Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 338s ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
N,IONDAY. THE FIFTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE K. SUJANA
APPEAL SUIT NO: 2806 OF 2004
Appeal filed under sectton 96 of CPC agarnst the Judgment and Decree dated
30-09-2002 in o. S No 465 0f 1 994 0n the file of the 1 st Additronal Sentor ctvil
Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B. Nagar.
Between:
1. Gampana Garrdarah. S/o Shivaiah Rep by GPA G Darshan s/o G. Gandaiah
(1'' Appellant) rDied per I Rs 5 to B)
2. Gampana Anlarah, S/o Shivaiah, 65 years, died) per Lrs Appellants- 3 & 4
Both are R/o Akulamarlaram Village, Kandkoor [\4andal, R-R. District.
3 Smt G. Anasuyamma W/o. Late Gumpana Anlaiah, aged abqut 65 years,
Occ. Housewife, R/o Akulamailaram Village, Kandkoor Mandal, R R. District
Gurnpana Narasimha S/o Late G. Anjaiah, ag-ed about 34 years, Occ'
Agrrculture, Rio Akulamarlaram Village, Kandkoor lvlandal, R R. District'
Appel lants 3 and 4 are brought on record as LRs of deceased 2nd
Appel lant as per Court Order dated 23-9-08 in ASMP-2009/08.
,..APPELLANTS
5 Gumpanalangalah, S/o Gumpana Gandiah, Aged about 65 Years. Occ'
Agrrculture,
6. Gumpana Darshan, S/o Gumpana Gandiah, Aged about 60 Years' Occ'
Agriculture.
7. Gumpana Pandiah, S/o. Gumpana Gandaiah' Aged about 58 Years, Occ:
Agricualture.
8 Gumpana Venkata Ramulu, S/o. Gumpana Gandaiah, Aged aboaut 48 Years,
Occ. Agriculture.
(All are R/o. Akulamyalaram Village, Kandukuru Mandal, Ranga Reddy
District, Telangana State.)
PETITIONERS/PROPOSED APPELLANT-5 TO 8.
,7
Appellant Nos. 5 to 8 are brought on record ; s LRs of deceased
Appellant No.1, as per Court Order dated. 07.O1.i 022 vide A.No.4 of
2019 in A.S.No. 2806 of 2004.
AND
1 Garnpana Lachaiah, S/o Yenkaiah, 76 years (Died per L is-RR-6 to 9)
2. Garrpana V(rnkata Ramulu, 46 years (Died per LRs Flll 10 t,t 13)
3 Garrpana Shrvanandr-r, S/o Narsaiah 38 years
4. Gorge Acchaiah. S/o Laxmaiah 53 years
5. Gorrra Srrsailam, S/o Jangaiah 38 years
all are AgricultLrrrst and resrdents of Akulamailaranr Vi lrr 1e, KandukLrr I\,4andal
R R District.
(Respondents 4 and 5 are not necessary parties to tlrls /\ppeal as they were
set ex parte in sLlit)
...RESPONDENTS
6. Gur-npana Satyanarayana @ Babu, S/o Gumpana L:rr:l arah. Aged about 55
Years, Occ. Agriculture, R/o Akulamyalaram Vrllage Kandukurti [/landa],
Ranga Reddy District, Telangana State
7 Gurnpana Sunita, Wo. Lte G Bhaskar (S/o. G Lacl ; rah) agecl about 45
Years, Occ. House Wife, Occ. Agriculture, U/ l./andal. Ranga
Akulamyalaram Village, Kandukuru Reddy District, Tel:r I rr:na State
B Gumpana Yeshwanth, S/o. Late G. Bhaskar (S/o. G z charah), Aged about
L
20 years, Occ Student, R/o Akulamyalaram Village l(anciLrkurLr lr/andal
Ranga Reddy District, Telangana State
9. Gumpana Tarun, S/o. Late G. Bhaskar (S/o g. Laclrr:h) Aged about 18
years, Occ: Student, R/o. Akulamyalaram Village Kandr- <-rru tr.4antJarl, Ranga
Reddy Distrrct. Telangana State.
....RESPONDENTS/LRS. R1, RESPC I DENTS NO.6 TO 9.
10. Gupana Shantamma Wo. Late G. Narsaiah, aged a: rut 60 years, Occ.
House Wife. R/o. Akulamyalaram Village. Kandukuru l\l; rdal, Ranga Reddy
Di.,tr rct. Telanga na State.
11. Gumpana Naveen S/o. Late G. Narsaiah, aged abc; L,t 2S years, Occ
Agriculture, R/o. Akulamyalaram Village, Randukur Nlanda. Ranga
ReddyDistrict, Telangana State.
