The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. With regard to the reliance placed on Ext. P5 verdict passed by another Division Bench of this Court, giving a positive direction to pay the petitioner therein (Smt. M. K. Omanakutty- former 'Karanma' employee) all the pay and allowances as payable to the regular employees of the Board, it is very much relevant to note that no declaration is made by the Division Bench therein, that all the 'Karanma' employees after 06/08/1981 are entitled to get the pay and allowances as payable to the regular employees of the Board. On the other hand, the case of the petitioner therein was that her family was having 'Karanma' rights: that she and her sister Saraswathiamma were serving as 'Karanma' employees but were being treated as 'part time Kazhakam' though discharging duties as 'full time Kazhakam' and that the Board by proceedings dated 12/12/85 had allowed the petitioner and her sister to have the pay scale and allowances of a regular employee w.e.f. 01/01/1986, on condition that they gave up the 'Karanma' right of the family. The said petitioner was not given the above benefit, despite granting similar benefit to her sister Saraswathiamma. The petitioner therein came to know about the Board order only much later, where upon, the relinquishment of the 'Karanma' right was executed and given by the 'Karnavan' of the family, pursuant to which, the Administrative Officer and Assistant Devasw…
13. This Court had also occasion to go through the common order dated 08/08/2001 passed by a Division Bench of this Court, referring to the general decision stated as taken by the Devaswom Board to continue 'Karanma' service, whereby it was observed and directed that those who were already appointed would be given emoluments to which they were entitled to and those who had applied for appointment would be appointed as per 'Karanma Rules’. Quite incidentally, it is also relevant to note that the above order, which is subsequent to Ext. P5 verdict dated 07/08/2000, was also passed by the very same Division Bench, who passed Ext. P5 judgment and as such, this Court cannot but repel the contentions put forth from the part of the petitioners that the Division Bench of this Court, as per Ext. P5 verdict, has chosen to provide the pay and allowances as payable to the regular employees of the Board, to the 'Karanma' employee as well. This being the position, there is absolutely no conflict between the orders/verdicts passed by the different Division Benches of this Court as referred to herein before. Since the WP(C) NO. 9549 OF 2024 2025:KER:26795 conditions of service differ, there is no question of violation of the principle of Equal pay for Equal work and there is no discrimination or arbitrariness to attract any infringement of Art. 14 as well. No case is made out calling for any inter…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP(C) NO. 9549 OF 2024
2025:KER:26795
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE D. K. SINGH
WEDNESDAY, THE 26TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 5TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 9549 OF 2024
PETITIONER:
G.MADHUSOODANAN NAMBOOTHIRI,
AGED 56 YEARS
S/O GOVINDAN NAMBOOTHIRI, SOWPARNIKA, KALLANPALLIL ILLLAM,
MUTTOM PO, HARIPPAD.ALAPPUZHA, PIN - 690511
BY ADV R.RANJANIE
RESPONDENTS:
TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD,
DEVASWOM HEAD QUARTERS, NANDANCODE, KAVADIAR P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM- , REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, PIN 695003
THE DEVASWOM COMMISSIONER,
TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD, DEVASWOM HEAD QUARTERS , OFFICE
OF THE DEVASWOM COMMISSIONER, NANDANCODE, KAVADIAR P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-, PIN - 695003
THE ASSISTANT DEVASWOM COMMISSIONER, (GENERAL
ADMINISTRATION),
TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD, OFFICE OF DEPUTY DEVASWOM
COMMISSIONER, NANDANCODE, KAVADIAR P.O,THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-,
PIN - 695003
ASSISTANT DEVSWOM COMMISSIONER,
TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD,OFFICE OF THE ASSISTANT DEVSWOM
COMMISSIONER, HARIPPAD GROUP, RAILWAY STATION ROAD,HARIPAD
ALAPPUZHA DIST,, PIN - 690514
SUB GROUP OFFICER,
EVOOR SUB GROUP, TRAVANCORE DEWSWOM BOARD, HARIPPAD, PIN 690507
BY ADVS.
C.K. PAVITHRAN
SRI.C.K.PAVITHRAN, SC, TDB(SC-2440)
THIS
WRIT
PETITION
(CIVIL)
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
ADMISSION
26.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
WP(C) NO. 9549 OF 2024
2025:KER:26795
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 26th day of March, 2025
The petitioner who was giving services as Santhi in
Petty Muttom Mahadeva Temple coming under Muttom
Devaswom, Evoor Sub group since 01.01.1988 had
retired on 15.02.2023. This writ petition has been filed
by the petitioner for a writ of mandamus commanding the
respondents to disburse all retirement benefits to the
petitioner for his services as Santhi in Muttom Mahadeva
temple, including arrears of Dearness Allowance, prompt
payment of monthly pension, arrears of pension due from
15.03.2023, gratuity payable to the petitioner, leave
surrender amount and all other allowances legally
eligible to be paid as retirement benefits to the petitioner.
