Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/9
GAHC010264632025
2026:GAU-AS:5752
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7203/2025
GIRIDHAR KALITA
S/O- LATE JYOTISH KALITA, R/O- VILLAGE- KHETRIHARDIA/MAJARKURI,
P.S. HAJO, DISTRICT- KAMRUP (R), ASSAM, PIN- 781102
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 4 ORS
THROUGH THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY, REVENUE
DEPARTMENT, DISPUR, GUWAHATI-6
2:THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
KAMRUP
AMINGAON
ASSAM
3:SMTI. AFREEN HUSSAIN
THE CIRCLE OFFICER
HAJO REVENUE CIRCLE
.
DISTRICT- KAMRUP (R)
ASSAM
4:SMTI REHULI DEFUSHA
LAT MANDAL
HAJO REVENUE CIRCLE
KAMRUP (R)
ASSAM
5:SRI RANGAN SARMA
LAT MANDAL
HAJO REVENUE CIRCLE
KAMRUP
Page No.# 2/9
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner : MS. T SOM, MS. J SARMA,MS. M NATH,G IMTIAZ,MR. A
IKBAL ,MS. A MAHANTA,MS. U HAZARIKA
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM, MR. SHEELADITYA (R4,5),P KHATANIAR(R3),MR.
U S BORA (R3),SC, REVENUE
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KAUSHIK GOSWAMI
ORDER
27.04.2026
Heard Mr. G. Imtiaz, learned counsel appearing for the writ
petitioner. Also heard Ms. N. Bordoloi, learned Standing Counsel,
Revenue Department, Assam, appearing for the respondent No. 1, Mr.
H. Sharma, learned Additional Senior Government Counsel appearing
for the respondent No. 2, Mr. U.S. Bora, learned counsel appearing for
the respondent No. 3 and Mr. Sheeladitya, learned counsel appearing
for the respondent Nos. 4 & 5.
2.
By way of this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, the writ petitioner is challenging the impugned order dated
17.04.2025,
passed
in
Mutation
Case
No.
KAM/HAZ/2024-
25/2025000110930/FMUT, and seeks restoration of the petitioner’s
mutation dated 16.06.2023 in Mutation Case No. KAM/HAZ/202223/31077/OMUTC.
3.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioner claims to be
the lawful purchaser and pattadar of land measuring 1 Katha 10
Page No.# 3/9
Lechas, purchased through a registered Sale Deed No. 508/2023 dated
10.04.2023 from the legal heirs of Late Dhonu Keot, whose family held
a demarcated 30-lecha share from the ancestral property of Late Asom
Keot. Upon due enquiry, field verification, and compliance with the
statutory procedure, mutation was granted to the petitioner on
16.06.2023, and his name was entered into the Jamabandi in respect
of the land in question. However, upon facing disturbance from the
private respondents, the petitioner was compelled to file a title suit,
being T.S. No. 169/2024, along with Misc. (J) Case No. 126/2024,
wherein the learned trial court was pleased to grant an injunction by
order dated 03.08.2024, restraining interference with the petitioner’s
possession. Despite the aforesaid injunction, the mutation was
cancelled without notice to, or hearing of, the petitioner.
4.
Mr. G. Imtiaz, learned counsel appearing for the writ petitioner,
submits that though an appeal has been filed against the cancellation
of the mutation, seeking restoration thereof before the office of the
District Commissioner, Kamrup (R), on 13.08.2025, the same has not
yet been considered or disposed of.
5.
Per contra, Mr. Sheeladitya, learned counsel for respondent Nos.
4 & 5, submits that the present writ petition is not maintainable
inasmuch as, under the provisions of the Assam Land and Revenue
Regulation, 1886 (hereinafter referred to as the “Regulation, 1886”),
an appeal lies against the order of the Sub-Divisional Officer
(hereinafter referred to as the “SDO”) cancelling the mutation of the
petitioner.
He
further
submits
that
the
representation
dated
Page No.# 4/9
13.08.2025 to the District Commissioner, enclosed as Annexure-9 in
the writ petition, cannot be construed as an appeal under Regulation
147 of the Regulation, 1886.
6.
Mr. H. Sharma, learned Additional Senior Government Counsel
for respondent No. 2, fairly submits that under Regulation 147 of the
Regulation, 1886, an appeal against the order of the SDO lies before
the jurisdictional Deputy Commissioner, and since the appeal has
already been filed in the instant case, the writ petition may be
disposed of by directing the appellate authority to dispose of the said
appeal in accordance with law.
7.