12.Alvalu Manasa, Wo. Srikanth, aged aboaut 22 yrars, t) ;,: Housewife, R/o
Pittalagudem Village, Kotur Mandal, Ranga ReddyDistric. T elangana State.
Wo
13. NedunuruSwathi,
Sai, aged about 20 years, Cc ; Houser,vrfe, R/o.
H No.1 0/5/12, Kameswara Colony, Saroornagar IVlarr, erl, Ranga Reddy
District
RESPONDENTS/LRS. R-2/RESPO,IDENTS
1O TO 13
Respondent Nos. 6 to 13 are brought on record LRs of deceased
Respondent Nos. 1 & 2, as per Court Order dated 07.01.2022, vide
l.A.No.4 ot 2021 in A.S.No. 2806 of 2004)
Counsel for the Appellants: Sri M.V. Durga Prasad
Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 6: Sri G. Ramchander Rao
Counsel for the Respondent No. 10: Sri Krishna Kishore Kovvuri
Counsel for the Respondent No. 11: Sri Syam Sunder Rao
Counsel for the Respondent No. 3 and 12: Sri G. Venkateshwarlu
Counsel for the Respondent No. 13: Sri K. Arvind Kumar
The Court delivered the following: JUDGMENT
-,
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF 3'- )LANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE K. SI JANA
APPEAL SUIT No.28O6 OF 2OO4
DATE: O5.O1.2026
Between :
Ciarnpana Candaiah
(dicd per L.Rs. 5 ro 8) &,7 othcrs
Appctir r ts/ l)laintilfs
And
Gampana Lachaiah (died per L.Rs.6 to 9) & l2 ot.r';-s
... Responder I / Dclendant
: JUDGMENT:
Challenging the judgment and decree dertt r 30.O9.2002
passed in O-S.No.465 of 1994 by the learned I Aclrl t onal Senior
Civil Judge, Ranga Reddy Dislrict at L.B. Nagzr. Lhc presenl
appeal suit is filed.
2.
Thc brief facts of the case arc that the plrr rtifls hled a
sr-rit seeking partition and separate possession c f agriculttrral
lands measuring a total extent of Ac.45.18 gunt: r situated in
Panjaguda village, Kandukur Mandal, Ranga R< r cly District.
-
These lands originally belongcd to tu,o brothers, Gumpana
Chennaiah and Gumpana Ycnkaiah, each holding a hall share.
After Chennaizrh died issuelcss, his share was succeeded by his
wido',v, Narsamma, who resided u.ith and was maintained by the
plaintiffs until her dearh irr rhe -vcar 1985. The plaintiffs
claimed that Narsarnma executed a rcgistcred Witl dated
03.07.I984 bequeathing hcr entire share to them. They
contended that, despite thc Will and subsequent mutation of
their names in the revcnue rccords, the defendants had relused
to partition the land, nccessitating thc suit for partition and
separate posscssion.
3.
On the other hand, defcndant Nos.1 to 3, w,ho were legal
heirs of Yenkaiah and Narsamma, contcstcd the suit, claiming
that the plaintilfs had no legal right to the share of Narsamma.
They contended that there had been a family arrangcment on
02.06.1984 in which Narsamma's share was equally divided
between the plaintiffs and dcfendant Nos.1 to 3, and that the
arrangement had been acted upon. They alleged that thc Will
produced by the plaintiffs was a forged and fabricated
document, and that the plaintiffs had not proved its execuLion
properly. The defendants also asserted that they were in
exclusive possession of the lands and had pcr t:ct('d titlc by
advcrsc possr:ssion. Furthermorc, they quesli r red the locus
starndi of the plaintil'[s, the correctness of the ,- ]ut-l lce [raid,
rr r r, I ra ised i l
4.
r issut rf limitat ion
,
.
Basing on the :rbove pleadings, the trial Ct r rt lrzrmed hve
issues and on behalf of thc plaintiffs i.e., PWs and 2 u'ere
cxamined and trx.Al to A18 are marked- DW; I and 2 arc
cxamined and Exs.B I to B I 1 u'ere marked o,r rehirll of the
cleli:ndants
5.
After examining the evidence , the trial Cor r I, uide order
dakd 3O.09.20O2, dccreed the suit holding th:rt ti're plaintiffs
l-rad failed to provc thc execution ar-rd validity of tlr( ',Vill (trx.A7),
as the Lestatrix, Narsamma, was an illiterate anrl rgcd womzln,
and the evidence did not shou. that the contenLs ri':;-e read over
and explarned to her in a language she underst r t,l. The trial
Court found that the Wil[ was suspicious ar ( unreliabte.
