Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No. 1/25
GAHC040018582025
2026:GAU-AP:414
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(THE HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
WRIT PETITION (C) NO. 530[AP]/2025
Shri Gonong Pertin, Son of Late Panggo Pertin
and presently serving as Regular Executive
Engineer [WRD], Government of Arunachal
Pradesh,
Yingkiong,
Upper
Siang
District,
Arunachal Pradesh.
………………Petitioner
-VERSUS-
1.
The State of Arunachal Pradesh, represented
by
the
Department,
Secretary,
Water
Government
Resources
of
Arunachal
Water
Resources
Pradesh.
2.
The
Chief
Engineer,
Department, Itanagar.
3.
The Superintendent Engineer, Pangin Circle,
Pangin, Siang District, Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No. 2/25
4.
Mr. Karik Apang, Assistant Engineer [functional
EE], Yingkiong Division, Yingkion, Upper Siang
District, Arunachal Pradesh.
5.
Sri Alo Libang, Member of Legislative Assembly
[MLA],
Tuting-Yingkiong
Assembly
Constituency, Simong Village, P.O. & P.S.
Yingkiong, Upper Siang District, Arunachal
Pradesh.
6.
Sri
Oni
Panyang,
Member
of
Legislative
Assembly
[MLA],
Mariyang-Geku
Assembly
Constituency, Mariyang, P.O. & P.S. Mariyang,
Upper Siang District, Arunachal Pradesh.
……………….Respondents
Advocates :
Petitioner
: Mr. T. Pertin, Advocate
Respondent nos. 1 - 3
: Mr. R.H. Nabam, Additional Advocate General, A.P.
Respondent nos. 4 & 5
: Mr. P. Taffo, Senior Advocate
Respondent no. 6
: Mr. A. Tatak, Advocate
Date of Hearing
: 27.04.2026
Date of pronouncement of Judgment : 30.04.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the operative part of the judgment ? : No
Whether the full judgment has been pronounced ? : Yes
Page No. 3/25
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MANISH CHOUDHURY
JUDGMENT & ORDER
In this writ petition preferred under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
the petitioner has assailed an Order bearing no. SWRD/E-09/2013/Pt-II
dated 10.11.2025 issued by the Secretary to the Government of Arunachal
Pradesh, Water Resources Department [WRD]. It is stated that the
impugned Order is in partial modification of an earlier order of even number
dated 29.10.2025. By the impugned Order, the petitioner, an Executive
Engineer in the Water Resources Department [WRD], Government of
Arunachal Pradesh, has been transferred and posted from Seppa WRD
Division to Daporijo WRD Circle vice one Sri Hanu Techi Tara, Executive
Engineer transferred. In the impugned Order, it is stated that the petitioner
was under an order of posting at Yingkiong WRD Division. By the same
impugned Order, the respondent no. 4, also an Executive Engineer, who
was also under an order of posting to Daporijo WRD Circle, has been shown
to be retained at Yingkiong WRD Division.
2.
The petitioner is in service in the rank and post of regular Executive
Engineer under the Water Resources Department [WRD], Government of
Arunachal Pradesh. Pursuant to recommendation of the Departmental
Promotion Committee, the petitioner was promoted to the post of Executive
Engineer and posted at Seppa WRD by an Order dated 26.11.2014. The
respondent no. 4 is in the substantive post of Assistant Engineer and he was
appointed as Executive Engineer on functional basis in his own pay level and
grade pay of Assistant Engineer by an Order dated 17.06.2020.
Page No. 4/25
3.
By an Order dated 11.07.2023, a number of Executive Engineers were
transferred and posted at different places, as indicated therein, in the
interest of public service. The petitioner who was then serving as Executive
Engineer
at
Pasighat
Division,
was
transferred
to
the
Office
of
Superintending Engineer Coord, WRD, Itanagar as Executive Engineer
[P&D]. By the same Order, the respondent no. 4 was transferred from
Kolorian Division, WRD to Yingkiong Division, WRD as Executive Engineer.
4.
By a subsequent Order dated 05.08.2024, a number of Executive Engineers
were again transferred and posted at different places, as mentioned therein,
in the interest of public service. The petitioner was transferred from the
Office of the Superintending Engineer, Coord, Itanagar to Seppa WRD
Division as Executive Engineer. While the petitioner was serving as
Executive Engineer at Seppa Division for about one year and two months
after the Order dated 08.05.2024, the petitioner was again transferred and
posted as Executive Engineer at Yingkiong Division, WRD by an Order dated
29.10.2025 in the interest of public service. By the Order dated 29.10.2025,
the respondent no. 4 was transferred from Yingkiong Division, WRD to
Daporijo Circle, WRD as Executive Engineer [P&D].
5.
I have heard Mr. T. Pertin, learned counsel for the petitioner; Mr. R.H.
Nabam, learned Additional Advocate General, Arunachal Pradesh for the
respondent nos. 1, 2 & 3; Mr. P. Taffo, learned senior counsel for the
respondent nos. 4 & 5; and Mr. A. Tatak, learned counsel for the
respondent no. 6.
6.
