Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S/L 11
31.03.2026
Court No.04
B.K.N
W.P.S.T. 253 of 2025
Gopal Chakraborty
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Anjan Bhattacharya,
Ms. Anita Shaw
Ms. Seema Thakur
… for the Petitioner.
Mr. Tapan Kumar Mukherjee, Ld. AGP,
Mr. Pinaki Dhole,
… for the State Respondents.
1. Heard the learned advocate for the writ petitioner as well
as the learned AGP.
2. The admitted fact emerging from the record is a 12 days
deficiency in qualifying service of 10 years, requisite for
the purposes of grant of minimum pension under the
Death-cum-Retirement Benefit Rules, 1971 (hereinafter
referred to as DCRB Rules). Seeking condonation of such
deficiency the petitioner approached the authorities
pursuant to an order passed in the earlier O.A. No. 271 of
2025 filed by the writ petitioner.
3. The petitioner’s claim for such condonation in deficiency
is rejected by a reasoned order dated 10.10.2025 issued
under the Signature of the Additional Chief Secretary to
the Government of West Bengal in the Irrigation and
Waterways Department of the State Government. The
order dated 10.10.2025 was put to challenge by the writ
petitioner again before the West Bengal Administrative
Tribunal (for short Tribunal) in O.A. No. 604 of 2025
4. On account the Tribunal being non-functional for want
of any member, the petitioner having filed the Original
Application approached this Court alleging that he is left
remedy less in the circumstance. He has placed reliance
on decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
Roger Mathew –Vs.- South Indian Bank Limited
represented by its Chief Manager and Others
reported in (2020) 6 SCC 1. In the above noted facts
and circumstances, we proceeded to consider the claim.
5. The reasoned order dated 10.10.2025 is founded on a
consideration by the Additional Chief Secretary that
there is some bar in Rule 36 of the DCRB Rules in
granting such relaxation to the writ petitioner and since
interpretation
of
the
Rule
is
reserved
for
the
Government, he has rejected the representation filed by
the writ petitioner. An issue of law, therefore, emerges
whether Rule 36 provides any scope for relaxation or
condonation in the requisite qualifying service for grant
of minimum superannuation pension under the DCRB
Rules. Since the fact and the number of days of
deficiency is not in dispute, the parties have advanced
submissions with reference to the Rule 36.
6. The learned advocate for the writ petitioner in course of
his submissions has also relied upon a decision of a
coordinate Bench rendered in W.P.S.T. 20 of 2024 on
02.12.2024. The judgment was delivered in the case of
Tapan Kumar Mondal –Vs.- The State of West
Bengal & Ors. He submits that the judgment was
assailed by the State in SLP(Civil) Diary No. 12085 of
2025. The Hon’ble Apex Court was not inclined to
interfere with the judgment and the SLP was dismissed
by an order dated 09.04.2025. He submits that the
judgment in the case of Tapan Kumar Mondal
(supra) has considered the very same issue whether a
relaxation/condonation is permissible under Rule 36 of
the DCRB Rules insofar as superannuation pension is
concerned.
7. The learned AGP has opposed the submissions advanced
by the learned advocate for the writ petitioner. However,
he is not in a position to deny the submission regarding
judgment in the case of Tapan Kumar Mondal
(supra).
8. On consideration of the rival submissions we find that in
the case of Tapan Kumar Mondal (supra) there was a
shortfall of three months and ten days in the requisite
qualifying service for grant of minimum superannuation
pension. Whether Rule 36 provides or leaves any scope
for such condonation was considered by the coordinate
Bench. Similar arguments were considered which we
consider it apposite to reproduce in the present order:
“2. The learned Counsel for the petitioner submits
that the Tribunal has misdirected itself by relying
upon the order passed by the Chief Engineer in
consultation with the Finance Department. The
power of the Government to condone deficiency in
service is specified in Rule 36 of the DCRB Rules.
Since the petitioner has placed reliance on this Rule
we propose to reproduce the same herein, which
reads as follows:
“36. Power of Government to condone
deficiency in service – Upon any
condition which it may think fit to impose,
Government may condone a deficiency of
six months in the qualifying service of a
Government servant.
Note – The deficiency should not be
condoned with a view to make up the
minimum prescribed qualifying service for
the purpose of death gratuity or family
pension. In other cases power should be
restricted to Government servant drawing
pay not exceeding Rs.425/- per month at
the time of retirement on invalid or
compensation pension.”
3. Referring to the provision, it is submitted that
the Rule contemplates condoning the deficiency in
qualifying service of a Government servant up to
six months. The exceptions are contained in the
note below the Rule. The petitioner’s case does not
come within any of the exceptions curbed out in the
note below of the Rule 36 of DCRB Rules and
therefore, the decision of the Chief Engineer, as
affirmed by the Tribunal is unsustainable.
