Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 325 of 2020
Date of Decision: 01.07.2022
Federation of NEEPCO Employees Vs. North Eastern Electric Power
(Union) & Ors.
Corporation Limited & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s) :
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv.
Mr. P. Shati, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. V.K. Jindal, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. E. Marwein, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The writ petitioners herein, are before this Court praying
for appropriate orders for initiation of disciplinary action against the
officers of the respondent Corporation in connection with the promotions
that had been made from Assistant (SG) (W-A) to Junior Executive
Supervisor (S-1) conducted by the respondent No. 5 (DPC) on
21.02.2012 to 23.02.2012 w.e.f. 01.01.2012 and further for setting aside
the impugned enquiry report submitted by the respondent No. 6 (CVO)
and for further direction to direct the respondent No. 8 (CVC) institute
an impartial inquiry.
2.
The grievance of the petitioner Union, which is stated to be
a Federation of NEEPCO Employees, is that the respondent NEEPCO
had constituted a Departmental Promotion Committee to fill up 35
vacancies by promotion, from the post of Assistant (SG) (W-A) to Junior
Executive Supervisor (S-1) and in this exercise 76 employees holding the
post of Assistant (SG) (W-A) were called for interview, out of which 27
candidates were declared successful and recommended for promotion.
However, it is alleged that contrary to the roster which had earmarked 17
posts for General candidates and 18 for Schedule Caste candidates, the
respondent had indulged in large-scale malpractice and manipulation in
the promotion process in total disregard to fairness and transparency.
3.
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr.
P. Shati, learned counsel for the petitioner, firstly submits that the
fundamental grievance of the writ petitioner is that there has been a
manipulation by the respondent NEEPCO in the said selection, which is
apparent from the assessment sheets, inasmuch as, candidates securing
lesser marks were promoted by denying other meritorious candidates and
that some who had failed, were given promotions illegally. The learned
Senior counsel submits that these discrepancies came to the notice of the
petitioner Union, when they had received a Note Sheet maintained by the
respondent No. 5, Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) as well as
an Assessment Sheet for promotion w.e.f. 01.01.2012, containing the list
of successful and un-successful candidates in 2014 from the Executive
Director (HR) while the said person was in service but, who had later
expired in 2016.
4.
To substantiate his argument, the learned Senior counsel has
referred to an Assessment Sheet dated 23.02.2012 (Page 39 of the writ
petition) and submits that an examination of the Assessment Sheet which
was received by the petitioner and the RTI reply which was provided by
the respondents reflects that there is gross inconsistency. To illustrate
this point, the learned senior counsel has taken this Court to the Note
Sheets and also the recommendation which contains 27 names. It is
submitted that, a comparison of 3 documents namely; the Assessment
Sheet, the Recommended Panel for Promotion and the RTI reply giving
the list of the persons who were accorded promotion, clearly show the
discrepancies in the entire process of selection and promotion, as out of
the 27 candidates, 19 were promoted and out of 19, 15 were lifted from
the list of recommended candidates and out of 15, 6 candidates securing
lesser marks were promoted by denying 6 more meritorious candidates,
and that 4 candidates who were not recommended were promoted.
5.
The learned Senior counsel submits that the petitioner Union
on the malpractices as indicated above in its meeting on 09.12.2017,
resolved to demand for an impartial inquiry by an independent authority
and accordingly a Complaint Petition dated 11.12.2017, along with
copies of the said documents as received of the DPC, were placed before
the respondent No. 2, who on receipt of
the same, requested the
petitioner to disclose the source of information which was declined by
the petitioner, but who however, informed him that they would fully
cooperate and would give statements when an Inquiry Committee was
constituted. It is submitted that the petitioner was then informed vide
letter dated 06.07.2018, that the Vigilance Department had conducted an
enquiry and found no anomalies or irregularities, which however was not
found acceptable to the writ petitioner, who after receiving a copy of the
enquiry report, requested that the CVO re-inquire and re-investigate into
the matter. The learned Senior counsel submits that though the matter
thereafter was referred to the CVC, and it was observed that no further
investigation was required, he asserts that the manner in which the
respondent CVO conducted the enquiry, by relying solely on the version
as well as the records provided by the respondent NEEPCO management,
without independently examining the materials i.e. the copies of the
recommendation and assessment sheets of the respondent DPC provided
by the writ petitioner, was highly irresponsible and an abdication of its
independent powers.
6.
The learned Senior counsel submits that the respondent
CVO mechanically hushed up the inquiry without hearing the writ
petitioner, which has resulted in the violation of the principles of natural
justice. On the delay in taking action against the perceived illegalities,
the learned Senior counsel submits that the same is not deliberate and
willful and even though this Court was approached only on 29.10.2020,
it is due to the fact that the irregularities in the DPC, surfaced when one
failed candidate brought up the issue, and thereafter the petitioner Union
obtained the information under an RTI application dated 12.10.2017 and
immediately filed the complaint thereafter.
7.
