The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
6. OBSERVATION OF THIS COURT: a) It appears that, in order to bring home the charge against the petitioner under Section 304-A of I.P.C., the prosecution must have to prove that the petitioner, being the driver of the lorry, was driving the vehicle in a rash or negligent manner and that as a result thereof, two persons has expired. In this case, it has been alleged that P.Ws.1, 2, 4 & 5 were inside the cabin of the lorry while the petitioner was driving the vehicle. P.W.1 has stated that, at the time of driving, the petitioner slept. Reasons thereof, lorry dashed a milestone on the right side of the road and turned turtle to the right side. b) It is the case of the defence that petitioner was not involved in the accident and was not driving the vehicle at the relevant point of time. Upon a careful reading of the evidence of the prosecution witnesses (P.Ws.), it appears that the accident occurred due to the lorry driver slept while driving. When the driver of lorry slept during driving, accident may be occurred or lorry may hit the mile stone of the road. c) The evidence further suggested that P.Ws.1, 2, 4, and 5 were travelling inside the cabin of the offending lorry. Surprisingly, all the prosecution witnesses sustained minor injuries, except the petitioner, who is alleged to be the driver. -7CRL.R.C. No.1347 OF 2014 d) It is the submission of the learned Assistant Public Prosecu…
7. Accordingly, the criminal revision case is disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010709062014
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3560]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY,THE EIGHTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
CRIMINAL REVISION CASE NO: 1347/2014
Between:
1. GANGALA SRINIVASULU, NELLORE DT., S/O SUBBAIAH, AGED 34
YEARS, R/O MUTYALAPADU, CHILLAKURU (V&M), NELLORE
DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. STATE OF A P REP BY P P, Rep. by its Public Proseuctor, High Court
at Hyderabad
...RESPONDENT
Revision filed under Section 397/401 of CrPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the
CriminalRevisionCase, the High Court may be pleased toto file this Criminal
Revision Case against the Judgment dt. 23.06.2014 passed in Crl.A. No. 101
of 2013 ont he file of IV Additional District and Sessions Judge, Nellore
confirming the sentence and conviction passed by the learned Additional
Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Kavali, Nellore District in C.C. No. 360 of
2007 dt. 28.05.2013 sentencing and convicting the petitioner herein to
undergo six months imprisonmetn and also to pay a fine of Rs. 1,000/- for the
offence punishable U/s 304-A of IPC and further fine of Rs. 1,000/- and Rs.
5,00/- for offences u/s 338 and 337 of IPC with a default clause
IA NO: 1 OF 2014(CRLRCMP 2105 OF 2014
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
-2CRL.R.C. No.1347 OF 2014
dispense with the filing of the certified of order dt.28-05-2013 passed in
C.C.N0.360 of 2007 by the learned Additional Judicial Magistrate of First
Class, Kavali, Nellore District and to pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2014(CRLRCMP 2166 OF 2014
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the judgment dated 23.06.2014 passed in Crl.A.No. 101/2013 on the
file of the IV Additional District and Sessions Judge, Nellore confirming the
sentence and conviction passed by the learned Additional Judicial Magistrate
of First Class, Kavali, Nellore District in Cc.No.360/2007 dated 28.05.2013 by
granting bail to the petitioner in the interest of justice
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. M RAMALINGESWARA REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
The Court made the following:
-3CRL.R.C. No.1347 OF 2014
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
CRIMINAL REVISION CASE NO: 1347/2014
ORDER:
1. The instant criminal revision case has arisen out of conviction and
sentence against the petitioner under Sections 304-A, 338 and 337 of
the Indian Penal Code (for short, ‘I.P.C.’). There are concurrent findings
by the learned trial court and the appellate court.
2. BRIEF FACTS OF THE PROSECUTION CASE:
a) On 07.03.2007, the accused (petitioner herein), being the driver of a
lorry transporting white stones, with some coolies, sat on top of the lorry
along white stones. At the time of driving, the accused drove the vehicle
in a rash and negligent manner and slept. Resultantly, the lorry dashed
to milestone on the right side of the road and turned turtle towards right
side. Due to which, two coolies who were sitting on top of the lorry with
white stones was fell under the white stones and died on the spot.
