Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010659822018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3566]
THURSDAY,THE NINTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 2563/2018
Between:
1. GOGULA VENKATESH, OCC - COOLIE,
R/O OPP NAGUR
PETROL BUNK, KADIRI ROAD, MUDIGUBBA VILLAGE AND
MANDAL, ANANTAPURAM DISTRICT.
...APELLANT
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, Rep., by Public Prosecutor,
High Court at Hyderabad.
...RESPODENT
Appeal under Section 372/374(2)/378(4) of Cr.P.C praying that the
High Court may be pleased to The present Appeal is being filed aggrieved
by the Judgment dt 01.03.2017 made in Sessions Case No.340 of 2015 on
the file of III Addl. Sessions Judge (F.T.C), Anantapuram, the present of
Appeal filed for the following among other.
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be
pleased may be pleased to condone the delay of 489 days in filing the
Crl.A. of 2018 and to pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be
pleased may be pleased to release the Appellant / Petitioner on bail by
suspending the execution of sentence passed in Sessions Case No.340 of
2015 dated 01.03.2017 by the III Addl. Sessions Judge (F.T.C)
Anantapuramu, pending disposal of the main Criminal Appeal and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be
pleased pleased to suspend the execution of sentence in S.C.No. 340 of
2015 on the file of the III Additional Sessions Judge, Anantapuram Dated:
01-03-2017 and release the Petitioner/Accused on bail in Crl.A.No. 2563
of 2018, which is pending before this Hon’ble Court
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. A GAYATRI REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
The Court made the following:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH :: AMARAVATI
THURSDAY,THE NINTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
SPECIAL DIVISION BENCH
PRESENT
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
And
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 2563 of 2018
JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice A. Hari Haranadha Sharma)
Introductory:[i]
Sole accused in Sessions Case No.340 of 2015 on the file of
the III Additional Sessions Judge, (Fast Track Court), Anantapuramu, (for
short referred as ‘the Sessions Court’) is the appellant.
[ii]
He was tried by the learned III Additional Sessions Judge
(FTC), Anantapuram for the charges under Sections 498-A IPC and 302
IPC.
2.
State represented by the Inspector of Police, Nallamada Circle filed
Charge Sheet against the appellant/accused, alleging commission of
offences under Sections 498-A on the ground of subjecting his wife to
physical and mental cruelty, and under Section 302 IPC for causing death
of his wife by pouring kerosene and setting fire.
3.
The Sessions Court found the appellant/accused guilty for the
offence under Section 302-IPC and sentenced him to suffer imprisonment
for life and to pay fine of Rs.10,000/-; in default to pay fine amount to suffer
simple imprisonment for a period of one year and acquitted him for the
charge under Section 498-A IPC under the judgment dated 01.03.2017.
Questioning the propriety and sustainability of the conviction and sentence,
the present appeal is filed.
Case of the prosecution:4.
[i]
PW1-D.Lakshmi Devi, PW.6-D.Shankar are the parents of one
G.Nagendramma (herein after referred to 'as the deceased'). The accused
is the husband of the deceased.
[ii]
During their wedlock, the accused and the deceased were
blessed with a son by name Mohan. Accused addicted to alcohol etc., and
used to harass the deceased physically and mentally, on that count the
deceased came to her parental home along with her son. But four days
prior to the incident, accused asked the deceased to come to home stating
that if she does not come, he will commit suicide. Then, PW.1 and PW.6
taken the deceased to the house of the accused and left her there, asking
the accused to take care of her.
[iii]
On 07.05.2014 at about 10.00p.m., the accused consumed
alcohol and beat the deceased indiscriminately, when she tried to come out
of the house of the accused, he caught hold of the deceased, poured
kerosene on her body and set ablaze. On hearing cries, PW.2 and others
came there, then the accused poured water on the deceased and put off
the flames. Son of the deceased was also stained with kerosene but he
has escaped from the house.
[iv]
The deceased was shifted to Government Area Hospital,
Kadiri in 108 ambulance van as the condition was critical.
PW.9-Doctor,
sent medical intimation to the local Magistrate, immediately.
