Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
134421
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE SEVENTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION Nos. 4230 and 4217 OF 2024
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 4230 OF 2024
Petition under Article 227 of the constitution of lndia aggrieved by the Order
dated 18-08-2022 Passed in lA No 248 of 2017 in O.S.No.115 of 2023 (Old
O S.No 12 of 2014) on the file of the Court of the Junior Civil J udge-Cum-J udicial
[\/agistrate of First CIass at Nandimyadaram, Peddapalli District.
Between:
'1
. Ethadi Rajeshwar Reddy, S/o.Malla Reddy, aged about 45 years,
Occ.Agricu lture.
2. Ethadi Bhumi Reddy, S/o Bapu Reddy aged about 40 years, Occ.Agriculture.
Both R/o.Kanampalli Village, Dharmaram (M),Peddapalli District.
3. Goli Kistaiah, S/o.Beemaiah, aged about 55 years, Occ.Agirculture
R/o.Dharmaram (V and M).Peddapalli District.
... Petitioners/Defendants
NO.11,12 & 14
AND
Pulugu Venkatesh, S/o, Sath v anarayana Aged about 33 years, Occ.Business
Rlo.10-1 -4218. Alladi pentaia h Nagar West Maredpalli, Secunderabad500026
...RespondenUPlaintiff
2. Devi Lachiah, S/o.Pochaiah Aged about 36 years, Occ.Agriculture
3. Renugunta Sathyanarayana, S/o.Hanmandlu Aged about 45 years,
Occ Agriculture.
4. Adepu Buchaiah, S/o.Pochamallu Aged about 46 years, Occ.Agriculture.
5. Adepu Rajesham, S/o.Pochamallu Aged about 55 years, Occ.Agriculture.
6. Baddam Srinivasa Reddy, S/o.Venkat Reddy Aged about 40 years,
Occ.Ag ricu ltu re.
7. Devi Narsarah, S/o Ramaiah,Aged about 44 years, Occ.Agriculture.
B. Devi Lamirajam, S/o.Ramaiah Aged about 39 years, Occ.Ag ricultu re.
9. Devi Mallesh, S/o.Ehumaiah Aged about 3'1 years, Occ.Agriculture.
-10.
Md.Brsmilla, S/o.Ankus Aged about 48 years, Occ.Agric -r ture.
11. Devi Lachaiah, S/o.Lingaiah Aged about 5'1 years, Occ.,l lriculture. All are
R/o. Erraguntapalli Village,Dharmaram (M), Peddapalli Di trict.
'12. Medi Pochaiah, S/o.Bheemaiah
Aged about 55 years, Cc :.Agriculture.
R/o Dharmaram (V and M). Peddapalli Diskict.
( Respondents 2 to 12 are Not necessary parties to I e petition )
..ResF,r n dents/Defenda nts
lA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 of CPC praying that in the r rcumstances stated
in the affidavit frled in support of the petition, the High Cou- may be pleased to
stay the further proceedings rn suit in O.S.No.115 of 2023 (Olc O.S.No.'12 of 2014)
on the file of the Junior Civil Judge cum-Judicial Magistr: te of First Class,at
Nandimydaram, Peddapalli District Judge, pending disposal o the above Revision
petrtion.
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 42't7 OF 2024
Petition under Article 227 of the constitution of lndia a(1, rieved by the Order
dated 18-08-2022 Passed in lA.No.251 of 2017 in O.S lrl .114 of 2023 (Otd
O.S,No.10 of 2014) on the frle of the Court of the Junior Civil J udge-C um-Jud icial
lVlagistrate of First Class at Nandimyadaram, Peddapalli Distr r l.
Between:
1. Ethadi Rajesher Reddy, S/o.Nlalla Reddy aged abc ut 56 years, Occ
Agriculture.
2 Ethadr Bhumi Reddy, S/o Bapu Reddy aged about 50 y: rrs, Occ.Agriculture
Both R/o.Kanampalli Village, Dharmaram (lV), Peddapalli fistrict.
3. Goh Kistaiah, S/o. Beemaiah, aged about 65 yea', , Occ. Agirculture
R/o.Dharmaram (V and M), Peddapalli District.
