Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:13782
NAFR
VAIBHAV
SINGH
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
VAIBHAV SINGH
Date: 2026.03.27
11:44:51 +0530
ARBR No. 56 of 2025
Esds Software Solution Limited Through Its Authorised Signatory Mr.
Rajeev Thakur Having Its Registered Office At Plot No. B- 24 And 25,
Nice Industrial Area Satpur Midc Road Nashik Maharashtra - 422007
...Applicant
versus
Chhattisgarh Infotech Promotion Society (Chips) Through Its Chief
Executive Officer 2nd And 3rd Floor, State Data Centre Building, Opp.
New Circuit House, Civil Lines, Raipur, Chhattisgarh- 492001
...Respondent
For Applicant
: Mr. Anmol Singh Khanuja, Advocate.
For Respondent
: Mr. Rishabh Garg, Advocate.(through V.C.)
Hon’ble Mr. Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Order on Board
23.03.2026
1. This is an application under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short, “the Act of 1996”) for appointment
of an arbitrator.
2. The applicant has prayed for the following relief:-
a.
Appoint a Sole Arbitrator, to adjudicate the dispute
between the parties arising out of the MSA dated
24.12.2021 pertaining to the IPeG Project between
the applicant and the Non-Applicant/Respondent;
And/or
b.
Grant such other order(s) as this Hon'ble Court
may deem fit in the interest of justice.
3. The fact, in brief, as projected by the applicant is that the ESDS
Software Solution Limited (hereinafter referred to as “ESDS” or
“Applicant”), is a public company duly incorporated under the
Companies Act, having CIN U72200MH2005PLC155433 and
registered office at Nashik, Maharashtra. The applicant is a leading
and diversified entity engaged in information and communications
technology solutions, including large-scale e-Governance platforms,
secure cloud hosting, programme management, operations and
maintenance, and allied digital infrastructure services. The applicant
is represented through its authorised signatory and Power of
Attorney Holder. The respondent, Chhattisgarh Infotech Promotion
Society (CHiPS), is a registered society promoted by the
Government of Chhattisgarh and functions as the State’s nodal
agency for implementation of IT initiatives and e-Governance
projects, including those under the National e-Governance Plan
(NeGP). In association with the World Bank, the respondent issued
request for proposal (RFP) No. 81971/CEO/CHIPS/IPEG/2021
dated 19.08.2021 for implementation of the Integrated Proactive eGovernance System (IPeG Project), aimed at providing a unified
digital platform for delivery of government services to citizens.
Pursuant to the RFP, the applicant participated in the bidding
process and was selected as the Master System Integrator (MSI).
Accordingly, a Letter of Intent dated 30.10.2021 was issued in its
favour, followed by execution of a Master Service Agreement (MSA)
dated 24.12.2021 between the applicant and the respondent,
governing the rights and obligations of the parties. The scope of the
Project included design, development, integration, hosting, security
certification, and operation of a unified citizen-centric platform,
along with integration of identity systems, payment gateways,
dashboards, grievance redressal mechanisms, and programme
management functions. That upon commencement of the Project,
the applicant mobilized its resources and undertook development of
the platform, including core and extended modules. However, the
progress of the Project was substantially dependent on fulfillment of
several owner-side prerequisites, including provisioning of UIDAI
authentication services (AUA/KUA), Aadhaar Data Vault (ADV),
departmental datasets, and payment gateway approvals. That
despite repeated communications from the applicant since early
2022, the respondent failed to ensure timely provisioning of these
critical dependencies. The absence of these prerequisites materially
impeded the progress of the Project and delayed transition to User
Acceptance Testing (UAT), certification and Go-Live stages. The
Project envisaged milestone-based progression culminating in UAT,
followed by security certification through STQC and eventual GoLive. The applicant submitted multiple milestone deliverables and
demonstrated functional modules on various occasions; however,
the Respondent failed to schedule and complete UAT, which was a
condition precedent for further progress. Further complications
arose on account of delays in data sharing by the Respondent. A
tripartite Memorandum of Understanding dated 07.12.2022 was
executed between the applicant, respondent and Foundation for
Science, Innovation and Development (FSID) for enabling secure
data exchange. However, due to non-payment by the respondent,
FSID suspended its services, thereby severely impacting testing
and integration activities. The respondent issued a cure notice
dated 27.08.2024 alleging delay, to which the applicant replied on
25.09.2024, clearly explaining that the delays were attributable to
non-fulfilment of owner-side obligations, including lack of UAT
scheduling and data provisioning. Despite the above, the
respondent issued a termination notice dated 28.05.2025 alleging
non-performance and imposing penalties, which, as per the
applicant, are arbitrary, contrary to contractual provisions and
beyond the permissible limits. That immediately thereafter, the
applicant
issued
communications
dated
29.05.2025
and
05.06.2025, disputing the allegations, highlighting contractual
breaches by the Respondent, and requesting adherence to dispute
resolution mechanisms, including restraint on invocation of bank
guarantees.
