Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRM-M-69911-2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
CRM-M-69911-2025
Date of decision: 17.02.2026
Gaurav Chhabra
...Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab
...Respondent
CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE AARADHNA SAWHNEY
Present :
Mr. Priyanshu Kamra, Advocate
for the petitioner. (through VC)
Mr. Gautam Thapar, Sr. DAG, Punjab.
*****
AARADHNA SAWHNEY, J.(ORAL)
1.
By virtue of the present petition under Section 483 BNSS,
petitioner, an accused in case bearing FIR No.42 dated 23.02.2019 registered
against him, u/s 420, 406, 120-B IPC at Police Station Gobindgarh Mandi,
District Fatehgarh Sahib, has prayed for grant of bail.
2.
Relevant facts as emerging from the FIR be noticed
hereinbelow:Rajiv Singla, son of Shri Pritam Singla, is the resident of
House No. 322, Sector 4-C. Shastri Nagar, Mandi Gobindgarh,
Tehsil Amloh, District Fatehgarh Sahib, hereby submits as
follows: 1. That I am a resident of the said address and am
engaged in the business of iron. 2. That Shahbaz Singh Virk,
son of Sukhjit Singh, currently residing abroad in Canada, has
given me power of attorney to prosecute the case of fraud
committed by Nature Heights Infra Limited and its associated
conspirators. 3. That Neeraj Thathai, Sandhya Wadhwa, Dolly
Thathai came to Kharar, District Mohali in March 2012 and
told Shahbaz Singh Virk about the project of their company
Nature Heights Infra Limited and started building trust by
influencing in their words. In the first week of April 2012,
HAMANT
2026.02.24 19:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Sandhya Wadhwa, Neeraj Thathai, Pankaj Puri and Asha Rani
CRM-M-69911-2025
came to Kharar again and showed Shahbaz Singh Virk their
site at village Jhungian Kharar and they assured Shahbaz that
this project would be completed within 24 months. 4. That the
said person kept contacting Shahbaz to purchase flat and built
trust by telling him big stories about his project and Shahbaz
told Sandhya to tell this entire plan to my uncle Rajiv Singla ji
so that I could make up my mind and asked him to come to my
office at Mandi Gobindgarh. On 11th April 2012, Sandhya,
Neeraj and Dolly Thathai came to my office and told that
Sandhya Wadhwa, Amit Kakkar, Neeraj Thathai, Doli Thathai,
Gaurav Chhabra, Asha Rani, Pankaj Puri all work together on
big projects and all of them have formed many other companies
in which each company has one of them as the Director. Then
he explained the plan to me and Shahbaz and showed me the
map and told me his plan to build a 1530 square feet flat on the
ground floor in Tower No. 23 in the village Jhungian Kharar
site. He told me the price of this flat was Rs.40,50,000 and told
me that out of this entire amount of Rs.40,50,000/-, half of the
amount of Rs.20,25,000/- would have to be paid (Rs.12,15,000/till the agreement is made and Rs.8,10,000/- till August 2013)
and the remaining half of the amount of Rs.20,25,000/- would
have to be paid by May 2014 at the time of delivery of the flat.
The said persons developed complete trust in me to sell the flat
to Shahbaz and give him possession. Shahbaz Singh Virk gave
him an advance of one lakh thousand (Rs.1,20,000) in my office
at the spot. 8. That after taking one lakh twenty thousand
(1,20,000 rupees), Sandhya Wadhwa told Shahbaz that she
would get a memorandum of understanding prepared for
Rs.12,15,000/-and bring it back very soon and out of
Rs.12,15,000/-, she would take the balance of Rs.10,95,000/-, 9.