...Pe t tioners/Defendants
AND
Kotha Mohan, S/o.Sarvaiah, Aged about 48 years, Occ.Ei
R/o 3-36-270, Sanjeevaiah Colony, West Maredpalli, Ser:
SINESS,
'nderabad-500 026.
...li :s pondenUPla intiff
Devi Lachiah, S/o.Pochaiah Aged about 46 years, Occ.Ac -iculture.
Renugunta Sathyanarayana, S/o. Hanmandlu Aged abou: 55 years,
Occ.Ag ricu ltu re.
Adepu Buchaiah, S/o.Pochamallu Aged about 56 years, _ cc.Agriculture.
Adepu Rajesham, S/o Pochamallu Aged about 65 years, { )cc.Agriculture
Baddam Srinivasa Reddy, S/o.Venkat Reddy Aged abou
Occ.Ag rrcu lture.
i0 years,
7. Devi Narsaiah, Sio.Ramaiah, Aged about 41 years, Occ.Agrlculture.
8. Devi Lamirajam, S/o.Ramaiah Aged about 49 years, Occ.Agriculture.
9. Devi tt/lallesh, S/o.Bhumaiah Aged about 41 years, Occ.Agriculture.
1 0.
lt/d. Bismilla, S/o.Ankus,Aged about 58 years, Occ.Agriculture.
11. Devi Lachaiah, S/o.Lingaiah Aged about 6'1 years, Occ.Agricult'ure. All are
R/o. Erraguntapalli Village, Dharmaram (M), Peddapalli District
12.lVedi Pochaiah, S/o.Bheemaiah Aged about 65 years, Occ.Agriculture
R/o.Dharmaram (V and M). Peddapalli Diskict. (Respondents 2 to 12 are Not
necessary parties to the Revision )
...Respondents/Defendants
lA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 of CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
stay the further proceedings in suit in O.S.No.114 of 2023 (Old O.S No.10 of 2014)
on the file of the Junior Civil Judge cum-Judicial Magistrate of First Class,at
Nandimydaram, Peddapalli District Judge, pending disposal of the above Revision
petition.
Counsel for the Petitioners in both CRPs : SRI P.SRINIVASA RAO ADVOCATE
REPRESENTING SRI PUTLURI
GIRIDHAR ADVOCATE
Counsel for the Respondents in both CRPs : SRI G CHANDRASEKHAR
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
b
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TI} ,ANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE RENUK.A TARA
C.R.P.Nos.423O an d4217 of2024
OTTH JANUARY,2026
C.R.P.No.4230 of 2024
Between:
Ethadi Rajesher Reddy and others
Petitioners
AND
Pulugu Venkatesh and others
. , Respondents
C.R.P.No.42L7 of 2o24
Between:
Ethadi Rajesher Rcddy and others
Petitioners
AND
Kotha Mohan and others
?espondents
COMMON ORDER:
Since the issue involved in both the : evisions is
one and the same, they are being heard t:3ether and
disposed of by way of this common order
2.
Aggrieved by the docket orders dated 8.O8.2O22
passed in I.A.No.248 of 20 17 in O.S.No.1 5 of 2023
(old O.S.No.l2 of 2014) and I.A.No.2Si tf 2Ol7 in
O.S.No.114 of 2023 (old O.S.No.10 of 20,4) by the
Iearned Junior Civil Judge-cum-Judicial lV.. rgistratc of
RY,]
Ctp_423O and 4Zt7 2024
First Class at Nandimyadaram, both the
revisions have
been preferred by the petitioners-defendant
Nos. 11,12
artd 14.
3. Heard Sri p.Srinivasa Rao, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioners_defendant
Nos. 1 1, 12 and,
L4 and Sri G.Chandra Sekhar, learned counsel
appearing for the I", respondent-plaintiff.
4. For the sake of convenience, the facts in
C.R.P.No.4230 of 2024 are discussed hereunder.
