Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Date of reserved for judgment
Date of pronouncement
Date of uploading
APHC010793022016
: 03.08.2026
: 25.08.2026
: 25.08.2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
Bench Sr.No:
[3614]
WRIT APPEAL NO: 475 of 2016
E.O., Sri Anjaneya Swamy Vari Temple
...Appellant
Vs.
M V Satyanarayan Charyulu and Others
...Respondent(s)
**********
Advocate for Appellant:
Ms. Pulipati Radhika
Advocate(s) for Respondent(s):
GP for Revenue
Mr. V. Subrahmanyam
CORAM : THE CHIEF JUSTICE LISA GILL
SRI JUSTICE BALAJI MEDAMALLI
DATE
: 25th August 2026
JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Balaji Medamalli)
1.
This Writ Appeal is directed against the order dated 31.12.2014 passed
in W.P.No.25600 of 2005 passed by the learned Single Judge, whereby the
writ petition was allowed by setting aside order passed by the 3rd respondent.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties herein are referred to as they
were arrayed in the writ petition.
3.
Brief facts leading to file W.P.No.25600 of 2005 by the writ petitioners
are that:
On an application made by one Malyavantam Srinivasa Charyulu, for
grant of patta under the provisions of A.P. (Andhra Area) Inams
(Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) Act, 1956 (for short, 'the
Inams Act'), in respect of the land admeasuring Ac.13.21 cents in
Survey Nos.809, 926 and 927 of Gannavaram village and mandal,
Krishna district, the authorities, after holding enquiry under the
provisions of the said Inams Act, issued proceedings saying that the
said person was entitled for a claim under the Inams Act. Pursuant
thereto, the revenue authorities prepared adangal and also issued
pattadar passbook and title deeds under the provisions of the A.P.
Rights in Land and Pattadar Passbooks Act, 1971.
Writ Petitioner Nos.1 and 2 are the son and brother's wife of the
said Srinivasa Charyulu. Earlier Srinivasa Charyulu and, after his
death, the petitioners have been in possession and enjoyment of the
subject property for more than 45 years. Previously, in the year 1969,
the 1st respondent in the writ petition filed O.A.No.141 of 1969 against
the 1st petitioner's father under the Andhra Pradesh Charitable and
Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act, 1966 (Act 18 of
1966) (for short, 'the Endowments Act, 1966'), before the Deputy
Commissioner of Endowments, Vijayawada, for production of records
and for possession, and the same was dismissed on 16.12.1970.
After a lapse of 35 years, the 1st respondent in the writ petition filed
Inam Appeal No.1 of 2000 under Section 7(2) of the Inams Act, with
an application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, for condonation
of delay in filing appeal before the 2 respondent. The 2nd respondent
in the writ petition, by order dated 29.10.2005, condoned the delay. In
the above background, the writ petition came to be filed, seeking writ
of prohibition for restraining the 2nd respondent from adjudicating the
Inam Appeal No.1 of 2000, and to set aside the order in I.A.No.1 of
2000.
4.
After hearing learned counsel on either side and upon consideration of
the material on record, statutory provisions, and the precedents cited, learned
Single Judge allowed the writ petition, by an order dated 31.12.2014, holding
that statute prescribes a limitation of 60 days for filing an appeal, whereas the
1st respondent filed the appeal under Section 7(2) of the Inams Act after an
inordinate delay of nearly three decades without any valid or satisfactory
explanation, and that the reasons assigned for condonation of delay were
vague and insufficient. Aggrieved thereof, the present writ appeal is filed.
5.
Heard Ms. Pulipati Radhika, learned counsel for appellant / respondent
No.1 and learned Government Pleader for Revenue appearing for respondent
No.3 and Sri Mr. V. Subrahmanyam, learned counsel for respondent No.4.
6.
