Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/gandip-prasad-vs-state-of-sikkim-20160405/ · Printed 18 Nov 2026
Criminal

Gandip Prasad vs State Of Sikkim

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Sikkim High Court
Date
5 April 2016
Case No.
Crl. A. 15/2015
Result
Dismissed
Bench
Justice Justice, Justice S. Justice Meenakshi Madan Rai
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

HI GH COURT OF SI KKI M , GANGTOK (Crim inal Appellat e Jurisdict ion) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- D.B.: HON’BLE SH RI SUNI L KUM AR SI NH A, C.J. & HON’BLE M RS. M EENAKSHI M ADAN RAI , J. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Crl. A. No. 15 of 20 1 5 Sh r i Gan dip Pr asad, Son of lat e Lalan Pr asad, Residen t of : Ran gpo Bazar , East Sik k im . At Pr esen t : Ron gyek Jail … Appellant . … Respondent Versus St at e of Sik k im . Appeal u/ S. 3 7 4 of t he Code of Crim inal Procedure, 1 9 7 3 . ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Appearance : Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocat e wit h Ms. Tam anna Chet t ri, ( Legal Aid Counsel) and Ms. Malat i Sharm a, Advocat e for t he Appellant . Ms. Pollin Rai, Assist ant Public Prosecut or for t he St at e. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- J UDGM E NT (05.04.2016) Followin g Ju dgm en t of t h e Cou r t was deliver ed by SUNI L KUM AR SI NHA, CJ. 1. Th is Appeal is dir ect ed again st t h e Ju dgm en t dat ed 31.03.2015 passed in Session s Tr ial Case No. 02 of 2014 by t h e Session s Ju dge, Sou t h Sik k im at Nam ch i. By t h e im pu gn ed Ju dgm en t , t h e Appellan t h as been con vict ed u n der Sect ion 302 IPC an d sen t en ced t o u n der go im pr ison m en t for life an d t o pay fin e of Rs.50,000/ - wit h defau lt sen t en ce of SI for on e year . 2. In all, t wo accu sed per son s wer e pr osecu t ed. Th e Appellan t h er ein (A-1) was pr osecu t ed u / Ss. 302/ 498-A IPC wh er eas, h is m ot h er , Gir ja Devi (A-2) was pr osecu t ed u / Ss. 302/ 109 & 498-A/ 109 IPC. 3. (A-1). Deceased, Kalawat i Devi, was wife of t h e Appellan t Th e case of t h e pr osecu t ion is t h at bot h t h e accu sed per son s (A-1 an d A-2) u sed t o t r eat h er wit h cr u elt y an d Kalawat i was n ot h appy in h er m at r im on ial h ou se. On 28.10.2013 at abou t 0930 Hr s. t h e Appellan t an d t h e deceased bot h wer e seen t oget h er on t h e Jh olu n gay br idge over Teest a r iver . All of su dden t h e Appellan t for cefu lly t ook deceased in t o h is lap an d t h r ew h er in t o r iver Teest a, in wh ich t h e wat er level was ver y h igh an d t h e h eigh t bet ween wat er level an d br idge was abou t 50 – 60 feet . 4. Th e in ciden t was wit n essed by five eye wit n esses, n am ely, Ren u Ch et t r i (PW-6), Bh im Bdr . Su bba (PW-7), San ch a Raj Su bba (PW-8), Pr em Ku m ar Rai (PW-9) an d Su r aj Gu r u n g (PW-11). Ren u Ch et t r i (PW-6) im m ediat ely gave t eleph on ic in for m at ion t o ASI D.N. Rai (PW-10), wh o was In -ch ar ge of Mam r in g Police Ou t post of Nam ch i Police St at ion . Mr . D.N. Rai (PW-10) r edu ced it in wr it in g (Exh ibit -5) an d for war ded t h e sam e t o Nam ch i Police St at ion an d a for m al Fir st In for m at ion Repor t (FIR Exh ibit -6) was r egist er ed u / S. 307 IPC. 5. Lat er on , at abou t 1300 Hr s. Mu n n a Lal Pr asad (PW- 14), u n cle of t h e Appellan t , r eceived in for m at ion t h at dead body of on e fem ale was seen at 12 th m ile n ear village M an gch u . He im m ediat ely r u sh ed t h er e an d iden t ified t h at it was t h e dead body of t h e deceased, Kalawat i Devi. He gave a wr it t en r epor t (Exh ibit 14) t o t h e Officer -in -ch ar ge, Ran gpo Ch eck -post (u n der Kalim pon g Police St at ion ). Th er eaft er , in qu est (Exh ibit -10) was dr awn at abou t 1405 Hr s. Th e dead body was t h en sen t for post m or t em exam in at ion , wh ich was con du ct ed by Dr . Pr asen jit Biswas (PW13), wh o su bm it t ed h is r epor t (Exh ibit 15) an d opin ed t h