Hou,ever, the trial Court also found that the fami11 r.rangemcnl
(Ex. B I 1) had not been acted upon
or proved rir .I[rciently to
confer exclusive rights on the defendants. It was further held
that, in the absence of a valid Will or enforr:, ablc family
settlement, thc plaintiffs and defendants were en t I ('d ro equal
i'
sharcs in the estate ol Chennaiah, inherited by Narsamma.
Accordingly, the trial Court decreed the suit by granting a
preliminary dccrce, holding that the p1:rintiffs and delendant
Nos.1 to 3 u,er-e cach cntitled to a onc lourth share in the share
of Chcnnaiah, and defcndant Nos. 1 to 3 wcrc also entitled to
half share in the portion inhcritcd from Yenkaiah. The trial
Court rejccted the plea of limitation and aclverse possession and
dirccted partition and scparate possession as prayed for, with
each party bearing thcir own costs. Aggrieved therebl'', the
appellants/ plaintiffs filed the prcserlt Appeal Suit.
6.
Heard Sri M.V. Durga Prasad, learncd counsel appearing
on behalf of the appetlants, Sri G.Ramchander Rao, Iearned
counsel appearing for respondeDt Nos.6 to 9, Sri Krishna
Kishore Kowouri, learned counsel appearing for respondent
No.1O, Sri S.Shyam Sunder Rao, learned counsel appearing for
respondent No. I 1, Sri G.Venkateshlvarlu, lcarned counsel
appearing for respondent Nos.3 and 12 and Sri K.Aravind
Kumar, learned Counsel appearing for respondent No.13.
.
Learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the
judgment and decree passed by the trial Court rvas contrary to
the record and the probabilities of the case and that the trial
ii'"
-
Court had failed to properly appreciate t re oral and
documentan, evidence placcd on record and I'i ct r.--arched an
erroneous conclusion that the appellants hzrd : rt established
their claim. FIc flrrthcr submitted that the plain, '1-s hrrd clearl-r'
provcd their cntitlcment to thc share of late Nar : i rnm.r tl-rrough
a registercri Will cleccl, marked as Ex.A7. Acc: -ding to him,
Ex.A7 rl,as 4s11, provcd through the testimonl,ol l'W2, u.ho u,as
one of the .rttcsting u'itnesses to the Will. Despit: this, the tnal
Court rcjectr:d thr: Will solel-v- on the ground th:rt r he testatnr,
bcing illiterate and unfamiliar with English, .: r rld not have
exccuted a Will in English and that this r r rsoning t'as
unfortnclcd, pa rticr.rlarl5. whcn the Will was impl: nented upon
the dcal h o[ Narsamma and the name of the itr; tell:tnts u,ere
rn uL:iLed in t l-re revcnrre records accordingly.
8.
Learnt'd counscl for the appellants conLolr llrd Lhat lhe
documents produced by thc rcspondents thems: r'es revealed
that the sharc of Narsamma was in the pos;ession and
enjoyment o1' the appcllants, and following he r de I .h, t lre sarne
q,as duly mutated in their favour. He pointe<l ,ut that the
respondents had taken contradictory stands rep rrding tlicir
claim over the share of Narsamma, at one stage clai nrng to have
purchased it, and at another stagc, asserting a family
settlement under Ex.B I i.
He emphasized that Ex.B 1 1 was
nevcr produccd in earlier procecdings nor was it submitted to
thc rcvenue authorities for mutation, therebl. raising doubts
about its authenticity and e nforceabilit]-. He lurther concended
that thc trial Court failed to take note of the incoDsistencies in
the evidence ol DW 1, u'hose testimony \\'as allegedly contrary to
the documentary record and, according to the le:rrned counsel,
indicative of deliberate falsehood. Thercfore, he praved the
Court to set aside the order of the trial Court bv allou'ing this
appeal suit.
9.
On the other hand, learned courtsel for the respondents
submirtcd that the prcsent suit hlcd by the plaintiffs for
partiLion u,as not maintainable, as the partition among the three
brothers, Shivaiah, Chennaiah, and Latchaiah, had already
taken place and that the real dispute !\ras only regarding the
entitlcment to the share of late Chennaiah, and since the
plaintiffs were claiming title based on a Will (Ex.A7), they ought
to have filed a suit for declaration or injunction, rather than one
for partition. He further submitted that Will Ex.A7 was
surrounded by suspicious circumstances and that plaintiff No.2
had earlier hled O.P.No.69 of 1968 claiming t() xr the adopted
son of Chcnnaiah, ,"r'hich rvas dismissed. I-: rrned counsel
emphasizeri thal thc plaintilfs hacl also i,. evio(rsly filed
C).S.No.13!t of I984 asainst Narsamma (the testirt ix ol rhe Wilt),
u'hich unclcu-ninccl Lheir curren[ claim under r - : Will ancl he
highlightecl scveriLl dclects in the Will. He fur t rer submitted
that Ex.A7 con[ainec] no sctredule, no survey nl t-rbers, and no
mention of cxtr:nl ol land. Hc argued that the Wrl r.as ,"vritten in
trr'rqlish, brrt t here \\'as no evidence that its ( ont('nts $.ere
explaincd to N.rrsamma in 'lelugu, though she u e s an illitcrate
markswoma n ancl tl'rat both plaintiffs, who s1 re the main
benel-rciaries undcr the Will, clid not enter the l,itncss box,
which warrantcd an adverse infcrence against th,t I
.
