The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. Considering the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, and further taking into account that although the petitioner was deprived of discharging duties on the promoted post due to inaction of the respondent-State, this Court cannot lose sight of the fact that the petitioner did not actually perform the duties attached to the promoted post. As such, an equitable relief is need of the hour by balancing the burden on the public exchequer, of course, due to lapses and untimely action on the part of the authorities, this Court is of the view that if the petitioner is granted 50% of arrears of difference of pay between the post of Deputy Commissioner and the Assistant Commissioner for the period from 13.07.2011 to 31.12.2016, i.e., from the date on which his juniors were promoted till the date of his superannuation, that will meet the ends of justice. Therefore, the respondent-State is directed to calculate and pay the aforesaid arrears i.e. 50% of difference of pay between the post of Deputy Commissioner and the Assistant Commissioner from 13.07.2011 to 31.12.2016, within a period of four months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. In the event of failure to comply within the stipulated period, the entire amount shall thereafter carry interest @ 6% per annum till realization.
14. With the aforesaid observation and direction, the Writ Petition (S) is allowed in part. Sd/(Narendra Kumar Vyas) Judge Kishore / Arun Head Note Principle of ‘No Work, No Pay’ is not universally applicable, it is dependable upon facts and circumstances of each case. gsM uksV *uks odZ] uks is^ dk fl)kar loZ= ykxw ugha gksrk] ;g izR;sd izdj.k ds rF; rFkk ifjLFkfr;ksa ij fuHkZj djrk gSA
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:21380
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 10339 of 2019
Reserved On: 15.04.2026
Delivered On: 07.05.2026
G. R. Sahu S/o Late Shri Punarad Sahu Aged About 64 Years Occupation
Retired Assistant Commissioner Tribal Welfare, R/o Near Sahu Sadan, Kela
Badi, Durg Chhattisgarh, District : Durg, Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner (s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Additional Chief Secretary,
Government Of Chhattisgarh, Department Of Scheduled Caste And
Scheduled Tribal Welfare Department, Mahanadi Bhawan, Capital Complex,
Atal Nagar, Raipur District Raipur Chhattisgarh
2 - Commissioner Directorate Of Scheduled Caste And Scheduled Tribe
Development, Indravati Bhawan, Block-D, Ground Floor, Capital Complex,
Atal Nagar, Raipur District Raipur Chhattisgarh.
3 - Chhattisgarh Public Service Commission Through Secretary,
Chhattisgarh Public Service Commission, Shankar Nagar Road, Raipur
District Raipur Chhattisgarh
4 - Shri Jitendra Gupta Aged About 48 Years Occupation Service, Presently
Posted As Deputy Commissioner Office Of Commissioner, Directorate Of
Scheduled Caste And Scheduled Tribe Development, Indravati Bhawan,
Block-D, Ground Floor, Capital Complex, Raipur District Raipur Chhattisgarh.
5 - Shri A. R. Navrang Aged About 49 Years Occupation Service, Presently
Posted As Deputy Commissioner Office Of Commissioner, Directorate Of
Scheduled Caste And Scheduled Tribe Development, Indravati Bhawan,
Block-D, Ground Floor, Capital Complex, Naya Raipur District Raipur
Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondents
For Petitioner
: Ms. Shriya Jaiswal, Advocate
For
Respective : Mr. Sanjeev Pandey, Dy. Advocate General, Mr. K.G.
Respondents
Yadav, Dy. Govt. Advocate, Ms. Subhi Rusia, Ms.
Priyanka Rai, Advocates.
ARUN
KUMAR
DEWANGAN
ARUN KUMAR
DEWANGAN
Date: 2026.05.07
16:54:03 +0530
Hon'ble Shri Narendra Kumar Vyas, J.
CAV ORDER
1.
The petitioner initially filed present petition with prayer to direct the
respondents
to
promote
him
with
effect
from
the
date
of
recommendation of review DPC placing him above respondents No. 4
and 5 with arrears of salary, seniority for further promotion and Revision
of Pension.
2.
