The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. In the light of the above, though the principle of ‘no work no pay’ would be applicable, meaning that a person will not be entitled to pay and allowances during the period for which he did not perform his duties, but as pointed out, in the case of Ramesh Kumar (supra) this principle cannot be accepted as a rule of thumb and that the matter will have to be considered on a case to case basis. In the case of the petitioner by a series of judicial pronouncement, he was directed to be promoted to the cadre of Assistant Commandant w.e.f. 22.01.1997, though notionally, therefore the principle of ‘no work no pay’ will not be applicable to his case as it is incumbent upon the respondent Authority to comply with the direction of the Court.
22. In the final analysis, this Court finds that the petitioner has been able to make out a case for grant of arrear pay and allowances as prayed for in this petition and accordingly, the same is allowed. The respondent Authority, particularly the respondent No. 2 is hereby directed to issue necessary orders in this regard preferably within two months from the date of this order.
23. Petition disposed of. No costs. Judge Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 74 of 2020
Date of Decision: 07.07.2022
ND AR-272A Shri. Ganesh Kumar
Vs.
Union of India & 2 Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
Mr. M. Chanda, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. R. Debnath, CGC.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
This Court vide order dated 01.02.2018 in WP(C) No. 232 of 2013,
between the same parties herein indicating that in the third round of litigation
between the same parties on the petitioner’s claim for promotion and
consequential benefits, in the operative part of the order has held as follows:“This Court is clearly of the view that in the given set of facts
and circumstances and particularly in view of the concluded
findings in the case of the petitioner, the requirement of notional
promotion and fixing of seniority carried inherently the
requirement of fixation of scale pay of the petitioner w.e.f.
22.01.1997 and for further fixation of pay on notional basis after
placement in appropriate scale as applicable at the relevant
point of time in all the cadres of progression.
For what has been discussed hereinabove, this writ
petition is allowed in terms of the relief prayed for. The
respondents shall carry out the corresponding modifications and
take all necessary corrective steps at the earliest, preferably
within 60 days from today.”
2.
Pursuant to the said order, the respondent No. 2 through his assign,
has issued a speaking order dated 28.08.2018 indicating thereto that the pay
of the petitioner has been fixed at Rs.8,000/- in the pay scale of Rs. 8,000/275-13,5000/- per month w.e.f. 22-01-1997 (date of appointment of the batchmates) on notional basis and corresponding re-fixation in the rank of Dy.
Comdt (Rs. 10,000-325-15,200/-) on 01-04-2004, in the rank of 2IC (Rs.
31,420/- plus Grade pay Rs. 7,600/-) on 01-07-2008 and in the rank of Comdt.
(Rs. 37,400/- plus Grade pay Rs. 8,700/-) on 11-03-2013, have also been
done. After detailed work out, it has been found that there is no difference in
pay of the officer and his pension has been calculated correctly based on his
last pay (Rs.1,34,500/-) drawn. All his pensionary benefits have already been
assessed/granted to him as per CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 and PPO (Pension
Payment Order) No. 234981807077 dated 18-05-2018 has been issued in his
favour.
3.
It now appears that in this fourth round of litigation, the petitioner
has once again approached this Court by way of this instant writ petition with
a prayer to direct the respondents to pay the arrear pay and allowances with
effect from 22.01.1997 till 31.12.2005 correspondingly in the scale of pay due
and payable to the Assistant Commandant with effect from 22.01.1997 to
31.03.2004, and as Deputy Commandant from 01.04.2004 to 31.06.2008 and
again as Commandant from 01.07.2008 to 11.03.2013, since the same has not
been paid to him and also, since the speaking order dated 28.08.2018 has
failed to address the issue of arrear pay and allowance due and payable to the
petitioner.
4.
The brief background of the case between the parties, is that the
petitioner was enrolled as Rifleman in Assam Rifles on 31.10.1977. In 1996
he was selected by the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) as
Assistant Commandant and was accordingly sent for training and on
completion of the same, had waited for the piping ceremony, but when the
said piping ceremony was held, seven of his batch-mates were selected while
he was not selected nor promoted on account of a departmental proceeding
against him.
