Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N.TUKARAMJI
CRIMINAL PETITION Nos. 9072 AND 9073 OF 2026
DATE: 09.07.2026
Crl. P. No. 9072 of 2026:
Between :
Konda Venkanna and another.
… Petitioners/Accused
AND
The State of Telangana, Represented by its Public Prosecutor,
High Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad, through
SHO, Nalgonda II Town P.S., Nalgonda District.
… Respondent.
Crl. P. No. 9073 of 2026:
Between :
Gattu Sravan and three others.
… Petitioners/Accused
AND
The State of Telangana, Represented by its Public Prosecutor,
High Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad, and
another.
… Respondents.
NTR,J
Crl.P. Nos. 9072 and 9073 of 2026
COMMON ORDER
These Criminal Petitions are filed under Section 482 of the Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (for short, “BNSS”), seeking the relief of
anticipatory bail.
2.
The petitioners in Crl.P. No.9072 of 2026 are arrayed as accused
Nos.1 and 2 in Crime No.76 of 2026 registered at Nalgonda II Town Police
Station, whereas the petitioners in Crl.P. No.9073 of 2026 are arrayed as
accused Nos.1 to 4 in Crime No.37 of 2026 registered at Nalgonda Rural
Police Station, Nalgonda District. Both the crimes are registered for the
offences punishable under Sections 316(2), 316(5) and 318(3) of the
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (for short, “BNS”), and Section 7 of the
Essential Commodities Act, 1955.
3.
Although the factual circumstances involved in these petitions are
distinct, having regard to the analogous nature of the issues raised, the
submissions advanced, and the relief sought, both the petitions were heard
together and are being disposed of by this common order.
4.
Heard Mr. R. N. Hemendranath Reddy, learned Senior Counsel,
argued on behalf of Mr. Venkataramanaiah K, learned counsel for the
petitioners in Crl.P. No. 9072 of 2026; Mr. Vinod Kumar Deshpande, learned
Senior Counsel, argued on behalf of Mr. Venkataramanaiah K, learned
NTR,J
Crl.P. Nos. 9072 and 9073 of 2026
counsel for the petitioners in Crl.P. No. 9073 of 2026 and Mr. Palle
Nageswar Rao, learned Public Prosecutor, appearing for the respondentState.
5.
In Crl.P. No. 9073 of 2026 the petition of petitioner No.2/accused
No.2 is dismissed as not pressed, as he was arrested on 18.06.2026.
6.1.
The brief facts of the prosecution case in Crl.P. No.9072 of 2026 are
that, petitioner Nos.1 and 2/accused Nos.1 and 2 are the Managing Partner
and Partner, respectively, of Kanaka Mahalaxmi Para Boiled Rice Private
Limited, Nalgonda. The said mill was entrusted with 12,856.200 Metric
Tonnes of Government paddy under the Custom Milling Agreement for the
Rabi Season 2022-23. Similarly, in Crl.P. No.9073 of 2026, petitioner
No.1/accused No.1 is the Managing Partner and petitioner Nos.3 and 4
/accused Nos.3 and 4 are the partners of Gouthami Para Boiled Rice Mill
Private Limited, Nalgonda, which was entrusted with 21,724.480 Metric
Tonnes of paddy under the Custom Milling Agreement for the Rabi Season
2022-23.
6.2.
The paddy was entrusted for the purpose of conversion into Custom
Milled Rice (CMR) and delivery of the same to the Telangana State Civil
Supplies Corporation Limited (TGSCSCL) within the stipulated period. It is
alleged that the petitioners delivered only a part of the Custom Milled Rice,
resulting in shortages equivalent to 8,026.059 Metric Tonnes (MT) and
NTR,J
Crl.P. Nos. 9072 and 9073 of 2026
15,980.392 MT of paddy, respectively, in the said crimes, causing alleged
losses running into crores of rupees, which led to registration of the crimes
for the offences of criminal breach of trust and cheating.
7.1.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners respectfully
submits that the entire prosecution case, even if accepted at its face value,
arises out of purely contractual transactions flowing from the Custom Milling
Agreements entered into between the respective rice milling firms and the
Telangana State Civil Supplies Corporation Limited (TGSCSCL) for milling of
Government paddy and delivery of Custom Milled Rice (CMR). The
allegations essentially pertain to alleged non-delivery of certain quantities of
CMR and shortage of paddy stocks, which are matters relating to contractual
obligations, reconciliation of accounts, stock verification, quality assessment
and determination of civil liability.
7.2.
It is submitted that the allegations do not satisfy the essential
ingredients of the offences alleged. To constitute criminal breach of trust, the
prosecution must establish not merely entrustment of property but also
dishonest misappropriation, conversion, use or disposal thereof in violation
of law or contract. Mere failure to fulfill a contractual obligation, in the
absence of dishonest intention from inception or criminal intent, cannot be
converted into a criminal offence.
