Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P. (C) No. 48 of 2020
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------D.B.: HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Writ Petition (Civil) No. 48 of 2020
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited,
Represented by Samik Sarkar,
Attorney Holder of Glenmark,
Pharmaceuticals Limited,
Samlik-Marchak,
Industrial Growth Centre, Near Ranipool,
East Sikkim, Sikkim – 737 135.
.… Petitioner
versus
1. Union of India,
Through the Secretary,
Department of Revenue,
Ministry of Finance,
North Block, New Delhi – 110 001.
2. Director, Department for Promotion of
Industry and Internal Trade,
Ministry of Commerce and Industry,
Udyog Bhawan,
New Delhi – 110 001.
3. The Assistant Commissioner,
Central Goods & Service Tax,
Gangtok Division, Gangtok,
Indra By-Pass Road, Near District Court,
Sichey, East Sikkim, Gangtok – 737 101.
4. The Commissioner of CGST,
Siliguri, Gangtok Division,
Gangtok II Range – 737 101.
…. Respondents
-------------------------------------------------------------------------Application under Article 226 and 227 of the Constitution of
India
Appearance:
Mr. Rahul Tangri and Mr. Aditya Makkhim Advocates for the
Petitioner.
Mr. Ajay Rathi, Senior Standing Counsel with Mr. Dilip
Kumar Agarwal, Junior Standing Counsel for the
Respondents.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 48 of 2020
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
Date of hearing
Date of pronouncement
:
:
19.11.2021.
24.11.2021.
JUDGMENT
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J
1.
The dispute in the present writ petition lies in a narrow
compass and relates to the rejection of the petitioners claims for
budgetary support under a “Scheme of Budgetary Support under
Goods and Service Tax” regime on the ground that the claims were
made
for
the
period
prior
to
the
registration
which
is
impermissible.
2.
The writ petitioner is engaged in the manufacture and supply
of pharmaceutical products at their unit situated in Sikkim. They
seek to challenge four orders, all dated 05.12.2019 (the impugned
orders), passed by the Assistant Commissioner, Central Goods and
Service Tax, Gangtok Division, Gangtok rejecting the four claims
for budgetary support for four quarters filed by the petitioner
under Notification No. 10(1)/2017-DBA-II/NER dated 05.10.2017
(notification dated 05.10.2017) for the period July, 2017 to June,
2018.
3.
The impugned orders record that the petitioner has been
assigned
with
the
unique
ID
(UID)
registration
number
UNQSBS11AAACG2207L1Z50001 upon validating them to be
eligible for “Scheme of Budgetary Support under GST” (the
scheme) in terms of CBEC Circular No. 1060/9/2017-CX dated
27.11.2017 (Circular dated 27.11.2017) read with Notification
dated 05.10.2017. Thus, as rightly contended by Mr. Rahul
Tangri, Learned Counsel for the petitioner, that the petitioner was
eligible under the scheme is not in controversy.
W.P. (C) No. 48 of 2020
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
4.
The impugned orders records that the petitioner filed an
application dated 02.11.2018 in terms of paragraph 7.1 of the
scheme in the prescribed format claiming budgetary support for
the quarters ending September, 2017, December, 2017, March,
2018 and June, 2018 in relation to supply of specified goods. The
petitioner had been issued UID on 31.10.2018 whereas they have
claimed for budgetary support for the period prior to the issuance
of
UID
in
terms
of
Notification
dated
05.10.2017
which
mandatorily required pre-registration. Further, as per paragraph
7.1 claim for budgetary support is required to be submitted by the
15th of succeeding month after end of quarter after payment of tax
relating to the quarter to which the claim relates. However, as per
show-cause notice issued dated 28.06.2019 it has been alleged
that the petitioner availed ineligible TRAN 1 credit which is yet to
be proved otherwise by them. As per the impugned orders since
the petitioner had not complied with the provision of the
notification dated 05.10.2017 their claim for budgetary support
under the scheme is liable to be rejected.
5.
