The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
27. 12.2017 and the mutations order Nos.3656 and 3677 passed in favour of the appellant herein were set aside and the matter was remanded to the Assistant Commissioner, Revenue, concerned for passing of fresh order on spot after affording an opportunity of being heard to all the stakeholders including the ex-owners. 3) The aforesaid order passed by the Commissioner Agrarian Reforms was challenged by the appellant herein by way of a revision petition before the J&K Special Tribunal. The learned Tribunal vide order dated 04.07.2018 allowed the revision petition and set aside the order passed by the Commissioner Agrarian Reforms. 4) The predecessor-in-interest of respondent Nos.1 to 5, Haji Ghulam Rasool Chaku, filed a writ petition throwing challenge to the order passed by the learned J&K Special Tribunal on the grounds that that the mutation orders could not have been passed in favour of the appellant herein because he was not a tiller of the land in question prior to Kharif 1971. It was contended that the mutation orders have been passed in violation of Standing Order No.23-A Instruction 104 and, as such, the same were contrary to the provisions of the Act. It was also contended that the learned Tribunal has not appreciated the controversy properly and has, without any cogent reasoning, proceeded to set aside the order passed by the learned Commissioner. 5) The learned Writ Court, …
27. 12.2017 has been upheld and the order passed by the Tribunal on 04.07.2018 has been quashed. As already stated, the Commissioner has, vide his order dated
27. 12.2017, without deciding the issues raised on their merits, simply remanded the case to the Assistant Commissioner, Revenue, Srinagar, for conducting enquiry on spot after affording an opportunity of being heard to all the stakeholders including the ex-owners. 12) Thus, the appellant herein has all the opportunity to put forward his contentions, claims and material in support thereof before the Assistant Commissioner, Revenue, Srinagar, during the course of enquiry. It is always open to him to raise all the issues that have been raised by him in the present appeal which would include the effect of pendency of the suit on the subject matter of the dispute. Therefore, the impugned order passed by the learned Writ Court does not in any manner prejudice the right of the appellant to present his case before the learned Assistant Commissioner, Revenue, Srinagar. 13) One thing is clear from the record of the case that the mutations under Section 4 and 8 of the Act in respect of the land in question have been attested in favour of the appellant and the correction in the cultivation column of subject land in Kharif 1971 has been effected without hearing the ex-owners and other stakeholders. This is clear from a bare perusal of the mutation orders passed by the Tehsildar concerned. Therefore, learned Commissioner Agrarian Reforms was right in remanding the case back to the Assistant Com…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Item No.33
Regular List
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND
LADAKH AT SRINAGAR
Pronounced on:29.06.2026
Uploaded on: 01.07.2026
LPA No.118/2023
GHULAM AHMAD CHAKU
... APPELLANT(S)
Through: -
Mr. Z. A. Qureshi, Sr. Advocate, with
Mr. Anurag Verma, Advocate.
Vs.
ABDUL MAJEED CHAKU & ORS.
…RESPONDENT(S)
Through: -
CORAM:
Mr. G. A. Lone, Sr. Advocate, with
Mr. Mujeeb, Andrabi, Advocate.
Mr. Shuja-ul-Haq, Advocate.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHD. YOUSUF WANI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
Sanjay Dhar ‘J’:
1)
The appellant has called in question order dated
12.06.2023 passed by the learned Writ Court, whereby writ
petition bearing OWP No.1296/2018/2025 filed by one Haji
Ghulam Rasool Chaku, the predecessor-in-interest of
respondent Nos.1 to 5, has been allowed and order dated
04.07.2018 passed by the J&K Special Tribunal, Srinagar,
has been set aside.
2)
The facts giving rise to the filing of the present appeal
are that mutation Nos.3655 dated 02.12.1988 and 3677
LPA No.118/2023
dated 16.02.1989 under Section 4 and 8 of the Agrarian
Reforms Act (for short “the Act”) with regard to land
measuring 3 kanals and 4 marlas falling under Survey
Nos.1217-min, 1222-min and 1232-min situated at Ishber
Nishat, Srinagar, came to be attested in favour of Haji
Ghulam
Ahmad
Chaku
(the
appellant
herein).
