The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds that respondent No. 4’s engagement under Phase-I at Hangal Buch stood displaced upon relocation of the Centre due to migration of the local populace. The advertisement dated 18.12.2009 under Phase-II relocation programme for Panchayat Halqa Kathpora was a valid and independent exercise confined to residents of that Halqa and the learned Single Judge erred in quashing the said advertisement and in holding that respondent No. 4 continued to hold the post in absence of any valid legal basis. LPASW 134 of 2018
22. Accordingly, the appeal succeeds and is allowed. The judgment and order dated 12.05.2016 passed by the learned Single Judge in SWP No. 2059/2009 is set aside. It is declared that the appointment of the appellant, Ms. Fatima Bano, pursuant to advertisement notice dated 18.12.2009 for Panchayat Halqa Kathpora, Nadimarg, is valid and lawful. Respondent No. 4 shall have no subsisting claim over the said post.
23. The instant appeal is, accordingly, disposed of in the aforesaid terms. ( Shahzad Azeem) Judge (Sindhu Sharma) Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
Case No. LPASW 134/2018
Reserved on : 17.09.2025
Pronounced on : 25.03.2026
Uploaded on : 25.03.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced
Fatima Bano, D/O Gh. Mohammad Sheikh,
R/O Nadimarg, Konthpora, Kulgam
....Petitioner/Appellant
Through:- Mr. S. R. Hussain, Advocate
V/s
1.State of Jammu and Kashmir Through
Commissioner/Secretary to Government, Social Welfare
Department, Civil Secretariat, Jammu/Srinagar
2. Director, Social Welfare Department, Kashmir/Srinagar
3. CDPO, ICDS Project, Humshalibugh, Qaimoh, Kulgam
4. Shagufta Shaheen, D/O Ghulam Hassan Shah, R/O
Hangal Butch, Nadimarg District Kulgam, Kashmir
Through:-
…..Respondent(s)
Mr. Waseem Gul, GA
Mr. Rizwan-ul-Zaman, Advocate
\
CORAM: HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SINDHU SHARMA, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SHAHZAD AZEEM, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
PER: SINDHU SHARMA-J
1.
This Letters Patent Appeal (for short, <LPA=) has been
preferred by the appellant against the judgment and order
LPASW 134 of 2018
dated 12.05.2016 passed by the learned Single Judge in writ
petition bearing SWP No. 2059/2009, titled <Shagufia
Shaheen vs. State of J&K & Ors.=
2.
The brief facts giving rise to the present appeal are
that,
in
response
to
an
advertisement
notice
dated
17.02.2005 issued by the Social Welfare Department,
applications were invited for engagement of Anganwadi
Workers on honorarium basis for various centres, including
Anganwadi Centre, Hangal Buch (Nadimarg). Respondent
No. 4, namely Ms. Shagufta Shaheen, was selected and
engaged as Anganwadi Worker at Anganwadi Centre,
Nadimarg, during the first phase of expansion in October
2005. An order to this effect was issued on 03.10.2005,
subject to certain terms and conditions.
3.
It is stated that in a militancy-related incident in the
year 2003, the inhabitants of village Nadimarg, belonging to
the minority community, had to migrate to safer places.
Consequently, the Anganwadi Centre at Nadimarg was
shifted to Kokergund, and a new incumbent came to be
engaged in place of respondent No. 4.
4.
Aggrieved by the shifting of the Anganwadi Centre,
respondent No. 4 approached this Court by filing SWP No.
625/2008, seeking a direction to allow her to discharge her
duties
as
Anganwadi
LPASW 134 of 2018
Worker
at
Anganwadi
Centre,
Nadimarg (Hangal Buch), to pay her honorarium from the
date of engagement, and to restrain the respondents from
disengaging her or shifting the Anganwadi Centre to another
village.
5.
