Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
"
!
$
%
"#
&
&
%
' ! ' (
)*
!'
)
+
!
" #
"
!
"
"
# "
SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
# "
$
%
&
'
()(
()(
$
%
&
"
'
"
&
'
)
*
&
'
-2-
!
"
( !+ ! !( &
+ ! !('
! &,'&--'& '
*)(
!)
! !
#
"
"
/
".
.
"
0-1 234-4-56 -1 7-839 :693;
,= 403 234-4-563;1 ><<:139
;-@3
:693;
3<4-56 !)
,;3A-4=
D403
>;<54-<
! !
! ! !( ;3?-143;39 ,= 403
58-<3
75; 403 57736<3 2:6-10>,83
0>;>4-=>
! ! EF >69
=>=>
>60-4> ! !
C75;
3<4-56 ! &,'&--'& ' 57
:,14>6<31
<4
*)( C75;
<4EF 2;313648= 2369-6? 56 403 7-83 57
-14;-<4 >69
>1>A>B>8=>6> -6
!
:;>8
) 57
>69 ! 75; ?;>64 57 ,>-8 -6
;:?1 >69 1=<054;52-<
,;3A-4= D403
99-4-56>8
+ ! !( 9>439
>1>A>B>8=>6>
3<4-56
311-561
:9?3
-9>;
1-44-6? >4
5 ( !+ ! !(
03 7><4:>8 @>4;-G 57 403 <>13 -1 40>4
! ! !( >4 >,5:4 !
2 @ 56 403 ,>1-1 57 <;39-,83
-3-
-675;@>4-56
:, 6123<45; 57
>1A>B>8=>6>
:;>8
58-<3 >69 0-1 43>@
-643;<32439 > H0-43 <585:; ">;:4-
H-74 <>; ,3>;-6?
5"
+(
3?
(
)* >4 5A3; ,;-9?3 56
-?0H>= ;5>9 H-40-6 403 8-@-41 57
>I310H>; A-88>?3
>69 >22;3036939 403 234-4-563;1 >69 13-J39 ?>6I> 45 >6
3G4364 57
!
B? *
?;>@1 H0-<0 H>1 ,3-6? 4;>6125;439
-883?>88= ,= 403 234-4-563;1 7;5@
=93;>,>9 45 ">0>;>104;>
H-405:4 >6= 8-<36<3 5; 23;@-4 75; 403 2:;2513 57 1>83
1:<0
403 ;312569364
234-4-563;1
58-<3 ;3?-143;39 403 <>13 >?>-614
-6
;-@3
>75;3@364-5639 57736<31
+ ! !(
75;
:,13K:3648= 403 ;312569364
58-<3 2;59:<39 403@ ,375;3 403
23<->8
403;3>743; 1364 403@ 45 I:9-<->8 <:1459=
>;3 -6 I:9-<->8 <:1459= 7;5@
! ! !(
5:;4 >69
03 234-4-563;1
??;-3A39 ,= 403
1>@3 403 234-4-563;1 0>9 >22;5><039
99-4-56>8
>69
>1>A>B>8=>6> 75;
311-561
:9?3
?;>64 57 ;3?:8>; ,>-8 -6
-9>;
1-44-6? >4
;8 "-1<
H>1 ;3I3<439 ,= 5;93; 9>439
234-4-56
5( )
! !(
+ * ! !(
-14;-<4
03 1>@3
36<3
40-1
-4-
3>;9 83>;639 <5:6138 75; 403 234-4-563;1 >69
83>;639
75; 403 ;312569364 L
4>43
2>;4 7;5@ :;?-6? 13A3;>8 <564364-561
<5:6138 75; 403 234-4-563;1 ><<:139
>69 ! 0>1
2;-@>;-8= <56436939 40>4 403;3 -1 65
@>43;->8
>A>-8>,83 56 ;3<5;9 45 <5663<4 40313 234-4-563;1 45 403
>883?39 <564;>,>69
3 <56436939 40>4 403 >883?39 ?>6I>
2><B341 0>A3 ,336 <>;;-39 -6 $ 28>14-< ,>?1
05H3A3;
403;3 -1 65 H0-123; >,5:4 403 1>-9 $ 28>14-< ,>?1 3-403; -6
403 13-J:;3 @>0>J>; 5; -6 403 -6A3645;= @>0>J>; 2;32>;39
-6 403 2;3136<3 57 83>;639 "
>1>A>B>8=>6
3 >815
<56436939 40>4 403 13-J:;3 @>0>J>; -1 654 <569:<439 >1
23; 403 2;5A-1-561 57
(
3<4-56 !&!' 57
<4
<<5;9-6? 45 0-@ 403;3 -1 > <83>; 2;5<39:;>8
8>213 H0-83 ;3?-143;-6? 403 <>13 >?>-614 403 234-4-563;1
:693; 403 2;5A-1-561 57
<4
03 >883?39 13<;34
-675;@>4-56 ;3<3-A39 ,= 403 ;312569364
H;-4436 -6 > 132>;>43 ;3?-143; 3G<324 -6 403
58-<3 H>1 654
4>4-56
5:13
-5-
->;=
6 1:<0 <-;<:@14>6<3
403 1>@3 -1 >?>-614 403
1344839 2;-6<-2831 57 8>H 8>-9 95H6 ,= 40-1
56E,83
577-<3;
23G
5:;4
4 -1 403 14>4:45;= @>69>43 56 403
H05 -643691 45 3643; >69 13>;<0
-675;@>4-56 -6 > 132>;>43 ;3?-143;
5:13
->;=
5:;4 >69 403
45 H;-43 403
>2>;4 7;5@
4>4-56
<<5;9-6?8= 03 2;>=1 45 >885H 403 234-4-56
+
83>;639
75; ;312569364L 58-<3
<56436939 40>4 403 ;312569364
58-<3 0>A3 @364-5639 403
-675;@>4-56 -6 403
4>4-56
5:13
->;= >69 >815 75;H>;939
403 1>@3 45 403 0-?03; 577-<3; >69 5,4>-639 23;@-11-56 45
<569:<4
13>;<0
<<5;9-6?
