Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Date of reserved for Judgment :12.12.2025
Date of Pronouncement
:13.03.2026
Date of uploading
:14.03.2026
APHC010593752012
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3520]
FRIDAY,THE THIRTEENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 858/2012
Between:
1. GANJI DEMULLU NAIDU, S/O LATE RAMUNAIDU R/O RAVIKAMATHAM
VILLAGE AND MANDAL, VISAKHAPATNAM.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. ML SRINIVASA RAO AND 2 OTHERS, S/O RAJA RAO DRIVER OF THE
LORRY NO. AP 16 T 3988 R/O 17/319, VALANDAPALEM,
MACHILIPATNAM,
2. S NAGESWARA RAO, S/O KRISHNAYYA R/O 14-1, NAVATA ROAD
TRANSPORT ROAD, OLD CHECK POST JUNCTION, BANDAR ROAD,
3. NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, REP.BY ITS DIVISIONAL
MANAGER, INSURER OF THE LORRY NO. AP 16 T 3988
DWARAKANAGAR, VISAKHAPATNAM.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC praying thet the Highcourt may be
pleased to
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. G RAMA GOPAL
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1.
2. V VEERABHADRA CHARY
The Court made the following:
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
M.A.C.M.A.No.858 of 2012
JUDGMENT:
Introductory:
1.
This appeal is directed against the Judgment and decree dated 28.12.2011
passed in M.O.P. No.1332 of 2005 by the Chairman, Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal-cum-I Additional District Judge, Visakhapatnam (for short “the learned
MACT”). The claimant before the learned MACT is the appellant herein.
2.
Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the quantum of compensation of
Rs.20,000/- awarded as against the claim made for Rs.3,00,000/-, the present
appeal is filed.
3.
Respondent Nos.1 and 2 herein are the driver and owner of the lorry
bearing registration No. AP 16 T 3988 (hereinafter referred to as “the offending
vehicle”), and Respondent No.3 is the insurer of the offending vehicle.
4.
For the sake of convenience, the parties will be referred to as the claimant
and the respondents as and how they are arrayed before the learned MACT.
Case of the claimant/ appellant:
5(i).
On 26.07.2005 at about 06:00 a.m., the claimant/appellant was going to
Gantikorlam from Ravikamatham on his motorcycle with milk cans to purchase
milk. When he reached near Gurrayya Kotta Bridge, the offending vehicle, driven
by its driver, came in a rash and negligent manner and dashed the claimant’s
motorcycle from the back side. As a result, the claimant sustained grievous
injuries all over the body, fractures on ribs, left ankle, right shoulder, right thigh,
and head injury. He was immediately taken to K.G. Hospital, Visakhapatnam for
treatment and was admitted as an in-patient and took treatment from 26.07.2005
to 02.09.2006. He has also undergone four operations in the said hospital.
(ii)
As on the date of accident, the claimant was engaged in milk business
and agricultural activities and was earning about Rs.10,000/- per month.
(iii).
The accident occurred solely due to the rash and negligent driving of the
offending vehicle by its driver. A case in Crime No.25 of 2005 was registered
against respondent No.1driver by the Ravikamatham Police.
6.
Respondent Nos.1 and 2, the driver and the owner of the offending
vehicle, remained ex parte before the learned MACT.
Case of respondent No.3 / Insurance Company:
7(i).
Age, occupation and income of the claimant and the nature and effect of
injuries, cost of treatment etc. shall be strictly proved.
(ii).
The driver of the motor cycle had no valid driving licence, and the accident
might have occurred due to the petitioner’s negligence.
(iii).
It is also the case of the respondent Insurance Company that since the
claimant was negligent, he is not entitled to compensation and respondent No.3 /
Insurance Company is not liable.
8.
On the strength of pleadings, the following issues were settled for trial by
the learned MACT:
(i). Whether the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of
the lorry bearing No.AP 16 T 3988?
(ii). Whether the petitioner is entitled for compensation? If so, to what
amount?
(iii). To what relief?
Evidence before the learned MACT:
9(i).
The claimant was examined as P.W.1 and one Dr. Chadisetty Subba Rao
examined as P.W.2.