That on dated 16.04.2012, Sandhya Wadhwa called Shahbaz
Singh Virk and told him that she had to go to Gobindgarh for
some new project and also called Shahbaz Singh Virk to Mandi
Gobindgarh. Shahbaz asked Sandhya Wadhwa to come to my
HAMANT
2026.02.24 19:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
office where she came to my office along with Neeraj Thathai,
CRM-M-69911-2025
Dolly Thathai, Amit Kakkar, Gaurav Chhabra, Asha Rani,
Pankaj Puri and told him that now they have a big meeting
regarding their projects in Delhi all the Directors are going
there together. After reaching my office, Pankaj Puri and
Gaurav Chhabra demanded Rs. 10,95,000/- and on their
demand, Shahbaz gave Rs.10,95,000 and Gaurav Chhabra
filled the details on the receipt and gave Shahbaz a receipt of
Rs.10,95,000/-. Everyone congratulated Shahbaz Singh Virk on
the new flat and Pankaj Puri and Sandhya Wadhwa said that
now in 2 years, you will get the ownership of your flat. Saying
this, everyone left my office. 10. That Amit Kakkar, Asha Rani
and Sandhya Wadhwa went to Kharar on 10.05.2012 and gave
the agreement dated 09.05.2012 to Shahbaz Singh Virk, which
he had already brought with the medicine prepared and they
told Shahbaz Singh Virk that now deposit an installment of
Rs.8,10,000/- by August 2013 and the remaining amount will be
paid on interest after 24 months. 11. That Gaurav Chhabra
demanded Rs.8,10,000/- from Shahbaz Singh Virk on phone on
30.07.2013 and Shahbaz told that he is going to Faridkot for 2
days. On which, Gaurav said that he or one of his associates
would take the draft from Faridkot itself and on 31.07.2013,
Shahbaz informed about the draft of Rs.8,10,000/- issued by
Axis Bank of Faridkot. On 01.08.2013, Sandhya Wadhawa,
Asha Rani and Pankaj reached Faridkot in the morning to take
the draft and left with Shahbaz and the draft. 12. That even
after so many years since 2012, no work of constructing a flat
on their land has been started and the said persons in
connivance with each other and have grabbed Rs. 20,25,000/which was the intention of all of them to grab money and all of
them had an idea/knowledge from the first day that they would
not build any flat and would grab the money. 12. That I and
Shahbaz talked and searched a lot about their said projects at
Abohar, Kharar site and Mandi Gobindgarh, but none of the
above mentioned were found anywhere and according to the
HAMANT
2026.02.24 19:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
information received, many cases have already been registered
CRM-M-69911-2025
against Neeraj Thathai and others in Punjab and all of them
have formed many companies with different names with the
intention of cheating people on a large scale and some of the
above mentioned people have become Directors in some and
some in others. All of them have together cheated many people
on a very large scale and have defrauded many people. I
request that strictest legal action should be taken with
immediate effect for breach of trust and fraud and for betraying
trust. Your Faithfully: Sd/- Rajiv Singla. Rajiv Singla son of
Shri Pritam Singla Power of Attorney of Shahbaz Singh Virk,
House No. 322 Sector 4-C, Shastri Nagar, Mandi Gobindgarh
(Punjab).
Mobile
No.:
98140-76643.
That
Senior
Superintendent of Police, District Fatehgarh Sahib marked the
application to DSP Amloh. Deputy Superintendent of Police,
Circle Amloh, after investigating the application, wrote in his
investigation report No. 1536/5 DSP/ Amloh dated 02.02.2019
that on the basis of my investigation and intelligence so far has
been thoroughly checked, the testimony and records have been
found that Shahbaz Singh Virk son of Sukhjit Singh is currently
living in a foreign country, who has given Power of Attorney to
the aforementioned Rajiv Singla to handle the case of Nature
Heights Infra Limited. That in March 2012, Neeraj Thathai,
Sandhya Wadhwa, Dolly Thathai came to Kharar, District
Mohali and told Shahbaz Singh Virk about the project of his
company Nature Heights Infra Ltd, and took Shahbaz Singh
Virk into their confidence. In the first week of April 2012,
Sandhya Wadhwa, Neeraj Thathai, Pankaj Puri and Asha Rani
again came to Kharar and they showed Shahbaz Singh Virk
their site at village Jhungiyan, Kharar and Neeraj Thathai etc.
assured Shahbaz Singh that this project would be completed
within 24 months. Neeraj Thathai etc. kept contacting Shahbaz
Singh Virk continuously to get the flat. Shahbaz Singh Virk told
Sandhya Wadhwa to tell this whole plan to my uncle Rajiv
Singla once and he was asked to come to Rajeev Singla's office
HAMANT
2026.02.24 19:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
in Mandi Gobindgarh. On 11.04.2012, Sandhya Wadhwa,
CRM-M-69911-2025
Neeraj Thathai and Dolly Thathai came to Rajiv Singla's office
and told that Sandhya Wadhwa, Amit Kakkar, Neeraj Thathai,
Dolly Thathai, Gaurav Chhabra, Asha Rani and Pankaj Puri
all work together on different projects and all of them have
formed many other companies together in which they are the
Directors in each company. Neeraj Thathai and others
explained the entire plan to Rajiv Singia and Shahbaz Singh
Virk and showed the map and told about the construction of a
1530 square feet flat on the ground floor in Tower No. 23 in the
side of village Jhungian Kharar.