P.Ws. 1 to 5, who were travelling in the cabin of the lorry along with the
accused driver, sustained minor injuries. P.W.1, being the cleaner of the
lorry, reported the matter to police. Upon which, a case was registered
and investigation was conducted.
b) During trial, prosecution has examined as many as eleven (11)
witnesses and eight (08) documents are exhibited. After hearing the
parties, learned trial court has found petitioner guilty for offence under
-4CRL.R.C. No.1347 OF 2014
sections 304-A of IPC and imposed simple imprisonment for six (06)
months with fine of Rs.1,000/-. The learned appellate court dismissed
appeal and confirmed the order of conviction. Hence, present revision.
3. SUBMISSIONS OF THE LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
PETITIONER:
a) It is argued on behalf of the petitioner that the petitioner was not the
driver of the offending vehicle at the relevant point of time. He was
falsely implicated in the case due to prior enmity between owner of
the vehicle and the petitioner, on account of the demand of salary;
the fact of the prosecution case cannot be believed as P.Ws. 2 to 4,
who are stated to be eyewitnesses to the accident, did not support
the prosecution case.
b) The learned counsel further submits that there are several
discrepancies in the evidence of the prosecution, thereby recording
conviction and sentence is doubtful; if petitioner was driver of
offending vehicle, he would have sustained injuries along with other
inmates of the lorry. But in this case, petitioner was not driving the
offending vehicle.
Thus, order of conviction and sentence is not
sustainable.
c) Lastly, it is submitted that petitioner is more than 50 years of age and
has been dealing with this criminal case since the year 2007. Thus, a
lenient view may be adopted by imposing fine instead of conviction
and sentence. .
-5CRL.R.C. No.1347 OF 2014
4. SUBMSISSIONS OF THE LEARNED ASSISTANT PUBLIC
PROSECUTOR APPEARING FOR THE STATE:
a) The learned Assistant Public Prosecutor submits that the prosecution
sufficiently bring home charge against present petitioner. The petitioner
was the driver of offending lorry and his rash and negligent driving was
well proved from the evidence of P.Ws.1 and 5. Though P.Ws.2 to 4 did
not support the prosecution case, evidences of P.Ws.1 and 5 are
corroborative in nature. The involvement of the petitioner as the driver
of the offending vehicle is thus well proved from the evidence of P.Ws.1
and 5.
b) Further, the Investigating Officer and the witnesses who conducted
inquest over the dead body has also supported the prosecution case. At
this juncture, it cannot be said that the petitioner was not involved in the
accident or was not driving the vehicle at the relevant point of time.
P.W.1 has categorically stated that the petitioner drove the vehicle in a
rash and negligent manner and he slept while driving. P.W.5 supported
the version of P.W.1 saying that the petitioner was driving the lorry in a
zigzag manner. He further submits that involvement of the petitioner as
driver cannot be ruled out. Therefore, the order of conviction and
sentence cannot be set aside.
5. Heard
Sri
I.V.N.
Raju,
learned
counsel
representing
Sri
M.Ramalingeswara Reddy, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
-6CRL.R.C. No.1347 OF 2014
and Sri K.Sandeep, learned Assistant Public Prosecutor appearing for
the State.
6. OBSERVATION OF THIS COURT:
a) It appears that, in order to bring home the charge against the petitioner
under Section 304-A of I.P.C., the prosecution must have to prove that
the petitioner, being the driver of the lorry, was driving the vehicle in a
rash or negligent manner and that as a result thereof, two persons has
expired. In this case, it has been alleged that P.Ws.1, 2, 4 & 5 were
inside the cabin of the lorry while the petitioner was driving the vehicle.
P.W.1 has stated that, at the time of driving, the petitioner slept.
Reasons thereof, lorry dashed a milestone on the right side of the road
and turned turtle to the right side.
b) It is the case of the defence that petitioner was not involved in the
accident and was not driving the vehicle at the relevant point of time.
