Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited, represented
by Soumaya Dutt, Site Head (Attorney Holder)
for the petitioner,
Samlik- Marchak, Industrial Growth Centre,
Near Ranipool, East Sikkim,
Sikkim- Pin Code – 737 135
….. Petitioner
Versus
1.
Union of India,
Through the Secretary,
Department of Revenue,
Ministry of Finance,
North Block, New Delhi – 110 001.
2.
Director, Department for Promotion of
Industry and Internal Trade,
Ministry of Commerce and Industry,
Udyog Bhawan, New Delhi-Pin Code 110 011.
3.
The Assistant Commissioner, Central Goods &
Service Tax, Gangtok Division, Gangtok,
Indira By-Pass Road, Near District Court, Sichey,
East Sikkim, Gangtok-737 101.
4.
The Commissioner of CGST,
Siliguri, Gangtok Division,
Gangtok II Range 737 102.
….. Respondents
------------------------------------------------------------------------------Application under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India.
(Order No.307/BS/GST/GTK-DIV/2021-22 dated 01.03.2022 issued
vide C.No. V(18) 229/GST/BS/Glenmark/Gtk-Div/2020-21/3000
passed by the Ld. Assistant Commissioner, Central Goods & Service
Tax, Gangtok Division, Gangtok).
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
Appearance:
Mr. Rahul Tangri, Ms. Gita Bista, Ms. Pratikcha
Gurung, Advocates. Ms. Tanya Roy (through V.C.) and
Mr. Dipendra Chettri, Advocates (through V.C.) for the
Petitioner.
Ms. Sangita Pradhan, Deputy Solicitor General of
India (through V.C.) assisted by Ms.Natasha Pradhan,
Advocates. Ms. Manasi Mukherjee Advocate (through
V.C.) for the Respondents.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing
:
28.03.2024 & 01.04.2024
Date of Judgment
:
06.05.2024
JUDGMENT
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
1.
The
rejection
of
the
petitioner’s
claim
for
budgetary support for the period July-September, 2017
even while its claim for October, 2017 to June, 2018 was
allowed under the “Scheme of budgetary support under
Goods and Services Tax Regime” to the units located in
States of Jammu & Kashmir, Uttarakhand, Himachal
Pradesh
and
North
East
including
Sikkim
dated
05.10.2017 (the Budgetary Support Scheme) has led to the
present litigation.
2.
The question which seeks determination in the
present writ petition is whether the budgetary support
claimed by the petitioner for the month of July 2017 and
August 2017 separately in their initial applications ought to
have
been
favourably
considered
by
the
Assistant
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
Commissioner, Central Goods & Service Tax (respondent
no.3) although as per the respondent no.3 the Budgetary
Support Scheme envisaged working it out on a quarterly
basis on claims to be filed on quarterly basis.
3.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that there was a violation of principles of natural justice as
the
same
has
been
passed
without
granting
any
opportunity of personal hearing to the petitioner. The
Budgetary Support Scheme provides the manner in which
the claims can be made and determined. The initial orders
of rejection passed by the respondent no. 3 had been set
aside by this Court and thereafter, the claims of the
petitioner were re-examined. Pursuant thereto out of the
four claims made by the petitioner for four quarters, three
claims were accepted and budgetary support granted. The
petitioner
has
no
grievance
against
non
grant
of
opportunity of hearing for those quarters for which their
claims were accepted and budgetary support granted. In
spite of the petitioner having not fulfilled the requirement of
the Budgetary Support Scheme to make their claims for the
quarter opportunity was granted to them to resubmit their
applications for budgetary support. Pursuant thereto the
petitioner claims to have submitted fresh applications for
budgetary support for the four quarters out of which
budgetary support was granted for three quarters.
In the
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
circumstances this Court is of the view that there has been
no violation of principles of natural justice.
4.
