Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Regular
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
OWP 1552/2018 IA(1/2018) IA(2/2018)
c/w
i)WP(C) 1023/2020 CM(2400/2020).
ii)CCP(S) 139/2023
iii)WP(C) 691/2023 CM(1636/2023) CM(1637/2023)
iv)CCP(S) 409/2025.
Fatima And Ors.
…Applicant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Through:
Mr. Bilal Ahmad Khan, Advocate.
VERSUS
State Of J And K And Ors.
…Respondent(s)
Through:
Mr. Bikram Deep Singh, Dy AG.
Mr. Ilyas Nazir Laway, GA.
Mr. Jahinger Dar, GA.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAHUL BHARTI, JUDGE.
ORDER
04.07.2026
WP(C) No. 1023/2020:
1. In the name of Inhabitants of Gassi Mohalla, Safa Kadal,
Srinagar, one person- Zahoor Ahmad Khanday introducing
himself as Chairman as if the Inhabitants of Gassi Mohalla is a
body corporate or a registered body acting through its chairman,
approached this Court by way of a representative writ petition.
2. Permission for maintaining the representative writ petition came
to be granted in terms of an order dated 10.07.2020 and
simultaneously, the writ petition was taken on board with a
direction for maintenance of status quo obtaining as on that
date with regard to the position of the land in question came to
be passed.
3. In the writ petition, the following reliefs are being claimed:
“A. A Writ of Mandamus, commanding to process the
case for land compensation in terms of provisions of Land
Acquisition Act, Land Revenue Act and the Circulars
issue thereunder on the analogy of similarly dealt cases
on the same land comprising under Khasra No.'s 177 m,
397 min, 600, 657, 666,408, 410, 457, 621, 623, 663,
624, etc whereof the said land has been mutated by way
of a common mutation bearing mutation No. 2120 of
Estate Baghwan-pora, Tehsil khas and District Srinagar,
in favour of the forefathers of the petitioners.
B. A Writ of Mandamus, respondents be commanded to
extend the benefit of Govt. Order No. 88 of 2005 dated
18-03-2005 by adopting the same analogy as they have
adopted by regularining 13 unauthorized colonies in
Jammu City as forming Annexure-III of the Writ petition
as petitioners also form a class with them, as such
respondent No.12 be commanded to pass same and
similar order of regularization for Estate BhagwhwanPora area.
C. A Writ of Prohibition, respondents be commanded
not to disturb the possession of the petitioners not to
resort to illegal and forcible eviction without following the
due process of law.
D. A Writ of Mandamus, respondents be commanded to
declare land covered by Khasra No.'s given hereinabove
relief situated at Estate Bhaghwan Pora, tehsil Khas ard
District Srinagar and assign the same to the petitioners
as envisaged u/s 6 of the Jammu & Kashmir Commons
Lands (Regulation Act, 1956) to the extent of their
possession as mentioned in the revenue record.
E. A Writ of Mandamus, District Collector/Deputy
Commissioner be commanded firstly to exercise powers in
terms of
Section 6 of
the J&K Commons Lands
(Regulation Act) 1956, and in alternative be commanded
to exercise the powers in terms of Section-26 of the J&K
Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976 by assigning/allotting land
as envisaged under the above mentioned provisions of
the
law
and
be
also
commanded
to
reflect
all
assignees/allottees as owners in the ownership column
of Annexure-l by deleting the name of the State.
F. A Writ of Mandamus, in alternative the respondents
be commanded to exercise the powers vested with the
Collector/respondent No.12 u/s 26 of the J&K Agrarian
Reforms Act, 1976 by allotting 02 Kanals of land each by
passing allotment orders separately in favour of each
petitioners.
G. Any other Writ, order or direction the Hon'ble court
deems appropriate in the attending circumstances of the
case may kindly be issued in favour of the petitioners
and against the respondents for which act of kindness
the petitioner shall ever pray.”
3.
In the entire writ petition, there is no whisper as to who are the
persons with respect to whom Zahoor Ahmad Khanday,
purportedly acting as a Chairman, came forward seeking
issuance of a writ of mandamus and, thus, the writ petition,
right from its very inception was and continues to be so
afflicted with a serious deficiency of foundational facts, in the
absence of which this Court cannot, at any given point of time
contemplate issuance of any writ of mandamus much less as
asked for.
4.
When this Court today called upon Mr. Bilal Ahmad Khan,
learned counsel for the petitioner to assist this Court on this
aspect as to the very maintainability of the writ cause in the
petition, Mr. Bilal Ahmad Khan, learned counsel for the
petitioner submitted that he would come prepared on the next
date.
5.
Be that as it may, this Court is inclined to vacate the status
quo direction as given in order dated 10.07.2020, as vacation
of the status quo would prejudice none when none is
mentioned in the writ petition to be the beneficiary of the status
quo direction.
