Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No. J(2)
In the High Court at Calcutta
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’be Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya
And
The Hon’ble Justice Supratim Bhattacharya
F.M.A. 695 of 2025
Estate of Narayan Chandra Ghosh
Vs.
Board of Trustees and others
For the appellant
:
Mr. Haradhan Banerjee
Mr. Pradeep Kumar
Mr. Suresh Kumar Sahoo
For the respondents
:
Mr. Subhankar Nag
Mr. Snehashis Sen
Mr. Adipta Kumar Pandit
Heard on
:
22.01.2026
Judgment on
:
22.01.2026
Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.:-
1.
The present appeal has been preferred against the judgment of a
learned Single Judge of this Court dismissing a writ petition of
the appellant.
2.
The present appellant/writ petitioner filed the application under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India on behalf of the estate of
late Narayan Chandra Ghosh, alleging that the officers of the
respondent-authority, that is, the Board of Trustees, Kolkata
Port Trust (now Shyama Prasad Mukherjee Port, Kolkata) evicted
the appellant from the subject property without due process of
law.
3.
The learned Single Judge proceeded on the premise that a deed
of trust was executed by Narayan Chandra Ghosh, the original
lessee, on October 14, 1938, by virtue of which one Pannalal
Ghosh, second son of Narayan Chandra Ghosh and Raj Krishna
Ghosh, sixth son, became the joint trustees.
4.
On the death of one of the trustees, the remaining trustee would
be the sole trustee.
5.
However, after recording the same, the learned Single Judge
proceeded on the premise that the materials-on-record suggests
that an order of eviction was passed against the legal heirs of
late Narayan Chandra Ghosh under Section 5 of the Public
Premises (Eviction of Unauthorized Occupants) Act, 1971.
6.
The learned Single Judge held that since Section 9 of the said
Act provides for an appeal against the order of eviction passed
under Section 5, the appellant had an equally efficacious
alternative remedy by way of such appeal.
7.
Accordingly, on the ground of availability of such alternative
remedy, the writ petition was held to be not maintainable and
consequentially dismissed.
8.
Learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant submits that
during pendency of the writ petition, by way of a supplementary
affidavit, the writ petitioner had clarified that he was grandson
of the original tenant Narayan Chandra Ghosh and one of his
surviving heirs.
9.
Thus, even as an heir of Narayan Chandra Ghosh, the writ
petitioner/appellant was entitled to inherit the tenancy along
with the other heirs of the original tenant late Narayan Chandra
Ghosh.
10. It is submitted that the writ petitioner had filed the writ petition
in representative capacity on behalf of all the co-lessees, being
heirs of the original lessee Narayan Chandra Ghosh (since
deceased).
11. Thus, it is argued that the learned Single Judge proceeded on a
perverse premise by holding that an order of eviction was passed
against the legal heirs of Narayan Chandra Ghosh, whereas the
respondent-authorities
themselves
admitted
in
a
written
information given on June 2, 2017 that no proceedings have
been initiated against the legal heirs of late Narayan Chandra
Ghosh, although the tenancy of such heirs had been terminated.
12. Thus, the ouster of the legal heirs of late Narayan Chandra
Ghosh, being the current lessees of the subject property, without
following due process of law, was vitiated in law.
13. Accordingly, it is argued that the impugned order ought to be set
aside and possession restored to the said surviving lessees.
14. Learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
respondent-authorities
submits that by operation of Section 111(f) of the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882, it has to be construed that there was implied
surrender of the subject property by the heirs of late Narayan
Chandra Ghosh in favour of the lessor/respondent no.1.
15. It is argued that since the property was found to be vacant on
inspection by the respondents, the principle of Section 111(f)
applies.
16. In support of his contention, learned counsel cites a Division
Bench Judgment of the Delhi High Court in the matter of
Municipal Corporation of Delhi vs. Ashok Kumar Mishra and
another reported at ILR (2007) II Delhi 259.
17. Upon hearing learned counsel for both sides, we find from the
impugned judgment that the learned Single Judge proceeded to
hold that there was material to suggest that an order of eviction
was passed, without any such material actually being on record
and contrary to the admission of the respondents that no
eviction proceedings were initiated against the heirs of late
Narayan Chandra Ghosh, the original lessee, thus rendering the
impugned order perverse.
18. On the contrary, from the written information furnished by the
Senior Assistant Estate Manager and CPIO, Estate Division of
the Kolkata Port Trust dated June 2, 2017, it is evident that no
proceedings had been initiated against the legal heirs of late
Narayan Chandra Ghosh in respect of the premises-in-question.
19. Coupled with the same, it is found from an eviction notice dated
June 15, 1983, which was also produced before the writ court,
that the heirs and legal representatives of late Narayan Chandra
Ghosh, including the present petitioner, by admitting them to be
the monthly tenants of the respondent no.1, were asked by the
respondent-authorities to quit, vacate and deliver up the vacant
and peaceful possession of the subject property.
20. From a bare perusal of the same, it is evident that the argument
of the respondents as to implied surrender falls flat, since the
respondents
themselves,
in
the
quit
notice,
categorically
admitted that the heirs of late Narayan Chandra Ghosh had
become monthly tenants.