(ii). On behalf of the claimant, Exs.A1 to A16 and Ex.X1 (case sheet) were
marked in support of his claim.
(iii). The Insurance Company did not examine any witness or produce any
rebuttal evidence.
Findings of the learned MACT:
10(i). The accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the
offending vehicle.
(ii).
The claimant failed to establish his income and also failed to prove
permanent disability.
(iii).
Claimant is entitled to a sum of Rs.20,000/- towards pain and suffering.
(iv). Claims for past earnings, medical expenses, transport, extra nourishment,
permanent disability and loss of earning capacity cannot be allowed.
(v). All respondents are jointly and severally liable to pay the awarded amount.
11.
Heard
both
sides
extensively.
Perused
the
record.
Thoughtful
consideration is given to the arguments advanced by both sides.
Arguments in the appeal:
For the claimant:
12(i). The compensation awarded is grossly inadequate.
(ii).
The learned MACT failed to properly appreciate the medical evidence
available on record and erroneously came to the conclusion that the injuries
sustained by the claimant are simple in nature and thereby awarded a meagre
amount of Rs.20,000/-.
The evidence on record clearly establishes that the
claimant sustained grievous injuries to the abdomen and spinal cord and that his
spleen was severely damaged.
(iii).
The claimant had undergone several operations at K.G. Hospital. These
facts are reflected in Ex.A13 and are also substantiated by the evidence of the
Doctor examined as PW.2. Therefore, the finding of the learned MACT that the
claimant sustained simple injuries and awarding Rs.20,000/- is totally unjustified.
(iv).
The learned MACT failed to appreciate that due to the injuries sustained in
the accident, the claimant incurred huge medical expenditure. It is also submitted
that the claimant had to sell away his agricultural lands to meet the medical
expenses, extra nourishment and family sustenance and the said sale
transactions were marked as Exs.A10 and A11. However, the learned MACT
failed to properly consider the said evidence.
(v).
The learned MACT ought to have assessed the disability at 100% and
awarded compensation accordingly.
(vi).
The award passed by the learned MACT is contrary to the scope and spirit
of Chapter XII of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
(vii). The learned MACT ought to have awarded the compensation as prayed
for.
For the respondent-Insurance Company:
13(i). The compensation awarded by the learned MACT under the impugned
order is excessive.
(ii).
The claimant failed to produce sufficient documentary evidence to prove
his income, medical expenditure or permanent disability and therefore the
learned MACT was justified in disallowing those claims.
(iii).
The compensation awarded by the learned MACT is reasonable in the
facts and circumstances of the case and that the claimant is not entitled to any
further enhancement.
(iv).
There are no grounds to interfere.
14.
This is an appeal filed by the claimant. There is no appeal by the Insurance
Company. Therefore, the liability of the Insurance Company is out of dispute.
15.
The points that arise for determination in this appeal are:
1)
Whether the compensation of Rs.20,000/- awarded by the learned
MACT to the claimant under the impugned judgment dated 28.12.2011 in
M.O.P.No.1332 of 2005 on the file of the learned MACT is proper, viz. just
and reasonable or requires any modification and if so, to what extent.
2)
What is the result of the appeal?
Point No.1:
Precedential Guidance:
16.
A reference to parameters, for quantifying the compensation under various
heads, addressed by the Hon’ble Apex Court is found necessary, to have
standard base in the process of quantifying the compensation, to which the
claimant is entitled.
(i)
With regard to awarding just and reasonable quantum of
compensation, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Baby Sakshi Greola vs. Manzoor
Ahmad Simon and Anr.1, arising out of SLP(c).No.10996 of 2018 on
11.12.2024, considered the scope and powers of the Tribunal in awarding just
and compensation within the meaning of Act, after marshaling entire case law,
more particularly with reference to the earlier observations of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court made in Kajal V. Jagadish Chand and Ors.2, referred to various
2025 AIAR (Civil) 1
2020 (04) SCC 413
heads under which, compensation can be awarded, in injuries cases vide
paragraph No.52, the heads are as follows:Amount (In ₹)
S. No.
Head
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Medicines and Medical Treatment
Loss of Earning Capacity due to Disability
Pain and Suffering
Future Treatment
Attendant Charges
Loss of Amenities of Life
Loss of Future Prospect
Special Education Expenditure
Conveyance and Special Diet
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
10.