6.
As such, order dated 10.07.2020 read with the subsequent
orders whereby the status quo direction came to be extended,
shall stand vacated. With the vacation of the status quo
direction, the Authorities shall be at liberty to deal with the
matter in accordance with law.
7.
List on 21st July, 2026.
WP(C) No. 691/2023:
8.
In the name of Inhabitants of Garind Khurd, District Budgam,
one person- Mohammad Ramzan Mir introducing himself as
Chairman as if the Inhabitants of Garind Khurd is a body
corporate or a registered body acting through its chairman
approached this Court by way of a representative writ petition.
9.
Permission for maintaining the representative writ petition
came to be granted in terms of an order dated 31.03.2023 and
simultaneously, the writ petition was taken on board and a
direction for maintenance of status quo obtaining as on that
date with regard to the position of the land in question came to
be passed.
10. In the petition, the following reliefs are being claimed:
“A. A Writ of Mandamus, commanding to process
the case for land compensation in terms of
provisions of Land Acquisition Act, Land Revenue
Act and the Circulars Issue thereunder on the
analogy of similarly dealt cases on the same the
land measuring more than 51 kanals since times
immemorial comprising under Khasra No.'s 33, 34,
44, 46, 51, 55, 57, 58, 60, 114, 113, 115, 116,
117, 118, 119, 130, 511, 512, etc of estate Kakan
Maran and District Budgam, whereof the said land
has been mutated by way of mutations Inserted in
the revenue record in favour of the forefathers of
the petitioners.
B.
A
Writ
of
Mandamus,
respondents
be
commanded to extend the benefit of Govt. Order No.
88 of 2005 dated 18-03-2005 by adopting the
same
analogy
as
they
have
adopted
by
regularizing 13 unauthorized colonies in Jammu
City as forming Annexure-VI of the Writ petition as
petitioners also form a class with them, as such
respondents be commanded to pass same and
similar order of regularization for Estate Kakan
Maran and District Budgam.
C.
A
Writ
of
Prohibition,
respondents
be
commanded not to disturb the possession of the
petitioners not to resort to illegal and forcible
eviction without following the due process of law.
D.
A
Writ
of
Mandamus,
respondents
be
commanded to declare land covered by Khasra
No.'s as reflected in relief First of the writ petition
as given hereinabove relief situated at Estate
Kakan Maran and District Budgam and assign the
same to the petitioners as envisaged u/s 6 of the
Jammu & Kashmir Commons Lands (Regulation
Act, 1956) to the extent of their possession as
mentioned in the revenue record.
E. A Writ of Mandamus, District Collector/Deputy
Commissioner be commanded firstly to exercise
powers in terms of Section-6 of the J&K Commons
Lands (Regulation Act) 1956, and in alternative be
commanded to exercise the powers in terms of
Section-26 of the J&K Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976
by assigning/allotting land as envisaged under the
above mentioned provisions of the law and be also
commanded to reflect all assignees/allottees as
owners in the ownership column of Annexure-I, by
deleting the name of the State.
F. Any other Writ, order or direction the Hon'ble
court
deems
appropriate
in
the
attending
circumstances of the case may kindly be issued in
favour
of
respondents
the
petitioners
and
against
the
for
which
of
kindness
the
act
petitioner shall ever pray.”
11. In the entire writ petition, there is no whisper as to who are the
persons with respect to whom Mohammad Ramzan Mir,
purportedly acting as a Chairman, came forward seeking
issuance of a writ of mandamus and, thus, the writ petition,
right from its very inception, was and continues to be so
afflicted with a serious deficiency of foundational facts, in the
absence of which this Court cannot, at any given point of time,
contemplate issuance of any writ of mandamus much less as
asked for
12. When this Court today called upon Mr. Bilal Ahmad Khan,
learned counsel for the petitioner to assist this Court on this
aspect as to the very maintainability of the writ cause in the
petition, Mr. Bilal Ahmad Khan, learned counsel for the
petitioner submitted that he would come prepared on the next
date.
13. Be that as it may,
this Court is inclined to vacate the status
quo direction as given in order dated 31.03.2023, as vacation
of the status quo would prejudice none and when none is
mentioned in the writ petition to be the beneficiary of the status
quo direction.
14. As such, order dated 31.03.2023 read with the subsequent
orders whereby the status quo direction came to be extended,
shall stand vacated. With the vacation of the status quo
direction, the authorities shall be at liberty to deal with the
matter in accordance with law.
15. List on 21st July, 2026.
OWP No. 1552/2018:
16. List this petition along with its connected CMs on 21st July,
2026.
(RAHUL BHARTI)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
04.07.2026
Bisma Jan.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review