NTR,J
Crl.P. Nos. 9072 and 9073 of 2026
7.3.
It is further submitted that the petitioners have substantially performed
their obligations under the Custom Milling Agreements by milling and
delivering considerable quantities of CMR, which were duly received and
accepted by TGSCSCL without objection. The alleged balance quantity is a
matter of accounting, assessment of loss and contractual adjustment and
does not, by itself, establish dishonest misappropriation or fraudulent
conduct. The remaining paddy could not be processed due to deterioration
caused by natural factors and circumstances beyond the control of the
petitioners. This position was recognised by the Government itself while
taking a policy decision for disposal of damaged/unmilled Rabi 2022-23
paddy on an “as is where is” basis through e-auction/e-Global Tender
process. Such recognition and creation of a separate mechanism for
disposal of damaged paddy clearly demonstrates that the alleged shortage
cannot automatically be presumed to be criminal misappropriation.
7.4.
It is further submitted that the quantity of paddy allotted to various
millers was far beyond the prescribed operational and storage capacities
contemplated under applicable Government Orders and guidelines. Despite
being aware of the milling capacity and available storage infrastructure, the
Corporation entrusted huge quantities without ensuring corresponding
logistical arrangements. Further, the designated authorities under the
scheme were also responsible for supervision and monitoring of stocks.
NTR,J
Crl.P. Nos. 9072 and 9073 of 2026
Therefore, the entire responsibility for alleged shortage cannot be fastened
exclusively upon the petitioners without proper adjudication of facts.
7.5.
It is submitted that the prosecution has erroneously sought to describe
the petitioners/millers as “agents” of the Corporation to create an alleged
fiduciary or juridical relationship for attracting criminal breach of trust. Such
characterisation is contrary to the express terms of the Custom Milling
Agreements. The agreements were entered into with the respective
partnership firms as Custom Millers/Millers, creating contractual obligations
between independent contracting parties governed by agreed terms and
conditions. Mere use of the expression “entrustment” or subsequent
description of the millers as “agents” cannot alter the legal character of the
transaction unless the agreement itself creates such an agency relationship.
7.6.
It is further respectfully submitted that the prosecution suffers from a
fundamental defect as the partnership firms, which are the actual contracting
entities under the Custom Milling Agreements, have not been arrayed as
accused. Instead, individual partners are sought to be prosecuted merely on
account of their association with the firms. Criminal liability of partners
cannot be presumed from their status alone and requires specific allegations
showing active participation, knowledge, dishonest intention or individual
overt acts. Some petitioners are not even named in the FIR, while others are
merely sleeping partners having no role in day-to-day management or
NTR,J
Crl.P. Nos. 9072 and 9073 of 2026
operational decisions of the respective rice mills and continue as partners
only due to family business arrangements. In the absence of specific
allegations of personal involvement and in the absence of statutory vicarious
liability under the alleged IPC offences, prosecution cannot be sustained
merely on the basis of partnership status.
7.7.
It is also submitted that TGSCSCL has withheld custom milling
charges payable to the petitioners and effected unilateral adjustments/set-off
without final determination of mutual claims and liabilities. Such disputed
financial adjustments further establish the civil and contractual nature of the
controversy rather than any criminal culpability. Moreover, despite the
present allegations, the Custom Milling Agreements with the petitioners’
firms have not been terminated, and the petitioners continue to undertake
milling operations for Government paddy in subsequent seasons, which itself
negatives the allegation of fraudulent intention or breach of trust.
7.8.
It is finally submitted that the prosecution case is entirely founded
upon official records, stock registers, agreements, correspondence and
documentary material, all of which are already in the possession of the
investigating agency. There is no allegation that the petitioners have
attempted
to
destroy
evidence
or
influence
witnesses.
Custodial
interrogation is therefore unnecessary. The petitioners are permanent
residents carrying on established business activities, have no likelihood of
NTR,J
Crl.P. Nos. 9072 and 9073 of 2026
absconding or interfering with investigation, and undertake to fully cooperate
with the investigating agency and comply with any conditions imposed.
Hence, the petitioners pray that they may be granted anticipatory bail.
8.1.
The learned Public Prosecutor opposed the petitions, contending that
the allegations levelled against the petitioners are grave in nature and
disclose the commission of cognizable offences involving misappropriation of
Government paddy entrusted under custom milling agreements. It is
submitted that the TSCSCL had entrusted substantial quantities of
Government paddy to the respective rice mills for the Rabi season 2022-23,
and that the petitioners, being the partners responsible for managing the
affairs of the said rice mills, were custodians of the entrusted stock and were
under a statutory and contractual obligation to mill the paddy and deliver the
prescribed quantity of custom milled rice (CMR) to the Corporation.