2. Muttom Mahadeva temple is one of the temples
under the Travancore Devaswom Board where Santhies
are appointed as Karanma hereditary Santhi.
WP(C) NO. 9549 OF 2024
2025:KER:26795
3. After the enactment of the Travancore Cochin
Hindu Religious Institution Act 1950, the terms and
conditions of the employment of the employees in the
Temples/Devaswom
coming
under
the
Travancore
Devaswom Board are governed by the relevant Rules
framed by the Travancore Devaswom Board under the
Act. The Travancore Devaswom Board is a statutory body
created under Section 28 of the Travancore Cochin
Hindu Religious Institution Act, and the Board is fully
empowered to have absolute control over all the
employees of Temples and Devaswom coming under the
Board including Karanma employees and Santhies. The
Santhikars have two classifications ie, karanma santhi
and Non-Karanma Santhies. Karanma Santhies are those
who hold Santhi service hereditarily by virtue of special
rights vested in their family and Non-Karanma Santhies
hold the service not hereditarily, but by appointment. The
appointment of Santhikars is made from the selection list
duly prepared by the Devaswom Board, and the selection
WP(C) NO. 9549 OF 2024
2025:KER:26795
is made on the basis of the recruitment Rules framed by
the Board whereas Karanma Santhies do not face any
selection process and they get appointments to perform
Santhi service hereditarily by virtue of special rights
vested in their family.
4. It is not in dispute that the petitioner was
appointed by virtue of special rights vested in his family
as Santhikars and therefore, he is a Karanma Santhi. The
petitioner is not a regular selected Santhikar. Therefore,
the petitioner cannot claim the benefit of the service
conditions as of the regular employees of the Devaswom
Board including the employees of the temple where the
petitioner was performing Santhi services and retired on
15.02.2023.
5. The service conditions of the Karanma employees
are governed by a separate set of Rules framed by the
Board under Section 28 of the Travancore Cochin Hindu
Religious Institution Act. Rule 2 of the said Act provides
that no Karanma right will be recognized in respect of
WP(C) NO. 9549 OF 2024
2025:KER:26795
any post unless the holders are able to produce original
or attested copies of orders issued by the competent
authority definitely granting or recognizing Karanma
right. Though the Travancore Devaswom Board would
have control over the Karanma employees including the
Santhies, however their service conditions are separate
than the regular employees.
6. Smt.Neenu
Pavithran, representing Sri.C.K
Pavithran, learned Standing Counsel for the respondents
submits that as Karanma Santhies are appointed because
of the special rights conferred in the family, therefore,
they are not entitled for pension etc, inasmuch as the son
of the petitioner being born in the family got the right of
appointment as Santhi in Temple and the under the Rules
framed for Karanma employees, no pension is provided.
7. I have considered the submissions advanced on
behalf of the learned counsel for the petitioner and the
respondents. The issue involved in this writ petition is no
longer Res-integra inasmuch as the learned Single Bench
WP(C) NO. 9549 OF 2024
2025:KER:26795
of this Court in R.Manohara Warrier & others v. State
of Kerala and another [2009(2) KHC 928] has
unequivocally held that the Karanma claiming pay
pension and other service benefits as payable to the
regular employees of the Board would not be admissible
to them. Paragraphs 11,12 and 13 of the said judgment
of the learned Single Judge are extracted hereunder:
“11. As observed already, the Division Bench of this
Court, while passing the verdict in 1988 KHC 82: 1988
(1) KLT 16 (Travancore Devaswom Board v. Chellappan
Pillai) had also occasion to advert to the order of the
Secretary of the Board ROC 2901/87 Misc. dated
26/08/87, prescribing the 'Scale of Pay' of 'Karanma'
employees in 'Major' and 'Minor' Devaswoms
(paragraph 5). It was also placing reliance there on,
that the finding was rendered, sustaining the action
pursued by the Devaswom Board fixing the conditions of
service of the concerned employee, who was a
'Karanma' employee earlier, as to his age of
superannuation. The above order explicitly referring to
the prescription of the 'Scale of Pay' of the 'Karanma'
employee in Minor and Major Devaswoms i.e over and
above the Rules and Orders prescribing the scales of pay
of other employees of the Board has very well been
sustained and relied on by the Division Bench,
upholding the Rule making power of the Board and the
consequential steps taken thereunder. In other words,
even though the actual issue involved in the above case
was with regard to the 'age of superannuation' of the
'Karanma' employee, the authority of the Board and the
orders passed fixing the conditions of service including
prescription of Pay Scale separately to the 'Karanma'
WP(C) NO. 9549 OF 2024
2025:KER:26795
employee of the Major and Minor Devaswoms, stand
approved by the Division Bench. As such, the above
decision actually stands against the case put forth by the
petitioners, claiming the pay, pension and other service
benefits as payable to the regular employees of the
Board and the understanding of the petitioners to the
contrary is only wrong and misconceived.
