Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S. No. 18
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
Date of Pronouncement:17.02.2026
Uploaded on:09.03.2026
WP(C) No.1327/2024
GHULAM MOHAMMAD BEIGH
…Petitioner/Appellant(s)
Through: Mr. Shabir Ahmad Budoo, Advocate with
Mr. Suhail Ahmad Dar, Advocate.
Vs.
UNION TERRITORY OF J&K AND ORS.
...Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Lone Altaf, Advocate for private respondents 3 to 9.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE JAVED IQBAL WANI, JUDGE
O R D E R (ORAL)
17.02.2026
Facts;
1.
Ownership of land measuring 04 kanals falling under Survey No.395
min in Estate Sonamarg, Tehsil Kangan, District Ganderbal, passed unto the
petitioner herein pursuant to the attestation of mutation No.602 dated
05.09.1986 and mutation No.605 dated 02.12.1986 respectively, attested by
respondent 10 herein, under Sections 4 and 8 of the Jammu and Kashmir
Agrarian Reforms Act 1976 (for short ‘the Act of 1976) and feeling aggrieved
of the said mutations, private respondents 3 to 9 herein claiming to be the
successors of the original owners of the said land namely Abdul Ahad Raina,
Ghulam Mohi-ud-din Raina and Ghulam Mohammad Raina, preferred an
appeal before Joint Agrarian Reforms Commissioner respondent 2 herein, on
03.01.2022, accompanied with an application for condonation of delay
seeking condonation of delay in preferring the said appeal, wherein the said
condonation of delay application came to be allowed on 15.12.2022 by the
respondent 2, aggrieved of the which order dated 15.12.2022, the petitioner
herein preferred WP(C) No.05/2023 before this Court, which WP(C)
however, came to be withdrawn on 20.01.2023 owing to the disposal of the
main appeal in the meantime by respondent 2 on 10.01.2023, whereafter the
petitioner herein preferred WP(C) No.69/2023 challenging both the orders
being order dated 15.12.2022 passed in the condonation of delay application
as also the order dated 10.01.2023 passed in the main appeal and the said
WP(C) 69/2023 came to be disposed of on 10.07.2023 by this Court directing
the respondent 2 to consider and decide the application for condonation of
delay afresh on merits by passing a speaking/ reasoned order and to make an
endeavor to dispose of the matter within a period of two months positively,
whereafter the respondent 2 on 10.10.2023 decided the condonation of delay
application and allowed the same, aggrieved whereof the petitioner herein
preferred WP(C) No.2811/2023 before this Court, which petition however,
came to be dismissed on 03.11.2023, upholding the said order dated
10.10.2023 passed by respondent 2 and aggrieved of the dismissal of the said
WP(C) 2811/2023, the petitioner herein preferred LPA No. 248/2023, which
LPA came to be disposed of on 23.10.2024 on the premise that since the
petitioner herein (being the appellant before the LPA Bench) had challenged
the order passed in the main appeal in a separate writ petition i.e. WP(C)
No.1327/2024
(being
present
petition)
and
that
as
such,
the
appellant/petitioner herein shall be free to raise the question with regard to the
legality of the order of condonation of delay dated 10.10.2023 passed by
respondent 2 while providing further that the order of dismissal of the writ
petition of the petitioner dated 03.11.2023 passed in WP(C) No.2811/2023 of
2023 shall not come in the way of appellant/petitioner herein in assailing the
said order dated 10.10.2023 on the ground that the respondent 2 herein has
erroneously condoned the delay and the petitioner herein whereafter in view
of the aforesaid liberty granted by LPA Bench amended the said WP(C)
No.1327/2024 incorporating therein challenge to the condonation of delay
order dated 10.10.2023 passed by respondent 2 herein and consequently
amended the petition being the present one.
2.
