Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.35
REGULAR CAUSE LIST
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
CRM(M) No.315/2023
CrlM No. 772/2023
Ghulam Nabi Mir and Others.
Through:
…Petitioner(s)
Mr. Sheikh Hilal, Advocate.
Vs.
Station House Officer Police Station
Khan Sahib Budgam
Through:
...Respondent(s)
Mr. Bikramdeep Singh, Dy.AG.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
ORDER
31.08.2026
1. The petitioners have invoked the inherent jurisdiction of
this Court seeking quashment of the criminal proceedings
arising out of FIR No. 46 of 2023, primarily on the ground
that a dispute essentially civil in nature has been given a
criminal colour and that continuation of the criminal
proceedings would, therefore, amount to an abuse of the
process of law.
2. The case projected by the petitioners is that the impugned
FIR owes its origin to a pre-existing civil dispute between
the parties concerning land measuring 18 marlas falling
under Khasra No. 368 of Village Bugroo. According to the
CRM(M) No. 315/2023
petitioners, the said land fell to the share of petitioner No.
1 pursuant to a decree passed by the competent civil court
in the year 2007, whereafter the corresponding revenue
entry came to be recorded in his favour. Petitioner No. 1
claims to have remained in peaceful possession and
enjoyment of the said land ever since.
3. It is further pleaded that respondent No. 2, on the strength
of an allegedly forged power of attorney and sale deed,
asserted a claim over the aforesaid property. The
petitioners maintain that they became aware of such claim
only when respondent No. 2 instituted civil proceedings in
respect of the property. Their case is that, having failed to
dislodge petitioner No. 1 from possession through
recourse to civil proceedings, respondent No. 2 set the
criminal law into motion by concocting an incident and
thereby caused registration of the impugned FIR against
the petitioners and their family members.
4. The petitioners further contend that the material forming
part of the charge-sheet itself acknowledges the claim of
petitioner No. 1 over the land in question. On this premise,
it is urged that a person asserting ownership and being in
settled possession of immovable property cannot, in the
facts alleged, be prosecuted for criminal trespass or
mischief in relation to the very same property. It is also
CRM(M) No. 315/2023
urged that settled possession cannot be disturbed except by
authority of law and that the criminal proceedings have
been initiated merely as a device to overreach and frustrate
the pending civil proceedings.
5. Upon consideration of the petition at the initial stage, this
Court, by order dated 12 July 2023, stayed the trial arising
out of the aforesaid FIR.
6. The respondents have resisted the petition. Their case is
that on 30 April 2023 the petitioners unlawfully entered
upon the proprietary land of respondent No. 2, damaged
the barbed-wire fencing and standing crop and broke open
the iron gate erected thereon, thereby causing loss and
damage to the property. It is on the basis of this
occurrence that FIR No. 46 of 2023 came to be registered.
According to the respondents, the matter was duly
investigated and, upon completion of investigation,
sufficient material was found indicating commission of the
alleged offences by the petitioners. It is, therefore,
contended that no case for exercise of the inherent
jurisdiction of this Court to quash the criminal proceedings
is made out.
7. It is further urged on behalf of the respondents that the
pleas raised by the petitioners involve seriously disputed
questions of fact, particularly in regard to title and
CRM(M) No. 315/2023
possession over the land, which cannot appropriately be
adjudicated in proceedings seeking quashment of a
criminal prosecution. It is also contended that neither the
investigation has been shown to be tainted nor has any
material been placed on record to demonstrate that it was
conducted unfairly or improperly. The respondents
maintain that respondent No. 2 is the lawful owner of the
property and that the petitioners have no right, title or
interest therein. According to them, notwithstanding the
title claimed by respondent No. 2, the petitioners took the
law into their own hands, entered upon the property and
caused damage thereto.
8. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, placing
reliance upon Mohammad Wajid & Anr. v. State of U.P. &
Ors., 2023 Live Law (SC) 624, and R. Nagender Yadav v.
State of Telangana, 2022 Live Law (SC) 1030, submits
that the criminal proceedings have their genesis in a purely
civil dispute and have been instituted with an oblique
motive. It is accordingly urged that permitting such
proceedings to continue would amount to an abuse of the
process of the Court.
9. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents
submits that the question as to which of the contesting
parties has title over the property is a disputed question of
CRM(M) No. 315/2023
fact incapable of determination in proceedings of the
present nature. It is urged that mere pendency of civil
litigation between the parties does not, by itself, render the
occurrence dated 30 April 2023 fictitious or obliterate the
criminality, if any, arising therefrom.
10.Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
11.In Mohammad Wajid & Anr. v. State of U.P. & Ors., 2023
Live Law (SC) 624, the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed
that where an accused invokes the inherent jurisdiction
under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure or
the extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution seeking quashment of an FIR or criminal
proceedings on the ground that the prosecution is
manifestly frivolous, vexatious or actuated by an ulterior
motive to wreak vengeance, the Court is under an
obligation to examine the allegations with greater care and
circumspection. In an appropriate case, the Court is not
required to confine itself mechanically to the recitals
contained in the FIR but may also take into account the
attending circumstances emerging from the record.