During the pendency of the aforesaid writ petition, the
official respondents issued another advertisement notice
dated 18.12.2009 under Phase-II relocation programme for
various centres, including Panchayat Halqa Kathpora,
Nadimarg. Respondent No. 4 did not apply pursuant to the
said notice. The present appellant, Ms. Fatima Bano, being a
resident of Kathpora and otherwise meritorious, applied and
was selected under the said advertisement.
6.
Respondent No. 4, feeling aggrieved, filed SWP No.
2059/2009 challenging the advertisement notice dated
18.12.2009, inter alia, on the ground that she had already
been appointed as Anganwadi Worker at Nadimarg vide
order dated 03.10.2005 and was continuing on the said
post, and that the subsequent advertisement was arbitrary
and intended to displace her.
7.
The appellant as well as the official respondents filed
objections before the learned Single Judge. It was contended
that the advertisement dated 18.12.2009 had been issued
under the Phase-II relocation programme for Panchayat
Halqa Kathpora, Nadimarg, whereas respondent No. 4 was
LPASW 134 of 2018
not a resident of the said Panchayat Halqa and, therefore,
was ineligible to apply. It was further submitted that
respondent No. 4 had already surrendered her claim under
Phase-I engagement after the migration of population from
Nadimarg, which fact was also evident from the affidavit
sworn by her.
8.
In support of her stand, the appellant placed reliance
upon the communication dated 29.06.2016 issued by
Tehsildar, Yaripora, in response to an RTI application,
clarifying that Anganwadi Centre, Kathpora, falls under
Revenue Village Kathpora and Panchayat Halqa Kathpora,
whereas Hangal Buch falls under Revenue Village Hangal
Buch
and
Panchayat
Halqa
Hangal
Buch,
thereby
establishing that respondent No. 4 belonged to a different
Panchayat Halqa.
9.
The
learned
Single
Judge,
vide
judgment
dated
12.05.2016, allowed the writ petition (SWP No. 2059/2009 c
SWP No. 625/2008) and held that respondent No. 4 had
been duly appointed on 03.10.2005 against the available
vacancy at Anganwadi Centre, Nadimarg, and continued on
the said post. It was observed that there was no record or
official communication to show that her appointment had
ever been cancelled, rescinded, or that the Centre itself had
been closed.
LPASW 134 of 2018
10.
The learned Single Judge further held that no material
was produced either by the official respondents or by the
appellant to establish that any valid appointment order had
been issued in favour of the appellant pursuant to
advertisement notice dated 18.12.2009. It was also noted
that the plea regarding shifting of the Anganwadi Centre, as
raised by the appellant, was not substantiated by any official
record. In such circumstances, the learned Single Judge
concluded that issuance of another advertisement notice for
the same Anganwadi Centre was unjustified and arbitrary.
Accordingly, the advertisement notice dated 18.12.2009 was
quashed, and prayers (i) and (ii) made in SWP No. 625/2008
were allowed, thereby granting protection to respondent No.
4 to continue as Anganwadi Worker and to receive
honorarium.
11.
Aggrieved by the judgment dated 12.05.2016, the
appellant has preferred the present appeal on the ground
that the learned Single Judge failed to appreciate that
respondent No. 4 was not a resident of Panchayat Halqa
Kathpora and hence, had no right to claim the post
advertised under Phase-II. It is contended that the affidavit
filed by respondent No. 4 clearly demonstrates that she had
surrendered her post after the migration of population, and
therefore, she had no subsisting right to claim continuation.
LPASW 134 of 2018
12.
It is further submitted that the RTI communication
dated 29.06.2016 issued by Tehsildar, Yaripora, establishes
beyond doubt that Hangal Buch and Kathpora are distinct
revenue villages falling under different Panchayat Halqas.
Therefore, respondent No. 4 could not have laid claim to the
post meant for residents of Kathpora. The appellant further
submits that the learned Single Judge overlooked the fact
that she, being a resident of Kathpora and otherwise
meritorious, had been duly selected under the Phase-II
programme, while respondent No. 4 had not even applied
pursuant to the advertisement notice dated 18.12.2009.