4. The petitioner’s case is neither a claim for
compensation pension, nor invalid pension. It is a
claim for a pension simpliciter and therefore the
note appended below Rule 36 will have no
application in the case of the petitioner. It is
submitted that rejection of a claim under similar
circumstance of one Uday Kumar Pore was
considered by this Court in the writ proceeding
arising out of W.P.S.T. 125 of 2022. The
coordinate Bench of this Court has set aside such
consideration leading to rejection of his claim. The
learned Counsel for the petitioner has also relied on
the case of one Asoke Bhakat. It is submitted that
the said Asoke Bhakat had moved this Court
under similar circumstances by filing a Writ
Petition bearing W.P.S.T. No. 37 of 2022. The
deficiency in his case was condoned by a direction
of a coordinate Bench of this Court in his favour.
The Court has directed that the petitioner shall be
treated as having completed the qualifying service
under the scheme and be paid all admissible
consequential benefits. It is submitted that the
petitioner’s claim is also fit to be allowed in terms
of the said Judgment.”
9. In such factual background and upon such consideration
of the submissions, the coordinate Bench held:
“6. We have heard the learned Counsel for the
parties. Considered the two rules being relied upon
as well as the two decisions of the coordinate Bench,
taken note of above. A bare perusal of Rule 36,
extracted above, makes it clear that the discretion to
condone a deficiency of six months in qualifying
service of a Government servant for grant of
pension is limited by the note below the Rule, if the
deficiency arises in the qualifying service for the
purposes of death gratuity or family pension. In
other cases of retirement on invalid or
compensation pension also there is a limit specified
by the note below Rule 36. The note below Rule 36,
therefore has no application in the case of the
petitioner who is seeking relaxation/condonation in
the qualifying service for the purposes of grant of
superannuation pension or pension simpliciter. The
relaxation being sought for is well within the six
months’ limitation as specified in Rule 36, as he has
a deficiency of only three months and ten days. The
note below Rule 36 therefore does not come in the
way of condonation of deficiency in service in the
case of the petitioner.
…………..
…………..
9. In our considered opinion Rule 36 of the DCRB
Rules covers the claim of the petitioner. The power
of condonation having been granted under the Rule
36 and since petitioner’s claim is for condoning the
short-fall in the superannuation pension only we do
not find any limitation being specified by the note
below Rule 36 for grant of condonation to the
petitioner.
………
………
11. We, therefore, set aside the order of the Tribunal
as well as the Chief Engineer (Head Quarter),
insofar as it has rejected the claim of the writ
petitioner, we find that the power under Rule 36 to
condone the deficiency or relax the requirement of
qualifying service for superannuation pension is
with a rider that the same may be upon any
condition which the Government may think fit to
impose. What condition the Government will think
fit
to
impose
for
grant
of
such
relaxation/condonation, therefore lies in the
discretion of the State Government.
12. Reserving the discretion of the competent
authority to take a decision only with respect to the
conditions to be imposed for purposes of granting
the condonation, we dispose of the matter. The
competent authority however would be under a legal
obligation to take a decision on the conditions to be
imposed in terms of Rule 36 and to grant extension
subject to such conditions, positively within three
months from the date of receipt of the copy of this
order and Judgment.
13. The writ petition stands allowed.
14. There shall be, however, no order as to costs.”
10. The only difference between the case of Tapan Kumar
Mondal (supra) and the present writ petitioner is that
whereas Tapan Kumar Mondal required condonation of
a shortfall of three months and ten days, the present writ
petitioner requires a condonation of only twelve days so
as to achieve the requisite qualifying service of ten years
for grant of minimum pension. In view thereof we find
that the petitioner’s case is covered by the decision,
extract of which we have quoted above. The petitioner,
therefore, is entitled to the relief in the same terms. We,
therefore, set aside the order of the Additional Chief
Secretary dated 10.10.2025.
11. The competent authority is directed to take a decision
with respect to the conditions to be imposed for the
purpose of granting condonation. The competent
authority would be under a legal obligation to take a
decision in terms of Rule 36 and to grant condonation
subject to such conditions, positively within three
months from the date of receipt/production of a copy of
this order.
12. After the order was dictated the learned AGP rightly
pointed out that the petitioner, before availing the
benefit of pension would be required to refund/return
any benefits which he has also availed, and which are
beyond the scope of superannuation pension in terms of
the DCRB Rules.
13. Mr. Bhattacharya submits that there can be no dispute to
such a proposition. In view thereof, we leave it to the
authority to work out the adjustment/refund in
accordance with law, but within the time frame specified
above.
14. The writ petition is disposed of.
15. Urgent Photostat Certified copy of this order, if applied
for, be supplied to the parties upon compliance with all
necessary formalities.
(Madhuresh Prasad, J.)
(Prasenjit Biswas, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review