[v]
PW.11- The Judicial First Class Magistrate came to the
Hospital, recorded the statement of the victim/injured, marked as Ex.P15
and obtained Ex.P8 and P9-Certificates from the Doctor as to the mental
condition of the patient.
[vi]
On receipt of medico legal information, on 07.05.2014 mid
night PW.12 recorded the statement of injured/deceased vide Ex.P11. He
has obtained the endorsement of Doctor as to coherent condition of the
victim injured. Ex.P16 is the endorsement of the duty doctor.
[vii]
On the strength of Ex.P11-statement of the victim,
PW.10
registered FIR in Crime No.125 of 2014 for the offences under Sections
498-A, 307 IPC vide Ex.P12, and he came to know that the victim /injured
was shifted to Ruya Hospital, Tirupati. He went there and recorded her
statement under Ex.P13.
Thereafter, PW.10 has visited the scene of
offence, prepared rough sketch of scene of offence under Ex.P14.
[viii]
The deceased died on 12.5.2014 while she was bringing back
to the village, when the Doctors declared that her survival is difficult. The
corpse was brought to the Government Hospital, Kadiri. The matter was
informed to Police. PW.1 submitted Ex.P1- report. On the strength of the
same, the section of law was altered to Section 498-A, 302 IPC by PW13
and the altered FIR is Ex.P17.
[ix]
Further investigation is done by PW14. He has secured the
inquest Panchayatdars – PW3, PW4, PW5 and held inquest over the dead
body of the deceased at Government General Hospital, Kadiri and sent a
requisition for Post-Mortem Examination. Inquest Report is Ex.P18.
[x]
PW.8, Dr.K.N. Vijaya Lakshmi, Civil Assistant Surgeon,
conducted autopsy over the dead body of the deceased and issued Ex.P6Post-Mortem Examination report opining that the cause of death is due to
septicemic shock due to extensive infected burns.
[xi]
PW.14 filed Charge Sheet alleging commission of the offences
punishable under Sections 498-A and 302 IPC.
5.
Accused was tried for the charges under Sections 498-A and 302
IPC on denial.
6.
In support of its case, prosecution examined PWs.1 to 14 and got
marked Ex.P1 to P18 and M.O.1/Kerosene can.
7.
The accused was examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C., he has
denied the incriminating evidence appearing against him.
8.
Learned Sessions Judge convicted the appellant/ accused for the
offence 302 IPC relying on the evidence of PW.12- Assistant Sub-Inspector
of Police, and PW11- Judicial Magistrate, who recorded the Dying
Declaration of the deceased vide Exs.P12 and P15 respectively, observing
that the accused poured kerosene and set the deceased ablaze, and the
evidence of Doctor – PW.9 shows that he was present during recording of
the statements by PW.11 and PW.12 and that the dying declarations
marked under Ex.P15 and Ex.P11 recorded by PW.11 and PW.12 have
corroboration from the evidence of PW.1 and PW.6.
9.
Further, the learned Session Judge observed that, as there is
confirmation of the Doctor as to mental and coherent condition of the
deceased, conviction will sustain even without corroboration, by referring to
the precedents vide Nese Sulthan narayana Swamy Vs. State of Andhra
Pradesh1, and M.Venkata Ramana Vs.State of Andhra Pradesh2.
However, found that the prosecution failed to prove the offence under
Section 498-A IPC as the statement of victim did not reveal about the
demand for money by the accused.
10.
Heard Smt. A.Gayathri Reddy, learned counsel for the appellant and
learned Sri Marri Venkata Ramana, Additional Public Prosecutor appearing
for the respondent-State.
Arguments in the appeal:For the appellant :11.
as to
[i]
There is no consistency between the two Dying Declarations
who set fire and there is a clear contradiction as to whether the
accused set fire or the deceased set fire to herself.
[ii]
There is ample evidence indicating that the accused tried to
save the deceased, putting off the fire, taking to hospital etc., which
indicates the innocence of the accused.
[iii]
There was no motive for the accused to eliminate the
deceased. When the alleged demand for money is not believed, and when
there is acquittal of charge under Section 498A IPC, the motive for the
accused to kill the deceased cannot be believed.