The learned counsel for the petitioner also
contends that the petitioner had satisfied all the conditions
of the Budgetary Support Scheme but was denied on its
erroneous
interpretation
and
of
the
Circular
dated
27.11.2017 and Circular dated 10.01.2019 issued by the
Central Board of Excise and Customs. Attention was drawn
to paragraph 5.1 and 5.6 of the Budgetary Support
Scheme. The petitioner’s contention that therefore, the
petitioner claimed budgetary support for the month of July
2017 and August 2017 but did not claim for the month of
September 2017 since no IGST was paid in cash for that
month. It is their contention that the petitioner’s separate
claims for the months of July 2017 and August 2017 was
in terms of Circular dated 10.01.2019. The petitioner
contends that reliance placed on Circular dated 27.11.2017
is misplaced and incorrect. It is contended that Circular
dated 27.11.2017 allows adjusting the balance of ITC
against IGST paid in cash but does not allow aggregation of
figures for the entire quarter. It is submitted that reliance
placed on format and formula of the Circular dated
27.11.2017
is
incorrect
and
cannot
supersede
the
Budgetary Support Scheme. Relying upon the judgment of
the Supreme Court in Commissioner of Central Excise,
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
Bolpur vs. Ratan Melting and Wire Industries 1 it is
submitted that any circular which is contrary to the
statutory provisions has no existence in law. The petitioner
also contends that the interpretation of the Budgetary
Support Scheme by the authorities expects the petitioner to
perform an impossibility and thereby in violation of the
GST law. The petitioner contends that the balance of ITC at
the end of September 2017 was carried forward to October
2017, November 2017 and December 2017, thereby being
utilized for payment of taxes in the said months which in
turn reduced the claim for budgetary support for the
months of October 2017, November 2017 and December
2017.
It is the petitioner’s case that the petitioner is
entitled to interest on account of delay in sanction of
budgetary claim as well.
5.
The learned Deputy Solicitor General of India
appearing for the respondents draws attention of this Court
to paragraphs 3.2, 5.1, 5.4 of the Budgetary Support
Scheme as well as paragraph 9(ii) of the Circular dated
27.11.2017 and submits that a combined reading of these
provisions requires that as per the formula, whatever
balance of ITC of CGST/IGST is available at the end of
quarter, the same is to be deducted from the cash payment
1 (2008) 13 SCC 1
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
for calculation of budgetary support claim for the quarter.
It is pointed out that the petitioner has not challenged the
Circular dated 27.11.2017 and Circular dated 10.01.2019.
It is submitted that since the petitioner themselves had
claimed budgetary support in the negative there was no
need for any personal hearing. It is also submitted that the
Budgetary Support Scheme does not envisage grant of any
interest as claimed by the petitioner. It is the submission of
the respondents that the budgetary support under the
Budgetary Support Scheme is in the nature of grant and
not refund of duty under taxation law.
6.
The writ petition does neither challenge the
Budgetary Support Scheme and specifically the mandate of
paragraph 5.4 thereof nor the two circulars i.e. circular
dated 27.11.2017 and Circular dated 10.01.2019 issued by
the Central Board of Excise and Customs.
In fact it is
contended that respondent no.3 has rejected the claim for
budgetary support in contravention of the Budgetary
Support Scheme and the two circulars. Let us therefore
examine the Budgetary Support Scheme and the Circular
dated 27.11.2017 and Circular dated 10.01.2019.
7.
Determination of the amount of the budgetary
support under the Budgetary Support Scheme was to be
done in the manner provided under paragraph 5 thereof.
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
8.
Paragraph 5 of the Budgetary Support Scheme
has several sub-paragraphs from 5.1 to 5.9.2. The relevant
sub-paragraphs as pointed out by the learned counsel for
the parties are reproduced below:
“5.1
The amount of budgetary support under the scheme for
specified goods manufactured by the eligible unit shall be sum
total of(i)
58% of the Central tax paid through debit in the cash
ledger account maintained by the unit in terms of sub-section (1)
of section 49 the Central Goods and Services Act, 2017 after
utilization of the Input tax credit of the Central Tax and
Integrated Tax.
(ii)
29% of the integrated tax paid through debit in the cash
ledger account maintained by the unit in terms of section 20 of
the Integrated Goods and Services Act, 2017 after utilization of
the Input tax credit Tax of the Central Tax and Integrated Tax.
Provided where inputs are procured from a registered person
operating under the Composition Scheme under Section 10 of
the Central Goods and Services Act, 2017 the amount i.e. sum
total of (i) & (ii) above shall be reduced by the same percentage
as
is
the
percentage
value
of
inputs
procured
under
Composition scheme out of total value of inputs procured.
Explanation:Explanation-I. ..........
Explanation-II
(a)
Calculation of (ii) shall be followed by calculation of (i)
(b)
To avail benefit of this scheme, eligible unit shall first
utilize input tax credit of Central tax and Integrated tax and
balance of liability, if any, shall be paid in cash and where this
condition is not fulfilled, the reimbursement sanctioning officer
shall reduce the amount of budgetary support payable to the
extent credit of Central tax and integrated tax, is not utilized for
payment of tax.