5.
The petitioner then approached this Court (the then Shillong Bench
of the Gauhati High Court) by way of a writ petition being WP(C) No. 209
(SH) 2001 and vide order dated 07.04.2003, his prayer was allowed. The
petitioner was then granted promotion to the post of Assistant Commandant
w.e.f. 01.08.2006. Again, this Court was approached by the petitioner by
filing a writ petition being WP(C) No. 312 (SH) 2006 and vide order dated
23.03.2010, this Court directed that the petitioner be given notional promotion
in the cadre of Assistant Commandant from the date of promotion of his
batch-mates i.e. 22.01.1997. The authorities by relevant order has re-fixed the
seniority of the petitioner and has granted him promotion in the cadre of
Assistant Commandant w.e.f. 22.01.1997. It may be noted that the order of
the Single Bench in the said WP(C) No. 312 (SH) 2006 was assailed by the
respondents before the Division Bench of this Court (the then Shillong Bench
of the Gauhati High Court) in WA. No. 20 (SH) 2010 which was dismissed
by this Court.
6.
Yet again, the petitioner said to have been aggrieved by the failure
of the respondent authority to carry out adequate compliance of the order
passed by this Court (the then Shillong Bench of the Gauhati High Court) in
WP(C) No. 312 (SH) 2006, inasmuch as, the benefits of notional fixation of
pay in the cadre of Assistant Commandant w.e.f. 22.01.1997 and
consequential re-fixation of pay in other cadres of progression was denied to
him, has approached this Court by way of WP(C) No. 232 of 2013 and as
indicated above vide order dated 01.02.2018, this Court has passed the order
indicated above leading to the passing of the said speaking order dated
28.08.2018 which is impugned herein.
7.
Heard Mr. M. Chanda, learned counsel for the petitioner who has
submitted that in view of the many orders and directions issued by this Court
whereby the petitioner was finally given notional promotion right from the
level of Assistant Commandant w.e.f. 22.01.1997 and was also notionally
promoted progressively till he finally retired in the rank of Commandant, the
pay and allowance as applicable to him has also been given. However, as to
the arrear pay and allowance from the time he was notionally promoted as
Assistant Commandant on 22.01.1997 to 31.12.2005 when he was promoted
to the rank of Deputy Commandant, the same was denied to him. Hence this
case.
8.
The learned counsel has further submitted that since the respondents
has paid the arrear pay and allowances to the petitioner from 01.01.2006 to
31.03.2013, they are also duty bound to pay the same arrear for the period
w.e.f. 22.01.1997 to 31.12.2005. The case of Nand Kumar Verma v. State of
Jharkhand & Ors: (2012) 3 SCC 580 at para 40 & 41 was referred to in this
regard.
9.
On the contention of the respondents that the petitioner cannot be
given the arrear pay and allowance for the period 22.01.1997 till 31.12.2005
since he was only notionally promoted to the rank of Assistant Commandant
and has actually not functioned as one during the relevant period, therefore
the principle of ‘no work no pay’ would be applicable. The learned counsel
for the petitioner has submitted that under the facts and circumstances of the
case of the petitioner, the same is not applicable as it was not the fault of the
petitioner having not performed his duty as Assistant Commandant during the
relevant period, but the fault squarely lies with the respondents who have not
promoted the petitioner along with his batch-mates at the relevant period, that
is, during the year 1997. The case of Ramesh Kumar v. Union of India &
Ors: (2015) 14 SCC 335 at para 14 & 15 was also cited in this regard.
10.
