental or judicial proceeding at the time of retirement is pending. Sub-Regulation
(2) merely serves as a mechanism to govern the conditional disbursement and
adjustment of gratuity for individuals caught in the specific matrix of Sub-Regulation (1).
It clarifies that during the pendency of such proceedings, Gratuity is withheld and is
payable only upon final conclusion, subject to adjustments for verified financial recoveries.
14.
This provision cannot be interpreted as overriding or rewriting the substantive
eligibility criteria laid down in the 2010 Regulations. Notably, the heading of Regulation 44
explicitly refers to a "Provisional Pension" rather than a final entitlement. It operates as an
interim measure, analogous to Rule 22 of the Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969,
Page No.# 9/11
designed to preserve the status quo during an active inquiry. Therefore, the interpretation
advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioner with regard to the applicability of the
provisions of Regulation 44 of the Pension Regulations of 2018, to the case of the
petitioner cannot be sustained and stands rejected.
15.
Having drawn the said conclusions, this Court would now examine the decisions
relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioner. The learned counsel for the
petitioner had relied upon a decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Shyam
Lal (Supra) to project that on being compulsorily retired, the delinquent cannot be
prevented from receiving his pension and pensionary benefits. On a perusal of the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Shyam Lal (Supra), this Court
finds that the compulsory retirement as imposed upon the appellant, therein, was so
imposed after he had completed 25 years of service and it was found that it was in public
interest to dispense with his further services. The compulsory retirement, therein, was not
imposed as a manner of penalty. Accordingly, the said decision, in the considered view of
this Court cannot advance the case of the petitioner, herein. Further, the decisions of the
Coordinate Bench of this Court as well as the Division Bench and the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of Boloram Bordoloi (Supra) would also in the considered view of
this Court, not advance the case of the petitioner, herein. The Coordinate Bench in its
decision in the case of Boloram Bordoloi (Supra) had drawn its conclusions basing on
the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Shyam Lal (Supra) although
the petitioner, therein, was imposed with a penalty of compulsory retirement by way of a
penalty.
Accordingly, this Court is of the considered view that the decisions in the case
Page No.# 10/11
of Boloram Bordoloi (Supra) would also not advance the case of the petitioner, herein.
16.
At this stage, this Court would consider the decision of the Division Bench of this
Court in W.A. No. 59/2015. The Division Bench of this Court in the said case by
considering the provisions similar to the one as contained in the Regulation of 2010, had
held that the termination of service of the respondent, therein, having occasioned on
account of being imposed with a penalty of dismissal from service, he would not be
entitled to receive gratuity in view of the Bar constituted under the provision of Regulation
46 of the Service Regulation of 1979 as applicable, therein. Accordingly, in the present
case also there being a bar for authorisation of gratuity to officers of the Bank whose
services were terminated by way of imposition of penalty, the petitioner would not be
entitled to receive gratuity in terms of the provision of Regulation 79 of the Regulations of
2010.
17.
The learned counsel for the petitioner having not pressed the prayer for issuance of
a direction upon the respondent authorities for release to the petitioner the amounts due
to him against leave encashment and GSLI, this Court provides that the petitioner would
be at liberty to approach the respondent authorities by way of filing an application
seeking release of the said two benefits. In the event of filing of any such application by
the petitioner, the respondent authorities shall consider the same on its merit and pass
appropriate order(s) as would be so deemed fit.
18.
In light of the foregoing conclusions, and subject to the liberty granted to the
petitioner to approach the respondent authorities with a formal application for the release
of leave encashment and GSLI benefits, the present writ petition stands dismissed.
Page No.# 11/11
19.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review