5. The 1"t respondent_plaintiff has filed O.S.No.115
of 2023 (old O.S.No.I2 of 2014) seeking perpetual
injunction with respect to the suit schedule property
consisting of Acs.O-34 guntas, out of total
Ac.l3-24 Guntas in
extent of
Sy.No.113, situated at
Erraguntapalli Village under Bommareddypalli revenue
Village of Dharmaram Maldal, Karimnagar District
bounded by East: Land of Shatrajula pochmatlu
and
others; West: Land of Adepu Buchaiah and others;
North: Land of Kotha Mohan and others and South:
RY,.J
Ctl. _4230 and 4211 _2024
r
Land of Odna-la Bhumaiah and others. [l >on receiving
summons in the suit, the revision peti - oners herein
have filed written statements disputing tli I existence of
the suit schedule property on the gror nd that the
boundaries mentioned in the plaint scht duie are not
correct
6.
It is the specihc case of the revisic n petitioners
that the vendors of the plaintiff did not h: ve ownership
and possession over single gunta of 1er Ld 1n Survey
No.113, which had tota-l extent of Ac. 13'114 guntas. A
copy of the written statement producr', I before this
Court shows that there are pleadingr; about nonexistence of the plaint schedule land. As ler the plaint
schedule, the vendor of the 1"t responderL. is not owner
of single gunta of land in Survey No.- 13 when he
executed registered sale deed uide docur rent No.3303
of 2017, dated 24.71.2011 in favout of the 1"t
respondent. Relevant pleadings a( - extracted
hereunder
RY,J
Crp_423O and 42t1 2024
".," .
J}:::il:i[ :::T]::,:.#T:'# :ff Ti#
are totally not identifiable and there
existence for the land of A
were no boundaries are in
t-'u gts Involved in the registered
sare deed. More over ,n.'"so
called vender by name Baddam
Raji Reddl had no single gunta
of land out of the Surt Sy.No.
113 to sell land to the plaintiff
a1d another person by name
Kotha Mohan.
Originally the total extant of Sy.No.
113 is Ac.13 24
of land, the father of plaintiffs
Vendor by name B. Kotaiah and
his brother Venkat Reddy and
his Sister Katnapalli Rajamma are
having three equal shares
out oI above said land.
guntas_ Out of Ac.l3_24 guntas
In turn Akarapu Raji Reddy sold an extant
gts to One Devi Ramaial, an extent
of Ac.O1_1S
of Ac_ l- 15 gts to one Devi
Pochaiah, and Ac. l_15 gts to Devi
Lingaiah purchased an extant of Ac.o_
Lachaiah and one Bore
16 gts. Out of the share
land of l(atnapalti Rajamma, she sold
one Medi pochaiah and Medi
Ac. I _05 gts of land to
Rajaiah under simple sale deed
long back and it was validated under
ROR Act by settting their
respective extents. Further, Katnapalli
Rajamma has given
Ac.1-10 gts of tand to one Kallem Thirupathi
Rcddy, who is the
o!r'n son-in-law of Katnapalli Rajamma, in
turn Kallem
Thirupathi Reddy sold the above said land
to defendant
Nos. 11 and 12 by name lthadi
Rajeshwer Reddy and
Reddy through the registered sale deed
document No. 1386/2012 jointly.
Bhoom
on O5.05.2012 rzde its
Further, defendant No. 2 purchased 0.02 7a
gts of land,
out oI the suit Sy.No.113 from one Nalla Rajamani
simple sale deed who purchased the land
Kistaiah who purchased the same from
under
from one Goli
one Baddam Kohiah,
father of the vendor of the plaintiff. In
the said land,
defendant No. 2 constructed a
House urde its H.No.1_37 and
residing therein. Defendant No.3
purchased an extent
of Ac.O_
04 gts of land out of the suit Sy.No. l3 from
l
one Goli Kistaiah
@ Krishna Murthy who purchased the same from Baddam
Kotaiah on 0l/02/2OO3 under simple sale deed.
Defendant
No.4 had no single gunta of land out of
the suit
RY,J
Ctp_t . \O and 4277 _2024
)
Sy.No.113, defendant No. 5 is also had no single gunl of land
out of the suit Sy. No. 1 14. But the plaintiff made rl fendant
No.5 as party to the suit by keeping into view that (1 fendant
No-5 is the brother's son of the vendor of the ptaintilf
It was clearly mentioned as Ac-1-15 gts was sold to
defendant No. 10 by name Devi Lachaiah. The entire Ac. 1- 15
gts of purchased land is in physical possession and €r ioyment
of defendant No. I 0 only.