12.Likewise, in R. Nagender Yadav v. State of Telangana,
2022 Live Law (SC) 1030, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
considered a matter in which allegations of forgery in
CRM(M) No. 315/2023
relation to a sale deed were accompanied by civil
proceedings seeking cancellation thereof. The Supreme
Court, while exercising jurisdiction under Section 482
Cr.P.C., reiterated that although a civil transaction may, in
a given case, also disclose criminal ingredients, the Court
must nevertheless examine whether a dispute which is
essentially civil has merely been clothed with allegations
of criminality. Where the civil remedy has already been
invoked, resort to criminal proceedings may, depending
upon the facts and circumstances of the case, constitute an
abuse of the process of law.
13.There can be no quarrel with the proposition that the
aforesaid judgments were rendered in the backdrop of
their respective facts. Nevertheless, the principle that
emerges is that where criminal proceedings are challenged
as being manifestly frivolous, vexatious or motivated by
personal
vengeance,
the
Court,
while
exercising
jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C. or Article 226 of
the Constitution, is required to examine not only the
allegations
in
isolation
but
also
the
surrounding
circumstances with due care and circumspection.
14.The reason is evident. Where criminal law is allegedly set
in motion for an ulterior purpose, the mere fact that the
FIR has been drafted in a manner facially disclosing the
CRM(M) No. 315/2023
ingredients of an offence cannot invariably conclude the
matter. In an appropriate case, the Court is required to
look beyond the form of the allegations and examine the
circumstances in which the criminal proceedings came to
be instituted. Such scrutiny is necessary to ensure that the
criminal process is not employed as an instrument of
harassment or as a means of settling scores in disputes
which properly fall within the domain of civil law.
15.In State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal 1992 Supp (1) SCC
335, the Hon'ble Supreme Court delineated the wellrecognised categories in which the extraordinary or
inherent jurisdiction for quashing criminal proceedings
may appropriately be exercised. The question that,
therefore, arises for consideration in the present case is
whether, having regard to the nature of the accusations,
the antecedent civil litigation and the material collected
during
investigation,
sufficient
grounds
exist
for
permitting the petitioners to be subjected to a criminal
trial.
th
16.The record reveals that on 30 April 2023 respondent No.
2/complainant lodged a written report before the
concerned Police Station alleging that she had purchased a
parcel of land, fenced the same and erected a gate thereon.
The complainant alleged that Ghulam Nabi Mir, Fayaz
CRM(M) No. 315/2023
Ahmad Mir, Tanveer Ahmad Mir, Ashiq Ahmad and
Muzaffar Ahmad had trespassed upon the land, removed
the gate and caused damage to the standing crop. It was
further alleged that the land formed part of Khasra No.
368 and that mutation in respect thereof stood attested in
favour of the complainant.
17.On the basis of these allegations, FIR No. 46 of 2023
came to be registered initially for offences under Sections
427 and 447 IPC. During investigation, the Investigating
Officer visited the spot, prepared the site plan, seized
pieces of barbed wire and recorded statements of the
witnesses.
Upon
completion
of
investigation,
the
Investigating Officer concluded that the petitioners had
trespassed upon the land claimed by the complainant,
damaged the property and threatened the complainant with
dire consequences. Consequently, offences under Sections
447, 427 and 506 IPC were stated to have been established
against the petitioners.
18.At this stage, however, an important circumstance
emerging from the record requires notice. It is not in
dispute that civil litigation concerning the same property
was already pending between the parties. One such suit
had been instituted by Mst. Fazi seeking injunctive relief
and, by order dated 28thApril 2023, the Court of learned
CRM(M) No. 315/2023
Munsiff, Budgam, had restrained the complainant and her
accomplices from interfering with the suit-schedule
property measuring 2 kanals and 13 marlas falling under
Khasra No. 368 of Village Bargo, Tehsil Khansahib.The
significance of the aforesaid circumstance lies in the
chronology of events. The order of restraint was passed on
28th April 2023, whereas the occurrence forming the basis
of the impugned FIR is alleged to have taken place on
30thApril 2023, barely two days thereafter. The proximity
between the civil court's order and the institution of
criminal proceedings is, therefore, a circumstance which
cannot altogether be brushed aside while examining the
petitioners' plea that the criminal prosecution is a sequel to
the subsisting civil dispute.
19.The record further indicates that the petitioners had
instituted a separate civil suit asserting possession over
land measuring 18 marlas under Khasra No. 368 and
alleging interference therein by the complainant. Thus,
much before the criminal prosecution is taken to its logical
conclusion,
competing
claims
regarding
title
and
possession over the same property were already engaging
the attention of the competent civil court.
20.The mere existence of a civil dispute does not, as a
proposition of law, bar criminal prosecution where the
CRM(M) No. 315/2023
allegations independently disclose the commission of a
cognizable offence. A transaction or occurrence may
possess both civil and criminal facets, and the availability
or invocation of a civil remedy cannot by itself afford
immunity against prosecution for an otherwise established
criminal act. At the same time, the criminal process cannot
legitimately be permitted to become an instrument for
exerting pressure upon an adversary in a pre-existing
property dispute.