Mr. R. Debnath, learned CGC on the other hand while supporting
the action of the competent authority has submitted that though the petitioner
was notionally promoted to the rank of Assistant Commandant in the year
1997, yet because he has not actually served in that capacity during the
relevant period since the promotion was given to him notionally by virtue of
the Court’s order and as such, it was only w.e.f. 01.08.2006 that the arrear pay
and allowance was given to him as he has physically assumed the rank in
officer category from that date. The principle of ‘no work no pay’ would
therefore be applicable. The case of State of Haryana & Ors v. O.P. Gupta
& Ors: (1996) 7 SCC 533, para 7, 8 & 9 was referred to by the respondents
in this regard.
11.
The case of the parties has been examined in the light of the
pleadings and the argument advanced by both sides. It is not necessary to
revisit the history of how the matter has come to a pass in this fourth round of
litigation, suffice it to say that the only issue to be decided here is whether the
petitioner is entitled to arrears of pay and allowances w.e.f. 22.01.1997 till
31.03.2004 when he was notionally promoted as Assistant Commandant and
correspondingly from 01.04.2004 to 31.12.2005 when he has attained the rank
of Deputy Commandant at the relevant period.
12.
The only contention raised by the respondents is that though the
petitioner was notionally promoted to the cadre of Assistant Commandant
w.e.f. 22.01.1997 in compliance with this Court’s order dated 23.03.2010, he
is actually entitled to arrears only w.e.f. 01.08.2006 i.e., on the date of
physical assumption in the rank of Officer category.
13.
The respondents in their affidavit-in-opposition have pleaded that in
compliance to the direction of this Court, due-drawn statement along with pay
fixation of the Officer has been carried out and the Department has fixed the
pay of the petitioner w.e.f. 22.01.1997 tabulated as under:-
Rank and pay
Date
Notional pay fixation
Remarks
scale
Assistant
22.01.1997
Pay notionally fixed wef
8000/-
No arrear of pay
Commandant
22.01.1997 with date of
and allowances
(8000-275-
next
is entitled to the
13500/-)
01.01.1998
increment
on
officer as pay
was
Granted annual increment
notionally
1,925/-
wef
notionally
the
@ Rs. 275/- (7 x 275/-)
9,925/-
01.04.2004
Pay notionally fixed wef
Commandant
01.04.2004 with date of
(10000-325-
next
15200/-)
01.04.2005
Granted
increment
one
10,325/-
on
annual
650/-
increment notionally on
01.04.2005 and one addl.
increment on 01.01.2006
under 6th CPC provision
@ Rs. 325/- (2 x 325/-)
Pay raised to
Pay
revised 01.01.2006
under 6th CPC
Pay
revised
10,975/on
01.01.2006 as per 6th CPC
and pay fixed at Rs.
(including Grade Pay Rs.
6,600/-)
27,020/-
Hon’ble
Court
on
principle
of
“NO
Deputy
as
per direction of
01.01.1998 to 01.01.2004
Pay raised to
fixed
WORK
NO PAY”.
Granted annual increment
810/-
notionally on 01.07.2006
@ 3% of basic pay
Pay raised to
Date
of 01.08.2006
physically
Notional
27,830/-
pay
as
on
27,830/-
01.08.2006
Officer
was
actually entitled
assumption of
for arrear from
Granted annual increment
rank in officer
840/-
01.08.2006
on 01.07.2007 @ 3% of
category.
basic pay
Second-in-
01.04.2008
Pay raised to
28,670/-
Pay notionally fixed wef
31,420/-
Command
01.07.2008
15600-39100/-
exercised
with Grade Pay
Rs. 7600/- pm.