10. Learnr:d counscl for the respondents reft:rred to
inconsistencies in
t
he evidence. pW 1 admir t :,1 that he
purchascd tlle stamp papers and did not know th: rlate or time
of execution. PW2, the attesting witness, did ;t rt know thc
language in ri'l-rich thc Will u,as typed and adnl I cd that the
advocate hact dictated it.
Furthermore, the Wil. showed tti,o
conflicting ages for thc testatrix, 6O and 70 years, uhich raiscd
further doubts. He also pointed out that Ex.A8, t re mutation
record, wrongl]r referred to a Will dated 25.06.1984, l'hereas
Ex.A7 bore the date O3.O7.1984. He further contended that the
Will g'as nei,er properly' proved, and referred to authoritative
judgmcnts u lterc Courts had hcld that in cascs o[ suspicious
circumstances, the onlrs lies heavi[5' on the propouncicr to
remo\re all doubts. In support of his submissious, he relied
upon thc judgments in the case of Sivakoti Dasarandharam
and others v. sivakoti Yoganandam and othersl, Addepalli
Venkata Laxmi v. Ayinampudi Narasimha Rao and others2
and Bandaru Manikyala Rao and others v. Kedari Srinivasa
Rao and otherss, which cmphasized the importancc of attesting
u.itnesses being examincd, cxplanation of contents to illiterate
testators, and tl-re necessify of the propounder entering the
u'itness box. Thereforc, he prayed the Court to dismiss the
Appeal Suit.
The points Lhat arise for consideration in this appeal are
I
Whether the plaintiffs are entit.led to a sharc in
the suit schedule property for partition ald
sepa,rate possession?
I AIR 1996 AP 273
, AIR 1994 AP 72
3 202016) ALD 184
1l
Whether the suit filed by the plaintiffs is I arrerl
bl' lin-ritation on the qround that they we; r rut o[
posscssion of the suit schcdulc propertvl)
[11
\\'het her thc .luclgment :rnd decree of I I (
triill
Court requires ary interfcrence?
Point Nos.i to iii :
12.
Upon considering the sllbmissions madc I . bor I'r par-tics,
it is observecl thzrt the plainti[[s have hled tl-r - pre.sent suit
seeking partiti()n erncl separatc posscssion of tl-( iuit sche dule
Iands. Thev conLend that thc plaintiffs are rc:r. brorlters and
that the suir s<;hedule lancls constitute joint propertl4 of
Gumpana Chcr-rnaiah and Gumpana Yenkaiah, he father of
defendant No. I , eacl'r holding an equal half shar:
It is stated
that Gumpana Cl-rennaiah cliccl issueless apl)- ,ximzrtely 2r
years ago, arld his sharc devolved upon I i; wrfe, lale
Narsamma. Tl-rc plaintiffs' claim that since CL t nnaiah died
without any legal heirs, both the plaintiffs and t I : defendants
are entitled to equal sharcs in the suit schedule troperty. On
the other hand, the defendanls argue that disputes betu,een the
parties are longstanding and referred to O.P. Nc. 59 of 1968
Iiled by the second plaintiff before the II AdditioruL Judge, City
Civil Court, Hyderabad, seeking a declaration the t he was the
adopted son ol the late Chennaiah. Horvever, thc said pctition
was dismissed
13. Subscqucntly, in 1978, the flrst defendant and the father
of dcfendants 2 and 3 filcd O.S. No. 258 of 1978 before the
DisLrict Munsif, IbrahirnpaLnam, seeking a decrce of perpetual
injunctior-r zrgainst the plaintiffs, Narsamma (wife of Chennaiah),
zrnd othcrs. [n that surt, iL was asserted that during his lifetime,
Chennaiah had executcd an agreement ol sale in favour of the
I'irst delcndant and thc lather ol defendants 2 and 3, and aftcr
his demise, his wife Narsamma also executed a similar
agreemcn t in tlrrir lavour.