21.It is, therefore, necessary to ascertain the real substance of
the accusations rather than their mere form. Where the
very foundation of an allegation of criminal trespass
depends upon a seriously contested question as to
possession over immovable property, and where such
possession is already the subject matter of civil
proceedings
and
subsisting
judicial
orders,
those
circumstances assume considerable significance while
examining
whether
continuation
of
the
criminal
prosecution would advance the cause of criminal justice or
merely perpetuate an essentially private dispute through
the machinery of criminal law. Equally, while undertaking
such scrutiny, this Court cannot convert proceedings under
Section 482 Cr.P.C. into a trial on title or embark upon an
adjudication of disputed questions which properly fall
CRM(M) No. 315/2023
within the jurisdiction of the civil court. The limited
inquiry is whether, upon taking the allegations and the
attending circumstances together, continuation of the
criminal proceedings is warranted or whether the criminal
process has been invoked for a collateral purpose.
22.The incident dated 30.04.2023 has been duly investigated
by the Investigating Agency. During the course of
investigation, the Investigating Officer visited the spot and
seized broken pieces of wire as well as broken pieces of
the gate, which are alleged to have been removed and
damaged by the petitioners. The investigation further
revealed that, at the relevant time, the complainant was in
possession and dominion over the land in dispute. The said
fact was also verified by the Investigating Officer from the
concerned Revenue Agency. The statements of the
witnesses recorded during investigation further reveal
allegations that the petitioners trespassed upon the
property in possession of the complainant, caused damage
thereto and extended threats of dire consequences to her.
23.Once the incident dated 30.04.2023 has been investigated
and no challenge has been laid to the fairness or manner of
such investigation, the mere fact that the question of
possession of the parties qua the landed property in
dispute is also the subject matter of civil proceedings
CRM(M) No. 315/2023
cannot, by itself, furnish a ground for quashing the
criminal proceedings. Pendency of a civil dispute does not
confer upon either party a licence to commit acts which
may independently constitute criminal offences. It is the
case of the petitioners that orders had been passed by the
competent Civil Court in their favour. Even if the
petitioners apprehended interference with or violation of
the said orders at the hands of the complainant, the remedy
available to them was to approach the competent Civil
Court for enforcement or implementation thereof in
accordance with law. They could not have taken the law
into their own hands.
24.The matter may also be viewed from another perspective.
The possibility that the petitioners, under the purported
protection of the orders passed by the Civil Court,
attempted to interfere with the complainant's possession
through the alleged incident dated 30.04.2023, which was
resisted by her and ultimately resulted in registration of
the FIR, cannot be ruled out at this stage. Whether the
allegations are ultimately proved is, however, a matter for
trial
and
cannot
appropriately
be
determined
in
proceedings seeking quashing of the criminal case.
25.In the aforesaid backdrop, the contention that a purely
civil dispute has been given the colour of a criminal
CRM(M) No. 315/2023
offence does not find support from the material collected
during investigation. On the contrary, the material
presently available with the Investigating Agency prima
facie discloses the commission of offences punishable
under Sections 447, 427 and 323 of the Indian Penal Code.
The existence of civil proceedings concerning the property
does not, in the facts and circumstances of the present
case, efface the criminality alleged in respect of the
incident dated 30.04.2023.
26.The principles governing exercise of the extraordinary
jurisdiction for quashing criminal proceedings have been
authoritatively delineated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in State of Haryana & Ors. v. Ch. Bhajan Lal & Ors.,
1992 Supp (1) SCC 335, wherein illustrative categories of
cases warranting interference, either to prevent abuse of
the process of law or to secure the ends of justice, have
been enumerated. Tested on the touchstone of the
aforesaid principles, the petitioners have failed to bring the
present case within any of the categories illustratively laid
down in Bhajan Lal (supra). Rather, the material collected
during investigation prima facie discloses sufficient
grounds for the criminal proceedings to continue and for
the petitioners to face trial in accordance with law. No
ground for interference by this Court is, therefore, made
CRM(M) No. 315/2023
out. The disputed question regarding possession over the
landed property is a matter to be adjudicated by the
competent Civil Court on the basis of the evidence
produced before it. The criminal proceedings arising out
of the alleged incident dated 30.04.2023, on the other
hand, have to be adjudicated independently on their own
merits and on the basis of the evidence led before the
competent
criminal
court.
In
these
circumstances,
continuation of the criminal proceedings against the
petitioners cannot be said to constitute an abuse of the
process of law or of the Court so as to warrant exercise of
the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court for quashing
the same. For the reasons recorded hereinabove, this Court
finds no merit in the present petition, is accordingly,
dismissed.
27.Interim direction(s) if any shall stand vacated.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
SRINAGAR:
31.08.2026
Shaista-PS
CRM(M) No. 315/2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review