5.2.
..........
5.3.
Notwithstanding,
the
rescinding
of
the
exemption
notifications listed under para 2 above, the limitations,
conditions and prohibitions under the respective notifications
issued by Department of Revenue as they existed immediately
before 01.07.2017 would continue to be applicable under this
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
scheme.
However,
the
provisions
relating
to
facility
of
determination of special rate under the respective exemption
notifications would not apply under this scheme.
5.4.
Budgetary support under this scheme shall be worked
out on quarterly basis for which claims shall be filed on a
quarterly basis namely for January to March, April to June,
July to September & October to December.
5.5.
..........
5.6.
The grant of budgetary support under the scheme shall
be subject to compliance of provisions relating to any other law
in force.
...”
9.
Paragraph 5.4 of the Budgetary Support Scheme
provided that the budgetary support shall be worked out on
quarterly basis for which claims shall be filed on a
quarterly basis namely for January to March, April to June,
July to September and October to December.
10.
When the petitioner made the claims for the four
quarters as above, four Orders dated 05.12.2019 were
passed rejecting all the claims of the petitioner on the
ground that claims made for the period prior to the
issuance of unique ID (UID) is not maintainable. This was
challenged by the petitioner in Writ Petition (C) No. 48 of
2020 Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. vs. Union of India &
Ors.2. The Division Bench of this Court vide Judgment
dated 24.11.2021 set aside those Orders with the direction
to the authorities to process the four claims made by the
petitioner
for
budgetary
2 2021 SCC OnLine Sikk 176
support
and
sanction
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
reimbursements as found eligible within three months from
the date of the judgment. Pursuant thereto the respondent
no.3 vide three orders, all dated 01.03.2022 sanctioned
various amounts as budgetary support for three quarters
i.e. October, 2017 to December, 2017, January 2018 to
March, 2018, April 2018 to June, 2018.
11.
However,
the
respondent
No.307/BS/GST/GTK-DIV/2021-22
no.3
vide
Order
dated
01.03.2022
(impugned order) informed the petitioner that he had
sanctioned Rs.0/-(Rupees zero) only to the petitioner as
budgetary support for goods cleared by the petitioner
during the quarter - July 2017 to September, 2017 in
terms of paragraph 7.2 read with paragraph 6.1 of the
Budgetary Support Scheme read with Circular dated
27.11.2017 as the petitioner has claimed budgetary
support of Rs.(-)9,24,99,472/- (Rupees Nine Crores Twenty
Four Lakhs Ninety Nine Thousand Four Hundred and
Seventy Two) in the negative. According to the impugned
Order the computation of the budgetary support had been
made as per the data in statutory documents submitted by
the petitioner.
12.
The Budgetary Support Scheme was introduced
on 05.10.2017.
13.
On 27.11.2017 Circular No.1060/9/2017-CX
was issued by the Central Board of Excise and Customs
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
regarding procedure for manual disbursal of budgetary
support under Goods and Service Tax Regime to the units
located in States of Jammu & Kashmir, Uttarakhand,
Himachal Pradesh and North East including Sikkim. It
mentioned that budgetary support under the Budgetary
Support Scheme shall be worked out on quarterly basis
and claims for the same shall also be filed on a quarterly
basis viz. April to June, July to September, October to
December and January to March. It was also stated that
the manner and method of determination of amount of
budgetary support, recovery procedure thereof etc. has
been enumerated in the Budgetary Support Scheme. It was
pointed
out
in
paragraph
of
the
circular
dated
27.11.2017 that the claim for quarter ending September,
2017 has already become due. In order to mitigate the
difficulties of the eligible units, it has been decided that
units would be registered on the basis of application filed
by them manually and application for claim of budgetary
support for the quarter would also be filed and processed
manually. It was further pointed out that the approval of
the registration for the Budgetary Support Scheme and
processing of the application for budgetary support for the
quarter
shall
also
be
undertaken
manually
by
the
jurisdiction Deputy Commissioner/Assistant Commission
of the Central Tax. The circular dated 27.11.2017 also
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
provided
forms
for
registration
of
eligible
units
for
budgetary support and application for budgetary support.
The form for application for budgetary support inter alia
sought information from the petitioner of the amount of
total tax paid during the quarter in respect of Goods and
Services Tax Identification Number (GSTIN).
14.
