Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
!"
%
!
& $
'
!"#!""$
%
! &#"'"
(
)
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
*
"
! +'''"
$
!
!
! &#"'"
! &#"'"
#
!
! &#"'"
-2-
%
! &#"'"
+
!
%
! &#"'"
(
)
*
$$+
$$,
'# $'$
$
!
*
) *
) *
) *
%
'# $'$
$)
-
'!"$!$'$
! *
-3-
./0/012.3 456 708.9 /406 :./0/012 6..;02< /4. 71881=02<
3.80.76
!!
" #$%
&
#
'
(
(
&
, $- $
.
$
+
*
'
)
*
*
#)
#)
)
(
+
/
$
*
)0
./0/012.3 06 5 :.3>52.2/ 3.609.2/ 17
5990:./
06/30@/
13?53
50@4A3
. 06 5 @1180. BC
5?1@5/012
3.60902< =0/4 406 =07.
@40893.2 529 189 5<.
:53.2/6
53.2/6 529 @40893.2 53. 9.:.29.2/ 12 /4.
:./0/012.3
/4.03
80?.804119
4.
@1A26.8
/4.
:./0/012.3 @12/.296 /45/ 7586. 529 B56.8.66 @1>:8502/6
=.3. 819<.9 5<5026/ /4. :./0/012.3 529 :./0/012.3 =56
5335C.9 56 5@@A6.9 02 6.?.358 @30>0258 @56.6
@56.6
A/ 17 $$
128C $ @56.6 53. :.2902< 529 02 1/4.3 @56.6
-4-
:./0/012.3 06 5@DA0//.9
3.6:129.2/
406 B.02< /4. 6/5/. 17 5775036
/1 + 9.80B.35/.8C /5;02< 21/. 17 /4. :113
70252@058 B5@;<31A29 17 /4. :./0/012.3
/1 1?.33.5@4 /4.
139.36 17 5@DA0//58 :566.9 02 /4. @30>0258 @56.6 :3.:53.9 5
3.:13/ >5;02< 1>021A6 588.<5/0126 5<5026/ /4. :./0/012.3
.6:129.2/
713=539.9 5 3.:13/ 3.@1>>.2902< /4.
25>. 17 :./0/012.3 713 .E/.32>.2/ /1 /4. 3.6:129.2/
2 3.@.0:/ 17 6A@4 5 3.DA.6/ 3.6:129.2/
6.2/ 5 8.//.3
/1 3.6:129.2/
1 $ /1 020/05/. 5@/012 5<5026/ /4. :./0/012.3
713 .E/.32>.2/
56.9 12 /4. 6509 3.@1>>.295/0126 5
641= @5A6. 21/0@. =56 066A.9 /1 =40@4 /4. :./0/012.3 456
3.:80.9
2DA03C
=56
@129A@/.9
.E/.32>.2/ @5>. /1 B. :566.9 12
139.3
' "$ $'$
./0/012.3
06 5<<30.?.9 BC /4. 139.3 17 .E/.32>.2/ :566.9 BC
3.6:129.2/
30<4/6
1 $ =40@4 06 02 ?0185/012 17 /4. 7A295>.2/58
<A5352/..9
A29.3
126/0/A/012 17 2905
3/0@8.
"
)"*
)9*
/4.
. 5861 @12/.296 /45/ /4.3. 06 5 @8.53
?0185/012 17 /4. :302@0:8.6 17 25/A358 FA6/0@. 529 /4.
:31?060126 17
.@/012
)5* 529 )B* 17 /4.
5325/5;5
-5-
180@.
@/ " +
)4.3.0257/.3 3.7.33.9 /1 56 G/4.
@/H*
>5295/13C :31@.9A3.6 56 @12/.>:85/.9 A29.3 /4.
4.
@/ 456
21/ B..2 71881=.9
4.3.BC /4. 139.3 =40@4 06 :566.9 BC
/4. 3.6:129.2/
1 $ .E/.3202< /4. :./0/012 06 088.<58
53B0/353C 529 06 805B8. /1 B. 6./ 5609. 529 DA564.9
/
@12/.29.9
/45/
=4.2
/4.
@/
:3.6@30B.6 5 :53/0@A853 >522.3 /1 B. 71881=.9 02 FA6/07C02<
/4. .E/.32>.2/
/4. 6509 :31@.9A3. =088 45?. /1 B.
71881=.9 02 /4. 6/30@/ 6.26. 529 6:.@070@588C =4.2
)5* 529 )B* 17 /4.
.@/012
@/ @1221/.6 41= /4. .E/.32>.2/
139.3 @52 B. :566.9 529 12 =45/ 3.56126 /4. 65>. =088
45?. /1 B. 71881=.9 02 /4. 8.//.3 529 6:030/ 35/4.3 /452
>5;02<
5A/4130/0.6
1>20BA6
6/5/.>.2/
BC
/4.
3.6:129.2/
/ 06 /4. ?.4.>.2/ @12/.2/012 17 8.532.9
@1A26.8 713 :./0/012.3 /45/ /4. :31?060126 17
529 )B* 17 /4.