The
predecessor-in-interest of respondent Nos.1 to 5 assailed
the said mutation orders by way of an appeal before the
Commissioner Agrarian Reforms, J&K. The appeal was
allowed by the Commissioner vide his order dated
27.12.2017 and the mutations order Nos.3656 and 3677
passed in favour of the appellant herein were set aside and
the matter was remanded to the Assistant Commissioner,
Revenue, concerned for passing of fresh order on spot after
affording an opportunity of being heard to all the
stakeholders including the ex-owners.
3)
The aforesaid order passed by the Commissioner
Agrarian Reforms was challenged by the appellant herein
by way of a revision petition before the J&K Special
Tribunal. The learned Tribunal vide order dated 04.07.2018
allowed the revision petition and set aside the order passed
by the Commissioner Agrarian Reforms.
4)
The predecessor-in-interest of respondent Nos.1 to 5,
Haji Ghulam Rasool Chaku, filed a writ petition throwing
LPA No.118/2023
challenge to the order passed by the learned J&K Special
Tribunal on the grounds that that the mutation orders
could not have been passed in favour of the appellant
herein because he was not a tiller of the land in question
prior to Kharif 1971. It was contended that the mutation
orders have been passed in violation of Standing Order
No.23-A Instruction 104 and, as such, the same were
contrary to the provisions of the Act. It was also contended
that the learned Tribunal has not appreciated the
controversy
properly
and
has,
without
any
cogent
reasoning, proceeded to set aside the order passed by the
learned Commissioner.
5)
The learned Writ Court, after hearing the parties and
after considering the material on record, passed the
impugned order dated 12.06.2023, whereby the writ
petition was allowed and, while upholding the order passed
by the Commissioner Agrarian Reforms on 27.12.2017, the
order passed by the learned Tribunal on 04.07.2018 was
quashed. The learned Writ Court observed that the
Commissioner had considered the entire controversy in
right perspective and the conclusion drawn by the Tribunal
is not based upon any cogent reasoning.
6)
The appellant has challenged the impugned order
passed by the Writ Court on the grounds that he was not
LPA No.118/2023
allowed by the learned Writ Court to file detailed objections
to the writ petition. It has been contended that the
appellant had only filed a short reply to the writ petition
wherein he had raised a preliminary objection with regard
to maintainability of the writ petition as the writ petitioner
had filed the petition under Section 104 of the Constitution
of J&K and not under Section 103 of the Constitution of
J&K.
7)
It has been contended that the learned Writ Court,
without
dealing
with
the
objection
with
regard
to
maintainability of the writ petition and rendering a finding
thereon, proceeded to deal with the merits of the case
without obtaining a reply on merits from the respondents.
On this ground, it is being submitted that the version of the
appellant on merits of the case has not been considered by
the learned Writ Court while passing the impugned order.
It has been further contended that the writ petitioner had
suppressed the material fact with regard to pendency of the
civil suit in respect of the land which was subject matter of
the writ petition, as a result of which the said aspect of the
matter has not been considered by the learned Writ Court
while passing the impugned order. It has also been
contended that mutations under Section 4 and 8 of the Act
were attested in favour of the appellant after adhering to
LPA No.118/2023
the procedure prescribed under the Act and the rules
framed thereunder, as such, the mutation orders attested
in favour of the appellant could not have been set aside by
the Commissioner Agrarian Reforms, which order has been
upheld by the learned Writ Court.
8)
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and we
have also gone through the grounds projected in the appeal
as also the record of the Writ Court.
9)
A perusal of the writ record would reveal that the writ
petitioner had initially filed a petition under Section 104 of
the Constitution of J&K, which corresponds to Article 227
of the Constitution of India. It seems that, during pendency
of the writ petition, when an objection was raised by the
appellant before the Writ Court about maintainability of the
petition, the writ petitioner filed an application with the
prayer that the petition may be treated as one under Article
226 of the Constitution of India read with Section 103 of
the Constitution of J&K. The said application was objected
to by the appellant by filing reply thereto. On 08.05.2023,
the learned Writ Court, while taking note of the objection
raised by the appellant with regard to maintainability of the
petition as also with regard to application of the writ
petitioner for treating his petition as a writ petition under
Article 226 of the Constitution, posted the matter for 12th
LPA No.118/2023
June, 2023 for the purpose of hearing the application as
well as the main writ petition.