The respondents’ counter affidavit takes a stand that the
claim for budgetary support for the period July, 2017 to June,
2018 was filed belatedly in violation of Notification dated
05.10.2017. It is contended that as per the Notification dated
05.10.2017 to claim budgetary benefit, one must have UID
number which as per records was allocated on 31.10.2018 against
the online application filed by the petitioner. The respondents also
clarify that although in annexure P-8 the date of approval of the
UID is mentioned as 31.07.2018 it is in fact 31.10.2018. It is thus
W.P. (C) No. 48 of 2020
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
contended that despite getting UID number on 31.10.2018, the
petitioners have made their claims only on 02.11.2018 for the
period from July, 2017 to June, 2018 which period is prior to the
allocation of UID to the petitioner.
6.
Notification dated 05.10.2017 is a Scheme of Budgetary
Support under Goods and Service Tax regime to the units located
in the States of Jammu and Kashmir, Uttarakhand, Himachal
Pradesh and North East including Sikkim. In pursuance of the
decision of the Government of India to provide budgetary support
to the existing eligible manufacturing units operating in the above
named states under different industrial promotion schemes of the
Government of India, for a residual period for which each of the
units is eligible, a scheme was introduced as a measure of good
will. To the extent of the present controversy clause 7 and 8 are
the relevant clauses of the Notification dated 05.10.2017 dealing
with manner of budgetary support. It is quoted below:“7. MANNER OF BUDGETARY SUPPORT
7.1 The manufacturer shall file an application
for payment of budgetary support for the Tax
paid in cash, other than the amount of Tax paid
by utilization of Input Tax credit under the Input
Tax Credit Rule, 2017, to the Assistant
Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner of
Central Taxes, as the case may be, by the 15 th
day of the succeeding month after end of
quarter after payment of tax relating to the
quarter to which the claim relates.
7.2 The Assistant Commissioner or Deputy
Commissioner of Central Taxes, as the case
may be, after such examination of the
application as may be necessary, shall
sanction reimbursement of the budgetary
support. The sanctioned amount shall be
W.P. (C) No. 48 of 2020
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
conveyed to the applicant electronically. The
PAO, CBEC will sanction and disburse the
recommended reimbursement of budgetary
support.
8. BUDGETARY PROVISION AND PAYMENT
OF AMOUNT OF BUDGETARY SUPPORT
8.1 The budgetary support shall be disbursed
from budgetary allocation of Department of
Industrial Policy & Promotion (DIPP), Ministry of
Commerce & Industry. DIPP shall keep such
budgetary allocations on the disposal of PAO,
CBEC. The eligible units shall obtain one time
registration on the ACES-GST portal and obtain
a unique ID which is to be used for all
processing of claims under the scheme. The
application
by
the
eligible
unit
for
reimbursement of budgetary support shall be
filed on the ACES-GST portal with reference to
unique ID obtained and shall be processed by
the Deputy Commissioner or Assistant
Commissioner of the Central Tax for sanction of
the admissible amount of budgetary support.
8.2 The application for reimbursement of
budgetary support shall be made by the eligible
unit after the payment of CGST/IGST has been
made for the quarter to which the claim relates,
in cash in respect of specified goods after
utilization of Input Tax credit, if any.”
7.
Reading clause 7 and 8 together it is clear that the petitioner
was required to obtain one time registration on the ACES-GST
portal and obtain UID which is to be used for processing of all
claims under the scheme.
8.
On 27.11.2017 the Central Board of Excise and Customs
issued a communication prescribing the procedure for manual
disbursal of budgetary support under the Goods and Service Tax
regime to the eligible units. It was stated that the Department of
Industrial
Policy
and
Promotion
(DIPP),
the
administrative
department, had issued Notification dated 05.10.2017 which had
W.P. (C) No. 48 of 2020
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
come into operation with effect from 01.07.2017 and shall remain
in operation for the residual period. Budgetary support under the
scheme shall be worked out on quarterly basis and claims for the
same shall also be filed on a quarterly basis. It was also specified
that the eligible units was required to obtain one time registration
and file an application for payment of budgetary support which
shall be processed by the Deputy/Assistant Commissioner of the
Central Taxes for sanction of the admissible amount. The sanction
amount shall be credited into bank accounts of the beneficiaries
through PFMS platform of the Central Government. Paragraph 6
thereof, which is pressed by the petitioner, states that the claim
for the quarter ending September, 2017 has already become due.