.@/012
)5*
@/ 45?02< 21/ B..2 71881=.9 02 /4. 6/30@/
6.26. 06 5 @8.53 ?0185/012 17 /4. >5295/13C 3.DA03.>.2/6
17 /4.
@/ " +
529 /4.3.713. /4. 139.3 17 .E/.32>.2/ 06
088.<58 53B0/353C 529 /4. 65>. 9.6.3?.6 /1 B. DA564.9
.
-6-
3.80.6 12 /4. FA9<>.2/ 17 /4.
12-B8.
:.E
@56. 17
1A3/ 02 /4.
3.:13/.9 02
02 6A::13/ 17 406 @56.
#
8.532.9
990/01258
1?.32>.2/
9?1@5/. 3.:3.6.2/02< /4. 3.6:129.2/! /5/. 6A6/5026 /4.
0>:A<2.9 139.3 @12/.2902< /45/ 2.@.6653C :31@.9A3.6 53.
71881=.9 02 /4. 8.//.3 529 6:030/ 529 /4. 3.56126 53. @8.538C
5660<2.9
4.3.713. /4.3. 06 21 ?0185/012 17 52C 17 /4.
:31@.9A358 713>580/0.6 529 /4. >5295/13C 3.DA03.>.2/6 56
@12/.>:85/.9 A29.3 /4.
1?.32>.2/
9?1@5/.
@/
2 75@/
@12/.296
8.532.9
/45/
990/01258
3.56126
53.
713/4@1>02< 02 /4. 139.3 17 .E/.32>.2/ 529 07 5/ 588 /4.
:./0/012.3 06 5<<30.?.9 12 /4. >.30/6 17 /4. >5//.3 /4.2
4. =1A89 45?. /1 @4588.2<. /4. 6509 139.3 BC 70802< 52
5::.58 56 @12/.>:85/.9 A29.3
35/4.3 /452 5::315@402< /406
4.3.713.
.@/012
17 /4.
@/
1A3/ 02 /4. =30/ FA30690@/012
4. @12/.296 /45/ /4. :3.6.2/ :./0/012 06 21/
>502/5025B8.
4. :./0/012 9.6.3?.6 /1 B. 906>066.9 529
-7-
/4. :./0/012.3 @52 5?508 /4. 5::.58 3.>.9C :31?09.9 A29.3
/4.
@/
45/ 3.DA03.6 /1 B. 6..2 02 /4. :3.6.2/ @56. 12
4529 06 =4./4.3 /4. 3.6:129.2/6 45?. 71881=.9 /4.
:31@.9A3. @12/.>:85/.9 A29.3 /4.
@/ 529 =4./4.3 /4.3.
06 52C ?0185/012 17 7A295>.2/58 30<4/6 BC /4. 3.6:129.2/
5A/4130/0.6 02 139.302< .E/.32>.2/ 5<5026/ /4. :./0/012.3
/ =1A89 B. 3.8.?52/ /1 .E/35@/ /4. :31?060126 17
)5* 529 )B* 61 5861
529 )B* 17 /4.
.@/012
& 17 /4.
@/
.@/012
.@/012
)5*
@/ 3.596 56 A29.3
!
!
$ 2
)
&
(
#
!!
!!
"
(
#)
!
.
&
&
!
!
5 6
%
&
! (
*
! )
#)
" #$%
/
)
!
#
$
)
&
!
&
!
)7
*#
#
& &
&
#
#
&
#
-8-
& &
!!
&
#
8'' 89'
# !
89''
(
#)
&
:'
;
)
(
(
&
(
!
&
*
#
)
)7
...
.@/012
"
& 17 /4.
#
%
@/ 3.596 56 A29.3
$
$
%
!
%
&'
( $*- 3
"
<
)
&
&
)
)
#
=
!
#)
(
&
'
&
&
!
&
!
)
&
&
! =
! '
. !
)
!
#
.
&
) (
#)
&
. !
#
(
)
)
#
"
&
&
.
(
. !
#)
*-
(
#
#
>
!
!
) (
#)
#)
&
&
(
&
.
!
*
&
)
! )
)
&
!
&
#$
&
&
(
!
)
-9-
#
!
"
) #
#
(
+ )
+
(
&
<
) #
#
+
)
!
'
+
)
#
(
(
(
+
#
&
)
)
&
! ! ) #
+
2 @53.7A8 :.3A658 17 /4.6. :31?060126 0/ 06 6..2
/45/ /4.3. 06 5 @8.53 >5295/. /1 /4. 5A/4130/0.6 /1 71881=
/4. 3.8.?52/ :31?060126 56 @12/.>:85/.9 A29.3
)5* 529 )B* 529
& 17 /4.
.@/0126
@/ =4.3.BC /4. 5A/4130/0.6
=1A89 45?. /1 @1>. /1 5 @8.53 1:02012 56 /1 =4C /4.