Likewise, Ms. N. Bordoloi, learned Standing Counsel, Revenue
Department, Assam, and Mr. U.S. Bora, learned counsel for respondent
No. 3, also make submissions to the same effect.
8.
Upon hearing learned counsel for the parties and perusing the
materials available on record, it appears that against an order passed
by the SDO, an appeal lies before the jurisdictional Deputy
Commissioner under Regulation 147 of the Regulation, 1886, which
reads as under:—
“147. Appeals shall lie under this Regulation as follows:— (a)
To the Board from orders, original or appellate passed by a Deputy
Commissioner Settlement officer or Survey officer; (b) To the Deputy
Commissioner, from orders passed by a Subdivisional Officer, an
Assistant Commissioner or Extra Assistant Commissioner; (c) To the
Settlement Officer, from orders passed by an Assistant Settlement
Officer; (d) To a Survey Officer, from orders passed by an Assistant
Survey Officer:
Provided that no appeal shall lie against the following orders:—
Page No.# 5/9
(i) Orders of an Assistant Settlement Officer or Assistant Survey
Officer under section 21 and 22;
(ii) Orders of a Survey Officer or Settlement Officer;
(1) Under Section 21, 22, and 24;
(2) Apportioning the expense of erecting and repairing boundarymarks in accordance with rules made under section 27;
(iii) Orders of a Survey Officer, Settlement Officer or Deputy
Commissioner, original or appellate imposing or confirming a fine not
exceeding fifty rupees;
(iv) Orders of a Deputy Commissioner under section 79 setting aside
or refusing to set aside the sale;
(v) Any decision given in accordance with an award of arbitrators
appointed under section 143, except in the case of fraud or collusion;
(vi) Orders under section 148, admitting an appeal after the period of
limitation has expired;
(vii) Orders expressly declared by this Regulation to be final subject
to the provision of section 151.”
9.
In the present case, it appears that the Circle Officer, by order
dated 17.04.2025, cancelled the mutation in favour of the petitioner.
Against the aforesaid cancellation, an appeal has been filed before the
District Commissioner, Amingaon, Kamrup (R), Assam, on 13.08.2025,
which reads as under:—
“To
The District Commissioner,
Amingaon,
Kamrup (R), Assam.
Ref: Title Suit No 169/2024 & Misc (J) Case No 126/2024 (dated
03/08/2024) pending before Civil Judge (Jr Divn), Kamrup.
Sub:- Complaint against illegal mutation order dated 17-04-2025
passed by the Circle Officer, Hajo in Mutation Case No
KAM/HAZ/2024-2025/2025000110930/FMUT in respect of a plot of
land measuring 1 Katha 10 lesa covered by Dag no. 934(Old)/1095
Page No.# 6/9
(New)and patta no. 354 (Old)/820 (New) Revenue Village- Bardadhi
under Hajo Mouza, Kamrup, Assam.
Sir,
With due respect, I the undersigned would like to place the following
facts for information and necessary action:1. That the undersigned is a permanent resident of Hajo. The
undersigned is currently serving UD, Senior Secretary to Advocate
General, Assam, Gauhati High Court.
2. That in the month of December, 2022 the undersigned was
approached by one Sri Romoni Das and Sri Amulyo Das both sons of
late Dhonu Keot with a proposal to sell land measuring 1 Katha 10
lesa covered by Dag no. 934(Old)/1095 (New)and patta no. 354
(Old)/820 (New)under Hajo Mouza. On being clearly satisfied with
the title and possession of the vendors, I agreed to purchase the said
land.
3. That accordingly after completion of the sale formalities and also
after securing the requisite sale permission, both the vendors
executed a registered deed of sale bearing Deed No 508/2023 dated
10-04-2023 in my favour The vendors handed over khas and vacant
possession of the purchased land in my favour. I had also
constructed an ekchali Assam type house in my said land for
keeping building materials to the Petitioner. My name was also duly
mutated in respect of my purchased land vide order dated 16-062023
passed
in
Mutation
Case
No
KAM/HAZ/202223/31077/OMUTC by your esteemed authority.
However, after some months, some persons namely Jibon Das,
Achyut Das, both sons of Late Dom Keot, Sri Bhupen Das son of late
Thanu Das, Sri Bhaskar Das, son of Late Komola Das and Sri Pallab
Das, son of late Arun Das started raising illegal claim over my
aforesaid plot of land.