During pendency of the petition, the respondents No. 1 & 2 have
promoted the petitioner vide order dated 29.11.2019 on the post of the
Deputy Commissioner in the Scheduled Tribe and Scheduled Caste
Development Department w.e.f. 13.07.2011 notionally by applying the
principle of ‘No Work, No Pay’. Accordingly, his seniority, pay, pension
and gratuity were revised. As such, this case is now confined to the
issue whether principle of ‘No Work, No Pay’ is applicable to the present
facts of the case or not?
3.
Keeping this issue in mind, the brief facts are being considered which
are as under :-
A)
The petitioner was working as an Assistant Commissioner in the
Scheduled Tribe and Scheduled Caste Development Department and
attained the age of superannuation on 31.12.2016. As per the gradation
list of Assistant Commissioners issued on 01.04.2008, the petitioner
was placed at Serial No. 16, whereas Respondent Nos. 4 and 5 were
placed at Serial Nos. 17 and 19 respectively. However, vide order dated
13.07.2011, Respondent Nos. 4 and 5 were promoted to the post of
Deputy Commissioner, while the petitioner was denied such promotion.
B)
Prior to issuance of the said promotion order (Annexure P-2), the
petitioner had submitted representations dated 07.09.2010 and
04.02.2011 seeking consideration for promotion, but the same were not
decided. Subsequently, on 31.01.2014, the respondent-State issued an
order based on the recommendations of the Departmental Promotion
Committee dated 10.07.2012, whereby the petitioner was granted
seniority on the post of Assistant Commissioner with retrospective effect
from 07.09.2006, and his seniority was fixed above Respondent No. 4,
Shri Jitendra Gupta.
C)
On 15.07.2014, a proposal was forwarded to Respondent No. 3 for
convening a review Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) meeting
to consider the case of the petitioner and other eligible officers for
promotion to the post of Deputy Commissioner. Pursuant thereto, a
review DPC meeting was held on 20.02.2015, wherein it was
recommended that the petitioner is fit for promotion and was entitled to
be placed above Respondent Nos. 4 and 5, who were admittedly junior
to him. The petitioner thereafter submitted several representations
dated 15.07.2015, 04.08.2015, 02.09.2015, 24.09.2015, 16.10.2015,
17.11.2015, and 23.11.2015, requesting consideration of his case for
promotion.
D)
However, no action was taken which compelled the petitioner to file Writ
Petition before this Court which was registered as W.P.(S) No.175/2016
and this Court vide order dated 22/07/2016 disposed of the petition
directing the State Government to consider the claim of petitioner for
promotion and while taking decision recommendations of PSC shall also
be kept in view. In pursuance of the order passed by this Hon'ble Court
petitioner made representation along with a copy of the order on
01/08/2016, 23/08/2016, 14/09/2016 and 13/06/2016 but nothing
happened to those representations. When the respondent authorities
did not take any action despite the orders passed by the Court and the
representations of the petitioner, he filed a Contempt petition before this
Court which was registered as Contempt Petition No. 533/2016. On
11/11/2016, said petition was disposed of stating that there is no specific
time frame provided but the order reasonably construed that claim of the
petitioner shall be considered as early as possible. Still as nothing
moved, yet again, the petitioner made representations on 24/11/2016
and 26/11/2016 with the hope that he would be given promotion before
attaining the age of superannuation i.e. on 31/12/2016.
E)
About one year later, i.e. on 29/12/2017 some more officers were
promoted from the post of Assistant Commissioner to Deputy
Commissioner but no orders with regard to petitioner's promotion were
issued. He further submitted representations on 10/01/2019 and
21/01/2019 requesting that he be promoted as per recommendations of
Public Service Commission.
F)
After filing of the present petition, the petitioner was granted notional
promotion on 29.11.2019 retrospectively w.e.f. 13.07.2011 as detailed.
Now the petition is only confined to arrears of salary to the promotional
post from 13.07.2011 to 31.12.2016. Additionally, the petitioner has
prayed for Rs. 5,00,000/- as compensation towards cost of litigation and
hardship suffered by him.
4.