at t h e cau se of deat h was dr own in g in fr esh wat er , wh ich was an t em or t em in n at u r e. 6. Th e case of t h e pr osecu t ion was based on t h e eye wit n esses’ accou n t of PW-6, PW-7, PW-8, PW-9 an d PW-11. Lear n ed Session s Ju dge r elied on t h e t est im on ies of t h ese eye wit n esses an d h eld t h at it was pr oved beyon d all r eason able dou bt s t h at t h e Appellan t h ad for cefu lly t h r own h is wife in t o r iver Teest a, wit h t h e in t en t ion of cau sin g h er deat h , t h er efor e, h e was liable for pu n ish m en t u / S. 302 IPC. Th e Appellan t , t h u s, was con vict ed an d sen t en ced as above. However , h e was acqu it t ed of t h e ch ar ges fr am ed u / S. 498-A. Th e secon d accu sed (A-2) was also acqu it t ed of all t h e ch ar ges fr am ed again st h er . Th e Appellan t h as ch allen ged h is con vict ion by filin g t h is Appeal. 7. Mr . N. Rai, lear n ed Sen ior Advocat e appear in g on beh alf of t h e Appellan t , h as ar gu ed t h at t h e eye wit n esses wer e n ot r eliable as t h ey h ad seen t h e in ciden t fr om a dist an ce of abou t 30 feet an d som e of t h em h ad adm it t ed t h at t h ey cou ld n ot iden t ify t h e Appellan t at t h e t im e of com m ission of offen ce. Th e said ar gu m en t can n ot be accept ed aft er goin g t h r ou gh t h e en t ir e eviden ce of t h e eye wit n esses. Ren u Ch et t r i (PW-6) h as deposed t h at h e h ad clear ly seen t h e Appellan t lift in g t h e deceased an d t h r owin g h er in t o t h e wat er . At t h at t im e, t h e wat er level of t h e r iver was ver y h igh . Th ou gh , t wo of h is fr ien ds, n am ely, San ch a Raj Su bba (PW-8) an d Pr em Ku m ar Rai (PW-9) t r ied t o save t h e deceased by t h r owin g a bam boo t owar ds h er , sh e cou ld n ot cat ch t h e bam boo an d u lt im at ely h ad swept away in r iver cu r r en t . Th er eaft er , t h ey cau gh t t h e Appellan t on t h e spot it self an d br ou gh t h im t o Mam r in g Police Ou t post . Ren u Ch et t r i (PW-6) h as been du ly cor r obor at ed by t h e r em ain in g eye wit n esses, i.e. PW-7, PW-8, PW-9 an d PW-11, wh o all wer e pr esen t at t h e t im e of t h e in ciden t an d h ad seen t h e in ciden t fr om a dist an ce of abou t 30 feet . As n ot ed above, it was a day t im e in ciden t of abou t 0930 Hr s, so it can n ot be h eld t h at in n or m al cir cu m st an ces t h e wit n esses sit t in g at a dist an ce of 30 feet wou ld n ot be able t o see it . So far as t h e ar gu m en t of iden t ificat ion of t h e Appellan t as a per son wh o t h r ew t h e deceased in t h e r iver is con cer n ed, t h e sam e is m ean in gless becau se t h e eye wit n esses h ave deposed t h at t h ey im m ediat ely r u sh ed t o t h e place of occu r r en ce i.e. on t h e br idge an d cau gh t t h at per son wh o t h r ew t h e lady (deceased) in t o t h e wat er , wh o was n on e else t h an t h e Appellan t . Th u s, t h is is a case in wh ich t h e Appellan t was cau gh t r ed-h an ded at t h e place of occu r r en ce it self by as m an y as five eye wit n esses, wh o h an ded over h im t o t h e con cer n ed Police Ou t post . We fin d t h at t h e ver sion s of t h e eye wit n esses ar e du ly cor r obor at ed by t h e FIR (Exh ibit -5) wh ich was r ecor ded by Mr . D.N. Rai, In -ch ar ge, Mam r in g Police Ou t post . It was a pr om pt FIR lodged t eleph on ically, wh ich con t ain s t h e n am e of t h e Appellan t as t h e sole cu lpr it of t h e cr im e. 8. Mr . Rai t h en con t en ded t h at t h e dead body wh ich was r ecover ed by t h e police was n ot iden t ified t o be t h at of t h e deceased. Th e ar gu m en t appear s t o be fish y. Th e Appellan t (A-1) is t h e n eph ew of Mu n n a Lal Pr asad (PW-14), wh o deposed t h at on com in g t o k n ow abou t t h e deceased h avin g been swept away by r iver Teest a an d h er dead body was fou n d n ear Man gch u village, h e h ad lodged a r epor t (Exh ibit -14) befor e t h e Officer -in -ch ar ge of Ran gpo Ch eck -post (u n der Kalim pon