Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:31873
W.P(C)No.14203 of 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. NITIN JAMDAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE S.MANU
TUESDAY, THE 8TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 18TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO.14203 OF 2024
PETITIONERS:
GEORGE PHILIP
AGED 71 YEARS
S/O. POTHEN, MANAGER, MANIMALA ESTATE, DWARAKA
PLANTATIONS, PANNIYANKARA P.O., PALAKKAD DISTRICT.,
PIN - 678683
GEORGE
AGED 73 YEARS
S/O. PAILY, RESIDING AT PUTHULLI HOUSE,
VANIYAMPARA,THRISSUR., PIN - 678686
BY ADVS.
P.R.VENKATESH
ASHA P.KURIAKOSE
LAKSHMI MEENAKSHI P.R.
RESPONDENTS:
UNION OF INDIA
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF SURFACE
ROAD TRANSPORT, NEW DELHI, PIN - 110001
NATIONAL HIGHWAY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
MINISTRY OF ROAD TRANSPORT & HIGHWAYS, G5&6, SECTOR
10, DWARKA, NEW DELHI. REP.BY ITS CHAIRMAN, PIN 110075
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY, SECRETARIAT,
2025:KER:31873
W.P(C)No.14203 of 2024
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM - 695001
NATIONAL HIGHWAY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
CHANDRANAGAR, PALAKKAD REPRESENTED BY THE PROJECT
DIRECTOR, REGIONAL OFFICE, PALAKKAD, PIN - 678007
THRISSUR EXPRESS WAY LIMITED
PERAMBRA, THRISSUR DISTRICT, REP BY ITS PROJECT
DIRECTOR, PIN - 680689
PRAKRITHI ENGINEERING AND RAIL PVT. LTD
IRUMPUPALAM, VANIYAMPARA REPRESENTED BY ITS
MANAGING DIRECTOR, PIN - 678686
T.P.VELAYUDHAN
INDEPENDENT ENGINEER, INTERCONTINENTAL CONSULTANTS
& TECHNOCRATS PVT. LTD., A-B, GROUND FLOOR, GREEN
PARK, NEW DELHI, PIN - 110015
BY ADVS.
S.BIJU, SENIOR CENTRAL GOVERNMENT COUNSEL
MARTIN JOSE P
P.PRIJITH(K/233/2005)
THOMAS P.KURUVILLA(K/420-B/2005) – FOR R5
R.GITHESH(K/630/2002)
AJAY BEN JOSE(K/729/2012)
MANJUNATH MENON(K/000474/2015)
HARIKRISHNAN S.(K/497/2019)
SACHIN JACOB AMBAT(K/734/2016)
ANNA LINDA EDEN(K/1201/2020)
S.SREEKUMAR (SR.)(S-571)
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
08.04.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:31873
W.P(C)No.14203 of 2024
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 8th day of April, 2025
Nitin Jamdar, C.J.
Heard Mr.P.R.Venkatesh, learned counsel for the Petitioners,
Mr.S.Biju, learned Senior Central Government Counsel appearing for
Respondent Nos.1, 2 and 4 and Mr.Thomas P.Kuruvilla, learned counsel
appearing for Respondent No.5.
2.
This Public Interest Litigation (PIL) is filed in respect of levy of toll
for the users of road between Mannuthy in Thrissur District and
Vadakkencherry in Palakkad District.
3.
Before filing the present PIL, a Division Bench of this Court in
W.P(C)No.20796 of 2018, by judgment dated 9 March 2021, had issued
certain directions for completion of the project in question by October
2021, subject to any unforeseen adverse conditions. This petition was filed
raising a grievance that the construction of the tunnel is not complete and
the Respondents have started collecting toll for the tunnel portion even
though the construction has not been completed which is being undertaken
by Respondent No.5, the concessionaire. The prayers in the PIL are as under
:
“a)
Declare that the respondents cannot collect any toll fee
for the tunnel portion as seen from Ext P9 reply
2025:KER:31873
W.P(C)No.14203 of 2024
nd
issued to the 2 petitioner P.P.George, which
specifically fixed the fee for the tunnel at Rs.69.85,
especially when the work which was undertaken by the
consessionaire and bound to be completed before the
opening of the project and part of the concessionarire
agreement and now closed for completion of the said
work;
b)
4.