In closing his submissions, the learned Senior counsel submits that
the discrepancies are writ large as earlier illustrated, which has been
amply demonstrated by the Assessment Sheets relied upon by the
petitioner vis-à-vis, the one relied upon by respondent NEEPCO. As
such, it is submitted notwithstanding the delay and the fact that the
promotees have not been arrayed as parties, directions are called for from
this Court for action to be taken against any erring officers found
involved in the malpractice and corruption, which has occurred in
connection with the said promotions.
8.
Mr. V.K. Jindal, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. E.
Marwein, learned counsel for the respondents, submits that the basis for
alleging such malpractice by the petitioner Union is based on the
documents annexed at Annexure-2 of the writ petition. These documents
it is submitted, are not final or authenticated copies, but are drafts and
the correct final approved panel list and the Assessment Sheets are
enclosed by the respondents at Annexure-A and B to the affidavit-inopposition. As per this list, the learned Senior counsel submits the DPC
recommended not 27 but 31 candidates.
9.
It is also contended that the writ petitioners’ claim is
hopelessly delayed, as allegedly the writ petitioners had received copies
of the recommendation and Assessment Sheets of the DPC in 2014, but
waited for 3 years until the sources of the information namely; one Nagen
Chandra Das was no longer in service and one Shri T. Kakoty who had
expired in 2016, were no longer available, to lodge the protest on
11.02.2017, and even thereafter refused to reveal the sources of these
documents, which were confidential in nature. It is submitted that the
aforesaid complaint, was inquired into twice by the CVO and thereafter
reviewed by the CVC, who saw no infirmity in the said reports. The
allegations it is contended has no basis, as no irregularity was found in
the process of the promotion, and therefore the filing of the writ petition
for setting aside and quashing the inquiry report of 2018 submitted by
the CVO, as well as the impugned letter dated 02.09.2020, and for
directions to constitute an Inquiry Committee to consider the matter
afresh is misplaced and untenable.
10.
The learned Senior counsel also submits that the case is bad
for mis-joinder of parties, as the CVO and CVC cannot be impleaded as
parties as per the provisions contained in Section 15 of the Central
Vigilance Act, 2003, for which a Misc. application had also been filed
for striking them off as necessary parties. It is further submitted the
promotions were conducted and granted in the year 2012 and the writ
petition has only been filed in 2020, and the non-impleadment of the
promotees who will be directly affected, in the event any adverse orders
are passed, makes the case also bad for non-joinder of necessary parties.
On these grounds the learned Senior counsel submits that the writ
petition deserves to be dismissed with cost.
11.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have given
due consideration to the entire facts and circumstances of the case. The
matter it is seen revolves on the alleged malpractice which the petitioner
has sought to demonstrate by referring to the note sheets and assessment
sheets which they have received as early as on 2014. In this regard, the
facts that cannot be overlooked is that on these perceived illegalities,
action was initiated by the petitioner only on 2017. Another factor that
weighs heavy in the consideration of this case is that the impugned
promotion process had taken place in 2012 and therefore in the long
intervening period, persons who have been promoted have acquired
vested rights, and even though the petitioner has submitted that no action
is sought against the promotees, any adverse orders that may be passed
will surely have consequential effects on them. Their non-impleadment
in these proceedings by the petitioner is therefore a point that cannot be
ignored.
12.
The writ petitioner while seeking the relief amongst others,
for appropriate consequential penal and disciplinary action against the
erring officers if found involved in the alleged malpractice, is a prayer
that is unspecific as the said officers who it is alleged to have indulged
in the same, are also not party to these proceedings.
13.
Allegations have been levelled by the petitioner against the
Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) of 2012 where the exercise
of promotion by the DPC is questioned. The members of the said DPC
have not been arrayed as parties by the petitioner, even though serious
allegations of lack of transparency, manipulation, forgery, cheating have
been made against them in the writ petition as also in rejoinder affidavit.
14.
The petitioner has however impleaded the Chief Vigilance
Officer and Chief Vigilance Commissioner as party respondent seeking
the quashment of the report of the CVO dated 19.07.2018, as well as the
impugned letter dated 02.09.2020, wherein on the direction of the CVC
the matter was reviewed and it was found that no further investigation
was required. In this aspect also Section 15 of the Central Vigilance Act
2003 has provided: “15. No Suit, prosecution or other legal proceeding shall
lie against the Commission, the Central Vigilance
Commissioner, any Vigilance Commissioner, the
Secretary or against any staff of the Commission in
respect of anything which is in good faith done or intended
to be done under this Act.”
Though the petitioner may feel aggrieved with the
impugned report and letter, in view of the express provisions of the Act,
no justification is there to implead these respondents, which clearly
seems to have been made with the sole objective to exert undue pressure,
which in the view of this Court, is irregular and does not put the petitioner
in a good light.
15.
This Court has also examined the Note Sheets and
Assessment Sheets which has been produced/annexed by the parties. The
Note Sheets and Assessment Sheets as annexed to the writ petition have
been contested and disputed by the respondent as being not final or
approved, and that the correct and final approved Note and Assessment
Sheets are annexed at Annexure A and B to the affidavit-in-opposition.