g Police St at ion ). He h ad pr oved t h e r epor t (Exh ibit -14) an d h ad also pr oved h is sign at u r e (Exh ibit -14[a]). If we look in t o t h e con t en t s of Exh ibit -14, it wou ld be clear t h at on 28.10.2013 at abou t 1300 Hr s. Mu n n a Lal (PW14) h ear d abou t discover y of t h e dead body of on e fem ale on t h e ban k of r iver Teest a, n ear village Man gch u . He wen t t h er e im m ediat ely an d aft er seein g t h e dead body h e iden t ified t h at it was t h e dead body of t h e deceased Kalawat i Devi an d t h en on ly h e lodged t h e r epor t Exh ibit -14. Not on ly t h is, h e was also a wit n ess t o in qu est , wh ich was con du ct ed on t h e dead body of t h e deceased at abou t 1405 Hr s on t h e sam e day. It con t ain s t h at h e lodged t h e r epor t in t h e said Police Ch eck -post in wh ich h e h ad iden t ified t h e deceased. Th u s, t h er e is n o m at er ial t o sh ow t h at t h e dead body of t h e deceased was n ot iden t ified. 9. Mr . Rai h as also con t en ded t h at t h e Doct or m en t ion ed in t h e post m or t em r epor t t h at n o pr odu ct of con cept ion was det ect ed, wh er eas, t h e deceased was car r yin g pr egn an cy of t h r ee m on t h s, t h er efor e, t h e en t ir e post m or t em r epor t as well as iden t it y of t h e deceased becom es dou bt fu l. Dr . Pr asen jit Biswas (PW-13) in h is cr oss-exam in at ion h as adm it t ed t h at t h er e was n ot h in g t o su ggest t h at t h e deceased was pr egn an t at t h e t im e of deat h . Bu t h e added t h at h e h ad collect ed viscer a alon g wit h com plet e u t er u s for it s exam in at ion , wh ich r epor t was n ot befor e h im wh ile pr epar in g t h e post m or t em r epor t , t h er efor e, t h e post m or t em r epor t was n ot com plet e, m ean in g t h er eby t h at if t h e viscer a r epor t wou ld h ave been br ou gh t on r ecor d t h en t h e r epor t of t h e con t en t s of u t er u s wou ld h ave sh own t h e pr egn an cy an d t h en it cou ld h ave been opin ed t h at t h e deceased was car r yin g pr egn an cy. M or eover , m er ely on t h is accou n t t h e eviden ce r elat in g t o ph ysical iden t it y of t h e deceased by t h e u n cle of t h e Appellan t , Mu n n a Lal Pr asad (PW-14) can n ot be ign or ed. He h as clear ly st at ed t h at h e h ad iden t ified t h e dead body t o t h at of t h e deceased an d t h en h ad lodged a r epor t (Exh ibit -14) in Ran gpo Ch eck -post u n der t h e Kalim pon g Police St at ion . We h ave n o r eason t o disbelieve t h e t est im on y of Mu n n a Lal Pr asad, wh o is a close r elat ion of t h e Appellan t . We fin d fr om t h e r ecor ds t h at n ot a sin gle qu est ion was ask ed fr om Mu n n a Lal Pr asad an d h is en t ir e eviden ce wh ich h e deposed in exam in at ion -in -ch ief in t h e above m an n er r em ain s fu lly in t act . 10. Mr . Rai h as last ly con t en ded t h at it was a case of su icide as t h e deceased ju m ped in t o t h e r iver on h er own . Th e said ar gu m en t of Mr . Rai can n ot be accept ed in ligh t of t h e eviden ce of t h e above eye-wit n esses, wh o clear ly deposed t h at t h e deceased was cau gh t by t h e Appellan t an d t h en was for cibly t h r own by h im , over t h e r ailin g of t h e br idge wh ich was of 3 feet h eigh t , in t o t h e deep wat er of t h e r iver . Th e ver sion s of t h e eyewit n esses fr om wh om n ot h in g adver se cou ld be elicit ed in t h eir cr oss-exam in at ion s, clear ly n u llify t h e elem en t of su icide as ar gu ed by Mr . Rai. 11. For t h e for goin g r eason s we do n ot fin d an y su bst an ce in t h e Appeal. It is, accor din gly, dism issed. Approved for Report in g Internet jk : Yes/ No. : Yes/ No. Sd/ - Sd/ - Judge Chief Just ice 0 5 .0 4 .2 0 1 6 0 5 .0 4 .2 0 1 6

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Sikkim HC judgments →
LegalFirms.in Directory
Find an advocate for this matter
Dealing with a similar case? Find an advocate who handles this kind of matter on LegalFirms.in.
Find an advocate →