Defendant No. 13 rs in possession and enj() ment of
Ac.Q-22 % gts of Iand out of the suit Sy.No. and the ) other of
defendant No- l3 is in possession and enjoyment ol Lr .O-22 %
gts ofland out of the Suit Sy.No, 113
Against the possession and enjoyment of nol )nly the
defendants is the matter but also some third per ;ons by
seeing the name of vendor of the plaintiff. The plaint f created
false documents and hted false Suit.
Whatever the boundaries shown in the suit r chedule
are not so correc[ and no single gunta of land is ; vailable
within the boundaries mentioned in the schedule.
'lhe fact may be true Baddam Kotaiah mal' died by
Ieaving the vendor of the plaintiff as his Legal-heir ar t he did
not left any single gunta of land to his son to sell th l same to
the plaintill and whatever the title and pass book anrl .13 B &
C' certificates are filed by the plaintiff are total J formal
documents and the revenue people have prepared he said
documen t without proper enquiry.
Plaintiff is not at all in possession over he sult
schedule property, the question of interference by the
defendants does not arise.'
7. Upon filing the written statement II the year
2014, after lapse of three years, the 1"t : )spondent-
plaintiff has hled I.A.No.248 of 2Ol7 und: - Order VI
RY,',
Ce_423O and4277 2024
Rule 17 read with Section lS1 CpC
seeking
amendment of the plaint schedule
8. It is pertinent to note that the cause
for
amendment as stated in the affidavit
hled is as follows:
"[ submit that the above respondents/defendants
specilically pleaded that the boundaries
mentioned in the praint
schedule are \{rrong; as such I
co-vendor have approached our common
to get the land measured again to
have
along rvith
m_v
vendor, and requested
determine the boundanes.
That our vendor has considered and agreed
measured and to fix up the boundaries
to get the land
by the competent
authority [n pursuance of the application made
by our vendor,
the Mandal Surveyor, Dharmaram has inspected
the suit survey
number and demarcated the same by lxing
up the boundaries
in the presence of the witnesses. t submit that, the
Surveyor, Dharmaram also prepared a panchanama
e[fect. I have brought the said attested copy of
dated 29.O9.2016 into the Court record and
9.
Mandal
to that
the panchanama,
filed the same.
According to the above pleadings in the affidavit,
after perusing the written statement filed by the
revision petitioners, the 1"r respond.ent along
with co_
vendee, has approached the common vendor
artd
sought measurement of the land to determine
the
boundaries. The common vendor has considered the
same, measured the land and fixed the boundaries.
RY,]
,t t
Ct
t. 4234 and 42!7 _2024
The Manda-l Surveyor has inspected the r uit schedule
land and demarcated the sarne bl, hxirrg the
boundaries in the presence of the u i -nesses and
panchanama was executed to the saic effect. After
conducting Panchanama, the l"t responr ent and his
co-vendee have noticed that the boun,l eries in the
registered sa-le deed are mentioned \ /rongly and
therefore, sought for amendment of thr boundaries
and filed the I.A under revision.
10. In spite of opposition by the revisio r petltroners
by filing counter stating that the amend.r ent is likely
to cause prejudice to them as it take
s
away valid
defence about non-existence of the sr it schedule
property on ground; that by perusing thc pleadings in
the written statement, survey was condl cted, and a
rectification deed was got executed in tlr : year 2016
and then, amendment petition was filec in the year
2017, the trial Court has allowed I.A.No. |48 of 2Ol7
uide ordet dated 18.08.2022. Aggrieved t y the same,
RY,J
Ctp_423O and
42tj 2024
the present revision is preferred by
the petitioners_
defendant Nos. 1 1, 12 and 14
11. In the grounds of revision, it is pleaded
under original document there is a joint
purchase by
the 1st respondent_plaintiff along with other
arrd there is no partition between them
that
vendee
and no division
drawn under rectihcation deed and the
same was
permitted by the learned trial Court without
noticing
the pros and cons. It is emphasized that
the
amendment is based on rectihcation deed
executed in
the year 2O16, which was not present at
the time of
presentation of the plaint. Further,
in a suit for
perpetual injunction, the Court may
take into
consideration the state of affairs as they existed
on the
date of filing of the suit but not later developments
therefore, pleaded that the order passed
and
by the trial
Court is illegal. The reasons cited for allowing
the
amendment i.e., to avoid multiplicity of proceedings
and proper adjudication of suit is unjust and
on such
?easoning, the plaint schedule was altered
in a
RY,J
( p 4230 and 4217 _2024
amendment, which is prejudicial to the interest of the
revision petitioners.