The contention of Appellant/respondent No.1 is that Appellant Temple is
the titleholder of subject land, having acquired the same by way of an Inam
granted by the then Zamindar to the Temple for performing services to the
Deity. The subject land is registered in the name of the Deity in Resettlement
Register (RSR) as well as the Inam Fair Register (IFR), and the same is
evident from the counter filed by the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) in the
Writ Petition. The title deed in respect of subject land stands in the name of
the Temple/Deity vide T.D.No.1387, and an entry was also made in the
Section 38 Register dated 10.10.1938, all solidifying the title of the Temple
over subject land. It is further contended that since writ petitioners claim right
over the subject land on the basis of Ryotwari pattas alleged to have been
obtained subsequent to the Estates Abolition Act, the respondent No.1
Temple preferred an appeal before the RDO challenging the said pattas, in
Inam Appeal No.1 of 2000. Though the said appeal was preferred after a
delay of nearly three decades, the delay was condoned by the RDO vide order
dated 29.10.2005, primarily on the reason that the statutory procedure
prescribed for the grant of the alleged Ryotwari pattas had not been not
followed.
7.
Aggrieved
by
the
aforesaid
order,
writ
petitioners
preferred
W.P.No.25600 of 2005, which was allowed by the learned Single Judge vide
order dated 31.12.2014, holding that the delay cannot not be condoned and,
consequently, the appeal cannot be adjudicated by the RDO. Assailing the
said order, the respondent No.1 has preferred the present appeal, contending
that there was, in fact, no delay in preferring the appeal and that, even if there
is a delay, the same ought to have been condoned in the interest of
substantial justice and for protecting the valuable pre-abolition rights of the
Temple. It is further contended that in view of the amended Act 16 of 2013,
even if the alleged pattas are valid and genuine, the same are liable to be
considered as null and void. Since the very validity of the alleged pattas is
under challenge, the question of delay cannot be an impediment or bar for
adjudicating the said issue.
8.
Learned counsel appearing for respondents No.1, 2 and 4/Writ
petitioners submitted that one Malyavantam Srinivasacharyulu made an
application for grant of Ryotwari patta under the provisions of A.P. (Andhra
Area) Inams (Abolition and Conversion into Ryotwari) 1956, in respect of an
extent of Ac.13.21 cents in Sy.Nos.809, 926 and 927 of Gannavaram village
and Mandal, Krishna District. Upon enquiry under the provisions of the Inams
Act, the competent authority held that the said individual was entitled to the
grant of patta. Pursuant thereto, the Revenue authorities issued pattadar
passbooks and adangals under the Andhra Pradesh Rights in Land and
Pattadar Passbooks Act. For more than 45 years, the said Srinivasacharyulu
and his successors-in-interest have been in possession and enjoyment of the
subject property. In the year 1969, the Executive Officers of the Temple filed
O.A.No.141 of 1969 before the Deputy Commissioner of Endowments,
Vijayawada, against M.Srinivasacharyulu (father of the writ petitioner No.1)
under the Andhra Pradesh Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and
Endowments Act, 1966, for production of certain records and recovery of
possession of the subject property. The said application was duly enquired
into by the Deputy Commissioner of Endowments, who being a statutory
authority, adjudicated upon the rights of the parties, and dismissed the said
appeal on 16.12.1970 holding that as per the evidence, the respondent
therein (father of writ petitioner No.1) was not at all the Managing Committee
at any point of time as trustee cannot be expected to be in possession of the
accounts shown in A schedule and the records shown in B schedule, and
further held that it is seen from the accounts Ex.R1 that Narayanacharyulu
and the respondent (father of writ petitioner No.1) are the pattadars and
further concluded that previously, the lands were held by the institution as
contended were granted in favour of the Archakas; and in such a case, the
appeal should have been filed by the institution to get the judgment set aside;
and at present, they stand as personal properties of the respondent (father of
writ petitioner No.1) and others, as such, the petitioner (respondent No.1
Temple) is not entitled to recover possession.
9.