4. It is further submitted that the contractual term of the MSA expired
on 23.12.2024, and prior thereto, the applicant had sought
extension of the Project period vide letter dated 11.12.2024 to
enable completion of pending dependencies and UAT; however, no
response was received from the Respondent. The disputes
between the parties thus crystallised upon issuance of the
termination notice and related communications, giving rise to
arbitrable disputes. That Clause 25 of the MSA provides for a
dispute resolution mechanism comprising escalation, mediation,
and thereafter arbitration. In accordance with the said clause, the
applicant invoked mediation vide notice dated 09.06.2025, however,
the respondent failed to participate, and no settlement was reached.
Thereafter, the applicant invoked arbitration vide notice dated
26.06.2025 and called upon the respondent to mutually agree upon
appointment of a Sole Arbitrator. However, despite lapse of the
contractual period of one month, no consensus was reached, nor
was any arbitrator appointed. That the failure of the respondent to
act in accordance with the agreed procedure constitutes failure of
the appointment mechanism, thereby attracting the jurisdiction of
this Hon’ble Court under Sections 11(5) and 11(6) of the Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996. The seat and venue of arbitration is
Raipur, Chhattisgarh, and the parties have expressly agreed that
this Hon’ble Court shall have jurisdiction to appoint the Arbitrator. A
substantial part of the cause of action has also arisen within the
State of Chhattisgarh. The present Application is within limitation.
The disputes crystallized upon termination dated 28.05.2025 and
subsequent invocation of arbitration dated 26.06.2025. The present
application is confined to appointment of an Arbitrator and does not
seek adjudication on merits. The applicant has not filed any other
application seeking appointment of an Arbitrator in respect of the
same dispute. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, it is
just, proper and necessary that this Hon’ble Court may be pleased
to appoint an independent, impartial and competent Sole Arbitrator
to adjudicate the disputes between the parties.
5. Mr. Anmol Singh Khanuja, learned counsel for the applicant,
submits that the applicant, ESDS Software Solution Limited,
respectfully submits that despite successful execution of substantial
portions of the work under the Master Service Agreement dated
24.12.2021, the respondent has failed to release the legitimate dues
payable to the applicant, even after repeated requests, reminders,
and formal notices. The applicant duly performed its obligations by
mobilizing resources, developing core and extended modules, and
submitting milestone deliverables from time to time; however,
payments linked to such milestones have been wrongfully withheld
by the respondent without any lawful justification. The applicant
further submits that the project progression was significantly
dependent upon owner-side prerequisites such as provisioning of
AUA/KUA services, Aadhaar Data Vault (ADV), departmental
datasets, and data exchange mechanisms, which were either
delayed or not made available in a timely and continuous manner,
thereby impeding completion of subsequent stages like User
Acceptance Testing (UAT) and certification. Thus, the delay, if any,
cannot be attributed solely to the applicant.
