Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.253 of 2025
======================================================
Faiyaz Ahmad S/o- Late Md. Yaseen Ansari, R/o- Ward No.-9, Barhara
Bahraha, P.S.- Babu-Barhi, District- Madhubani.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1.
The State of Bihar through Additional Chief Secretary, Prohibition, Excise
and Registration Department, New Secretariat, Patna.
2.
Additional Chief Secretary, General Administration Department, Old
Secretariat, Patna.
3.
Secretary, Prohibition,
Secretariat, Patna.
4.
Commissioner, Prohibition, Excise and Registration Department, New
Secretariat, Patna.
5.
Niranjan Kumar Son of not known the then Deputy Secretary, Prohibition,
Excise and Registration Department, New Secretariat, Patna and at present
working as Deputy Secretary in Culture and Youth department New
Secretariat, Patna.
Excise
and
Registration
Department,
New
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Pratap Sharma, Advocate
For the State
:
Mr. Madhaw Pd. Yadav, GP-23
Mr. Arvind Kumar, AC to GP-23
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DR. ANSHUMAN
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date : 30-06-2026
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned
counsel for the State.
2. The present writ petition has been filed for
quashing the order dated 30.09.2024 and the consequential order
dated 02.12.2024, whereby a major punishment has been
Patna High Court CWJC No.253 of 2025 dt.30-06-2026
2/13
imposed upon the petitioner by withholding two increments
with cumulative effect, and a further direction has been issued
that the petitioner shall not be entitled to any payment for the
suspension period except the suspension allowance. A further
prayer has been made for setting aside Memo No. 4718 dated
18.08.2025, whereby and whereunder, without considering the
materials available on record, the claim of the petitioner has
been rejected.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the petitioner was appointed to the post of Excise Inspector by
the order of the Member, Board of Revenue, vide Memo No.
4152 dated 19.09.2007, pursuant to an open advertisement
through the BPSC and on its recommendation. Counsel further
submits that the petitioner was placed under suspension vide
order dated 26.06.2023 by respondent No. 5, the Deputy
Secretary, Prohibition, Excise and Registration Department.
4. Counsel further submits that, in light of the order
dated 12.07.2021 (Annexure-P/3) issued by the General
Administration Department, it had already been determined as
to who would be the Disciplinary Authority for the petitioner,
who belongs to Group 'Kha' service. Counsel further submits
that, in that light, the Principal Secretary/Secretary, through the
Patna High Court CWJC No.253 of 2025 dt.30-06-2026
3/13
departmental minister, is the competent authority in respect of
the petitioner.
5. Counsel further submits that the suspension order
dated 26.06.2023 indicates not only the suspension of the
petitioner but also the decision to initiate a departmental
proceeding, which has been taken at the level of the Deputy
Secretary, who is not the competent authority in light of the
letter dated 12.07.2021 (Annexure-P/3) issued by the General
Administration Department. Counsel further submits that since
the suspension order and the decision to initiate the
departmental proceeding against the petitioner were taken by an
incompetent authority, the said decision is non-jurisdictional.
6. Counsel further submits that the petitioner had
approached this Court in CWJC No. 12593 of 2024, wherein,
vide order dated 30.08.2024, liberty was granted to the
petitioner to raise the issue as to whether the order of suspension
is legal, valid and sufficient before the Disciplinary Authority
and the Disciplinary Authority while passing the order shall
decide this question by passing reasoned order within 30 days
from the date of communication of this order. Counsel further
submits that though the co-ordinate Bench of this Court was not
inclined to restrain the respondents from carrying out the
Patna High Court CWJC No.253 of 2025 dt.30-06-2026
4/13
disciplinary proceeding against the petitioner, it was for this
reason that the departmental proceeding was continued against
the petitioner and the charge-memo was issued.
7. Counsel further submits that subsequently, in the
year 2024, the petitioner received a reply to the RTI application,
from which it is evident that on the date the Deputy Secretary
placed the petitioner under suspension and took the decision to
initiate the departmental proceeding, there was no direction
issued by the competent authority, i.e., the disciplinary or
appointing authority, in accordance with the letter dated
12.07.2021 issued by the General Administration Department,
rather, on request, post facto sanction has been demanded by the
Deputy Secretary. Counsel further submits that any action taken
on the basis of such a letter, which was not issued by the
competent authority, is absolutely non-jurisdictional and,
therefore, is fit to be quashed. Consequently, no further
proceeding ought to be initiated against the petitioner on the
basis of such a jurisdictionally defective letter.