13.
It is thus, contended that the findings recorded by the
learned Single Judge are contrary to the pleadings and
documentary evidence on record, resulting in serious
prejudice to the appellant. The appellant accordingly, seeks
setting aside of the judgment and order dated 12.05.2016
passed by the learned Single Judge.
14.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material on record.
15.
The principal questions that arise for consideration in
this appeal are:
(i) Whether respondent No. 4 continued to have a
subsisting right over the post of Anganwadi Worker
after the migration of inhabitants and consequent
relocation of the Centre; and
LPASW 134 of 2018
(ii) Whether the subsequent advertisement dated
18.12.2009 for Panchayat Halqa Kathpora was validly
issued and whether respondent No. 4, not being a
resident of that Halqa, could lay claim to the said post.
16.
It is an admitted position that respondent No. 4 was
engaged as an Anganwadi Worker at Anganwadi Centre,
Nadimarg (Hangal Buch), vide order dated 03.10.2005 under
Phase-I expansion. It is equally undisputed that due to the
unfortunate migration of minority community inhabitants in
2003,
the
Centre
was
rendered
non-functional
and
subsequently relocated.
17.
The respondent No. 4 has sworn an affidavit by
acknowledging that she had surrendered her claim after
migration,
as
well
as
the
RTI
communication
dated
29.06.2016 issued by the Tehsildar, Yaripora, unequivocally
establishes that Hangal Buch and Kathpora are two distinct
Revenue Villages falling under different Panchayat Halqas.
18.
The
advertisement
dated
18.12.2009
was
issued
specifically for Panchayat Halqa Kathpora, Nadimarg, and
eligibility
for
engagement
as
Anganwadi
Worker
was
confined to residents of that Halqa. Respondent No. 4, being
a resident of Hangal Buch, was therefore ineligible to apply
under the said advertisement. The appellant, Ms. Fatima
Bano,
being
a
resident
of
Kathpora
and
otherwise
meritorious, was validly considered and selected.
LPASW 134 of 2018
19.
The learned Single Judge appears to have proceeded on
the assumption that respondent No. 4’s appointment order
dated 03.10.2005 continued to subsist in the absence of a
formal
cancellation
order.
However,
the
principle
of
subsistence of right cannot be applied in abstraction when
the very basis of engagement the functioning of the original
Centre stood displaced due to relocation and restructuring
under a distinct administrative unit.
20.
In the instant case, respondent No. 4 neither applied
pursuant to the fresh advertisement nor established that the
post advertised under Phase-II was identical to her earlier
position, and as such, can have no grievance against
issuance of fresh advertisement notice. Consequently, her
claim to continuation is unsustainable.
21.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds
that respondent No. 4’s engagement under Phase-I at
Hangal Buch stood displaced upon relocation of the Centre
due to migration of the local populace. The advertisement
dated 18.12.2009 under Phase-II relocation programme for
Panchayat Halqa Kathpora was a valid and independent
exercise confined to residents of that Halqa and the learned
Single Judge erred in quashing the said advertisement and
in holding that respondent No. 4 continued to hold the post
in absence of any valid legal basis.
LPASW 134 of 2018
22.
Accordingly, the appeal succeeds and is allowed. The
judgment and order dated 12.05.2016 passed by the learned
Single Judge in SWP No. 2059/2009 is set aside. It is
declared that the appointment of the appellant, Ms. Fatima
Bano, pursuant to advertisement notice dated 18.12.2009
for Panchayat Halqa Kathpora, Nadimarg, is valid and
lawful. Respondent No. 4 shall have no subsisting claim over
the said post.
23.
The instant appeal is, accordingly, disposed of in the
aforesaid terms.
( Shahzad Azeem)
Judge
(Sindhu Sharma)
Judge
SRINAGAR
25.03.2026
Bir
LPASW 134 of 2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review