Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MLHC:582
Serial No. 46
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 460 of 2024
Date of Decision: 09.06.2026
Shri Edmund Charlesterwell Nongrum,
S/o (L) P.S. Swer,
R/o Lawsohtun, Block-2,
P.O. & P.S. Laban,
East Khasi Hills District, Shillong-793004,
Meghalaya
…. Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. State of Meghalaya represented by
Chief Secretary Government of Meghalaya
2. The Secretary & Commissioner,
Health & Family Welfare Department,
Shillong, Meghalaya
3. The Under Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya,
Health and Family Welfare Department.
4. The Director of Health Services (MI),
Health Complex, Red Hills,
Laitumkhrah, Shillong-793003.
5. The Under Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya,
Personnel & Admn. Reforms (B) Department,
Shillong-793001.
…. Respondent(s)
2026:MLHC:582
________________________________________________________
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Ms. R. Kharshiing, Adv. with
Ms. F. Langbnang, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Mr. E.R. Chnye, GA
Ms. Z.E Nongkynrih, GA
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
Yes/No
in press:
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
Yes/No
The petitioner is before this Court with a prayer for
regularization of the services with effect from his initial date of
appointment as LDA since 03.04.1998, and to include him under the Old
Pension Scheme, on the ground that the same benefit has been allowed
to other similarly situated persons who have been regularized at a much
later date but appointed as adhoc/temporary before 31.12. 2007.
2.
The brief facts are that the petitioner, was appointed as LDA
on 03.04.1998 and continued in service on being extended till
2026:MLHC:582
19.12.2003, and despite no formal regularization, continued to work and
received pay equivalent to regular employees. Though he was
subsequently allowed to officiate as LDA, vide an office order dated
30.04.2010, the question of his regularization remained. The petitioner
then filed a writ petition being WP(C) No. 26 of 2013, wherein this Court
by order dated 05.05.2014, directed the respondents to consider the
representation of the petitioner sympathetically in view of his 15 years
of continuous service. The services of the petitioner were then
regularized with effect from 01.07.2015, which however, rendered him
ineligible to be put under the Old Pension Scheme, on account of the new
Pension Scheme being implemented from 01.04.2010. The petitioner
thereafter, pursued his case and though there was no positive indication
from the respondents as to any change in the retrospectivity of
regularization, submitted fresh representations upon learning that by a
Cabinet decision of October, 2022, benefit under the Old Pension
Scheme had been extended to all regularized adhoc employees who
entered service before 31.12.2007. However, to the petitioner’s
representation, the respondents by letter dated 06.03.2024, reiterated the
Department’s decision of the date of regularization on the ground that it
was in compliance with the Court’s order dated 05.05.2014.
2026:MLHC:582
3.
It has been argued by Ms. R. Kharshiing, the learned counsel
for the petitioner that firstly, his regularization should have occurred as
early as 2006, but was delayed due to the failure of the respondent No.
4, to comply with the requirements from the Government, which on
earlier dates i.e. by communications dated 11.12.2006, and 03.04.2009,
had already favourably considered the case of the petitioner for
regularization. Reliance has also been placed on Rule-10 of The
Meghalaya Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1993 that provides that the
qualifying service be calculated from the date of first appointment
(including temporary or officiating capacities) and on the Office
Memorandum dated 21.12.2022, that regularized 3635 adhoc employees
who were placed under the Old Pension Scheme, which she submits
should equally apply to the petitioner.
4.
It is then contended that the petitioner cannot be forced into
the New Pension Scheme, as the delay has been caused by the
respondents and further the Old Pension Scheme having been granted to
3635 similarly situated adhoc employees, this benefit cannot be withheld
from the petitioner, inasmuch as, his appointment was before the cut-off
date i.e. 31.12.2007. Learned counsel therefore, prays that the petitioner
be allowed the benefit of being placed under the Old Pension Scheme,
2026:MLHC:582
and in support of her submissions, has relied upon the following
decisions: -
5.
i)
Aplyne Mary Sunn vs. State of Meghalaya 2019 SCC OnLine
Megh 247
ii)
Rupak Chandra Kalita vs. State of Assam Rep. by the
Secretary & Ors. 2025 SCC OnLine Gau 603
Mr. N.D. Chullai, learned AAG assisted by Ms. Z.E.