Upon a careful reading of the evidence of the prosecution witnesses
(P.Ws.), it appears that the accident occurred due to the lorry driver
slept while driving.
When the driver of lorry slept during driving,
accident may be occurred or lorry may hit the mile stone of the road.
c) The evidence further suggested that P.Ws.1, 2, 4, and 5 were travelling
inside the cabin of the offending lorry. Surprisingly, all the prosecution
witnesses sustained minor injuries, except the petitioner, who is alleged
to be the driver.
-7CRL.R.C. No.1347 OF 2014
d) It is the submission of the learned Assistant Public Prosecutor that the
petitioner, being the driver, slept and suddenly he came to know that the
lorry is out of control, thus, he was conscious to avoid any injury.
e) In this case, if the lorry is turned turtle right side, all the persons in the
cabin would have fallen over the driver. Moreover, when the driver was
running the lorry in sleeping condition, he could not be so conscious to
stop the lorry or saved himself from getting injured. Surprisingly in this
case, the driver of the offending vehicle was not surrendered before the
Court voluntarily, but he was arrested. It is the case of the petitioner
that he was not driving the lorry at the relevant point of time. Though
P.Ws.1 and 5 stated that the petitioner was driving the lorry, but in this
juncture, as the petitioner could not sustain any injury, the presence of
the petitioner becomes doubtful.
f) Same doubt was appeared before the learned appellate court.
In
paragraph 20 of the judgment, learned appellate court has opined that
the driver would have certainly received injuries. However, the learned
appellate court is of the view that, from the evidence of P.Ws.1 and 5,
who are the material witnesses to the accident, were travelling in the
offending vehicle, the involvement of the petitioner is acceptable.
g) This is a court of revision. While both the courts are of the view that the
petitioner was driving the lorry at the relevant point of time and
observations of the learned trial court are on the basis of evidence of
P.Ws.1 and 2, there may have another view of accepting that the
-8CRL.R.C. No.1347 OF 2014
petitioner has not received any injury may not have driving the lorry at
the time of accident. But both learned trial court and learned appellate
court accepted that involvement of the petitioner as driver of the lorry on
the basis of the evidence of P.Ws.1 and 5.
h) When in a case, two views are possible and both the courts below have
adopted a view, this court being a the revisional court has to accept the
view adopted by court below unless the view is so perverse to accept.
In this case, in my view, learned appellate court has decided the issue
correctly; though there may be certain other chances, where another
view may be accepted. But, in this case, I cannot accept the submission
of the learned counsel for the petitioner to hold that the petitioner was
not driving the vehicle at that point of time. It further appears that rash
and negligent driving of the petitioner has been well proved by the
evidence of P.Ws.1 and 5 and other witnesses, including the Motor
Vehicle Inspector and the Investigating Officer. Thereby, I find no
justification to interfere with the findings of the learned trial court as well
as the learned appellate court. The order of conviction and the sentence
passed by the learned trial court and the appellate court are hereby
confirmed.
i) However, it appears that the present petitioner is more than 50 years
old and has been roaming around the courts for 20 years. The petitioner
has already suffered mental agony and hardship for a long period. The
punishment under Section 304-A of I.P.C. provides imprisonment of
-9CRL.R.C. No.1347 OF 2014
either description, or fine, or both. In this case, the learned trial court as
well as the appellate court punished the petitioner for 6 months simple
imprisonment as well as a fine of Rs. 1,000/- for the offence punishable
under Section 304-A of I.P.C. In these circumstances, it is fit to observe
that the period of simple imprisonment as ordered by the learned trial
court is hereby converted into a fine of Rs.2,000/- (rupees two thousand
only) more. The petitioner is directed to deposit the fine amount before
the trial court within four (04) weeks from the date of this order. The fine
amount of Rs. 2,000/- shall be in addition to the fine already imposed.
7. Accordingly, the criminal revision case is disposed of.
8. Pending miscellaneous petition(s), if any, shall stand closed.
____________________________
JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
Dt.08.04.2026
BV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review