Mr. Pertin, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted that
during the period from 11.07.2023 to 29.10.2025, the petitioner was
transferred on three occasions. In obeisance to the Order of transfer dated
29.10.2025, the petitioner joined in the post of Executive Engineer,
Page No. 5/25
Yingkiong Division, WRD in strict observance of all the procedures as laid
down in an Office Memorandum dated 13.02.2007. He has pointed out that
on 29.10.2025, the petitioner did not even complete a period of three
months at his previous place of posting as Executive Engineer, Basar
Division, WRD, which is much less than the normal tenure of two years as
provided in the Transfer Policy Guidelines framed by a Circular dated
02.06.1998 and partially amended subsequently by an Order dated
19.12.2008. On the other hand, the respondent no. 3 had completed more
than two years in the Yingkiong Division, WRD since 11.07.2023. As per the
norms and procedure prescribed by the Office Memorandum dated
13.02.2007, the petitioner started working as the Executive Engineer,
Yingkiong Division, WRD on and from 07.11.2025. Yet, in the impugned
Order dated 10.11.2025, the petitioner was shown to be under an order of
posting to Yingkiong Division, WRD and the respondent no. 4 was shown to
be in the post of Executive Engineer, Yingkiong Division, WRD and was
under an order of posting to Daporijo Circle, WRD. He has further submitted
that from the impugned Order which was shown to be passed in partial
modification of the Order dated 29.10.2025, it does not emerge that the
impugned Order was passed in the interest of public service’ as the said
words are missing therein. The impugned Order has been passed without
any application of mind by the respondent authorities in the WRD and
merely at the behest of two Members of Legislative Assembly [MLAs] who
purportedly sought retention of the respondent no. 4 at Yingkiong Division,
WRD on the basis of Representations from local people. Mr. Pertin, by
referring to the contents of the Representations, has submitted that the
respondent no. 4 was sought to be retained on the ground that he was in
charge of number of works of importance in the said Division and his
presence would be necessary to carry out those works. But, a mere look at
the works would go to show that the works are of normal nature and they
do not need a high level of expertise and a person possessing high skills for
execution. The petitioner is very well capable of executing all those works.
Page No. 6/25
He has contended that by 10.11.2025, the petitioner was already working
as Executive Engineer, Yingkiong Division, WRD after taking over charge of
the said post unilaterally on 07.11.2025 in strict adherence to the procedure
laid down by the State Government. He has, thus, submitted that though
the impugned Order is not in violation of any statutory provision or may not
be mala fide but the same is against the norms professed by the State
respondents. Being aware of the fact that transfer is an incident of service,
the petitioner has followed the transfer orders, as and when passed, without
raising any question. But in the case in hand, the petitioner is constrained to
approach the Court as the State respondents has passed the impugned
Order in total violation of the law merely to accommodate the respondent
no. 4 and after the earlier Order dated 29.10.2025 was duly carried out.
7.
Mr. Nabam, learned Additional Advocate General, Arunachal Pradesh
appearing for the State respondents has supported the Order dated
10.11.2025. It is his submission that at the time of passing the impugned
Order dated 10.11.2025, both the Officers were under orders of posting. It
is his further submission that till 10.11.2025, the previous Order of transfer
dated 29.10.2025 was not acted upon and therefore, it was open for the
employer to issue the impugned Order on 10.11.2025, which was in partial
modification of the Order dated 29.10.2025. He has submitted that as the
impugned Order was issued in partial modification of the previous Order
dated 29.10.2025, there was no necessity to express specifically that the
order was passed ‘in the interest of public service’. He has submitted that
there is no bar to make transfer order on the basis of Representations
received from public representatives like an MLA and in the case in hand,
after the Order dated 29.10.2025, two Representations were received from
two local MLAs making request for retention of the respondent no. 4 as the
Executive Engineer, Yingkiong Division, WRD in order to enable him to
supervise the ongoing public works in the same Division despite the fact
that he was posted in the Yingkiong Division, WRD for more than three
Page No. 7/25
years. He has submitted that since the impugned Order is neither in
violation of any statutory rules nor there is an allegation of mala fide, the
same does not require any interference.
8.
Mr. Taffo, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent no. 4 has
submitted in similar lines as the learned Additional Advocate General,
Arunachal Pradesh. He has submitted that the Transfer Policy framed by the
State Government are merely Guidelines and they may be followed to the
extent possible. But, the Guidelines are not enforceable in the writ
jurisdiction. If the respondent no. 4 has been sought to be retained at a
particular place of posting beyond the normal tenure of two years by the
employer by the impugned Order, no interference can be made. Further, it
is the employer who has the power and authority to make transfers in
administrative exigency. A Government employee has to comply with an
order of transfer and it is not open to question an order of transfer only
because the order is passed before expiry of the normal tenure of two years
at a particular place.
9.
Both Mr. Taffo and Mr. Tatak, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
no. 5 and the respondent no. 6 respectively have submitted that even if any
allegation is made by a Government employee under an order of transfer
that he has been transferred on the recommendation of a public
representative like an MLA that by itself would not vitiate the transfer order.
It all depends upon on the facts and circumstances of the individual case.