That Neeraj Thathai told the price of the said flat as Rs.40 lakh
50 thousand and told that out of this entire amount, the first
half amount of Rs.20 lakh 25 thousand (Rs.12,15,000/- till the
agreement is made and Rs.8,10,000/- till August 2013) and the
remaining half of the amount of Rs.20,25,000/- would have to
be paid by May 2014 at the time of delivery of the flat. The said
persons developed complete trust in me to sell the flat to
Shahbaz and give him possession. Shahbaz Singh Virk gave him
an advance of one lakh thousand (Rs.1,20,000) in my office at
the spot. That after taking one lakh twenty thousand (1,20,000
rupees), Sandhya Wadhwa told Shahbaz that she would get a
memorandum of understanding prepared for Rs. 12,15,000/and bring it back very soon and out of Rs.12,15,000/-, she
would take the balance of Rs. 10,95,000/-. That on dated
16.04.2012, Sandhya Wadhwa called Shahbaz Singh Virk and
told him that she had to go to Gobindgarh for some new project
and also called Shahbaz Singh Virk to Mandi Gobindgarh.
Shahbaz asked Sandhya Wadhwa to come to my office where
she came to my office along with Neeraj Thathai, Dolly
Thathai, Amit Kakkar, Gaurav Chhabra, Asha Rani, Pankaj
Puri and told him that now they have a big meeting regarding
their projects in Delhi all the Directors are going there
together. After reaching my office, Pankaj Puri and Gaurav
Chhabra demanded Rs. 10,95,000/- and on their demand,
HAMANT
2026.02.24 19:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Shahbaz gave Rs.10,95,000 and Gaurav Chhabra filled the
CRM-M-69911-2025
details on the receipt and gave Shahbaz a receipt of
Rs.10,95,000/-. Everyone congratulated Shahbaz Singh Virk on
the new flat and Pankaj Puri and Sandhya Wadhwa said that
now in 2 years, you will get the ownership of your flat. Saying
this, everyone left my office. That Amit Kakkar, Asha Rani and
Sandhya Wadhwa went to Kharar on 10.05.2012 and gave the
agreement dated 09.05.2012 to Shahbaz Singh Virk, which he
had already brought with the medicine prepared and they told
Shahbaz Singh Virk that now deposit an installment of
Rs.8.10,000/- by August 2013 and the remaining amount will be
paid on interest after 24 months. That Gaurav Chhabra
demanded Rs.8,10,000/-from Shahbaz Singh Virk on phone on
30.07.2013 and Shahbaz told that he is going to Faridkot for 2
days. On which, Gaurav said that he or one of his associates
would take the draft from Faridkot itself and on 31.07.2013,
Shahbaz informed about the draft of Rs.8,10,000/- issued by
Axis Bank of Faridkot. On 01.08.2013, Sandhya Wadhawa,
Asha Rani and Pankaj reached Faridkot in the morning to take
the draft and left with Shahbaz and the draft. That even after so
many years since 2012, no work of constructing a flat on their
land has been started and the said persons in connivance with
each other and neither has Neeraj Babai etc, returned the
amount of Rs. 20 lakh 25 thousand of Shahbaz Singh Virk. That
Neeraj Thathai, Dolly Thathai have not been involved in the
investigation nor are they cooperating in the investigation of
the application. In this regard, a case has been registered and
an investigation is being conducted. Apart from this, if any fact
came against Amit Kakkar, Gaurav Chhabra, Pankaj Puri,
Anupama Duhia and Rajesh Duhia during the investigation into
light, then action should be taken. Therefore, if it is acceptable,
it is recommended that the Station House Officer of Police
Station Gobindgarh should register a case against Neeraj
Thathai, Sandhya Wadhwa, Dolly Thathai, Asha Rani under
sections 406, 420, 120-B of the Indian Penal Code and issue
HAMANT
2026.02.24 19:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
directions to take further action.
CRM-M-69911-2025
On the basis of the said complaint a formal case vide FIR No.
42 dated 23.02.2019 u/s 420, 406, 120-B IPC was registered against
petitioner and others.
During the course of investigations, statements of witnesses
were recorded, relevant documents were collected. On culmination thereof,
challan was filed in the Court.
3.
Petitioner/accused, who was arrested on 30.10.2023, moved an
application for grant of bail before the learned Additional Sessions Judge,
Fatehgarh Sahib. The same was dismissed vide order dated 28.05.2024.
Aggrieved of which, the present petition has been filed.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that petitioner was
never at the helm of the affairs of the company, of which, his real brother-inlaw was the Managing Director. It was the Managing Director of the
company, who used to take all administrative and financial decisions with
regard to the affairs of the company. Petitioner had never received any
financial benefits. Only general bald allegations have been levelled against
him. Learned counsel further submits that despite specific allegations
levelled by the complainants, none of them ever initiated civil proceedings.