Nongkynrih, learned GA for the respondents in reply has submitted that
the regularization of the petitioner was not an automatic right, but was
done in compliance with the High Court judgment dated 05.05.2014,
which directed for the consideration of the petitioner’s case on
sympathetic and humanitarian grounds. The learned AAG has submitted
that the New Pension Scheme was already in force, both at the time of
the passing of the High Court’s judgment, and at the time of the
petitioner’s regularization in 2015 and as such the petitioner is squarely
covered under the New Pension Scheme, which came into force on
01.04.2010. In this context, the learned AAG has referred to Clause-2
and 3.1 of the Guidelines for implementation, of the NPS to show that
the Scheme was to made applicable to all new entrants who joined State
Government service on a regular basis against sanctioned vacant posts
on or after 01.04.2010, and that the same would also be applicable to all
Government employees whose services were/will be regularized against
2026:MLHC:582
regular posts on or after 01.04.2010. As such he contends, the petitioner
being regularized after 01.04.2010, is not entitled to the Old Pension
Scheme. It has also been submitted that the petitioner can no longer claim
any retrospective right, inasmuch as, the claim for regularization from
the date of initial appointment had already been made in the earlier writ
petition. Further he submits, the Cabinet decision of 2022, was confined
only to 3635 employees, which however were subject to four specific
conditions which also included special examinations, whereas the
petitioner, was regularized without such conditions, but solely on the
basis of the 2014 Court’s order. The claim of the petitioner that staff
regularized after him were placed in the Old Pension Scheme, he
submits, is but a bald statement as no materials has been placed on record
to substantiate this fact. With regard to the contention that the petitioner’s
regularization should have been effected as far back as in 2006, the
learned AAG submits that the said communications referred to by the
petitioner, was concerned only with the filling up of vacant LDA posts
through direct recruitment and promotion, and any proposal made at that
point of time has no bearing in the present case. The learned AAG has
relied upon the following decision in support of his case.
i)
Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Ors. vs. Dr. H.C. Gupta WP(C) Case
No. 4705/2018
2026:MLHC:582
6.
Heard the learned counsel for the parties, the only issue it
appears is whether in the circumstances surrounding the case, there can
be any scope or ground to consider the services of the petitioner served
on an adhoc basis, to be counted for the purposes of coverage under the
Old Pension Scheme.
7.
As noted above, the petitioner had approached this Court on
an earlier occasion, whereby this Court by order dated 05.05.2014 passed
in WP(C) No. 26 of 2013, had directed for consideration of the
petitioner’s case for regularization. In view of this direction, the
petitioner’s services were regularized w.e.f 01.07.2015. This Court to in
order to verify the contents of the earlier writ petition i.e. the pleadings,
prayer and other materials, as opposed to the instant fresh writ petition,
had called for the records of WP(C) No. 26 of 2013, which were
accordingly produced before the Court. On examination of the prayer
made therein, it is noted that at caption No. (i), it has been prayed as
follows: “(i) Regularization of the service of the Petitioner with
retrospective effect from the date of his initial appointment
on 03.04.1998 with all the consequential benefits viz
arrear salary with time to time increment- fixation of pay
and allowances seniority and promotion as due and
admissible alongwith benefit of General Provident Funder
under Rule 4 of the Meghalaya Civil Service (General
Provident Fund) Rules, 1985;”
2026:MLHC:582
8.
This Court on perusing the order dated 05.05.2014 passed in
WP(C) No. 26 of 2013, notes that the same is not exhaustive, and the
directions for consideration of regularization are general in nature.
However, the fact that the prayer for retrospective regularization and for
all consequential benefits from the date of initial appointment had been
made in the earlier round of litigation, also cannot be easily disregarded.
