The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. The first issue which is in controversy in both the Appeals is the assessment of income of the deceased. The Tribunal, on appreciation of evidence, in particular, Exs.A.13 and A.25, coupled with the evidence of PWs.6 and 12, has assessed annual income of deceased as Rs.10,07,524/- and after deducting the tax payable, arrived at the income as Rs.9,58,826/-. In assessing the said income, the Tribunal has also taken note of the fact that the deceased was an assessee much before the occurrence of accident and that even the income tax returns for the preceding assessment years 2006-‘07, 2007-‘08 and 2008-‘09 were placed by way of evidence under Exs. X.2, X.3 and X.4. The Tribunal has also considered the factum of the assesseethe deceased being engaged in cultivation of lands, and therefore, rightly considered the agricultural income, which was disclosed in the income tax return for the assessment year 2009-‘10. However, since the evidence on record has revealed that the deceased was merely cultivating the lands on lease and whereas the lands originally belonged to third parties, despite the objection raised that the income ought not have been taken into consideration, the agricultural income has been factored into for the purpose of assessing the income of the HCJ & CGR, J. M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1806 of 2015 & 2588 of 2017 deceased. The approach of the Tribunal, in our considered opinion, …
14. The Tribunal has considered future prospects at the rate of 30%, which is not in consonance with the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Pranay Sethi1. Likewise, the Tribunal has considered various amounts towards conventional heads as mentioned supra, which are not in consonance with the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Pranay Sethi1. Therefore, both these heads are required to be modified accordingly. The claimants, therefore, are entitled to just and fair compensation as under: Compensation Heads Amount Awarded Net annual income ₹9,58,826/- Future Prospects (Age being 43 years) 25% of ₹9,58,826/- = Deduction (1/4) Multiplier (14) Loss of Income of the deceased Loss of Estate ₹2,39,706/₹11,98,532 – ₹2,99,633 = ₹8,98,899/₹8,98,899/- x 14 = In Accordance with: National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi Para 37, 39, 41, 42 and 59.4 ₹1,25,84,586/₹1,25,84,586/₹18,150/- HCJ & CGR, J. M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1806 of 2015 & 2588 of 2017 (with 10% increase every 3 years from 2017) ₹18,150/Funeral expenses (with 10% increase every 3 years from 2017) National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi Para 37, 39, 41, 42 and 59.4 United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satinder Kaur, Para 37.12 Loss of Consortium ₹48,400 x 4 = ₹1,93,600/- Rajwati alias Rajjo v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (with 10% increase every 3 years from 2017) 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1699 Para 34 Sadhana Tomar v. As…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010589672017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
Bench Sr.No:-79
[3584]
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS
APPEAL Nos.1806 of 2015 AND 2588 of 2017
MACMA No.1806 of 2015:
Gannapureddy Vara Lakshmi and Others.
…Appellants
Vs.
Shaik Habijur Rahaman, driver of lorry & Ors.
….Respondents
****
Advocate for Appellants:
MR. B.V. KRISHNA REDDY
Advocate for respondent No.3:
MR. GUDI SRINIVASU
*****
MACMA No.2588 of 2017
The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
...Appellant
Vs.
Gannapureddi Vara Lakshmi and Others
...Respondent(s)
**********
Advocate for Appellant:
MR.GUDI SRINIVASU
Advocate for respondents:
Mr.B V KRISHNA REDDY
*****
CORAM : THE CHIEF JUSTICE LISA GILL
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 9th July 2026
COMMON JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
Both these appeals - one preferred by claimants and the other
by insurer - arise out of the very same award, dated 13.03.2015, in
M.V.O.P. No.85 OF 2010, passed by the Chairman, Motor Accident
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1806 of 2015
& 2588 of 2017
Claims Tribunal-cum-Principal District Judge, Eluru, (for short, “the
Tribunal”), hence, the same are heard together and disposed of by
this common judgment.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties hereinafter are
referred to as they were arrayed in the M.V.O.P. before the Tribunal.
3.
M.A.C.M.A. No.1806 of 2015 is preferred by claimants and
whereas M.A.C.M.A.No.2588 of 2017 is preferred by Insurer. The
insurance company challenges the quantum of compensation
determined by the Tribunal, whereas the claimants in their Appeal
seek further enhancement of compensation.
4.
The facts relevant for disposal of these appeals are set out as
under:
(a) Deceased, Gannapureddi Srinivasa Rao, along with his
friend M.Satish, was travelling in a new F/R Swift car, from
Veeravasaram to Visakhapatnam, on NH-5, driven by the driver G.