8. Counsel further submits, on merits, the chargememo
was
issued
against
the
petitioner
despite
his
objection/representation having been filed, on which no decision
has been taken till date. Counsel further submits that the
Patna High Court CWJC No.253 of 2025 dt.30-06-2026
5/13
petitioner participated in the departmental proceeding, in which
the Enquiry Officer submitted the enquiry report and held that
the petitioner was not involved in the collection of money, as
alleged in the viral video, though his involvement could not be
ruled out on the basis of suspicion. Counsel further submits that
the disciplinary authority found that the petitioner had no
administrative control over the driver, due to which the incident
took place and was recorded in the viral video. Counsel further
submits that the findings recorded in the departmental
proceeding and contained in the enquiry report do not form part
of the articles of charge contained in the charge-memo. Counsel
further submits that it is well settled that any allegation not
forming part of the charge-memo cannot be proved, and no
punishment can be imposed on the basis of such an allegation.
9. Counsel further submits that, in response to the
second show-cause notice, the petitioner raised all the grounds
of his defence, but none of the same was taken into
consideration, and in gross violation of Rule 18(3) of the Bihar
Government Servants (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules,
2005 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Bihar CCA Rules, 2005’),
punishment has been imposed upon the petitioner. Counsel
further submits that the punishment was imposed vide Memo
Patna High Court CWJC No.253 of 2025 dt.30-06-2026
6/13
No. 4038 dated 30.09.2024. Counsel further submits that,
against the said order, the petitioner preferred an appeal, but the
same has also been rejected, and the punishment imposed upon
the petitioner has been upheld. Counsel further submits that
since the appellate order has been passed by the authority during
pendency of the writ petition, therefore, the said order dated
18.08.2025 contained in Memo NO. 4718 (Annexure-P-15) has
been challenged by virtue of the Interlocutory Application No. 1
of 2025 which was subsequently allowed vide order dated
27.04.2026.
10. Counsel further submits that the impugned
orders are liable to be set aside on two grounds, namely, that the
decision to initiate the departmental proceeding is nonjurisdictional, and the petitioner has been punished on the basis
of a charge which does not form part of the charge-memo.
11. Learned counsel for the State, on the other
hand, opposes the pleadings of the writ petition and submits that
every decision taken by the State is completely in accordance
with law. Counsel further submits that the petitioner was
appointed as an Inspector in the year 2007, and prior to the
Bihar Excise Service (Recruitment & Service Conditions)
Rules, 2009, the said post was a non-gazetted post. However,
Patna High Court CWJC No.253 of 2025 dt.30-06-2026
7/13
the post was kept in the gazetted category but, subsequently,
after restructuring of the subordinate services, the post was
declared as a non-gazetted post in the year 2018.
12. Counsel further submits that, in light of the
approval of the State Pay Commission, all the posts of the
Excise Service cadre have been reorganized, and the post of
‘Excise Inspector’ has been renamed as ‘Inspector, Prohibition’
and restructured as a non-gazetted post vide Notification No.
2071 dated 20.06.2018.
13. Counsel further submits that the petitioner has
filed CWJC No. 16918 of 2023, which is still pending before
this Hon’ble Court. Counsel further submits that the appointing
authority for the post of Inspector, Prohibition, is the
Commissioner, Excise. In view of Rule 2(A) of the Bihar CCA
Rules, 2005, the appointing authority is the disciplinary
authority, and in the present case, the Commissioner, Excise has
passed the order of punishment, who is the competent authority.
14. Counsel further submits that the petitioner
preferred an appeal, but the Appellate Authority has affirmed the
order passed by the Disciplinary Authority. Counsel further
submits that there is no deficiency in the orders passed against
the petitioner, and therefore, the present writ petition may be
Patna High Court CWJC No.253 of 2025 dt.30-06-2026
8/13
dismissed, as it is totally misconceived, since there is no
illegality or irregularity in the said orders.