They have submitted, in unison, that in the present case, the respondent
no. 5 and the respondent no. 6 as the MLAs of the local area had received
Representations from the local public wherein it was mentioned that
presence of the respondent no. 4 would be necessary to supervise and
monitor the ongoing public works. They have referred to the decisions of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Mohd. Masood Ahmad vs. State of
U.P. and others, [2007] 8 SCC 150, and Pubi Lombi vs. State of
Page No. 8/25
Arunachal Pradesh and others, [2024] 12 SCC 292, in support of their
submissions.
10.
I have given consideration to the submissions of the learned counsel for the
parties and have also gone through materials brought on record by the
pleadings of the parties. The decisions cited by the learned counsel for the
parties in support of their contentions are perused.
11.
It is the case of the petitioner that the respondent no. 4 who is in the
substantive post of Assistant Engineer, was allowed to serve in the post of
Executive Engineer on functional basis only from 17.06.2020. The
respondent no. 4 was transferred to and posted at Yingkiong Division, WRD
as Executive Engineer by the Order dated 11.07.2023. When his order of
transfer and posting to Daporijo Circle, WRD was passed on 29.10.2025, the
respondent no. 4 had already spent more than two years at Yingkiong
Division of the WRD. It was made specific in the Order dated 29.10.2025
that the transfer and posting of the three Executive Engineers effected
thereby were in the interest of public service. By the Order dated
29.10.2025, the petitioner was transferred from Seppa Division, WRD to
Yingkiong Division, WRD vice the respondent no. 4.
12.
By a Circular dated 02.06.1998, the State Government issued Guidelines on
the transfer and posting of all categories of officers and staffs in Arunachal
Pradesh upon approval by the Governor, in supersession of all previous
notifications / circulars, etc. issued on the subject. As per the said transfer
policy Guidelines, all postings including those in the Secretariat, in the
offices of the Heads of Departments and in the districts should be normally
for a period of three years for the sake of continuity. The exceptions can be
transfers on promotion, for filling up a crucial vacancy based on
specialization, on compassionate and health ground with the approval of the
competent authority. It was specified that its proposal for transfer must
Page No. 9/25
clearly state on the file that it satisfied all the conditions mentioned in the
transfer policy Guidelines. By an Order dated 19.12.2008, the normal tenure
was modified from three years to two years in the transfer policy Guidelines.
Therefore, the transfer and posting of the respondent no. 4 by the Order
dated 29.10.2025 from Yingkiong Division, WRD to Daporijo Circle, WRD
was in conformity with the transfer policy Guidelines framed by the State
Government.
13.
It is settled law that a transfer is an incidence of service and is a part of the
service conditions of a Government employee. An order of transfer is made
in exigency of service and is an administrative decision. The power of
judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is not to be
exercised in a matter where no injustice has been caused. It has emerged
as a settled proposition that an order of transfer is not to be interfered in
exercise of the jurisdiction under Article 226 unless it is found that the order
is mala fide, or that the order is in violation of any statutory provision, or
that the authority who has issued the order is not competent to pass the
order, or in infraction of any professed norms. It is also settled that any
policy guidelines on the transfer and posting issued by the employer does
not confer any enforceable right upon an employee if such policy guidelines
do not have any statutory force. Therefore, it cannot be said that the policy
guidelines on the transfer and posting, as issued by the Circular dated
02.06.1998 and the Order dated 19.12.2008, have created any enforceable
right upon a Government employee to seek enforcement of such policy
guidelines under Article 226 of the Constitution even if he has been
transferred before completing the normal two years tenure or he has served
at one place beyond the normal tenure of two years.
14.
It has been brought to the notice of the Court that after the Order dated
29.10.2025, there were correspondences from two elected representatives,
who sought retention of the respondent no. 4 at Yingkiong Division, WRD.
Page No. 10/25
Recommending for retention of the respondent no. 4 at Yingkiong Division,
the Member of Legislative Assembly [MLA], 34th Tuting – Yingkiong
Legislative Assembly Constituency [LAC] [the respondent no. 5] wrote to
the Minister, WRD, Government of Arunachal Pradesh vide U.O. Note dated
31.10.2025. The MLA, 40 no. Geku-Mariyang LAC [the respondent no. 6]
also wrote to the Minister, WRD, Government of Arunachal Pradesh vide
U.O. Note dated 01.11.2025 recommending retention of the respondent no.
4, who had already been transferred and posted to Daporijo Circle, WRD
vide Order dated 29.10.2025, as Executive Engineer, Yingkiong Division,
WRD. It was inter alia stated that the respondent no. 4 was personally
known to him for long.
15.
The proposal for retention of the respondent no. 4, after receipt of
recommendations from two MLAs, was processed on and from 07.11.2025
after the Minister, WRD, Government of Arunachal Pradesh made an
endorsement on the U.O. Notes to process. While processing the proposal,
the authorities were in clear knowledge that pursuant to the Order dated
29.10.2025, the petitioner had already handed over the charge of Executive
Engineer, Seppa Division, WRD on 04.11.2025 vide a Certificate of Transfer
of Charges which stood uploaded in the concerned portal. Subsequently, the
Superintending Engineer, Jamiri Circle, WRD released the petitioner from
Seppa Division, WRD on 06.11.2025 enabling the petitioner to join his new
place of posting vide an Order no. WRCJ/ESTT/PF-84/2024-25/296-98 dated
06.11.2025. The authorities were also in clear knowledge that transfer and
posting of the petitioner from Seppa Division, WRD was effected before
completion of the normal tenure of two years. The authorities in the WRD
processed the proposal after receipt of the two U.O. Notes from the MLAs of
the area seeking retention of the respondent no. 4 at Yingkiong Division,
WRD after the Order dated 29.10.2025.