14. Dtrring the pendency of the said suit, with thc
intervention and advice of well rvishers and village elders, all the
parties cntered into a family arrangement. As per this
arrangement, Narsamma's share u.as equally divided among the
plaintiffs and dclendants I to 3, and the arrangement was acted
upon b,v all parties. However, the plaintiffs, allegedly with an
intention to usurp the share of defendants, hled O.S. No. 139 of
1984 before the District Munsif, Ibrahimpatnam. In that suit,
the plaintiffs allegedly hled a written statement purportedly
signed by Narsamma, which the defendants claim was forged.
The suit u,as not pressed against the father ol r efendant No.1
and thc fathcr of defer-rdants 2 and 3, and a decr: : was obtained
solely zrgainst Narsarnmar- Aggrieved by the s I ne, defendant
No. 1 ar-rd thc lathcr ol defendants 2 and 3 filer \.S. No. 19 oi
1985 beforc the Adciitional Distlict .-[udge, Ran:1 r .r:dclv Dis[ricr.
While clisposing of thc appeal, the Court observr r that tlte suit
was one [or injr-rnction sin-rplicitor, arnd thc r t.crtre pa sse d
therein would be binding only on [he thirc responrlent.
Consequent.l1', the
plaintifls' claim of or, rtrrship over
Narsamma's share u,as held to bc without mcrit. Ifurtherntore,
the Will allegedly cxecuted by Narsamma was forr I I to be forged
and fabricated- It was thus concluded that Narsrr I rna r:easecl to
be the owner ol'propcrtv in vicu,of the lamily arr,l: lemcnt.
15. Even othcrwisc, rhe plaintilfs and defendarris L trr 3, being
CIass-II legal heirs, arc entitled to equal shares ir lhe property
left behind bl Narsamma. As per thc family arrir rqernent, the
defendants arr: cntitled to Ac.17.19 guntas of 1and in
Narsamma's properly situated in Sur-vey Nos. 24, ')5,29, and
30. There is no dispute regarding the relationshi , among the
parties. Gumpana Shivaiah, Chennaiah, and Yenk.r ah u'ere real
brothers. Plaintiffs 1 and 2 are the sons of Shivaiat . Chennaiah
died issueless, and defendant No.1 and the father c . delendants
2 and 3 are the sons o[ Yenkaiah. There is also no dispute
rcgarding the properties of their respective fathers in
Meerkhanpet and Panjaguda villzrges. Thesc properties u'ere
partitionecl, with the lands at Mccrkhanpet falling to the share
ol the plaintiffs'fat[-rer, and the lands at Panjaguda falling to the
sharc o[ Chennaiah arrd Ycnkaiah. Chennaiah died leaving
bchind lris wifc Narsamr.na as his sole legal heir. Accordirtg [o
the plaintiffs, Narsamma cxecuLed a registercd Will deed dated
03.07.198,1 in their favour, bequcathing all the landcd property
tl-rat t-rad fallen to her l'rusband's share atrd was succcedecl by
her. 81'r,irtue ol this Wiii (trx.A-7), the plaintiffs claim ownership
of half o[ the suit schcdule lands. It is further contended that
during the lifetimc of Ctrcnnaiah and Yenkaiah, thc suit lands
were nol partitioned b1 rnetes:rnd bounds. Therefore, basecl on
the Will deed (Ex-A.7), thc plaintiffs assert entitlement to a half
share in the propertics at Meerkhanpet village. However, the
defendants dispute the validity of Wi1l, alleging it
to bc a
fabricated document. Thcy argue that the Will is written in
English, whereas Narsamma was illiterate, as was the attesting
witness, who also did not know trnglish. Consequently, the Will
was not duly proved by the plaintiffs before the trial Court.
16. Going through the said contention, troueh F)x.A.7
registered Will deed is in English which u.r r exccuted bv
Narsamma on 03.07.1984 bcqueathing her. rnovable and
irlmovable properties in favor-rr of plaintiffs, thal i . not a grcund
to disbclieve the registcred Will deed executed ;- he.r arrrl the
said Will deed is proved by examining thc attesro L\r..2. llcre
illiteracl, is not a ground to clisbr:lieve the Will dr.. 1 exccurcd bv
Narsamma. In view of the judgment of Hon,ble ii rpre mc Court
in Metpalli Lasum Bai (Since deadt and others V Metapalli
Muthaiah (D) by LRs.+, u,hercrr.r it was held as u r I rr:
"9.
The Will is a registcred documcnt. Thc rr: cnrlirrrL
Muthaiah in his evidencc, admittcd thc srgriri res as
appearing on the said WiU (lixt. ,A1) to be that J t:i fa rer.
i.e., M. Rajanna. The Will disrributed the properties ,: <lefi,.rcd
proportions betiveen the plain tif[-l_asum Bai, .l , :ldarrr
Muthaiah an_d Rajamma (rvidorved daughter of M. I Ljanrr;r).