2004 (1) ALT (Crl.) 466 (D.b.) (A.p.)
ALT (Crl.) 444/(204) 2 ALD (cri) 185
[iv]
When there is no consistency between two dying declarations,
both shall be discarded.
For the prosecution:-.
12.
[i]
The deceased and the accused were living together, and the
incident has occurred at the house of the accused.
The presence of the
accused is not denied. Then, the burden lies on the accused to explain as
to what has happened and in the absence of any satisfactory explanation
from the accused, the prosecution case shall be accepted.
[ii]
Though there are two dying declarations, there are common
factors that can be believed i.e., the presence of the accused at the time of
the incident, and the act of accused pouring kerosene on the deceased. All
these would indicate the intention of the accused to commit the offence.
[iii]
The reasoning given by the learned Sessions Judge is
acceptable in the facts and circumstances of the case and that there are no
grounds to interfere.
13.
Perused the material on record.
14.
Thoughtful consideration is given to the arguments advanced by
both sides.
15.
Points that arise for determination in this appeal are -
1) Whether the prosecution is able to bring home the guilt of the
appellant/ accused for the offence under Section 302 IPC, under
which he is charged? And whether the conviction and sentence
imposed by the learned Sessions Judge under the impugned
judgment dated 01.03.2017 passed in S.C.No.340 of 2015 is
sustainable in law and on facts? Or require any interference?
2) What is the result of the appeal?
Point No.1:16.
Relationship between the deceased and the accused and they living
together are not in dispute. Their marriage was performed about 8 years
prior to the incident. Admittedly, Accused was not related to the family of
the deceased prior to the marriage. The evidence of PW1 is that, the
accused poured kerosene on the deceased and his son, and when
deceased tried to escape, he caught hold of tuft of the deceased and
dragged her inside the house, lit the matchbox and set her ablaze. But all
this is hearsay.
She is not an eyewitness to the accident.
She was
informed about the incident by neighbours. Who is that neighbor is not
stated by her.
When she went to the hospital, her daughter was not in a
speaking condition. PW.1 and her husband- PW.6, brought the deceased
to their house, expecting change in the conduct of the accused, but when
the accused asked the deceased to join with him, stating that he will
commit suicide if the deceased do not join him, the deceased was dropped
in matrimonial home.
17.
PW1 and PW6 are not eyewitnesses. They were informed by the
neighbour about the incident and who is that neighbor is not stated by
them.
It is clearly admitted by PW.1 that by the time PW.1 and PW.6
reached the hospital, accused was there and he has taken them to the
deceased; throughout the night, the accused was also there with them and
accompanied them to the hospital at Tirupati, and that he was present with
them when the deceased was brought back from Tirupati hospital.
18.
Evidence of PW6 is in the same lines of PW1, with an addition that
the accused contacted the deceased and asked her to come back,
assuring that she will be treated well, when she was in the house of her
parents. Admittedly no dowry was given at the time of marriage. The
evidence of PW1 and PW6 is, to some extent, natural with regard to the
non-payment of dowry and the presence of accused at the hospital during
the treatment.
19.
PW1 stated that they did not inform the Police about the earlier
disputes, etc.
It is admitted by PW.6 that the accused himself took the
deceased to hospital. It is also stated that the accused sold his auto and
brought the amount to the hospital for the treatment of the deceased. PW6
further stated that, after death of his daughter, they have taken back
whatever articles given and the son of the deceased with them.
20.
PW.2, owner of the house where the deceased and accused were
residing, deposed that when he was in shop, received information that the
accused and deceased were quarrelling and went to the spot, observed the
deceased with burns. He stated that he does not know about the affairs of
the family of the deceased and the accused.
The incident taken place at
about 9.00 or 9.30 p.m. He further stated that he has informed the incident
to the parents of the deceased.
21.
Evidence of PW.1, PW.2 and PW.6 is helpful to note that the
deceased and accused were living together, an incident of fire has
occurred, and that the deceased was shifted to hospital by the accused.
What has happened between the deceased and accused shall be known to
them alone. There are two dying declarations of the deceased.