12. With regard to the reliance placed on Ext. P5
verdict passed by another Division Bench of this Court,
giving a positive direction to pay the petitioner therein
(Smt. M. K. Omanakutty- former 'Karanma' employee)
all the pay and allowances as payable to the regular
employees of the Board, it is very much relevant to note
that no declaration is made by the Division Bench
therein, that all the 'Karanma' employees after
06/08/1981 are entitled to get the pay and allowances
as payable to the regular employees of the Board. On
the other hand, the case of the petitioner therein was
that her family was having 'Karanma' rights: that she
and her sister Saraswathiamma were serving as
'Karanma' employees but were being treated as 'part
time Kazhakam' though discharging duties as 'full time
Kazhakam' and that the Board by proceedings dated
12/12/85 had allowed the petitioner and her sister to
have the pay scale and allowances of a regular employee
w.e.f. 01/01/1986, on condition that they gave up the
'Karanma' right of the family. The said petitioner was not
given the above benefit, despite granting similar benefit
to her sister Saraswathiamma. The petitioner therein
came to know about the Board order only much later,
where upon, the relinquishment of the 'Karanma' right
was executed and given by the 'Karnavan' of the family,
pursuant to which, the Administrative Officer and
Assistant Devaswom Commissioner recommended the
claim. Instead of the posting the petitioner as a ‘full
time departmental Kazhkam’, the Devaswom Board
passed an order, granting the departs of pay and
allowances payable to 'full time Karaıma-Kazhakam',
which hence was sought to be intercepted by filing OP
17715 of 1993. This was allowed by the Division Bench
WP(C) NO. 9549 OF 2024
2025:KER:26795
as per Ext. P5 verdict, directing the respondent
Devaswom Board to grant all the pay and allowances as
payable to the 'Departmental Kazhakam' to the
petitioner therein. In view of the very admitted separate
existence of full time 'Departmental Kazhakam' and full
time 'Karanma-Kazhakam', attached with different pay
scale and allowances as discernible from paragraph 4 of
Ext. P5 itself, there is absolutely no merit in the
contention raised by the petitioners that all the
'Karanma' employees after 06/08/1981 are entitled to
have similar pay and allowances as payable to the
regular departmental employees of the Devaswom
Board. More so, in view of the existence of the separate
orders issued by the Secretary of the Board providing
for the scale of pay of 'Karanma' employees in 'Major'
and 'Minor' Devaswoms as referred to in paragraph 5 of
the verdict rendered by the earlier Division Bench in
1988 KHC 82: 1988 (1) KLT 16 (Travancore Devaswom
Board v. Chellappan Pillai).
13. This Court had also occasion to go through the
common order dated 08/08/2001 passed by a Division
Bench of this Court, referring to the general decision
stated as taken by the Devaswom Board to continue
'Karanma' service, whereby it was observed and
directed that those who were already appointed would
be given emoluments to which they were entitled to and
those who had applied for appointment would be
appointed as per 'Karanma Rules’. Quite incidentally, it
is also relevant to note that the above order, which is
subsequent to Ext. P5 verdict dated 07/08/2000, was
also passed by the very same Division Bench, who
passed Ext. P5 judgment and as such, this Court cannot
but repel the contentions put forth from the part of the
petitioners that the Division Bench of this Court, as per
Ext. P5 verdict, has chosen to provide the pay and
allowances as payable to the regular employees of the
Board, to the 'Karanma' employee as well. This being the
position, there is absolutely no conflict between the
orders/verdicts passed by the different Division Benches
of this Court as referred to herein before. Since the
WP(C) NO. 9549 OF 2024
2025:KER:26795
conditions of service differ, there is no question of
violation of the principle of Equal pay for Equal work
and there is no discrimination or arbitrariness to attract
any infringement of Art. 14 as well. No case is made out
calling for any interference.