There is ample matenal on record to est;Llish that Nl ,,1rr,,,o
anticipateri that the relations beLrveen plaintiff Lasu:r 3ii and
defendant Muthaiah lvere no[ .u.,g..riul and that . , try, ,n
order to avoid futurc conflicts, nJ dlvlaea his pr-o,r: t e's lrr
way of a lamily settlement and bcqueathed a sharc t I .reol
Lo
plaintiff-Lasum tsai, rvhile leaving the major share ,,. ,,s
i.e., the defendant Muthaiah. The distribution rl ",,u
the
properties, as per the family settlement (regarding !\,iU rl1
or al
evidence rr,as led), and the registercd WitI is al"mr.s ir
ttre
same proportions. The Wi[, is a registered document
i r I thus
-ll.tre
there is a presumption regarding genuineness the .,,, f
trial Court accepted the execution;f the Will basccl rr.r
tire
evidence led before it. As the Will is a registered clocu,ne
iq
tlre
burden would tie on the party who Jisputed its c. ;re.,,."
thereof, rvho would be defendart Muthaiah in this ,:r se,
ro
establish that it was not executed in the manner
,,t. fi ,r.
that there n ere suspicious circumstarces which
"" nr.u e
same doubtful. However, the defendant_Muthaiah ii ttLe
tirs
the
signatures
as
appearing
I
r
the
:d9.."..,.
registered .ad_mitted
Will to be those of his father, M. -ia.lann-a. I . also
4 2025 SCC
Online SC 1488
admitted the fact that the plaintiff Lasum Bai was rn
possesston of 6 acres and 16 guntas of land, which fell into
her share as per the Will. In this background, the trial Court
$,as right in holding that M. Rajanna made a fair distribution
of his tangiblc assets amongst hrs legal heirs by executing the
will clated 2.+ h .rull, 1974 and so ztlso the oral famill'
Seltlement. We are o[ the vic\l- thal the er ii]cnce ar.ailable on
record fortilles the existence ancl pcrsuasive nature oI the oral
family settlernent u,hich is countenanced l)\ the facfunr oI the
posscssion of the suit schedule propcrties includirlg the
disputed propert],, rlhicir rvas adn)ittedl\ !!ith the plaintiffLasum Bai and subscqucntlv tlle l)urchascr i.e., Janardhan
Rcdd!'.
10. 'lhc genuincr.ress oI l]rc Will is also bc,r ond doubl because
ir not onlv coufers the right and titlc over a part ol thc land
owned by the Testator, M. Rajanna to thc plaitrtif[- Lasu m Bai,
but it also grarlts a lion's share of the l)ropertJ to the
defcndant MLrthaiah. Had it becn the intcntron of M Rajanna
ro deprive the defendant Muthniah of tlrc land or i[ the Will
had becn manipulated, then tlte tlelenrlan t - M uthaiah could
har e bcen lclt out colrplct(:l,r- frorr1 gainirtg altr bencfils under
the Will."
17. The defendants relied on Exs.B.1 to B.1 1. Ex.B.1 is the
copy of written statemcnt filcd by plaintilf in O.S-No 258 of
1978, Exs.B.2 to 8.9 are certified copies of pahanies for the vear
1984-85 Lo 1991-92, u'ht:rein, in pattedar and possessory
column the namc of Narsamma and Chennaiah and defendants
1 to 3 arc recorded. Ex.B.1O is the true copy of pahani for the
year Tggg-2o00 and Ex,B. i 1 is the family arrangement dated
02.06. 1980 between plaintiff and defendants and Dw.2 is the
scribe of Ex.B.1 1. Ex.B.1 1 is executed on a white paper in
which it is stated that Narsamma is having Ac.22.36 guntas of
land in the suit schedule lands towards her share and plaintiffs,
i
defendants 1 to 3 are cntitled to take half sh r rr each in her
share. But the same was not filed in O.S.No.I iB ol 19?-g lor
implementarion and the suit u,as dismissecl for il lault. As the
Will deed w:rs executed after exccution of allegc,-l I 1x.8.11. ir-r the
year 1984, it cannot be said that Ex.tj.1 I cont,,r to rhc errd of
clefendants. Irurther contention of the delendarr is that rhcre
is no scheduic of property mentioncd in the Will ,l .rtd, therr.forc,
Lhe same cannot be considered. Going tl.rro rgh the saicl
contention, the Will deed is executed by i,1 rrsa rnma lor
undivided joinr family propertv stating that hcr. s larr: is to be
given to the plaintiffs family. When the propr:rrr s undiviclcd
share of executants, there is no question of mentrr,: ing schcdule
o[ property in the Will deed. Thercfore, thcre is l
for.ce in i.he
said contention. It is also further submitted that: tatrL]r pltpcrs
are purchased in the name of pw. 1, but he failec . , idcntily the
signatures of his father, whereas it is not;
srrspicious
circumstance to disprove the Will. Will is a registe - rl document
and attestor lvas also examined by the plaintiffs rL rd t hcrc are
no such suspicious circumstances as alleged by th : clefcndant s,
are proved to disbelieve the Will. Further the writtc -i statement
hled by the defendants, shows that they are relyir
1 on a MOU
which was not acted upon. Further with regarc to rhe Will
deed, except stating that it is a fabricating document, no such
suspicious circumstances n,as pleacled in the written statement_
ln view of the same, it can be said that appellants herein proved
the Will deed. As such, rhe appellanLs/plaintiffs:rrc entitled for
the share of late Narsamrna_ Hence, thc judgmcnt of the trial
Court is liable to be set aside. Accordingh,, point Nos. (r) to (iii)
are answered.