duly
option
and
annual
increment
and
notional
increment
on
promotion for Rs. 860
and 890 respectively with
date of next increment on
01.07.2009
(including
Grade pay Rs. 7,600/-)
Granted annual increment
1930/-
notionally on 01.07.2009
and 01.07.10 @ 3% of
basic pay Rs. 950/- and
980/- respectively
Pay raised to
Date
of 22.02.2011
physically
Notional
pay
33,350/as
on
33,350/-
22.02.2011
was
actually entitled
assumption of
rank of 21C
Officer
for arrear from
Granted annual increment
on
01.07.2011
and
01.07.2012 @ 3% of
2,030/-
22.02.2011
in
the rank of 21C
basic pay Rs. 1000/- and
1030/- respectively
Commandant
Pay
11.03.2013
Band-4
Pay raised to
35,380/-
Pay fixed wef 11.03.2013
46,100/-
on
promotion
to
the
(37400-67000
Commandant with date of
with Grade Pay
next
Rs. 8,700/- pm)
01.07.2014
increment
on
Granted annual increment 2,820/on
01.07.2014
and
01.07.2015 @ 3% of
basic pay Rs. 1390/- and
1430/- respectively
Pay raised to
Pay
revised 01.01.2016
under 7th CPC
Pay
revised
48,920/on
1,26,800/-
Proceeded
on
01.01.2016 as per 7th CPC
Superannuation
and pay fixed in the Pay
pension
Matrix
31.05.2018
Level-13
with
on
date of increment on
01.07.2016
Granted annual increment
on
01.07.2016
7,700/-
and
01.07.2017 Rs. 3800/and 3900/- respectively
Pay raised to
14.
1,34,500/-
To strengthen their case, the respondents has relied upon the case of
O. P. Gupta (supra) wherein at paras 7 & 8, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
observed as follows: -
“7. This Court in Paluru Ramakrishnaiah & Ors. vs. Union of
India: (1989) 2 SCR 92 at page 109 considered the direction
issued by the High Court and upheld that there has to be "no pay
for no work", i.e., a person will not be entitled to any pay and
allowance during the period for which he did not perform the
duties of higher post, although after due consideration, he was
given a proper place in the gradation list having been deemed to
be promoted to the higher post with effect from the date his
junior was promoted. He will be entitled only to step up the scale
of pay retrospectively from the deemed date but is not entitled to
the payment of arrears of the salary. The same ratio was
reiterated in Virender Kumar vs. Avinash Chandra Chadha:
(1990) 3 SCC 472 (SCC p. 482, para 16).
8.
It is true, as pointed out by Shri Hooda, that in Union of
India v. K.V. Jankiraman: AIR 1991 SC 2010, this Court had
held that where the incumbent was willing to work but was
denied the opportunity to work for no fault of his, he is entitled
to the payment of arrears of salary. That is a case where the
respondent was kept under suspension during departmental
enquiry and sealed cover procedure was adopted because of the
pendency of the criminal case. When the criminal case ended in
his favour and departmental proceedings were held to be invalid,
this Court held that he was entitled to the arrears of salary. That
ratio has no application to the cases where the claims for
promotion are to be considered in accordance with the rules and
the promotions are to be made pursuant thereto.”
15.
In reply to this, in the case of Ramesh Kumar (supra) cited by the
petitioner at paragraphs 14 & 15, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as
under:“14. In normal circumstances when retrospective promotions
are effected, all benefits flowing therefrom, including monetary
benefits, must be extended to an employee who has been denied
promotion earlier. So far as monetary benefits with regard to
retrospective promotion are concerned that depends upon case
to case. In State of Kerala v. E.K. Bhaskaran Pillai: (2007) 6
SCC 524, this Court held that the principle of “no work no pay”
cannot be accepted as a rule of thumb and the matter will have
to be considered on a case-to-case basis and in para 4, it was
held as under: (SCC p. 527)
“4. … We have considered the decisions cited on
behalf of both the sides. So far as the situation with regard
to monetary benefits with retrospective promotion is
concerned, that depends upon case to case. There are
various facets which have to be considered. Sometimes in
a case of departmental enquiry or in criminal case it
depends on the authorities to grant full back wages or 50
per cent of back wages looking to the nature of
delinquency involved in the matter or in criminal cases
where the incumbent has been acquitted by giving benefit
of doubt or full acquittal. Sometimes in the matter when
the person is superseded and he has challenged the same
before court or tribunal and he succeeds in that and
direction is given for reconsideration of his case from the
date persons junior to him were appointed, in that case
the court may grant sometimes full benefits with
retrospective effect and sometimes it may not. Particularly
when the administration has wrongly denied his due then
in that case he should be given full benefits including
monetary benefit subject to there being any change in law
or some other supervening factors. However, it is very
difficult to set down any hard-and-fast rule. The principle
‘no work no pay’ cannot be accepted as a rule of thumb.
