Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S. No.3
Regular List
,,,
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
Uploaded on 24.04.2026
WP(C) No.297/2022
CM No. 794/2022
Ghulam Mohammad Hajam & Anr.
…..Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr.Javid Ahmad Parray, Advocate.
V/s
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS
… ..Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Bashir Ahmad Zargar and
Mr. A.S.Sodhi, Advocates
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
ORDER
23.04.2026
1.
The petitioners through the medium of present petition have
sought the following reliefs:“I.
II.
III.
An appropriate writ, order or direction, holding the
petitioners entitled for the family pensioner benefits
accrued in lieu of the death of the Constable Mohammad
Amin Hajam in the wake of the remarriage of the
respondent No.07 and commanding the respondents 01
to 05 not to release the pensioner benefits in question in
favour of the respondent No.07 and make the payment
of the same to the petitioners being the dependent
parents of the deceased constable.
An appropriate writ, order or direction, commanding the
respondent No.06 to make payment of the pension
amount which has accumulated in the account lying with
his bank to the petitioners.
Any other writ, order or direction which this Hon’ble
Court deems just and proper, be issued in favour of the
petitioner for the same would be in consonance with law
and justice.”
2.
Respondent No.7 in her objections to the writ petition has
raised preliminary objection with regard to the maintainability of
the writ petition. It has been submitted that the writ petition is
not maintainable as the petitioners had filed a civil suit before
the Court of learned Sub Judge, Pattan on the same cause of
action against the respondents herein, which stands dismissed in
terms of order dated 13.06.2022 passed by the said Court.
3.
Vide order dated 24.03.2025 the petitioners were directed to
place on record copy of Civil suit titled Ghulam Mohammad
Hajam and Anr. vs Union of India and Ors as well as the
certified copy of the order passed by learned Sub Judge, Pattan
in the said suit. Pursuant to the said direction, the petitioners
have placed on record certified true copy of the plaint filed by
them before the Court of learned Sub Judge, Pattan. A certified
true copy of order dated 13.06.2022 passed in the said suit has
also been placed on record.
4.
A perusal of the plaint filed by the petitioners before the
learned Sub Judge, Pattan would reveal that in the said suit the
petitioners have prayed for the following reliefs:“a.
b.
WP(C) No.297 of 2022
A Decree of declaration, declaring the plaintiffs
entitled to the family pension in lieu of the death of
their son, being his only surviving dependant parents,
in view of the revival of their right on remarriage of
the defendant No.06.
A decree of permanent injunction, whereby the
official defendants be permanently restrained from
making the payment of the family pension to the
2|P a g e
defendant No.06, having lost her entitlement by
remarriage.
A decree of mandatory injunction, commanding the
official defendants to make the payment of the family
pension to the plaintiffs being the only surviving
dependant parents of the deceased defence personal.
Any other order or direction which this Hon’ble court
deems fit and proper in the attending facts and
circumstances of the case be also passed in favour of
the plaintiffs and against the defendant.”
c.
d.
5.
The aforesaid suit came to be dismissed for non prosecution
by the learned Civil Court vide its order dated 13.06.2022. The
same is reproduced as under:“Nemo for the plaintiffs present. Ld.Counsel for
defendant No.6 present. Perusal of the order sheet
reveals that for the last two hearings nobody is
appearing on behalf of plaintiff and today also nobody
is present on their behalf which shows that plaintiffs
are not interested in pursuing the suit. In view of the
same, the instant suit is dismissed in default of
appearance of plaintiffs. Be consigned to record.”
6.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties on the question
of maintainability of the present writ petition and I have also
perused record of the case.
7.
It is not in dispute that the petitioners had filed a civil suit
before the Court of learned Sub Judge, Pattan against the
respondents herein, in which they had prayed for a decree of
declaration that they are entitled to the family pension in lieu of
death
of
their son, being his only legally
surviving
dependents/parents in view of the revival of their right on remarriage of defendant No.6, who happens to be respondent No.7
herein. A decree of permanent injunction restraining the official
WP(C) No.297 of 2022
3|P a g e
defendants from making any payment of family pension to
defendant No.6/respondent No.7 herein was also sought with a
mandatory injunction that official defendants should make the
payment of family pension to the plaintiffs/petitioners herein.
8.
A perusal of the reliefs prayed in the present writ petition as
quoted hereinbefore would reveal that exactly similar reliefs
were sought by the petitioners herein against the respondents/
defendants in the Civil suit. Thus, the cause of action and even
the relief prayed in both the cases is the same. The suit filed by
the petitioners stands dismissed for non-prosecution.
9.
Order XXIII Rule 1 governs the legal position with regard
to effect of withdrawal of suit or abandonment of part of claim.