The petitioner herein has challenged orders dated 10.10.2023 and
30.11.2024 being the order of condonation of delay and the order of disposal
of the appeal respectively passed by respondent 2 herein in the instant petition,
inter alia, on the grounds that the respondent 2 entertained the time barred
appeal and condoned the delay without any lawful justification after a
considerable period of time of 34 years and that the impugned orders are bad
in law having been passed without assigning any reasons in a novel, unknown
mode having directed the respondents 3 to 9 herein during the course of the
proceedings of the case to file a supplementary condonation of delay
application in order to bestow favour upon them and that the law on the subject
of condonation of delay was not considered by respondent 2 herein while
condoning the delay of 34 years without there being a sufficient cause as the
ex-land owners have had never ever thrown challenge to the mutations in
question during their lifetime and that the land in question attracted the
application of the Act of 1976 and mutations were rightly attested in favour
of the petitioner herein.
3.
Objections to the petition have been filed by the private respondents 3
to 9 wherein the petition is being opposed on the premise that the writ petition
is not maintainable as the petitioner has approached the Court with unclean
hands and that the petition involves determination of disputed questions of
fact and title, which is beyond the purview and scope of jurisdiction of this
Court under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution and that the mutations
in question had been rightly set-aside by the respondent 2 as there was no
title/entry made in the revenue records establishing the relationship of the
landlord and tenant between the answering respondents and the petitioner
herein and that, in fact, the respondents herein had been in continuous personal
cultivation and occupation of the land in question even recorded as such in
Khasra Girdawari and Jamabandi and that the mutations had been attested in
violation of Standing Order 23-A and that the answering respondents had
come to know about attestation of said mutations only after the petitioner
herein had filed objections to the claim lodged by the answering respondents
for release of compensation of the land in question which meantime had been
acquired for public purpose by the official respondents and that the mutations
in question had been attested fraudulently without any competence by
attesting officer.
Heard counsel for the parties and perused the record.
4.
According to the counsel for the petitioner, the respondent 2 herein has
decided the condonation of delay application in terms of impugned order
dated 10.10.2023 without there being either sufficient cause or plausible
reason expressed therein in the application for condonation of delay
application either initially filed by respondents 3 to 9 herein as also
subsequently upon filing of supplementary application. Counsel for the
petitioner would insist that respondent 2 herein could not have condoned the
period of delay of more than 30 years in absence of sufficient reasons and yet
decided the validity of the mutations under challenge under the guise that there
has been a strong case on merits involved in the appeal maintained by
respondents 3 to 9 herein which could not have been done in view of law laid
down by the Apex Court in cases titled as “Pathapati Subba Reddy and
Ors., Vs. Special Deputy Collector” reported in 2024 (12) SCC 336, and
“Shivamma Vs. Karnataka Housing board and Ors.”, reported in 2025
SCC Online SC 1969.
5.
On the contrary the counsel for the respondents 3 to 9 herein while
defending the impugned orders would reiterate that the said orders came to be
passed validly and lawfully by the respondent 2, and that owing to the cast
iron strength case of the respondents 3 to 9 herein, setup in the appeal against
the mutations in question, the respondent 2 herein, rightly condoned the delay
after being convinced with the explanation offered therein the application for
condonation of delay and the supplementary application subsequently filed
thereto.
6.
Before proceeding to advert to the rival submissions of the counsel for
the parties, it is significant to refer hereunder to the order of Division Bench
dated 23.10.2024 passed in LPA No. 248/2023 supra being relevant to the
controversy ;
1. This intra-court appeal is directed against the Judgement of the learned
Single Judge of this Court dated 03.11.2023 passed in WP(C) No.
2811/2023 titled "Ghulam Mohammad Beigh vs. Union Territory of
Jammu & Kashmir and Others" whereby the writ court has upheld the
order of Additional Deputy Commissioner, (Joint Agrarian Reforms
Commissioner) Ganderbal, condoning the delay in appeal under Section
19 of the Jammu & Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act 1976.