In order to mitigate the difficulties of the eligible units, it has been
decided that units would be registered on the basis of application
filed by them manually and application of claim for budgetary
support for the said quarter would also be filed and processed
manually. The approval of the registration for the scheme and
processing of the application for budgetary support for the quarter
shall also be undertaken manually by the jurisdictional Deputy
Commissioner/Assistant Commissioner of the Central Tax. The
sanctioned amount shall be credited to the bank accounts of the
beneficiaries through the PFMS platform in a manner fully
compliant with the direct transfer of the benefit to the account of
the assesse.
9.
The communication dated 27.11.2017 also provided the
Standard Operating Procedure for the claims relating to the first
W.P. (C) No. 48 of 2020
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
quarter ending September, 2017 in paragraph 8 and
9 thereof.
They are quoted below:“8. Registration of the eligible units under
the scheme
(i) The application for registration under the
scheme by the eligible units shall be submitted
in triplicate in the format attached to this
circular. The application shall be signed by the
proprietor/partner/managing director of the
eligible unit or by the person authorized by him
in this behalf and support by the selfauthenticated copies of the documents in
support of information as per the application.
The registration under GST is a necessary prerequisite for the scheme.
(ii) In case more than one eligible unit is
operating under the same GSTIN, separate
registration is required to be obtained for each
of the eligible units.
(iii)The
jurisdictional
Deputy
Commissioner/Assistant Commissioner of the
Central Taxes would examine the application in
terms of the scheme as notified on the basis of
documents submitted along with the application
for registration.
(iv) A unique ID for each of the eligible units
shall be allotted after registration and ID shall
be indicated in the following manner:- sl.no/
name of the Central Tax Division/name of the
Commissionerate/GSTIN. The ID shall be
endorsed on all the three copies of the
application.
(v) It shall be ensured by the jurisdictional
Divisional Officer that record of registration is
maintained against the sl. no. which is part of
the unique ID.
(vi) The second copy of the application after
registration of the eligible unit under an official
communication shall be forwarded to the DDO
of the Division for registration of the unit under
PFMS. This would ensure validation of the
Bank Account details of the beneficiary. This
exercise should be completed within 3 days of
receipt of the copy of application by the DDO.
(vii) The third copy of the application after
registration shall be forwarded to the ADG, DG
W.P. (C) No. 48 of 2020
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
Audit, Delhi who in turn would be providing the
details to programme division (PD) of DIPP in a
compiled manner. The DIPP on the basis of
these details shall draw a programme for
inspection of the eligible unit by a team
constituted
by
them.
Jurisdictional
Commissionerate of CGST shall provide
necessary assistance in carrying out the
inspection. Immediately after completion of
inspection copy of Inspection report would be
forwarded
to
the
Assistant/Deputy
Commissioner having jurisdiction over the
eligible unit.
9. Submission of application for budgetary
support by the eligible unit for quarter
ending September, 2017 and its sanction
(i) An eligible unit after allotment of the Unique
Id may file an application for claiming
budgetary support under the provisions of para
5.7 of the scheme in the format attached to this
circular. The application shall be filed by the
eligible unit only after return for the quarter has
been filed and tax as per return is paid.
(ii) Once application is filed, duly supported by
the prescribed document, the same shall be
processed for sanction. The claim shall be
sanctioned after verification of the tax paid by
the eligible unit. The details relating to tax
payment in cash and input tax credit availed,
utilized including purchases made form a
composition dealer during the quarter shall be
available in the GST returns of the taxpayer,
which are available on the CBEC GST
application for verification of the application for
the budgetary support filed by the unit. The
closing of the credit after end of the quarter
shall also be provided for verification by the
Assistant/Deputy Commissioner.
