Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND
LADAKH AT SRINAGAR
Reserved on: 18.08.2026
Pronounced on: 29.08.2026
Uploaded on: 29.08.2026
Whether the operative part
or full judgment is
pronounced:
Full
CRM(M) No.126/2024
c/w
Bail App No.45/2024
... PETITIONER(S)
FAISAL AHMAD GANIE
Through: -
Mr. Parvaiz Lone, Advocate.
Vs.
…RESPONDENT(S)
UT OF J&K
Through: -
CORAM:
Mr. Mohammad Younis Hafeez, Assisting Counsel.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
01. By this common judgment, afore-titled two petitions
filed by the petitioner, namely, Faisal Ahmad Ganie, one
under Section 482 of Cr. P. C seeking quashment of order
dated 26.02.2024 passed by the learned Additional Sessions
Judge, Kupwara, whereby charges have been framed against
him and the other under Section 439 of Cr. P. C seeking bail
in a case arising out of FIR No.103/2023 for offences under
Section 8/20/29 of NDPS Act registered with Policed Station,
Kupwara, are proposed to be disposed of.
02. Briefly stated, the case of the prosecution is that on
16.05.2023, the police had laid a Naka on the National
CRM(M) No.126/2024 c/w
Bail App No.45/2024
Highway at Kawari Crossing. They intercepted a load carrier
bearing No.JK02L-1826, that was proceeding from Srinagar
towards Kupwara. Upon questioning, the driver of the
vehicle disclosed his name as Sajjad Ahmed Mir. He felt
nervous on spotting the police party, whereafter he was
subjected to search. During the search, five pouches of
charas-like substance, which were wrapped in plastic tape,
were recovered from his trouser. Thereafter the vehicle was
also subjected to search and from there seven more packets
of charas-like substance were recovered. Upon weighing, the
recovered contraband substance was found to be 2.10 kgs
in weight. FIR No.107 of 2023 was registered and
investigation was set into motion.
03. During the course of investigation, the samples were
drawn from the recovered contraband substance and the
same were sealed and sent to FSL for chemical analysis. The
statements of witnesses were recorded and accused Sajjad
Ahmed Mir was arrested. During his interrogation, accused
Sajjad Ahmed Mir made a disclosure statement that he had
obtained the supply of contraband substance from accused
Mashooq Ahmad Malik and it was meant to be delivered to
accused Mudasir Ahmed Malik. The disclosure statement of
accused Sajjad Ahmed Mir was recorded in presence of
witnesses and the Executive Magistrate.
CRM(M) No.126/2024 c/w
Bail App No.45/2024
04. During investigation of the case, accused Mudasir
Ahmad Malik was also arrested and he made a disclosure
statement in the presence of witnesses and the Executive
Magistrate that on 12.05.2023, he had transferred an
amount of Rs.80,000/- from Jammu and Kashmir Bank,
Kralpora, to the account of accused Mashooq Ahmad Malik
for the purpose of getting the supply of charas from him
through accused Sajjad Ahmed Mir. Accused Mashooq
Ahmad Malik was also arrested during investigation of the
case. The investigating agency obtained the CDRs in respect
of the cell phones of the above-named accused and, upon
analysis of the CDRs, accused Faisal Ahmad Ganai (the
petitioner herein), was suspected to be involved in the
conspiracy. The petitioner was also arrested and he made a
disclosure statement admitting his involvement in the
conspiracy. He further disclosed that he knows accused
Sajjad Ahmed Mir and, at his instance, he transferred an
amount of Rs.10,000/- in his bank account on 16.05.2023
from J&K Bank Ltd. Panzgam.
05. The challan was laid against the accused before the
learned
Additional
Sessions
Judge,
Kupwara,
on
31.10.2023 and vide impugned order 26.02.2024, charges
for offences under Sections 8/21, 27A and 29 of the NDPS
CRM(M) No.126/2024 c/w
Bail App No.45/2024
Act were framed against the accused, including the
petitioner herein.
06. It appears that trial of the case has progressed
substantially, inasmuch as out of 18 prosecution witnesses
cited in the challan, statements of as many as 11
prosecution witnesses have already been recorded, which
includes most of the material witnesses.
07. Having regard to the fact that evidence of the
prosecution has progressed substantially and most of the
material witnesses have been examined, it would be too late
in the day to test the legality of the order whereby charges
have been framed against the accused persons including the
petitioner herein. For this reason, this Court declines to go
into the legality of the order passed by the trial court
whereby charges have been framed against the petitioner,
leaving it open to the trial court to go into the contentions
raised by the accused persons including the petitioner
herein at the time of final disposal of the case.
08. That takes us to the application of the petitioner for
grant of bail. According to the petitioner, no contraband
substance has been recovered from his possession and that
there is no material available on record connecting him to
the alleged conspiracy. It has been contended that the
CRM(M) No.126/2024 c/w
Bail App No.45/2024
alleged disclosure statement made by the petitioner before
the police, on the basis of which he is being sought to be
implicated, is not admissible in evidence, as such, there is
no legally admissible evidence on record to connect him with
the alleged crime. It has also been contended that the trial
court, while refusing bail to the petitioner, has not taken all
these aspects into consideration.