The State has filed its reply contending that since the petitioner has
been
given
promotion
to
the
post
of
Deputy
Commissioner
retrospectively w.e.f. 13.07.2011 and he has been provided with
consequential benefits and accordingly, his pension has also been
revised and arrears of gratuity has been paid. However, since the
promotion has been given on notional basis he is not entitled to any
arrears of salary for the said period and would pray for dismissal of the
writ petition. He would refer to judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in case of State of Haryana vs. O.P. Gupta {(1996) 7 SCC 533} and
Union of India vs. B.M. Jha {(2007) 11 SCC 632}.
5.
The Chhattisgarh Public Service Commission has filed reply contending
that they had recommended that the petitioner was fit for promotion and
above the respondent No. 4 and 5. The concerning department is
proper and necessary party to put forth its stand in the matter of
promotion, they do not have any role to play to the relief sought by the
petitioner in the matter.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that he has been
promoted notionally from 13.07.2011 whereas he was always willing to
discharge duties on the promotional post but was prevented due to
inaction on part of the respondents. Therefore, the principle of “No Work
No Pay” is not applicable in the present case, as the petitioner was kept
away from work for no fault of his own. She would further submit that
due to illegal denial of promotion, the petitioner has suffered substantial
monetary loss for the period from 13.07.2011 till 31.12.2016, apart from
severe mental harassment and prolonged litigation spanning several
years. Therefore, the petitioner is entitled for full arrears of salary and all
consequential benefits on the promotional post of Deputy Commissioner
for the period from 13.07.2011 to 31.12.2016 with an additional
compensation of Rs. 5,00,000/- towards the hardship, harassment, and
prolonged litigation suffered by him and would pray for allowing the
petition.
7.
On the other hand, learned State counsel would submit that the
grievance of the petitioner does not survive in the present form,
inasmuch as the respondents have already granted him notional
promotion to the post of Deputy Commissioner vide order dated
29.11.2019 with retrospective effect from 13.07.2011 and pursuant
thereto, all consequential service benefits have been extended to the
petitioner, including revision of pay on notional basis, re-fixation of
pension, and payment of arrears of gratuity. Thus, the grievance of the
petitioner has redressed substantially. He would further submit that
notional promotion does not entitle an employee to back wages it is a
settled principle of service jurisprudence that where promotion is
granted retrospectively on notional basis, the employee is not entitled to
arrears of salary for the period during which he did not actually
discharge duties on the promotional post. It is well settled position of law
that the purpose of grant of notional promotion is limited to fixation of
seniority, current salary and retiral benefits. The financial burden on the
State exchequer cannot be imposed in absence of actual discharge of
duties. The petitioner’s claim for compensation of Rs. 5,00,000/- is
wholly misconceived and without any legal basis. Therefore, he would
pray for dismissal of the writ petition.
8.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record with
utmost satisfaction.
9.
Undisputed facts as reflected from the records are that the petitioner
was earlier denied his seniority on the post of Assistant Commissioner
by the respondents without any rhyme and reason. From perusal of
gradation list issued by the respondent State as on 01.04.2008, it is
quite vivid that the petitioner was promoted to the post of Assistant
Commissioner on 20.02.2008 and respondent No. 4 and 5 were
promoted on 07.09.2006 as Assistant Commissioner. However, in the
gradation list, the petitioner was placed above respondents No. 4 and 5.
Thereafter, the respondent-State has conducted DPC for promotion
from the post of Assistant Commissioner to Dy. Commissioner on
25.03.2011 and respondents No. 4 and 5 have been promoted on
13.07.2011. It is also not in dispute that petitioner submitted
representation for granting him seniority w.e.f. 07.09.2006 and the State
has considered his representation and he was granted seniority w.e.f.
07.09.2006 by applying the principle of ‘No Work, No Pay’ vide order
dated 31.01.2014. It is also not in dispute that the respondent vide
memo dated 15.07.2014, has initiated proceedings for review DPC on
20.02.2015 vide Annexure P/6 wherein the petitioner was also found fit
for promotion above respondents No. 4 and 5. Despite this, he was not
granted promotion w.e.f. the date on the juniors have been promoted.
