The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. It is sufficiently clear from the record that neither any finding had been returned by the Committee constituted indicting the Petitioner herein nor any regular enquiry was conducted against him, for having incurred expenditure in contravention to the provisions of the J&K Municipal Act, 2000, by purchasing three number of Multi-Para Monitors for being installed in the Sub-District Hospital Dooru, though having been authorized by the Municipal Council. The Directorate, however, by its impugned communication dated 23rd of November, 2023, had directed recovery of the amount incurred from the Petitioner’s salary without seeking his explanation or giving him any right of being heard against the legal principle of “Audi alteram partem”. The Respondents had every right to proceed against the Petitioner with regard to the allegation of having unauthorizedly incurred an expenditure by placing order for the purpose of the aforesaid three number of Multi-Para Monitors for being installed in Sub-District Hospital, Dooru as a Principal Officer of the Municipal Committee Dooru-Verinag, however, he could not be condemned unheard. The Petitioner, in such circumstances, has a legal and constitutional right of being heard on the subject, before taking a final decision in the matter. It was incumbent upon the Respondents to proceed in the matter by holding a proper enquiry, after a show cause no…
15. Viewed thus, the instant Writ Petition is allowed and the impugned communication No. DULB/Acctts/1315-11/32994-98 dated 23rd of November, 2023 issued by Respondent No.2 and No. MC/D-V/202324/5725-28 dated 22nd of December, 2023 issued by Respondent No.4 are hereby quashed. However, the Respondents shall be at liberty to proceed in the matter relating to unauthorized purchase of three Multi-Purpose Monitors in Municipal Committee, Dooru-Verinag for their installation in Sub-District Hospital Dooru, in accordance with law, if they so choose.
16. Writ Petition is, thus, disposed of on the above terms, along with connected CM(s).
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
WP (C) No. 49/2024
Reserved On: 31st of August, 2026.
Pronounced On: 8th of September, 2026.
Uploaded On: 8th of September, 2026.
Whether the operative part or
full Judgment is pronounced:
Full.
Gh. Mohd. Dar, (59 Years)
S/O Late Haji Ab. Aziz Dar
R/O Danganpora, Pulwama
Pin Code: 192301
D.O.B.: 01.12.1964.
… Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr Sajid Ahmad Bhat, Advocate vice
Mr M. Y. Bhat, Senior Advocate.
V/S
1. Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir,
Through Commissioner/ Secretary to Government,
Housing and Urban Development Department,
Civil Secretariat, Srinagar.
2. Director, Urban Local Bodies,
Kashmir, Bemina, Srinagar.
3. Pay & Accounts Officer,
Municipal Council, Pulwama/ Tral,
Kashmir.
4. Irfan Ah. Wani, Executive Officer,
Municipal Committee Dooru-Verinag,
Anantnag.
… Respondents
Through: Mr Ilyas Nazir Laway, Government Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR JUSTICE M. A. CHOWDHARY, JUDGE.
(JUDGMENT)
01.
The Petitioner, through the medium of the instant Writ Petition
filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, has assailed
WP (C) No. 49/2024
communication
No. DULB/Acctts/1315-11/32994-98 dated
23rd
of
November, 2023 issued by the Directorate of Urban Local Bodies,
Kashmir/ Respondent No.2 herein, directing the Executive Officer,
Municipal Committee, Dooru-Verinag (Respondent No.4 herein) to recover
the amount from the salary of the Petitioner in connection with the supply
of three Multipara Monitors; as well as communication No. MC/D-V/202324/5725-28 dated 22nd of December, 2023 addressed by the Executive
Officer, Municipal Committee, Dooru-Verinag (Respondent No.4) to the
Pay & Accounts Officer, Municipal Council, Pulwama (Respondent No.3
herein) requesting to deduct an amount of Rs. 1,64,235/- from the salary of
the Petitioner.
02.
The Petitioner claims to have been appointed as a Junior
Assistant in the Respondent-Department way back in the year 1986,
whereafter, he was granted several promotions, as a result whereof, he rose
to the rank of Executive Officer in June, 2018 and, subsequently, retired
from service upon reaching the age of superannuation on 30th of November,
2024. It is stated that the Petitioner exhibited diligence and rendered
exceptional services to the Respondent-Department during his entire service
career, which was duly acknowledged by the Respondents.
03.
It is further averred by the Petitioner that in the year 2023, on
23rd of November, 2023 to be precise, the Respondent No.2 issued
communication No. DULB/Acctts/1315-11/32994-98 (impugned herein) to
the incumbent Executive Officer of the Municipal Committee, DooruVerinag/ Respondent No.4 herein, thereby instructing to recover the amount
from the salary of the Petitioner; that the basis for this recovery was stated
to have emanated from the Petitioner’s tenure as Executive Officer,
Municipal Committee, Dooru-Verinag, during which period the said
Municipal Committee, while following a resolution, initiated a tender on
Government-e-Marketplace Portal (GeM Portal) for the procurement of
Multi-Para Monitors and Benches for Sub-District Hospital, Dooru; and
that the Petitioner, in his capacity as the Executive Officer, was tasked
WP (C) No. 49/2024
solely with the execution of this procurement and the decision-making
authority rested entirely with the Municipal Committee, headed by its
President.