2. It is submitted that during the pendency of this appeal, the main appeal
has been decided by the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Ganderbal,
finally vide its order dated 30.04.2024 which has been assailed by the
appellant before this Court in WP(C) No. 1327/2024.
3. Vide order dated 25.03.2024 passed in this appeal it was provided that
any order that may be passed by the concerned appellate authority shall
remain subject to the outcome of the present appeal and status quo on
spot shall be maintained. Before us learned counsel for the parties fairly
submitted that the controversy raised in this appeal can be settled by
reserving a liberty to the appellant to raise the issue of condonation of
delay ordered by the Additional Deputy Commissioner. Ganderbal, either
in the writ petition which has been disposed of or by filing a separate writ
petition notwithstanding the Judgement passed by the learned Single
Judge dated 03.11.2023.
4. Having regard to the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties
and with their consent, this appeal is disposed of along with all connected
CMs by providing as under:
i. That the appellant who has already challenged the final
order passed in appeal by the Additional Deputy
Commissioner, Ganderbal, shall be free to raise the question
with regard to the legality of the order of the Additional Deputy
Commissioner, Ganderbal, condoning the delay in filing the
appeal by the respondents.
ii. This liberty shall be available to the appellants
notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in the
Judgment passed by the Single Bench. To make it more clear
and unequivocal, the judgment passed by the learned Single
Judge shall not come in the way of the appellant to assail the
impugned order on the ground that the Additional Deputy
Commissioner has erroneously condoned the delay.
As is manifest from above the Division Bench in essence left it open
for the petitioner herein to agitate the matter of condonation of delay before
this Court in the already pending petition being the present WP(C)
No.1327/2024 filed by filed by the petitioner herein against the order of
disposal of the appeal dated 30.04.2024 passed by respondent 2 herein and in
clear and unequivocal terms provided that the dismissal of the petition filed
by the petitioner herein against the condonation of delay order 10.10.2023
shall not come in his way in assailing the said order of condonation of delay
in the said WP(C) No.1327/2024. Therefore, in this view of the matter, it is
deemed appropriate to advert to the order dated 10.10.2023 passed in
condonation of delay application passed by respondent 2 herein in the first
instance.
7.
Before proceeding further in the matter, it would be advantageous and
appropriate to refer hereunder the judgement of the Apex Court passed in case
titled as “Pathapati Subba Reddy and Ors., Vs. Special Deputy Collector,
wherein following has been held: 28. On a harmonious consideration of the provisions of the law, as aforesaid,
and the law laid down by this Court, it is evident that:
28.1. Law of limitation is based upon public policy that there should be an end
to litigation by forfeiting the right to remedy rather than the right itself;
28.2. A right or the remedy that has not been exercised or availed of for a
long time must come to an end or cease to exist after a fixed period of time;
28.3. The provisions of the Limitation Act have to be construed differently,
such as Section 3 has to be construed in a strict sense whereas Section 5
has to be construed liberally;
28.4. In order to advance substantial justice, though liberal approach. justiceoriented approach or cause of substantial justice may be kept in mind but the
same cannot be used to defeat the substantial law of limitation contained in
Section 3 of the Limitation Act;
28.5. Courts are empowered to exercise discretion to condone the delay if
sufficient cause had been explained, but that exercise of power is
discretionary in nature and may not be exercised even if sufficient cause is
established for various factors such as, where there is inordinate delay,
negligence and want of due diligence;
28.6. Merely some persons obtained relief in similar matter, it does not mean
that others are also entitled to the same benefit if the court is not satisfied with
the cause shown for the delay in filing the appeal;
28.7. Merits of the case are not required to be considered in condoning the
delay: and
28.8. Delay condonation application has to be decided on the parameters laid
down for condoning the delay and condoning the delay for the reason that the
conditions have been imposed, tantamounts to disregarding the statutory
provision.