12. In spite of the objections raised n the written
statement, the amendment was permitlt d and thereby
permission was accorded to the 1"t respl:rdent to setup
a new case altogether to claim interest : n the property
which was not available to them and e.r such, prayed
that the impugned order be set aside.
13. During arguments, learned cot nsel for the
revision petitioners relied upon the rati,, Iaid down by
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in lr'.l Reuanna us
AnjanammolDead) bg legal representatiaes qnd.
otherst, wherein it was held as lollows
ttLeave
to amend may be refused if it
introduces a totally different, nerv ald
inconsistent case, or challenges the
fundamenta-l character of the suit.
The proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 ]PC
vrrtually prevents an application for
amendment of pleadings from being a1l wed
after the trial has commenced, unlcss the
Court comes to the conclusion that in rpite
Itzg4s) a scc raz
i
RY,J
Ce_423O and 4277 2024
of due diligence, the party could not have
raised the matter before the commencement
of the trial.
The proviso, to an extent, curtails
absolute discretion to allow amendment at
any stage. Therefore, the burden is on the
person who seeks an amendment after
commencement of the trial to show that in
spite of due diligence, such an arnendment
could not have been sought earlier. There
cannot be any dispute that an amendment
cannot be claimed as a matter of right, and
under all circumstances. Though normally
amendments are allou,ed tn the pleadings to
avoid multipliciry of litigation, rhe Court
needs to take into consideration whether the
application for amendment is bona fide or
mala fide and whether the amendment
causes such prejudice to the other side
which calnot be compensated adequately in
terms of money."
14. Learned counsel also relied on the decision of the
Apex Court in Basauoraj os. Indira qnd otheri
wherein it was held as under:
ttln response,
the learned counsel for
respondents I and 2 submitted that it was
merely an oversight mistake which occurred
at the time of filing of the suit and at the
subsequent stage for which the amendment
was prayed lor by respondents 1 and 2. It is
' 1zozt1 I scc tos
,
RY,J
| 'A_423O aod 4217 _2024
not a case where the pleadrngs to that € Iect
are not available on record. Respondc r s1
zrnd 2 had fairly pleaded about the ee 'lier
compromise decree. lnadvertently, the t r Iycr
for declaration thereof as null and void i ,u Id
not be made. The Court fee also could rr tbc
deposited. No fresh evidence is to be lec. l'he
case is at the arguments stage. The sarn: can
be argued with mere re-framing of the rss les.
lt will avoid multiplicity of litigation
ultimately complete justice will be
,rnd
r
onc
arnongst the parties, who are merely pr I 'ing
for partition of the ancestral property Ihc
other side can be compensated with cos r ,as
was even done by the High Courl
prejudice as such will be caused rr
N<r
the
appellant. Substantial justice will be do' r t()
the parties. In support of t1.e ar:gurnc rts,
reliance was placed upon a judgment o '
fr is
Court in Dondapati Narayala Reddl
Duggireddy Venkatara-rayana Redd1,
rnd
Estralla Rubber v. Dass Estate (P) Ltd."
15. Lastly, reference is made to the ,i :cision of the
Apex Court in Life fnsttrance Corporotion of India
us. Sanjeea Builders Prluate Limited. t,.nd. al.othe€,
wherein, certain guidelines have been issued to be
followed while permitting amendm( nts to the
pleadings, more particularly, Iearned c( unsel for the
t (zozz)ro
scc r
..
