Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Uploaded on 20.02.2026
CJ Court
Case : RP No. 12/2026 in
LPA No. 131/2024
Food Corporation of India and others
….. Appellant/Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. M. K. Bhardwaj, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. A. H. Bhat, Adv.
vs
.…. Respondent(s)
Sushila Gupta and others
Through: Mr. Sunil Sethi, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Paras Gupta, Adv.
Coram:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
ORDER
16.02.2026
CM No. 706/2026
1.
This is an application seeking condonation of delay of 59 days in filing the
review petition against the judgment dated 15.10.2025 passed by this Court.
2.
Notice. Notice waived by Mr. Paras Gupta, learned counsel representing
respondents. He submits that he has no objection in case delay in filing the
review petition is condoned.
3.
For the reasons set out in the application, which is duly supported by an
affidavit, the same is allowed. Consequently, the delay of 59 days in filing
the review petition is condoned.
4.
Application stands disposed of.
5.
Main Appeal is taken on board.
RP No. 12/2026
1.
By way of the instant petition, the petitioner seeks a review of the judgment
dated 15.10.2025 rendered by this Court in LPA No. 131/2024, primarily on
the following grounds:
A. Because this Hon'ble Court in the Judgment dt. 15.10.2025 has erred
in holding that only 23 Kanals and 5 Marlas was allotted to FCI after
the land acquisition in the year 1976. In fact, a perusal of the letter dt.
20.1.1977 shows that possession of a total area of 44 Kanals and 5
Marlas was handed over to FCI by the authorities after the land
acquisition. This was also clarified in the affidavit dt. 12.12.2023
filed by the Appellants. It is submitted that the finding that only 23
Kanals and 5 marlas was allotted to FCI amounts to an error apparent
on the face of the record and is liable to be reviewed. In fact, in the
letter dt. 20.1.1977 two sets of land acquired are mentioned, the first
set totaling at 20 Kanals and 16 Marlas and the second set totaling at
23 Kanals and 13 Marlas totaling at 44 Kanals and 5 Marlas. This
was also clarified by the Appellants through the affidavit filed on
12.12.2023.
B. Because this Hon'ble Court erred in upholding the Judgment of the
Writ Court and in not noticing that the Respondents who claim to
have purchased the land in the year 1992 through a registered sale
deed dt. 23.10.1992 official translation of which was filed by them
shows that neither are the boundaries of the land purchased by them
mentioned in the sale deed nor is there any indication as to the Khasra
number of the land allegedly purchased by them. Even the extent of
the land purchased has not been mentioned in the sale deed and the
alleged sale deed seems to be a sham document created only to raise
false claims against FCI. Relying on the said sham document for
allowing the Writ Petition, it is submitted, amounts to an error
apparent on the face of the record and the Judgment dismissing the
LPA is liable to be reviewed for this reason.
C. Because the Judgment of this Hon'ble Court is vitiated due to an error
apparent on the face of the record in upholding the claim of forcible
occupation of the land by FCI in the absence of any allegations as to
how the land was forcibly occupied by FCI in the year 2000 and in
the absence of any contemporary evidence supporting the allegations
in terms of any complaint lodged with any independent authority or
any FIR lodged or any protest made by the Respondents. In case there
had been any such incident of forcible occupation, the time and place
and the date on which it would have taken place would be known to
the Respondents and their failure to give any particulars falsifies their
entire stand more particularly when they have changed the year of
alleged forcible occupation from 1993 to 2000.
D. Because the Judgment is also vitiated due to an error that Court not
considered the affidavit dt. 12.12.2023 filed by FCI stating that the
boundary wall constructed in the year 1978-79 has remained
RP No. 12/2026
unaltered except for repairs and maintenance done periodically.
Without any change in the boundary wall there can be no question of
any further encroachment of land by FCI. This Hon'ble Court failed
to notice that there is no description in the Writ Petition as to how
forcible occupation of the land was done by FCI without altering its
boundary wall and there are no details provided regarding the alleged
encroachment and there is also no independent evidence
corroborating the allegations.