04.
The Petitioner proceeds to plead that, thereafter, a meeting was
convened on 2nd of December, 2023 for the purpose of addressing the
pending payment complaint relating to the order placed by Municipal
Committee Dooru-Verinag for the procurement of Multi-Para Monitors;
that the meeting was attended by various officers, including the Petitioner,
who articulated his rationale for the aforementioned procurement; that the
Petitioner staunchly reiterated his position and clarified that the decision to
procure the items was exclusively taken by the Municipal Committee,
presided over by its President, through the passage of a detailed resolution;
and that the Petitioner emphasized that his role was limited to the execution
of the decision to procure the said item and did not extend to the decisionmaking process.
05.
The Petitioner has further pleaded in his Petition that,
subsequent to the aforementioned meeting, he received a communication
dated 21st of December, 2023 from the Respondent No.4, wherein various
concerns regarding payment claims of Municipal Committee DooruVerinag were raised and a clarification was sought from the Petitioner with
regard to those claims; that, upon receipt of the aforesaid communication,
the Petitioner promptly claims to have responded to the same on the very
next day, vide letter dated 22nd of December, 2023, requesting for providing
him photostat copies of all payment files for which Objections had been
raised by the Accounts Officer and for which justification/ explanation was
being sought from the Petitioner by the Executive Officer; and that,
however, on the very same day when the Petitioner sought the
aforementioned documents, the Respondent No.4 issued the impugned
communication No. MC/D-V/2023-24/5725-28 dated 22nd of December,
WP (C) No. 49/2024
2023 to the Respondent No.3, thereby requesting to deduct an amount of
₹1,64,235/- from the salary of the Petitioner.
06.
Upon notice having been issued, the Respondents have filed
their Objections, inter alia, stating therein that the Writ Petition is not
maintainable as the Petitioner has not approached the Court with clean
hands and has suppressed the material facts; and that the Petitioner, while
posted as Executive Officer, Municipal Committee, Dooru-Verinag, has
utilized the municipal funds contrary to law and rules as he has installed
three (03) Multipara Monitors and Multi-seated Bench at Sub-District
Hospital, Dooru which amounted to diversion of municipal funds for the
purpose not coming within the jurisdiction of the Committee.
07.
It has been further stated by the Respondents in their
Objections that, as per Section 48 of the Jammu & Kashmir Municipal Act,
2000, the powers and function of a Municipality relates to around 18
subjects mentioned in the twelfth Schedule of the Constitution of India as
well as in the aforesaid Section of the Act of 2000, as such, the municipal
funds cannot be utilized for any purpose which do not fall within the
purview/ domain of the Municipal Council/ Committee in view of their
powers and functions enumerated under the aforesaid provisions of law;
that the development of the Hospitals is coming under the administrative
control of the Health and Medical Education Department and, therefore, the
Municipal Council/ Committee has no authority to allot municipal funds for
any purpose beyond the subjects mentioned in the twelfth Schedule of the
Constitution of India and Section 48 of the Act of 2000; and that a
Committee was constituted to enquire into the matter, wherein it has
emerged that the Petitioner has diverted the funds and that the procurement
was contrary to the norms and loss is liable to be recovered from the salary
of the officers/ officials involved in such diversion of funds.
08.
The Petitioner has also filed a Supplementary Affidavit
pursuant to Order dated 13th of February, 2026. In the said Affidavit, it has
WP (C) No. 49/2024
been stated that the Petitioner has retired from service upon reaching the
age of superannuation on 30th of November, 2024, as notified vide
notification dated 5th of October, 2024 issued by the Respondent No.2,
whereafter, he was granted vigilance clearance on 14th of October, 2024;
that a ‘No Demand Certificate’ was also issued by the Respondent No.2 in
favour of the Petitioner and, accordingly, after obtaining all the requisite
NOCs, pension was also sanctioned in favour of the Petitioner vide Order
dated 18th of November, 2024; that no enquiry of any nature whatsoever
was held by the Respondents and the impugned orders/ communications
were issued at his back, after he had been transferred from Municipal
Committee, Dooru; and that the Petitioner was never ever associated with
any enquiry and no notice was ever issued to him, however, he, on his own,
submitted a representation before the Respondent No.2 clarifying that he
had not indulged in any misconduct, whatsoever.
09.
Heard and considered.
10.