09. The respondent-Investigation Agency has contested the
bail application by filing its reply. In its reply, the
respondent, after narrating the allegations made in the
charge-sheet, has contended that the petitioner is involved
in a heinous crime relating to possession of commercial
quantity of contraband substance and, as such, he does not
deserve the concession of bail. It has been contended that
the rigours of Section 37 of the NDPS Act are applicable to
the present case and the petitioner has not been able to
satisfy the requirements of the said provisions so as to claim
bail in his favour. It has also been contended that if the
petitioner is enlarged on bail, he may tamper with the
prosecution witnesses.
10. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused record of the case.
11. As per the allegations made in the charge-sheet, as
narrated hereinbefore, the petitioner is alleged to have
CRM(M) No.126/2024 c/w
Bail App No.45/2024
conspired with other accused in connection with possession
and sale of commercial quantity of contraband substance.
Thus, the rigours of Section 37 of the NDPS Act are
applicable to the present case. Unless the petitioner is able
to satisfy this Court that there are reasonable grounds for
believing that he is not guilty of the offences of which he has
been charged, it would not be legally permissible for this
Court to extend the concession of bail in his favour. The
Court has also to consider as to whether there is any
material on record to show that, in case the petitioner is
enlarged on bail, he may indulge in similar activities.
12. Turning to the facts of the present case, as per the
allegations made in the charge-sheet, the contraband
substance has not been recovered from the immediate
possession of the petitioner. He is sought to be implicated on
the basis of the disclosure statement made by him while in
custody in the presence of police officials. Section 23(1) of
the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSS) makes a confession
made to a police officer inadmissible in evidence. However,
proviso to Section 23 of BSS makes so much of the
information, whether it amounts to a confession or not,
which relates distinctly to the discovery of a fact, admissible
in evidence. Therefore, the disclosure statement made by the
CRM(M) No.126/2024 c/w
Bail App No.45/2024
petitioner while in police custody is admissible only to the
extent it leads to discovery of a fact.
13. If we have a look at the disclosure statement made by
the petitioner before the police, it is revealed that he has
furnished information to the police that an amount of
Rs.10,000/- had been transferred into the account of
accused Mashooq Ahmad Malik on 16.05.2023. If the said
information leads to discovery of the fact relating to transfer
of Rs.10,000/- into the bank account of accused Mashooq
Ahmed Malik, the same is admissible in evidence. However,
other part of the disclosure statement dated 16.05.2023,
wherein the petitioner is stated to have admitted that he had
transferred said amount for the purpose of supply of charas,
prima facie, is not admissible in evidence.
14. There is yet another aspect of the matter which is
required to be noticed. During trial of the case, the statement
of PW-16 Mohammad Ashraf Mir, the person through whom
the petitioner is stated to have got the amount transferred
into the account of accused Mashooq Ahmad Malik, has
been recorded. He has stated that the petitioner came to his
shop at Panzgam and requested him to transfer an amount
of Rs.10,000/- into a bank account, whereafter he
transferred an amount of Rs.10,000/- through his mobile
cell phone into his account and requested him to transfer
CRM(M) No.126/2024 c/w
Bail App No.45/2024
the said amount into the account of another person and,
accordingly, the witness transferred the said amount from
the account of his daughter to the account as per the
instructions of the petitioner. The witness, in his crossexamination, denied having any knowledge about the
petitioner indulging in the business of drug trafficking. He
further stated that he does not know accused Mashooq
Ahmad Malik, in whose account the money was transferred.
This is the only evidence available on record against the
petitioner so far as his involvement in the present case is
concerned.
15. A cursory analysis of the aforesaid evidence reveals
that, at the instance of the petitioner, a sum of Rs.10,000/has been transferred by PW-16 Mohammad Ashraf Mir into
the account of accused Mashooq Ahmad Malik. Merely on
this basis, when the petitioner himself has not transferred
any amount into the account of accused Mashooq Ahmad
Malik, prima facie, it cannot be stated that he is guilty of the
offences for which he has been charged. Thus, the petitioner
has been able to carve out a case for grant of bail in his
favour.
16. There is no material on record to show that the
petitioner has any previous history of having indulged in
CRM(M) No.126/2024 c/w
Bail App No.45/2024
drug trafficking, nor is there any material on record to show
that, in case he is admitted to bail, he is going to indulge in
similar activities. Besides this, as already stated, most of the
material witnesses of the case have already been examined
and, in fact, the evidence to the extent of alleged involvement
of the petitioner in the crime stands already recorded.
Therefore, even if the petitioner is enlarged on bail, there is
hardly any chance of his tampering with the prosecution
witnesses.
17. For what has been discussed hereinabove, while
dismissing the petition challenging the order framing
charges against the petitioner, the application of the
petitioner for grant of bail is allowed and the petitioner is
enlarged on bail, subject to the following conditions:
(i)
That he shall furnish personal bond
in the amount of Rs.1,00,000/
(Rupees one lakh) with two sureties
of the like amount to the
satisfaction of the learned trial
court;
(ii)
That he shall appear before the
learned trial court on each and
every date of hearing till conclusion
of the trial.
(iii)
That he shall not leave the territorial
limits of the Union Territory of J&K
without prior permission of the
learned trial court;
CRM(M) No.126/2024 c/w
Bail App No.45/2024
(iv)
That he shall not intimidate or
tamper with prosecution witnesses/
evidence.
18. Anything said in this order shall have no bearing upon
the merits of the case.
19. The trial court record along with a copy of this
judgment be sent back.
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
Srinagar,
29.08.2026
“Bhat Altaf-Secretary”
Whether the judgment is reportable: YES/NO
CRM(M) No.126/2024 c/w
Bail App No.45/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review