Moreover, so far as present petitioner is concerned, he was arrested in
30.10.2023 and has been in custody ever since then. Despite the fact that the
challan was filed on 13.12.2023, charges were framed on 21.05.2025 and out
of 18 cited prosecution witnesses none has been examined till date, thus, the
possibility of completion of trial in the near future is quite remote.
Learned counsel has also drawn the attention of this Court to
several orders passed by different Benches of this Court vide which, on
similar allegations, petitioner was extended the concession of bail including
CRM-M-19147-2018, decided on 06.08.2018 (Annexure P-2) pertaining to
FIR No. 151 dated 22.10.20216, under Sections 420, 120-B of IPC,
HAMANT
2026.02.24 19:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-69911-2025
registered at Police Station City Malout, District Sri Muktsar Sahib, CRM3078-2023 decided on 19.04.2023 (Annexure P-3) pertaining to FIR No. 46
dated 28.03.2019, under Sections 420 and 120-B IPC, registered at Police
Station Division No.2, District Ludhiana, CRM-M-64485-2023 decided on
05.02.2024 (Annexure P-5) pertaining to FIR No. 217 dated 28.12.20218,
under Sections 420, 120-B of IPC, registered at Police Station City-I,
Abohar, CRM-M-30056-2023 decided on 27.10.2025, pertaining to FIR No.
95 dated 20.5.2017, under Sections 420, 120-B of IPC, registered at Police
Station City Faridkot, District Faridkot (Annexure P-6), CRM-M-376352025 decided on 30.10.2025 (Annexure P-7) pertaining to FIR No.218 dated
28.12.2018, under Sections 420, 120-B IPC, registered at Police Station
City-1, Abohar.
It has, thus, been prayed in view of submissions advanced
hereinabove, petitioner be released on bail, as his further incarceration
would not serve any useful purpose. Further, as per learned counsel,
petitioner undertakes to abide by stringent conditions, so imposed by this
Court while allowing this petition.
5.
Status report by way of affidavit of Gurdeep Singh, PPS,
Deputy Superintendent of Police, Sub Division, Amloh, District Fatehgarh
Sahib has been filed. In para 16 thereof, the role of the petitioner has been
highlighted. Learned State counsel submits that in view of questionable past
antecedents of petitioner, who is involved in as many as 13 cases of like
nature, if extended the concession of bail, there is every likelihood of him
fleeing from the process of justice by not appearing in the Court, over-awing
complainants and other related witnesses and indulging in the similar
offence yet again. Prayer for dismissal of the petition has been made.
6.
Both the counsel have been heard and documents on record
have been perused.
7.
HAMANT
2026.02.24 19:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Factual aspects of the case leading to the registration of the FIR
CRM-M-69911-2025
have been noticed in para 2 of the order. The fact that the petitioner has been
in custody since the year 2023, has not been disputed by learned State
counsel. Further, the fact that in some other cases, referred to above in the
status report, petitioner has been acquitted, some of FIRs have been
cancelled. Insofar as present case is concerned, out of 18 prosecution
witnesses none has been examined till date, thus, likelihood of completion of
trial in near future is remote. Nothing has been brought on record from
where an inference can be drawn that petitioner has misused the concession
of bail granted to him by Coordinate Benches of this Court. When viewed as
a whole, this Court is of the opinion that further incarceration of petitioner
would not only be violative of his rights under Article 21 of the Constitution
of India, including right to speedy trial but would also be against the
principle of "Bail is a general rule and incarceration is an exception" as
held by Hon'ble Supreme Court in Dataram vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and
another, 2018(2) R.C.R. (Criminal) 131. It deserves to be mentioned here
that in some of the cases referred to in the Status Report, petitioner stands
acquitted, whereas some proceedings have been cancelled.
8.
In case of Rup Bahadur Magar @ Sanki @ Rabin Vs. State of
West Bengal, Criminal Appeal No.4144 of 2024 decided on 04.10.2024, in
a case under Sections 394, 395, 397, 307 read with 120-B of IPC, Hon'ble
Supreme Court granted bail to the accused considering long incarceration
undergone by him of 2 years and 9 months.