Coming to the present writ petition, at caption No. 4, the prayer is as
follows: “4 And/or direct the respondent authorities to regularize
the petitioner’s service with retrospective effect from his
initial date of appointment, i.e. 03/04/1998, thereby
enabling him to avail of pensionary benefits under the Old
Pension Scheme, in alignment with the treatment
accorded to other similarly situated staff.”
A comparison of the above captioned prayers made in the
two writ petitions however, show that in present writ petition, the same
is specific to praying for consideration for retrospective regularization
from the initial date of appointment, to enable him to avail of pensionary
benefits under the Old Pension Scheme. Thus, it cannot be held that
identical prayers have been re-agitated on this aspect.
9.
The petitioner in the other parts of the prayer, apart from the
prayer for regularization from the date of initial appointment for the
purposes of pension, has also prayed for other service benefits on the
2026:MLHC:582
basis of new grounds i.e. the Office Memorandum of 2022, which had
accorded regularization to 3635, employees appointed before
31.12.2007, and also Clause-10 of The Meghalaya Civil Services
(Pension) Rules, 1993, which provides for the counting of officiating or
temporary service, towards qualifying service for such service benefits.
10.
On the other prayers, i.e. the claim for parity with other adhoc
employees who were regularized vide the Memorandum dated
21.12.2022, the prayer of the writ petitioner on this ground is not
sustainable, inasmuch as, the said regularization exercise implemented
through the Memorandum of 2022, was a special one-time exercise with
regard to only 3635 employees and not a universal policy, which would
include the petitioner, whereas, the petitioner’s regularization was by
way of, and pursuant to orders of the Court. As such, the case of the
petitioner standing on a completely different footing, there is no
similarity with other adhoc employees regularized by the Cabinet
decision in 2022.
11.
The New Pension Scheme as has been noted came into effect
on 01.04.2010, and under Guideline 3.1 of the Guidelines, the same
being prospective, would normally also cover the case of the petitioner
who was regularized w.e.f. 01.07.2015. However, on the other hand a
perusal of Clause-10 of The Meghalaya Civil Services (Pension) Rules,
2026:MLHC:582
1993 would show that qualifying service of a Government servant, shall
commence from the date he takes charge of the post. For the sake of
convenience Clause-10 is reproduced hereinbelow: “Commencement of qualifying service:
10. Subject to the provisions of these rules qualifying
service of a government servant shall commence from the
date he takes charge of the post to which he is first
appointed either substantively or in an officiating or
temporary capacity.
Provided that officiating or temporary service is
followed without interruption by substantive appointment
in the same or another service or post.
Provided further that:
(a) In the case of a Government servant in a Class IV
service or post who held a lien or a suspended lien on a
permanent pensionable post prior to the 17th April 1950,
service rendered before attaining the age of sixteen years
shall not count for any purpose, and
(b) In the case of a Government servant not covered by
clause (a) service rendered before attaining the age of
eighteen years shall not count, except for compensation
gratuity.”
12.
On examination of the above, an aspect with regard to the
service of the petitioner which this Court notices, is that the petitioner
was already in employment albeit, on adhoc basis, since 03.04.1998, that
is much before the New Pension Scheme came into being on 01.04.2010.
Taking into consideration the fact that the petitioner has also been
undisputedly in continuous service since that date, but however,
2026:MLHC:582
regularized only on 01.07.2015, by application of Clause-10 of the
Guidelines, notwithstanding other circumstances, this would surely
entitle him, for placement under the Old Pension Scheme.
13.
It is thus ordered accordingly, it is further made clear that
this relief granted, is confined only to the counting of the period under
adhoc employment for determining the qualifying years of service for the
purposes of pension, and not for any other service benefits, emoluments,
or back wages, inasmuch as, these are no longer open for the petitioner
to re-agitate.
14.
The judgment placed by the learned AAG i.e. Government
of NCT of Delhi & Ors. vs. Dr. H.C. Gupta (supra) being of no
assistance to the respondents and on a different footing is not elaborated
upon.
15.
The writ petition is allowed to the extent indicated above,
and is accordingly disposed of.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
09.06.2026
“V. Lyndem-AR-PS”
VALENTINO LYNDEM
Date: 2026.06.13 13:32:56 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review