IN THE RESULT, thc Appeal Suit is allowed serring aside
thc judgment and decrcc dated 30.09.2O02 passed
1n
O.S.No.465 of 1994 by thc learncd I Addirional Senior Civil
Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.ts
Nagar,
Hlderabad. No
costs
Miscellaneous applications, if any pending, sl-rall stand
closed.
SD/- K.SHY
HI
JOINT RE
TRAR
//TRUE COPY'
ION OFFICER
To,
The 1st Additional S enior Ctvil Judge, Ranga Redd
(with records, if any)
istrict at L. B. Nagar
One CC to Sri M.V. Durga prasad, Senior Advocate
J
One CC to Sri G. Rama Chander Rao, Advocate
tOpUCl
One CC to Sri Krishna Kishore Kovvuri, Advocate
[OpUC]
One CC to Sri Syam Sunder Rao, Advocate
tr
One CC to Sri G. Venkateshwarlu, Advocate
[OpUC]
7. One CC to Sri Arvind Kumar Katta, Advocate
[OpUC]
,'lpya
Two CD Copies
[OpUC]
l
I]
tOpUCl
;i
I
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0510112026
\
--:::::=:\
/'
,a2-- . .i i'.r 1l:
\
(
I
JUDGMENT+DECREE
AS.No.2806 of 2004
ALLOWING THE
APPEAL SUIT
WITHOUT COSTS
(
v9
l
"'l
$1
t\t rs
-ll
't:
.t!
/
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
IVONDAY, THE FIFTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE K. SUJANA
APPEAL SUIT NO: 2806 OF 2004
Between:
1 Ga.mpana Gandarah, S/o Shivaiah Rep. by GPA G. Darshan s/o G. Gandaiah
(
l'' Appellant) (Dred per LRs 5 to 8)
2 Gampana An;aiah. S/o Shrvaiah, 65 years, died) per Lrs Appellants- 3 & 4
Both are R/o Akulamailaram Vrllage, Kandkoor tr,4andal, R R. Distnct.
3 Smt. G. Anasuyamma Wo Late Gumpana Anjaiah, aged about 65 years.
Occ Housewife, Rio. Akulamarlaram Village, Kandkoor Mandal, R.R. District
4. Gumpana Narasimha S/o Late G Anjaiah, aged about 34 years, Occ
Agriculture, R/o Akulamailaram Village, Kandkoor lrlandal, R. R- District.
Appellants 3 and 4 are brought on record as LRs of deceased 2nd
Appellant as per Court Order dated 23-9-08 in ASMP-2009/08.
,.APPELLANTS
5. GumpanaJangalah. S/o Gumpana Gandiah. Aged about 65 Years, Occ
Agriculture,
6 Gumpana Darshan, S/o. Gumpana Gandiah, Aged about 60 Years, Occ.
Agriculture
7 Gumpana Pandiah. S/o. Gumpana Gandaiah, Aged about 58 Years, Occ.
Agricualture.
8. Gumpana Venkata Ramulu, S/o. Gumpana Gandaiah, Aged aboaut 48 Years,
Occ. Agriculture.
(All are R/o. Akulamyalaram Village, Kandukuru [\/andal, Ranga Reddy
District, Telangana State.)
PETITIONERS/PROPOSED APPELLANT-5 TO 8.
Appellant Nos.5 to 8 are brought on record as LRs of deceased
Appellant No.1, as per Court Order dated. 07.O1.2022 vide l.A.No.4 of
20'19 in A.S.No. 2806 of 2004.