Page No. 11/25
16.
Stating that transfer and posting of officers in the prerogative of the
Government to be exercised in the exigency of public service and
departmental requirement, a Note was placed on 07.11.2025 before the
higher authorities for partial modification of the Order dated 29.10.2025. It
transpires that the proposal for retention of the respondent no. 4 received
approval from the Secretary, WRD; the Minister, WRD; and the Chief
Minister on 08.11.2025. Thereafter, the impugned Order dated 10.11.2025
came to be issued.
17.
In the case of Mohd. Masood Ahmad [supra], a contention was raised that
the transfer of the appellant was made at the instance of an MLA. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court has opined that even if the allegation of the
appellant is correct that he was transferred on the recommendation of an
MLA, that by itself would not vitiate the transfer order. It is the duty of the
representatives of the people in the Legislature to express the grievances of
the people and if there is any complaint against an official the State
Government is certainly within its jurisdiction to transfer such an employee.
There can be no hard-and-fast rule that every transfer at the instance of an
MP or MLA would be vitiated. It all depends on the facts and circumstances
of an individual case.
18.
The stands taken by the respondent no. 5 and the respondent no. 6 in their
respective affidavits can be looked at first. The respondent no. 5 has stated
that as a public representative of the area, he received a Representation
from the local public on 30.10.2025 requesting retention of the respondent
no. 4 at Yingkiong Division, WRD. It was highlighted in the Representation
that the respondent no. 4 was instrumental in timely planning, execution
and monitoring of several key irrigation and flood protection works and
other development projects in the area and his change would bring adverse
impact on public interest. On receipt of the Representation, the respondent
no. 5 stated to have placed the U.O. Note dated 31.10.2025. It is further
Page No. 12/25
stated that there was no personal and political interest in retention of the
respondent no. 4. In his affidavit-in-opposition, the respondent no. 6 has
stated that he received a Representation from the local public on
31.10.2025 requesting retention of the respondent no. 4 at Yingkiong.
Accordingly,
considering
the
grievances
expressed
in
the
said
Representation, he as a public representative of the area forwarded the
U.O. Note dated 01.11.2025 to the Minister, WRD, Government of Arunachal
Pradesh requesting for retention of the respondent no. 4 at Yingkiong as the
local public had highlighted that the respondent no. 4 was supervising and
implementing several public utility projects of the Water Resources
Department at that time. In the U.O. Note dated 01.11.2025, the
respondent no. 6 mentioned that the respondent no. 4 was personally
known to him for long.
19.
In the two Representations of the local public, stated to have been received
by the respondent no. 2 and the respondent no. 6 respectively, the works
with which the respondent no. 4 was involved with at the relevant time
were mentioned. Those were : [i] construction of integrated 10-bedded
AYUSH Hospital at Yingkiong; [ii] G+2 [35-seat] Hostel building for working
women in Upper Siang District; [iii] construction of girls hostel, Government
Upper Primary School at Moying, Upper Siang District; [iv] construction of a
craft center building at Mariang, Upper Siang District; [v] 8 units of staff
quarter at CHC, Geku; [vi] construction of administrative building, quarter
for principal, gate, kitchen for boys and girls hostel and boundary wall
around girls hostel, Government Model College, Geku. Having regard to the
nature of constructions involved in the afore-mentioned works, it is not
incomprehensible for the Court to reach a view that these kinds of
construction works were key irrigation and flood protection works, and
though public projects of importance, would require an Officer in the rank of
Executive Engineer possessing high level of expertise to execute them. Yet,
the two public representatives deemed it proper to forward the
Page No. 13/25
Representations vide U.O. Notes seeking retention of the respondent no. 4
at Yingkiong Division of the WRD to carry out those public works by
unsettling the previous Order of transfer dated 29.10.2025, which was
issued by the competent authority in the Water Resources Department in
the interest of public service.
20.
From the affidavits-in-opposition of the respondent no. 5 and the
respondent no. 6, it can be noticed that both of them had forwarded their
U.O. Notes on 31.10.2025 and 01.11.2025, subsequent to the Order dated
29.10.2025, stating that the local public had sought for retention of the
respondent no. 4 at Yingkiong as he was involved in implementation and
execution of several public projects as Executive Engineer, Yingkiong
Division, WRD. Neither in the U.O. Notes nor in the affidavits-in-opposition,
the respondent no. 5 and the respondent no. 6 have made any allegation
against the petitioner and any shortcoming on his part. It is not the stand of
the respondent no. 5 and the respondent no. 6 that if the petitioner is
transferred as the Executive Engineer, Yingkiong Division, WRD in place of
the respondent no. 4 there would be any adverse impact in implementation
and execution of the ongoing public projects. It is also not the stand of the
respondent no. 5 and the respondent no. 6 that the petitioner would not be
suitable to implement and execute the ongoing public projects.