Loss of Marriage Prospects
xxxxxx
_________
xxxxxx
_________
Total
(ii).
Rs. …
Hon’ble Apex Court in Yadava Kumar Vs. Divisional Manager,
National Insurance Company Limited and Anr.,3 vide para No.10, by referring
to Sunil Kumar Vs. Ram Singh Gaud4,as to application of multiplier method in
case of injuries while calculating loss of future earnings, in para 16 referring to
Hardeo Kaur Vs. Rajasthan State Transport Corporation5, as to fixing of
quantum of compensation with liberal approach, valuing the life and limb of
individual in generous scale, in para 17 observed that :“The High Court and the Tribunal must realize that there is a distinction between
compensation and damage. The expression compensation may include a claim for
damage but compensation is more comprehensive. Normally damages are given for an
injury which is suffered, whereas compensation stands on a slightly higher footing. It is
given for the atonement of injury caused and the intention behind grant of
compensation is to put back the injured party as far as possible in the same position, as
2010(10)SCC 341
2007 (14) SCC 61
1992(2) SCC 567
if the injury has not taken place, by way of grant of pecuniary relief. Thus, in the matter
of computation of compensation, the approach will be slightly more broad based than
what is done in the matter of assessment of damages. At the same time it is true that
there cannot be any rigid or mathematical precision in the matter of determination of
compensation.”
(iii).
In Rajkumar Vs. Ajay Kumar and Another6, the Hon’ble Apex
Court summarized principles to be followed in the process of quantifying the
compensation after referring to socio economic and practical aspects from which,
the claimants come and the practical difficulties, the parties may face in the
process of getting disability assessed and getting all certificates from either the
Doctors, who treated, or from the medical boards etc. principles summarized vide
para No.19 are as follows:
19. We may now summarise the principles discussed above:
(i) All injuries (or permanent disabilities arising from injuries), do
not result in loss of earning capacity.
(ii) The percentage of permanent disability with reference to the whole
body of a person, cannot be assumed to be the percentage of loss of
earning capacity. To put it differently, the percentage of loss of
earning capacity is not the same as the percentage of permanent
disability (except in a few cases, where the Tribunal on the basis of
evidence, concludes that the percentage of loss of earning capacity is
the same as the percentage of permanent disability).
(iii) The doctor who treated an injured claimant or who examined him
subsequently to assess the extent of his permanent disability can give
evidence only in regard to the extent of permanent disability. The loss
of earning capacity is something that will have to be assessed by the
Tribunal with reference to the evidence in entirety.
2011 (1) SCC 343
(iv) The same permanent disability may result in different percentages
of loss of earning capacity in different persons, depending upon the
nature of profession, occupation or job, age, education and other
factors.
(iv)
In Sidram vs. United India Insurance Company Ltd. and Anr.7
vide para No.40, the Hon’ble Apex Court referred to
the general principles
relating to compensation in injury cases and assessment of future loss of earning
due to permanent disability by referring to Rajkumar’s case, and also various
heads under which compensation can be awarded to a victim of a motor vehicle
accident.
(v)
In Sidram’s case, reference is made to a case in R.D. Hattangadi
V. Pest Control (India) (P) Ltd.8. From the observations made therein, it can
be understood that while fixing amount of compensation in cases of accident, it
involves some guess work, some hypothetical consideration, some amount of
sympathy linked with the nature of the disability caused. But, all these elements
have to be viewed with objective standards. In assessing damages, the Court
must exclude all considerations of matter which rest in awarding speculation or
fancy, though conjecture to some extent is inevitable.
Evidence and Analysis:
17(i). P.W.2, who treated the petitioner, stated that the claimant was admitted in
the hospital on 26.07.2005 and discharged on 05.08.2005. Again, the petitioner
2023 (3) SCC 439
1995 (1) SCC 551
was admitted on 12.09.2005 and discharged on 13.09.2005. Again, there was
admission on 06.12.2005 and surgery was conducted on 09.12.2005 and he was
discharged on 17.12.2005.