6. Mr. Khanuja, further submits that the disputes and differences
having arisen between the parties, the applicant duly invoked the
dispute resolution mechanism as contemplated under the contract,
including issuance of notices seeking amicable resolution and
thereafter invoking arbitration. However, despite receipt of such
notices, the respondent failed and neglected to appoint an arbitrator
within the stipulated period of 30 days, as required under the
agreed terms. The inaction and failure of the respondent to act in
accordance with the arbitration clause clearly demonstrate its
unwillingness to resolve the disputes through the agreed contractual
mechanism, thereby frustrating the very purpose of the arbitration
agreement between the parties.
7. He further submits that in these circumstances, the applicant left
with no efficacious alternative remedy except to approach this
Hon’ble Court under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 for appointment of an independent Sole Arbitrator. The
existence of a valid and binding arbitration clause between the
parties is undisputed, and the failure of the respondent to act in
terms thereof necessitates judicial intervention. The applicant
submits that the disputes raised are bona fide, live, and arbitrable in
nature, and therefore, for the ends of justice and proper adjudication
of disputes, it is necessary that this Hon’ble Court be pleased to
appoint an independent and impartial Sole Arbitrator to adjudicate
upon the disputes between the parties.
8. Mr. Rishabh Garg, learned counsel for the respondent submits that
the present application is wholly misconceived, frivolous, and
devoid of merit, having been filed on the basis of false, misleading,
and afterthought allegations. The respondent denies each and
every averment made by the applicant, save and except those
specifically admitted herein, and submits that nothing in this reply
shall be deemed to have been admitted merely for want of specific
denial. It is further submitted that the present petition itself is not
maintainable in law, as the applicant has failed to establish proper
authorization to institute the proceedings, and the alleged Board
Resolution dated 16.10.2025 is invalid and not in accordance with
law, thereby rendering the filing of the present application defective
and unsustainable at the threshold.
9. Mr. Garg, further submits that the applicant has consistently failed to
perform its contractual obligations under the Master Service
Agreement dated 24.12.2021 and has attempted to shift the burden
of its own defaults upon the respondent by making baseless and
unsubstantiated allegations. It is denied that the applicant mobilized
adequate resources, developed functional modules, or achieved
any milestone in accordance with the contract. On the contrary, the
deliverables, if any, were incomplete, deficient, and not fit for User
Acceptance Testing (UAT), which prevented further progression of
the project. The allegations regarding non-provisioning of AUA/KUA
services, Aadhaar Data Vault (ADV), datasets, payment gateway
integration, or data exchange through FSID are wholly incorrect and
are merely an afterthought to conceal the applicant’s inefficiency
and non-performance. Despite issuance of a Cure Notice dated
27.08.2024 granting sufficient opportunity to remedy the defects,
the applicant failed to take any corrective steps, compelling the
respondent to terminate the contract on 28.05.2025 strictly in
accordance with the agreed terms and to impose penalties as per
the contract.
10.
He further submits that the applicant has failed to comply with
the mandatory pre-conditions for invocation of arbitration as
stipulated under Clause 25 of the Master Service Agreement as well
as Section 21 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The
applicant did not issue any valid demand notice setting out the
disputes and claims in the manner prescribed, nor did it adhere to
the agreed dispute resolution mechanism, including escalation
procedures, mediation, and reference to experts prior to invoking
arbitration. In the absence of compliance with these mandatory prerequisites, no valid dispute can be said to have arisen or been
referred to arbitration, and consequently, the present application
under Section 11(6) is premature and not maintainable. The
allegations that the respondent failed to appoint an arbitrator within
the stipulated period are also denied, as no valid invocation of
arbitration was ever made by the applicant. In view of the above, it
is submitted that the present application is an abuse of the process
of law, filed with the sole intention of evading contractual liabilities
and creating an artificial dispute where none exists. The applicant,
being in material breach of the contract, cannot be permitted to take
advantage of its own wrongs or seek equitable relief from this
Hon’ble Court. Accordingly, it is most humbly prayed that this
Hon’ble Court may be pleased to dismiss the present application
under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as
being not maintainable, devoid of merit, and filed in contravention of
the contractual and statutory provisions, along with such other
reliefs as this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper in the facts
and circumstances of the case.