15. In light of the submissions made, it transpires to
this Court that it is true that the petitioner was appointed prior to
the Bihar Excise Service (Recruitment & Service Conditions)
Rules, 2009, on the post of Excise Inspector. Vide notification of
2021, his service status was treated as that of a non-gazetted
post, against which the petitioner has preferred a writ petition
before this Court bearing CWJC No. 16918 of 2023, in which
no decision has been taken till date. Therefore, on the date on
which the proceeding was initiated against the petitioner, he
could not be treated as a gazetted officer, and his status on the
date of initiation of the proceeding was that of a non-gazetted
officer.
16. It further transpires to this Court that even if the
petitioner was a non-gazetted officer, the appointing/disciplinary
authority for the petitioner is the Commissioner, Excise, and not
the Deputy Secretary. From the RTI reply, it transpires to this
Court that post facto sanction was sought by the Deputy
Secretary from the competent authority.
17. This Court, upon perusal of the record,
particularly Annexure-P/4 and P/5, finds that the letter contained
Patna High Court CWJC No.253 of 2025 dt.30-06-2026
9/13
in Memo No. 3359 dated 26.06.2023 is not only a suspension
order but also contains a decision regarding the initiation of the
disciplinary proceeding, with a direction stating that sanction
has been obtained from the competent authority. However, from
the RTI reply, it is clear that on 26.06.2023, no sanction for
initiation of suspension or initiation of departmental proceeding
had been obtained from the competent authority. Therefore, this
Court is of the firm view that, on the date on which the said
order was passed by the Deputy Secretary, no sanction had been
granted by the competent authority either for suspension of the
petitioner or for initiation of the departmental proceeding.
18. This Court is well aware of the legal position
under the Bihar CCA Rules, 2005. There is no provision under
the said Rules for obtaining post facto sanction for suspension
or for taking a decision to initiate disciplinary proceedings.
Rather, the Bihar CCA Rules, 2005, by which the services of the
petitioner are governed, clearly provide that the decision to
initiate a departmental proceeding shall be taken only by the
appointing/disciplinary authority.
19. This Court is also of the view that, even on
merits, the enquiry report records a specific finding that the
petitioner was not taking bribe, as is apparent from the viral
Patna High Court CWJC No.253 of 2025 dt.30-06-2026
10/13
video. However, the finding recorded by the Enquiry Officer is
that the petitioner had no administrative control over his driver.
20. This Court is also surprised that, though a
finding regarding failure of administrative control over the
driver has been recorded, no such allegation is contained in the
charge-memo. Therefore, even on merits, the finding recorded
by the Enquiry Officer is not based on any allegation levelled in
the charge-memo. On this ground also, this Court is not in
agreement with the decision of the Disciplinary Authority and
the Appellate Authority. It further transpires to this Court that
the petitioner had raised these points before the Disciplinary
Authority as well as the Appellate Authority, however, from
both the orders, it transpires that none of the said points have
been discussed or considered by them.
21. After observing the aforesaid findings, counsel
for the State raised a further submission that Annexure-P/4
clearly indicates that the decision was taken after obtaining
sanction from the competent authority.
22. In this regard, the relevant portions of
Annexure-P/4 i.e. order dated 26.06.2023 contained in Memo
No. 3359 and Annexure-P/5 i.e. letter dated 15.04.2024 are
hereby extracted below:-
Patna High Court CWJC No.253 of 2025 dt.30-06-2026
11/13
Patna High Court CWJC No.253 of 2025 dt.30-06-2026
12/13
23. Upon perusal of the report, it transpires to this
Court that on the date and time when Memo No. 3359 dated
26.06.2023 was issued by the Deputy Secretary, no sanction had
been granted by the competent authority.
24. The order dated 30.09.2024 contained in Memo
No. 4038 passed by the Deputy Commissioner, Prohibition,
Bihar Patna (Annexure-12), order dated 02.12.2024 contained in
Patna High Court CWJC No.253 of 2025 dt.30-06-2026
13/13
Memo No. 4999 passed by the Deputy Commissioner,
Prohibition, Bihar Patna (Annexure-13) and order dated
18.08.2025 contained in Memo No. 4718 passed by the Deputy
Secretary to the Government of Bihar, Patna (Annexure-15), are
hereby set aside. The respondents are directed to make the entire
payment due to the petitioner within three months from the date
of production of a copy of this order.
25. In light of the discussions made above, the
present writ petition stands allowed.
(Dr. Anshuman, J.)
Aman Kumar/AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE
Uploading Date
Transmission Date
AFR
NA
07.07.2026
NA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review