-@@39->438=
;3<3-A39
@364-5639 403 1>@3 -6 403
<569:<439 ;>-9
<;39-,83
4>4-56
0-@
1-6<3
-675;@>4-56
5:13
->;= >69
6 1:<0 <-;<:@14>6<3 03 1:,@-41 40>4 65
1:<0 2;5<39:;>8 -;;3?:8>;-4-31 0>223639 -6 403 <>13 56
0>69
:;403;
03 <56436939 40>4 403 0:?3 K:>64-4= 57
?>6I> 0>1 ,336 13-J39 >4 403 -614>6<3 57 40313 234-4-563;1
<<5;9-6?8= 03 2;>=1 45 9-1@-11 403 234-4-56
-6-
$
0>A3 ?-A36 @= >6G-5:1 <561-93;>4-56 ,540 56
403 1:,@-11-56 @>93 ,= 403 83>;639 <5:6138 75; 403
;3123<4-A3 2>;4-31 15 >815 23;:139 403 @>43;->81 >A>-8>,83
56 ;3<5;9
)
375;3 938A-6? -645 403 @3;-41 57 403 <>13 -4 -1
>22;52;->43 45 3G>@-63 403 2;5A-1-561 57
>69 &!' 57 403
3<4-56
<4 H0-<0 ;3>91 >1 :693;.
!
"
#
!
$
!
#
$
!
#
#
#
#
#
%
#
%
!& '
-7-
#
&
&
'
#
"
(
(
&
#
#
%
#
&
&
'
(
#
)
#
#
"
#
#
#
)
-8-
*
+
#
#
"$
#
"#
,
*
1 23; 403 1344839 251-4-56 57 8>H
405:?0
3<4-56
!& ' ;38>431 45 403 25H3; 57 364;=
13>;<0
13-J:;3 >69 >;;314 H-405:4 H>;;>64 5; >:405;-J>4-56 >4 403
1>@3
4-@3
3<4-56
!&!'
<>141
>
@>69>43
931-?6>439 577-<3; 45 ;3<5;9 0-1 ;3>156 45 ,38-3A3 7;5@
23;156>8 B65H839?3 5; -675;@>4-56 ?-A36 ,= >6= 23;156
>69 4>B36 95H6 -6 H;-4-6? 40>4 >6 57736<3 -6 ;3123<4 57
>6= 6>;<54-< 9;:?1 5; 21=<054;52-< 1:,14>6<31 H0-<0 -1
2:6-10>,83 :693; 403
<4 0>1 ,336 <5@@-4439 5; >6=
95<:@364 5; >;4-<83 H0-<0 @>= 7:;6-10 3A-936<3 57 403
<5@@-11-56 57 57736<3 -1 B324 5; <56<3>839 -6 >6= ,:-89-6?
<56A3=>6<3 5; >6= 36<85139 28><3
3 @:14 ;3<5;9 403
;3>156 75; 1:<0 ,38-37 ,375;3 3643;-6? >69 13>;<0-6? >6=
1:<0 ,:-89-6? 5; <56A3=>6<3 ,34H336 1:6;-13 >69 1:6134
56,E83
<>13 57
-A-1-56
36<0 57
>8<:44>
-?0
5:;4 -6 403
-9-
-6
$% &$' 9>439
!"# #
)
! !
>4 2>;>1
45 ! 0389 >1 :693;.
M$( $
-*"
./ $
#
&
$
#
-*"
*
&
#
#
-*"
#
#
$'
-*"
#
./ $
&
#
$
-8
$
( *6 7 8 $
#
89:
" "
#
)
- 10 -
;
<
$
( *6*8
<
.
7==
#
$
-*"
#
*
%
&
?
>5?
@
%
>
#
&
%
?