Learned counsel for writ petitioners further submitted that aforesaid
order dated 16.12.1970 was never challenged and remained unassailed for
nearly three decades, until the filing of Inam Appeal No.1 of 2000. The said
appeal was preferred under section 7(2) of the Andhra Pradesh Inams
Abolition Act r/w 13 of the rules framed under the said act, questioning the
grant of Ryotwari pattas in favour of the writ petitioners. In spite of such
inordinate delay, no sufficient or cogent reasons were assigned for seeking
condonation of the delay. Mere filing of an appeal, without filing any
accompanying application seeking condonation of such inordinate delay, the
Revenue Divisional Officer ought not to have allowed the appeal. Though
learned counsel for respondent No.1 contended that no Ryotwari patta was
granted in favour of the writ petitioners, and therefore, the corresponding
entries in the revenue records were without basis, the record reflects that
appeal was filed specifically challenging the alleged grant of Ryotwari patta in
favour of the respondents and that too after suffering the proceedings against
the
respondent
No.1/Temple
before
the
Deputy
Commissioner
of
Endowments in O.A.No.141 of 1969, wherein the property was specifically
held to be personal properties of the father of writ petitioner No.1 and others.
Respondent No.1 Temple cannot now agitate after long lapse of more than 30
years. As per provisions under the Inams Abolition Act, any person aggrieved
by grant of the Ryotwari patta, the appeal would lie under section 7 of the
Inams Abolition Act within a period of sixty days and that there being any
proper explanation for such delay and having sought for the similar relief for
possession of the subject property as long as back in the year 1969 itself, the
respondent No.1 Temple cannot be allowed to re-agitate the same under the
present appeal.
10.
Learned Single Judge of this Court, having gone through the record and
relevant provisions of the Inams Abolition Act, and particularly, section 7(2)
thereof, as well as the reasons stated in the affidavit filed in support of the
application seeking condonation of delay under section 5 of the Limitation Act,
allowed the Writ Petition. The learned Single Judge accordingly set aside the
order dated 29.10.2005 passed by the Revenue Divisional Officer in I.A.No.1
of 2000 in Inam Appeal No.1 of 2000, and consequently held that respondent
No.2 cannot proceed with further adjudication of the said Inam Appeal.
11.
Upon hearing submissions of learned counsel for respondent No.1 and
also writ petitioners and upon perusing the record, learned Single Judge
considered the contentions advanced on behalf of respondent No.1 in detail
and framed the point for consideration that whether respondent No.2 is
justified in condoning the delay in filing the appeal and proceeding further with
the process of adjudicating of the Inam Appeal filed by respondent No.1 under
the provisions of section 7(2) of the Inams Abolition Act. While considering the
said issue, learned Single Judge held that in O.A.No.141 of 1969 filed against
the father of writ petitioner No.1 under section 93 of the Endowments Act,
1966, the Deputy Commissioner of Endowments, by order dated 16.12.1970,
held that proper remedy for the Executive Officer to recover the lands, is the
Civil Court or the Revenue Court, and they cannot be recovered under section
93 of the Endowments Act.
12.
In the above order, the Deputy Commissioner of Endowments also
observed that it was for the Assistant Commissioner to enquire into the matter
and take appropriate action. Despite a lapse of nearly three decades,
respondent No.1 had not taken any steps either to approach the competent
Civil Court or to initiate any other proceedings as contemplated in the said
order. Instead, respondent No.1 approached the Revenue Divisional Officer
under section 7(2) of the Inams Act against Srinivasacharyulu, father of the
writ petitioner No.1, by filing I.A.No.1 of 2005 along with an application under
section 5 of the Limitation Act seeking condonation of delay, even without
indicating the delay. Except stating that there was no bad intention in not
preferring the appeal earlier, no sufficient or valid reason was assigned for the
delay. However, the Revenue Divisional Officer allowed the application filed
by the respondent No.1, which was challenged before the learned Single
Judge in the aforesaid Writ Petition.
13.
Learned Single Judge, while considering the provisions under section
7(2) of the Inams Abolition Act, observed that it is obligatory on the part of the
person aggrieved to file an appeal within a period of 60 days from the date of
grant of Ryotwari patta; respondent No.1 Temple, having approached the
Deputy Commissioner of Endowments long back in the year 1969 and
suffered an order dated 16.12.1970, failed to assign any reason for not taking
further steps pursuant to the said order.
14.
Learned Single Judge also considered the judgments relied upon by
either side and, after taking into consideration section 143 of the Endowments
Act, 1987, held that the said provision of law deals with a claim of vesting of
the Endowments property in the individual and the effect of law of limitation,
but not with the present contingency of filing of an appeal under the provisions
of the Inams Act. The provision imposes a prohibition on individuals to claim
ownership in the Endowments property on the ground of expiry of period of
limitation i.e., plea of adverse possession is not available in respect of
Endowment properties. Learned Single Judge, therefore, concluded that the
scope, ambit and parameters of the applicability of the said provision are
different and cannot be extended to the contingencies of the present nature.