AND
1 Gampana Lachaiah S/o Yenkaiah, 76 years (Died per LRs-RR-6 to 9)
2. Gampana Venkata Ramulu,46 years (Died per LRs R: 10 to 13)
3. Gampana Shivananadu, S/o Narsaiah, 38 years
4 Gorge Acchaiah, S/o Laxmaiah, 53 years
5. Goura Srisailam. S/o Jangarah, 3B years
all are AgricultLrrist and resrdents of Akulamailaram V : 1e, Kandr-rkur lt/landal,
R R. Drstrict
(Respondents 4 and 5 are not necessary parties to ti' Aplteal as they were
set ex-parte in su it)
-..RESPONDENTS
6. Gumpana Satyanarayana @ Babu, S/o. GLrmpana La: r,arah, Aged about 55
Years, Occ Aqnculture. R/o Akulamyalaram Villal: Kandukuru IVandal,
Ranga Reddy Distrct, Telangana State.
7. Gumpana Sunita Wo Lte G Bhaskar (S/o. G. Lacr rrah), aged about 45
Years, Occ House Wrfe. Occ Agriculture, Fl I tVandal, Ranga
Akulamyalaranr Village. Kandukuru Reddy District, Te : r 3ana State
8. Gumpana Yeshwanth, S/o Late G Bhaskar (S/o G rr:haiah),,Aged about
20 years, Occ Student. R/o Akulamyalaram Villarlr: Kandukuru l\,4andaj,
Ranga Reddy Distrrct, Telangana State.
9. Gumpana Tarun, Sio Late G. Bhaskar (S/o. g. Lar:l i rah) Aged about 18
years, Occ: Student, R/o Akulamyalaram Village, Kartrl kuru [/andal, Ranga
Reddy District, Telangana State
..RESPONDENTS/ LRS. R1 , RESP() ,IDENTS NO.6 TO 9
10 Gupana Shantanrrra W/o. Late G. Narsarah, aged irl out 60 Years, Occ.
House Wife, R/o Akulamyalaram Village, Kandukuru i/ rndal, Ranga Reddy
Drstrict, Telangana State
1 1-
Gumpana Naveen S/o. Late G. Narsaiah, aged ab i I tt 25 Years, Occ.
Agriculture, R/0. Akulamyalaram Village, Kanduk I u lvlandal, Ranga
ReddyDistrict, Teiangana State.
12.Alvalu Manasa, W/o. Srikanth, aged aboaut 22 Yrars, ( cc Housewrfe, R/o
Pittalagudem Vrllage, Kotur lVlandal, Ranga ReddyDistn( I felangana State
Wo. Sai, aged about 20 Years O .c l lousewrfe, R/o
H.No.'10/5/-12, Kameswara Colony, Saroornagar IVlar 1al, Ranga Reddy
District.
13. NedunuruSwathi,
RESPONDENTS/ LRS. R.2/RESP( NDENTS 1O TO 13.
Respondent Nos. 6 to 13 are brought on recorri LRs of deceased
Respondent Nos. 1 & 2, as per Court Order dat: I 07.01 .2022, vide
l.A.No.4 of 2021 in A.S.No. 2806 of 2004)
Appeal filed under section 96 of CPC against the Judgment and Decree dated
30-09-2002 in O.S No 465 of 1994 on the file of the 1st Additional Senior Civil
Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B. Nagar.
This appeal coming on for hearing and upon perusing the grounds of appeal, the
Judgment and Decree and the material papers tn the petttton and upon hearrng the
arguments of Sri N,4.V. Durga Prasad, Senior Advocate for the Appellants, Sri G.
Ramchander Rao. Advocate for the Respondent Nos 6, Sri Krishna Kishore Kovvurr,
Advocaie for the Respondent No 10, Sri Syam Sunder Rao, Advocate for the
Respondent No.1'l , Sri G. Venkateshwarlu, Advocate for the Respondent Nos. 3 and
'12 and Sri Arvind Kumar Katta, Advocate for the Respondent No.13.
This Court doth Order and Decree as follows
.1
. That the Appeal be and hereby is allowed setting aside the judgment and
decree dated 30.09.2002 passed in O.S.No. 465 of 1994 by the learned
I
Additional Senior Civil Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L B Nagar, Hyderabad.
2. Ihat there shall be no order as to costs in this appeal.
SD/- P.CH.NAGABHUSHAMBA
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The '1st Additional Senior Crvil Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B. Nagar
2. Two CD Copies
VIVPSL
&
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0510112026
DECREE
AS.No.2806 of 2004
ALLOWING THE
APPEAL SUIT
WITHOUT COSTS
)
P
r,L
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review