The Writ Petition fails and it is dismissed
accordingly.”
8. The said judgment of the learned Single Judge is
upheld by the Division Bench of this Court in W.A
No.2446/2009 dated 22.11.2014.
In view of the law laid down in the aforesaid decision
as well as the relevant provisions of the Statute and the
Rules made thereunder, the petitioner cannot claim the
right to pension inasmuch as his service conditions are
different than the regular employees of the Devaswom
Board. Thus, I find this writ petition has no merit and
substance, which is hereby dismissed.
Sd/D. K. SINGH
AP
JUDGE
WP(C) NO. 9549 OF 2024
2025:KER:26795
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 9549/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
THE TRUE COPY OF THE SERVICE DETAILS OF THE
PETITIONER AS APPROVED BY THE 5TH RESPONDENT
Exhibit P2
THE TRUE COPY OF THE STATEMENT OF FIXATION OF PAY
OF THE PETITIONER IN THE REVISED SCALE, AS
APPROVED BY THE RESPONDENTS 4 AND 5
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION OF SUB GROUP
DEVASWOM OFFICE, EVOOR, DATED 8.10.1943(ME 1.3119)
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION DATED
18.10.1943(ME 22.02.119) ISSUED BY THE ASSISTANT
DEVASWOM COMMISSIONER, MAVELIKKARA GROUP,
Exhibit P5
THE COPY OF THE LETTER ISSUED BY THE SUB GROUP
OFFICER TO GOVINDAN NAMBOOTHIRI DATED 20.12.1987
Exhibit P6
THE TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 05.11.1992
ISSUED BY NARAYANA NAMBOOTHIRI TO THE DEVASWOM
COMMISSIONER OF MAVELIKKARA GROUP OF TRAVANCORE
DEVASWOM BOARD
Exhibit P7
THE TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION DATED
14.2.2023 ISSUED BY THE SECOND RESPONDENT
Exhibit P8
THE TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION DATED
15.6.2023 ISSUED BY THE ASSISTANT DEVASWOM AUDIT
OFFICER, AMBALAPUZHA, TO THE 4 TH RESPONDENT
Exhibit P9
THE TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGES OF THE
APPLICATION OF THE PETITIONER FOR PENSION AND
COMMUTATION, ADDRESSED TO THE SECOND RESPONDENT,
Exhibit P10
THE TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT DATED 9.11.2023,
ISSUED BY THE 5TH RESPONDENT TO THE 4 TH
RESPONDENT,
Exhibit P11
THE TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION ISSUED BY THE
5 TH RESPONDENT TO THE 4 TH RESPONDENT, DATED NIL
Exhibit P12
THE TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 10.11.2022 IN
W.P.(C)NO. 28180/2022
WP(C) NO. 9549 OF 2024
2025:KER:26795
Exhibit P13
THE TRUE COPY OF THE QUESTIONNAIRE DATED
15.10.2020 SUBMITTED BEFORE THE GROUP
COMMISSIONER OF HARIPAD GROUP OF THE 1ST
RESPONDENT, ALONG WITH THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION
Exhibit P14
THE TRUE COPY OF THE ANSWER RECEIVED FOR EXT.P13
APPLICATION FROM THE PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER,
ALONG WITH THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION
Exhibit P15
THE TRUE COPY OF THE QUESTIONNAIRE DATED NIL
SUBMITTED BEFORE THE 4TH RESPONDENT, ALONG WITH
THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION
Exhibit P16
THE TRUE COPY OF THE ANSWER DATED 5.3.2021
RECEIVED FOR EXT.P15 APPLICATION FROM THE PUBLIC
INFORMATION OFFICER, ALONG WITH THE ENGLISH
TRANSLATION
Exhibit P17
THE TRUE COPY OF THE QUESTIONNAIRE DATED NIL
SUBMITTED BEFORE THE 4TH RESPONDENT, ALONG WITH
THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION
Exhibit P18
THE TRUE COPY OF THE ANSWER DATED 18.2.2020
RECEIVED FOR EXT.P17 APPLICATION FROM THE PUBLIC
INFORMATION OFFICER, ALONG WITH THE ENGLISH
TRANSLATION
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R1(a)
True copy of the proceedings No. Roe
10816/22/Mis-1 dated 02.02.23
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review