A further reference to the judgement of the Apex Court passed in case
titled as “Shivamma Vs. Karnataka Housing board and Ors.”,, would also
be advantageous herein, wherein at paras 234, 235, 258 and 259, following
has been held: 234. Even otherwise, it is no more res-integra, that law of limitation has to be
applied all but the same and with all its rigour, even if it may harshly affect a
particular party. In Basawaraj (supra) this Court observed that a result flowing
from a statutory provision is never an evil. A court has no power to ignore that
provision to relieve what it considers a distress resulting from its operation.
Even if the statutory provision may cause hardship or inconvenience to a
particular party the court has no choice but to give full effect to the same. It is
based on the legal maxim dura lex sed lex i.e., "the law is hard but it is the
law". The relevant observations read as under:7
"12. It is a settled legal proposition that law of limitation may harshly
affect a particular party but it has to be applied with all its rigour when
the statute so prescribes. The court has no power to extend the period
of limitation on equitable grounds. 'A result flowing from a statutory
provision is never an evil. A court has no power to ignore that
provision to relieve what it considers a distress resulting from its
operation.' The statutory provision may cause hardship or
inconvenience to a particular party but the court has no choice but to
enforce it giving full effect to the same. The legal maxim dura lex sed
lex which means "the law is hard but it is the law", stands attracted in
such a situation. It has consistently been held that, "inconvenience is
not" a decisive factor to be considered while interpreting a statute.
13. The statute of limitation is founded on public policy, its aim being
to secure peace in the community, to suppress fraud and perjury, to
quicken diligence and to prevent oppression. It seeks to bury all acts
of the past which have not been agitated unexplainably and have from
lapse of time become stale. [...]"
235. An application seeking condonation of delay is to be decided only within
the parameters laid down by this Court. In case there was no sufficient cause
to prevent a litigant to approach the court on time condoning the delay without
any justification, on lofty ideals amounts to passing an order in violation of the
statutory provisions and it tantamounts to showing utter disregard to the
statute.
258. The length of the delay is a relevant matter which the court must take
into consideration while considering whether the delay should be condoned
or not. From the tenor of the approach of the respondents, it appears that they
want to fix their own period of limitation for instituting the proceedings for
which law has prescribed a period of limitation. Once it is held that a party
has lost his right to have the matter considered on merits because of his own
inaction for a long, it cannot be presumed to be non-deliberate delay and in
such circumstances of the case, it cannot be heard to plead that the
substantial justice deserves to be preferred as against the technical
considerations. While considering the plea for condonation of delay, the court
must not start with the merits of the main matter. The court owes a duty to
first ascertain the bona fides of the explanation offered by the party seeking
condonation. It is only if the sufficient cause assigned by the litigant and the
opposition of the other side is equally balanced that the court may bring into
aid the merits of the matter for the purpose of condoning the delay.
259. We are of the view that the question of limitation is not merely a technical
consideration. The rules of limitation are based on the principles of sound
public policy and principles of equity. We should not keep the 'Sword of
Damocles' hanging over the head of the respondent for indefinite period of
time to be determined at the whims and fancies of the appellants.
8.
Keeping in mind the facts of the case, the order passed by the Division
Bench supra inasmuch as the position and principles of law laid down by the
Apex Court in the aforesaid judgements, the condonation of delay applications
filed initially by respondents 3 to 9 herein and subsequently by way of
supplementary application before respondent 2 herein need to be extracted
and reproduced here under in extenso: 1/ That the applicant has filed the above titled petition before this Hon'ble
court and the same is registered and numbered accordingly.
2/ That for the sake of brevity the pleas taken in the main petition are adopted
as grounds for the present application which need not to be repeated.
3/ That the applicants have a strong prima facie case in their favour and they
are sure to succeed in the same.
4/ That the balance of convenience is in favor of the applicants and against
the Non-applicants.
5/ That the applicants were unaware of the Mutations as attested by Tehsildar
Gund till date as same has been attested at the back of petitioners.
6/ That in case the relief as prayed for in this application is not granted in favor
of the applicant, the applicants shall suffer an irreparable loss and injury which
cannot be compensated in any manner later on and the petition will become
infractuous.