(ii).
Further, the claimant was admitted in hospital on 18.04.2006 and the
operation was conducted on 19.04.2006 and he was discharged on 22.04.2006.
Again, there was admission on 29.08.2006, operation was conducted on
01.09.2006 and he was discharged on 02.09.2006.
Nothing important was
elicited in the cross- examination.
18.
The petitioner has taken treatment in a Government Hospital. That does
not mean that the petitioner might not have incurred any expenditure for
medicines, transportation and attendant charges etc. Therefore, the petitioner is
entitled for reasonable compensation under the heads of pain and suffering
attendant charges and reasonable medical expenditure etc.
19.
The petitioner/claimant was engaged in milk business claimed that he was
earring an income at Rs.10,000/- per month and as per his evidence, he
sustained grievous injuries all over the body, especially burst of spleen, fracture
of ribs on both sides, fracture of left ankle, right shoulder, right thigh and head
injury etc.
20.
The only point considered by the Court is that there is no proof of loss of
income and no medical bills are filed to indicate the expenditure incurred. The
precedential guidance indicates the difficulties faced by the parties in placing
documents before the Court and procurement of medical records may sometimes
be difficult. Therefore, the Court has to take empathetic concerns and holistic
view and certain hypotheses are also permissible.
21.
The findings of the learned MACT indicate that no medical bills are filed
and there is no evidence to prove that any amount was spent and that the
claimant might have taken treatment free of cost in the Government Hospital and
that the petitioner is not entitled to any compensation except Rs.20,000/-. These
findings and quantification of compensation are found just and reasonable.
22.
In the light of the precedential guidance and in view of the reasons and
evidence referred to above, the entitlement of the claimant for reasonable
compensation, in comparison to the compensation awarded by the learned
MACT, is found as follows:
Sl.
Head
No.
1. Pain and suffering
Granted by the
learned MACT
Rs.20,000/-
Fixed by this
Appellate Court
Rs.60,000/-
2. Loss of income due to
disability
3. Transportation
-Nil-
-Nil-
-Nil-
Rs.20,000/-
4. Medical
expenditure/treatment
5. Attendant charges
-Nil-
Rs.10,000/-
-Nil-
Rs.20,000/-
6. Loss of income / earnings
during the period of
hospitalization etc.
-Nil-
Rs.20,000/-
7. Loss of amenities
Total:
Interest (per annum)
23.
-Nil-
Rs.20,000/-
Rs.20,000/-
Rs.1,50,000/-
7.5%
7.5%
For the reasons aforesaid and in view of the discussion made above, the
point framed is answered in favour of the claimant, concluding that the claimant
is entitled for compensation of Rs.1,50,000/- and the judgment and decree dated
28.12.2011 passed by the learned MACT in M.O.P.No.1332 of 2005 require
modification accordingly.
Point No.2:
24.
In the result, the appeal is allowed in part as follows:
(i) Compensation awarded by the learned MACT in M.O.P.No.1332 of
2005 at Rs.20,000/- with interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum is
modified to Rs.1,50,000/- with interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum
from the date of petition till the date of realization.
(ii) Respondent Nos.1 to 3 are jointly and severally liable. However,
Respondent No.3 / Insurance Company is liable in view of the
insurance policy.
(iii) Time for payment/deposit of the balance amount is two months.
(a) If the claimant furnishes the bank account number within 15 days
from today, Respondents No.3 / Insurance Company shall deposit
the amount directly into the bank account of the claimant and file
the necessary proof before the learned MACT.
(b) If the claimant fails to comply with (iii)(a) above, Respondent
No.3/Insurance Company shall deposit the amount before the
learned MACT and the claimant is entitled to withdraw the amount
at once on deposit.
(iv) There shall be no order as to costs in the appeal.
25.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in the appeal shall
stand closed.
____________________________
A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA, J
Date:13.03.2026
Knr
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
M.A.C.M.A.No.858 of 2012
13.03.2026
Knr
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review