Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 125 of 2022
Date of Decision: 12.04.2023
Shri. Gagan Ch Kalita
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. S. Deb, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Ms. Z.E. Nongkynrih, GA.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
Oral:
1.
The petitioner by way of the instant writ petition, has put to
challenge an order dated 22.11.2021, whereby a request for correction of
his date of birth, in his service record from 12.04.1965 to 18.01.1969, has
been rejected by the respondent No. 3 (Superintendent of Police, West
Garo Hills).
2.
The case of the petitioner is that, he had joined service on
01.07.1987, as a Fireman and came to learn about the incorrect entry as
to his date of birth, only on 12.08.2020, which he maintains should have
been recorded in his service book as 18.01.1969, instead of 12.04.1965.
Thereafter, the petitioner had submitted a written application for change
in the date of birth along with supporting documents, namely Birth
Certificate issued on 25.03.2021, an affidavit dated 31.08.2021, and his
High School Leaving Certificate Admit Card, in support of his claim. His
request however, was rejected by the impugned order, hence the instant
writ petition.
3.
Mr. S. Deb, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that, the
rejection of the request of the petitioner is unjustified, inasmuch as, the
petitioner has produced irrefutable evidence to show that, his date of birth
is 18.01.1969, and not 12.04.1965, as recorded in his service book. The
only lapse on the part of the petitioner, he submits, is that the request for
correction of his date of birth was made at the fag end of his career, and
not within 3 (three) years from the date of superannuation, as prescribed
by SR 8 of the Meghalaya Fundamental and Subsidiary Rules, 1984. It is
submitted that, this lapse occurred due to the advent of the COVID
epidemic, which prevented the petitioner from approaching the
respondents within the time as prescribed. It is also submitted that, the
Identity Card of the petitioner shows his correct date of birth, and that he
came to learn about the discrepancy only when he received his GPF
statements for the year 2019-2020.
4.
The learned counsel has strenuously argued that, the case of the
petitioner falls under exceptional circumstances, and due consideration
should have been accorded by the respondents, while considering his
prayer. In support of his arguments, the learned counsel has placed
reliance in the case of State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors. vs. Premlal
Shrivas reported in (2011) 9 SCC 664, and submits that, in exceptional
cases, such as the case of the petitioner, change in the date of birth in the
service record, on the production of irrefutable evidence is permitted.
5.
Ms. Z.E. Nongkynrih, learned GA on behalf of the State
respondents has strongly refuted the arguments advanced by the learned
counsel for the petitioner, and has placed reliance on the affidavit filed by
the respondents. The learned GA has drawn the attention of this Court to
the service sheet of the petitioner from the date of his initial appointment,
wherein the date of birth is recorded as 12.04.1965, which has also been
signed and thumb imprinted by the petitioner. With regard to the
statement that, the writ petitioner only came to learn about the date of
birth from his GPF Account statement on 12.08.2020, she submits that
the same cannot be accepted, as the GPF Account statements are issued
annually by the Office of The Principal Accountant General, Meghalaya,
Shillong, to the petitioner. The learned GA has also referred to the fact
that, the petitioner had submitted Form No. 17 on 16.05.2002, which
deals with the details of an employee’s family, wherein he had entered
his date of birth as 12.04.1965, which was signed by him, countersigned
by the Head of the Office, and placed in the service book.
6.
The learned GA submits that, the case of the petitioner was
examined in detail by the respondents, and in fact, an inquiry was also
gone into, but however, by the application of law, the request was
rejected. Learned GA finally submits that, the writ petitioner was well
aware all along, about the entry of the date of birth in his service record
as 12.04.1965, and it cannot be accepted that, he came to learn about the
same recently, and that special consideration be given. The learned GA
in support of her submissions, has placed reliance in the case of State of
Haryana vs. Satish Kumar Mittal & Anr. reported in (2010) 9 SCC 337,
and submits that, in such matters, request for correction must be made
within the time limit prescribed, inasmuch as, if such request accepted at
the end of the service career of an employee, the same will result in
disruption in the service and benefits of other employees. She finally
submits that, the writ petition being without any merit is liable to be
dismissed.