7/ That the Hon'ble court may be pleased to condone the delay which the
applicants have made in filing the appeal.
8/ An affidavit in support of application is hereby annexed.
In the premises, it is therefore prayed that the delay as made in presenting
the appeal may be condoned so as to secure ends of justice.
Supplementary application
1.That the appellant has filed the above titled petition/appeal before this
Hon'ble and same is registered and numbered accordingly.
2. That the appellants are the owners and in possession of land measuring 4
kanals under survey no 359 situated at Mouza Sonamarg as appellants got
surprised when they approached the revenue department for the issuance of
revenue extract of land measuring 4 kanals and was recorded in the name of
the respondent no 1 and the type of the land is maidani, as per the Jamabandi
for the year 1967-68 Survey no 395 in estate Sonamarg is shown as Maidani
has been vested from Ahad, Mahad and Ghulam Mohammad sons of Gaffar,
and the said land has been fraudulently mutated in the name of Ghulam
Mohammad Beigh by virtue of mutation no 602, section 4 and as land is
Maidani and such type of land is not cultivated by any person particularly the
respondents.
3. That the appellants got the knowledge of the same when the land was
acquired by the NHIDCL in December 2021 for the road project as the
appellants approached the revenue authorities for the sake of compensation
and they got surprised to see that the said land was recorded in the name of
the respondents by way of the fraud mutation as it is mentioned that the land
is self cultivated by the respondents which is against the supremacy of the
law laid down in the provisions of the revenue laws. Then after, the appellants
approached the court of A.D.C. for the instant appeal.
4. That as per the records it is clear that the mutation has been attested
against the provisions of the law and once the fore fathers of the appellants
were in self cultivation of the said land in the year 1971 AD and the said land
is recorded as the Maidani and vacant, how could the mutation be affected in
the name of the respondents who were residing at Srinagar at a distance of
90 kilometers away from the said land and it is not possible for respondent no
1 to cultivate such type of land.
5. That it is needful to mention here that the father of the appellants as well
as the appellants were in continuous possession of the said land till the land
was acquired by the NHIDCL in December 2021 for road project and the fact
of continuous possession can be gathered from the Khasre Girdawari/
Jamabaridi issued by the Revenue Officers. Once the appellants are in the
continuous possession of land under Khasre no 395 which means that they
are unaware about the said fraud mutation attested in the name of the
respondent no 1.
6. That the appellants have the strong prima facia case in their favour and
they are sure to succeed in the same.
7. That any application or any appeal, other than the application under any
provisions of the Order XXI of Code of Civil Procedure may be admitted after
prescribed provisions, if the defeated. As against this, when the delay is
condoned, the highest that can happen is that a cause would be decided on
merits after hearing the parties, as it is also mentioned in the various
judgements that substantial justice and technical consideration are pitted
against each other, cause of substantial justice deserves to be preferred for
the other side cannot claim to have vested right in injustice being done
because of non-deliberate delay, it should be grasped that the judiciary is
respected not on the account of its power to legalize the injustice on the
technical grounds but because it is capable of removing injustice and is
expected to do so, as making a justice oriented approach from the
prospective that was a sufficient cause for condoning the delay in the instant
appeal as the appellants are in continuous possession till the land was
acquired by NHIDCL for road purpose in December 2021 and till then the
appellants were not having the knowledge about fraud mutation attested in
favour of the respondent. Then after they immediately approached before this
court with the instant appeal for setting aside the mutation as it means for
filling the instant appeal and cause of action accrued by the appellants when
they got the knowledge of the said mutation and limitation from the same date
accrued to the appellants for filling of the instant appeal.
8. That the supreme court has mentioned in the various judgement that the
persons living in the far flung areas are not aware about the revenue laws in
such cases condonation of delay can be condoned at any stage whether it is
hit by limitation or not.