Earliest
version is recorded by the Judicial First Class Magistrate- PW 11 vide
Ex.P15. Exs.P8 and P9 are the Certificates of the Doctor as to the mental
condition of the patient /deceased at the time of recording statement.
As
per Ex.P15, the accused poured kerosene on the deceased and the
deceased burnt herself; Kerosene was also poured on the son of the
deceased; for the past one month prior to that, accused was consuming
alcohol and there were quarrels. Accused himself has poured the water
and put off the flames. A clear reading of the Dying Declaration, Ex.P15
reveals that Kerosene was poured by the husband/accused, and the
deceased set fire to herself, and the accused himself put off the fire.
22.
Another dying declaration is Ex.P11, was recorded by PW12 -Police
personal.
His evidence is that on 8.5.2014, when he was at home, he has
received information that burn injuries were caused by the husband of the
victim and he went to hospital, recorded Ex.P11 -statement of the
deceased and obtained endorsement Ex.P16 as to the coherent condition
of the patient. He has admitted that by the time he went to the Hospital,
Magistrate was recording statement of the victim.
After completing
recording of the statement by Magistrate, he has recorded the statement of
the victim.
Therefore, the earliest version of the victim is the statement,
recorded by the Magistrate vide Ex.P15. As per Ex.P11 there was quarrel
and accused poured kerosene on the victim / injured /deceased and set
fire; when she raised cries, neighbors came, then accused poured water
and shifted her to hospital.
The version in the statement recorded by the
Magistrate is different as to role of accused.
23.
The statement recorded by the Magistrate -PW11 at about 11.55p.m.
Ex.P13 is another statement of the deceased recorded by PW10- the
Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police. On the strength of Ex.P13, Ex.P12 –FIR
was registered under Sections 498-A, 307 IPC.
As per Ex.P13, the
accused poured kerosene and set fire.
Ex.P13 and Ex.P.11 are in
conformity with each other, whereas Ex.P15 -statement is contradictory as
to the Exs.P11 and P13 with regard to the accused setting fire.
Ex.P15
leads to a clear understanding that the deceased set fire to herself,
whereas the Exs.P11 and P13 shows that the accused set fire to the
deceased.
24.
PW.3, PW.4, PW.5 are the Panch witnesses for the inquest and that
the Panchayatdars during inquest opined that the accused poured
kerosene on the deceased set fire and taken her to hospital. However,
they did not support the prosecution version as to their knowledge about
the contents in the inquest report and stated that for the purpose of
Postmortem Examination, they were asked to sign and put their signatures
vide Exs.P2, P3, P4 and Inquest report was marked under Ex.P18.
25.
PW7-P. Ramanappa is an eyewitness to the observation of the
scene of offence and recovery of the kerosene tin from the scene of
offence, covered by Observation Mahazarnama vide Ex.P5. During the
chief-examination, PW.7 stated that - “I know Lw.11/D.Nabi Rasool. At
about 11.00 a.m. on 10.05 at about one year ago we went to petrol bunk at
Mudigubba where one women by name Nagendramma died by setting
herself ablaze with kerosene.”
26.
The statement of the deceased made to Magistrate, and the
statement of PW.7, clearly suggests that the deceased set ablaze to
herself. There were disputes and strained relationship between the
deceased and accused.
27.
The learned Sessions Judge did not accept the allegation of
harassment for the purpose of Section 498A IPC and acquitted the
accused of the charge under Section 498A IPC, considering the absence
of any demand for money, etc., in the statement of the deceased.
28.
With regard to the allegation that the accused set fire to the
deceased, attracting the commission of culpable homicide amounting to
murder, the earliest statement viz., the dying declaration recorded by the
Magistrate vide Ex.P15-runs counter.
29.
The next aspect is whether the accused is responsible for the
deceased setting herself on fire. If so, the question arises as to the offence
for which the accused is accountable or punishable; however, this is not
the case of the prosecution.
30.
At no stage has it been alleged that the accused has abetted the
commission of suicide. Even the charges framed are only under Section
498A and 302 IPC. Charge under Section 306 is not framed, either in the
alternative or otherwise, by the learned Sessions Judge.
The offence
under Section 302 IPC and the offence under section 306 are entirely
different.