15.
That
apart,
having
approached
the
Deputy
Commissioner
of
Endowments in the year 1969 and suffered the order dated 16.12.1970,
respondent No.1 Temple failed to explain the inordinate delay in preferring the
Inam Appeal under Section 7(2) of the Inams Abolition Act. Therefore, reliance
cannot be placed on section 143 of the Endowments Act before the Revenue
Divisional Officer without first satisfying the requirement of condonation of
such inordinate delay filed under section 5 of the Limitation Act. It is not open
to the respondent No.1 to contend that the appeal itself before the RDO is
maintainable under law. Accordingly, learned Single Judge, upon considering
the aforesaid findings, allowed the Writ Petition, and set aside the order dated
29.10.2005 passed in I.A.No.1 of 2000 in Inam Appeal No.1 of 2000 and
further held that the RDO cannot proceed further for adjudication of the appeal
filed under section 7(2) of the Inams Abolition Act in Inam Appeal No.1 of
2000.
16.
As discussed above, and upon considering the material on record, it is
evident that respondent No.1 Temple filed O.A.No.141 of 1969 before the
Deputy Commissioner of Endowments, which was dismissed by order dated
16.12.1970, recording that the Temple has to initiate proceedings before the
competent Civil Court for declaration or any other proceedings in terms before
the revenue court and further held that the property was in possession of the
unofficial respondents, who were shown as Ryotwari pattadars. Having
suffered the said order, respondent No.1 Temple, after a lapse of nearly three
decades, approached the RDO under section 7(2) of the Inams Aboliton Act
and filed an application for condonation of delay without even specifying the
period of delay. The RDO, nevertheless, allowed the application and
proceeded to entertain the Inam Appeal.
17.
Learned counsel for respondent No.1 would further submit that as writ
petitioners failed to produce the Inam pattas granted in their favour, they are
not entitled to claim any benefit under the Inams Abolition Act, and that the
revenue records were mutated in their favour without there being any
documentary evidence evidencing the grant of such pattas. In this connection,
it is apt to mention here that the appeal filed by the respondent No.1 Temple
before the RDO under section 7(2) of the Inams Abolition Act, wherein, the
appeal itself speaks that it was filed against the grant of Ryotwari patta in
favour of the father of the writ petitioner No.1. That part, the findings recorded
in O.A.No.141 of 1969 also clearly establish that the father of the writ
petitioner No.1 was recorded as a pattadar. Having approached the RDO,
after a lapse of nearly three decades, challenging the patta granted in favour
of writ petitioners, respondent No.1 Temple cannot now contend that no patta
was issued in their favour. If no patta had been granted, there was no basis
for filing such an appeal before the RDO under section 7(2) of the Inans
Abolition Act. Therefore, the said contention cannot be countenanced.
18.
In view of the observations made above, we are of the considered view
that the respondent No.1 Temple has miserably failed to explain the inordinate
delay of nearly 30 years in preferring the appeal. Having itself agitated the
grant of Ryotwari patta by filing an appeal before the RDO under Section 7(2)
of the Inams Abolition Act, respondent No.1 Temple cannot now turn around
and contend that no such patta was ever granted. Learned Single Judge,
having elaborately dealt with all the contentions of the parties, recorded
specific findings thereon, as stated above. In view of the foregoing, we find no
reason to interfere with the order under appeal.
19.
Accordingly, the Writ Appeal is dismissed. No order as to costs.
Interim orders, if any, granted earlier shall stand vacated, and all
pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand closed.
LISA GILL, CJ
JUSTICE BALAJI MEDAMALLI
SAK
Whether the order is:
Speaking
Reportable
☑
Reasoned
☑
Non-reportable
☑
HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE LISA GILL, CHIEF JUSTICE
&
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BALAJI MEDAMALLI
WRIT APPEAL NO: 475 of 2016
Date: 25.08.2026
SAK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review