Issue a writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ,
order or direction restraining the respondents from
collecting any amount as toll fee or otherwise for user of
the tunnel to the tune of Rs.69.85 as stated in Ext P9 till
the tunnel work is completed and opened for the user of
the public;”
On 28 February 2025, when the Petition came up on board, the
learned counsel for the Petitioner submitted that according to his
information, the construction of the tunnel is complete and a counter
affidavit was filed by Respondent No.5, the concessionaire, confirming the
said position. However, in the earlier Writ Petition, this Court had placed
the mandate on the National Highways Authority of India and it was upto
the National Highways Authority of India to confirm that the work is
complete. We called upon the National Highways Authority of India to
place the statement of the responsible officer on record regarding the
completion of the project and the collection of toll.
5.
The learned Senior Central Government Counsel appearing for
Respondent Nos.1, 2 and 4 has placed before us an affidavit filed by the
Project Director, National Highways Authority of India, PIU, Palakkad. He
has stated in the affidavit as under :
2025:KER:31873
W.P(C)No.14203 of 2024
“11. Therefore, upon completion of 90% of the Project Highway
and issuance of PCC, the 5th Respondent became legally
entitled to commence commercial operations and collect
toll charges/user fees. Thereafter, upon successful
completion of 1.230 km of the balance Project Highway
and completion of the various tests stipulated in Article 14
and Schedule I of the Concession Agreement, a cumulative
length of 26.955 km (i.e., PCC-1: 25.725 km + PCC-2
1.230 km) was opened for tolling, and user fee was revised
with effect from 01.04.2022. Subsequently, upon
completion of an additional 1.400 km of the balance Project
Highway and completion of the requisite tests as per Article
14 and Schedule I of the Concession Agreement, a total
cumulative length of 28.355 km (i.e., PCC-1: 25.725 km +
PCC-2: 1.230 km + PCC-3: 1.400 km) was put into tolling,
and user fee was revised with effect from 03.11.2022 for the
entire Project Highway.
12. Accordingly, the entire length of the Project Highway
became operational, and the user fee was rightly levied by
the Concessionaire. As per the terms agreed under the
Settlement Agreement dated 10th August 2023, the Left
Hand Side (LHS) tube of the Kuthiran Tunnel was
temporarily closed to carry out certain additional concrete
lining works on the tunnel roof, which were not a part of the
initial scope of works to be undertaken by the
Concessionaire. The concrete lining was carried out so as to
comply with the conditions setforth in the Supplementary
agreement dated 10.03.2023, hence, the averment of the
Petitioner that the tunnel works were incomplete as on the
date of issuance of PCC is denied as false and baseless.
Consequently, to complete the gantry concreting, only the
LHS tube was closed for a period of five months from midJanuary 2024 to mid-June 2024. During this period.
although traffic was regulated, the Concessionaire ensured
that the closure did not cause any inconvenience or safety
concerns for the users. The gantry concreting was
completed in June 2024, and the LHS tunnel was reopened
to traffic with effect from 14.06.2024.
2025:KER:31873
W.P(C)No.14203 of 2024
13. It is submitted that the user fee was determined and
approved by the NHAI strictly in accordance with the
provisions of the National Highways Fee (Determination of
Rates and Collection) Rules, 2008 ("Rules"), and in
consonance with the Concession Agreement and the User
Fee Notification published for the said project.