It reads as under:ORDER XXIII
Withdrawal and Adjustment of Suits
[1. Withdrawal of suit or abandonment of part of
claim.—
(1) At any time after the institution of a suit,
the plaintiff may as against all or any of the defendants
abandon his suit or abandon a part of his claim:
Provided that where the plaintiff is a minor or other
person to whom the provisions contained in Rules 1 to 14
of Order XXXII extend, neither the suit nor any part of
the claim shall be abandoned without the leave of the
Court.
(2) An application for leave under the proviso to
sub-rule (1) shall be accompanied by an affidavit of the
next friend and also, if the minor or such other person is
represented by a pleader, by a certificate of the pleader to
the effect that the abandonment proposed is, in his
opinion, for the benefit of the minor or such other person.
(3) Where the Court is satisfied,—
WP(C) No.297 of 2022
4|P a g e
(a) that a suit must fail by reason of some
formal defect, or
(b) that there are sufficient grounds for
allowing the plaintiff to institute a fresh suit for
the subject matter of suit or part of a claim,
It may, on such terms as it thinks fit, grant the plaintiff
permission to withdraw from such suit or such part of the
claim with liberty to institute a fresh suit in respect of the
subject-matter of such suit or such part of the claim.
(4) Where the plaintiff—
(a) abandons any suit or part of claim under
sub-rule (1), or
(b) withdraws from a suit or part of a claim
without the permission referred to in sub-rule
(3),
he shall be liable for such costs as the Court may award
and shall be precluded from instituting any fresh suit in
respect of such subject-matter or such part of the claim.
(5) Nothing in this rule shall be deemed to
authorise the Court to permit one of several plaintiffs to
abandon a suit or part of a claim under sub-rule (1), or to
withdraw, under sub-rule (3), any suit or part of a claim,
without the consent of the other plaintiff.]
10. Sub rule (4) quoted above provides that in a case where
plaintiff abandons any suit or part of claim or withdraws any suit
or part of a claim without permission to institute fresh
proceedings, he shall be precluded from instituting any fresh suit
in respect of such subject matter or such part of the claim.
11. In the present case the petitioners admittedly had filed a
civil suit before the Court of Sub Judge Pattan in respect of the
same subject matter which is the subject matter of present writ
petition. The said suit came to be dismissed for non-prosecution
by the said Court on 13.06.2022, meaning thereby, that the
petitioners/plaintiffs abandoned the claim set up by them before
the Civil Court. It is not the case of petitioners that they had
WP(C) No.297 of 2022
5|P a g e
sought any permission to institute fresh proceedings nor does
order dated 13.06.2022 passed by the Sub Judge Pattan suggest
so. Therefore, in the face of provisions contained in Sub rule (4)
of Order XXIII Rule 1 of CPC, the petitioners are precluded
from instituting fresh proceedings, including a writ petition in
respect of the same subject matter.
12. The question whether the provisions contained in Order
XXIII Rule 1 of CPC are applicable to writ proceedings came up
for consideration before this Court in the case of Zamindaran
Lorow and others vs State and Ors, 2008(II) SLJ 495. While
holding that the said provision is applicable even to writ
proceedings, a co-ordinate Bench of this Court relied upon the
following observations made by the Supreme Court in the case
of Sarguja Transport Service vs.T.A.Tribunal Gwalior, (1987) 1
SCC 5.
“The Code as it now stands thus makes a
distinction between 'abandonment' of a suit and
'withdrawal' from a suit with permission to file a fresh
suit. It provides that where the plaintiff abandons a
suit or withdraws from a suit without the permission
referred to in Sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order XXIII of
the Code, he shall be precluded from instituting any
fresh suit in respect of such subject matter or such part
of the claim. The principle underlying Rule 1 of Order
XXIII of the Code is that when a plaintiff once
institutes a suit in a Court and thereby avails of a
remedy given to him under law, he cannot be
permitted to institute a fresh suit in respect of the
same subject-matter against after abandoning the
earlier suit or by withdrawing it without the
WP(C) No.297 of 2022
6|P a g e
permission of the Court to file fresh suit. Invito
beneficium non datur. The law confers upon a man no
rights or benefits which he does not desire. Whoever
waives, abandance or disclaims a right will loose it. In
order to prevent a litigant from abusing the process of
the Court by instituting suits again and again on the
same cause of action without any good reason the
Code insists that he should obtain the permission of
the Court to file a fresh suit after establishing either of
the two grounds mentioned in Sub-rule (3) of Rule 1
of Order XXIII. The principle underlying the above
rule is founded on public policy, but it is not the same
as the rule of res judicata contained in Section 11 of
the Code which provides that no Court shall try any
suit or issue in which the matter directly or
substantially in issue has been directly or substantially
in issue in a former suit between the same parties, or
between the parties under whom they are any of them'
claim, litigating under the same title, in a Court
competent to try such subsequent suit or the suit in
which such issue has been subsequently raised, and
has been heard and finally decided by such Court. The
rule of res judicata applies to a case where the suit or
an issue has already been heard and finally decided by
a Court. In the case of abandonment or withdrawal of
a suit without the permission of the Court to file a
fresh suit, there is no prayer adjudication of a suit or
an issue is involved, yet the Code provides, as stated
earlier, that a second suit will not lie in Sub-rule (4) of
Rule 1 of Order XXIII of the Code when the first suit
is withdrawn without the permission referred to in
Sub-rule (3) in order to prevent the abuse of the
process of the Court.