A perusal of the Note Sheet as annexed to the writ petition though
seemingly appearing to be detailed with file notings made therein,
alongwith the signature of a Deputy Manager dated 23.04.2012, its
authenticity however, cannot be verified by this Court, as to whether the
same is a draft as alleged or otherwise. With regard to the Assessment
Sheet which was allegedly prepared on 23.02.2012, the same has clearly
not been approved as the portion provided for the signature of approval
to be put by the Deputy General Manager (P&A) is blank. In contrast,
the Note Sheet said to be authentic and approved, as annexed by the
respondents has been signed on 14.06.2012 and file notings made therein
are dated 29.06.2012 and 04.07.2012. The Assessment Sheets appended
thereto, are seen to have been approved by the said Deputy General
Manager (P&A). These records which contain this sensitive information
are confidential and have been marked as such, which however on
comparison though dealing with the same issue are found to be
inconsistent. This certainly raises questions as to the process that was
adopted and the manner in which the records have been maintained.
16.
Situated thus, this Court will therefore not place reliance on
the Note Sheet and Assessment Sheet provided by the petitioner but will
examine the issue raised by the petitioner, on the documents that have
been placed by the respondent before this Court. As noted earlier 76
employees holding the post of Assistant (SG) (W-8) were called for
interview for promotion to the post of Junior Executive Supervisor (S-1)
against 35 vacancies (17 vacancies unreserved and 18 for SC). 31
candidates came out successful and as per the respondent, all the 31
candidates from the final approved panel list and Assessment Sheet were
recommended for promotion. At this juncture it would be useful to revert
to the RTI reply which had been provided by the respondent on the
request for information by the petitioner wherein the name of the persons
promoted from (W-8) to (S-1) w.e.f. from 01.01.2012 has been provided.
A comparison of the Assessment Sheet and the RTI reply showing the
persons who have been promoted, reveals that the promotion for 17 Unreserved and for 2 Schedule Caste reserved post vacancies is in
accordance with the order of recommendation or merit. However, with
regard to the other promotions granted to the remaining persons, if the
RTI reply is taken to be the correct chart, there appears to be
inconsistencies, as the names of some persons who were not
recommended for promotion as per the Assessment Sheet have found
place in the list of employees promoted w.e.f., 01.01.2012. In the note
sheet signed on 14.06.2012, the approved panel list (Annexure-B to the
affidavit-in-opposition), was put up for approval by the DPC, showing
the list of 31 candidates recommended for promotion in order of merit.
The approved panel list appears not to tally with the RTI reply, as the
names of 6 persons appearing at Serial No. 21, 22, 23, 27, 28 and 29 who
are shown recommended for promotion in the approved panel list, do not
appear in the said RTI reply.
17.
Another glaring point is the fact that 2 candidates belonging
to Schedule Tribe category have been recommended as per the panel list
for promotion, when by the statement of the respondents themselves, to
fill up the 35 vacancies, the proportion was Un-reserved -17 and
Schedule Caste -18. It is undisputed and stated on affidavit by the
respondents that 17 Un-reserved and 2 (SC) were promoted that is, a total
of 19 candidates against the recommendation of 31, as it appears there
were no other Schedule Caste candidates who were recommended. In the
view of this Court, the bone of contention therefore, is with regard to the
remaining 12 posts, which the petitioner alleges promotions have been
manipulated, and granted to undeserving persons.
18.
From the materials available, though certain doubts are
raised, it will not be possible for this Court to conclusively arrive at any
decision that will justify re-opening of the entire matter, or to call for a
review or a re-visit of the impugned promotion process. Firstly, the
promotions have been granted and acted upon a decade ago, and there is
no question of unsettling a settled position. The other factors, that go
against the consideration of the prayer of the petitioner is the non-joinder
and mis-joinder of parties which by itself disables the writ petition,
notwithstanding the fact, that the writ petitioner has submitted that they
are not seeking to quash the promotion order dated 04.07.2012. Another
aspect, that cannot be ignored is that the matter was looked into by the
CVO twice and also put up before the CVC, who are independent
authorities to look into such matters, who found no anomalies to warrant
a fresh enquiry. Lastly, the approach of the writ petitioner in seeking
redressal of the matter raises substantial doubt, inasmuch as, by their own
admission, they were in receipt of the questionable confidential
documents in 2014 itself, but waited until 2017, to initiate any action. A
bonafide writ petitioner or a person aggrieved will in the normal course,
on a perception of violation of any right or aware of a wrong doing that
affects him, will at once seek redressal. The writ petitioner by
purportedly waiting for their sources of information to be unavailable
before pursuing any remedy, have by themselves rendered their own
claim stale.
19.
Though, arguable and the debatable questions have been
raised, as to the procedure, method and process by which the exercise of
promotions has been conducted by the respondents, in view of the
reasons aforementioned, this Court does not deem it fit to direct for any
further enquiry as prayed for, and leaves it to the respondents themselves
to take any further action in this regard, if deemed necessary.
20.
The writ petition is accordingly dismissed.
21.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
01.07.2022
“V. Lyndem-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review