10)
A perusal of the impugned order dated 12.06.2023
passed by the learned Writ Court would reveal that the
petition has been treated as one under Article 226 of the
Constitution, which is clear from the first para of the
impugned order, wherein it has been noted that the
petitioner has invoked the extraordinary jurisdiction of the
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Keeping in view the fact that the learned Writ Court has
treated the petition filed by the writ petitioner as one filed
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the issue with
regard to maintainability of the petition has lost its
significance.
11)
That takes us to the question as to whether any
prejudice has been caused to the appellant by not
permitting him to file objections to the writ petition on
merits. In this context, if we have a look at the impugned
order passed by the learned Writ Court, vide the said order,
the order passed by the Commissioner Agrarian Reforms on
27.12.2017 has been upheld and the order passed by the
Tribunal on 04.07.2018 has been quashed. As already
stated, the Commissioner has, vide his order dated
27.12.2017, without deciding the issues raised on their
LPA No.118/2023
merits, simply remanded the case to the Assistant
Commissioner, Revenue, Srinagar, for conducting enquiry
on spot after affording an opportunity of being heard to all
the stakeholders including the ex-owners.
12)
Thus, the appellant herein has all the opportunity to
put forward his contentions, claims and material in support
thereof before the Assistant Commissioner, Revenue,
Srinagar, during the course of enquiry. It is always open to
him to raise all the issues that have been raised by him in
the present appeal which would include the effect of
pendency of the suit on the subject matter of the dispute.
Therefore, the impugned order passed by the learned Writ
Court does not in any manner prejudice the right of the
appellant to present his case before the learned Assistant
Commissioner, Revenue, Srinagar.
13)
One thing is clear from the record of the case that the
mutations under Section 4 and 8 of the Act in respect of the
land in question have been attested in favour of the
appellant and the correction in the cultivation column of
subject land in Kharif 1971 has been effected without
hearing the ex-owners and other stakeholders. This is clear
from a bare perusal of the mutation orders passed by the
Tehsildar concerned. Therefore, learned Commissioner
Agrarian Reforms was right in remanding the case back to
LPA No.118/2023
the Assistant Commissioner, Revenue, to hold an enquiry
and affording an opportunity of hearing to all stakeholders
including the ex-landowner before proceeding to pass
appropriate orders under rule 4 of the J&K Agrarian
Reforms Rules. Thus, there is no infirmity in the impugned
order so far as it upholds the aforesaid order passed by the
Commissioner Agrarian Reforms.
14)
The learned Writ Court is also right in setting aside
order dated 04.07.2018 passed by the learned Special
Tribunal as the learned Tribunal has not given any cogent
reasoning for allowing revision petition against the order of
Commissioner Agrarian Reforms. A perusal of the order
passed by the learned Tribunal would reveal that the
learned
Tribunal
has,
while
observing
that
the
Commissioner has not gone into and adjudicated the issues
which were presented before him, instead of remanding the
matter to the Assistant Commissioner for adjudication of
these so-called issues, proceeded to set aside the order of
the Commissioner without rendering any finding on the
issues, which according to the learned Tribunal were not
gone into by the Commissioner Agrarian Reforms. The order
passed by the learned Tribunal is clearly unsustainable in
law and, as such, the finding recorded by the learned Writ
Court in this regard is also perfectly in accordance with law.
LPA No.118/2023
15)
For what has been discussed hereinabove, we do not
find any ground to interfere in the well-reasoned and lucid
order passed by the learned Writ Court. The appeal lacks
merit. The same is dismissed accordingly.
(Mohd. Yousuf Wani)
Judge
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
Srinagar,
29.06.2026
“Bhat Altaf-Secretary”
Whether the ORDER is reportable: YES/NO
LPA No.118/2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review