Narayana Rao. When they reached near Marribanda Village,
Visakhapatnam, around midnight, driver of lorry bearing registration
No.WB 41 B 4628, drove the lorry in a rash and negligent manner at
high speed without blowing the horn and dashed against the said new
Swift car, from its behind. As a result, the new Swift car was totally
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1806 of 2015
& 2588 of 2017
damaged and the deceased sustained multiple, grievous and
bleeding injuries on head and stomach and died on the spot. It is
stated that at the time of his death, the deceased was 43 years old
and was an established businessman, agriculturist, and regular
income-tax assessee with several commercial ventures. Wife along
with two minor children and mother of deceased preferred a claim
before the Tribunal claiming compensation of Rs.2,03,00,000/-.
(b) The driver and owner of the lorry, who have been arrayed
as respondent Nos.1 and 2, during trial remained ex parte, and
whereas respondent No. 3 Insurer filed counter denying and disputing
the manner in which the accident occurred. The driver of offending
vehicle was not negligent in causing the accident, besides disputing
the earnings, age and driving licence of the deceased, therefore, the
claim to be excessive and exorbitant and prayed for dismissal of the
O.P.
5.
Considering the respective pleadings, the Tribunal has framed
the following issues:
“i. Whether the Motor Vehicle accident on 27.03.2009
on N.H.5 near Marribanda Village of Visakhapatnam District,
arose on account of negligence of driver of R.1 Lorry bearing
No.WB 41 B 4628, resulting death of the deceased
Gannapureddi Srinivasa Rao?
ii. Whether the petitioners are entitled for
compensation and if so, for what amount and from which of
the respondents?
iii. To what relief?”
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1806 of 2015
& 2588 of 2017
6.
In support of the claim, PWs.1 to 15 were examined and
Exs.A.1 to A.25 and Exs.X.1 to X.5 were marked. Likewise, on behalf
of Insurer, RW.1 was examined and Ex.B1 was marked.
7.
On appreciation of both oral and documentary evidence, the
Tribunal ultimately concluded that the driver of offending vehicle was
negligent and responsible for causing accident and that the deceased
died due to injuries sustained in the accident. The Tribunal partly
allowed the O.P., awarding a total compensation of Rs.1,31,53,000/with interest @ 7.5% p.a. from the date of petition till the date of
deposit. The compensation awarded was apportioned among the
claimants – Rs.1,00,00,000/- to the wife; Rs.15,00,000/- each to the
two minors sons; and Rs.1.53,000/- to the mother of deceased. The
Tribunal held that the driver, owner and the insurer jointly and
severally liable to pay the aforesaid award amount.
8.
Aggrieved by the same, the Insurer had preferred M.A.C.M.A.
No.2588 of 2017 contending that the compensation awarded was
excessive and exorbitant.
The claimants have also preferred
M.A.C.M.A. No.1806 of 2015, dissatisfied with the quantum of
compensation so determined.
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1806 of 2015
& 2588 of 2017
9.
Heard Sri B.V. Krishna Reddy, learned counsel for the
claimants and Sri Gudi Srinivasu, learned standing counsel for the
insurer, in both the appeals.
10.
Learned counsel for the insurer mainly contended that the
Tribunal was not justified in considering the income-tax return for
assessment year 2009-’10, inasmuch as the same came to be filed
after the date of accident, therefore, the earnings of the deceased
were not properly assessed. He also contended that the agricultural
income as shown in income tax return for the year 2009-‘10,
particularly depicting that there was a loss on account of agricultural
operations, ought not to have been taken into consideration,
inasmuch as the deceased would still be left with the agricultural
property. He further contended that the Tribunal has granted future
prospects at the rate of 30%, whereas, by applying the formulae laid
down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v.
Pranay Sethi1, inasmuch as deceased was aged 43 years, the
appropriate future prospects to be applied would be 25%.
11.
Learned counsel for the claimants, while supporting the order
of the Tribunal with regard to placing reliance on income tax returns
1 (2017) 16 SCC 680
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1806 of 2015
& 2588 of 2017
for 2009-10 for the purpose of assessing the income of deceased,
would contend that the Tribunal not only has taken into consideration
the income tax returns for the year 2009-’10, but also taken note of
the fact that the deceased was assessed to income tax much prior to
and even the income tax return for the preceding assessment years
viz., 2005-‘06, 2006-’07, 2007-’08 and 2008-‘09 were also brought on
record by examining PW.12-the auditor and PW.6-the income tax
officer. Therefore, the order does not suffer from any perversity in that
regard.