31.
The accused was not put to face the trial for the charge under
section 306 IPC.
Therefore, in the absence of a charge under Section
306 IPC, holding the accused accountable under the said penal provision
does not arise. For a charge under Section 302 IPC, there must be an
intentional act on the part of the accused causing death of the deceased,
attracting the ingredients of Section 300 IPC.
32.
Where multiple dying declarations exist with material inconsistencies,
the declaration recorded by the higher-ranking officer, such as a
Magistrate, is generally regarded as more reliable. The other available
evidence must be examined to corroborate the contents of the dying
declarations and assess their credibility.
33.
The homicidal nature of the death is a serious dispute and the dying
declaration recorded by the Magistrate is not supporting the same. The
conduct of the accused subsequent to the incident as to - putting off the
fire, shifting the deceased to hospital, staying at the hospital throughout the
night at Kadiri and thereafter shifting the injured/deceased to Ruya
Hospital, Tirupati and remaining there till hospital people expressing no
hope and getting her back to village etc., must be considered in assessing
the conduct and intention of the accused. This conduct of the accused,
when viewed in the light of the dying declaration recorded by the
Magistrate under Ex.P15- which reveals that she set fire to herself and that
the accused put off the fire and shifted her to the hospital, the accused
causing homicide cannot be believed.
34.
The statement of PW7 that “he went to the scene of offence, where
the deceased set fire to herself, when the observation of the scene of
offence is prepared”, also plays some significance in the context of the
case to corroborate declaration made by the deceased that she set fire to
herself.
35.
To attract punishment in terms of any other provision of law such as
Section 306 IPC for abetment of suicide etc., no charge has been framed,
nor the accused is put to knowledge of allegations, attracting said
provision.
Therefore, there exists reasonable doubt as to whether the
accused has committed murder of the deceased, particularly when the
homicidal nature of the death itself is not established. The available
circumstances are, accused and deceased living together, quarrel between
them and suicidal death of the deceased.
36.
In this connection, it is relevant to note that the Hon’ble Apex Court
in a catena of judgments including the decision in Sharad Birdhichand
Sarda v. State of Maharashtra3, has laid down five (5) golden principles,
which govern a case based only on circumstantial evidence:
“(1)
The circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is
to be drawn should be fully established.
(2)
The facts so established should be consistent only with
the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say,
they should not be explainable on any other hypothesis
except that the accused is guilty.
(3)
The circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and
tendency.
(4)
They should exclude every possible hypothesis except
the one to be followed, AND
(5)
There must be a chain of evidence so complete as not
to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion
consistent with the innocence of the accused and must
show that in all human probability the act must have
been done by the accused.”
37.
In the facts and circumstances and in light of the of the foregoing
discussion, we find that the prosecution failed to prove the guilt of the
accused/ appellant for the offence under Section 302 IPC, beyond
reasonable doubt. Therefore, he is entitled to the benefit of doubt.
No.1 framed is answered accordingly.
(1981) 4 SCC 116
Point
Point No.2:38.
In the result, the Criminal Appeal is allowed and the conviction and
sentence recorded by the learned Sessions Judge, Ananthapuramu in SC
No.340 of 2015 under the impugned judgment dated 01.03.2017 under
Section 302 IPC is hereby set aside.
The fine amount, if paid by the
accused shall be refunded.
As the appellant/accused was released on bail vide order dated
23.09.2024, in terms of the order of the Composite High Court for the State
of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh in Batchu Ranga Rao Vs.
State of Andhra Pradesh4, he is directed to appear before the concerned
Superintendent of Jail authorities and complete the formalities in terms of
Batchu Ranga Rao’s case. The bail bonds and the sureties, if any, shall
stand cancelled.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in the Criminal Appeal, shall
stand closed.
________________________
JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
__________________________________
JUSTICE A.HARI HARANADHA SARMA
Date: 09.04.2026
Pnr
2016(3) ALT (crl.) 505 (DB) (A.P.)
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.SURESH REDDY
And
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
(per Hon’ble Sri Justice A. Hari Haranadha Sharma)
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 2563 of 2018
Date: 09.04.2026
Pnr
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review