The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. The instant appeal stands disposed of. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of. (S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J MUNNA SAHA Digitally Pijush/ (APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
IA No.01/2024 in WA No.10 of 2024
WA No.10 of 2024
Gayatri Chakraborty
………Applicant/Appellant(s);
Versus
The State of Tripura & others
………Respondent(s).
For Applicant/Appellant(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Koomar Chakraborty, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A.,
Mr. A. Bhaumik, Advocate,
Mr. S. Dey, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
Order
26/03/2024
Heard Mr. P Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Koomar Chakraborty, learned counsel for the applicant/appellant, Mr. D.
Sarma, learned Additional Government Advocate for the respondents-State and
Mr. A. Bhaumik, learned counsel for the Agartala Municipal Corporation
(AMC) on the prayer for condonation of delay of 457 days in preferring the
instant memo of appeal through IA No.01/2024.
2.
Writ petition was preferred by this appellant and one other seeking
the benefit of gratuity under Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (Act of 1972, for
short). The appellant had superannuated in the year 2010 while the other writ
petitioner had superannuated in the year 2014 from the services of AMC. The
writ petition was filed in the year 2022. The learned Writ Court however
dismissed the writ petition as being barred by delay and laches. Only the first
writ petitioner has preferred this appeal. As informed, the second writ petitioner
has not preferred any appeal. Incidentally, it needs to be mentioned here that
several appeals were filed by the respondents-Corporation being aggrieved by
the judgment passed by the learned Writ Court on 27.06.2022 in a batch of writ
petitions of ex-employees of the same Corporation seeking gratuity benefit
under the Act of 1972. The learned Writ Court had, at that instance, directed the
Corporation to grant gratuity in terms of the Act of 1972. It had overruled the
objection of the Corporation that the employees of the Corporation are
governed by the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 which had been adopted by the
Government of Tripura for the Corporation by notification dated 21.12.1991.
Those writ appeals were dismissed by a common judgment dated 19.02.2024
upholding the view of the learned Writ Court that the employees of the
Corporation are covered under the Act of 1972.
3.
These writ petitioners however suffered a different fate though the
instant impugned order has been delivered two months after that common
judgment & order rendered in favour of the writ petitioners who were the exemployees of the Corporation. The reason being that the writ petitioners had
approached the Court in the year 2022 though the petitioners had retired in
2010 and 2014 respectively.
4.
The appellant has preferred an interlocutory application to explain
the delay. She has, in so many paragraphs of the interlocutory application,
taken the plea that she is a septuagenarian; aged about 72 years and suffering
from several old age ailments like arthritis, neurological disorder, etc. which
required frequent visits to Sakra World Hospital, Bangalore over a period of
time starting from 16.06.2022 i.e. prior to the passing of the impugned order on
06.09.2022 till 30.10.2023. The medical prescriptions dated 16.06.2022 till
30.10.2023 are enclosed as Annexure-I series. All the prescriptions relate to the
same hospital at Bangalore. According to the applicant, she could not move her
hands and legs properly. There was difficulty in her mobility. She had
approached her learned counsel first on 05.01.2023 after knowing of the fate of
her case. But thereafter she could not pursue it due to her serious illness and
frequent visits to the doctor at Bangalore. Later she again approached her
learned counsel after returning from Bangalore on 17.11.2023. The memo of
appeal was finally ready on 14.12.2023 and it was filed on 10.01.2024, which
occasioned a delay of 457 days.
5.
Mr.
Koomar
Chakraborty,
learned
counsel
for
the
applicant/appellant, submits that delay, though large, is not deliberate but duly
explained on account of medical reasons. It is submitted that the Appellate
Court in the case of Agartala Municipal Corporation & another v. Smt. Ratna
Roy & others [WA No. 161 of 2022] and other analogous cases has held that
the
Agartala
Municipal
Corporation
has
a
statutory
obligation
to
pay gratuity to its ex-employees upon their retirement and failure to do so,
would result in payment of interest for such delay in terms of Section 7(3) of
the Act of 1972. This Appellate Court has also held that no question of waiver
or estoppel would arise against a beneficial statute like the Act of 1972
conferring benefits of gratuity in favour of such employees. The Corporation
has not been exempted from such liability by a notification of the State
Government under Section 5 of the Act of 1972. As such, delay if any in
approaching the Appellate Court by the appellant should not defeat her
legitimate rights to receive gratuity under the Act of 1972 from the due date. By
Central Government’s notification dated 24.05.2010, the ceiling of gratuity has
been enhanced to rupees ten lakhs for those retiring after that date. As such, a
purposive and beneficial construction of the provisions of the Act of 1972 has
been accorded by this Court which the petitioner/appellant herein also deserves.