(iii) In cases where an entity is carrying out its
operation in a State from multiple business
premises, in addition to manufacture of
specified goods by the eligible unit, under the
same GSTIN as that of the eligible unit, the
application for budgetary support shall be
supported by additional information duly
certified by a Chartered Accountant, relating to
receipt of inputs (receipt from composition
dealer to be indicated separately), input tax
credit involved on the inputs or capital goods
received by the eligible units vis-à-vis the
inputs, input tax credit availed and specified
W.P. (C) No. 48 of 2020
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
goods supplied by the registrant under the
given GSTIN.
In such case, on the basis of additional
information and the refund application the
jurisdictional Deputy Commissioner/Assistant
Commissioner shall ensure the budgetary
support is limited to the tax paid in cash after
utilization of the input tax credit on the
specified goods manufactured by the eligible
unit. The return filed by the unit may be
covering the entire transactions taking place
outside the eligible unit in the same GSTIN.
(iv) Further, in cases where the other units
operating under same GSTIN, is supplying the
inputs to the eligible unit as such or after
manufacture, the credit availed by supplying
unit on the inputs would have to be factored for
determining the input tax credit of the eligible
unit. The information in terms of para 5.9.2 of
the scheme is required to be submitted by the
eligible unit duly certified by a Chartered
Accountant.
The
jurisdictional
Deputy/
Assistant Commissioner in such cases shall
sanction the budgetary support after reducing
input tax credit relatable to inputs used by the
supplying unit under same GSTIN without
payment of tax as certified by a Chartered
Accountant.
(v) Para 5.8 of the scheme defines the scope of
manufacture by the eligible unit. The eligible
unit shall also indicate the value addition
achieved by it in respect of each category of
specified goods and where the value addition is
higher than the limit provided in the table under
the said para, the sanction of the claim shall be
after verification of the value addition.
(vi) Para 6 of the scheme provides for
inspection of the eligible unit by a team
constituted by DIPP and the findings of the
team shall be provided to the Deputy/Assistant
Commissioner before sanction of the claim of
budgetary support. However, in cases where
inspection cannot be conducted the budgetary
support
amount
may
be
sanctioned
provisionally for a period of six months.”
10. From the circular dated 27.11.2017 it is clear that although
the claim for the quarter ending September, 2017 had already
become due “In order to mitigate the difficulties of the eligible
W.P. (C) No. 48 of 2020
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
units” it was decided that those eligible units would be registered
on the basis of application filed by them manually and application
for claim for budgetary support for the said quarter (i.e., quarter
ending September, 2017) would also be filed and processed
manually. Reading the Standard Operating Procedure even for the
first quarter ending September, 2017 it is clear that registration
under the GST is a necessary prerequisite for the scheme and the
UID would be issued only after registration. It is also seen that an
eligible unit could file an application for claiming budgetary
support for the quarter ending September, 2017 only after
allotment of the UID. On 12.12.2017 the petitioner made a manual
application for registration under the scheme to the Respondent
No. 3. The application is marked as annexure P-7 by the
petitioner. According to the petitioner this application was filed by
relevant documents for obtaining registration and UID under the
scheme. It is seen that there is a stamp of the authority along with
the date “12.12.2017” and signature thereon. The respondents in
their counter affidavit do not specifically deny receipt of the
application. However, an argument is sought to be made that if
such an application is presumed to have been made even then the
petitioner failed to follow up the application. Quite evidently, the
manual application 12.12.2017, although permitted under the
circular dated 27.11.2017, was not processed for registration by
the respondents.
11.
Faced with this situation, the petitioner made an online
application when the respondents provided the facility for filing
application by activating the same in the GST portal. Admittedly,
the registration and UID was allotted to petitioner on 31.10.2018.
W.P. (C) No. 48 of 2020
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
12.