On
10.01.2019
Circular
No.1068/1/2019-CX
dated 10.01.2019 was issued by the Central Board of
Indirect Taxes and Customs regarding review of progress of
implementation of Budgetary Support Scheme to eligible
industrial units located in States of Jammu & Kashmir,
Uttarakhand, Himachal Pradesh and North East including
Sikkim. Paragraph 5 of the circular dated 10.01.2019
sought to meet the issue regarding difficulty in verification
of the refund claim raised by the Chief Commissioner
(Shillong). It was pointed out that as per the procedure in
place an assessee files monthly returns under the GST
whereas refund application is for the quarter. Accordingly,
as per the circular dated 10.01.2019, it was decided that in
the table annexed to the refund application month wise
details may be attached. This, according to the circular
dated
10.01.2019,
would
enable
speedier
and
more
accurate verification of the refund claims. Admittedly, the
petitioner filed the claims for budgetary support in both
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
offline and thereafter online mode between the period
02.11.2018 and 22.08.2019.
15.
The Budgetary Support Scheme clearly mandated
that it should be worked out on quarterly basis for which
claims shall be filed on a quarterly basis. Although the
Circular dated 27.11.2017 permitted manual application
for budgetary support for the quarter ending September,
2017 it did not digress from the mandate of paragraph 5.4
of the Budgetary Support Scheme requiring the filing of the
claim on quarterly basis and working the same out also on
quarterly basis. The Circular dated 10.01.2019 permitted
the assessee to provide month wise details in the table
annexed to the refund application to enable speedier and
accurate verification of the refunds claims. This circular
was also issued to resolve, inter alia, an issue regarding
difficulty in verification of the refund claim as raised by the
Chief Commissioner (Shillong). It is evident that the
circular dated 10.01.2019 was issued to make easier the
process of verification of refund claim by the authorities as
an assessee would file monthly returns under the GST
whereas the refund application is for the quarter. It did not
permit the assessee to make monthly claims as opposed to
the mandate of paragraph 5.4 of the Budgetary Support
Scheme.
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
16.
The petitioner however, admittedly did not follow
the budgetary scheme or the instructions of the two
Circulars dated 27.11.2017 and 10.01.2019 and file the
claim application on a quarterly basis. Instead the
petitioner filed separate claims for the month of July 2017
and August 2017 under one covering letter. By this process
the petitioner claimed budgetary support of Rs.16,88,693/(Rupees Sixteen Lakhs Eighty Eight Thousand Six Hundred
and Ninety Three) for July 2017 and Rs.1,54,00,360/(Rupees One Crore Fifty Four Lakhs Three Hundred and
Sixty) for August, 2017.
No claim for budgetary support
was made for September 2017.
17.
The Circular dated 27.11.2017 required that the
claim for budgetary support to be calculated in the manner
provided therein. This Circular dated 27.11.2017 is not
contrary
to
the
Budgetary
Support
Scheme
but
in
furtherance thereof. Claim for budgetary support was to be
calculated in the following order:
“(a)
Budgetary support in respect of intra-state
supplies + {(CGST in cash Balance of (ITC of CGST
+ITC of IGST)) * 58%) * (1-Value under (G)}/ Value
under (F)
(b)
Budgetary support in respect of inter-state
supplies {(IGST in cash - balance # of (ITC of IGST +
ITC of CGST)) * 29%) * (1-Value under (G)}/Value
under (F).
# Balance to be taken under (b) after excluding
amount considered under (a) above
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
(c)
18.
Total Budgetary Support (a) + (b)”
According to the petitioner after the submission
of the initial applications for budgetary support the
department orally directed the petitioner to resubmit the
applications for claiming budgetary support through the
online portal pursuant to which the petitioner filed four
separate online applications claiming budgetary support for
the four quarters i.e. July 2017 to June 2018 on
22.08.2019. For the quarter July 2017 to September 2017
the application provided the following details:8. Claim of Budgetary Support based on S. No. above to be calculated
in following order
(a)
Budgetary Support in respect of Intra-State supplies=
{CGST in cash-Balance of (ITC of CGST + ITC of IGST)) *
58%) * (1-Value under (G)/Value under (F)}
{0-(125963822+0))*58%)*(1-0/110896468)
=
(b)
-7,30,59,017
Budgetary Support in respect of Inter-State supplies=
{IGST in cash-Balance of (ITC of IGST + ITC of CGST)) *
29%) * (1-Value under (G)/Value under (F)}
{58927769-(0+125963822))*29%)*(1-0/110896468)
(c)
19.