21.
On receipt of the U.O. Notes form the respondent no. 5 and the respondent
no. 6 in the Water Resources Department, it was expected that the request
made by them on the basis of such public representations would be
objectively assessed by the Water Resources Department authorities to
exercise the discretion. On going through the records of the relevant file, as
annexed to the case papers as Annexure-16, it is discernible that none of
the authorities before whom the proposal for retention of the respondent
no. 4 was placed had made any comment either in favour of the respondent
no. 4 or in favour of the petitioner, except subscribing their signatures, in
Page No. 14/25
the file. It is suggestive of a situation where the public functionaries had
abdicated their responsibility to decide in the matter of transfer from the
standpoint of administrative exigency to the U.O. Notes forwarded by the
two public representatives.
22.
In Pubi Lombi [supra], the impugned transfer Order was of 15.11.2022. By
the said Order dated 15.11.2022, the appellant who was holding the post of
Deputy Director of School Education [DDSE], Seppa, East Kameng District
was transferred as Principal, Dani Punia Government Higher Secondary
School [GHSS], Ziro and the respondent no. 5 was transferred from the post
of Principal, GHSS, Kanubari, Longding District and was posted as DDSE,
Leparada District with a condition that he would join the transferred post in
the last part of April, 2023. Such condition was incorporated for the reason
that the incumbent holding the post of DDSE, Leparada District would be
superannuated in the last part of April, 2023. Pursuant to the Order dated
15.11.2022, the appellant joined at his transferred place of posting at Ziro.
On 19.04.2023, the respondent no. 5 was released to join at his transferred
place of posting in terms of the Order dated 15.11.2022 and on being so
released, the respondent no. 5 submitted his joining report on 20.04.2023.
But the Order dated 15.11.2022 was partially modified by the impugned
Order dated 20.04.2023 whereby the respondent no. 5 was retained as
Principal at the GHSS, Kanubari, Longding District and the appellant was
transferred from the post of Principal, Dani Kunia GHSS, Ziro as the DDSE,
Leparada District. The respondent no. 5 challenged the Order dated
20.04.2023 primarily on the ground that the impugned transfer Order was
made on the basis of a U.O. Note dated 28.02.2023 put up by the MLA, 29
– Basar [ST] LAC.
22.1. Taking note of the entire facts and circumstances, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court has observed as under :-
Page No. 15/25
16. On examining the facts of the present case, it is apparent that
Respondent 5 herein was transferred from Government Higher
Secondary School [GHSS] Kanubari, Longding District to Leparada
as Deputy Director of School Education [DDSE] vide Order dated
15.11.2022 and was directed to join in the last part of April 2023.
The U.O. Note dated 28.02.2023 has been written by the MLA
specifying the administrative exigency and public interest in posting
the appellant on the post of DDSE, Leparada.
17. The said U.O. Note has been examined and competent
authority has exercised its discretion in favour of the appellant, and
Respondent 5 herein has been retained on the same post in the
same district in same status which he was holding prior to order of
transfer dated 15.11.2022 un-affecting his salary. Besides, it is also
averred by the State that the modified order dated 20.04.2023 was
passed prior to effective period during which Respondent 5 was
directed to join i.e. in the last part of April 2023.
In the absence of any plea of mala fide or no violation of any statutory
provision, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has affirmed the transfer order dated
20.04.2023 holding that the interference was not justified on the
unsubstantiated pretext that the proposed modification was arbitrary or
without application of mind for the sole reason that it was mooted by the
MLA.
23.
From the above two decisions, it transpires that an MLA of the concerned
LAC being a public representative of the area can make an opinion in
matters of transfer and posting of public servants keeping the interest of
public service in mind. If he is in receipt of any public complaint or if he has
any personal knowledge as regards suitability of a public servant or
allegation of any misdeeds of a public servant to be transferred in the areas
Page No. 16/25
of the LAC then he can make the concerned Department aware of his
opinion and concerns. No such situation is present in the case in hand.
24.
It would be apposite to refer to the following observations made by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of N.K. Singh vs. Union of
India and others, [1994] 6 SCC 98 : -
9. Transfer of a public servant from a significant post can be
prejudicial to public interest only if the transfer was avoidable and
the successor is not suitable for the post. Suitability is a matter for
objective
assessment
by
the
hierarchical
superiors
in
administration. To introduce and rely on the element of prejudice to
public interest as a vitiating factor of the transfer of a public servant,
it must be first pleaded and proved that the replacement was by a
person not suitable for the important post and the transfer was
avoidable. Unless this is pleaded and proved at the threshold, no
further inquiry into this aspect is necessary and its absence is
sufficient to exclude this factor from consideration as a vitiating
element in the impugned transfer. Accordingly, this aspect
requires consideration at the outset.
25.