On 05.10.2018 the Central Board of Excise and Customs
issued another circular regarding online registration and online
filing and processing of claims. It reiterated that eligible units were
required to obtain one time registration on the ACES-GST portal
and obtain an UID which should be used for filing application by
the eligible units for reimbursement of budgetary support. It also
stated that it had been decided that units may be registered for
the scheme on the basis of manual application and claim for
quarter ending September, 2017 was also directed to be filed and
processed and manually. As per the circular dated 05.10.2018 the
same stand replicated and registration of units and filing of claims
upto quarter ending June, 2018 is taking place manually.
13.
Thus, all the four claims of the petitioner were to be made
manually.
14.
According to the petitioners pursuant to the circular
05.10.2018
the
petitioner
filed
four
applications
all
dated
02.11.2018 for the four quarters of the period July, 2017 to June,
2018 for claiming budgetary support before the Respondent No. 3
along with various documents in support thereof. On an oral
direction the petitioner also filed the four claims electronically on
the ACES-GST portal on 22.08.2019. The factum of the manual
claims being made on 02.11.2018 and the electronic claims on
22.08.2019 are not disputed by the respondents.
15.
The impugned orders was thereafter passed on 05.12.2019
rejecting the claim of the petitioner on the grounds that the claims
made for the period prior to the issuance of UID is not
maintainable.
W.P. (C) No. 48 of 2020
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
16.
Mr. Rahul Tangri’s submission that the uncontroverted facts
would reflect that the failure to register the admittedly eligible unit
of the petitioner and issue the UID was the respondents’ failure
and for no fault of the petitioner is correct. Quite evidently
although the application for registration and issuance of UID made
by the petitioner had been received by the respondent No. 3 on
12.12.2017, the authority neither registered the petitioner nor
rejected the application compelling the petitioner to reapply for the
same electronically pursuant to which registration and UID was
granted on 31.10.2018. The fact that registration and UID was
granted makes it evident that the petitioner was eligible for the
budgetary
support
under
the
scheme.
Quite
clearly
the
Respondent No. 3 failed to process the application for registration
as required. Since, the Respondent No. 3 failed to grant the
registration to the petitioner, although it was an eligible unit, the
petitioner could not have made their claims for budgetary support
before being allotted the UID. When the Respondent No. 3
registered the petitioner and allotted the UID on 31.10.2018, just
two days after, on 02.11.2018, the petitioner made all the four
claims for the four quarters. The impugned orders rejected the
petitioner claim for budgetary support on that sole ground without
examining the application as to how much of the amount claimed
was liable to be sanctioned as admissible amount of budgetary
support. The stand of the respondents is fallacious. It is not only
without substance but clearly illegal in as much as it sought to
take advantage of its own wrong and deprive the petitioner of its
rights under the scheme. Once an unit is found to be an eligible
unit the only question kept open to the authorities is the
W.P. (C) No. 48 of 2020
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors.
admissible amount of budgetary support from the claims made by
the eligible unit on compliance of the requirement of the scheme.
We are thus of the firm view that the impugned orders are liable to
be set aside. It is accordingly so ordered. As the respondents have
rejected the claims of the petitioner on the technical ground as
stated above it is directed that the authorities shall process the
four claims made by the petitioner for budgetary support and
sanction reimbursements as found eligible within three months
from the date of this judgment. These claims have been made by
the petitioner vide their four manual applications Exhibit-P10
(colly), Exhibit-P11 (colly), Exhibit-P12 (colly), Exhibit-P13 (colly)
and 02.11.2018 and electronic applications Exhibit-P14 (colly),
Exhibit-P15 (colly), Exhibit-P16 (colly), Exhibit-P17 (colly) for the
quarter July, 2017 to September, 2017; October, 2017 to
December, 2017; January, 2018 to March, 2018 and April, 2018
to June, 2018.
17.
The writ petition is allowed to the above extent. The parties
shall bear their respective cost.
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
sdl/
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
(Meenakshi Madan Rai)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review