RY,J
Ctp_423O and 427j 2OZ4
L2
revision petitioners relied upon the guidelines
issued
by the Hontrle Supreme Court at paras
71.3.2 @) e
(b),71.4.2, 71.4.3 and,71.4.4, which reads
as follows:_
"2t.g.2. To avoid multiphcitv of proceedings,
provided
(a) the amendment does not result
in injustice
to the other side,
(b) by the amendment, thc parties seeking
amendment do not seek to withdraw any clear
admission made by the partv lvhich confers a
right on the other side, and
71.4.2, The amendment changes the nature of
the suit.
71.4.3. The prayer for amendment rs mala fide,
or
77.4.4. By the amendment, the other side loses
a valid defence."
16. On the basis of the above citations, learned
counsel for the revision petitioners contended that
he
is not on the point of commencement of trial but on
the point of prejudice that is likeiy to be caused to the
petitioners-defendalt Nos.l1, 12 and, 14, who have
specifically taken up the plea about non_existence of
the suit schedule property as per the boundaries
mentioned in the plaint schedule.
RY,]
Ctp_42 O and 4277
)
-2024
17. Learned counsel had further contender' that once
the boundaries a-re changed, the 1"t : :sPondentplaintiff has given up the original
C€I C
seeking
perpetual injunction with respect to land as per the
boundaries in the original plaint schecr rle and is
seeking perpetual injunction with respec t to some
other land by producing a Mandal Surveyor report and
rectification deed in support of his case, art I that such
an amendment cannot be Permitted.
18. In support of his contention, learr.t :d counsel
relied on the guidelines issued by the Atrt :x Court in
Ltfe Insurance Corporation of India (3 supro , wherein it
was held that amendment maY not b: permitted,
when such an amendment causes injus tice to the
other side or such an amendment whicl is a clear
admission made by a party which confet
r
a right on
the other side is taken awaY, such an mendment
which changes the nature of the suit anrl by such an
amendment, the other side losses a valid c.' fence.
RY,J
Ctp_423O and 42t7 2024
L4
19. In response, learned counsel for the lst
respondent-plaintiff relied upon the decision
of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Boppidi Ailaiah
us. S
Venkqto.naraso;iq.h q.nd. otherc, wherein,
it is held
as follows:"It is no doubt true that the suit is of the
year 1997 and this application had been
thought of in 2OO2. It is brought to the
notice of this Court that the trial had not
yet commenced_ In view of the fact that
the
bounda:-ies had been specihed in the plarnt
schedule and in the light of the averments
made in the affidavit filed in support of the
application, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the approach adopted by the
learned Judge cannot be sustained. Evcn
otherwise, the merits and demerits which
are to be decided at the stage of trial need
not be gone into at the time of considering
an application for amendment of pleading.
It is made clear that the mcrits and
demerits of the proposed amendment
sought to be introduced may have to be
gone into at the stage of final disposal of the
suit."
20. Further, reliance is placed upon the judgment of
^tAis Court in Smt.p.Shailaja Kumari @ Shaila
' zooslzl ato nt
RY,]
-rp 4230 and 4277 2024
Kumari u. Vasantha Malanrika and anothefi,
wherein it was held as under:
"Mo.eove., the purpose of permir t ng
amendment of pleadings is to a,, rid
multiplicity of proceedings. 't'ris
fundamental principle seems to L:i ve
been lost sight olf by the Court belorr in
considering petitioner's application or
amendment."