:./0/012.3 3.DA03.6 /1 B. .E/.32.9
2@. 6A@4 52 1:02012 06
713>.9 /4. 3.6:129.2/6 =1A89 45?. /1 713> 52 1:02012 56
/1 /4. =08802<2.66 17 /4. =0/2.66.6 /1 @1>. 713=539 02
:AB80@ /1 <0?. .?09.2@. 5<5026/ /4. :.36126 61A<4/ /1 B.
:31@..9.9 713 .E/.32>.2/ =40@4 06 >5295/13C
2 /4.
:3.6.2/ 3.561202< 17 /4. 0>:A<2.9 139.3 /4.3. 06 21 6A@4
@8.53 1:02012 713>.9 BC /4. 3.6:129.2/ 5A/4130/0.6 /1
.E/.32
/4.
:./0/012.3
41A<4
/4.3.
1>20BA6
6/5/.>.2/ >59. /4.3. 06 21 >5/.3058 :85@.9 12 3.@139 61
- 10 -
5861 21/402< 06 :85@.9 /1 641= /45/ B.@5A6. 17 /4. /43.5/
13 :.3@.:/012 <0?.2 /1 52C 17 /4. =0/2.66.6
/4.C 53.
5::3.4.260?. 529 /45/ /4. =0/2.66.6 53. 21/ =08802< /1
@1>. 713=539 /1 <0?. 6/5/.>.2/ 13 .?09.2@. 5<5026/ /4.
:./0/012.3
,
4.
12-B8.
:.E
1A3/ 02 /4. @56. 17
)
:535<35:4
16 + "
529 "
< 2
* 5/
456 4.89 56 71881=6
&
#!
?
*
-@*!
'
&
&
)
*
#
-@ "
'!
&
.
<
&
(
(
*
!
!
!
!
#)
>
&
!
-@*- *
&
#
-
&
&
A
.
!
!
...
-,
"
.
)
#)
&
!
(
! =
'
#
&
!
-@ ( !
.
"
'
!
&
<
(
!
/ &!
(
)
&
#
- 11 -
A (
#/
&
!
#
>
#$
!
#/
&
) !
*-
!
)
/
(
&
!
&
.
)
+
(
(
#/
( )
.
) !
#
#/
#
>
(
!
!
#
>
#
)
(
!
=
!
!
#
&
#
#
...
!
!
&
&
#
!
'
-@
&
(
=
#
#
&
#
&
( #
)
/
-
&
#
A (
(
(
!
<
) !
#
!
>
!
!
#
(
(
.
"
#
+
>
=
-@*- *
( )
#)
!
#
$
*
!
#
>
#
!
(0
29.3 /4. @03@A>6/52@.6 45?02< <12. /431A<4
/4. >5/.30586 529 /4. 0>:A<2.9 139.3 /406
1A3/ 06 17 /4.
1:02012 /45/ /4. :./0/012.3 456 >59. 1A/ 5 <119 <31A29 /1
- 12 -
@12609.3 406 @56. 75?1A35B8C 529
5> 17 /4. 1:02012 /45/
/4.
>59.
3.6:129.2/6
/41A<4
45?.
61>.
1>20BA6
6/5/.>.2/ @5221/ B. /5;.2 56 5 6:.@070@ 6/5/.>.2/ 56
@12/.>:85/.9 A29.3
.2DA03C 8.532.9
.@/012
990/01258
)B* 17 /4.
1?.32>.2/
@/ 529 12
9?1@5/. 06 21/
5B8. /1 :102/ 1A/ 52C 6A@4 >5/.3058 713/4@1>02< 02 /4.
3.:13/ 17 /4. 3.6:129.2/ 5A/4130/0.6 /1 :02:102/ 529 641=
/45/ /4. =0/2.66.6 53. 21/ @1>02< 713=539 /1 <0?.
.?09.2@. 5<5026/ /4. :./0/012.3 02 ?0.= 17 /43.5/ 13 02 ?0.=
17 /4. /43.5/ /1 /4. =0/2.66.6 =41 53. A2=08802< /1 @1>. /1
<0?. .?09.2@. /4. :./0/012.3 456 B..2 5@DA0//.9 02 6.?.358
@56.6
29.3 6A@4 @03@A>6/52@.6
406 :./0/012 06
4.
0>:A<2.9
B.5302<
:566 /4. 71881=02<
+ %
139.3
95/.9
.?.2A.
:566.9 BC 3.6:129.2/
06 4.3.BC DA564.9
1 $ ?09.
' "$ $'$
'# $'$
22.EA3.!
- 13 -
0B.3/C
3.6.3?.9
/1
/4.
3.6:129.2/
5A/4130/0.6 /1 020/05/. :31@..902<6 529 =408.
9102< 61 /4.C 45?. /1 6/30@/8C 71881= /4.
>5295/13C 3.DA03.>.2/6 56 @12/.>:85/.9
A29.3 /4.
12-B8.
@/ 529 5861 /4. FA9<>.2/ 17 /4.
:.E
1A3/ 02 /4. @56. 17
)
*
()
&
!
%
$
""
'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review