Therefore, the delay may be condoned in the interest of justice.
6.
Mr. A. Bhaumik, learned counsel for the Corporation has filed an
objection to the present interlocutory application. Mr. D. Sarma, learned
Additional Government Advocate for the respondents-State, has also opposed
the prayer for condonation of delay. Learned counsel for the Corporation
submits that the present appeal ought to have been filed on 05.10.2022. At the
relevant point of time, the period for filing intra-Court appeal was governed by
the Gauhati High Court Rules i.e. 30 days. Therefore, the applicant cannot take
a plea that in view of the notification of the High Court of Tripura Rules on
04.01.2023, no limitation was prescribed for preferring an intra-Court appeal.
As such, the contention that there was no period of limitation for preferring an
intra-Court appeal is not correct in the eye of law. Learned counsel for the
Corporation has also submitted that the medical prescriptions annexed to the IA
No.01/2024 suggest visit for treatment purpose on few dates whereas the total
delay is 457 days. There is also no explanation as to why when the memo of
appeal was ready on 05.01.2023, the appellant met her advocate on 05.11.2023
leading to further ten months delay. No air tickets have been enclosed to
substantiate that the applicant had been frequently moving out of the State for
medical treatment to Bangalore. He submits that the appellant had approached
the Writ Court after 12 years of her retirement. Therefore, her case was
dismissed on grounds of delay and laches. Appellate was a fence-sitter as the
decision in the other batch of cases was rendered in July, 2022 and she
approached the Writ Court in September, 2022. Learned counsel for the
Corporation has also relied upon a decision of the Coordinate Bench of this
Court dated 21.08.2023 passed in IA No.01/2023 in Review Petition
No.43/2023 where this Court had refused to condone the delay of 416 days in
similar circumstances where the review petitioners had approached the Court
after relief of pay revision and scale advancement was granted to some other
employees. Learned counsel for the Corporation, however, is not in a position
to dispute that this Court in the case of Agartala Municipal Corporation &
another v. Smt. Ratna Roy & others and other analogous writ appeals has held
that the Corporation is under a statutory obligation under the Act of 1972 to
grant the benefits of gratuity as per the revised ceiling to its ex-employees as no
exemption notification in terms of Section 5 has been issued by the State
Government.
7.
We have considered the submission of learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the explanations urged by the applicant/appellant and
also the objection filed by the Corporation.
Apparently, applicant approached the Writ Court after 12 years of
her superannuation claiming benefits of gratuity under the Act of 1972. The
learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petition on grounds of delay and
laches. However, it is also not in dispute that the learned Writ Court has by
judgment & order dated 27.06.2022 passed in a batch of writ petitions being
WP(C) No.218/2021 and other analogous matters held that the Corporation is
under a statutory obligation to grant gratuity in terms of the Act of 1972 and not
in terms of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 which were adopted for the
Corporation by the State Government vide notification dated 21.12.1991.
8.
Applicant has taken the grounds of her medical treatment for the
delay. Medical prescriptions enclosed to the interlocutory application of course
indicate that she had been visiting Sakra World Hospital, Bangalore for her
treatment on different dates since 16.06.2022 till 30.10.2023. The visits are
spread over almost one and a half year. As such, the grounds of medical
treatment cannot be outrightly dismissed. This explanation for the delay,
therefore, is not manufactured though it appears that the appeal could have been
filed earlier during interregnum in her treatment. However, we also cannot lose
sight of the fact that this Court has, in a batch of writ appeals read by WA
No.161/2022 in the case of Agartala Municipal Corporation & another v.
Smt. Ratna Roy & others and other analogous cases held that the Corporation
is under a statutory obligation to pay the gratuity under the Act of 1972 as per
the ceilings revised from time to time. In those writ appeals also, certain writ
petitioners had approached the Court for relief after a number of years of their
retirement. The plea of delay and estoppel were negatived by this Court in view
of the beneficial nature of the legislation. The present appeal has been filed on
10.01.2024 before the judgment & order passed in the batch of writ appeals on
19.02.2024. Taking an overall view of the matter, therefore, we are inclined to
condone the delay in the interest of justice. IA stands disposed of.
9.
Since the main appeal [WA No.10/2024] relates to the claim of
gratuity under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 by the writ petitioner who is
an ex-employee of the Corporation, we are of the view that her case should also
be governed by the ratio rendered by this Court in the case of Agartala
Municipal Corporation & another v. Smt. Ratna Roy & others and other
analogous cases.
10.
The instant appeal stands disposed of. Pending application(s), if
any, shall also stand disposed of.
(S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J
signed by MUNNA SAHA
MUNNA SAHA Digitally
Date: 2024.04.02 17:39:11 +05'30'
Pijush/
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review