E. Because the Appellant has now been able to recover the old
documents from its files pertaining to the period which shows that
after handing over of the acquired land FCI had taken on lease land
from the Railways on which the Railway siding and godowns has
been constructed for which it was paying license fees to the
Railways.
F. Because the Appellant has now been able to recover documents
pertaining to the construction of the godowns by FCI which shows
that the godowns and buildings were constructed in the years 1978
(I0000MT), 1 983 (6680MT) and 1985 (5000MT) much before the
land was purchased by the predecessor in interest of the Respondents
in the year 1992 and no construction has been done after the year
1985. Hence the finding given by the Writ Court and upheld by this
Hon'ble Court that FCI had constructed godowns in the year 2000
encroaching upon the land belonging to the Respondents amounts to
an error apparent on the face of the record and liable to be reviewed.
G. Because this Hon'ble Court erred to consider the fact the Respondents
who claim to have purchased the land in the year 1992 could not have
claimed for return of land which was never in their ownership prior to
that date and their entire case has been built up on the basis of false
and unsubstantiated allegations about FCI forcibly occupying the
land either in the year 1993 or in the year 2000 which is falsified due
to absence of any independent corroboration of the same.
H. Because as submitted hereinabove, the land in question was handed
over by the State Government after acquisition and the FCI had
constructed its boundary wall as per the boundaries demarcated in the
map and the boundary wall remains intact even today. It is quite
possible that the State Government while handing over possession of
the land in the year 1977 may have included additional land which
could explain why additional land was found in the survey in the
Khasra No. 169/M. Even assuming without admitting this to be true,
the Respondent not being the owners of the land in the year 1976 are
not entitled to claim either the return of the land or to claim
compensation for the same having allegedly purchased the same in
the year 1992. However, even this allegation seems to be false
because the sale deed in their favour is bereft of particulars like area)
boundary description, and extent of land purchased.
I. Because this Hon'ble Court erred to notice that the Judgment in the
Vidhya Devi case is based on the admission by the State Government
in that case regarding the illegal occupation of the land and hence the
case did not involve any disputed questions of fact unlike in the
present case wherein the title and the allegations regarding forcible
RP No. 12/2026
occupation of land are all disputed questions of fact which will have
to be proved by adducing evidence of the parties.
J. Because this Hon'ble Court also erred to notice that in the Vidhya
Devi case the Hon'ble Supreme Court had after finding that the land
was illegally takeover by the State had directed award of
compensation under the Land Acquisition Act, 1892 which was in
force at the time the illegal occupation took place while in the present
case for alleged encroachment in the year1993/2000 this Hon'ble
Court has upheld the direction for proceeding under the Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Act, 2013. In fact, in the present case the Writ
Petition was filed in the year 2004 and same was disposed of only
on28.3.2024. Had there been no delay in disposal of the case the 2013
Act would not have been in force. The Appellants are being
prejudiced due to the delay of the Court in disposal of the Writ.”
2.
Mr. Bhardawaj, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant, has submitted that
this Court, while rendering the judgment sought to be reviewed, has not taken
note of the fact that land measuring 1 kanal and 10 marlas comprising survey
No. 169 situated at village Channi Himmat Jammu was transferred to
petitioners. This court has dealt with this issue in detail in para-16 of the
judgment, after taking note of report of revenue Authorities reproduced in
para-11 of the judgment. This contention of the learned senior counsel is misconceived. No other ground was urged by him before this court.
3.
Be that as it may, even in the ground-A of the petition, it is stated by the
petitioners that this Court has erred in holding that only 23 kanals and 5
marlas was allotted to the Food Corporation of India after the land
acquisition in the year 1976, whereas a perusal of the letter dated 20.01.1977
shows that the possession of 44 kanals and 5 marlas of land was handed over
to Food Corporation of India by the authorities after the land acquisition. So
far as this contention of the petitioners is concerned, this Court in para 9 of
the judgment has observed that “to set the record straight, the stand of
the appellants, as it is discernible from their response in the writ
RP No. 12/2026
petition, is that land measuring 23 kanals 13 marlas comprising various
survey numbers, including survey No. 169 min, measuring 1 kanal and 10
marlas situated at village Channi Himmat, was transferred to the appellants
in the year, 1977-78”. The findings of this Court were limited to the land in
Village Channi Himmat. Since the subject matter of the LPA pertained solely
to Channi Himmat, this Court dealt only with the land situated at Channi
Himmat and not Channi Rama.