8.2.
It is further submitted that, after giving due credit to the quantities of
CMR delivered and making other permissible adjustments, substantial
quantities of paddy ought to have been available with the respective rice
mills. However, during the physical verification conducted by the Joint
Inspection Teams, huge shortages of Government paddy were detected.
Further, the petitioners failed to furnish any satisfactory explanation for the
missing stock and had dishonestly disposed of or misappropriated the
NTR,J
Crl.P. Nos. 9072 and 9073 of 2026
Government paddy entrusted to them, thereby causing wrongful loss to the
TGSCSCL.
8.3.
The learned Public Prosecutor further submits that the shortages
detected during the inspection have resulted in substantial financial loss,
running into several crores of rupees, to the Government/Corporation. It is
contended that, despite issuance of notices calling upon the petitioners to
account for the deficient stock and discharge their corresponding liability,
they failed to comply with the same, which ultimately led to the registration of
the present crimes.
8.4.
According to the prosecution, the allegations do not constitute a mere
contractual dispute, but disclose the commission of offences involving
criminal breach of trust, cheating, and dishonest misappropriation of public
stock entrusted to the petitioners. Having regard to the magnitude of the
alleged misappropriation, the extent of loss caused to the public exchequer,
the gravity of the accusations, and the necessity of ensuring a fair and
effective investigation, the custodial interrogation of the petitioners is
required.
8.5.
It is further contended that, in the event anticipatory bail is granted,
there is a likelihood that the petitioners may not cooperate with the
investigation,
which
may
adversely
affect
the
recovery
of
the
NTR,J
Crl.P. Nos. 9072 and 9073 of 2026
misappropriated dues and impede the effective progress of the investigation.
Therefore, it is submitted that the petitioners are not entitled to the
discretionary relief and accordingly seeks dismissal of the petitions.
9.
I have carefully considered the rival submissions and perused the
material available on record.
10.
It is a settled principle of law that the existence of a civil or contractual
relationship between parties does not, by itself, bar criminal prosecution
where the allegations disclose the essential ingredients of a penal offence,
such as entrustment, dishonest intention, deception or misappropriation. At
the same time, a mere breach of contract cannot be transformed into a
criminal offence unless the requisite mens rea and statutory ingredients of
the alleged offences are established.
11.
In Indian Oil Corporation v. NEPC India Limited, (2006) 6 SCC 736,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that a transaction may simultaneously give
rise to civil liability and criminal prosecution and that availability of a civil
remedy is not a ground to quash criminal proceedings where criminality is
prima facie disclosed. However, the Court cautioned that criminal process
should not be permitted to be used as a weapon of pressure in disputes
which are essentially civil in nature. Similarly, in S.W. Palanitkar v. State of
Bihar, (2002) 1 SCC 241, it was held that mere failure to honour contractual
obligations would not constitute cheating or criminal breach of trust unless
NTR,J
Crl.P. Nos. 9072 and 9073 of 2026
dishonest or fraudulent intention exists and the necessary ingredients of the
offence are satisfied.
12.
In the instant matters, the allegations revolve around entrustment of
Government paddy, performance of obligations under custom milling
arrangements and the alleged failure to account for entrusted stock. Whether
the shortage was attributable to deterioration of stock, storage conditions,
delay in disposal/lifting of damaged paddy and other operational factors, or
whether it was the result of dishonest diversion and misappropriation of
Government property, are matters requiring investigation, examination of
records and appreciation of evidence. Such disputed factual issues cannot
be finally determined while considering an application seeking anticipatory
bail.
13.
The parameters governing exercise of jurisdiction under Section 482
BNSS/438 Cr.P.C. require the Court to consider the nature and gravity of
accusation, role attributed to the accused, possibility of fleeing from justice,
likelihood of tampering with evidence, necessity of custodial interrogation
and the requirement of a fair investigation, while simultaneously protecting
the fundamental right to personal liberty.
14.1. In Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia v. State of Punjab, (1980) 2 SCC 565, the
Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that anticipatory bail
NTR,J
Crl.P. Nos. 9072 and 9073 of 2026
is an important safeguard of personal liberty and that discretion under
Section 438 Cr.P.C. must be exercised on the facts of each case without
applying rigid or mechanical formulas. The Court emphasized the need to
maintain a balance between individual liberty and legitimate investigative
requirements.
14.2. In Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2020) 5 SCC 1, the
Constitution Bench further clarified that anticipatory bail cannot be refused
merely on the seriousness of allegations and that the Court must examine
whether custodial detention is actually warranted.
14.3. Likewise, in Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar, (2014) 8 SCC 273, it was
held that arrest cannot be made mechanically and must be justified by
legitimate considerations such as effective investigation, prevention of
evidence tampering or securing the presence of the accused.