The above observations regarding suitability are relevant for both the
relieved officer and the relieving officer. The stance of the State
respondents would be adverted to in the later part of this order. But, it is
pertinent to mention that the State respondents have not taken any stand
that if the petitioner is allowed to take charge of the post of Executive
Engineer, Yingkiong Division, WRD there would be any adverse impact in
implementation and execution of the ongoing public projects in the
Yingkiong Division of the WRD. No stand has been taken by the State
respondents that the petitioner would not be suitable to carry on
implementation and execution of any of the ongoing public projects in the
Page No. 17/25
Yingkiong Division of the WRD. As found out from the affidavits-inopposition of the respondent no. 5 and the respondent no. 6, no adverse
comment has been made against the petitioner and there is no whisper
from their ends that the petitioner would be unsuitable to discharge the
duties as the Executive Engineer, Yingkiong Division, WRD.
26.
In the affidavit-in-opposition of the respondent no. 4, an Assistant Engineer
and working functionally as Executive Engineer, it has been admitted that
he has completed a tenure of two years at Yingkiong Division, WRD while
taking a stand that a tenure beyond the normal two years tenure is
permissible in exigent circumstances. He has not brought on record any
adverse material against the petitioner. It is not his pleaded case that his
transfer from Yingkiong Division, WRD would adversely impact the ongoing
public projects in the Yingkiong Division of the WRD. It is mentioned that
the local MLAs had initiated the Notes for his retention only in the public
interest of development activities. He has specifically averred that the
modification Order dated 10.11.2025 has neither expressed nor has implied
incapability or inefficiency of the petitioner.
27.
Notwithstanding the above observations, it is pertinent to note that while in
the Order dated 29.10.2025, it was mentioned that the Governor of
Arunachal Pradesh was pleased to order the transfer and posting of the
officers ‘in the interest of public service’, it was not mentioned in the
impugned Order dated 10.11.2025 that the Governor of Arunachal Pradesh
had made the order of transfer and posting ‘in the interest of public service’.
In the impugned Order dated 10.11.2025, the respondent no. 4 has been
shown to be transferred from Yingkiong WRD Division [under order of
posting to Daporijo WRD Circle] and retained at Yingkiong WRD Division as
Executive Engineer. At the same time, the petitioner has been shown to be
transferred from Seppa WRD Division [under order of posting at Yingkiong
Page No. 18/25
WRD Division] and has been posted at Daporijo WRD Circle as Executive
Engineer [P&D].
28.
In the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondent nos. 1 & 3, it is averred
that the modification in the Order dated 10.11.2025 was made in
administrative interest keeping in view field requirements, continuity of
ongoing works, and functional necessity of the Department. While admitting
that the respondent no. 4 has been posted at Yingkiong Division of the WRD
since 11.07.2023, it is mentioned that tenure norms are directory, not
mandatory. Mere completion of tenure at one place does not give rise to a
legal or enforceable right. It is stated that the Office Memorandum [O.M.]
dated 13.02.2007, relied upon by the petitioner, is a matter of record but
the interpretation given by the petitioner is incorrect as the Office
Memorandum does not prohibit modification of transfer and posting order.
It is stated that the Representations received from the MLAs were
acknowledged merely as inputs and those did not influence the decision.
29.
In the absence of any material indicating objective assessment as regards
suitability or otherwise of the two Officers involved in the impugned Order,
the Court is reminded of the settled principle that when a public functionary
makes an order based on certain grounds, its validity is to be judged by the
reasons so mentioned and cannot be supplemented by fresh reasons in the
shape of affidavit or otherwise. Recording of reason is prima facie
suggestive of conscious application of mind and non-recording of reason is
indicative of non-application of mind. The obligation to record reasons is a
possible check against arbitrary action on the part of the authority invested
with the power to transfer. The case in hand seems to be one where no
reason was assigned for issuance of the impugned Order and reasons are
subsequently assigned in the affidavit.
Page No. 19/25
30.
In the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondent no. 2, it is admitted
that in compliance of the Order dated 29.10.2025, the petitioner was
released from Seppa Division by the Superintending Engineer, Water
Resources Circle, Jamiri, Bichom District on 06.11.2025 [after-noon].
Thereafter, the petitioner submitted his joining report as Executive
Engineer, Yingkiong Division, WRD addressed to him on 06.11.2025 and the
joining letter was personally handed over by the petitioner to the Personal
Assistant of the respondent no. 2 at the official residence of the respondent
no. 2 in Pasighat. The respondent no. 2 has stated that during the said
period, he was out of station and he resumed office on 10.11.2025. The
respondent no. 2 has further stated that the soft copy of the petitioner’s
joining letter was also forwarded to the WhatsApp account of the
respondent no. 2 by the petitioner through his WhatsApp account at 11-21
a.m. on 06.11.2025. On 07.11.2025, soft copies of two letters were
forwarded by the petitioner through his WhatsApp account to the WhatsApp
account of the respondent no. 2. The contents of those letters were with
regards to assumption of charge of the office of the Executive Engineer,
Yingkiong Division, WRD ex-parte.
31.