4.
As for the petitioners' other contention that the godowns were constructed
prior to 1992 when the land was purchased by the predecessor-in-interest of
respondents and that the property was improperly defined in the sale deed,
these do not constitute valid grounds for a review of the judgment. In
essence, the petitioners are seeking to re-agitate a controversy that has
already been adjudicated and settled by this Court in the judgment dated
15.10.2025.
5.
The issue as to whether this Court has correctly interpreted the stand of either
of the parties cannot be a subject matter of review. The scope of review is
very limited in nature, and it cannot be extended to the extent of rehearing
the issues, already considered and decided by the Court. Even if it is assumed
that the view taken by this Court is not correct, still it cannot be a ground for
review. The power of review can be exercised for the correction of an error
apparent on the face of record but not to substitute a view. Such power can be
exercised within the limits specified in the statute governing the exercise of
such power. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India in “Malleeswari v. K.
Suguna and Another”, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1927, has observed:
RP No. 12/2026
15.2 Review is not to be confused with appellate powers, which may
enable an appellate court to correct all manner of errors committed by
the subordinate court.
15.3 In exercise of the jurisdiction under Order 47 Rule 1 of CPC, it is
not permissible for an erroneous decision to be reheard and corrected.
A review petition, it must be remembered, has a limited purpose and
cannot be allowed to be an appeal in disguise.
15.4 The power of review can be exercised for the correction of a
mistake, but not to substitute a view. Such powers can be
exercised within the limits specified in the statute governing the
exercise of power.
15.5 The review court does not sit in appeal over its own order. A
rehearing of the matter is impermissible. It constitutes an exception to
the general rule that once a judgment is signed or pronounced, it
should not be altered. Hence, it is invoked only to prevent a
miscarriage of justice or to correct grave and palpable errors.
16. To wit, through a review application, an apparent error of fact or
law is intimated to the court, but no extra reasoning is undertaken to
explain the said error. The intimation of error at the first blush enables
the court to correct apparent errors instead of the higher court
correcting such errors. At both the above stages, detailed reasoning is
not warranted.
17. Having noticed the distinction between the power of review and
appellate power, we restate the power and scope of review
jurisdiction. Review grounds are summed up as follows:
17.1 The ground of discovery of new and important matter or
evidence is a ground available if it is demonstrated that, despite the
exercise of due diligence, this evidence was not within their
knowledge or could not be produced by the party at the time, the
original decree or order was passed.
17.2 Mistake or error apparent on the face of the record may be
invoked if there is something more than a mere error, and it must
be the one which is manifest on the face of the record. Such an
error is a patent error and not a mere wrong decision. An error
which has to be established by a long-drawn process of reasoning
on points where there may conceivably be two opinions can hardly
be said to be an error apparent on the face of the record.
17.3 Lastly, the phrase „for any other sufficient reason‟ means a
reason that is sufficient on grounds at least analogous to those
specified in the other two categories.
(emphasis added)
RP No. 12/2026
6.
For what has been discussed hereinabove, we do not find that the petitioners
have been able to make out any case for review of the judgment dated
15.10.2025 rendered by this Court in LPA No. 131/2024. The review petition
is, accordingly, dismissed.
(RAJNESH OSWAL)
JUDGE
(ARUN PALLI)
CHIEF JUSTICE
JAMMU:
16.02.2026
Rakesh PS
Whether the judgment is speaking:
Whether the judgment is reportable:
Yes/No
Yes/No
Rakesh Kumar
2026.02.20 13:15
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Jammu
RP No. 12/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review