The point for consideration is whether a
petitioner after withdrawing a writ petition filed by
him in the High Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India without the permission to
institute a fresh petition can file a fresh writ petition in
the High Court under that Article. On this point the
decision in Daryao's case (supra) AIR 1961 SC 1457
is of no assistance. But we are of the view that the
principle underlying Rule 1 of Order XXIII of the
WP(C) No.297 of 2022
7|P a g e
Code should be extended in the interests of
administration of justice to cases of withdrawal of
writ petition also, not on the ground of res judicata but
on the ground of public policy as explained above. It
would also discourage the litigant from indulging in
bench hunting tactics. In any event there is no
justifiable reason in such a case to permit a petitioner
to invoke the extra ordinary writ jurisdiction of the
High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution once
again. While the withdrawal of the writ petition filed
in High Court without permission to file a fresh
petition may not bar other remedies like a suit or a
petition under Article 32 of the Constitution since
such withdrawal does not amount to res judicata. The
remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution should
be deemed to have been abandoned by the petitioner
in respect of the cause of action relied on in the writ
petition when he withdraws it without such
permission. In the instant case the High Court was
right in holding that a fresh writ petition was not
maintainable before it in respect of the same subjectmatter since the earlier writ petition had been
withdrawn without permission to file a fresh petition.
We, however, make it clear that whatever we have
stated in this order may not be considered as being
applicable to a writ petition involving personal liberty
to an individual in which the petitioner prays for the
issue of a writ in the nature of habeas corpus or seeks
to enforce the fundamental right guaranteed under
Article 21 of the Constitution since such a case stands
on a different footing altogether. We, however, leave
this question open.”
13. In view of the foregoing analysis of legal position, it is clear
that principles of Order XXIII Rule 1 of CPC are applicable
even to writ proceedings. Therefore, if a party abandons his suit
in respect of a particular subject matter, he is precluded from
filing a writ petition on same subject matter and same cause of
WP(C) No.297 of 2022
8|P a g e
action without obtaining leave of the Court where he had
instituted the suit.
14. Learned counsel for the respondents has contended that in
terms of Rule 4 of Order IX CPC, if a suit is dismissed for nonappearance of the plaintiff, a fresh suit can be brought by such
plaintiff on the same cause of action, as such, the petitioners
were well within their rights to institute the present writ petition
even if their suit had been dismissed for non prosecution by the
Civil Court.
15.
I am afraid, the contention of the learned counsel for the
petitioner in this regard is misconceived, because in the present
case the suit has not been dismissed by the civil Court either in
terms of Rule 2 or in terms of Rule 3 of Order IX of CPC. It is
not a case where suit of the plaintiff was dismissed on account of
failure of the petitioners to pay costs or on account of the fact
that none of the parties had appeared before the Civil Court at
the time when the suit was called on for hearing. In the present
case when the suit of the petitioners was dismissed for nonprosecution by the Civil Court, defendant No.6/respondent no.7
herein was present before the Court. This is clear from a perusal
of order dated 13.06.2022 passed by learned Sub Judge Pattan.
16. Thus, dismissal of the suit filed by the petitioners is not
covered either by Rule 2 or Rule 3 of Order IX of CPC, but it is
WP(C) No.297 of 2022
9|P a g e
covered by Rule 8 of Order IX of CPC. The consequences of
dismissal of a suit for non-appearance of plaintiff when the
defendant has appeared before the Court, are governed by Rule 9
of Order IX. The said rule specifically provides that when a suit
is wholly or partly dismissed under Rule 8, the plaintiff is
precluded from bringing a fresh suit on same cause of action.
Therefore, in the present case the petitioners are precluded from
filing a fresh suit or a writ petition, because their suit was
dismissed by the Civil Court when defendant no.6 was present
before the Court. The contention of the learned counsel for the
petitioners is, therefore, without any substance.
17. For what has been discussed hereinbefore, it is clear that the
present writ petition is not maintainable in view of the bar
contained in sub rule (4) of rule 1 of Order XXIII of CPC, the
principles whereof are applicable to the writ proceedings as well.
18. Accordingly, the objection raised by respondent No.7 is
upheld. The writ petition is held to be not maintainable and is
dismissed accordingly.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
23.04.2026
Sarveeda Nissar
1.
WP(C) No.297 of 2022
Sarveeda Nissar
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
every page at bottom left side
24.04.2026 18:23
Whether the order is speaking: Yes/No
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
10 | P a g e
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review