21. Furthermore, the issuance of the notice to quit and vacate itself
pre-supposes that the possession of the said heirs of the original
lessee, late Narayan Chandra Ghosh, in respect of the subject
property was admitted by the respondent authorities.
22. Even otherwise, the law of evidence is well-settled that once the
commencement
of
a
lessor/lessee
relationship
is
established/admitted, it is the burden and the initial onus of the
person disputing the continuance of such relationship to prove
the cessation of the said jural relationship.
23. In the present case, there is precious nothing on record to
establish the respondents’ plea of implied surrender by the said
heirs of late Narayan, who are admitted co-lessees in respect of
the property-in-question.
24. In the cited judgment of the Delhi High Court, the facts were
completely different.
25. In paragraph no. 5 of the said judgment, the admitted position
was recorded to be that the building-in-question was declared as
dangerous building and the Municipal Corporation of Delhi
(MCD) had itself demolished the building in the year 1970, after
which the MCD had shifted its school situated there to some
other site and at that time all the belongings of the MCD were
removed and there was nothing in existence as on that date.
Moreover, the MCD had stopped paying rent also from the year
1970 onwards, after the demolition of the property, and the land
was taken possession of by the then owner and new structure
constructed thereon. Only in such factual backdrop did the
Division Bench of the Delhi High Court observe that there was
implied surrender under Section 111(f) of the 1882 Act.
26. However, as opposed thereto, in the instant case, not an iota of
evidence of implied surrender has been furnished on behalf of
the respondents.
27. Rather, by issuance of the eviction notice, it was categorically
admitted by the respondents not only that the heirs of late
Narayan Chandra Ghosh were in possession of the property but
that they were also monthly tenants until the notice to quit was
issued to them.
28. Hence, the only remedy in law which was available to the
respondent authorities was to initiate an eviction proceeding
under Section 5 the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised
Occupants) Act, 1971 after issuing a proper show cause notice
under Section 4 of the said Act.
29. Having not done so, the eviction of the petitioner as well as the
other heirs of late Narayan Chandra Ghosh (who were admitted
in the quit notice dated June 15, 1983 to be lessees in
possession
of
the
subject
property)
by
the
respondent-
authorities without due process of law was palpably illegal and
de hors the law.
30. Thus, the learned Single Judge acted in a perverse manner and
failed to exercise jurisdiction vested in him by law in not
allowing the writ petition, thereby directing the possession of the
disputed premises to be restored to the writ petitioner/appellant
as well as other heirs and legal representatives of the deceased
Narayan Chandra Ghosh on the patently erroneous premise that
an eviction order had been passed against them under Section 5
of the 1971 Act.
31. We make it clear that although several capacities were disclosed
in respect of himself by the writ petitioner/appellant in the writ
petition initially, in some places as manager of the estate of the
deceased Narayan Chandra and in others as trustee, ultimately,
by a supplementary affidavit, it was clarified that the petitioner,
being the grandson of late Narayan Chandra Ghosh, was one of
the heirs of the said deceased and was acting in representative
capacity for all the other heirs, that is, the estate of the
deceased original lessee.
32. Keeping in view of such factual premise, it would only be
appropriate to direct restoration of possession to all the colessees, being the surviving heirs of late Narayan Chandra
Ghosh, as per the admission in the quit notice dated June 15,
1983 issued by the Land Manager of the Board of Trustees, Port
of Kolkata.
33. However, for the sake of convenience, such possession ought to
be handed over to the present petitioner/appellant, who will
receive the same on behalf of himself and the other co-lessees.
34. Such possession, as and when handed over, shall be deemed to
be the joint possession of all the co-lessees, as named in the quit
notice dated June 15, 1983, appearing at page- 66 of the Paper
Book of the instant appeal.
35. By no stretch of imagination, such possession, when handed
over, shall be construed to be exclusive to the writ petitioner in
view of our above observations.
36. Accordingly, FMA No. 695 of 2025 is allowed on contest, thereby
setting aside the impugned judgment and order dated August
31, 2023 passed in WPA No. 2099 of 2011 and directing the
respondent-authorities to hand over peaceful and unencumbered
vacant possession of the subject premises, as described in the
quit notice dated June 15, 1983, to the writ petitioner/appellant
within ninety days from this date.
37. It is made clear that such possession, as and when handed over,
shall
be
construed
to
be
accepted
by
the
writ
petitioner/appellant on behalf of all the other surviving colessees, being the surviving heirs of late Narayan Chandra
Ghosh, the original lessee, as described in the aforementioned
quite notice dated June 15, 1983.
38. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
39. It is made clear that nothing in the above judgment will prevent
the
respondent
authorities
from
initiating
appropriate
proceedings in accordance with law for eviction/recovery of
arrears of rent and/or other dues, if the respondents are so
entitled, against the petitioner as well as the other heirs and
legal representatives of late Narayan Chandra Ghosh (co -lessees
in respect of the subject property) without being prejudiced in
any manner by any of the observations made in this judgment.
40. There will be no order as to costs.
41. Urgent photostat copies of this judgment, if applied for, be given
to the parties upon compliance of all requisite formalities.
(Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.)
I agree.
(Supratim Bhattacharya, J.)
AD-03-04
AK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review