9. That the grave illegality committed by the mutating officer while attesting
the mutation is that he has made the impugned mutation at the back of and
without calling and hearing appellants/petitioners. Appellants/Petitioners
have been condemned unheard. on this count this mutation is nullity in the
eyes of law. As per the law laid down in the various judgements by the Hon'ble
High court of Jammu and
10. That it has been held that the mutation in hand is patently without
jurisdiction and void ab-initio because there is absolutely no law where under
such a mutation can be made that too in such and illegal manner. Hence no
question of limitation can come in the way of setting aside of such illegal
mutation. It has also been held by the Hon'ble High Court of Jammu and
Kashmir that against such an illegal mutation which is based on fraud and
made at the back of petitioner/appellant, rules of limitation have to be liberally
construed so as to substantiate justice and enforce rule of law.
11. That the approach of the courts/authorities must be to impart substantial
justice rather than to tangle in the technicalities as has been held in the case
of Collector Land Acquisition Anantnag V/S Katiji by the Hon'ble Supreme
court of India.
12.That it is needful to mention that as per the law the period of limitation
starts to run from the date of knowledge where impugned order has been
passed at the back of the aggrieved party as in the present case. So the court
is bound under law to ascertain the date of knowledge.
As is manifest from above, the aforesaid initial application for
condonation of delay filed by respondents 3 to 9 herein, is manifestly cryptic
and does not anywhere express any sufficient or plausible reason or cause for
condonation of delay as the only plea raised and urged in the application is
that the applicants/respondents 3 to 9 herein were unaware till date about the
mutations in question, as the same had been attested at their back though as
per the record available at the relevant point of time of attestation of mutations
in question amongst three of their predecessors in interest, two were alive and
the said alive predecessors in interest of the petitioner did not during their
lifetime challenge the said mutations.
Even it is manifest from the perusal of the supplementary application
surpa that the respondents 3 to 9 herein have not indicated in specific terms
as to why they had no knowledge about the mutations in question which
indisputably have been attested more than 30 years, before filing of the appeal
and it is merely stated that the knowledge of the mutations in question came
to be got by them only upon acquisition of land by NHIDCL in the month of
December 2021, so much so, the source of knowledge is also not disclosed in
both applications by the respondents 3 to 9 herein. Therefore, having regard
to the aforesaid position obtaining in the matter, it cannot, but be said, that the
respondents 3 to 9 herein have failed to express any plausible and sufficient
cause for condonation of delay and as such, the respondents 3 to 9 herein can
safely be said to have lost the remedy as well as the right available to them in
the mater, in view of law laid down by the Apex Court in case titled as
“Pathapati Subba Reddy supra and “Shivamma supra, and also that law of
limitation has to be applied all but the same and with all its rigour, even if it
may harshly affect a particular party, in view of law laid down by the Apex
Court in case titled as “Shivamma Vs. Karnataka Housing Board and
Ors.,” supra.
9.
Viewed thus, for what has been observed, considered and analyzed
hereinabove, the instant petition succeeds as a consequence whereof the
impugned order dated 10.10.2023 passed by respondent 2 herein condoning
the delay of more than 30 years in the condonation of delay application filed
by respondents 3 to 9 herein is quashed as a consequence whereof, the
impugned order dated 30.04.2024 passed in the main appeal filed by
respondents 3 to 9 against mutation Nos.602 and 605 as well is quashed and
the condonation of delay application filed by the respondents 3 to 9 herein
before respondent 2 herein shall be deemed to have been dismissed along with
the accompanying appeal.
10.
The amount of compensation which was previously ordered by this
Court to be deposited in terms of order dated 08.11.2025 in CM No.2615/2025
filed by the petitioner herein, as per report of the Registry has not been
deposited uptil now, as such, the official respondents shall be free to disburse
the said amount of compensation in accordance with law.
(JAVED IQBAL WANI)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
17.02.2026
Ishaq
Whether the order is speaking ?
Yes
Whether approved for reporting ?
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review