7.
I have heard learned counsels for the parties.
8.
As noted above, the petitioner has founded his prayer on the
basis that, inspite of irrefutable evidence being produced, the respondents
did not accede to his request. An examination of the materials relied upon
by the petitioner, that is the Birth Certificate, High School Leaving
Certificate Admit Card and the affidavit, reflects that apart from the
Admit Card, the other documents are of recent origin. It is noted however
that, in the service record of the writ petitioner, at the time of entry into
service, his date of birth has clearly been recorded as 12.04.1965, to
which he had appended his signature and thumb print, which has not been
refuted. Further, the statement that, the writ petitioner came to learn of
the alleged discrepancy only from the GPF statements of 2019-2020, is
belied by the fact that, GPF statements are supplied annually to
government employees such as the petitioner. Furthermore, the writ
petitioner on 16.05.2002, as per Rule 52(1)(i) of the Meghalaya Civil
Service (Pension) Rules, 1983 (Annexure – 3 to affidavit of respondents
No. 1 and 2), had furnished the details as required in Form 17, and had
entered his date of birth as 12.04.1965, which was countersigned by the
Head of Office, the Superintendent of Police, West Garo Hills, at the
relevant point of time.
9.
From the facts, as set out above, the contention that, the writ
petitioner was unaware about the entry being recorded as 12.04.1965, in
the service record, therefore, cannot be accepted. Another aspect which
defeats the case of the petitioner is that, the request for change in the date
of birth was made on 31.08.2021, which is less than the prescribed limit
of 3(three) years for such applications before superannuation, as
mandated by SR 8 of the Meghalaya Fundamental and Subsidiary Rules,
1984, which reads as follows;
“No alteration in the date of birth of a Government servant
should be allowed except in very rare cases where a manifest
mistake has been made. Such mistake should be rectified at the
earliest opportunity in the course of periodical re-attestation of
the entries in the first page of Service Book. In no case, request
for change in the date of birth of a government servant made
on a date within three years of the date of his actual
superannuation should be entertained.”
10.
The respondents on the request of the petitioner, as it appears
from the pleadings in the writ petition and the statements on affidavit,
have actively considered the request and had even instituted an inquiry to
go into the claim of the writ petitioner, which however, was rejected by
the respondent No. 3, in view of the prohibition prescribed by the Rules.
The judgment State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors. vs. Premlal
Shrivas(supra) placed by the learned counsel for the petitioner, is of no
assistance to his case, and in fact, Para – 8 which is reproduced
hereinbelow, encapsulates the law in this regard and has a direct bearing
on the instant case.
“8.
It needs to be emphasised that in matters involving
correction of date of birth of a government servant,
particularly on the eve of his superannuation or at the
fag end of his career, the court or the tribunal has to be
circumspect, cautious and careful while issuing
direction for correction of date of birth, recorded in the
service book at the time of entry into any government
service. Unless the court or the tribunal is fully satisfied
on the basis of the irrefutable proof relating to his date
of birth and that such a claim is made in accordance
with the procedure prescribed or as per the consistent
procedure adopted by the department concerned, as the
case may be, and a real injustice has been caused to the
person concerned, the court or the tribunal should be
loath to issue a direction for correction of the service
book. Time and again this Court has expressed the view
that if a government servant makes a request for
correction of the recorded date of birth after lapse of a
long time of his induction into the service, particularly
beyond the time fixed by his employer, he cannot claim,
as a matter of right, the correction of his date of birth,
even if he has good evidence to establish that the
recorded date of birth is clearly erroneous. No court or
the tribunal can come to the aid of those who sleep over
their rights (see Union of India Vs. Harnam Singh).”
[Emphasis supplied]
11.
The judgment State of Haryana vs. Satish Kumar Mittal & Anr
(supra) placed by the respondents’ counsel need not be discussed, as it
reiterates a settled position of law.
12.
Accordingly, in view of the facts and circumstances, as
deliberated above, no case has been made out for interference by this
Court, and the writ petition stands dismissed.
13.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
12.04.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review