4. That it may be pointed herein that all the aforesaid persons are
cousins of my vendors and are legal heirs of Late Asom Keot. Said
late Asom Keot during his lifetime was the owner of a plot of land
measuring 91 lechas covered by Dag no. 934(Old)/1095 (New)under
Hojo Revenue Circle. Said Late Asom Keot had 3 sons namely Late
Dom Keot, Late Bhojohu Keot and Late Dhonu Keot. After the death
of Asom keot, all his three sons inherited the said property with 30
lechas falling in each share. My vendors are the sons of Late Dhonu
Page No.# 7/9
Keot and have clear title over the 30 lechas land by way of
inheritance. The remaining persons are the legal heirs of Late Dom
Keot and Late Bhojohu Keot to the extent of 60 lechas in total. It may
be stated herein that all the legal heirs of Asom Keot had mutually
partitioned the aforesaid property decades ago and has been living
in their respective shares
5. That as the legal heirs of late Bhojohu Keot and Late Dom Keot
caused disturbance over my purchased land with a gang of land
grabbers, I filed a Title Suit being T.S No-169/2024 before the
Hon'ble Court of Civil Judge (Jr Divn), Amingaon alongwith Misc (J)
Case No 126/2024 praying for ad interim temporary injunction
against the aforementioned group of persons. The said suit was filed
on 03-08-2024.
6. That the Hon'ble Court on 03-08-2024 after hearing the matter
was pleased to pass and order of temporary injunction specifically
directing the opposite parties not to disturb my peaceful possession
over the suit land. After passing of the aforesaid order, I had duly
communicated the same to the Hajo Circle Office. All the opposite
parties have appeared and contested the said suit which is pending
before the Hon'ble Court today.
7. That inspite of the aforesaid Civil Suit filed by me which is
pending before the Hon'ble Court of Civil Judge (Jr Divn) Amingaon,
and the order of injunction passed by the Hon'ble Court dated 03-082024, the Circle Officer, Hajo in a 04-2025 passed most illegal
manner cancelled my valid mutation vide order dated 17-in Mutation
Case No KAM/HAZ/2024-2025/2025000110930/FMUT. Having not
stopped here, the Circle Officer, Hajo also inserted the names of the
opposite parties in the Sadar Jamabandi by deleting my name
alongwith the names of my vendors pending disposal of the Civil
Suit.
8. That the Circle Officer, Hajo well aware of the fact that once any
party has approached a Competent Civil Court for redressal of his
grievance, such illegal orders are not only abuse of the process of
law but also at the same time contravenes the administrative
discipline and is extremely uncalled for. The concerned Officer had
no power to pass such order cancelling my valid mutation (Order
dated 16-06-2023 passed in Mutation Case No KAM/HAZ/202223/31077/OMUTC) without any notice that too during pendency of a
civil suit before a competent court of law.
Page No.# 8/9
9. That it has also come to light that the concerned Lat Mandal,
namely Smti R.Difusa has been in a open manner conniving with the
opposite party giving a total goodbye to the system. The said Lat,
Mandal has deliberately filed a false and misleading report leading
to such illegal cancellation of my valid mutation.
10. That in light of the aforesaid facts and circumstances I therefore
request you to kindly take immediate action in this regard and undo
the wrong by restoring my valid mutation granted vide Order dated
16-06-2023 passed in Mutation Case No KAM/HAZ/202223/31077/OMUTC) and be further pleased to recall the erroneous
and illegal order dated 17-04-2025 passed in Mutation Case No
cancelling
my
mutation.
KAM/HAZ/20242025/2025000110930/FMUT cancelling my mutation.
I have annexed all necessary documents for your perusal. My
representation may be treated as an appeal against the illegal
mutation order.
Thanking You
Your’s Faithfully
(Sri Giridhar Kalita),
Son of late Jyotish Kalita
Village Khetrihardia,
Kamrup, Assam,
Ph-9864321181”
10. The
contention
of
the
learned
counsel
for
the
private
respondents that the aforesaid is not an appeal in the strict sense
cannot be accepted, inasmuch as, there being no specific format
prescribed for filing an appeal under the Regulation, the appeal filed
before the District Commissioner, Amingaon, seeking restoration of
mutation by setting aside the cancellation order, cannot be said to be
contrary to the Regulation, 1886.
11. Since the appeal has not yet been considered, this Court is of the
Page No.# 9/9
view that the writ petition can be disposed of, in the interest of justice,
by directing the appellate authority to consider and dispose of the
appeal in accordance with law, after affording due hearing to all
affected parties, within a period of 2 (two) months from the date of
receipt of a certified copy of this order.
12. Ordered accordingly.
13. Let a certified copy of this order, along with the appeal, be
submitted before the appellate authority.
14. The writ petition is accordingly disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review