>$@ 1
%
#
&
>$@ 5 ? ;
A
! ( *66- : $
$
$
%
$
#
#
$ 1
+ -
&
&
#
$
#
+ 7
&
#
#
#
#
+ 9 $
"
A
<
- 11 -
#
&
>
#
&
%
#
#
66 =
$
66 =
%
'55
#
#
#
#
;
= = *6 :
#
)
)
./ $
<
$
#
)
=*
./ $
#
&
#
$
$
#
=*
./ $
+ 8
#
&
</0 $
+
6 #
B
#
- 12 -
&
$
$ #
B
#
#
+ C
#
$
=
** 6-
#
*
./ $
.
#
#
;
&
#
&
D
#
&
./ $
;
#
,
- 13 -
0-1 >75;31>-9
>8<:44>
-?0
,375;3 403
( *
36<0 5;93; 57 403
5:;4 0>1 ,336 <0>8836?39 ,= 403
56E,83
! !
:2;3@3
>223>8 7-839 ,= 403
-A-1-56
-A-1-56
36<0
56E,83
5:;4 -6
:2;3@3
4>43
& ;8 '
>-;=
5:;4 9-1@-1139 403
4>43 ,= <567-;@-6? 403 5;93; 57 403
6 1:<0 <-;<:@14>6<3 >9@-44398= -6 403
<>13 56 0>69 403 13<;34 -675;@>4-56 H>1 654 6>;;>439 -6
403 132>;>43 9->;= ;3?-143; ,= 403
4>4-56
5:13
403;3 -1 > 2;5<39:;>8 8>213 <5@@-4439 ,= 403
77-<3;
58-<3 H0-83
;3?-143;-6? 403 <>13
6 1:<0 <-;<:@14>6<3 >1 0389 ,= 403
-A-1-56
36<0 -6 403 >,5A3 I:9?@364 403 234-4-563;1 >;3 364-4839
75; ;3?:8>; ,>-8
<<5;9-6?8= 28><-6? ;38->6<3 56 403 >,5A3
I:9?@364 >69
>815
<561-93;-6?
>123<4 40>4 403
234-4-563;1 >;3 -6 I:9-<->8 <:1459= 7;5@ 8>14 563 =3>; >69
65H 40>4 -6A314-?>4-56 -1 <5@283439 >69 <0>;?3 10334 0>1
,336 8>-9 ,= 403 ;312569364 L
-6<>;<3;>4-56
58-<3 403 7:;403; <:1459->8
234-4-563;1
-1
<>8839
75;
<<5;9-6?8= H-405:4 3G2;311-6? >6= 52-6-56 56 403 @3;-41
- 14 -
57 403 <>13
1:77-<3 45 0589 40>4 403 234-4-563;1 <>6 ,3
>9@-4439 45 ;3?:8>; ,>-8
!
<<5;9-6?8= 403 234-4-56 -1
234-4-563;1 ><<:139
>69
9-;3<439 45 ,3 368>;?39 56 ,>-8 -6
5 ( !+ ! !(
>;-1-6?
;3?-143;39
,=
57736<31
5:4
>1>A>B>8=>6
;-@3
:;>8
2:6-10>,83 :693;
+ ! !(
58-<3
4>4-56
75;
! !
3<4-561 !)
!
>69
<4 2369-6? 56 403 7-83 57
99-4-56>8
311-561
:9?3
-9>; 1-44-6? >4
>1>A>B>8=>6 1:,I3<4 45 403 75885H-6? <569-4-561.
>'
34-4-563;1 10>88 3G3<:43 > 23;156>8 ,569
75; > 1:@ 57
3><0 H-40 4H5
1:;34-31 75; 403 8-B31:@ 45 403 1>4-17><4-56 57
403 I:;-19-<4-56>8
,'
5:;4N
03 234-4-563;1 10>88 >223>; ;3?:8>;8= 56
>88 403 9>431 57 03>;-6? ,375;3 403 ;->8
5:;4
:68311
403-;
;->8
5:;4
>223>;>6<3 75; A>8-9 ;3>1561N
3<4-56
! &,'&--'& ' 57
-14;-<4 >69
>;3
3G3@241
- 15 -
<'
234-4-563;1
-69-;3<48=
40;3>436
10>88
5;
9-;3<48=
5;
4>@23;
H-40
2;513<:4-56 H-4631131N
9'
03 234-4-563;1 10>88 654 -6A58A3 -6 1-@-8>;
57736<31 -6 7:4:;3N
3'
234-4-563;1
I:;-19-<4-56
10>88
;->8
23;@-11-56 57 403 1>-9
83>A3
5:;4
H-405:4
5:;4 :64-8 403 <>13
;3?-143;39 >?>-614 403@ -1 9-125139 577
7'
03 234-4-563;1 10>88 @>;B 403-; >44369>6<3
,375;3
>1>A>B>8=>6
4>4-56
:;>8
58-<3
5:13
77-<3;
4>4-56
56 7-;14
:69>= 57 3A3;= @5640 ,34H336
>69
2@
4-88
<>13
>@
;3?-143;39
>?>-614 403@ -1 9-125139 577 ,375;3 403
5:;4
,*
'
&
)
&
-14
5.
5.+
;->8
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review