14. In the above context, the 4th respondent has issued letter No.
12276/PIU
PKD/NH544/V-T/KL3/IE/819
dated
27.06.2024 to the Independent Engineer, M/s Dhruv
Consultancy Services Ltd according approval for issuance of
completion certificate pursuant to the settlement agreement
dated 10.08.2023. True copy of the letter No. 12276/PIUPKD/NH544/V-T/KL3/IE/819 dated 27.06.2024 is
produced herewith and marked as Exhibit R4(a). Pursuant
to Ext. R4(a) communication, the Independent Engineer
has issued completion certificate certifying completion of all
works pertaining to concession agreement dated
24.08.2009 as completed. A true copy of the letter NO.
DCSL VA/NHA/KL03/2024-25/530 dated 28.06.2024
issued by the M/s independent Engineer, M/s Dhruv
Consultancy Services Ltd is produced herewith and marked
as Exhibit R4(b).
15. It is submitted that in view of Ext. R4(a) and R4(b), the
grievances of the petitioner as highlighted in the writ
petition has been redressed and the prayers in the writ
petition has become infructuous, In view of the above, none
of the grounds stated in support of the reliefs in the Writ
Petition is maintainable and the same is liable to be
dismissed.
16. In view of the above contentions, the reliefs sought in the
Writ Petition cannot survive and the same may be rejected.”
2025:KER:31873
W.P(C)No.14203 of 2024
6.
In view of the above position placed before us, we do not deem it
necessary to take the cause raised in this PIL any further.
7.
The Writ Petition is accordingly closed.
Sd/Nitin Jamdar
Chief Justice
Sd/S. Manu
Judge
vgd/09.04.25
2025:KER:31873
W.P(C)No.14203 of 2024
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 14203/2024
PETITIONERS’ EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF DETAILS OF THE CONCESSION
AGREEMENT DATED 24.8.2009 ALONG WITH TYPED
COPY OF EXT P1
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 10.12.2012 IN W.P.
(C) NO. 20656/2012 OF THIS HON’BLE COURT
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 16.1.2013 IN W.P.
(C) NO. 20656/2012 OF THIS HON’BLE COURT
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 29.1.2013 IN W.P.
(C) NO. 20656/2012 OF THIS HON’BLE COURT
EXHIBIT P5
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 2.4.2013 IN W.P.
(C) NO. 20656/2012 OF THIS HON’BLE COURT
EXHIBIT P6
TRUE COPY OF JUDGMENT DATED 9.3.2021 IN
W.P.(C) NO. 20796/2018 OF THIS HON’BLE
COURT
EXHIBIT P7
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY DATED 02.06.2022
GIVEN TO THE 1ST PETITIONER BY THE DGM(T) &
PROJECT DIRECTOR
EXHIBIT P8
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
SAID
PROVISIONAL
CERTIFICATE ISSUED BY T.P. VELAYUDHAN DATED
9.3.2024
EXHIBIT P9
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY DATED 03.02.2024 OF
THE PROJECT DIRECTOR TO THE 2ND PETITIONER
RESPONDENTS’ EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT R5(A)
TRUE COPY OF THE COMPLETION CERTIFICATE
DATED 28-06-2024ISSUED BY THE INDEPENDENT
ENGINEER
ANNEXURE R4(A)
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
LETTER
12276/PIU-PKD/NH544/V-T/KL3/IE/819
27.06.2024
ANNEXURE R4(B)
A
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
LETTER
NO.
DATED
NO.
2025:KER:31873
W.P(C)No.14203 of 2024
DCSL-VA/NHA/KL03/2024-25/530
DATED
28.06.2024 ISSUED BY THE M/S INDEPENDENT
ENGINEER, M/S DHRUV CONSULTANCY SERVICES
LTD
EXHIBIT R4(A)
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
LETTER
12276/PIU-PKD/NH544/V-T/KL3/IE/819
27.06.2024
NO.
DATED
EXHIBIT R4(B)
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
LETTER
NO.
DCSLVA/NHA/KL03/2024-25/530
DATED
28.06.2024 ISSUED BY THE M/S INDEPENDENT
ENGINEER, M/S DHRUV CONSULTANCY SERVICES
LTD
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review