In case of Javed Gulam Nabi Shaikh Vs. State of Maharashtra
and Anr., (2024) 9 SCC 813, the Supreme Court while granting bail to
accused for 04 years in paragraph Nos. 16 and 17 held as under:"16. Criminals are not born but made. The human potential in
everyone is good and so, never write off any criminal as beyond
redemption. This humanist fundamental is often missed when
dealing with delinquents, juvenile and adult. Indeed, every saint
HAMANT
2026.02.24 19:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
has a past and every sinner a future. When a crime is
CRM-M-69911-2025
committed, a variety of factors is responsible for making the
offender commit the crime. Those factors may be social and
economic, may be, the result of value erosion or parental
neglect, may be, because of the stress of circumstances, or the
manifestation of temptations in a milieu of affluence contrasted
with indigence or other privations.
17 If the State or any prosecuting agency including the court
concerned has no wherewithal to provide or protect the
fundamental right of an accused to have a speedy trial as
enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution then the State or
any other prosecuting agency should not oppose the plea for
bail on the ground that the crime committed is serious. Article
21 of the Constitution applies irrespective of the nature of the
crime."
Recently, a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in Neelkamal
Singh Alias Billa Vs. State of Punjab passed in CRM-M-39765-2024 has
held that although an accused may have past criminal antecedents but
nonetheless if the incarceration period is long, he is entitled for the
concession of bail.
"Therefore, to elucidate further, this Court is conscious of the
basic and fundamental principle of law that right to speedy trial
is a part of reasonable, fair and just procedure enshrined under
Article 21 of the Constitution of India. This constitutional right
cannot be denied to the accused as is the mandate of the Apex
court in "Hussainara Khatoon and ors (IV) v. Home
Secretary, State of Bihar, Patna", (1980) 1 SCC 98. Besides
this, reference can be drawn upon that pre-conviction period of
the under-trials should be as short as possible keeping in view
the nature of accusation and the severity of punishment in case
of conviction and the nature of supporting evidence, reasonable
apprehension of tampering with the witness or apprehension of
threat to the complainant. As far as the pendency of other cases
and involvement of the petitioner in other cases is concerned.
HAMANT
2026.02.24 19:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-69911-2025
reliance can be placed upon the order of this Court rendered in
CRM-M-25914-2022 titled as "Baljinder Singh alias Rock vs.
State of Punjab" decided on 02.03.2023, wherein, while
referring Article 21 of the Constitution of India, this Court has
held that no doubt, at the time of granting bail, the criminal
antecedents of the petitioner are to be looked into but at the
same time it is equally true that the appreciation of evidence
during the course of trial has to be looked into with reference to
the evidence in that case alone and not with respect to the
evidence in the other pending cases. In such eventuality, strict
adherence to the rule of denial of bail on account of pendency
of other cases/convictions in all probability would land the
petitioner in a situation of denial of concession of bail."
Resultantly, petitioner is granted the concession of bail subject
to his furnishing bail bonds/surety bonds along with two local sureties to the
satisfaction of learned trial Court/Duty Magistrate concerned. The petitioner
shall abide by the following conditions:(i) The petitioner shall not leave the country without prior
permission of the trial Court and shall deposit the passport in
the trial Court.
(ii) The petitioner will not tamper with the evidence during the
trial.
(iii) The petitioner will not pressurize/ intimidate the
prosecution witnesses.
(iv) The petitioner will appear before the trial Court on each
and every date fixed, unless is exempted by a specific order of
Court.
(v) The petitioner shall not commit an offence similar to the
offence of which, he is an accused, or for commission of which
he is suspected of.
(vi) The petitioner shall not directly or indirectly coerce,
induce, threaten or promise to any person acquainted with the
facts of the case so as to dissuade him/her from disclosing such
HAMANT
2026.02.24 19:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-69911-2025
facts to the Court or to any police officer or tamper with the
evidence in any manner.
(vii) The petitioner shall not in any manner misuse his liberty.
(viii) The petitioner shall furnish his address and mobile
number to the Trial Court forthwith and shall not change the
same till the conclusion of the trial and in case for any reason,
the petitioner seeks to change any of the aforesaid, the same
shall be done only with prior intimation to the learned Trial
Court, stating the reason for the same.
(ix) The trial Court/Duty Magistrate may impose any other
condition, as deemed appropriate while releasing the petitioner.
9.
Accordingly, the present petition is allowed and it is made clear
that in case there is any breach of the aforesaid conditions, the State shall be
at liberty to seek cancellation of bail as granted to the petitioner by this
order.
In view of the above, it is clarified that the observations made
herein are limited for the purpose of present proceedings and would not be
construed as an opinion on the merits of the case and the trial would proceed
independently of the aforesaid observations.
(AARADHNA SAWHNEY)
JUDGE
17.02.2026
Hemant
Whether speaking/reasoned
Whether reportable
HAMANT
2026.02.24 19:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
:
:
Yes / No
Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review