=
-1,94,40,455
Total Budgetary Support = (a) + (b):-
-9,24,99,472
In the impugned Order dated 01.03.2022 the
same calculation made by the petitioner in its application
has been approved as verified from the data in statutory
documents submitted by the petitioner.
20.
During the arguments the learned counsel for
the petitioner sought to suggest that this application was
filed on the persistence of the authorities and not
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
voluntarily. However, in the writ petition what has been
stated is that the applications were filed on the oral
direction of the authorities to resubmit the applications.
The petitioner has not indicated that the application
provided incorrect information or that it was involuntary.
Further, although in paragraph 16 of the writ petition it is
stated that “Copy of the online applications for the quarters
July 2017 to September 2017 (on a sample basis and which
is the most relevant for the present proceedings) as well as
the acknowledgement copy of corresponding ARN is annexed
and marked as annexure P-4” the application was not filed.
Annexure P-4 as filed by the petitioner is a copy of the
acknowledgement
receipt
only.
The
application
was
however, filed by the respondents in their counter affidavit.
Although the petitioner has made an attempt to underplay
this application by suggesting that the earlier applications
filed by the petitioner were the correct applications it is
quite clear that what the petitioner intended to do was to
make the authorities to work out the budgetary support on
the basis of the monthly claims filed by them earlier and
not as per the quarter as required under the Budgetary
Support Scheme. Had the details required to be provided in
the form as mandated in the Budgetary Support Scheme
and the two circulars were filled by the petitioner in the
first instance there was no requirement for the authorities
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
to require the petitioner to resubmit the applications. The
details provided in the subsequent application by the
petitioner as per the Budgetary Support Scheme and the
two circulars led to the calculation of the budgetary
support in the negative as seen above by the petitioner
itself. The budgetary support under the Budgetary Support
Scheme is in the nature of grant and not refund of duty
under taxation law. It was incumbent upon the petitioner
to satisfy the requirements of the Budgetary Support
Scheme and follow the procedure prescribed. When a
procedure is prescribed, the petitioner while seeking the
grant of budgetary support, is required to follow that
procedure and not work out a different procedure for the
authorities to follow. The fact that budgetary support was
given to the petitioner for the other three quarters, it is
evident that there was no malice on the part of the
authorities while rejecting the claim for budgetary support
for the quarter July 2017 to September 2017. It is to be
noted that the petitioner makes no grievance about the
applications filed by them for the other quarters for which
budgetary support as sought for were granted.
21.
In their initial separate applications for the
month of July 2017 and August 2017 the IGST paid in
cash was Rs.58,23,079/- (Rupees Fifty Eight Lakhs Twenty
Three Thousand and Seventy Nine) and Rs.5,31,04,690/-
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
(Rupees Five Crores Thirty One Lakhs Four Thousand Six
Hundred Ninety) respectively. As against that, the balance
of ITC of CGST was 0 (zero) for both the months of July
2017 and August 2017. However, for the months of
September
the
balance
of
ITC
of
CGST
was
Rs.12,59,63,822/- (Rupees Twelve Crores Fifty Nine Lakhs
Sixty
Three
Thousand
Eight
Hundred
Twenty
Two).
However, as the petitioner made separate applications for
July 2017 and August 2017 without including the balance
of ITC of CGST for the month of September 2017 they could
attain positive budgetary support for each of the months
separately and claim it. The petitioner did not make any
claim for September 2017 in which the balance of ITC of
CGST was Rs. 12,59,63,822/- (Rupees Twelve Crores Fifty
Nine Lakhs Sixty Three Thousand Eight Hundred Twenty
Two) as they would not be entitled to any budgetary
support because of the balance of ITC of CGST for the
month of September 2017. However, what was required to
be done by the petitioner was to make the claim for the
quarter July 2017 to September 2017. The Budgetary
Support Scheme had envisaged the grant of budgetary
support to be worked out quarterly on a claim made for the
quarter and not for separate months. Therefore, when the
petitioner was required by the authorities to modify their
initial applications to a quarterly basis as required under
W.P. (C) No.02 of 2023
Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India & Ors.
the law they had no choice but to reflect the balance of ITC
of CGST for the month of September 2017 as well. This led
the petitioner to calculate their own budgetary support in
the negative correctly as done in the application mentioned
by the petitioner in the writ petition but filed by the
respondent in the counter affidavit.
22.
Thus this Court is of the view that the petitioner is
not entitled to any relief as sought for in the present writ
petition which is accordingly dismissed.
23.
The parties shall bear their respective costs.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
Approved for reporting
Internet
to/
: Yes
: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review