That apart, learned counsel for the claimants further
contends that the agriculture income shown in the income tax returns
emanated from leased lands, but not the lands owned by the
deceased, therefore, rightly, the Tribunal has taken into account
income per se. He further contended that the Tribunal has not
awarded just and fair compensation towards the conventional heads,
as merely an amount of Rs.25,000/- was awarded towards
consortium for only one claimant, besides Rs.10,000/- towards
funeral expenses and Rs.30,000/- towards loss of estate. In that view
of the matter, it is urged that, following the ratio laid down by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in Pranay Sethi1, the claimants are entitled to
various components of conventional heads.
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1806 of 2015
& 2588 of 2017
12.
We have gone through the material on record and considered
the submissions of both the learned counsels.
13.
The first issue which is in controversy in both the Appeals is the
assessment of income of the deceased. The Tribunal, on appreciation
of evidence, in particular, Exs.A.13 and A.25, coupled with the
evidence of PWs.6 and 12, has assessed annual income of deceased
as Rs.10,07,524/- and after deducting the tax payable, arrived at the
income as Rs.9,58,826/-. In assessing the said income, the Tribunal
has also taken note of the fact that the deceased was an assessee
much before the occurrence of accident and that even the income tax
returns for the preceding assessment years 2006-‘07, 2007-‘08 and
2008-‘09 were placed by way of evidence under Exs. X.2, X.3 and
X.4. The Tribunal has also considered the factum of the assesseethe deceased being engaged in cultivation of lands, and therefore,
rightly considered the agricultural income, which was disclosed in the
income tax return for the assessment year 2009-‘10. However, since
the evidence on record has revealed that the deceased was merely
cultivating the lands on lease and whereas the lands originally
belonged to third parties, despite the objection raised that the income
ought not have been taken into consideration, the agricultural income
has been factored into for the purpose of assessing the income of the
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1806 of 2015
& 2588 of 2017
deceased. The approach of the Tribunal, in our considered opinion,
is justified and we find no infirmity. Therefore, the income of deceased
as assessed by the Tribunal is hereby confirmed.
14.
The Tribunal has considered future prospects at the rate of
30%, which is not in consonance with the ratio laid down by the
Hon'ble Apex Court in Pranay Sethi1. Likewise, the Tribunal has
considered various amounts towards conventional heads as
mentioned supra, which are not in consonance with the ratio laid
down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Pranay Sethi1. Therefore, both
these heads are required to be modified accordingly. The claimants,
therefore, are entitled to just and fair compensation as under:
Compensation
Heads
Amount Awarded
Net annual income
₹9,58,826/-
Future Prospects
(Age being 43 years)
25% of ₹9,58,826/- =
Deduction (1/4)
Multiplier (14)
Loss of Income of the
deceased
Loss of Estate
₹2,39,706/₹11,98,532 – ₹2,99,633 =
₹8,98,899/₹8,98,899/- x 14 =
In Accordance
with:
National Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Pranay
Sethi
(2017) 16 SCC 680
Para 37, 39, 41, 42
and 59.4
₹1,25,84,586/₹1,25,84,586/₹18,150/-
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1806 of 2015
& 2588 of 2017
(with 10% increase every
3 years from 2017)
₹18,150/Funeral expenses
(with 10% increase every
3 years from 2017)
National Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Pranay
Sethi
(2017) 16 SCC 680
Para 37, 39, 41, 42
and 59.4
United India
Insurance Co. Ltd.
v. Satinder Kaur,
(2021) 11 SCC 780
Para 37.12
Loss of Consortium
₹48,400 x 4 = ₹1,93,600/-
Rajwati alias Rajjo
v. United India
Insurance Co. Ltd.
(with 10% increase every
3 years from 2017)
2022 SCC OnLine
SC 1699
Para 34
Sadhana Tomar v.
Ashok Khushwaha
2025 SCC OnLine
SC 554
Para 17
Total
15.
₹1,28,14,486/-
Accordingly, both the Appeals are disposed of. The impugned
order, dated 13.03.2015, shall stand modified, by revising the
compensation amount to Rs.1,28,14,486/- as just and fair
compensation. The Insurer to deposit the amount as aforesaid with
interest at the rate of 7.5% p.a., and costs, adjusting the amount
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1806 of 2015
& 2588 of 2017
already deposited/paid if any, before the Tribunal within one month.
On such deposit being made, the claimants shall be entitled to
withdraw the same in the proportion as per the Award, failing which,
the amount shall be recovered as per law.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending in these appeals,
if any, shall stand closed.
LISA GILL, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J
cs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review