2l-
Learned counsel contended thal irnendment of
pleading is permissible as per Order V Rule 17 CpC
as trial in the suit has not yet comm(t tced and it is
necessary for the purpose of avoiding nultiplicity of
proceedings in that context. In the cere of Boppidi
Ailo,iqh (4 supra) when there was a di:; :repancy with
respect to boundaries of the plaint ,,chedule, the
amendment was permitted to rectify tlr r same. The
one distinguishing factor tvith respect ro the said case
and the instant case is that the discre oancy in the
boundaries was between the registered r ale deed and
the plaint schedule. In the said car;:, the plaint
' zor91+1nrt rsr 1rs;
I
I
;f
RY,-I
Ctp_423O and 4277 2024
schedule was permitted to be amended to make
it
inconformity with the boundaries in the sale deed,
whereas, in the instant case, the registered sale deed is
of the year 2Ol1 with wrong boundaries in schedule,
therefore, a rectilication deed was executed in the year
2O16 and thereafter, amendment was sought to the
plaint schedule. In the case of
Shaila Kumari
(5 supra), a suit for perpetual injunction was filed and
after dismissal of the I.A liled seeking temporary
injunction, the petition to amend the prayer and add
certain paragraphs for the purpose of declaration of
title and recovery of possession was permitted. The
reason cited therein was that amendment is permitted
to avoid multiplicity of proceedings. The amendment
permitted in Shaila Kumari,s case (5 supra), is with
respect to nature of suit i.e., a suit for perpetual
injunction was permitted to be converted into a suit for
declaration of title and recovery of possession with
respect to same schedule property without changing
the boundaries. The judgment of Shaila Kumari (5
RY,.J
Ctp _1-, : ) and 4217 _2024
supra) is distinct from the present case. In he case of
Shrrilrz Kurnari, amendment to boundari:; was not
sought, only there was admission about clrt rd on title
and the plaintiff not being in possession anc therefore,
a prayer for declaration of title and :' :covery of
possesslon were permitted to be added ry way of
amendment without changing the bount aries i.e.,
though nature of relief sought has been pr rmitted to
be amended, the suit schedule property re I-rained the
same in Sho:ila Kumari's case. . In the irr;tant case,
the nature of relief sought is not to be chat.ged. What
1S
sought to be changed is the boundar.r s i.e., the
property as described in the plaint suit sch: lule at the
time of liling the suit is not the sarne as tl e property
as it would be after the amendment is permitted.
Therefore, the citations relied upon by t re learned
counsel for the 1 "t respondent-plainti i
are not
applicable to the facts of the present case.
22. In the instant case, a suit is filed J tr relief of
perpetual injunction, and the same is oppos:d by frling
RY,J
Ce_423O and 42t't 2024
written statement taking a specific plea about non_
existence of the suit schedule property as described
in
the plaint schedule and the vendor of the 1"r
respondent not having right, title interest to execute
any sale deed and not being in vacant possession.
Once such a plea is taken in the written statement,
permitting amendment to the pleadings to change the
boundaries would cause prejudice and injustice to the
revision petitioners. The amendment changes nature o[
the suit schedule property as described at the time of
filing the suit and after amendment is permitted, more
importantly, it would cause loss of the va_lid defence to
the revision petitioner.
23. In view of the loregoing discussion, this Court is
of the considered opinion that the amendment ought
not to have permitted and therefore, the impugned
orders are liable to be set aside.
24. Accordingly, both the Civil Revision petitions are
a-llowed by setting aside the impugned orders dated
18.O8.2O22 passed in I.A.No.248 of
20t7 in
RY,J
CrP_42 i0 and 4277 _2024
O.S.No.1 15 of 2023 and LA.No.251 ol 2017 in
O.S.No.114 of 2023 by the Junior Civil ,Judge-cum-
Judicial Magistrate of First Class at Nandi nyada_ram
No costs.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pend l Lg in these
petitions, shall stand closed.
SD/- T. OSMAN ALI BAIG
AS{i STANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
(->
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Junior Civrl Judge-Cum-Judrcial Magistrate of First Class at
Nandimyadaram, Peddapalli District. (with records if arr, )
2. One CC to SRI PUTLURT ctRtDHAR, Advocate tOpUCl
3. One CC to SRI c CHANDRASEKHAR, Advocate [OpU( ]
4. Two CD Copies
+, ADK/psl
ld
I
HIGH COURT
DATED:07 t0112026
(.\ )
c)
i,,
; 3 JAll 2028
'2.
:': I
,i,
_'
-^. :.\/-..
': -:-=----:1,'-7'
COMMON ORDER
CRP.Nos.4230 and 4217
o12024
ALLOWING THE BOTH
WITHOUT COSTS
CRPs
t.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review