At this juncture, it is found necessary to refer to an Office Memorandum
dated 13.02.2007 issued by the Department of Personnel, Administrative
Reforms and Training, Government of Arunachal Pradesh on the subject :
‘Joining and Relief and Transfer of Charge of Officers on Transfer – Certain
Clarifications Issued – regarding’. It has been clarified that once transfer /
posting orders are issued by the competent authority, no further order or
permission is required for the officer to join his new place of posting. By the
Office Memorandum, certain instructions regarding joining and relief of
officers on transfer are reiterated for clarity. The following instructions are
of pertinence :-
Page No. 20/25
[2] As soon as the transfer / posting orders are issued, the
relieving officer will proceed and join in his new place of posting
without undue delay.
[3] The relieved officer will prepare the accounts of the cash,
stores and other records to be handed over to the relieving
officer on his assumption of charge of the office, hand over the
same to the relieving officer, as and when he comes to assume
charge of the office. The relieved officer should not absent
himself or obstruct in anyway his reliever from joining the post
smoothly. Such action, if any, on the part of the relieved officer
will tantamount to disobedience of Govt. orders, attracting
disciplinary action under the CCS [CCA] and other relevant
Rules in force.
[4] In cases, where the relieved officer does not hand over
charge to the relieving officer when he comes to join, the
relieving officer will assume charge of the office unilaterally / exparte so as to implement the Govt.'s orders and to enable the
officer to discharge his duties and responsibilities without delay.
The relieved officer will stand automatically relieved once the
relieving officer assumes charge of the office. A copy of the
Joining Report and Assumption of Charge should be sent to the
Head of the Department concerned, the immediate Controlling
Officer, the Treasury Officer, and all concerned, as usual.
32.
From the materials on record, it has emerged that after the Order dated
29.10.2025, the Superintending Engineer, Water Resources Circle, Jamiri
who was the Controlling Officer of the petitioner at that point of time,
passed an Order bearing no. WRCJ/Estt/PF-84/2024-25 dated 06.11.2025
whereby the petitioner was released from the post of Executive Engineer,
Page No. 21/25
WRD, Sepa on and from 06.11.2025 [After-Noon] to enable the petitioner
join his new place of posting as Executive Engineer, WRD, Yingkiong in
pursuance of the Order dated 29.10.2025. A copy of the said Order dated
06.11.2025 was also forwarded to the Superintending Engineer, Water
Resources Circle, Pangin who was to be the next Controlling Officer for the
petitioner, for information. The petitioner accordingly handed over the
charge of Executive Engineer, WRD, Sepa on 04.11.2025.
33.
After being so released, the petitioner as the Relieving Officer for the
respondent no. 4, had proceeded to Pangin to report before the
Superintending Engineer, Water Resources Circle, Pangin and to submit his
joining letter. The petitioner had reported before the Superintending
Engineer, Water Resources Circle, Pangin on 06.11.2025 and submitted a
joining letter of even date. In his affidavit-in-opposition, the respondent no.
2 has admitted that the petitioner had submitted his joining letter as the
Executive Engineer, WRD, Yingkiong on 06.11.2025 and the joining letter
was personally handed over by the petitioner to the Personal Assistant of
the respondent no. 2 in the official residence of the respondent no. 2. The
Personal Assistant of the respondent no. 2 had acknowledged the receipt of
the joining letter of the petitioner under his signature. The office of the
respondent no. 2 also acknowledged the receipt of the joining letter of the
petitioner under seal vide Receipt no. 1196 dated 07.11.2025. The
respondent no. 2 has admitted that during the said period from 06.11.2025
to 10.11.2025, he was out of station and he resumed his official duties only
on 10.11.2025. It is further mentioned by the respondent no. 2 that the soft
copy of the joining letter was also forwarded by the petitioner to him
through WhatsApp and he received the same in his WhatsApp account at
11-21 am on 06.11.2025 itself. Therefore, it is not open for the respondent
no. 2 to take a plea that his office did not receive any copy of the joining
letter.
Page No. 22/25
34.
It is the case of the petitioner that after submitting the joining letter in the
afore-stated manner on 06.11.2025, he proceeded to Yingkiong to assume
charge of the post of Executive Engineer, WRD, Yingkiong Division on
07.11.2025. At Yingkiong, the petitioner proceeded to the office to take over
charge from the respondent no. 4 as the Relieving Officer as per the
procedure laid down in the Office Memorandum dated 13.02.2007. By going
to the office of the Executive Engineer, WRD, Yingkiong Division, the
petitioner did not find the respondent no. 4 who was the Relieved Officer.
The factum of absence of the respondent no. 4 is established from the
admission made by the respondent no. 4 in his affidavit-in-opposition
wherein he has stated that he was on station leave on and from 04.11.2025
including 06.11.2025. The respondent no. 4 has maintained silence as to
when he resumed his duties in the office after 06.11.2025. The petitioner
had started functioning as the Executive Engineer, Yingkiong Division, WRD
on and from 07.11.2025.
35.