11. I have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties, perused the
pleadings and documents appended thereto.
12. Clause 25 of the MSA provides for a dispute resolution mechanism,
which reads as under:a. This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in
accordance with the laws of India without giving effect to
conflict of law rules. The parties expressly agree to exclude
me application of the U.N. Convention on Contracts for the
International Sale of Goods (1980) to this Agreement and
the performance of the parties contemplates under this
Agreemars to the extent that such convention might
otherwise be applicable
b. Any dispute ansing out of or in connection with this
Agreement or the SLA shall in the first instance be dealt
with in accordance with the escalation procedure as set out
in the Governance Schedule set out as Schedule V of this
Agreement
c. In case the escalations do not help in resolution of the
problem within 3 weeks of escalation, both the parties
should agree on a mediator for communication between
the two parties. The process of the mediation would be as
follows:
● Aggrieved party should refer the dispute to
the identitled mediator in writing, with a copy
to the other party Such a reference should
contain a description of the nature of tha
dispute, the quantum in dispute (if any) and
the relief or remedy sought suitable
● The mediator shall use his best endeavors
to conclude the mediation within a certain
number of days of his appointment
● If no resolution can be reached through
mutual discussion or mediation within 30 days
then the matter should be referred to Exparts
for advising on the issue.
d. Any dispute or difference whatsoever arising between
the parties to this Contract out of or relating to the
construction, meaning, scope, operation or effect of this
Contract or the validity of the breach thereof shall be
referred to a sole Arbitrator to be appointed by mutual
consent of both the parties herein. If the parties cannot
agree on the appointment of the Arbitrator within a period
of one month from the notification by one party to the
other of existence of such dispute, then the Arbitrator
shall be appointed by the Honorable High Court of
Chhattisgarh (Bilaspur, India). The provisions of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 will be applicable
and the award made there under shall be final and
binding upon the parties hereto, subject to legal remedies
available under the law. Such differences shall be
deemed to be a submission to arbitration under the
Indian Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, or of any
modifications, Rules or re-enactment thereof. The
Arbitration
proceedings
will
be
held
at
Raipur,
Chhattisgarh, India. Any legal dispute will come under the
sole jurisdiction of Chhattisgarh. India.
e. Compliance with laws: Each party will comply with all
applicable export and import laws and regulations.
● Risk of Loss: For each hardware item,
MSI bears the risk of loss or damage up to
the
time
it
is
delivered
to
the
Implementation/CHiPS-designated carrier for
shipment to CHIPS or CHIPS's designated
location.
● Third party components: MSI will provide
all third-party components solely on a passthrough basis in accordance with the relevant
third-party terms and conditions.
13. Though the respondents have vehemently opposed the present
arbitration request petition, but this Court, having regard to the
existence of an arbitration agreement and the failure of the
respondents to act in accordance with the agreed procedure, is of
the considered opinion that the disputes deserve to be referred to
arbitration. Accordingly, the disputes between the parties are
referred to the sole arbitration of a retired Judge of this High Court,
to be appointed in accordance with law.
14. In view of the above, Hon’ble Mr. Justice Deepak Kumar Tiwari a
retired Judge of this High Court is appointed to act as the Sole
Arbitrator to resolve the dispute involved in this arbitration request
between the parties a retired Judge of this High Court, to act as the
Sole Arbitrator for resolving the dispute between the parties before
whom the respondent shall be at liberty to raise all his objections,
as has been raised herein.
15. The Registry is directed to communicate this order to Hon’ble Mr.
Justice Deepak Kumar Tiwari in the proper address.
16. The remuneration of the Arbitrator shall be settled with the mutual
consent of the parties.
17. The arbitration request petition, accordingly, stands allowed.
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
CHIEF JUSTICE
vaibhav
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review