There are exceptions where courts have granted monetary
benefits also.”
15. We are conscious that even in the absence of statutory
provision, normal rule is “no work no pay”. In appropriate
cases, a court of law may take into account all the facts in their
entirety and pass an appropriate order in consonance with law.
The principle of “no work no pay” would not be attracted where
the respondents were in fault in not considering the case of the
appellant for promotion and not allowing the appellant to work
on a post of Naib Subedar carrying higher pay scale. In the facts
of the present case when the appellant was granted promotion
w.e.f. 1-1-2000 with the ante-dated seniority from 1-8-1997 and
maintaining his seniority along with his batchmates, it would be
unjust to deny him higher pay and allowances in the promotional
position of Naib Subedar”.
16.
It may be mentioned that as regard the DPC held in the month of
August 1996, nine candidates including the petitioner were selected for the
post of Assistant Commandant and were accordingly sent for training before
actually being promoted to the said post. On completion of the training, the
normal procedure followed by the Department is that there has to be a piping
ceremony and in the said piping ceremony, only seven candidates were called
excluding the petitioner herein. This means that while the batch-mates of the
petitioner were promoted, the petitioner was not promoted. The reason being
that there was an allegation against him for improper submission of TA/DA
claim for which after summary trial, ‘Severe Reprimand’ was imposed upon
him.
17.
However, the petitioner had approached this Court (the then
Shillong Bench of the Gauhati High Court) at the relevant time and this Court
vide order dated 07.04.2003 in WP(C) No. 209 (SH) 2001 had directed the
respondent authority, particularly the respondent No. 2 herein to examine the
case of the petitioner.
18.
Again, the petitioner has approached this Court in the year 2006 by
way of WP(C) No. 312 (SH) 2006 and the Court while disposing of the
petition has opined that the petitioner is entitled to be appointed to the cadre
of Assistant Commandant from the time where his batch-mates were also
appointed as Assistant Commandant, though the same is only a notional
exercise.
19.
To the extent of repetition, on not being granted arrear pay and
allowances w.e.f. 22.01.1997 and progressively, the petitioner has again
approached this Court by way of a writ being WP(C) No. 232 of 2013 and
vide order dated 01.02.2018, the Court has allowed the prayer of the petitioner
and has directed the respondents to carry out corresponding modifications and
take all necessary corrective steps at the earliest, preferably within 60 days.
20.
In response to this, the respondents have accordingly issued the
speaking order dated 28.08.2018 confirming the notional promotion of the
petitioner to the cadre of Assistant Commandant and progressively till the
rank of Commandant. However, the arrear pay and allowances was admittedly
given to the petitioner only w.e.f. 01.08.2006.
21.
In the light of the above, though the principle of ‘no work no pay’
would be applicable, meaning that a person will not be entitled to pay and
allowances during the period for which he did not perform his duties, but as
pointed out, in the case of Ramesh Kumar (supra) this principle cannot be
accepted as a rule of thumb and that the matter will have to be considered on
a case to case basis. In the case of the petitioner by a series of judicial
pronouncement, he was directed to be promoted to the cadre of Assistant
Commandant w.e.f. 22.01.1997, though notionally, therefore the principle of
‘no work no pay’ will not be applicable to his case as it is incumbent upon the
respondent Authority to comply with the direction of the Court.
22.
In the final analysis, this Court finds that the petitioner has been able
to make out a case for grant of arrear pay and allowances as prayed for in this
petition and accordingly, the same is allowed. The respondent Authority,
particularly the respondent No. 2 is hereby directed to issue necessary orders
in this regard preferably within two months from the date of this order.
23.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
07.07.2022
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review