10. Only after, the intervention of this Court in writ petition and filing of
contempt petition, the respondents have initiated proceedings to redress
the grievances of the petitioner. Though, partly grievances have been
redressed, but again applying the principle of ‘No Work, No Pay’. From
the entire undisputed facts it is quite vivid that the mistake committed by
the respondents have compelled the petitioner to get fruits of promotion
and only after the intervention of the Court, the authorities have woken
up. Thus, the entire shortcoming is in the part of the respondents to
deprive the fruits of promotion to the petitioner. Therefore, this Court is
of the view that it is a fit case where the principle of “No Work, No Pay’
is not applicable but the entire denial occurs due to fault committed by
the authorities.
11. As such, the petitioner cannot be made to suffer for the fault of the
respondents. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Ramesh Kumar v.
Union of India, {(2015) 14 SCC 335} has reiterated that the doctrine of
"no work no pay" has no application where the employee was willing
and eligible to discharge higher duties but was prevented from doing so
due to illegal action of the employer. Hon’ble the Supreme Court has
held that readiness to work coupled with wrongful exclusion is sufficient
to attract entitlement to monetary benefits. Relevant extract of the same
is as under:
"13. We are conscious that even in the absence of statutory
provision, normal rule is "no work no pay". In appropriate cases,
a court of law may take into account all the facts in their entirety
and pass an appropriate order in consonance with law. The
principle of "no work no pay" would not be attracted where the
respondents were in fault in not considering the case of the
appellant for promotion and not allowing the appellant to work on
a post of Naib Subedar carrying higher pay scale."
12. Again, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of North Delhi Municipal
Corporation v. Ram Naresh Sharma {2021 (173) SCC 642} has
observed in paragraph 21 as under:21. …...But, there is sufficient evidence on record to suggest that
the respondent-doctor through several representations sought to
be re- appointed but it was the employer who created
impediments and did not allow the respondent to re-join his
duties in hospitals. In such circumstances, the principle of `No
Work, No Pay' cannot be raised by the employers, as it is they
who had obstructed the doctor from discharging his service. For
support we may cite Dayanand Chakrawarthy v. State of Uttar
Pradesh, (2013) 7 SCC 595 where 5 of 7 this Court speaking
through Justice S. J. Mukhpadhyaya rightly held that:
"48. ... If an employee is prevented by the employer from
performing his duties, the employee cannot be blamed for having
not worked, and the principle of "no pay no work" shall not be
applicable to such employee."
13. Considering the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, and
further taking into account that although the petitioner was deprived of
discharging duties on the promoted post due to inaction of the
respondent-State, this Court cannot lose sight of the fact that the
petitioner did not actually perform the duties attached to the promoted
post. As such, an equitable relief is need of the hour by balancing the
burden on the public exchequer, of course, due to lapses and untimely
action on the part of the authorities, this Court is of the view that if the
petitioner is granted 50% of arrears of difference of pay between the
post of Deputy Commissioner and the Assistant Commissioner for the
period from 13.07.2011 to 31.12.2016, i.e., from the date on which his
juniors were promoted till the date of his superannuation, that will meet
the ends of justice. Therefore, the respondent-State is directed to
calculate and pay the aforesaid arrears i.e. 50% of difference of pay
between the post of Deputy Commissioner and the Assistant
Commissioner from 13.07.2011 to 31.12.2016, within a period of four
months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. In the event of
failure to comply within the stipulated period, the entire amount shall
thereafter carry interest @ 6% per annum till realization.
14. With the aforesaid observation and direction, the Writ Petition (S) is
allowed in part.
Sd/(Narendra Kumar Vyas)
Judge
Kishore / Arun
Head Note
Principle of ‘No Work, No Pay’ is not universally applicable, it is dependable
upon facts and circumstances of each case.
gsM uksV
*uks odZ] uks is^ dk fl)kar loZ= ykxw ugha gksrk] ;g izR;sd izdj.k ds rF; rFkk ifjLFkfr;ksa
ij fuHkZj djrk gSA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review