It appears that the Directorate of Urban Local Bodies, Kashmir
constituted a Committee to enquire into various issues pertaining to
Municipal Committee-Dooru-Verinag in the light of observations raised by
the then Pay & Accounts Officer as well as response submitted by the then
Executive Officer to the said observations/ issues (under enquiry). The said
Committee, which comprised of Mr Zahoor Abass Choudhary, Deputy
Legal Remembrancer, Urban Local Bodies, Kashmir and Mr Mohammad
Gulzar Parrey, Pay & Accounts Officer, Municipal Council Anantnag,
summarized the findings and made recommendations against each of the
issues placed before the Committee. At S. No. 5 of their report, submitted
vide No. DULB/LR/Lit/04 dated 11th of January, 2025, which was
pertaining to purchase of three number of Multi-Para Monitors for Hospital,
the Committee, after recording the finding that there was no requisition
from SDH Dooru on record and that the purchase had been recommended
by the Council in its meeting held on 6th of March, 2023 for installation of
WP (C) No. 49/2024
Multi-Para Monitors at SDH Dooru (including multi-seater Benches) @
₹3.00 lacs out of GIA, accordingly, administrative approval was accorded
vide Order dated 13th of March, 2023 by invoking Government Order No.
52-JK HUDD dated 14th of February, 2022, recommended that the
competent authority may take a view/ decide the matter vis-à-vis the
irregularity committed, settlement of the due claim of the supplier/
contractor regrading release of his bill payment. The Committee had also
observed that such an expenditure was not permissible by the Municipal
Council under Section 48 of the Municipal Act, 2000, with further remarks
that the utilization of municipal fund for the support of health care of people
cannot be construed as misuse of funds and that the Accounts Officer of the
Municipality, instead of stopping the payment, should have cross-checked it
from the Hospital Administration to avoid any double drawer.
11.
The report of the Committee, as aforesaid, does not appear to
have returned a specific finding that the expenditure incurred by the
Municipal Committee, Dooru-Verinag, where the Petitioner was working as
Executive Officer at the relevant point of time, amounted to any illegality
by diverting the municipal funds for the expenditure incurred on purchase
of three number of Multi-Para Monitors for the Hospital.
12.
It appears that the Directorate of Urban Local Bodies,
Kashmir, vide impugned communication dated 23rd of November, 2023,
directed the Executive Officer, Municipal Committee Dooru-Verinag that
the amount incurred for the supply of Multi-Para Monitors may be
recovered from the Executive Officer out of his salary for its payment to the
concerned agency as the expenditure does not fall within the ambit of
municipal services as envisaged in the J&K Municipal Act, 2000 and other
instructions conveyed by the competent authorities from time to time.
13.
In compliance to the aforesaid direction, the Executive Officer,
Municipal Committee Dooru-Verinag, vide impugned communication dated
22nd of December, 2023 addressed to the Pay and Accounts Officer,
WP (C) No. 49/2024
Municipal Council, Pulwama, had requested that an amount of ₹1,64,235/may kindly be deducted from the salary of the Petitioner, who was at that
point of time working as Executive Officer, Municipal Committee, Tral.
14.
It is sufficiently clear from the record that neither any finding
had been returned by the Committee constituted indicting the Petitioner
herein nor any regular enquiry was conducted against him, for having
incurred expenditure in contravention to the provisions of the J&K
Municipal Act, 2000, by purchasing three number of Multi-Para Monitors
for being installed in the Sub-District Hospital Dooru, though having been
authorized by the Municipal Council. The Directorate, however, by its
impugned communication dated 23rd of November, 2023, had directed
recovery of the amount incurred from the Petitioner’s salary without
seeking his explanation or giving him any right of being heard against the
legal principle of “Audi alteram partem”. The Respondents had every right
to proceed against the Petitioner with regard to the allegation of having
unauthorizedly incurred an expenditure by placing order for the purpose of
the aforesaid three number of Multi-Para Monitors for being installed in
Sub-District Hospital, Dooru as a Principal Officer of the Municipal
Committee Dooru-Verinag, however, he could not be condemned unheard.
The Petitioner, in such circumstances, has a legal and constitutional right of
being heard on the subject, before taking a final decision in the matter. It
was incumbent upon the Respondents to proceed in the matter by holding a
proper enquiry, after a show cause notice to him and seeking his reply in the
matter, so that he could explain his position. However, the Respondents
proceeded to issue the impugned communications directing recovery of the
amount from the salary of the Petitioner, without affording any opportunity
of hearing to him. That being so, the impugned communications are
unsustainable in law and are liable to be quashed.
15.
Viewed thus, the instant Writ Petition is allowed and the
impugned communication No. DULB/Acctts/1315-11/32994-98 dated 23rd
WP (C) No. 49/2024
of November, 2023 issued by Respondent No.2 and No. MC/D-V/202324/5725-28 dated 22nd of December, 2023 issued by Respondent No.4 are
hereby quashed. However, the Respondents shall be at liberty to proceed in
the matter relating to unauthorized purchase of three Multi-Purpose
Monitors in Municipal Committee, Dooru-Verinag for their installation in
Sub-District Hospital Dooru, in accordance with law, if they so choose.
16.
Writ Petition is, thus, disposed of on the above terms, along
with connected CM(s).
(M. A. CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
September 8th, 2026
“TAHIR”
i.
Tahir Manzoor Bhat
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
Whether the Judgment is approved for reporting?
Yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review