15.
In the present cases, the transactions are predominantly founded
upon written agreements, stock registers, inspection reports, official
correspondence, notices, delivery records and other documentary material,
substantial portions of which are already within the custody and control of
the authorities. At this stage, the prosecution has not demonstrated that
custodial interrogation of the petitioners is indispensable either for recovery
of material evidence or for effective continuation of investigation. The
NTR,J
Crl.P. Nos. 9072 and 9073 of 2026
allegations primarily require scrutiny of documentary records, reconciliation
of quantities entrusted, CMR delivered, remaining stock position and the
circumstances resulting in the alleged shortage.
16.
Further, insofar as certain petitioners are sought to be proceeded
against on account of their association with the respective rice mills, the
question whether they were actively responsible for conduct of business or
whether liability is sought to be fastened merely by virtue of their status as
partners/proprietary associates is a matter requiring examination on the
basis of evidence collected during investigation. Criminal liability cannot be
presumed solely from association with a business entity unless individual
role, participation and requisite criminal intent are established.
17.
It is equally settled that arrest or threat of arrest cannot be employed
as a means of coercive recovery or enforcement of disputed contractual
liabilities. Criminal law is intended to investigate and punish offences
established in accordance with law and cannot be converted into a substitute
mechanism for recovery of amounts arising from contractual disputes. Pretrial deprivation of liberty must therefore be supported by genuine
investigative necessity and not merely by the existence of monetary claims.
18.
At the same time, this Court is conscious of the seriousness of the
allegations
involving
alleged
shortage
of
Government
paddy
and
NTR,J
Crl.P. Nos. 9072 and 9073 of 2026
consequential loss to the public exchequer. The petitioners are therefore
bound to cooperate with the investigating agency, make themselves
available whenever required, furnish relevant information and documents,
and shall not interfere with or obstruct the course of investigation.
19.
Having regard to the nature of accusations, the contractual origin of
the dispute, the documentary character of the evidence, the issues relating
to assessment of actual loss and respective obligations of the parties being
matters for investigation/trial, and considering that the petitioners have
established roots in society and have undertaken to cooperate with the
investigation, this Court is of the considered view that a case is made out for
favorably exercising the discretionary jurisdiction
20.
Accordingly, without expressing any opinion on the merits of the
allegations or the defences raised with regard to contractual liability, the
responsibility of individual partners, the authority of the complainant to
initiate prosecution, compliance with the mechanism prescribed under the
agreement, the role of the Corporation as custodian, the assessment of loss,
or the disposal of damaged stock through auction, all of which are left open
for investigation and determination at the appropriate stage, this Court is of
the considered view that the petitioners are entitled to be enlarged on
anticipatory bail, subject to appropriate conditions to ensure their
NTR,J
Crl.P. Nos. 9072 and 9073 of 2026
cooperation with the investigation and to safeguard the interests of the
prosecution.
21.
Accordingly, the Criminal Petitions are allowed.
The Petitioners in
both Criminal Petitions, except petitioner No.2/Accused No. 2 in Crl. P.
No.9073 of 2026, shall be enlarged on anticipatory bail, subject to the
following conditions:
(A) Petitioners shall surrender before the Station House Officers of
respective Police Stations, on or before 23.07.2026. Upon such
surrender or in the event of arrest, the Station House Officers shall
release petitioners on bail on execution of personal bonds for a sum of
Rs.50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand only) each with two sureties for a
like sum each, to the satisfaction of the said Officers.
(B) Petitioners shall not leave India without obtaining prior permission
from the jurisdictional Court concerned.
(C) Petitioners shall remain available for interrogation as and when
required by the Investigating Officer during the course of investigation
and shall extend full cooperation with the Investigating Officer(s).
(D) Petitioners shall strictly comply with all the conditions contemplated
under Section 482(2) of the BNSS.
(E) Petitioners shall furnish their complete residential addresses, mobile
numbers, and other contact particulars to the Investigating Officer(s)
and shall promptly intimate any change(s) therein.
NTR,J
Crl.P. Nos. 9072 and 9073 of 2026
(F) Petitioners shall not, directly or indirectly, induce, threaten,
influence, or make any promise to any person acquainted with the facts
of the case(s), nor shall they tamper with, alter, destroy, or otherwise
interfere with the prosecution evidence in any manner whatsoever.
(G) Any wilful breach or violation of any of the aforesaid conditions shall
render the petitioners liable to appropriate proceedings before the Court
concerned, including cancellation of bail, in accordance with the
provisions of the BNSS and other applicable laws.
22.
It is made clear that any observations made herein are confined
solely to the adjudication of the present applications for anticipatory bail
and shall not be construed as an expression on the merits of the case.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
_______________
N.TUKARAMJI, J
Date: 09.07.2026
svl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review