The petitioner has stated that in the absence of the respondent no. 4 in the
office of the WRD, Yingkiong Division on 07.11.2025, the petitioner had no
option but to assume the charge of the office of the Executive Engineer,
Yingkiong Division of the WRD unilaterally in terms of the Office
Memorandum dated 13.02.2007. On 07.11.2025, the petitioner wrote to the
respondent no. 2 informing him that the Relieved Officer was absent in the
office on his arrival and on further enquiry, it was found that the Relieved
Officer was not in the station for many days. It was further mentioned that
the petitioner had requested the respondent no. 4 via WhatsApp at 08-36
p.m., 06.11.2025 to be present in his office so as to enable him to take over
the charge, and the respondent no. 4 to hand over charge as the Relieved
Officer. It was further mentioned that having found the respondent no. 4 to
be absent in the office not only that day but also from several days before,
and in order to implement the Order dated 29.10.2025, he had to assume
the charge of the post of Executive Engineer, WRD, Yingkiong Division on
Page No. 23/25
ex parte basis in the after-noon of 07.11.2025 as per the requirement of the
Office Memorandum dated 13.02.2007. Along with the Letter dated
07.11.2025, the petitioner also forwarded a Certificate of Transfer of
Charges dated 07.11.2025 to [i] the respondent no. 2; [ii] the Secretary,
WRD, Government of Arunachal Pradesh; [iii] the Chief Engineer, WRD,
Itanagar; [iv] the Deputy Commissioner, Yingkiong, Upper Siang District; [v]
the Accountant General [A&E], Itanagar; [vi] the State Bank of India,
Yingkiong, Upper Siang, etc. for information.
36.
The professed norm of the State Government, as notified by the Office
Memorandum dated 13.02.2007, is that in a case where the Relieved Officer
does not hand over charge to the Relieving Officer when he comes to join,
the Relieving Officer would assume charge of the office unilaterally/ex parte
so as to implement the Government Order and to enable the Officer to
discharge his duties and responsibilities. As per the Office Memorandum
dated 13.02.2007, once the Relieving Officer assumes charge of the office
unilaterally in compliance of the Order of transfer passed by the competent
authority in the Government, the Relived Officer stand automatically
relieved. In the case in hand, the petitioner had to take over the charge of
the office of Executive Engineer, WRD, Yingkiong Division unilaterally in the
above obtaining fact situation. A Relieving Officer like the petitioner can
follow the procedure to the extent possible from his end. When a Relieving
Officer goes to report himself before the Controlling Officer at first, and the
Relieved Officer thereafter in order to assume the charge and at the time of
reporting, neither the Controlling Officer nor the Relieved Officer keeps
himself present in their respective office as per the extant procedure, the
Relieving Officer like the petitioner would have no option but to assume
charge unilaterally/ex parte basis as per the procedure laid down in the
Office Memorandum dated 13.02.2007. In the present case, the respondent
no. 2 as the Controlling Officer and the respondent no. 4 as the Relieved
Page No. 24/25
Officer made themselves absent from their respective office from days prior
to 06.11.2025 and 07.11.2025 respectively.
37.
As the petitioner is found to have assumed the charge of the office of the
Executive Engineer, Yingkiong Division, WRD by following the procedure
strictly in terms of the Office Memorandum dated 13.02.2007, this Court
finds that the Order dated 29.10.2025 stood effectuated on 07.11.2025 in
so far as the petitioner is concerned. Therefore, it is to be held that the
petitioner had assumed the charge of the office of the Executive Engineer,
Yingkiong Division, WRD on and from 07.11.2025 onwards. With such
assumption of charge by the petitioner and as per the Office Memorandum
dated 13.02.2007, the respondent no. 4 stood relieved from the post of
Executive Engineer, Yingkiong Division, WRD from that moment onward. By
choosing not to join in the post of Executive Engineer [P&D], Daporijo
Circle, WRD thereafter the respondent no. 4 had kept his status in a state of
uncertainty for which no one but he is responsible. In such facts and
circumstances, this Court is not in a position to hold that on and from
07.11.2025, the respondent no. 4 was holding the post of Executive
Engineer, WRD, Yingkiong Division.
38.
For the findings arrived at as above, the impugned Order dated 10.11.2025
is held to be infirm as the said Order has been passed by the respondent
no. 1, without proper application of mind, on the suppositions that the
petitioner was under an order of posting at Yingkiong Division, WRD and the
respondent no. 4 was under an order of posting to Daporijo Circle, WRD. It
needs to be iterated that by the impugned Order dated 10.11.2025, the
petitioner was transferred from Sepa Division, WRD to Daporijo Circle, WRD
and the respondent no. 4 was seen to be posted and retained at Yingkiong
Division, WRD. As this Court has found that on and from 07.11.2025, the
petitioner was at the post of Executive Engineer, Yingkiong Division, WRD
and the respondent no. 4 was not in the post of Executive Engineer,
Page No. 25/25
Yingkiong Division, WRD, the impugned Order dated 10.11.2025 is liable to
be set aside and quashed. It is accordingly set aside and quashed.
39.
As a result, the petitioner is to be treated to be working as the Executive
Engineer, Yingkiong Division, WRD on and from 07.11.2025. Consequently,
the writ petition stands allowed to the extent indicated. By an interim Order
dated 14.11.2025, the impugned Order dated 10.11.2025 was stayed. The
interim Order of stay dated 14.11.2025 stands accordingly merged with this
Order. There shall, however, be no order as to cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review